^ ORIGINAL
^4ujfo,%X*t PRECEIVED IN
COL'RT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS
JUL 14 2015
/^/////^/%*sA &dj*jJy Ap;//^ijj/?s<3j£ Abel Acosfa, Cfark
^ FILED IN
-uhT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS
JUL H 2015
A/aJ£"/?-dao97'&<
£t?sag~M._
•>%?f^^xj/eJlz/^ ^^Jl j&mfjjr//y ^c/j-^m^, jpfj&ry1-
^/^ M/jddfMJf
^feaf&ufag. ,3.
^stswx ay^y£j%&x>/E>_ .3
^JsyWtx/fy&sWc^^ Jss/^yy&s//y^
^7
/%%>> £&>/) - lz_
(&&*//>&/*(£, ?9oS,ijJ.Zc4'J71-,tft/(7h*.dki>m. fyp> 7?77) jo
(rc/iyipjed lAJfeAs 7rz J,lJ,$7 VFj 97f%/, &>*»* AM, **>*/•) — lo
My;#A7/7,Shil, g7/SuJ<^'7S3//S6(7i/l6i,M /ty. 7?f}) .to
AiJftfjfafcj 27J,iJ,jJfr£/%£(£/.<&*»*, Ttyf, loves') . ,/Zm
styp i/sShit, (3^S,i^.2/?aJ(71*,&,-»«, tyy, 7ni) _ /z_
tltoptfjfrA, gZ3J,uJ,*Jj&,2SJL J/J (77*. /&7dt7,jkfc, 7JTf,cJ,tj3U,g^7f7ZY. dk,h* Tfyp, 7?*g) Cj
/£*(&/Z.i/sJM/ P9o S*uf>*J 9/3,923f7?y. &,*», 7ty>, 7?fJ-) zo&3) ,—_ <\
6/y/iJj7'J&Ji, /73f,u/.*J 377yZ77{7x,fa.~lMcoZoo+j)i7,M'J)_. f
yTy. 3?*, £J7Z ) ty.
7&. As, tSJdr Jh*t. S&t/ftJ&i- JO?') ?
/&,>&, &/£•//*//* f<37,#ZCa)Ci/7MoA/ A?/t) , /^
yT*d„,&r7k*'£W03&M(l7/M*t*a/+)« ; IX
9
-)£/^Sjyfy$/WSy/s^y'd/kfy$s7,Jv70fyjf
^J/x%£ <3JJt3y7y7c"£ 4y^^7^^/OL£p7y?y*y&*Ay^df/A/j^fj,
cfa0£$^ti£,l72J d^cZ^yS^/^aifiJ^Aj %S^Ada-
i^xJ^ Jyi/Jyf/3y^7yAfr^y&£?£ JtfjLs,^yJyyC^Cj^ ±t£>
4&&J ^^y^67^7y77^y^^^y^^
J%^*^>^/&Gr
yyf'J /3 <*aS /%./sffiyty- /st 73/3sTyt^yyJA&Xp'sf/lTfajfThSe)dfylk
yfi:C/3y^yyy^7y^, (Zt,*/ af/faylfs/j zfyjffSyYti fafe^ r^ ^
d?A7j(£-/#M^ *y?y3%97-* /Yf.i77;J
(/) 7/? d*au*/-*fdfyw^/f dt/J/jy /J7/7 d/tycy deAd/y^e/
do/ddJyVMSrtMS yjTyiy^77^/j daorf/s £>p^yeyfyyf 7>Jl fp^t dSJ<7L.
(l) 77l dtu/t/'tff- yfy/s/J dy'A/j/dbyJc/y-d'<3 yVdyTke/yfi-
7///.cJiff 7$k d27yz//y7y:^t
(sITal du*/- c7/yfos*/j /pA/7't?77//?/yrct/5 Ute-JjlMt/j /y/yju/Tjy-oyt/yy4'y^J,c-f-
T^si /yiA/y^yp /fa/ M^ dy/Ayci. cdyyw7//^yyy/f£fc&7fc>//p
Scf/Tydy/yA
If ) /%• d%s/t/j7yfatW/s cy^y-yJMjJ 6A/d S<sia7/*(*/M^
dTjA/yfi yfcy^y j7 ff/t/yyv/syed'dfyp&d) d^y/ds/ty/cy.
(O y^L &l/*/'y7 /%y£y/7 y%//yf/£ yc/y^TT yiyTtt Co»j7/7fc-
/yV/L7yb d^ATJyyy^A^y&y&yyesS dyy/y^/j£A y^yrtyyj/dayy/Jri*/
yi>J&Jey^yty&Jysyyzffyjci. y%*/*7 £a/fosc7#sfM*/t #7?f2c/yzty-dy
JdC&/!'£ %yd? Afarfa 177// ^ 7>s.y.yZJr y7-«r f Aa/d>,7!ritMlk ./fOfr/'//.' wfo W2
C(1fi .*JJ7A ?** d77y.77M- 7,fw Jot^tofi M'JLC/aJ*dk /**-
yr&y£ yfayyy^J^jfyfe j6x£^jfe-p^s^ *&*fs3rf dhysrM
yydyd dyy^ytz ykyy^ yyytf^jfygyyy^A Jry&z z^^4^W
^y^c^yyVi.yy^c7y^y^y^yJsfyfyJ^ o^A^Ok^A^B y&/A/t/^/<7mJ,
cdydyyytyyt/y%* aWrys*.
f£A„* £,,71,7JJ?9- 3J?9~9d 77?*- /**.**. fa. Retool fafiUtoTlpfOmSWW
A/yfyyyyy dhyydh£ ys'J&*s**<£*/***&>^^yyycyyfyyy
ryjyt 7y-r^7.,y?ry rrvflK.Q^ tfifif/y ?drX,y2,dS70y7ryyyTy.7^.^. y^ym, /ffdJ: Tf/yfAA/ (/, fjMp #77
3Z,.}.9J77?L77s'Su*. sz.*.. fa 7/ /ft-
&J. UaJ- V9.ys. dlrdffo ftfr^ ?rrr<«t<*
fa. yyjczy
t°
y>/t xA7^y$y/tyVfydyAkoAu Ay^sA^
yfa^AZyjAy^ySyy^^ dZotAoAA^Z&y' ^yUd^y-
y6,A*3 yt7yc,7^Ayeayd*7*AA$i yyyAyytTLp#mty*£0O&^z&tz/ZP
.^y^ytAyyyyyys: 73SAyy/yyd^Azyy(i J^dA^yrc?Ayi7yO. j^yy^y^A/-^
^J/jtfyAy^^ yfry^^^
yyy^y^AyA^^^AyAk *AAyiyz yAydpyA? 3&fyyp *A/3h£jL
fA^. S7* r„y, *J<~yr Afc. fa, -d„tv/7i*tfatf*«itXy^AyA^^
ay^y^yyyyM^y^yA^/yy^^yAAyyy^^y^AyAy jto?M*&£La&/'yfi<
M yyyA&ycyi AAlXadZ^A dJa yA AfadyZyyifyGyryvfyTp &y7dd3ky2fdsAk3 cAsK
tAAyyyyfty *AA&3gy* *&*£. a/tytA* •';&/£ W Ai/yAycA.dZdd}
afatiA Ajft. AsdTfc c7#7sddprk&**£ ^A+A^JxAjwfc'
j&7/*/aSAk dtyyAsytyp' &77#c ,?#*»/&'*sn£*e& Sc^'*A*y Afc
yyyp3 a^SsmSs**">JS'* ***'<**&£*'&y *?«#**»'
/?j~) ••y?>*ryQcdy&yvryyjsArtJsyyyip 73*3 &f*&d&vA: ^T'
Colli* yy^Ajyp
y^ ,
yA«y, **«*£& * & O^gM^'^*"*'
,, . i^^.A^yy.yJ7ny^^Jyd^yy^yiy^yy
£dA T'AAyi^^ tppATd/yyA&r y^u^yyy /&£.
II
yfayyAwAAWAAyytsz. ^7tA^yy<>?A&A: y^/rdf^yayAAA
tyyyyjyy. At^A/'y^sA^ ysadyycdy ytyyfayrAfa7yAyyyyyfdf'' 7**>y
A^ yyy£yyy^A^^ y5y?c£ysr>J'£yc£-f y>yuAy yyAeAAfy^/tfaATAyfe/3?cA
0cccryy&y. ^yyyyyfyj/ycy•yAA&.J&M£- &d y7yy&£ lAh^y^ ad<*. yS/wy,
ay~ yyyyyy^AAAky^Afeyyyy7£s yyA&* yAfrtAgyyAy&a*. c?os»7d>,yfJyy3
ykyTuAAdy?y/A yyyy^yy y^yyy^d^y. A,yp? y33d^ dss?S.id.iJ?a3d73d,
dybrt/. fa, d?fZ), %yyj yydyyyytayeArfyp dCvyy/ytyr 7^7cy^Jy7y7yy/Ay^A
yyHAyyytTds^ydyyj yyy^yfyyyy^yyoyy y£ ydtds/yAfeyy*y/y^\ ''dZzdy yZfA^yAA^
AAy^yy^y^yfyfy* 3Z£ ^s^^^^^^^a^*^' ^i^g*i^y^^e^>i//^^^-/»0ff--
Sdyci. atc AyyyAydfr ad d&Ai 3fc/*dy yd/QcAyA^AapyrAf..*sfad/p/wtya
y<*.7y>yyiy7y3 yAy^c^yyAJp^y^Aady^y^
pj/dyeydAfcyt syc%yy<*f/wyy/3ydc/ycjA£^jy~
aAyy^y^yd ys£y7yCy/eca>'*/**?ffo*'7"
fa. *w/3 Apyyddyy'Ayyyp yAypl>yy/y,fy dyt7/7*7-
yyy&a*£ Asdyy-cyA **. d^^As &»*s*j£ yd^/&^yyyfa
tLm ~Aa*a»//. 7J. sA3*7. _4Urr*«7to&fy/t *<* */**&»*?>'-
4„&, >^W auat/J. 3Z><*f&*y* cA^7^AA6.^/3udd7cy^y
*y/& d^Ary^yyd^dy^^y a^yAJ^^yy€^Jp^A3yy^^^Ay7
>—32(»M( 7777 yj 7>yy)y Ads* d7,yp /J, f7>± 3>9rn I
' ^Ayy^ybyAzAy >Asdd7L dw*A*Af0K>J&*jrJ*yA'i)-
/yp> tAl dyy^/y^ &7*j A^d^joddyy^AA ^M»J^/(^/jy&y*-
^,3P&JWA&07&A0*Jfa*y Ayy*o>yyr,yfeJyyjpAr £&e*3fejA^yJ
fyAi/A)'yyjjSuAA^yyA ^yyJ^c^c7^yAy^^^ ifitefeA
Ad?ye£yJJaJ/ddJz. sAavyjp A7l ysf/^Ayrtxr6AZyA*cdiydk'£7/tfc*A/A/m^y* 46yy&JyAAyyyy3y dy,ijAj a7j y^yAy^yyA/Ayc^Mc
e?dtpyAtAsAy &7^7*y,77(//Zy: yd^JA/dy/^y,yyyy/yAyy^£/7y/yyylt/y3^y77tay-
?AyijA^y&Ajy*wsdAy6'p?cyyd/Ayy/jAy/7e?/S),J<7.y>y*Yz) .
dTAyMSAyfi &ycy*pysyy*d&AJd/yy djfta3): 7d//y37£yM&Lody2^y0,7%^A/ddJ)
yyyrfyy//&AA3,)/)jAj/yAAye>//p/ dvajrppyy*y ydyrd7yjjdp yv/73
d<^y^/y/'y/pyAyy/cTdlX.. 7yA,yd rfyppy^,//?^fy±Ay"d*ppy='y/As3yy 4'39,626?)70Ux/
Afy-yjy/yAjdyrdMy»7t3e^yfs£&y&ycAJ/yy/J Ay/^y^y &/p/*yayAj£
dAyMtyyAA/yyy A*Jdyyy^/yyyy>y ^d/psyAy^JAApyy/jy^yx. ad'd^AZyyjyAyy
Cy/ddA/dd/Lsydddydfeu ay^/yj^J^yA^yp^/yy^y yl/ysAyjA/AyAOAnJ/A/sLyS/ry
fdL%63te)(l)L
312f y^,/yyA^y^yd^^£ /Af/zjdvyyyyjtL *d&yj£r *£ycyp/?y>y*/fJ/ecAA/je7:
^jfcdd "y^y"^ysyjuddy3%l ApyyArf/&: yyjAdyyyyp Ay ^dAy/yyyyyiJjf^yda.-
ddc/Aya ytedb£ft'/(Ey^y^Ay^A yyA Ai drppttepg-jAAi3/(>£/t: Aaay^Ayymsf
%x,d?sy,yf*y£. d?yyy, IIM.ou&KO, 2i.o3fcX$ (VXy.fi. fo.dUyJ*U3Ubc)
(ys*Ay*AfJ?07j).
Y/J /Di/Mp/Z/.toty (Z)/AJ hALZur/tfydlXSSAjlM^ yfa///j^/p(9) JrJ
^AAJ/A^yA^AfA^CjA/jL 7cr 7/y.dkiy2je y;d'yas#7yM/yjfcjp yAlAd'^yyAyAyTy^7AAAyA
dAAyy jyfs^^yAyy^yAdcZyyA&Aty^/^AyAfr. &) /yA^A^T^y^iyAy^, ayC
y^ycAAyydy &c/yyA^Ap^/yAyt/yy'AJ/fyyydZaAlBfflJpyAeaAxyAy*?;/yM>~
AyyyfA^77 i/rs*flf*.ys/r*J/t y,fyj>s),,J,.u< wJAi*/^p d7t ys.^styr/u,**/
/jfAyjdysy/fyyyyjjvsdy.' ^J>ys^*/»?).
y^^&ytyyfcywyAyAy^yy^AyyyytyA7Ayyyy^d^d3A^7Ayy
y3>yyAdyy?y7yyyAA3yy/3yJjAyyAA?yAf^ Sod)3/y'7L/riypdfsyfa7/U'jArfAky
ALyyyyyc yvyrj&sAtxAAfc. yZysypfypy, ddtrsA^yr/fafAdyyiyL j^yM fa/
<3&*7yyyyy54^yy^£yd^fyAA^ yA^^uyyyAyyiM^AyA^y^dAip^yp'j
cy/yA/yAfSAu "Mi**. yy,y,A,j "Jf
1'-2^Ai'J yf3J£) tAAjJAJ'ytyr77/rt,'yy%y*Mp/?dy&AyAJdfpp7d
[)) Jyc/UtyycyM^/yyyAAydd adpAApAyyA/Ac/jTySyyA/AAoJA,y6yy7yS/'//Ay'y
y^yfeAytAA/^ytoysyyj/yjsyAdi) yyyAi ac/y/y^AA/^yyA/dAy o&AtoJ /i/AyA^-
y/yyyfyy/ij/Ayy/py yjyA/cAAsjyy y^/u/AAsyyycjj A*A$yypyyyyyyA'd^AJp33cdyJ'-
dAyyy^dyyyAL dp. fAtA/yyf*/ 77,'j yjyyidyyyfxtyj/yAdd/y^/jA^AyA^/^
T&yyydyy-AfMy/j MptpsJ/ ten: yTy£.,.YUs.a^i ff Z9.*i/j)/i)*-J4.A2ti).
*3Zyyj*yy, Adypyyy^> j%t.yyp7A/?A y*cy/4£s£yyA^y*yAy jA^foyAdA/ytAJfjdyyAt
£s7/yA3A£As*#AyA *AjAy, tdAdsyyrs^yA*Ay£*y7yty(rAQd^ypAArAA3yy^,
A3yyyAy/£ a/dyAAyjAA&c/yA
c;Ayyysy>yjA,AyAxA0?,ys yAdyyA/ya. ypryj*Ayyy^Ay^£ AAoya. dd(y#yp'>
CA/tAiAsA/LAdsa AJs*j*y. AyJ,uf.sJ27yyv. 3T*s^/pzyypy cdAdsyyyAAy.
fadAyyyyyy *AJ(l dyyJ/yctpyAi67dfJyyp Guy/Aa/j AA^A/eA^pAdyJjyypyyJp
eye yytydAi syyAycz. yyT,jyyp>sA7<*A &*#zjA*y£ A$,dd'A'yAA/y£ a/j 0a>t*-j
duT/fcypy'yyA_3y/AjAAi;A&fyyy at/^73£yy/y7AAyy^y/A y^yyyzJydAy//^fA^^AT^ydd(fdf-
A/Jfy^/ypAAy^y^ry/fyltAA/yyJbdtAyy/yyyyd&yyf yAydTfypy Add. fa(fy /y3u33, cre/vy
cidA? TAAyA/yrA, A^y&yy, yy^L^yyy/d?/^ AZuxTrAyyAyfyfyyAydyyAA/ya: h-
7Ayyso 63aCt)hyM^
3?AyJfa/3p> AAy3i/J:h'cdn,7J- d3ajfc/J A?y 0^4^62*7Jy^**/*?a***/^
yAoadfyyj f/feytpyAyy /yJyfyrtyAyf1yy/yd/yyPyai/Ajyfiy£3 y/AfpeA
"dA/Jyy cy^Jj,y'jfadxtj,333*77^73MdJrya. fe &7Ay>dp fcfo/,**/
/yy/3cyy>vyA&£/'AUAsyydAyujyyy/ 7?£yHy/£>7'AT/?*. 677*A Ad/Ay^d <2 /77dA/t t
yjyy yA73j/yMs/z7pyy7yc6dad ysj/yAd7yv/y^^AAy yyy ^Aaa frs3/y /UA/t/AjrJ
yAAyjyy yj/d/yey^d/dd^r jd^sy-^AyyAy'yps,*o/yjpy7/p~7'..., W^ /y^Ad
a7/ayAk/£ A*JotJl*ATAAAAaM*
&£ i?cAAL/cy?£L lid/jkpArz. S*vJ,sJ' 9$y11 (fe. &>•#». fift). Zoo*).
yfyyyAU/yy a5mx7> y*£ m*£Acd3'y?x*Au: yd/y/t dJ/rAi As3*3c?Aui
A&cirA Jy&yys/rAy /MAy/d/yp cy^AeAyfoyy//# ^AlAam of&i'Aiy-J/M?
ddAfc £3syyAAd/t^ryy?!/ odAe dAAyjy Ayy*yyA^'&m*7pA6tJyrM A/PasT-3c/y-
tdyp adyyyyyry/yc£yy& d/rcdy &yyoy/J//TyAcyAd*
7s:
(z) d/A7y1yd7yyjr yfgyAAvJj A// £>(/cAy£r A' j/fesAMCAU&>/p&/AjjyAy/^ /fefM?/*)/
% y^ytedA/yfAdo ayyAy^Ay^ y7;Ay^yiyyAJyAydAy^^y^Ac^ayJL
Jc? A^/Ayyi/yy/z y/yJAjATpyya /Ji/ytss &k//JAa/j/a/JAyfefAopy*/vy3f/ry.
7%£ d%uyfit7& /UtfyAyyA Ayd <3yy?/?77yyij/ 63J3 /Msyd/yy J AtAcfay/t /Art-
/ffl0h//'2<7yvAyJp37i0i ¥fA6*w/y:J&*/Ay/fA yyAy dAy^yAyy y*7Jj m^J^A
Ay yfcdbaeA yfaffyAtii/AyZyrfZ/Js rfkd'AdjPdCd**/ <£Af/ld/? /3 /9///A/y
&A?AyrAA/^/^yMAsSv/v=r AyA^/y^/Atp/Ayy Atcyyiyyy/Ajy tAa yypy/-
T&yjAj Ayjyfo/v/rsyrAAyt Jy/iy MyAAAtAAy yyyAy3rdiu^efTdyA tiv-
y£ycA= yy tiL 7%A7&«yiAtfyydk faz/ZA^/tu^ acfc*7frj£M Ay^tyixy
7aa•&sfai*yt. y^tAfcy^&^ty7fa&wJ&&6Jh^Mz/
yA/Je/ry/^yyrpp/AypJ-7t TtorudL AojAy//dv^AoA-3d tihryaty.
T&Ayty/yy yftx/tdofcyyiyA jyzfcrArAAa/e-rt/faAAzAfA/A'^yAd/tod
/,yjj A^yrz. U, A3yjAdrJj7n±s >32717.3. 913/ ?JAf/99d)fhA*M TA/yAyJ^A
i7,y£?y/7y/A3,**//&/Ay yA/^cAA^yddydu////
CAA/^ ?yy>s ^yAA'yA Afyyryyfy/ty*yyy3; a)\A7/y/pA'y adf*y&/d-
A/i Apd6, yid/y/ymc/jAAy-y?dA3eyyyJAy *yy 77/etrypyJA Ay^t/Tajd
7aaaAa &3/r. 0£r c^yi/jAAyAl/yy/dAeyby yyyrd/z /ydkyyfeyy/yfodAo
y%AA3AA/7dyy/y7d?jy/y^yAJy ad'dA7A7*ayVC£-. dZAyV? dAdA'AAo/J Id/7)//d4
7397AAA, 337* 397/ &J,M A0J~7yA77a), A^A/yyAipA/yy3AA3 A3M$&&~
//yy>y&73yd(?yy£yy3A/a yy7A&»y^mx/yyA)y^^AyiAlyyyy^c/wy/AdlJ
ay AyyyvyyAy^,y*y'yddyyyyAA' j/ojA/Ji y^*/farS£/M&*7r&~
yt/TyAb^JAyyydy AfrcA^Ajd&AJ Aa^^a/aA, ^fayyjA/yyyAyyyAyj
A7Ayy<£3'J^^y^^y^dyyA/iAAy/APAdCc/^3^£, 0/1 ymnyAds/fyf/AAAAiy33A
/%
AAJTfo/uf. "y«*yp? 77 *jA*fe. gZJJ,t*7,ld AyjpyytA/^JdyuA/
dzA cAyAyytfyUL £jAtAf£/t aAa Afc?dytiy&A cZdu^y'aA tAjy-yjrAdA/ yyczAAo-
d'AZ/yy Ai XftyAxy/yA "
A?yp7£dA#A (Zy/dxyyAy Ay7 Ak edpyAydApfe /%,*#/£ dry^^A7%l fa/
&y37y'ybA/dyjfiddoy^yAyd^AAaA/AaAaAj yyuy aTyyyyyjAfa AmoX
033a3'7'y/?s7Ay/dAAy /f/OyyeJ /j££. 77^,7/ Vjyizz. .
T^yyydAu/c/yyyr tAaa y3*sA AAyA'A&A A/a yAf,yAy7AuA*A*7/>~
yA5/zA/AyAjyy^Ay/J AydAcd ypyiydAy^AA Ay f/ryA///y^AuA AtrAA
A&A/syd1J/cyyAZ, ddAAy/'aasAyzyA/ry7£y,A2J>A3. ytfay^yyA-^&ypdyiA/d^^^^^e^L^^^^^-
y%A?y£yjA/yy^yZnyJ!/: yy/y^yy%/yAzAy//yyd/d1dtd^yA^A,
6^^dy^y/$%/
Y/3/d^aJ^yA/?yyy
d7£c/j*37yA£/y7dAA: /fayA AAdJddZj
y^Ayyy&^dyAyyyy^
A^AAAy^^J^y.
A?AAkyy, ySc A&jA
yzyAAAsy.
dyy^A'' ddsd?y&?7yyy/
AA/AaAytyAi."37yd/c>3 ,Akbjy,yyv?dA£ ydpyy/dyA
y7~AAf, /y/*y ,^ZyyyAyyr y7ydy£ Ay/yyAA ^AA-yyy-yy yAy/yyyyJ/^
/^^^^^^^^^^^^/^ */k& J^y^/zy/yy/ydazy/^y'ddy
y$y/Ayy Adz dyfyg y^(3/yy&/A,
£vyJ/*7 Afrs Ak-J*—yzfyiAjs/JL- J>dK/./?>
V/C7//•cSuAyTfAdVy*
\yJAkZJ7d73dyyy
"d&U AU/ydr/^d dAddyZyz?
AoAyAcy ddy/A
P37d A/7-$3-J3L
ypA/yy/yy^Ay/ Afd^y
y^yy^yyA^Ay y/A 9y/A/ry.
JyyyAy yzyAdy Ay-y^Aa? ^yy/Ayf^yy^Ay^pyy^yAs^y^
cPyyyySyyyayyyy /yj/y^yMA-Ayy^AAdZd!) AJdy y^d/y/yiyyyJA. A&d/A
,d4>ydyy 3^X33 AAAdd, yiytAzAy dAy.^- yAyyAfAy_ j^/T^/J
Jy yAAy^3yy%Ay^J3y3ay'^
.'AAy/AyS/A/y^y/
3&id/sAp&y7dyyyti-k y77?y^7
y^y^y/y^y dduyA
A37d 7^7/37-22-
MA&7/r, 73yc>j 77dA
J9'
In The
Court of Appeals
Sixth Appellate District of Texas at Texarkana
No. 06-14-00097-CR
WILLIE FRANK JACKSON, Appellant
V.
THE STATE OF TEXAS, Appellee
On Appeal from the 354th District Court
Hunt County, Texas
Trial Court No. 29,295
Before Morriss, C.J., Moseley and Burgess, JJ.
Memorandum Opinion by Chief Justice Morriss
MEMORANDUM OPINION
Near some Greenville apartments, Willie Frank Jackson stood over Steven Ray Cook—as
Cook lay on the ground after having been shot in the leg by Jackson—pointed his gun at Cook,
and demanded that Cook tell him the location of Cook's wallet. After being told that the wallet
was in the console of Cook's nearby truck, Jackson was seen rummaging through Cook's truck.
The wallet was later found, less the forty dollars previously in it, along the path of Jackson's
departure from the scene.
Jackson was convicted of aggravated robbery and, after enhancement of the charges to
habitual offender status, was sentenced to ninety years' incarceration. We affirm the trial court's
judgment, because (1) legally sufficient evidence shows Jackson's theft and (2) Jackson failed to
preserve his complaint of wrongful electronic restraint.
(1) Legally SufficientEvidence Shows Jackson's Theft
Pointing to a perceived lack of evidence of theft, Jackson claims the evidence is insufficient
to support his aggravated robbery conviction. We disagree.
In evaluating legal sufficiency of the evidence, we review all evidence in the light most
favorable to the verdict to determine whether any rational fact-finder could have found guilt
beyond a reasonable doubt. Brooks v. State, 323 S.W.3d 893, 912 (Tex. Crim. App. 2010) (citing
Jackson v. Virginia, 443 U.S. 307, 319 (1979)); Brown v. State, 333 S.W.3d 606, 608 (Tex. App.—
Dallas 2009, no pet.). We examine legal sufficiency under the direction of the Brooks opinion,
while giving deference to the responsibility of the jury "to fairly resolve conflicts in testimony, to
weigh the evidence, and to draw reasonable inferences from basic facts to ultimate facts." Hooper
v. State, 214 S.W.3d 9, 13 (Tex. Crim. App. 2007) (citing Jackson, 443 U.S. at 318-19).
Legal sufficiency of the evidence is measured by the elements of the offense as defined by
a hypothetically correct jury charge. Malikv. State, 953 S.W.2d 234, 240 (Tex. Crim. App. 1997).
The hypothetically correct jury charge "sets out the law, is authorized by the indictment, does not
unnecessarily increase the State's burden of proof or unnecessarily restrict the State's theories of
liability, and adequately describes the particular offense for which the defendant was tried." Id.
In this case, Jackson committed aggravated robbery if (1) Jackson committed theft of property
with the intent to obtain or maintain control of that property and (2) in the course of this theft,
Jackson intentionally, knowingly, or recklessly caused serious bodily injury to Cook by shooting
Cook in the leg. See Tex. Penal Code Ann. § 29.03 (West 2011). Jackson disputes only the theft
element of aggravated robbery. Theft is the unlawful appropriation of property, without the
effective consent of the owner, with the intent to deprive the owner of the property. See TEX.
PenalCode Ann. § 31.03 (West Supp. 2014).
The record indicates that Cook was visiting a friend at an apartment complex in Greenville
on the evening of the robbery. Cook left the apartment complex around 7:00 p.m. to go to a
convenience store. Cook returned to the apartment complex a short time later, parked his truck,
and noticed that Jackson was walking toward him. Jackson was wearing an oven mitt which
concealed a gun. After striking Cook in the face, Jackson pointed the gun directly at Cook's head
and pulled the trigger. The gun merely clicked. Jackson told Cook, who was seated in the driver's
seat of his truck with the door open, "[T]hat one's free. . . .You better move." Cook did not
understand what Jackson wanted. At that point, Jackson shot Cook in the lower leg. Jackson again
demanded that Cook move. Cook got out of the truck and began to trot off, falling after about
thirty feet. After Cook fell, he saw Jackson standing over him with the gun pointed at his face.
When Jackson asked Cook where his wallet was, Cook told him it was in the console of his truck.
Cook then saw Jackson rummaging through his truck, after which Jackson began to walk away
from the truck. Cook was able to make his way back to his friend's apartment, where he told the
friend of his encounter with Jackson and cleaned his leg wounds. Cook, believing his wounds
were not serious, bandaged his leg and then asked his friend to find out what was missing from his
truck.
The following day, Cook returned to the apartments to check on his truck and discovered
that the truck keys were missing. Cook's wallet was not in the truck, nor was a .22 caliber Stinger
hand gun he kept in the console. After walking in the general direction of Jackson's route of
departure on the previous day, Cook found his wallet lying on the ground. He discovered, though,
that forty dollars was missing from the wallet. After reporting the crime to the police, Cook went
to the hospital.
Jackson claims this evidence fails to show that he actually deprived Cook of his money and
gun. He claims that, because Cook was bleeding after the blow to his face, he was unable to clearly
see whether Jackson took the missing items from Cook's truck. He further claims that, because
Cook's friend looked in the truck after Jackson left to determine if anything was missing and
because the truck might have been left unlocked in the parking lot overnight, it is mere speculation
to conclude Jackson took money from Cook's wallet as well as the small gun that was stored in
the truck's console.
As described above, after Cook told Jackson that his wallet was in the console of his truck,
he witnessed Jackson rifling through the contents of the truck and then leaving the apartment
parking lot on foot. The following day, Cook found his wallet in Jackson's path of travel away
from the parking lot. The wallet was missing the forty dollars, and Cook's gun was missing from
the truck's console. That Cook's vision might have been impaired due to bleeding from a wound
is a factor for the jury to consider and resolve. The jury also heard testimony that Cook's friend
had access to the truck and that the truck could have been left unlocked overnight. These were
likewise factors for the jury to consider and resolve. The fact remains, however, that Jackson rifled
through the console before he left the parking lot that day—before anybody else could have
possibly done so, including Cook's friend. Considered in the light most favorable to the jury's
verdict, a rational jury could have found, beyond a reasonable doubt, the elements of aggravated
robbery. The evidence was sufficient to support the jury's verdict.
(2) Jackson Failed to Preserve His Complaint of Wrongful Electronic Restraint
During the punishment phase of trial, Jackson was asked to remove his shirt so that the
testifying witness could view his tattoos. Evidently, under his shirt, Jackson was wearing a shock
belt restraint1 when the request was made. Jackson complains of trial courterrorin failing to make
'A shock belt or stun belt
is a device placed around a defendant's midsection that uses an electric shock to temporarily disable
the defendant if his actions pose a security threat. The belt is controlled by a remote device held by
a security official in the courtroom. If the belt is activated, the defendant will receive a powerful
electric shock sufficient to temporarily incapacitate him.
5
specific findings on the record to justify imposition of the restraint at trial. Jackson further
contends that, because the jury was able to see that he was wearing an electronic restraint, he is
entitled to a new punishment trial.
The issue arose in connection with Jackson's tattoos, which the State sought to prove were
evidence of Jackson's membership in a prison gang known as the Mandingo Warriors. The State
questioned David Johnson, with the Texas Department of Criminal Justice, about tattoos indicative
of Mandingo Warrior membership. Although Johnson had viewed photographs of Jackson's
tattoos, he had never met Jackson. When the State sought to elicit testimony from Johnson
authenticating photographs of Jackson's tattoos, Jackson objected, stating that, because Johnson
did not take the photographs, he was not the proper person to authenticate them. In response, the
State asked "that the defendant remove his shirt and show the jury so that they can all properly
authenticate it. . . ." The following colloquy ensued:
[DEFENSE COUNSEL]: You want to take your shirt off -
[THE STATE]: We can do that in private or in front of the jury.
THE COURT: All right.
[DEFENSE COUNSEL]: So do you want to do it in front of the jury or do you
want to do it in just a little bit?
[DEFENDANT]: I'll do it right there in front of the jury. It don't matter.
State v. Belcher, 183 S.W.3d 443, 445 n.l (Tex. App.—Houston [14th Dist.] 2005, no pet.) (citation omitted); see
Taylor v. State, 279 S.W.3d 818, 820 n.l (Tex. App.—Eastland 2008, pet. ref d).
THE COURT: All right. If you'll step over here and raise your shirt and
show them your tattoos.
[DEFENSE COUNSEL]: Hold on, Your Honor, just a second. Can we
approach?
Just a second, Mr. Jackson.
They put a shock belt —
[THE STATE]: If he's willing to take his shirt off, then let him take his
shirt off.
[DEFENSE COUNSEL]: No. No. No. No. No. What I'm saying is--
THE COURT: He's already taken his shirt off.
[DEFENSE COUNSEL]: Huh?
THE COURT: His shirt's off.
[DEFENSE COUNSEL]: Oh, nevermind. Nevermind.
THE COURT: All right. If you'd step over in front of the jury, sir.
[THE STATE]: And since this is the witness that's testifying, if we could
show the witness? That's really the only person I need to see them.
That's far enough.
THE COURT: All right. Let the record reflect the defendant has removed
his shirt and has marched in front of the jury so they could see any tattoos that he
might have.
As is clear from the foregoing colloquy, defense counsel did not object to the use of an
electronic restraint or to the removal of Jackson's shirt in front of the jury. While counsel seemed
to indicate that Jackson was wearing a shock belt, no objection was stated on that or on any other
basis. Further, when counsel learned that Jackson had removed his shirt, any objection—to the
extent one was articulated—was abandoned when counsel told the court "nevermind [sic]." No
previous or subsequent mention of a shock belt appears in the record.
The Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments to the United States Constitution prohibit the use
of physical restraints visible to the jury unless the trial court determines that such restraints are
justified to ensure physical security, escape prevention, or courtroom decorum. Deck v. Missouri,
544 U.S. 622,.628 (2005), abrogated on other grounds by Fry v. Pliler, 551 U.S. 112 (2007).
However, even the most basic rights of criminal defendants are subject to waiver. Perez v. United
States, 501 U.S. 923, 936 (1991) (citing United States v. Gagnon, 470 U.S. 522, 528 (1985)
(absence of objection constitutes waiver of right to be present at all stages of criminal trial); Levine
v. United States, 362 U.S. 610, 619 (1960) (failure to object to closing of courtroom is waiver of
right to public trial); Segurola v. United States, 275 U.S. 106, 111 (1927) (failure to object
constitutes waiver of Fourth Amendment right to be free from unlawful search and seizure)). Here,
Jackson did not object to the use of the electronic restraint at any point during the trial.
"For a party to preserve a complaint for appellate review, the complaining party must make
a specific objection and obtain a ruling on the objection." Yazdchi v. State, 428 S.W.3d 831, 844
(Tex. Crim. App. 2014); see Tex. R. App. P. 33.1. "Almost all error—even constitutional error—
may be forfeited if the appellant failed to object." Fuller v. State, 253 S.W.3d 220, 232 (Tex.
Crim. App. 2008); see also Taylor v. State, 279 S.W.3d 818, 821 (Tex. App.—Eastland 2008, pet.
ref d) (issue of whether defendant properly restrained by use of stun belt at punishment phase not
preserved for appellate review where defendant failed to object); Cedillos v. State, 250 S.W.3d
145, 150 (Tex. App.—Eastland 2008, no pet.) (appellant waived constitutional due process
I
8
complaint regarding shackling during trial because he failed to object on record); see also Kelley
v. State, No, 05-09-01438-CR, 2012 WL 2628074, at *5-6 (Tex. App.—Dallas July 6, 2012, pet.
ref d) (mem. op., not designated for publication) (complaint of shackling at trial not preserved for
appellate review when defendant failed to object at trial); Pereida v. State, No. 13-09-00354-CR,
2010 WL 2783743, at *6 (Tex. App.—Corpus Christi July 15, 2010, pet. ref d) (mem. op., not
designated for publication).
The record here does not contain an explicit description of the reasons for the electronic
restraint. The record likewise does not indicate—assuming the restraint was visible to the jury
when Jackson removed his shirt—that the jury perceived the device as an electronic restraint.
These particulars are missing because Jackson did not object. Consequently, the issue has not been
preserved for our review2 and is therefore overruled.
2Even if Jackson had preserved this complaint for our review and error was determined to have occurred, it is unlikely
Jackson was prejudiced. The event occurred during the trial's punishment phase. After conviction, the defendant no
longer enjoys the presumption of innocence. See Deck, 544 U.S. at 632. Texas cases have also held that the
presumption of innocence does not apply at the trial's punishment phase. Marquez v. State, 725 S.W.2d 217, 227
(Tex. Crim. App. 1987), overruledon othergrounds byMoodyv. Stale, 827 S.W.2d 875, 892 (Tex. Crim. App. 1992);
see, e.g., Lewis v. State, 866 S.W.2d 272, 277 (Tex. App.—Houston [1st Dist.] 1993, pet. ref d). The punishment
phase here involved four prior felony convictions alleged by the State. Jackson pled "true" to three of these prior
conviction allegations, and the trial court instructed the jury to find each such conviction allegation to be true. Jackson
pled "not true" to the fourth alleged prior conviction, involving the possession of a deadly weapon in a penal
institution. The three prior conviction allegations to which Jackson pled true were sufficient to enhance his
punishment range to that of a habitual felony offender. See TEX. PENAL CODE ANN. § 12.42(d) (West Supp. 2014).
9
We affirm the trial court's judgment.
Josh R. Morriss, III
Chief Justice
Date Submitted: May 14, 2015
Date Decided: May 15, 2015
Do Not Publish
b'> • ' • • .i