State v. Thomas Dale DeLay

TEXAS COURT OF APPEALS, THIRD DISTRICT, AT AUSTIN






NO. 03-05-00817-CR

NO. 03-05-00818-CR


The State of Texas, Appellant



v.



Thomas Dale Delay, Appellee








FROM THE DISTRICT COURT OF TRAVIS COUNTY, 331ST JUDICIAL DISTRICT

NOS. D-1-DC-05-900725 & D-1-DC-05-904161,

HONORABLE WAYNE PATRICK PRIEST, JUDGE PRESIDING


O R D E R

PER CURIAM

The State invoked its right to a stay pursuant to article 44.01(e) of the code of criminal procedure, and the trial court has properly stayed the proceedings pending our resolution of the State's appeal. Appellee Thomas Dale Delay has now filed a motion to enforce the stay, complaining that the State has issued more than thirty subpoenas since it requested and obtained the stay. Delay asks this Court to (1) order the State to cease and desist from obtaining, serving, or enforcing subpoenas under the trial court cause numbers while the stay is in place, (2) rescind all subpoenas issued under the trial court cause numbers during the stay, and (3) order the district clerk not to issue any subpoenas under the trial court cause numbers until this Court issues its mandate.

Article 24.01 of the code of criminal procedure governs the issuance of subpoenas in a criminal case. Subpoenas may be issued to compel testimony and production of documents only in limited circumstances. See Tex. Code Crim. Proc. Ann. art. 24.01(a) (West 1989). Specifically, a person may only be compelled to appear at trial or any "other proceeding in which the person's testimony may be required." (1) Id. Because the State has obtained a stay in the proceedings pursuant to article 44.01(e) of the code of criminal procedure, we hold that subpoenas may not issue compelling witnesses to testify and produce documents at the stayed proceeding. See id. art. 24.01(a). Accordingly, we grant Delay's motion to the following extent:



The parties are prohibited from issuing subpoenas under the trial court cause numbers while the stay is in effect.



All subpoenas issued under the trial court cause numbers after the proceedings were stayed are null and void.



Any outstanding subpoenas issued before the stay are suspended while the stay is in effect.





All other relief requested is denied.



Before Justices B. A. Smith, Puryear and Waldrop

Filed: March 13, 2006

Do Not Publish

1. The code of criminal procedure enumerates several proceedings for which subpoenas may be issued: an examining trial, a coroner's inquest, a grand jury, and a habeas corpus hearing. See Tex. Code Crim. Proc. Ann. art. 24.01(a) (West 1989).