Tesmer v. Granholm

5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//7(;7 38%/,&$7,21
 7HVPHUHWDOY*UDQKROPHWDO 1RV 3XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUFXLW 5XOH 

(/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )(' $SS 3 WK &LU

ZHWKLQNDQXQFRQVWLWXWLRQDOOLQHKDVEHHQGUDZQEHWZHHQULFK )LOH 1DPH DS

DQGSRRUl'RXJODV86DW7KH\EXWWUHVVWKHIRUFH
RIWKLVREVHUYDWLRQE\SRLQWLQJRXWWKDWDVRIVWDWHV
SHUPLWWHGILUVWDSSHDOVDVRIULJKWDQGWKDWFDVHVOLNH$QGHUV 81,7('67$7(6&28572)$33($/6
Y&DOLIRUQLD86UHIHUUHGWRWKHULJKW )257+(6,;7+&,5&8,7
WRKDYHFRXQVHODGYRFDWHRQRQHjVEHKDOILQWKHmILUVWDSSHDOl BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
$VWKH6XSUHPH&RXUWQRWHGm7KHTXHVWLRQLVQRWRQHRI
DEVROXWHVEXWRQHRIGHJUHHVl5RVV86DW:KLOH
WKHDSSHDODWLVVXHLQWKLVFDVHLVXQGRXEWHGO\DGHIHQGDQWjV s2+1 &/,))25' 7(60(5 ;
ILUVW DSSHDO LW KDV DOVR EHHQ UHQGHUHG GLVFUHWLRQDU\ E\ KLV &+$5/(6 &$57(5DQG$/2,6 
GHFLVLRQWRSOHDGJXLOW\7KHVWDWHKDVDIXQGDPHQWDOLQWHUHVW 6&+1(//RQEHKDOIRIDOO 
LQWKHILQDOLW\RIJXLOW\SOHDV+LOOY/RFNKDUW86  1RV
 DQG E\ HQWHULQJ D SOHD D GHIHQGDQW KDV YROXQWDULO\ VLPLODUO\VLWXDWHGLQGLYLGXDOV 
DFNQRZOHGJHGWKDWKHGRHVQRWGLVSXWHWKHIDFWXDOEDVLVRIWKH $57+85 0 ),7=*(5$/'DQG !

VWDWHjV FDVHDJDLQVWKLP*LYHQWKDWWKHUHKDVQRWEHHQDQ 0,&+$(/ ' 92*/(5 
XQGHUO\LQJ WULDO WKH QXPEHU RI LVVXHV IRU DSSHDO KDV EHHQ 3ODLQWLIIV$SSHOOHHV 
JUHDWO\ UHGXFHG  )XUWKHUPRUH WKH VWDWXWH SURYLGHV WKDW D 
GHIHQGDQWFDQJXDUDQWHHKLPVHOIDSSRLQWHGDSSHOODWHFRXQVHO 
E\HQWHULQJDFRQGLWLRQDOSOHDWKDWSUHVHUYHVWKRVHLVVXHVWKDW Y

WULDOFRXQVHOKDVLGHQWLILHGDVYLDEOHRQDSSHDO0LFK&RPS 
/DZV†DG,QVKRUWWKHSURWHFWLRQVEXLOWLQWRWKH s(11,)(5 *5$1+2/0 
VWDWXWHFRQYLQFHXVWKDWLQWKLVmPDWWHURIGHJUHHVlWKHEDODQFH $WWRUQH\*HQHUDO 
WLSVLQIDYRURIFRQVWLWXWLRQDOLW\ 'HIHQGDQW 
,,, s8'*( s2+1 ) .2:$/6., 
s8'*( :,//,$0 $ &5$1( 
7KHLQMXQFWLRQRUGHUHGE\WKHGLVWULFWFRXUWLVGLVVROYHGWKH DQGs8'*( /<1'$ / 
GHFODUDWRU\MXGJPHQWLVYDFDWHGDQGWKLVFDXVHLVUHPDQGHG 
+($7+6&277LQWKHLURIILFLDO 
WR WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW ZLWK LQVWUXFWLRQV WR HQWHU MXGJPHQW LQ FDSDFLWLHVLQGLYLGXDOO\DQGDV 
IDYRURIGHIHQGDQWV
UHSUHVHQWDWLYHVRIDFODVVRI 
VLPLODUO\VLWXDWHGFLUFXLWFRXUW 
MXGJHV 
'HIHQGDQWV$SSHOODQWV 
 
s8'*( '(11,6 & .2/(1'$ 
 $SSHOODQW 
:KLOH LW GRHV QRW ELQG XV ZH QRWH WKDW WKH 6XSUHPH &RXUW GHFOLQHG 1
WR JUDQW FHUWLRUDUL WR UHYLHZ WKH 0LFKLJDQ 6XSUHPH &RXUWjV %XOJHU
GHFLVLRQ


 7HVPHUHWDOY*UDQKROPHWDO 1RV 1RV 7HVPHUHWDOY*UDQKROPHWDO 

$SSHDOIURPWKH8QLWHG6WDWHV'LVWULFW&RXUW  0LFK DW   1:G DW   ,W RIIHUHG WKH
IRUWKH(DVWHUQ'LVWULFWRI0LFKLJDQDW%D\&LW\ IROORZLQJUDWLRQDOH
1Rn9LFWRULD$5REHUWV'LVWULFWsXGJH
$SSHDOVIURPSOHDEDVHGFRQYLFWLRQVDQGDSSHDOVIURP
$UJXHG'HFHPEHU FRQYLFWLRQVREWDLQHGIROORZLQJWULDOVOLNHWKRVHDSSHDOV
DW LVVXH LQ 'RXJODV DQG 5RVV DUH IXQGDPHQWDOO\
'HFLGHGDQG)LOHGsXO\ GLIIHUHQW)RUHPRVWDGHIHQGDQWZKRWHQGHUVDSOHDKDV
DGPLWWHGJXLOWRIWKHRIIHQVHLQRSHQFRXUWm>$@JXLOW\
%HIRUH1255,66,/(5DQG%$7&+(/'(5&LUFXLW SOHDUHSUHVHQWVDEUHDNLQWKHFKDLQRIHYHQWVZKLFKKDV
sXGJHV SUHFHGHG LW LQ WKH FULPLQDO SURFHVV :KHQ D FULPLQDO
GHIHQGDQWKDVVROHPQO\DGPLWWHGLQRSHQFRXUWWKDWKHLV
BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB LQIDFWJXLOW\RIWKHRIIHQVHZLWKZKLFKKHLVFKDUJHGKH
PD\QRWWKHUHDIWHUUDLVHLQGHSHQGHQWFODLPVUHODWLQJWR
&2816(/ WKHGHSULYDWLRQRIFRQVWLWXWLRQDOULJKWVWKDWRFFXUUHGSULRU
WRWKHHQWU\RIWKHJXLOW\SOHDl7ROOHWWY+HQGHUVRQ
$5*8('  7KRPDV 5 :KHHNHU 2)),&( 2) 7+( 866&W/(GG
$77251(< *(1(5$/ /DQVLQJ 0LFKLJDQ sXG\ (
%UHJPDQ%5(*0$1 :(/&+*UDQG+DYHQ0LFKLJDQ 
IRU $SSHOODQWV  0DUN *UDQ]RWWR 'HWURLW 0LFKLJDQ IRU
$SSHOOHHV21%5,()7KRPDV5:KHHNHU2)),&(2) ,QFRQWUDVWZLWKWULDOVOHVVGDQJHUH[LVWVLQSOHDFDVHV
7+($77251(<*(1(5$//DQVLQJ0LFKLJDQsXG\( WKDWWKHUHFRUGZLOOEHVRXQFOHDURUWKHHUURUVVRKLGGHQ
%UHJPDQ%5(*0$1 :(/&+*UDQG+DYHQ0LFKLJDQ WKDW WKH GHIHQGDQWjV DSSHDO ZLOO EH UHGXFHG WR D
IRU$SSHOODQWV0DUN*UDQ]RWWR'HWURLW0LFKLJDQ.DU\/ PHDQLQJOHVV ULWXDO  $OVR D FRQFHVVLRQ RI JXLOW OLPLWV
0RVV $0(5,&$1 &,9,/ /,%(57,(6 81,21 'HWURLW FRQVLGHUDEO\ WKH SRWHQWLDO LVVXHV WKDW FDQ EH UDLVHG RQ
0LFKLJDQIRU$SSHOOHHV DSSHDO  7KHVH DUH DOO UHDVRQHG GLVWLQFWLRQV WKDW DUH
UHOHYDQW WR GHWHUPLQLQJ ZKHWKHU 0LFKLJDQ SURYLGHV
BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB mPHDQLQJIXODFFHVVlWRWKHDSSHOODWHFRXUWV
23,1,21 %XOJHU  0LFK DW   1:G DW 
BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB FLWDWLRQVDQGIRRWQRWHRPLWWHG
$/$1(1255,6&LUFXLWsXGJH$VDPHQGHGLQ 3ODLQWLIIV WDNH LVVXH ZLWK WKH GLVWLQFWLRQ GUDZQ E\ WKH
WKH 0LFKLJDQ &RQVWLWXWLRQ SURYLGHV WKDW LQGLYLGXDOV ZKR 0LFKLJDQ 6XSUHPH &RXUW EHWZHHQ DSSHDOV RI ULJKW DQG
SOHDGJXLOW\WRDFULPHPD\RQO\DSSHDOE\OHDYHRIWKHFRXUW GLVFUHWLRQDU\ DSSHDOV  ,Q WKHLU YLHZ WKLV HPSKDVLV LV
0LFK&RQVW$UW†7KHTXHVWLRQOLWLJDWHGEHORZ PLVSODFHG  ,QVWHDG WKH NH\ LV ZKHWKHU WKH DSSHDO LV D
FHQWHUHG RQ ZKHWKHU WKH IHGHUDO FRQVWLWXWLRQ UHTXLUHV GHIHQGDQWjV ILUVW DSSHDO  +HQFH WKH\ FRQWHQG WKLV FDVH LV
DSSRLQWPHQW RI FRXQVHO WR DVVLVW LQGLJHQW GHIHQGDQWV ZKR FORVHUWR'RXJODVWKDQWR5RVVEHFDXVHWKHODWWHULQYROYHGD
ZLVKWRDSSO\IRUOHDYHWRDSSHDO7KHGLVWULFWFRXUWLVVXHGD GLVFUHWLRQDU\DSSHDODIWHUWKHILUVWDSSHDORIULJKWKDGEHHQ
GHFODUDWRU\ MXGJPHQW KROGLQJ WKDW WKH GHQLDO RI DSSRLQWHG DGMXGLFDWHG  7KH\ SRLQW WR WKH IROORZLQJ ODQJXDJH LQ
FRXQVHOXQGHUWKHVHFLUFXPVWDQFHVYLRODWHVWKH8QLWHG6WDWHV 'RXJODVm>:@KHUHWKHPHULWVRIWKHRQHDQGRQO\DSSHDODQ
&RQVWLWXWLRQ,QDQHIIRUWWRHQIRUFHLWVMXGJPHQWWKHFRXUW LQGLJHQWKDVRIULJKWDUHGHFLGHGZLWKRXWEHQHILWRIFRXQVHO
 7HVPHUHWDOY*UDQKROPHWDO 1RV 1RV 7HVPHUHWDOY*UDQKROPHWDO 

>7@KHUH DUH REYLRXVO\ OLPLWV EH\RQG ZKLFK WKH HTXDO HQMRLQHGWKH0LFKLJDQMXGLFLDU\IURPIROORZLQJWKHFRQWHVWHG
SURWHFWLRQ DQDO\VLV PD\ QRW EH SUHVVHG ZLWKRXW GRLQJ SURYLVLRQRIWKH0LFKLJDQ&RQVWLWXWLRQDVZHOODVWKHVWDWXWH
YLROHQFHWRSULQFLSOHVUHFRJQL]HGLQRWKHUGHFLVLRQVRI GHVLJQHGWRFRGLI\LW
WKLV &RXUW  7KH )RXUWHHQWK $PHQGPHQW mGRHV QRW
UHTXLUHDEVROXWHHTXDOLW\RUSUHFLVHO\HTXDODGYDQWDJHVl :HFRQFOXGHWKDWWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWVKRXOGKDYHDEVWDLQHG
6DQ$QWRQLR,QGHSHQGHQW6FKRRO'LVWULFWY5RGULJXH] IURP KHDULQJ WKH FODLPV RI WKH WKUHH FULPLQDOGHIHQGDQW
 86    6&W    /(GG  SODLQWLIIVEHFDXVHWKH\FRXOGKDYHUDLVHGWKHLUFRQVWLWXWLRQDO
 QRU GRHV LW UHTXLUH WKH 6WDWH WR mHTXDOL]H FODLPVLQWKHLUSHQGLQJVWDWHFRXUWSURFHHGLQJVDVHYLGHQFHG
HFRQRPLFFRQGLWLRQVl*ULIILQY,OOLQRLV86DW E\WKHIDFWWKDWDQHDUO\LGHQWLFDOFKDOOHQJHZDVZHQGLQJLWV
 6&W DW  )UDQNIXUWHU s FRQFXUULQJ  ,W GRHV ZD\ WKURXJK WKH FRXUWV RI 0LFKLJDQ DW WKH WLPH WKDW WKH
UHTXLUH WKDW WKH VWDWH DSSHOODWH V\VWHP EH mIUHH RI OLWLJDWLRQEHIRUHXVZDVFRPPHQFHG7KDWGRHVQRWHQGRXU
XQUHDVRQHG GLVWLQFWLRQVl 5LQDOGL Y ,@WLVRUGLQDULO\WKHGHIHQGDQWUDWKHUWKDQWKH6WDWHZKR
LQLWLDWHVWKHDSSHOODWHSURFHVVVHHNLQJQRWWRIHQGRIIWKH
$IWHU WKLV GHFODUDWRU\  MXGJPHQW ZDV HQWHUHG SODLQWLIIV HIIRUWVRIWKH6WDWHjVSURVHFXWRUEXWUDWKHUWRRYHUWXUQD
VRXJKW LQMXQFWLYH UHOLHI EHFDXVH FHUWDLQ 0LFKLJDQ MXGJHV ILQGLQJRIJXLOWPDGHE\DMXGJHRUDMXU\EHORZ7KH
FRQWLQXHGWRGHQ\DSSRLQWHGFRXQVHOLQWKHVHVLWXDWLRQV7KH GHIHQGDQWQHHGVDQDWWRUQH\RQDSSHDOQRWDVDVKLHOGWR
GLVWULFWFRXUWHQMRLQHGDOO0LFKLJDQMXGJHVIURPWDNLQJDQ\ SURWHFWKLPDJDLQVWEHLQJmKDOHGLQWRFRXUWlE\WKH6WDWH
DFWLRQ ZKDWVRHYHU WR HQIRUFH RU LPSOHPHQW WKH VWDWXWH DQGVWULSSHGRIKLVSUHVXPSWLRQRILQQRFHQFHEXWUDWKHU
7HVPHUY.RZDOVNL)6XSSG('0LFK DVDVZRUGWRXSVHWWKHSULRUGHWHUPLQDWLRQRIJXLOW7KLV
7KHWKUHHQDPHGGHIHQGDQWMXGJHVKDYHDSSHDOHGIURP GLIIHUHQFHLVVLJQLILFDQWIRUZKLOHQRRQHZRXOGDJUHH
WKLVLQMXQFWLRQDVKDVsXGJH'HQQLV&.ROHQGDZKRZDVQRW WKDWWKH6WDWHPD\VLPSO\GLVSHQVHZLWKWKHWULDOVWDJHRI
QDPHG DV DQ RULJLQDO GHIHQGDQW EXW ZKR ZDV QRQHWKHOHVV SURFHHGLQJVZLWKRXWDFULPLQDOGHIHQGDQWjVFRQVHQWLWLV
DIIHFWHGE\WKHGLVWULFWFRXUWjVDFWLRQ FOHDUWKDWWKH6WDWHQHHGQRWSURYLGHDQ\DSSHDODWDOO
0F.DQH Y 'XUVWRQ  86   6&W  
:KLOHWKLVOLWLJDWLRQZDVSURJUHVVLQJLQIHGHUDOFRXUWDQ /(G    7KH IDFW WKDW DQ DSSHDO KDV EHHQ
DFWLRQ LQYROYLQJ WKLV VDPH TXHVWLRQ ZDV PDNLQJ LWV ZD\ SURYLGHGGRHVQRWDXWRPDWLFDOO\PHDQWKDWD6WDWHWKHQ
WKURXJK WKH FRXUWV RI 0LFKLJDQ  8OWLPDWHO\ WKH 0LFKLJDQ DFWVXQIDLUO\E\UHIXVLQJWRSURYLGHFRXQVHOWRLQGLJHQW
6XSUHPH&RXUWLVVXHGDQRSLQLRQWKDWFRQWUDVWHGVKDUSO\WR GHIHQGDQWV DW HYHU\ VWDJH RI WKH ZD\ 'RXJODV Y
WKDWRIWKHGLVWULFWFRXUW &DOLIRUQLDVXSUD8QIDLUQHVVUHVXOWVRQO\LILQGLJHQWV
DUHVLQJOHGRXWE\WKH6WDWHDQGGHQLHGPHDQLQJIXODFFHVV
:HJUDQWHGOHDYHLQWKLVFDVHWRGHWHUPLQHZKHWKHUDQ WRWKHDSSHOODWHV\VWHPEHFDXVHRIWKHLUSRYHUW\7KDW
LQGLJHQW GHIHQGDQW LV HQWLWOHG WR WKH DSSRLQWPHQW RI TXHVWLRQ LV PRUH SURILWDEO\ FRQVLGHUHG XQGHU DQ HTXDO
DSSHOODWHFRXQVHODWSXEOLFH[SHQVHZKHQDSSO\LQJIRU SURWHFWLRQDQDO\VLV
OHDYHWRDSSHDODSOHDEDVHGFRQYLFWLRQ:HKROGWKDW
QHLWKHUWKHVWDWHQRUWKHIHGHUDOFRQVWLWXWLRQUHTXLUHVWKH 
DSSRLQWPHQW RI FRXQVHO XQGHU WKHVH FLUFXPVWDQFHV
 7HVPHUHWDOY*UDQKROPHWDO 1RV 1RV 7HVPHUHWDOY*UDQKROPHWDO 

E\WKHFRXUWWKHGHIHQGDQWZDLYHVWKHULJKWWRKDYHDQ 8QGHURXUIHGHUDOLVWVFKHPHRIJRYHUQPHQW0LFKLJDQ
DWWRUQH\DSSRLQWHGDWSXEOLFH[SHQVHWRDVVLVWLQILOLQJDQ UHPDLQV IUHH WR GHFLGH WKH FRQGLWLRQV XQGHU ZKLFK
DSSOLFDWLRQ IRU OHDYH WR DSSHDO RU WR DVVLVW ZLWK RWKHU DSSHOODWH FRXQVHO ZLOO EH SURYLGHG ZKHUH RXU VWDWH
SRVWFRQYLFWLRQUHPHGLHVDQGVKDOOGHWHUPLQHZKHWKHUWKH FRQVWLWXWLRQFRPPDQGVWKDWWKHPHFKDQLVPRIDSSHOODWH
GHIHQGDQWXQGHUVWDQGVWKHZDLYHU8SRQVHQWHQFLQJWKH UHYLHZLVGLVFUHWLRQDU\&RQVWDUW†
FRXUWVKDOOIXUQLVKWKHGHIHQGDQWZLWKDIRUPGHYHORSHG
E\ WKH VWDWH FRXUW DGPLQLVWUDWLYH RIILFH WKDW LV 3HRSOHY%XOJHU0LFK1:G
QRQWHFKQLFDO DQG HDVLO\ XQGHUVWRRG DQG WKDW WKH FHUWGHQLHG860LFK7KH0LFKLJDQ
GHIHQGDQWPD\ FRPSOHWHDQGILOHDVDQDSSOLFDWLRQIRU 6XSUHPH &RXUW GLG QRW UHDFK WKH FRQVWLWXWLRQDOLW\ RI WKH
OHDYHWRDSSHDO VWDWXWH KRZHYHU EHFDXVH LW GLG QRW DSSO\ WR GHIHQGDQW
%XOJHU0LFKDW1:GDW
0LFK&RPS/DZV†D%\LWVRZQWHUPVWKHVWDWXWH
FDUYHVRXWVLJQLILFDQWH[FHSWLRQVWRWKHGHQLDORIFRXQVHOWR ,,
LQGLJHQW GHIHQGDQWV ZKR KDYH SOHDGHG JXLOW\  7KHVH
H[FHSWLRQV DUH GHVLJQHG WR SURWHFW D GHIHQGDQW LQ WKRVH $VWKH\GLGEHORZGHIHQGDQWVDUJXHWKDWWKHGLVWULFWFRXUW
VLWXDWLRQVZKHUHKHKDVWKHPRVWDWVWDNHZKHQWKHSURVHFXWRU VKRXOGKDYHDEVWDLQHGIURPWDNLQJDFWLRQEHFDXVHWKHRQJRLQJ
DSSHDOVZKHQWKHVHQWHQFHIDOOVDERYHWKHVHQWHQFLQJUDQJH FULPLQDO SURFHHGLQJV LQ WKH FRXUWV RI 0LFKLJDQ SURYLGHG
DQG ZKHQ KH KDV SUHVHUYHG DQ LVVXH E\ HQWHULQJ LQWR D SODLQWLIIV ZKR KDG SOHDGHG JXLOW\ ZLWK DQ DGHTXDWH
FRQGLWLRQDO SOHD  :H QRWH WKDW WKH VWDWXWH UHTXLUHV RSSRUWXQLW\WRSUHVVWKHLUFRQVWLWXWLRQDOFKDOOHQJHV7KH\DOVR
DSSRLQWPHQWRIFRXQVHOXQGHUWKHVHFLUFXPVWDQFHV XUJHXVWRILQGWKDWWKHDWWRUQH\SODLQWLIIVODFNHGVWDQGLQJWR
EULQJVXLW:HZLOODGGUHVVHDFKRIWKHVHDUJXPHQWVLQWXUQ
,QDGGLWLRQWKHVWDWXWHDFFRUGVWKHWULDOFRXUWGLVFUHWLRQWR
DSSRLQW FRXQVHO ZKHQ WKHUH KDV EHHQ D GLVSXWH DERXW WKH $EVWHQWLRQ
PDQQHULQZKLFKWKHVHQWHQFHKDVEHHQFDOFXODWHGRUZKHQDQ
LVVXHKDVRWKHUZLVHEHHQSUHVHUYHGIRUDSSHDO)XUWKHUPRUH ,Q :@KHQDULFK >,@QFDVHVZKHUHWKHVWDWHFULPLQDOSURVHFXWLRQZDVEHJXQ
PDQLVJLYHQDPHDQLQJIXORSSRUWXQLW\WRDSSHDOZKLOHDSRRU SULRU WR WKH IHGHUDO VXLW WKH VDPH HTXLWDEOH SULQFLSOHV
PDQ LV JLYHQ RQO\ D PHDQLQJOHVV ULWXDO WKDW LV LQYLGLRXV UHOHYDQWWRWKHSURSULHW\RIDQLQMXQFWLRQPXVWEHWDNHQ
GLVFULPLQDWLRQl7HVPHU)6XSSGDWFLWLQJ LQWR FRQVLGHUDWLRQ E\ IHGHUDO GLVWULFW FRXUWV LQ
'RXJODVY&DOLIRUQLD86:KLOHWKLVLVD GHWHUPLQLQJZKHWKHUWRLVVXHDGHFODUDWRU\MXGJPHQWDQG
WKDWZKHUHDQLQMXQFWLRQZRXOGEHLPSHUPLVVLEOHXQGHU
 7HVPHUHWDOY*UDQKROPHWDO 1RV 1RV 7HVPHUHWDOY*UDQKROPHWDO 

WKHVHSULQFLSOHVGHFODUDWRU\UHOLHIVKRXOGRUGLQDULO\EH DSSRLQWHG IRU UHYLHZ RI WKH GHIHQGDQWjV FRQYLFWLRQ RU
GHQLHGDVZHOO VHQWHQFH
6DPXHOVY0DFNHOO86  7KH WULDO FRXUW VKDOO DSSRLQW DSSHOODWH
FRXQVHO IRU DQ LQGLJHQW GHIHQGDQW ZKR SOHDGV JXLOW\
7KLV FLUFXLW ORRNV WR WKUHH IDFWRUV ZKHQ GHWHUPLQLQJ JXLOW\EXWPHQWDOO\LOORUQRORFRQWHQGHUHLIDQ\RIWKH
ZKHWKHUL@QGLJHQWGHIHQGDQWVGHQLHGDSSHOODWHFRXQVHO DQ DFWLRQ ZDV SHQGLQJ LQ VWDWH FRXUW  +RZHYHU LW IRXQG
IDFHVLJQLILFDQWLQVXUPRXQWDEOHREVWDFOHVLQEULQJLQJWKHLU DEVWHQWLRQWREHLQDSSURSULDWHDVWRKLPEHFDXVHKHODFNHGDQ
RZQFKDOOHQJHVWRWKH>VWDWXWH@l7HVPHU)6XSSGDW DGHTXDWH RSSRUWXQLW\ WR UDLVH KLV FRQVWLWXWLRQDO FODLP D
$OWKRXJKWKHVHREVWDFOHVDUHLQVXIILFLHQWWRRYHUFRPH FRQFOXVLRQWKDWZLOOEHGLVFXVVHGLQWKHQH[WVHFWLRQRIWKLV
WKH PRUH VWULQJHQW UHTXLUHPHQWV RI DEVWHQWLRQ WKH\ DUH RSLQLRQ
VXIILFLHQWWRVDWLVI\WKHUHTXLUHPHQWVIRUMXVWHUWLLVWDQGLQJ
)LQDOO\WKHGLVWULFWFRXUWFRQFOXGHGWKDWSODLQWLII6FKQHOO
,QRXUYLHZWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWFRUUHFWO\FRQFOXGHGWKDWWKH GLG QRW KDYH D SHQGLQJ VWDWH DFWLRQ  ,G DW   +LV
DWWRUQH\SODLQWLIIVPHWWKHFULWHULD IRUMXVWHUWLLMXULVGLFWLRQ DSSOLFDWLRQIRUOHDYHWRDSSHDOKDGEHHQGHQLHGRQ$SULO
RXWOLQHGE\WKH&RXUWLQ6LQJOHWRQDQG3RZHUV$FFRUGLQJO\ DQGKLVUHTXHVWIRUUHKHDULQJZDVGHQLHGRQ0D\
WKH\KDYHVWDQGLQJWRFKDOOHQJHWKH6WDWXWH:HQRZWXUQWR 8QGHUWKHDSSURSULDWH0LFKLJDQUXOHV6FKQHOOKDG
WKHPHULWVRIWKHLUFODLP GD\VLQZKLFKWRILOHDGHOD\HGDSSOLFDWLRQIRUOHDYHWRDSSHDO
ZLWK WKH 0LFKLJDQ 6XSUHPH &RXUW  7KXV LQ WKH GLVWULFW
&RQVWLWXWLRQDOLW\RIWKH6WDWXWH FRXUWjV YLHZ DW WKH WLPH WKH IHGHUDO FRPSODLQW ZDV ILOHG
6FKQHOOjVVWDWHDFWLRQKDGEHHQFRPSOHWHGDQGDEVWHQWLRQDV
7KH SURYLVLRQV RI WKH FKDOOHQJHG VWDWXWH DW LVVXH UHDG DV WRKLPZDVLQDSSURSULDWH,G
IROORZV
:HGLVDJUHHZLWKWKLVDQDO\VLV$VRXUGHFLVLRQLQ)RVWHU
6HFD ([FHSWDVSURYLGHGLQVXEVHFWLRQVDQG VXSUDPDNHVFOHDUWKHGHFLVLRQWRDEDQGRQDYHQXHVRIVWDWH
DGHIHQGDQWZKRSOHDGVJXLOW\JXLOW\EXWPHQWDOO\LOO FRXUW UHOLHI GRHV QRW QHFHVVDULO\ UXOH RXW DEVWHQWLRQ  ,Q
RU QROR FRQWHQGHUH VKDOO QRW KDYH DSSHOODWH FRXQVHO )RVWHU SODLQWLII FKDOOHQJHG WKH FRQVWLWXWLRQDOLW\ RI D
.HQWXFN\ VWDWXWH OLPLWLQJ WKH DPRXQW RI FRPSHQVDWLRQ WR
 7HVPHUHWDOY*UDQKROPHWDO 1RV 1RV 7HVPHUHWDOY*UDQKROPHWDO 

ZKLFK KHU DSSRLQWHG FRXQVHO ZDV HQWLWOHG DV ZHOO DV WKH 6LQJOHWRQ86DW7KHVDPHUHDVRQLQJDSSOLHVWRWKH
SUDFWLFHRIQRWSURYLGLQJDWULDOWUDQVFULSW)RVWHU)G DWWRUQH\ SODLQWLIIV  7KH\ KDYH DOOHJHG WKDW WKH\ KDYH
DW:KLOHKHUFODLPVKDGEHHQGHQLHGE\WKHFRXUWVRI UHSUHVHQWHG LQGLJHQW GHIHQGDQWV LQ WKH SDVW IRU ZKLFK WKH\
.HQWXFN\ DW WKH WLPH KHU †  FRPSODLQW ZDV ILOHG WKLV UHFHLYHGSD\PHQWIURPWKHVWDWHDQGWKDWWKH\ZLOOFRQWLQXHWR
FRXUWFRQFOXGHGWKDWVKHFRXOGSXUVXHKHUFODLPVRQGLUHFW GRVRLQWKHIXWXUH$VLQ6LQJOHWRQSODLQWLIIVZLOOVXIIHUDQ
DSSHDODQGIDLOLQJWKHUHFRXOGUHVRUWWRVWDWHKDEHDVUHOLHI DFWXDOLQMXU\LIWKHVWDWXWHUHPDLQVLQIRUFH
,QVHHNLQJLQMXQFWLYHUHOLHILQKHUVHFWLRQDFWLRQ 7KHQH[WFRQVLGHUDWLRQFRQFHUQVWKHUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQ
VKHLVDWWHPSWLQJWRREWDLQIHGHUDOUHYLHZRIVWDWHFRXUW WKH OLWLJDQWV DQG WKH SHUVRQV ZKRVH ULJKWV WKH\ VHHN WR
SURFHGXUHVLQDFULPLQDOFDVHEHIRUHWKHVWDWHFRXUWKDV HQIRUFH
KDG WKH RSSRUWXQLW\ WR GHFLGH WKHP ILQDOO\  )HGHUDO
UHYLHZVKRXOGEHJLYHQLQWKHFRQWH[WRIDIHGHUDOKDEHDV ,I WKH HQMR\PHQW RI WKH ULJKW LV LQH[WULFDEO\ ERXQG XS
SURFHHGLQJIROORZLQJWKHDSSURSULDWHH[KDXVWLRQRIVWDWH ZLWKWKHDFWLYLW\WKHOLWLJDQWZLVKHVWRSXUVXHWKHFRXUWDW
UHPHGLHV ZKHUH FRQFHUQV RI HTXLW\ FRPLW\ DQG OHDVWFDQEHVXUHWKDWLWVFRQVWUXFWLRQRIWKHULJKWLVQRW
IHGHUDOLVP  FRQFHUQV WKDW SODLQWLII@VWLOOKDV
LQFRPHV RI 0U )LW]JHUDOG DQG 0U 9RJOHU LQ WKDW LW ZLOO UHVRUWWRVWDWHKDEHDVUHOLHIZKHUHWKHFRQVWLWXWLRQDOLW\RIWKH
UHGXFHWKHQXPEHURIFDVHVLQZKLFKWKH\FRXOGEHDSSRLQWHG VWDWHSURFHGXUHVFRXOGEHGHWHUPLQHGE\WKHVWDWHFRXUWl
DQGSDLGDVDVVLJQHGDSSHOODWHFRXQVHOl
$FFRUGLQJO\ZHFRQFOXGHWKDWHDFKRIWKHWKUHHFULPLQDO
7KHGLVWULFWFRXUWFRQFOXGHGDQGZHDJUHHWKDWWKHGRFWULQH GHIHQGDQWSODLQWLIIVKDGDQRQJRLQJVWDWHFRXUWSURFHHGLQJDW
RIMXVWHUWLLDSSOLHVXQGHUWKHVHFLUFXPVWDQFHV7KH6XSUHPH WKHWLPHWKDWWKHIHGHUDOFRPSODLQWLQWKLVDFWLRQZDVILOHG
&RXUW KDV H[SODLQHG WKDW WKH GRFWULQH SHUPLWV D OLWLJDQW WR
EULQJ VXLW RQ EHKDOI RI D WKLUG SDUW\ SURYLGHG FHUWDLQ %$GHTXDWH2SSRUWXQLW\WR5DLVH&RQVWLWXWLRQDO&ODLPV
FRQGLWLRQVDSSO\WKHOLWLJDQWPXVWKDYHVXIIHUHGDQLQMXU\LQ
IDFWKHPXVWKDYHDFORVHUHODWLRQWRWKHWKLUGSDUW\DQGWKHUH ,QFRQVLGHULQJWKHDSSOLFDELOLW\RIWKHLWV@ FODLPVl
 $UPFR,QFY8QLWHG6WHHOZRUNHUVRI$PHULFD)G
 WK &LU  LQWHUQDO SXQFWXDWLRQ RPLWWHG FLWLQJ
7KH6XSUHPH&RXUWjVDQDO\VLVLQ6LQJOHWRQY:XOII )HGHUDO([SUHVV&RUSY7HQQHVVHH3XEOLF6HUY&RPPjQ
86DSSOLHVIRUFHIXOO\WRWKHIDFWVEHIRUHXV,Q )GWK&LU$IHGHUDOFRXUWVKRXOG
6LQJOHWRQWZRSK\VLFLDQVFKDOOHQJHGUHVWULFWLRQVRQIXQGLQJ QRW H[HUW MXULVGLFWLRQ LI WKH SODLQWLII KDG DQ RSSRUWXQLW\ WR
IRUDERUWLRQVSHUIRUPHGIRU0HGLFDLGHOLJLEOHSDWLHQWV7KH SUHVHQWKLVIHGHUDOFODLPLQVWDWHSURFHHGLQJV0RRUHY6LPV
&RXUWEHJDQE\REVHUYLQJWKDWmµ>R@UGLQDULO\RQHPD\QRW 86FLWLQJsXLGLFHY9DLO86
FODLPVWDQGLQJLQWKLV&RXUWWRYLQGLFDWHWKHFRQVWLWXWLRQDO $FFRUGLQJO\mDEVWHQWLRQLVDSSURSULDWHXQOHVVVWDWH
ULJKWVRIVRPHWKLUGSDUW\jl,GDWTXRWLQJ%DUURZVY ODZFOHDUO\EDUVWKHLQWHUSRVLWLRQRIWKHFRQVWLWXWLRQDOFODLPVl
sDFNVRQ  86     +RZHYHU WKLV UXOH ,GDW3XWDQRWKHUZD\m>:@KHQDOLWLJDQWKDVQRW
mVKRXOGQRWEHDSSOLHGZKHUHLWVXQGHUO\LQJMXVWLILFDWLRQVDUH DWWHPSWHGWRSUHVHQWKLVIHGHUDOFODLPVLQUHODWHGVWDWHFRXUW
DEVHQWl,G SURFHHGLQJV D IHGHUDO FRXUW VKRXOG DVVXPH WKDW VWDWH
SURFHGXUHVZLOODIIRUGDQDGHTXDWHUHPHG\LQWKHDEVHQFHRI
7KH&RXUWILUVWIRXQGWKDWWKHSK\VLFLDQVDOOHJHGDFRQFUHWH XQDPELJXRXV DXWKRULW\ WR WKH FRQWUDU\l  3HQQ]RLO &R Y
LQMXU\ 7H[DFR,QF86
,I WKH SK\VLFLDQV SUHYDLO LQ WKHLU VXLW WR UHPRYH WKLV 7KH GLVWULFW FRXUW IRXQG WKDW SODLQWLII 7HVPHU KDG DQ
OLPLWDWLRQWKH\ ZLOOEHQHILWIRUWKH\ZLOOWKHQUHFHLYH DGHTXDWHRSSRUWXQLW\WRSUHVHQWKLVIHGHUDOFODLPVEHFDXVHKH
SD\PHQW IRU WKH DERUWLRQV  7KH 6WDWH DQG )HGHUDO ILOHG D mODZ\HUO\ EULHIl VHHNLQJ D GHOD\HG DSSOLFDWLRQ IRU
*RYHUQPHQWZLOOEHRXWRISRFNHWE\WKHDPRXQWRIWKH OHDYHWRDSSHDO7HVPHUY*UDQKROP)6XSSGDW
SD\PHQWV  7KH UHODWLRQVKLS EHWZHHQ WKH SDUWLHV LV 7KHFRXUWFRQFOXGHGKRZHYHUWKDWSODLQWLII&DUWHUWKRXJK
FODVVLFDOO\DGYHUVHDQGWKHUHFOHDUO\H[LVWVEHWZHHQWKHP VLPLODUO\VLWXDWHGGLGQRWKDYHVXFKDQRSSRUWXQLW\EHFDXVH
DFDVHRUFRQWURYHUV\LQWKHFRQVWLWXWLRQDOVHQVH KHILOHGDGHFODUDWLRQVWDWLQJWKDWmKHGLGQRWKDYHDODZ\HUWR
UHSUHVHQWKLPDQGKHGLGQRWNQRZWKHODZl,G
 7HVPHUHWDOY*UDQKROPHWDO 1RV 1RV 7HVPHUHWDOY*UDQKROPHWDO 

:HDUHXQDEOHWRDJUHHZLWKWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWjVYLHZRIWKH &([WUDRUGLQDU\&LUFXPVWDQFHV
VFRSHRILWVLQTXLU\ZLWKUHVSHFWWRZKHWKHUWKHVWDWHSURYLGHG
SODLQWLII &DUWHU ZLWK DQ DGHTXDWH RSSRUWXQLW\ WR UDLVH KLV 7KH GLVWULFW FRXUW FRQVLGHUHG ZKHWKHU H[WUDRUGLQDU\
FRQVWLWXWLRQDOFODLPV7KHmDGHTXDWHRSSRUWXQLW\lSURQJRI FLUFXPVWDQFHV H[LVWHG WKDW ZRXOG PDNH DEVWHQWLRQ
WKHDEVWHQWLRQGRFWULQHUHTXLUHVDJHQHUDOL]HGUHYLHZRIWKH LQDSSURSULDWHRQO\ZLWKUHVSHFWWRSODLQWLII7HVPHU+RZHYHU
SURFHGXUHVPDGHDYDLODEOHE\WKHVWDWHWRUDLVHFRQVWLWXWLRQDO JLYHQ WKH VLPLODULW\ RI WKHLU VLWXDWLRQV WKH VDPH DQDO\VLV
LVVXHV$VWKHFDVHVFLWHGDERYHPDNHDEXQGDQWO\FOHDULQWKH DSSOLHVWRDOOWKUHHFULPLQDOGHIHQGDQWSODLQWLIIV
DEVHQFH RI FRPSHOOLQJ HYLGHQFH WR WKH FRQWUDU\ WKHUH LV D
VWURQJSUHVXPSWLRQRIDGHTXDF\ &LUFXPVWDQFHV MXVWLI\LQJ IHGHUDO FRXUW LQWHUIHUHQFH ZLWK
VWDWHSURFHHGLQJVRQO\H[LVWZKHUHLUUHSDUDEOHLQMXU\LVERWK
+HUHWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWGHWHUPLQHGWKDWSODLQWLII7HVPHUKDG mJUHDWDQGLPPHGLDWHlZKHUHWKHVWDWHODZLVmIODJUDQWO\DQG
DQ DGHTXDWH RSSRUWXQLW\ WR UDLVH KLV FODLP  ,I KH KDG DQ SDWHQWO\YLRODWLYHRIH[SUHVVFRQVWLWXWLRQDOSURKLELWLRQVlRU
DGHTXDWHRSSRUWXQLW\WKHQSODLQWLII&DUWHUZKRZDVVLPLODUO\ ZKHUHWKHUHLVDVKRZLQJRImEDGIDLWKKDUDVVPHQWRUDQ\
VLWXDWHGGLGDOVR7KDWSODLQWLII&DUWHUZDVDOOHJHGO\XQDEOH RWKHU XQXVXDO FLUFXPVWDQFHV WKDW ZRXOG FDOO IRU HTXLWDEOH
WRWDNHDGYDQWDJHRIWKHRSSRUWXQLW\EHFDXVHRIWKHODFNRI UHOLHIl$@VVXPLQJWKDWOLWLJDQWV