Smith v. . Weaver

This was an action of trespass for killing a slave, the property of the plaintiff, who had been hired to the defendant. The jury found a verdict for the plaintiff, under the direction of the Court, stating to them that in point of law the defendant was liable, if the facts charged in the declaration were established by satisfactory evidence. The objection taken in the trial was that the offense charged amounted to felony, the civil remedy for which, although the defendant had been indicted and was acquitted, was nevertheless merged in the crime. And now, upon a motion for a new trial, it was argued by