11101’\000€<0 01 0117 011_'00 v
1111'11111§110110¢, 15<19@11 11110070 1506/1064 101/1110711'10 111011011 0 001011/0 l
1110/51_170010001111110 7111111<111071110 1,101100 bdke" 7?011010 70 1101!111/11.
51)&,£100001170 1,101 01101111 Faom 1110110@001 7106 Au, §0001 '
10 1000000<101»1101 0071`110 Cmm0A110 7110`15)1<01\1011)0"711»(1 700
kwu,w11_,0'5011000,
1501er 0000'1»0100 111 1011 01 1110<_1»<11/1 1>0007»11\011 Frb>m 1110 Cmpmbw 71110 ‘).1<11101/4<0 Rwortf
1110 15000 bd»<0 1110 011-1 500101100
0171010111>011)< Pmkb'w@ix 111 0001>190/\1~10?@111~1 1_.0(:‘112.00 1511 1101611’
`111‘_111>1100.`1>10001_00 1’01101011 10 150111 15a111)1111 511/11111 />111071110110
001<0_1 bd 000 00001>\v00 1117110 1111110?\. Cbm 00110111 00 1100 11111011)110
L\B 1
Tix\a 15 laker»o'ikai,i,,l)iqoi,i11m15pko5i¢ OP 551+1km11~5»6'101~1 @FTML
DHk’Fi5s1 114 61 51`1551~111512)115"'|'1»10<1 Pko_viom lmimksi,i~/,
U1~1511,1~11k51,5P1100¢ Or/Coi)mkwoizi'rii> 50511‘1'55 s 'Di/Miui.iiids$,
kim `1<145151115 kim \1~111511'\10111;»11_ 501»155011,11151~11 05 55555%10151
5v10511551
Pi_r-,ksi, Rwi,k’fi> 6}<011'37]/ 11111'¢1 le 5156)011" 00 6,051>6 ibm ks 500,
4 ulmdimm’l'ixi/ikiioiiic¢" R550k5s Pi'/,i/mix',’ id 1555 605k1 '
kw511~11151~ 5005-155 i\k/> Biu_i,i) \-\kimiiz 605111~1’ k5151`1i5k \l‘L 15 0
01qu 1511);1101105’1'5155\15001_511115 kim FiH\i 651~11s'(5 `612110511~1 " kCi)i>~i
Oi>T115Ri,Poim l55ii1101'-¢i1i'/'k&'500:1/11x16 iii<-i ki._ki,ki>~i 5554
64111511 15i\115 ké kPkkl OiTiii R05000’61515 ibm k1_k5ki)-1 15101111115)
'Y€)ibmiw.
'Eii,/>mpm.im»i 6d15. N01 ks 55k1k111 idixi;iixikdkiim 6115
F\iM'RiE,Re@m 1 ik5ulu,5’ 5011 ksi,i/k'ik\ii Tkm 6115 Liei> keou'i \1,
li151_051110 Ldlxi.k5 kim kisco 6511/6501 \1.
\116551 155 ISZ_; 00 545501>15 s lin5i111011k51_1 Fk/ik55~1D5055111/i
mmmii, W\s 16055\1 ksikk111151~111650511511 F0k51s15e 551 5511 [1)1»111"5)1>111151
1501-51<10111115 ’5<115£1)1=11»11511 Di,sc/kiim iiis ” kim 601311 kim 60 6511,
le 511s1 \'W)im, iii \511'11\61<1550 Fk'xc/1155 iii Uiiio k1011k155~1,
56510<155 T@,Tw_," kim ” 05D555i>110111`
- 'I'ix\s !56101<1~15~115 D51115 N51i1;1i15./ |’1401115T1xkii 6a1/111 1115'1”115
-Fki,sc-, 15051511 T_kici 611¢5\‘1 kk /515 v05k15F0kT115 kw5 515\11¢5<110
kim Diu:i ii\=ii§)im \1115k5‘s1s k1 ki/kk'ri id1x5i1 1515_755 111)511.5
655 is Pk51/151115Tk5kw5515511 idmi 1551¢11151551_5?01501¢6)%(51>5
5¥555115% k mk¢,15k Ckkmsivikii \ii’l' 15|1~1001_5 kid 6)1= _
D555i>11011.
?5051'»- 00 1515115de5515~11 kim 1351/1051 l1\1-1i51111011s L15 R11'11x1
4 ldmxm kk111;1.5 [0'-1 05`N511500T061i11/5R5s?01~1s5 Pui,k<,i, Riiik
"65 661>5|55 ka‘ii ’\'ms \¢1'515 60mi>5~15k 6151~151501150 iikim\s
~1<1
Couz~\'r~r_ C&ammm.D\m¢."lo ‘Z,Ow_-, PLEA%NML\H*FM, £ou.umu Uunm‘fm,pcm u~uz~
" Co‘mmwn l'r S'mm :" Dumnm4 Br.m¢ flimmr¢, Am,m,o
u)m C_ounsu. Bo&r¢.Lem¥¥¥/\.” ’l'mDou/\ 'va hh'lon‘f D¢Tm;ft>€/J D)mchu/e,
&mmd)ommu lek\aiucmn,m lou, mmac¢&o¢cv¢ 0 mo DPTm:.sz,
Dmm immm k hamech ibm BFM¢w'£:l Sbez,'l P\Q>L,z,crle”[`w Tiw,CoUPl?_. le F\vsm Umu._§c'/PFMBLRZE)_,_ zol; . HDu)c/vE/&; APP/>aa¢ lr\m Comv\,mwMRe/sw Am> MCL)NMM
BF>TM,YMM\GM Am> Fu,a,s ‘TM/ mmlou U\'r kem/leeE/lm Am No»rmamlon L')r\?anvmmc»/id¢
DP¢>omum~'t F§WM\vMTwu/Mo'rlon Bu'/DPL l»r le FlL_w. _ '
4 11 11le C,.om'u\\ umwa L‘~{ F\U;v/‘I FORN~\ E,L~L'f whwi U'r~mL, €\'L)L‘f \'L
2015, wmw*l'axv, A<»lo Commumc,m. me
’:'>u, {>aPu~\om 553 ./lce\'~,,P&,o 6a himme 16 Ommousuf Ass mm .
F'amm’l'ua,?\mo¢>~b blle 11 EMOMG'$ B~¢ L»»u@ A 01011¢6001 1111st
03011_01 101113001 10 04 111151111, 001 111 1114 01911’1’11 1501/g
1015 11010,1140 1211<110101<141 1141111 00411>4)0111311 0FE1011101 04
1110 001/1006 04_1,1»11101 11111 11ka 51»1-'11.
"1'1111<, 50'11101<13" 14 10101=1)<110 111 ky<110.104 01`N11111 10
611<111><1101{151>01111".60001<1110&11911 1617611101:"014010111>1 0y
TMJW\111014’11111'.011\'111111 0 00010<161111,1_3 111 171’~0\/101 11<11k110111401‘
P\FPMM11N0TM,’51111 11)1111 k/’JJP~( Dy 11114 1111011014 0440 121
010)101|111011011104 wax/1041 1110”1”111/61)¢11'{0'17><11011101»'\'111
1“01.10101110 011101151111°\11/,1701461'1'0 111011'1011011 110 1 LA’IE,R 1111'<1\1
111 1001 11 Dk4 kFTBRT 110 DKTE,‘TRE,V\A 01 1011 1016 SERVE,D
014’11110111011114 1741/pm 041111<1»"111 61110. (AJ Dw\/£ATM.`,
0410114 0=.,’1'0’1'111 000€<1, kx_0140 11)1111 01010¢1111>11014 01mi
00141>111014 0FT1x1`['/v113014011 011(12>`) hamm 114 11)141111~10 10 T111
0001»<1 1014 '“1'11161/><110»<1411131 Dw\rmTM/Ewomc€,"l"oTMCOM.
119 "-" '_'|'111.0014\110111411» 1000 |11"114 17001110 UHMAM 1101-041 03
kwm40'13\11090411P11100 011094010 151 60011011014 141 121 1119
0\11°1¢410;1{11001401£/6‘1 09 111111:1 1101/1121 M10m411 1>\1'11>1’~106101411110
*0111161)<11600.1'111110.0 111/900 1151 1_1140;111 11111 600¢;101 1014.
’\'111411 nmmmv. 010 14 1111 <11:1101¢'11<00 1511413?111 07111>:1 kwoun
- 0004$01. 15110'51111111.111 000141~11:)1<,11~110115110411~1 ’7 01>¢*»1:. 00111’?11~11311111/1
F0000'10 11 PL.»'1'111111114 V10m1on 01=11.'11113 1711/501414 k’Fw0
F131.0 {1/11010111)11_1011111 1301 00011’1 kPP01141E000011611_.
11101>¢1110{['116® 14114101 01101<141¢ 01= 1»1)<14.416 001)14'11/ 1121/16,'11:11
bcr-rc>aua'x Rc,01.1511111141T11161m1,D10 1101 000/1911, 1101111<1/1’(111
E,'vubm 114 00m01,11a411 101-111 71'11¢1<4 000101= 0?\1»1111411 1710040 001
00~11101111113, kim 1031 10'~1 0 Z. (@\`1 121,50 1110 000&1 ky1>0114110
01011-511. 01111115101 ANAMDLMF.FOPK' 1111 kyp11_111411 1110 000111
kwmm\w 1.011144110\/11111<0*1'111 15141 111-1_11101€1 s 01*1<111101_1041,
1110 010101111 ’1"11<114 1410 000014141»110 0001»<17511>1114110
_ 001)14411_61111~1.4 Fou.oww Pr<0100011 k4 111111401110 64 kA110.1
_51
17
104.0_2'(1>`). mme 1000 1.0 1111/111_10‘1'0`TM14111?1,1<¢1 F01>4='1111
0<91>111_)7<_111 '”10»1111,'0 \7141_5\111 010 |1111114 1710-00001140 100111.0 1111/1 5104
511111)1_1 To k§KT111 110110&1<011 000&1 `T0 9101110"1’0 kam/11 0110'5
10511110,0110000 17111 1110 011>1110 10111»001 kRs/syoueru FR,>M 1111
. 5 11<11. 101111,1)1 1015 111 Fk;01 611111)1 1141 00511.,- kuo 1111 Fm.um_,
10 0061 15 1101 0051 1141%111 111111056 1115 00111 004111_ kND
0111~100141111111 01: 00014111_,'
"’mew_/ 10 womymw 01011114 191010001111 5111>5 001151111)1105
Pe 030 610 00 5 00 503 ('1`01' 00111!<1>0 HBS);
9111»¢.141-01» MK.\LU&L 10 511111>/1.:( Tkl<£, kwm'lm 00 01|..10'151.)¢111.0
» 600 1111,.'11¥1<1 1015 00111 kme 1011 10 1111 kpp10_1141 kun’ 1111 00>1>00<141
* 001><111'/1120 F0¢4“F11:1 50410117’1"11'1611>€011 Paovm@kup km_Rz/PMM,’E:
.1>11 114 11114111411/;1 01'/151110111111 101111:11 010 To 1110111111 141/5011 0y
10011/1011014011140 0041110. W\s 0010 01411 k01<114?1101r1611 15 14011)11
0111111'5 1015111¢, 51115 0014011041410 11)1111. »
'l' 1115 301405 `01"1'0 11161001~10 1911101¢1111/100» F01_0011.101m14
61141~1\'115 Pmur»uu.~.r 0011110"5 00101.1,1100101 15 1401 101111"1"1117°<1>1>111)411,
101201€,\1;1114[5 \'115. 00110 Rwan,sm04007 01'{1111,011111111~/ 0F
MF1111M0 111151,11¢171140 me»mw 1010/1001 k111011 15 k
Dlaz,m 1500/111 10'{`%.5<11014411 1?419&15111.1010'1'1161)<11 k140 1101
EWM F111,01110 001 1115 wm 00>051140 03014111. F111110 110 01>1’1>1111011
10111<1 500101,/1'1101001001 T111 01011’)41 0001).51 01>*1'1115 P1011071 141. mm
,”111101¢1 601 1011 1990114100 011111_'1‘111/11011011 10115 D114110 111111115 1401
01 511101,1611¢>10 015 04117111£0', DFk 6111011/><11 P1M0m10 B1k110111411
\_11¢1 M.€>c>m'[ 1111 ujéssTon,Sa.u¢mam B\zu40y11_ 10‘1”115101>0110441¢
T\_M./Fm.ww 1110 D000m11415 m kwa»mw ('374"37~> ] /|1111/31 ARL'
F0111\L1111&.5 1"14>01’1111,‘<1101411¢ 011/111 111 013110115 01/11)04001) 101
011110 014 111101111011110 kuo 01011 00141/><1111111 1111511111101111
“1’1114\5 5,»<10 15001011\1 15 60 11100 10 011/1_11/1’ 1 1111 00410111 10001,0
vama, 1145 K1140 01= Do10m114110 E_,V10101401kr_1m11'z1 Tmm511_,1/15,-
050101)40,1 kR1111/1¢1011k. 001 105 150001115 011/04 D131140T1115
\'/Daéo L&N rn Unmm ear \XUL./Xaao camera l»\xs 5 uapxs$£,c) lam
Commea éeme, kan S\i.reE)weA/m Suav\e "'A@ow,” Bemr'
D\au§>\,meo,~ kna§uré/ '\~'>an’\or> 5maa4 Tr> B\L C,»ruraid
_ `(Y\a ?>bar: Uéeh k Lu`/\/MPLG\¢ lN \X'ea. RDL,\=J ks /X V\WLL
_ Camsmm 154 EJrirmén/a,la kawa ur Bs/s'l A'rf D,e.ce'rr Aao __
Dec,emm .%)u¢e?uapoam Lr,xvrh onDer/, DPP be webs/rim
’\'o Lasxre DlF\=Lr.ur;r~r la -'Som mcf 091"‘1'1mmae/,,- D@xe bales AHD
S\icb\/\c>m'lb lhwca kDr,r¢ae.e OF£DMFL)MH fin HLR.'CMLH‘!§¢-
qume\e Oriu< OML mea rim DFTHF,Fr)ua, Hr/Ldru, Br,mr~\
him \XTM GN€/, Tm i>\remeaceOv aeak,mirea D.)?°\) \D Mc>»rjlwe AF'rml&w~Aamm rarem, 5 mrs mae ,N¢Tea
a aea.\"u.mrr Bv k F)dxu_~r Dz,rwrvr,morlo-a , 3 maru as M-eea€m v
Cm)eo Baven/\ww'l'aem o11ai?0awan xeroaprua TO'FW<§ ’ '
.Cnor»DFLa\m\r\\a\, Paor.r,or:ar, Aarlcu;, lo"{i OZ (b), Sme$'rmes ,"E)r\-e
lis/lb i_£:l ‘{ou `K\~\@w blum l&xr>pme\> wr'rrtRM@ec'-r TE) Oua Lx'n l
Sumueeo Coupexamee Dn Faloa<'~r,-Dec,eme>ea H,Zol?.. ’ .
PL£.aee RJEH_A’E) (UU bé. kPeBi|] , Tm’v tamara Cr>ul~dif C,leu~lert_
' brer arm `Dr>cae'n §ueea Peexee\\lme 014 haul ’FHF,D)<'ILZ)F
!\\ev emma Q,Lr) LL-. Peexse \\\M\z. Da uaw Unoea'Tae“` Commwf ”
\/E,xomrv'\'rm No'rm_lou:" P\r;‘»r=a E)-r Loua:c, Fr'.esauxa~r gray `LO-lf»,'
09 013/kan , MLM."
"l’w\e M\i)d~l'/»’Tam A iomec>m,eo Cour'a APPE.Pm DeM@ea_\B/.er. 'l 'uj¢ E)‘r fan Loua:r‘s Cr)oaommoa_,
bow ir\_.)_k¢. kov\-‘.»LD"T\W ’li>re D. Pe. L’\ab l\»`\`o lex/IU>TM \XE/l)d><‘) 51 u.L,H_C'T
P\eu-'v\ver>”lm, kee\bxvm \N ‘foua(,as_r/.”
’T'u£/ baum Looan\amoa\é blm am mcallen B'~r Tmi, l)cxaar<. foum'~{
D m am america ‘6 OFr/\CLTo W\a\u, tim ”Fc> D'eemee A*H.Mvr~s
beam \a¢'hwm de ward m 1555 mm Dmalm /kmane)r \/\ao ha
D\o \\\M \’ckv\b la.!ie@a.xiom& LNMLMM. MMrr/R,. Bmlxu..~r FrsaA
Seaa\aa-'I`am \‘)Nm OMT\-n,Dr>o\ ,’l"wo Budam L,le€_. ~
W\e._ mary C,om ames \aTae§er,r>\~\m anxe¢axmxr Seeorm
Seme\\\_c,e=` TMJ inoama>aoa'%xm |/1 u)o;<. t~\m Nereésxar Fr>a '
“RireD. br. N~\r> \’lo fsc/lo Cm) m 'l'm/Na)m Dx‘r; imeeTHeae was
' Nm'\xmr,'rk»d CouwBeDmii,.” k ' - *
_ Pu,oae¢Ree~ea‘T@`Tc'/ms mmr/09 drum mr_\:’a_oawuae Aa»nu,r,
[nL\. 01 (`b\ :-` adea foo Da% GFTmFlua@ OFTaemrr/l mar’l'ae
Ceuv\mlurr Coum mm Paoc,eeo Uaoeakvoase,?eaa co Desc,alaw E)'~r Surzw,m ma (°~\ (2) \»\Ae
E,\raaeo,_?\v»c<1 e,§ae>mvm.oer/,@m->e L!Hoea'TM §ue~swhoa. "
`(0\\ marx/h M~z Soac,» \»\a¢, beMTae Paxa/uc/e SF' wa"l'»':) ,Ac_w
` Uk~`l\_l£,w"zw’Tc) PAPan,svm Tm;, bramwxm,. TM»TM¢, \e An Orz~rr>\mwe?’m,mmma.
\Xou)e,vear ./Xu,le No/r Los'r . mi Boar’z €">"tlu_ Y\'\mx£'r,c)"lo Cue>ue Fuaoe Fr>a_k baum Dmrv')'ax’r Dlo tim F/usr.
SM,D;WMDM (3| 1 ~
`T\)dvv\"l"ae\/xamus" kee-ames farm Rmr)w) Tm_
Ev much \a ‘1'oo aCxee .Tm€,x%e was F\ez_e't.”
- 1 54
Twe?xe/\ 1671111,1/)<11.=,11)»1'>1@11,1 011 Nevemewqm Zmzs
’1'11 kl\\wo D_Me OFFeeauxM 3 7.013)1111~1011¢@11/.6@96.11,»<111 mm
mmon Coua1 fl'ms l,e 11,a`1¢, Dm w 5 FULL 11/11)111111 As1ea’111e
F\oar: 01='1'111,1110111>11.’1111/ foam Eooeo kaye Paoew,oeo Reram~'l L/1e‘z.
1a’111e?ooa1a anarc>mw 10 Ao-neefl'mo flaum 119 6 weari1.
1‘1ve‘1e1116,110os1 Flve 1?)1,1)<11~¢11 1,11/7', bow 60 1111 1311106 o 011,
11111@111<110111 1111,1{1/11/1><11101,1& DF 1101 11111..1 Tme Le11ea.~ 11\1 F/xe'r“f
E,vea~r 61_1~1111e _1/1,111,&1°\1,%11/1,0 Faom £111011111,~./ 1111 on Le»ea 111
&oee 145 Dvear/ 1010 11~11:,- 1151111 E)ex1m1 LAE/)'» m
111 1111\1):6111.1>¢_1'1\1 1501\1'611><1 es Sae le '1' mars Lermee
Far>maa 111~11;1 eweeo To Paxe’r roe on €oum Looanuqmea.` Co1\1ewesm~1rs
Tw_/N’Pelem1 5‘1”111111 171'1.111>111'13» Lerebel,.?¢wow,ms\rs P 1_1?01~1
’1'11»¢1 1101'11;/11, 111/1111 7110111111 11 adm 111 T 01)<1. Eaaoa Ses/Aar)'smr»
Te’\'mz/l\me 10111~11~1 mmmxe[)i%am Uowe»r 5111171.’1'111e"1)m111)m1,
f')em .’1~111011 11/' kwer>eaeo 11)1111 fooaeee" Boar» 1 1.1‘1,1<11 111.” A ’1'011>1
De 11111,’111111,6 111/1111/%1<11. 11 1116 1511 inewa 1'1111/ f>sr>per_em1
Nw/ea 11'111011 k 6111£¢1,11¢ kd>Pre/xam w Am_) 111/ies Ne\Aan/vm§mm 1111
Boar: .
111er1T111o011o1 ‘1'11111e” 1111,1)661<11;1 §1»<115$ 111/1310 1101 fws/aa 15
xesoTwe$me/Dm 11111/1\1>1>11,1.1,1¢111 Flw,o 111st §'e BQ:J emma
'11'3’1"1111/ "71x11i$ 1111 steers/se xav¢ Del,xj»cs A.H.o [.011~111‘111,/11%1;,~3 15<111>
1111>11011 /101°1101:1»,£0. 611,&<€1>1,1~1011¢ 6511.1%&?11_&“1 19 Vaomonw
Twokoaoaaewe foo-111 /ie 11091 116 11 11 111,111;)<11,1 1010 Dmmoo¢,o{
011/111111,1> Fae 111/me GmerxeKs.coan.
55
700-6 16‘1`11611§1>1>611)<1~11‘6 1700~»’ §6"196111101=169$6 116_;11,61`101~16 '1?:>"@16 -
§11><1601’1610¢6' 601111110 10061Rre6616 1010 11101101~1’10?1<0061.0.”’1§116
111011011 1111<6 1/111@6111 kova 00’11161111>60111~11 111 111
flow 06/11161>1/0101016 066&1<6 1'&610111) AHo16 1100 1101,6"10 §66’1'11_&1
111111;600601116 011111 111101>~116~1‘6 111v06v61116111 111 7116 11101;1 1116 1010 `
Uv\a_we 001-1066 D661e16
E>weuse D_r 1111111~1611\1611,1010 1316'1»<011661 1511.1,1110 Puee110e6
_ 11 150110116 111 1»\1:1`§11\1"16&66 1 To 111016 1116 6166110161 1’\1011<1
150_01~10 |.1)111><16. 566161<11161 119131~11 1010 kwwo\)o 1511 521
11601116 6001114 1<1>01161'6'6 Foam 1911¢'\6111»111 10'1'1»6006611101?000 100 10.05.
2166)<066”1116 15111011116~1 111116 1110111<1110 10101010 11101101011
111161>~1/616 1010 1\101 116661,161116, 11)1)1046 11111,116616 11le 1511/1110
~ 1131101.66~1 1~11'101,66101>,601\161111)166 D6111111_ DF 60011166 1>011>/1116
150>1>1,11,1111 1101/1.»<1116 111101110.1>0 1101126611¥166061 Or/ 11161)611111.
01 601111666. '
` 1361111>1_ 01600116;66 130 1011 6&111010.§1110»6 6111111,66”11116
1301,11,1<1~11 10 13161,16?.”
611?/>111<16§11011)@017 571 61'1_1 211 213 25 Z‘f 116>161>\1011@1> 1‘1’181.
1010 131100660 11 1310 111 '1'116\/61\~1 Nem 561-1 1110 P< 1161em110 1110
1'»161,1> 001116?01101011~111 1`.),1<‘1 1010 11161”1/101101~1 1)61~1161>
66010166111>'1116111»<11~1 119901111)1111166" 10 111V6T116111011011 '
15010<1101,0 130101\/10’11161161<111110 1011616 11 1016 Dwm> 161 F»e\ew 116
1110/161111\/1011006 1116 N0116 01 1116116,1116 001;101)6 1 11611<1101<1161
Lrw~0,1»10016/61011 16 60011,1,~1/°16
» 001/100611 16 1101\111166,16111 6 11116»~6616 1501 1166 0100, 50616 ~
1100100111;» 1101\0\;01\. »
15661<1166 1116 11§1°6’611)<1~11 19\61111><11~16 111~<1'~111612 116 ADl 1901/61 R661111
_ 1116011111 1000111100 101)11666`6 1111.1)116’” 10 1101 111 '1"10611111_1.11661
111z 11606116111 1110 156 111/1161.1011111 0116&61@&666111111011 DF _
F»ee16 1010 1116115111.100_ />010 10161111011/11. 60110616016111
` ` 510
OF Exwwmom E/vl'o web Cé;usm;/ ?/vm Fum.\xm_\§ww%‘l'm/
MDM,-Rno mmam.\sm/, ulm, E)c, 13me so bca hamm ,
P _’l?a "Tm<:» PP~Q/ ‘f)n_, Dle,G1APPMLA6 kuPw /\m/ Fu,_mcr DF M`PcNos/F\ei§mr"f§q foam woman
W.BL,LME, Ccumel,` hava 603 1 w _ ,
{ ¢r>w.s mss/1 RMDD¢)MH k
mm41w Ommm ’l'mmu» ASPMQIMBL@ E)u1TlxK1 A@oRi,s~zn/$
m lizauLR/xv)bo N~\o bkc/mem To F\um, Dl€ Poé~mob\ 0?’1'¢;\/@,
L,{ 4
’fvca/\_"oupoe mcrls‘»ur¢,¢, M,D\P~a,-cm Rm,mv,o /3<1~\9 Rm;a)vm"l§)
` T\xn,\e~'»uc~. Dv b< Vom fowleth WlM\o H FoiLD N.k"[rmu~\€r Be,mc»
Dm~\\m Foe~\~lo Mmmsous 3m Foe€mz,’ lmwm»v¢\g Am-z~.bdw
Dm\ssw.us E,-m,om co Fb&TuL$owH) RP'¢)$@ Dr/ Klu,ma~’tiwa, mmmu
h~lmm\~zl> B'~{ wut> two uJ/xe_ Ar>po\mz',o B~\/ '\'v<"e-,| wm Jumc,m.
016-1 mm flaum DF H/W\\s Comw 31sz ,“E> Rm>wwem' iks/APPLLLM1
m ’l'\m Cour»d Fo&’F\xL€paclplc Puru>oer,p OF P&wm¢~\&,$<)emmm&,
wm monday 'FOR, Or~\®w/Acl>pc~,¢_\,m»l’t'§ Bw_/)a~\ merrion FORE,H 5 10 D NA/l'c,§#m£y AHD Fo&’t~lcs
UM.REMQH. - ,
Pa.erm t~\mrp”l'uz, Fw\m §w-Two§, 0¢ me , Boracz‘$ me& ,
" F,N_amau> PmFmmez/wm Doc-,umm'rs `“.’ou Pa_c>.mow Wla/ link
Rz.v\@u>." />\er’\muc»/l'o `\/Amous Dk'r&/v bdnmm E/Aai& LE./'r'rm "rbu /F‘Ym, /§§Pps,l.c,.e RLP mg am \{m) Fo&
'1'115?111>4>04501 1014 1351101111:1 111141111 001¥111<"17111_,1’15111>095 111/1115
0111>1111\111111111 111011111>,11505109115011/1511145'10 1151 1150 011/1
'155111111»1)0145?01>;1'01).”
1114 1-, 1114 1501511"9 651/1500 151/1551 1:)"1115/11>9405<511 1040
§11511111115015:151.'~1 5615155161155 psi F./’sc1 '1"1)1511 501/1156 15554
1>11)501111501:01»\ 11 5951,1¢15115111>1145 1140 F011111/11 PURP1>95 01101',
1>1140|1411 1/01405'>55110114111 1101/1091 550@105@451 1/51‘<>’1'115
1><51>515441 1000 111 110 111155111)>1111 '1'5&1114®156 '111511 P11111>1145
14"/10 051 1450 131\11\/11/)11115 D0115F01>\‘{o15"1/151111115"11> 1165
011151>\ 11)1>1>4>4 ’ 1551/406 5\511501557 1411 1555151/5 1115/21@511.1111
Vo'v'>e,é%s 1115 114151,551 10 111405114615<110111115<151151>1519 13554
511’170114150/' 10 Dc>.
11 15 1‘-\50140)>11411,4 555»<1(10 1110 119951_5)041 11)115<1 1114
1501).11 11)5<9 111=1»0114150 10 Do
1511151101401>151055 found 1110151,0 PLM§5R51OR14/ 10 Avx 157 d 1,
11\4 151>1111 '~1?114¢, 1 w1151'~ 1511'515 3550110 2155 01 T1151-_511515
1101 1301 15551>111 111514 514151>1.-15111‘7 1010 D11>15511;1 5551>0"1115
53101111 6151151115141.`11151)~51’1>1’41 554 1\101111141'¢ P\BUM DNP< Frwv\
111111111551111511,5§01514551551115 00%111/50 1111111~1 0 P 1115 §5<1111)1,56 '1'51~'1:11
Fam 1115_51>111?1,5111115<1111~>’1115?1115.0011111~‘515/1551541 35554'5§5
01’11151’15901)`1.~ 1’1\1550“1'01§1401151’1’\0 __ 1111115111515‘1'11514511
P<_l~\. 01115&`&11><519 1=01>\1111551<1145 T115D 1451 R59 1515 0515 L300 1011/5
00~141’1\515 111541155<14 RM1111:> 1151
N50 0141>1'1&/9111111 00115.”
111514 1955/15513@~05151>510 111531101)545501'11155144151,51152_,
AP>@ 137€1 1440 114 11152111>1’5415¢51454>11 151654111,1155`1751‘,/’1‘)5
UJRlTE,` AND 1511/511’\5 1111»1)°<15‘151’4 11\11’0NY\A'1101\1 q()_U 1:1A\/E. '
OP\§_!__OU "'_1'1<\1111"\ 151/101)1.1> 1’\`1~1011) ”
’1115 Fum 191>1111 11111,1<10/>51_1_5441 11)151)51> 11/1)405 15 1’1/1413151155
01510115 1015"1°0411:515151€544 10551)5 10 1115<10510514111`1 A14
53
1
1-:>=11)0'1 10111011 0101100 10“110 5 1b1 0001_<101,~1 §'101¢10‘-1.»"' 1b1 00111110/100
900-500 10110 PLM<_DU> 15011:1~1’ 0101~1000 0011'101~1001<£4010, 1101110'111010
5010100010 1001010 00111/10/110111 N\P<110'1111000111110'11110 001)10'1 13 PRO111E)1 1013 Fxom F111`1>1111:# l1»1xr
1001111~1’ 1000 1101 /5111 166 110 111/1110 000 51111.01/ 011/1110 B_.x$l§
00T11x1 P01010., 1101111/1<11011,0100<01111¢1110111A¢1 00?011:/<0010.” `
50‘1110?110:11071'1111¢1 1\\01 0111,~1 101<:=_'1 1110|1191)0111/1/11011 5001010§
b<01<1110 1»"010'1"0 1/1/111100 k ‘)P1001¢10xxc10 111110111 10 1110 001)101 1101 01~11~1
1\101 Nm>w¢ 1110 1000/1 1000 3010/000 B\/ 3111(11)~10 Fx011v1 1061110 1110
11001110001>011~1 60011 1111/0¢1110<11011 PE,u./an. _
. 1006000110 1301111 \~1’|1100119110011100 T101vr 1110/1 §11011)§'1”1110 _
014/10101111)1 600011»101101_“1 1116101)0*11110 11111/.APP00011<11T |0 H)N’[E/'
13<110 §0110 131010`|:»<91‘6 "1'1101<1 61110 C_xH 01101°1'1)0",51)'1 11<1110\/010\1’
11101:1 1,'0/1~1 010 51106 01100_ AL_L 01‘1'111<1 1111'/0011\)<11011"1{101)1 1 B.xcx
"1'0 '1'110 />11’1>01001411 1000 101110 1511111?0106011011101100 110101'1 D001)1/11011'1z§'
111011191>011,1111~1 11)1101€)01:111 Bv’ 51)<11110 1101)11> 151<£101 1'_“1'
10111_)<1 ’1'111‘01/1<11)‘1 0&|11¢1'1101)010[3 |»\’°m'\/ 10 DD
151/1 1110 11111\001 1110 Boxc< § 1,0'110106,`11000191>000011'1 (`01151~101
111’11.101’00¢10%101~1 01>T1110, 0111011<0 010101\’§ R010100, ks 1000 1110
501001 1101001/0071'111¢1 1_1<111“0101100011/00 15)<»10/1011 10111115110 1016
100111110 F0101 D01.0011'1 1100111
110001 10§11100 0\/11;)01100 /1<110 -101110x011 1004 0000'1001 '
5100 1006 00111>11/squ 1110 500101)6051)10 1016 ALR,£KD_'\{ |1~1
PD§-s%~a1011-[01?T1X0§M10D000m01§1’1‘5 1110 APP0uJ¢111-=r 5001'1' 1111/101 01111)
1\1011)“1101<1611101<11011)9`1'1000@9101_1_1011'1 13006 N`m IRNE>N "Uekfu&f'/""E¥E,
_ F1116191100 101/100110010 100)<1001511<014 F1000'” 10 1100/01 |311111 1014
10101 §M,Pmée,'v," 51101111:1 1111111 151001111», As 0011 11 As'§l&n, 101011"§,.
l>
01100"1131111>1
59
~151/5<11?30011 01140T1>11.»5 0110510 1'1`1111501111@111 001)141 1 0161011’51 01111>111~05?
00114 0\01\/11"\'11€/111100<~11 0040(|"0<1/115 014 150111;~ 016‘1'1»1151 000-111 `E)1=51)1~us1|14
T1>115 01@0115115»1111'~'6 01114141111111406-11111,~ 011 16 00T1'111151<1"10"T1110101016 v
0301>6101'»015 001101€511011. _
0\6..[501=111\6 014 001111111’1 011111T111<14 01" F161111111:- E57~F> 10111014"'
\11 0151>1?111>111561111/111014 016 501 0/\011156 0114 \mm1501m1"10100 111 Fm}'
01110 6111<111,51115|5106 F0011 0 0151111<111"`F11401110~6"'.01111'>"M011¢56"'|11-11510511111£» `
01110 151/114 0016 014/116 Nkmrv§pwm@ 111011 .- 00 001)11615 501 011_01001
1*'\11111116&511)115115~1 11)1115115’11111£\111>1=54151\¢,,01140 001111_1 010111 l1 001
'011»51111 5111€11)61 1100<1416 701&141:1111 5010/1151 1011/11 1141 0011111141
\01401136 01001)1 l1.
111114 014 11'A15l51161 P1>111101/T1116|'Jf 1111°1( (010115711) 011116011_11)101);/14
5010014 511/110 114 00 UHMMMM ’1'1110\6,-’1'11/\1 §11150016 Bw-l
0076>01114’1150 'To RF/PRL%M'HCAPP£LLM’ 1 014 010601511’11115‘1 ND 0111{511
60@11¢1 011'0151 01111 (’511100016 10141’11156,011111\’1'1)100 0000/1111411
1501141'1» ‘)0?011016 10061141;/ 011111 1000105 10 0001111551)1>11011516 0101_1515
" 014011'1610140`,' §1)001,11151 0\06)`011401111=511 000ch
011601_11511151), 511115¥211111406 00 110516610501 `011101515, 001 0141<1151)<1160
\661115 mm 006 01060011111,1 00 R111515\/1111’5115 |o 01 P061 LoH\/1_1511014 04011014
F010`1401' l11ml140. 501 006 011560 11061 011001151410, lo 013/1111
0100151111141 1111\¢01/1111 01,{}1114110141140~'V1116 10 0>1)110101111511
1015 0_]001_0 \000011‘15 1017 MR'/`)Ca PAKBLL1
‘.>1115[5016 014 ’1'0 6111110010 11111_1'5111:/111101 016 |140»11\0151>11\11011
. "`51-,10\6 014061))>11_‘ 004'0 001111:5\/`150;’ 5001101111111 011101<1'411 .»_11)6'1
`\01011>1>111150 10 0\11411011 71111'111'1101<6`010110"111»11 TDC Ml|‘_l_
111151>111111111156 1111’51)611’)01 1_01411111 1111111@ 1061 00111/1011011
mMTERS 01RE5 PEND\NC<."
§105001411111111,6 151 6 11011411'|”1)1»<1 501\3015§ N0 l KND[J \F
"1'1116 l6 17110115{’0151151 001 11)111115510'|'116 16 1111111 01` KUMORJ 501 \1
15 010151011000\1111:>1:16 13011101)5/’|1155 1115 60151515 605(11/51111& 10 z1110
15591>0005111 151611¢11003111115 10 1301 001 01 P515011 1611_1_131015155’113
911 151)150011/1 1111)01115 111011011 16015?051 110111/10~11011 171\\11’1051111€1.
'1"110 1151)0013111~1 15 110151<111 1115 6000 11155 1101 6191201116100'10
110015050111 111111111 1111~1 111511055 1111/011/11111 165151)1_0,A110 F1115111100
1101>05 1551 100115'00 11500111100 10 15011)505'11111 111111111 11 111011101101110
1/1/\11/1'1015 1111101,111111:5 9051 Co 1111011011 DNP\ 105111115 1310 1105 R:»,u_e,emrz/
161015R051>01151011,11105 1010 130'110)11101~15"1'0 110/11055~6'.6\1110 R0m0155”
1>15§1)101)155 11`1)5'1 R0P'0r1501111,0 1110155001> 115 D011115.
1615550500 651'>11 1371>1. '1§11-5 15T110 1355/1 16500 Dr» 1115 . 601515‘5 1151/1015
05100 D10011111015 11. 2011.,'11155`15 3 11101~11115 6050110'"1'1101)05011110
111/1110500 65 1551 1000 1061 020 1151 11)11050 111/15 60115 11100 00 1151/0 1501111»~
51110016150000001> 1150 5501150 151011110510555 111= 1115 C01011'r 111
111\1110 16\011515011055 1)1= 1110§ 1510'5 F\051>01150 05 105015’11115001-.
111 11310153000110 P55501151>11 1’1/\5 6050 1~10111'151505 1105 1\1011
1101>0111»100 1605'111011 Dc' 16\151»5050111511011 1515/1110 P\Ppr011.5111'5
" 1655000 L)5111 501>1"'.» 511011111»15"605'1111 15 _Am_) 01~10’11'10 15050;' §D%
590515, 1010 toma/5 R101)1'1'T0’1'1101601111 111/1010110 1101>0 00511/1 110
1101/05 10 11/\5150A D001510’1~1 11)11\2;11105 0151~10/ 110 111511115'10 `60111111110
P00501111, N0111 1311 111051 1115 015-131500111 11100 000@1'¢1"0515 1510 611/1
16\0005511» 1311 17550100."
611015'|'001`,111115 11111”1//\11@1)01_1_51~1'1 10 111515060000151011 911 61161
600<101/1 5501)0051\10’1 601’5155011 1 151111/1 ON/;l," 10 161/1550 61 D00'1510111-
111 13111011\1551511/1 15 611(100 1115Fa1011351_, 9150011511100 Ou 15 E,FP01515
6111001011500011500 01116515000,' /511~1065,'1150\/015~1 011/1561 111515;111'
11\5150/>5000151011 65500 1111 60051)501111<1/01310500 R1)111005 "
111’111101’.151' "`.1>1110 1130 \\101 15110111 10 1111515'1'5110,11155051 111551 1
» - 1'/15\/0 1<\'01<150”
511~11:-0’111<0150|5 110 11005'111)1~1 A11 111101511101 CL10111 R0051101151110
ial
F/xc1‘)1‘1,(71115k44011111 14 E/v1511 4141151111441111171) P\Mu 14 1245 APP@LLA4'14 11014141141'4'151¥1/1>55011 10 7`E5&m1114¢4£1741/'P1)1141)14 DF D\`~lr&
145441111;- 50 1115€4111 B'r_L,Rm/we,o 1311 P414\1>1515) 5141@1_1150 1411-471114
151410111115'~./ 1515/5101415111& IXULCMUH le l/V\4<111_,Dr1/151410115 E).e 11111414554<4. 0 §1141'/1»5 I'11'r1/ P\_410R141_1)-{ |‘5
Nm 0111»51111111 41144"F4<154s','7114/411414111154<144 51114191,4 151101\111>
7121\'»5114\ UP l»\1w1¢sr1,15¢».'
7111;5?111546 /511115, ALL 11111>11111 70 711457&,)14<5 Aom1_14 19 44141411/£
Ceoe.71"1415153>7.C/14141441511145 5001114<441,4A1R111515 145 3
515@14411141111<4<1»11 (47 544<41»56 !‘1111 4 C011510115R4141011 B4A 504<-;110
1/\/\1:11\151_1>\ 011!\174<1°\111_115 Comm\ssmmv& 01 AN 011¢`151401151!5 151111»414101!
Rc,41141411-55 0311<1114 D15’111Rm11111111 914 011¢1~5141>_@11'6 11411111)4115'~1/?0&
P4111111511514_ 541<11,41511 1340411414114>. No 041/'1»5111)115& 144 1115B115 D11141150
741501>4111141111141 713 194154115114 71 7415 Juo1@14411 1111>,151101111;
91?1>151_154<415 C_eur>:r'f~ |X\s 011\31151\ 4111`!151:4<410'114 Conom~m'~le<
\{1114141014101 Fur~m 114151444<15 1501144141141011411_ chfme, P151\4141011 131 65111 L115@411_ 415411/1411,6 Dumn1~7115P4<1>5111515
Rw\a,w, '3111>11,1»\111611:11~1,01>57{151/01541411:)14 Prmws§,|°> k \/101'541.41£)14 04
wm P0151c5~1.”
1111114 161 UNL§,%‘YDUMRn/memol?w \)1131164'014` A440MM
15154<11 YY\ E)oac< _
712,\14<5- D1s 1511>151114<11¢1 17101_4/, Fop~PRapb%mN.AL C0141>141__41 R015115
1 03 6141415 (CG"_R l54111111,1>\51'141151_1&15151> />1 LL111144 RM~3011416154
1111011111151) Ae>om l1111.5 411411'7’ 01= 1511’\’14<441'59` 1 Aup Pmmo»tw [1')1'1114154
11)1411&141‘,1>14416151_/&1411411544 F014J1~1F11)11m4111014 (b) ALAMVUL§MLL
E5111>1.1111 MY\K441511 111'|11115@1¢411114 Rr1»4<5014415151 l`lr151515964<4¢1` 113
P15m14 71115 C15115114 711 VV\4<11115\1~11>1)1<111150 D15151410 141 Rrwm 1110
71115?\114>1115%15114441011.”
1404 014154 1046 NS~.BDM 1104 15104110451;111)`71') 5404<1:5'1471<11,
1'02.
31)_1:11.1111 1301350\0~11,11)1011~1001611151105 1115© 130/643 111&11~1£>. f
"E,.v11>1141r1, 11_11»<6 50001111141 106/1116 1051 511011110){ qu,o 1161\1',11.1>
L111141 50»061614100,14 14001111111,1 50101614.<106 00 50010161, FA<110D’IB
1141>110114 1501111>1”10 \’:»11'1141 50016 1611)061'4 N110,660<11'~1 116 P1Rm11
1111-411 16 11/110\1111000\11110 0111610116 51100114>111 10 5100116114101111>14
00500(:061 51141>1’/><1101)" 16 TN1161106 Te &11611 5106014103110
5111111111011 10?11161111 011111411 6 11111011616 110111 T1161111141<111)14 110
51111=1111‘01' 6 510016014 1611014 15001211’15101 1156 111 111011111614
001111>111 B11101114 5111111111 556 1111141 5010 51 1156 H1v101’0111)
( 1604 500 /0,1_11011 13\00111611410<110 11 ('51\/114’1”1111 5110011410 1310 haw
15011104`/101\000~0,601411 6141141 5<141)F/*<11,10 lo 611/11111660<011'
5010,11111111,141 “1'0 011111‘6 1911100111116'1'1'> 1010 1161 01111111 511111
D16m16611>11‘1>11111'T1> 114000111 510 00 510101’110116 5011051001061
17\1'1,1140 D16m166116 130161507111\1 51111000> 1500615114 111.00011110 Dw61o11
50141>1110101010101?1<111/116 19010111011~1 Commx 1111111 R106111)06111<10111616
F&om 1’1111141 110111140001110111014.510110150/§101>011651001161141114£0 500”
511416 \/6 , 51611111111111
26 610 511 @°17 (510013'D161 2.000).
- 114 11161~-15\141111¥,1/11115<001110<141 556 0000/0111> 11111>1141/~<161,11>11461141_
14116114 1115 51101114 114 130 5011)0111 1116111111014111;111> 1111111 51111110111
111 60111 511/111141110156’116 01111011/1 151101 111111111 1000/111 D111610116
1556017 1311 1116111141<1100001151110 15111111114 110-111 130/1101le 510 1/111 ,
1140 004111)1111614 55001&11101 10 1511‘111161 5141> 1112£1111> 500111/1<141 116 511 1114
111 601/11 1301660011411’F111 55011101111’ 6 F0011\114 1’1’11;1/1/11611116 16 6001/1011
101500>111.110111 10 1511 011 11 511 11_111 11 5111111100111 |/\111610114 10,11111111
16 110061500611<1111101 5100\1111 116 590'111,11141`.
5511?,1466 5151,11111151 § 14011141.0% 500 01111141 15m10'51
“'511‘16 500 E010110141 1145110 10101/501 1)1111<01510 14111’11\.
D16116111111111 516 110 11111/1)<11 51115016 '116 13141:11/1 516114141`)111411,
551 11111.11~\1113 1551 114 11111`11114£01
163
`l'\\\ \»&m F\MN_ Re,cme/>T \\~l \'Y\s,Bm§'§ Dmml\rE/z \HMM@.
.D‘Q~\o Fb<\_'s\??\w Nm¢ b\~l \‘0&?0 51 Couvxm\c>M Foau~\éw DNP `OP 35,.~;,/.10:»4 m(€&\_l'z'?ibAp¢$"d"-‘] ms Bnr<§ §~'m'r m a'-
v "Pm¢~mumeue/m Tume/z Cour\~’\, SLv>uu_) lrr Dmmmm\z,AND
f)m‘l"§m 'Pmnm~r\c/p\ le blm fm 11<.¢,0'1% blum DN k’l.'c»',s-T\N §
bow mm P\wu Rwuw1m twale ,T\m im foam m)\rm kan lwuv D/)mq few DP‘Era/"§w"l'v@xl€)‘iflw, AWMT
§ouu> Du,u N» mma/mrt kssum,§ liab u)c)_m,o Bz/
Mu;,’(o RE/|)K 01~\’11><§/?\¢1,§0¢11\#¢0!9 Rr+,c,op\c> Pa,oouw> f§‘~€’l"§c,
Dpr»\u§a,(loom Rr_,-,Pomm FomT§n,l%D{gd/uuo\kL sz--mm foam §§
io"l
1/1§§\§1§ §§§1~1'1'4.,"1.'§1/1¢1§§.
P§§§§§$§§~§§§§w§uc (2.2:1.50 T'§l§ 16 01 009§@§/|§§§63?111§§11‘5
P\§§§§§§ P§§§§§M "’1'§'1'§)§§§ Ru§§§ 0§ §111>§1_§§1§17§§§§0§§§ K§z_-§
311 § 1b1(0 '1'§’1'1§0§§1131§§ C§§m R§§m§§\/l§ '1'§§§§§§1§>§‘§1§
P\§§§§§ 0§§P1§§§1§1§ § T11§1 0111)§§§§ 011 1§§ `:11§ D§<'§ 0§ §§§§§1
2015,1§ ’1§§1001§61)0111§§91§1§1§1 C011§1 0§ 1)1§11§1§ C§§§§ 1,10§§11§
1§§1>§1>§11,§§1 6 mm 1§§ F§ §P§§§ &§1/11:11§§ Fo_§m§§,D 1~|§17§§11§§
. 1015§011§1§1> §§'111§ 01\§§ §§§§m§§§§TF§§§ &1§§1_,1§§1§§ /\§ F§m
11>1\§ 1016 .D<§ /)<1>\1§1>§§1<§1§§3§01§1§1.?§0§§§1) 111§.
"' `T§§ 5111/1§ Am§§§mz_/m [_§§.§11§§§§§§ §§§§`D§§w§.§§§ T§§
R§§'§§ To §§§§§1 11/§ §§§1§1»§§§0§ 00 §§§§§ A§' BV§§§ §§11'1§§1_
§/1§§§0§ 1111§1?§11§§§§1§§§ 1§ §1§ D§§§§§§.”
1111§1111§\/1§11§§ 561 1151 §§ 151(1%71
?§§§§§ §§§ /’1§§§§01§ 1571 ’F§§§ 1§'1'§§ R§§§§§§§ FRom 1§§0§§11~1§1_
flaum R§§§§§§§. A§T§§ Co§ 1151 0§15§§'1'11§11§,|§ l\|§ K§§§mm’§ R§Lo§§.
- ’\'§;WR§§§§ 0§§§§§§§§1§?§§§§0§§§[§0§§ 1511 011/111§§0§€1111§1
R§§§m§n;§ 51§§1§ 1§§0§§1§1§1. C§§p:r P\§@§§§§§ YY\U"> 1011 '0§§1/§§
§11§§§§1> 151 §§1§§1111§11 UFT§§P§§§§§ §11§111) 11011111 €§§§1§§§ A§§ 1'1'1§§§
§§§1,§1~11 §
"P§m~r '1'§’1§1§ V§§§§w§§, 111§ l§ T§§ |§111§10§ 0§" 1111§ 17§§1;§§01§§ 1515
Emom§§n 1511 1§1§17§§ §§ 1?11,1§§ 011 11.§§§§1§: 201201'1110§§§§ 1§'§
§§1>111§1111§§1 D;§ 0111§§§§ 1011§ A Dm§m R§§§_§§ 1§§§1§~ 10§'§ 1111 .
'1§§§ H§§ 111<§‘1'§1§§§\/§§5§111 §\1~1 A§mum ,P§mm§§m§ D§A§~z
01§1,§\§1>1§§11§§.0§1<1.1.1 0§1§10§111§1;~,'./' 1111<1 1§§§§§§1§§§1 110§§11)
0§§§1§§§’1§§101<1\11§§ 0§ § 1’.01)§1 R§§o§§§§ U§o§§ /’1§1 01§§1)111§1§§1:1§
k§o .b<§\( \111§11' §M1§1\1’F§§<1 lic§ L0§§1,1>0RD101‘5 FM§D§§§§T
155
1’>§,€)<§§§._11 110§§ Cc§§:l §§o@§m§§ 00§1~1§§§‘5"(’,01\1§§§§”
1’\§,§§§1>11~1§" Fri§§'§§m§§ 1§~11.1 §§ Fo¢§ A§o§§§_»a§ wm "-AH§
E)§§§§'§§ 1.§§§§§ §§§Bu§§ 51111§§§§1 B§§§§§T§§§\o§§ms§§ foam
0§ 1><§§§§1.§ 1§’5§;§ '1"11§ G§§ 11;,1§§ 01§/1§1§1 FDK`TI§, '61§1§ 0§ '1'§1§1§,
1><§1> `\§T§§ 1§~/1§11§§"1 0§ 011§11§§ C.o§§§m§§"`l§§ 11\§§1§1§§ §§o
1§'11'§1111_1§§1. ('0§1~/§§ `0§T§§0§§1§1§1,C§§§\1 R§§e§;r§§ 1311 §T§§ 1301§
. T§D‘\u §§ 1316-1 mm 00§1°:1 061/hika 0301~111* 101111'0 UT 7111:.,
1§§§§1'11§§ CD§S §§T 0§ 11§1§ §§1§§1,»’1"§1§ §§§§1,§§§1.- §§1)
B'r§§§§§§Tm§ 1111/10101a 1§ 1',1§§11§§1>15~1 7§§6/1'111‘1§ 0§1§1<§§ T§ _
R§§r-§v§ 110 1v11>§§§ §1.10§ A§L§§D1§§T§T§§T§m§ C§§§ 0§ Cmmm§§
?RD§§§§§§-A§11§§§ 2.(§.- 05 §.1-11_1§§15’1»<11":,§ ’11§§ M'{§§§§‘§ 1/1'11)§1 E)§
§ 0§§1_1 §1§_1§ §§1§§§§)1.1§§»1'1§1§\/§§1 C§§§<_r 101§1_- 0RDE;1L
§11§§§§1 1><1 L§§ L§§§ 1111. 15§1<1§"1§1 P§§\r§>§i§`§§§ C,§§§1111~113 10101 17111§‘1§\11/§'§§11 1")§1)11, F§r'»k?§w/M§ '
Rmf§§§ bc§§ 110§§1_§ 0§§~115§D§§§T§ PR§v§¢§T§§A§§§§§/§~H F§§m
R§l§\§§ 5§§§1§§§§ §<'§1> 10§§1?0‘§§ 101'11§ '1'1>1§[')1>§§1§1§ 11\1'1§§»1 ’11;
0§§§§ U§§§_c§§§§§§§§ 1\1>11§1111. ~
` 11/\§_01:1§§’§ 111/111111§§§§ 10.§11/§§0§§1§0§§1§1§§§0§§11§1§0§1§& 1
1§’§..11§0§§1, k.§§§m§§§§ Pvr 11111,1,1§§§1§11~ 1`0§§§§/111§§1§§§0§1: `
111§'11§1~1 1101<.§ 0§§1_1.~1 D§§uz,b 101’11)1§§1 Tw1§§§§m§0 013§§§§1 0§v
/1§§§§§§11_§§1 1§"1§§§ 111_,§§ P§§§§ "0§'1'§§1)11,1,1€1§§§1§ §111>
1§/1§§/11§1~1 §§ />N§§T§§§ 0§T§r§AP19§§§k1§1 ‘§ £V§J§ C§§u.§§§§ /§< §01<§§§§§1, °
C§§vmm§ §<111>1+'1 61§1§1?§§§§ 0§ 1111 §§o:)v§§§§.'_§ 1/11<1<.11/1
|§§11§1§0 111>§§1§§ §§1)§§1,§§»1 |?)'»1 §§§§§11§§§»1 ,D§1§1§1)1111§
» 1°<§1 15111§§ 0§ 1’§§~§§§\111§§ E§§§§ Fo§§§§§§§§§§ R§v1§111
§§1_) E)§ §§§01§§ 1’1/\§1,1§1§§§ 10§§1>§ F§§§'§ 111,1§§§1_§11§§,
lab
(202151222 2100 Flznml__.lxe 1 27204211!142021)1 2111.2<02‘110’§1 213 '1,2(12041
200 1022\12,1\("_0221111141`."22\111) 1017 2210/1200 L01~4'1111:,11,D 1.1 HUSQLL
00011;11\/12_ FRom lM/DM 6 110 11)20; 202011111,0 '
"\1111,\"0 u.,D-wu~& 221 PKE>RJ 1012 5010 11120’01 DF"E»EE,"R£P 14061,14-*[2<1®142'V
2140-1000 1511 141 20>20112011 15140_11/1 L01)1L1 212101141110 2401)~11014
211102011\1 l._11114 m 5010 2040 20 21912001 211/1131:1"1*14»202<121,11»041
mm DF,M 100 f14 \»1121 310 FC)RPM 1 6001/1011014[201,1012, 2040 2200/1200 1
4012201226005
"’ \ P1100 204`\_11111411014011._1_4 D111,011110 M011o14 01111111142 Rv,01112.10
0010141114121110.01‘1'11141 11§2<¢. 000111111> F024F2111.._10141_ |141,D.201 11 11ij Fu.c,u
2040 001101010 211411_4 60111114011) 2100 D4,1,201100 -'\1 F01411')111_ 271/114 21‘1’020_
2"'2_ 111/1401400 L001-11,2<110 bDDM R1,0201461,P11000F140~1612<11 2010
F20'1_1,0 70 M0v1, 6001»0 10?1401;000 .20¢11124 121112014111711000 H2<17 &211111.
25 61_.2<120411__‘1 011/570 2022111_2041 21001)1 \~\'000 ('01\$12111'4 Rr»,¢.s>onse,|n
0&01,1>5|'0 272001'.1,0
22 21.?1110 W1011041 C01412<_1111110 K11011)14F20.102040[1414.2<2,1,1)1z2110
\14102112011014
22 5 L100T0 2021011_32041 2100111 ` F21110 60111201410 i14 i01,121121141_,
L2<0`R1201L1.
= '*" 1010141_110 24211-.1.02041 Te 2011 611 014501.11:,111,0, 22161111>141,4110110 2040 F20_2;1_,
_ 4 21111101411\.211100.
~`2‘ 7 'R1/2102.e111100 421.1261,1.1 20 21001104111 1314 \02, 00 N01 21220114100 70
* 8 2101/1010 F201111;1 Mm_em ’E) Conwuc,r¢ 212.21'-,11,1041 10 2001 014
F2<1_01,' 11410 10061011
*”Cl 521 HmBlu/M; 2101111116"§7 1311_1_11~191 122004723 COUH‘I~(FMU)DM 1401/010
21212010111,0
~"’ |O.- F201.10 10 \10101011 Lloum 01 D011311104110 F211,1,11»110 2040 210me
E.11'0'1_11_2211014‘1 Ev101,141,0
"’ 1\ 112101200 Lom R0201411,21 21112111020140’1?)9101120111111 M011014 21211110131
\141014111100 (’,1')144014’1912'1`141,2121-1,112011
”*_ 12 1 `11011.111101420. 000'1140011014 01 51211 101
927
, "\'H)ce\/ioa_xuow OF D'a~m,Dl§cu>c,u¢¢\. umw D'\scu>i,me.
-2.'\»£ 60) 5@1175@,73‘?'(%¥ m wm zow).
b%
kwomm¢ OM,\§sue*Z).
’l'we,` 5¢»¢1¢,’§ 'Pro§w men as DF er DN*FM,CUUFQ: '5
. Dr,.\~m;\_, Dr> DNATE_,§#\,H 137 kim \1‘§ me tamm he ku baum
FRDMTM:, C,oup:r, EN TM,D lamar ma OP l»\kms clousw,
Twa Egm;murs\_ij;v E)uu;r D¢~e‘l’wc,B)m lOl%?>‘f.
'T»w,§wk"w».[buo‘rez :` l»\»ur\av., Br» bkw, harm /luLTz/x) Dls wasn Ev\nmanAvorL/z E\/mmc,v, As
Tw&E>-mw Fop(l'm<, lumur».»<'rz)`limomc¢€)c¢ ka_ j'Gwe/, Lhm
l Evm(" Rm¢m ”’H) Paoc,momu m ’l’L-krr.," Doc>&” T\m S~TML
|»\M Om~\u) B~z ’I'm&l&r~lowm£r Ac\~u_) l\~l‘r`m~\-'I m~u<\_' L)s\z,OF »
F¢u<&111‘1 Cou\~lf‘{ 'FE/Xz.xs.”
’1`1111, 151 1,111,1-> 1111._,131/¢1,1101<1~11"5 H,s,¢ 1101
131/mo 151)11:1~{ Bmuz.u,m,hh. '1'1111
111)¢, 111/1111 AGued 1111 E)u,n 511/110 AMD 1111, TNA=L _Commmw)
010’1111,111110111111}1 011{1,1;0111) 6A1/1o 1111 L 1111, ®00111/: Tw
111< 111/wyk 1111/1511¢1<&01,1) 111111,£11111_ U)1<10 15
C‘,ouuv/ 10 111/1111?‘(’1' g13111°\1>¢\011,0 11131&'1”1111,51)1‘11 16 C 111111161 fumes Auc>T\> 1111)1 61><1 ’FuLduusF 11 6101111
TO 15me ke FM::Y."
EAmuTuouuuTuLApmouLsu./mm1 1 MM’ELLL kDIPFM’l §1011¥,
’1'1111, wpa/wm 131_1,1)¢1> 111/mm Uuoa,& 11er DP `Tm1_111.61)2:1~11/10 Pcpuw¢ 15»11¢11¢/141~1 A&R@,E,mm~w 5111@111,1>
11110 pmm P& mm 1150 BM,N 6 umw AubTu\z/Pabsw’l»mou DP
Evmp.uc,a, 1110 E)wuu ,vaDuuwe10 ’1”0 "EA
`(er\/, Cour»me,mm-»r 111 '1'11/151"£,1¢1<_9 Da,@1. OP Cm;mwd_ §11)511¢¢,
1113111111101~1111_1)1\111>10,.”1»1
SE>LUM,P;.%PQ)L:L Dr §§ 111111.0 15 171101511<12>1:1’ 01111,151/`1`1111/1’1/1061
112/11101)5 huch 11~1£\1_1. 01= 600111/11. 11'» 1101 T111,u.1 01161 11 1111.11110
L’,mrmm_~r Rmu mum1'1’111z,111 Now 119 1111/511€11:,11)<1>111 F»1111,31»<11. 1,1,1§1)1111£>1~11."1111){ Cu<” 111»11.110111111> /1< 6111)1111100~1 11__)111101~11.1 bhd
TuLP\vA11_/zseLL‘.)m1we/L OF k 111&111111_,’/1/"1111/1 U)K,RE_,FRMA1\1:1/1,151"101~11) kRm<¢,ouM§L¢,f)o 1)1%11)1~11_11,¢,-1 ’1'1=111,111_/ 111/ks A
ll
70
Rm.LPoe/z_mwm"llm Tm Hm,§o FNLBW Soccms'r'm, m
'Conc,mum, . ’Hk';m` TmArbomm¢< E>Mmr~l "'l'\¢x'v_, S're E,\epo war/1 few Dmmo/‘ AH'D Ai w `
CM»[$£ 'lo Kuz,p film me hawk lmc) A<" boqu ” MM.Pr, Mmm hbml§mbmm,n€w TL\¢U[L\Q</> flaum 0¢ £’,_rcf hjouu>'
Tm¢t~\o»re,”`um "Ez@/B Mummw» For\u) m OP harm 60 ms Fu-,m>
EH ’fm/sz,u.hrr _Pm:> inv H)m/l~lm E>Lm Prw\u\b*{ .OPTWTLXKQ Comz, Dr/ hamm¢<_¢_ Prm mo u run
Fl.>mm~l‘( F\uw \/Xls Par)- 55 mcmoH Fo&
Po-‘n Bonvm\o\~x Fom§\e,DMb<’l'smmc, OH T.P Mm\on Fo¢LAnumw q ZDl'z . ’l'mz leeelm~\ \'\bRLAHo R£PRM_E,D
ln*l'\w"w mem D'F Tw@ Pa_¢>uM Fb¢L’F\aLPoaPo/nz, L`)P \léue W\mot~\."
TWLM»Hc>¢Acc\om’I/><¢_. Rpsuoom Dm\se\oa~ls, E)u1 SNL.\,FL)LL‘C
Mn\mm'uo\~\kwr`wmm ’\'01 Nume.n.a.©m. G\vz,’fwz, |'LLusiou '\"urv,
Coum \‘>’\FU\N M>" \»\u£"T\xL AQOE,LJ.RN‘I P\\~\o Nome. mTwo, "\'\&€, S‘r/>crr».
DDM Nm wm 70 ScLa,va w ow';" Jmum ZO. 2011--Ar)pe,r'e/_\»\e,m"?” 4 ‘
`Sueewumm.~r »’|'Lm, Lm)pcw,¢,w% '\'Lw, Aosn, 03 l)c\<, N\o416u {~’ (S@e/mumn;m Dl~\ \seuz,, Z.'). 4
*Sl ‘»" Dr+ /Quur ’LD ?__017_ ‘l”ur»/DPMPE,Ho/zs.p YY\cmoN_ FO&'FD&LM\¢‘TE,$'I\H Cr.” `
L)m_ou'r Twr¢,/Xporz,r_¢,m'r ‘s Km:> munoz U¢L£,msm~w, ’l'm, knowqu
D\er~rrr¢,t) E‘)\I‘T\m/l?)[)'ru D\s1 mm f.ouM FlL§.D P< 1414 blum G»L,“\’ -N‘lr>
lmm~ruomWF_, kmmo¢w Mo'uon. Br».c,e szu~m Paoc.u>um,
Tm,l?)m»lm*l FA<\L,uM,"I'o |~l_o»r\FY T\zce, Coua;r \1 C/oou_) Phoc/e-m
L)Nou§ l>§a:l\w, (o"{.OL 'fo [o"}.`DZ)"")'\€/e’rmcv' \FTWL§FMLFMLLO
""IB Pwvmrvh; Re,s?ou<¢/Pvl"l'\ai.€uo Dr> (oO DM$ OFT\m,Fle@ OF
T\&,YV}\£>¢\_ou -. mewsc, Ov/lmz`, $n:m‘s Rm?m~l% DK/lwe -
Lkm.. W~Lov.
'/I'\> FNL Fk\LuRLkaVW YV\omm4 11 (JJA:$ Flwo.TmPsPP&/u)Twr»/Tum, 0¢11‘5 D-wurre).- - _
gapje,u»wr F\uu') NmmerH TUL% ZO, ZOLY,.
' b.¢‘ 'TRL foam F\Nos. B_zsm 014/lim OFFLoW.Tm/a¢ Coum
Rf.coc\c>ef\'wm Tm, bseova/S~r~fLa/o bow Numemr-,D boxst le
bo-,<,oumr,o blm Lbous1oapoucn,DLPm1mmolNqu»l1 Rs.oom Numom '
050‘+[§ 1005 N, bous/Loa?ouc/LDM.Aoomn,-m Cam UO‘%. bmo \ou~\-rlcrn,\~m flqu N_ume»rd& ,H7IZ>5.'/
. 'TM, kPa@L_L/.>.5&¢,0 D¢~l “FM;§LVF,M Do¢oma_,r~rré l \Xow BVL&.H 15 _A~£ra¢,e.m mo
Ddr.¢, Nm \Mc,d,uc>a,‘Tm/" Fm:rdm_'°' Comu+m T\mu,mwmmos
bj\u_"Teu,- OH”F\xmsLL\/m "A¢,To Em,mcr EWML,‘\' alarm iad Aom,
Famnj;};}§;m. homoer PM$lc/)>TMM. b_<'cmm\\qc;»Td “l'\é(o,Kn,c/mans
DPTaa,\buc,ryD \u°PMam¢u>L/-I Pr\dpm~< Rc>om le Cc)m,m w I_H,
Pn¢,qu.e\do OF T»o,?c>adwm cr @v\mu~l md m ,CoHME/cmom wm
_ ."l"vrq,§»lmn,OPTs/x)r;ob:r`)r>lm.\_h;'dd,"boarv mmo OF las o L“S " PRL)\/xz,s
tmmm):r\errde~*r Tmn'r.r Fp.d m
wmme \*\ Oo~\ Poss \aufz E)r,,bo\o would blm Bc,bcr FmoeTmcl. `b<¢c,ormu~mr/L’DTM,
‘ 73
\7\0001>455 01’»'"114101»101151014 PDLlc,e/DPJFMMMMM @RJME/
0001\»<1004 ,‘1'1401)401151 014 170.1400[)0101>4411110141 014111\10 Lke»mbm?
15 bmm~rrut 114P0551:/5510M 01/`1'11001;0000 04 1140 E,v101014 011/114
11011141=.,1;11014 10111)( 1111/511»<10 0 1¢ T0x10/5\/ 01001410 13014@41',.
01<0411,14011/11510101‘1034 k110R10»c11111r'10 11401010114 13000101
1\101410110050415005 1010 0002<0004014¢1 140111001< 005'0300€1:
9 01111.511,1><001) 1)1)1\1111/1"/11\/00000 00141/2:1011110 ° 0110 00101_4:1°\
210000151><0 L)>< 53 ') 1/3” 0140504<000
50011111 014\10001@000<010000 §1»<11100144> 111\000 F00111
1&14011101130000 F&nm 00111\1>0 151\1140<114 6011/114 1<1101011 2,[3”
4 0140?0011<010111 1000§ 00<1_100 0/11014000»1114/><1'000'1”1)1510
000101_111) `130004 1400140‘ ")')1<1010 00144/><114 DNA< 011140015”
131400'1'\)115 1101400.001_10 0001°41 0011'11>010105 TmRv/)144»0101<£00/5<0150101£;00040 00050 00)1‘<141 1111400044.
W\m 5 00144114110<0 1110)<1400001101~11)010‘1"00<15'1"00010511” 00
00511001040201)01>00144<00000140111014 010‘1/4061.040‘5 00
000001>" Ev1o1014010~ "'01/1¢1 00001> 1\101 B0A00010100, 01400
E,xp0001>,114 b<14.4 0001»1111/_14><'10 00001 014 10 0&1141
‘*‘3 " 0000009:1 F1141>5 Twm. A0001°4)11~10"[0 1100[’\00014050¢
DFT\&LH/am5 [00141~1 1015-m 01 0001<1445 01=1=1001‘1'401)4»0010 -
00014~14 1315-10101 000194<<. 000-10015 1\101 Cumam0<1'114190550551014
0001441?/1¢10101400 101 0014»1100'11014 101114'1'1>¢0614<10 01"/1”01<415 V.
- ‘1'411014050¢404 001)50141)01000101%'54 001{000:11140 '1”0 11401010441
K€Po¢cf Nnmnc,k 30‘-11§00§ M-.”
' 14 15 140/1 9001000?00‘1"11017141000)1140 $4,4¢10111044 ’1'0 00
Fum\>rm?mm“rm“l”a»m.. 0101]0100141»<000 1500-1 00 Tws,f¥\¢104 010 § 010/141 1051 1010 00 __
00001011111 60&5010111. 11 15’|' 110 1501=101010 00001<5 1111/10 00‘1'1'101
0014101145 000 1010 011004 0000111041-,'1`1111101 51mP00 DB5001/m1011
bmc 10011>01015014 010050511 F_00E,w1r10 000190101101(100 1211451001_ 1501001100 1001 00141401 30
0100100,1)1501100 1101)01411)1>. '
` 91101-‘»-'"`"1’1101’,0001F1141)5T110110:10001141»/10010R0000051000
1100105 Cwm-z 60011101'5 001001700900:141200~1,0101100015 001)111.~1'
540011¢1¢'5 001100190000014 Room 15 1101 000001410~( 114 1905511/.=151014
01bd44 Paepm\z bmo 000»~11>01400114 110141110011014 101111 010 5000
01`10\<)15 V.TYN>N\‘./BM 1 0!;1)501\101\1000 1014 113"1 00R14.m1110
'1'0 10014)0111 Ru00:1111m100030"115005 1\1.’/ 1
'1'1101\00015 1001114 51100111~’5 01110015010 1101/1401 Tnm
0011_00100’11100111>4 1,01:00 b011-_4 130011111014100 Swnou-_,
110 1_1_0011011 ‘10‘01101?/1411001\/ 1111'1115 011/10100111 00100011014 00
FMOD 151140 1:005\\$10¢€11&46. 1>000<5051_0 ( CR 10 41151?>1~1"1 1 TL¥ERL
1100‘1`100 1'1/\0<100 130001_11115 F100/11l1051m0 0014000>11140 0115 ,
"P001>001_:( D)wm¢mw”Am> " 00001__04 001_1_001100"1 Dl\\bs 601'111>1_0.
Numm 0140= 11 11)05110011 1114 111114 15111,2,000",01»100 bm`
000110134'1’110101)01 F00T 1101)0101400<141 (1\100_1 KP@E.u_xM), '“1”0
50011111’1013<0 1111‘5)<1111>00 001.001’/11014 0140.11:1 Dk‘z’ 1114001>0.1111011
110 CDMPLM>D-TM[-s 110 01111._0€01101 001>00 160)'<0001100001441
00R0000000'60m100 101_1.0011014 90100’1"0 11104 Z.£)”,Z,oo£, _
\1)1111111001>101410000 130001»"1:111¢1'11_00 01'/:1`\4’15"’1'00'0110 11\1’,~"`1{€061£11/11!)',"
_0)><1451¢00001:)’1`15041115'2015”" 11001000110"` 510 anvil/3100 FNOIL%
W\M 251 1005 ,Au_ 1405. - -
Num@m‘l'wo: 0114:00'\114¢14 T110R000000o 00 1001/1 1014 '
11500\¢,»"1'\411)0§_,15 1\101)114011100 511~1£¢00 P(P;Ca/MN~M/L , N 01 151 4
5\141;1_1/170043~10141,.’1'1101 01100.1\!11_1411014`< ’1'11115 5101£¢00€0111900
130\1'5 001.1.001 101~1,111*\'110 011»11001100000. |\101'00101
_ ' ’1`\).111~'1 15 . U1~\110b111bc1>01044111 15 900011000‘&> 501»1>001 1110
"511<10‘5 111011014 Rw_uv/,< 1140 100010> D¢uw DN£<111511-1111`('
. ' (1’_,1’\11'.)1/13'1_1511>015~110`1114"_1`1415 511)0014 kmbmvr F00m 00010):0
75 _ . '
&.Tme-DE.N GVTRLHMH Cbm~rt“€ SHU`LPP‘S @PFLQL~T&EA_/smw
'Fm/r foam FJ_) Tmz/D I~l/’xl SMPJL;THKF HM: MQNE,€)F /l§'rtz_ ”
\,%Lel.mm Dowm\u~\'r)crm\~x DF E/vu>~ Em,u~\c<` Plom`» L)P,
No Dc>c,umm»rmmn DF E,va?ci/u~\ LY" Dm_l»vmo '.' No`£,umu
Or/ Cu‘floo~f M\oxvl/\”Pu&sumf’fo /l'z/)G»¢sa/ |111?1:01(&1415'1 Apx 1051, '|'1111 14 bc 1101111011 p0 alme
01101410 Ru,¢>om §up.c>l,mam `D00uw1l1,111/111011 lela.TMmFrL,& OF
Evlolmaa” Rm'»mmaa. 1005 5604 1701/11a DF_ |7\£,1,0,.1<412,: DN
113/204 105 1314 1>1PD "1'_. EUM PR* 121006. Rs,-omvmcr
Rla1111144 10 RPD’ (fbu> |1r1ms 014’\”1111
D0wmla141.11 %1/1<111/111011131 Ae 604140.'°`60/>.¢1,10 ENvm_oPa
Col41)>| L{ Al~lo \1lam` `”R Pm»ulzs
1_,11111140 Z)”)c 5” ”
11 511>:11% \1lawn. ks 1511/1115 delman E/Nvlaaol°a COH10<1141le
51»11140)>.1140 YY\1>10LmeK11011114 151,000(1111,11/1|&) FRr)m '
Comm.um»mm 151111<14~1 $1~111'11. ”
11 6 1)111=,¢, l1lam * 5 P:I
Pum»m’mTe/W) fnma/09 mmm/a<\. Vmuwuru, AR:IM
BB.°§L, \\£o"` Dcswmm’wmm FoK/mem@p E,\/Lowz,a,”
PG, Pw\ Rc>ueio\z\ Pc) L,\c,\z/Dwg;mgmmf ‘5 E,vlo_uju, RAH¢)L,MC< `
me>umz, . N§Lkm Rmos>cr¢; O&` mer>pm"` §chwa a/”Tm'c [\101 GML.Y bow 'T'kre, l<¥¢>( NQ[ ;B,
m 'r.
` 1 l'r 5@:>1\44 Tl»rm TM,L»\¢>SM% flaum ?5&£&12¢ ‘6 OPHM, ONCF`,
Rw.\z.mc, mem la mud homer ON l\~l Tme Cz wmme [’/Mn/. v '
. 49 \ \ .€"` "\"m, Coum F\ND¢,"\'M VNorLToTwL D'u wom'r'~s
?r_u< DF Bun.w kan \N' wm lemon mm fm lr~\\m,s'ucmmu
'DP TM/OPFmse/|NTW C/emo`ruf wmaer TM/ ComPLx\m/#¢~\. \Z)L)'l "l'me` Coum,”
T\xa,l@Om‘Drz/c mm toum--_r_@? }erM¥_N`) C,L,¢_Am_\( ll\\o_LcAMKE,DDE,RTTQ " ( ('. P\\Sq,
kvzc?| j,u)xx\wTaa/Qb LEBI$LATE,D *I'\»xm 'FOR§_NS\LD!§_M§ .
7 m
E.vlowor.,\‘z’l.”o BE/§*rmc:rc__‘{ \P\.RTM,‘S-'n>m,kuoww \M‘eru& .
§ Fn~m\mj DF-me "',’Il\xr T\xc,|’\/\m~nmz OF §Pr,wu>_"EMLTM\§ ND E/.~0 W\m\z,?rzomixc, KNowN E)Looo OFT\¢L
C,c>m¢>mh~\-rzxm. Au`o ’Fw o E)ue,c,,w_ Sw_we (".c> mem mc<'l'\m..
DE,r/r¢,r~mz_wz MmeueFa/mw`|'o TLH:,
lbm'mzrmn, Lkrbworw F£)KDNA kulw{%l% RHD ComP/)¢m\ l‘B' bow COUR'Y Oru> ms,D\LAQ~l~£ ®owmw-'tm 4
Fo¢\e,us 10 D\\lk €A iu@mv£ é:
F¢bo.m€w\;) MI>< 6 a¢.|‘{ ),
Tme\f |’Y\MQNL¢ \4 k PK\-€s\¢m~_ \mvo 561@>\ \..\" Ot~\ MKRMA/"Z,q l ZOOS, l Buc,m_§wws
‘1‘7
Cem~ \~m~a cf ?u@Dnyr/No»m's SALWA To lom\.c¢ms, OR hamm
E,L,s\z`, DN '\'KMDM. n "
\ NumamTW/i ' lam Fn~wmm @PFM"AL_LLLM firm A
` STMMLMYY\Koa/F&om\
J`TWAMTOBJQLM<\W@LABM4DRJ Fo&DHA IXNM.%L¢,
mo Comem¢m”ONTM/va Or/ MM 231 zoo§.
\ irwvale \FTM'> \/\m§\ omm.\b gould bd l LL?L,\z/es€rz. luec>n,£yl TPm>crm`l'c> `B\L` LAB Rm>n:r»s ')' FRbm"|Or,mu¢m£,”
M;oaz,fm\c,(uz,s'rmcy Lxe»amow toma /X Lox~uv R\efmu OF- _ `
Cn»`\'u>\m\um 1014 .- FéL bO “(/)?) ), PLE,/>.¢s@ l\lmi,
ONPM/,(H 1 m \+\m rao Am>bz~’) Tmrum maps
%omwmu,>d.l,\m,s baum er\Ho mmm) k-c THLT@P Dr»T\a, UNoe&Tu/e, flaan "'nm
FC>LL_.QMLNE:_ \'f\m\s him A§HAL~(LLD .‘
l\~\:'>\obw"€_)ox"kuo DHTM/\e-;T lez,le Tkk¢/Fomwu~w
Nmm mm .: [»Lw r\[u M@,_LK; Dmc,mp'r\om SAmeL"l'YPL ;.
koelan Pkom; A.HviRz/w\rm OH,- \Ns\DE/TM/ Lou,umm
W\m |H
Ek_c,\a fommu l’\/\mPa,c>LFLc/NMILLTO
‘T'KE»/FhwFLe/` FA %'wa/\N Four~\`o lr~L E,\'[H£,R_ OFTm/»rz/" Léct% KWO_RF§ .
60\1~1 Amum.m~f. \'lv,m ’¢“_ l'i\ l_a~\*-\”m/$'rma/~§: " monies OP
\"»d:l ” le m Pm;r.l>\"?wes\mw \mr>ossmr.£,F/ac:r ’ _ \~ln A
Vns\_'r\vux D\eé<_r)pmo FA¢<:F.G
` 7
’;‘l‘-\.‘~"T\am,£nur»:< FmoeT\m ~OM’YW lD 2005 l'ow¢lc,»z,u@
Rm_mM/mm€ Ru>or<\mu£f‘['\am,
Re,aoms D¢T_M |\lk A;NAMn,`: ,“VM,
kmrbu,m’l \`s WmAwuwu-cm b)me< TMV’YM` Lom>wmm's
Vr><\m'\'wn"|'um A‘) k" H\~lou~lc¢ OF» Fgm ”, CM¢IIHE_,D fivme
baum OM’F\xn,| wm Dp<% OP§M/Imo_\m, 2,0|3 (' CF\ (57Amc
90 )»/>T\e<\s"|§)m\~m Nr;,w,”(§&" N\¢m§arm Buo&sf,_` ‘
"` \"'¢>\m " bwmcm> D»om'[m` UH/l£/LM,Rc~,wwf'
(um\ mm 1th Am comm 472 mnle N@ c_mwAm/M_,
Oa_"Rw,wLn Fru,m "OP bmw "C,c)mrjz,/>RD Dr> A"Comm,km"l»c~r£‘§ _Kuowr~\
DNAP@DP\\,L” BUN&TMN¢,FFM To \‘Du\HLCrMG, bn 3/ 2_€1[05,
O& kch O*IMADM. ll ~
50 Tu_/L S’IME,")" Fl\~\o\\~\ irs O\"Fe¢c:r l\~\ a,L.UoL Fm:/rs
“V»x_)m D&Or/ ,Acm A<.
Look:.~wlal} ,"Fme," Foam/,LL U&emk'ro w R\wop:te ” me
` "\ow'lmwuj”‘l'm/Fomem“l'ew me L,A<\sM'-row idb/ua Tf’»ru.
7‘?
mm 05 (’,1>1111<11111111<11011 151115,15111:) R\u>o 1115 fmc lmpnopm
”\2.611115 %mum ,“Exn, iowa 11511_1. 13le 5111111501"3 ama
blum 1115\151161511 61550515”|11511 15141150 é.r:,wo FJN»H/)<11,\s Kbmd wm, T\a<¢>_551,1
(U'\\?H m 3, 11511<115115\¢,’F 1151,\>101141011 Po 1.11;11501151’/1<5<11115111’§
011111 baum Lk¢;&mo&¥ 1 61)51>11111111121 Rrwom, ”!><111> 611/mma
'51115 6011111115'05/1111,61511)/11551511<1)1,1 131/101511<;51:,¥§111/@151
11)111_?1110“5\»11 l*[E,m N 0&51. 6111/><5>4”51110 \15511/1 D$ 1&111:>1.)1\
6511/n 6111»¢151”!>1&115 Nm E\rm Uscu) B~errL 115qu mem' §
\/\1361>111<1,'< §11_5\<1)1»<1, 1565 asul:( buome Km’”
'r\k\% \‘1 kim @B`vmus lime Dr/ \\~\D\SPu’IAE>LL\F/&L,SLHG,O
E,vmww 51110\‘> \\\01 \?>/1<1550 011 1611/1 1501 011 DM,M’I 1611,
fmc“l"m’)»rm@§ umw 1515 54111><11\150 151 NM 0111.1 Tm&
fmcme 0511 E)Lw 1511 ‘Tmm 511/lamm To 6011€515151, 11
' 611 0.111<11 1511115"|”1151& blown 15 F¢usm 61.1<111@.,1<111> mmame
511011)11 151001>”’{1>'1'1111,"(’,011151,1;111115111 s \<11011111 b 1111me
61111,15 1111/611(11511\\11)11)1 hyman 111 111115111§1115111.1.
1<11/1:511>)<11011 5010 ’Exw\ 111111111011151. mm 0504111 (5|"11111111151,111
Dowm\vme /§ 114
\1 \6 ’1'11:\15/251>1>111,1¢11 s \)101>115"1'11>51'\'1115\5(01101\)1:@115 COUM
11)111_\”'1110'1"11156111115‘§ F1111;)111 1555 05 FLLD‘)
80
NL Cmm.u.rw me§o¢_)¢m. _
sr`
D:stc)mz,m ON 166 u rf '~1.
_ 1\)¢\2, CAAA\A OF Cus‘r_o‘o\{ _1)11 L_\zrwB*f"[-vc\z, §me DF¢EMM,FDR'\§YL
_ TW€FE&,EDW4LDN;1'@AT\N&AHDSTOML¢L OP'Bm¢.c>mc,AL_- Pwn FoRzN E,vr»_m 11a/n OF E,v\o mac 114 5&10
C,kus:-,As-Unmke.m baum 1uADmcsY E/vlowc,€/ z
Cmmm.~\m 111 ’1'\,1r_-J Or-r»l.ukL, Cw\ztekmcoap (CR l G£,, Apx )AHD Bv’finz.
C,F,Mw\u§menez CF Fe:c:r"(£R 15 3» 157, APx ia+~ 137 )P |mo
0@¢,&(£&157,/5@ 107 ),T)&E,`F»d_. D¢LUSA.\omc,z,'lhm Au. 0?'1’11¢:,5¢,
lmr>wmss ma.r. Pr\oc,mu m blm impuon D-umm_rTvkrz/ée¢4 50wAL_A11LM410\4 'E>’\Lm,Dmm.s DF 'l’we§1msu»40 Ka,vr§.LMlous
Bz,mr:r E,¥Posa,o,l><¢.wwu~lc¢ ~’Iien, Counzr Tp C,Le,éa 1100-mon Pouc,£,Dc-_.M OPPEMLRMM:I 9‘ 0 3041.560 5. T\&L PsFr-lk\~l4, `
CF\.`\&\L_L.¢ €Swms Umom DMHT\&E.Fou.ouJM& 515/1 warn lsTauLlwo
C.omm,:° T¢.)o E)uc,wd_ Sw.emv MERQ'FA@¢¢E,D
- 31 '
IM'IDTKE,HPD PRDPEK_W Roc'>m OH D'_’)/ 1-1/05 B~{ DPFlc,F/K.‘ m. Ci,mc, DPDNR?/vlowc,£,,?u&su/&m 'H> "1'&,)@<6 CUDLOP
['/leluo¢kaoo&/DuRLP§R»rLc,L.L 5 8.1#12.
~'l‘mq bkvm bike wm DNTKL Z,Luo DM DP &me,,Z,OLB. 'I?\LAFHD)<\/ 11
MA\<:/, 1~10 mm*rmn DPTms E,vmmquA\/mcr E>w+ TN ONM Lm) ARM€o\WzLLPM$oH '12) Bu.m/W,TM :Tm$ Bvlo ruch
1111¥, wm |mo Tv&€/HPD Pr_copwv Koom 011 03/11/05 E$'~r Omcm -
M.($M_\,kryv¢u wm b\M Rme¢\Neo"’f»\me/\Zv£,p,§mor». - 1
mmme 15 511.11»14 DF kw SE_AALA u)e\z.mm” Dr/Tm$ue):lzm Tk¢.€mpwujm‘&<\ Evmwu.Rmao”, C)cswlc>: 50‘115205 N-» szf\k&b@ : QB/ 11/.05'-’£'1»:,1
1530- S-u~spzm NkmLSTYrLoA¢,-BM< meds N.mz,~! WL égPL PQRP:JRI&D'E) LONTMN ` 2. Boka.
Bow.¢_ wm DFTQMME,BMM” Dr> wmw /5< limeme DNA' SAm¢>LLb)M
mem, Fu.xs'e/No*r&TuE/$m._l§s_& 111 r~l’EeE/E.~&vu,opn, blale 5'1’&(£9,
°wvwo~m Twu nw ’r’um, 14 k Bm»~ won/bjer ‘111:, lownf~nu@ mkm<,
DF" R 2 Z'L”l iuTwe,Cou,'umN Dlp.e,md "_E)THLL,HF OF TM, E»+vu,ovzmo '
B.>;&Cz)na, 511:4§2,9`,|3'1"11:£, mw OF" § E,‘+é¢ff sz,c:u_~z L)Hoe,rwe,mu v
'Ev L,w To DFF mazz,Ru>o 41
'No.D§oLt 151005 Ar~\'b fm LDS- D?;§>oq.'{)n me lZ-Am> 2_5 O¢>‘Eus
fhmz,m_u~w 15`5001£/130&»¢?11,1¥1"1,") B'z,mw ,TYR_QN \L"; Smr>’Fo £01~11;<114`.,` D HA Ex'£&éplev14 0&111‘{1&/&0€000 001 "Ll)'ew"
Cnu.wcm“lik_xe` Evmmm, ."|"M 10 1~10 lNoLL.KILDN \M‘Fm‘» AFFmM/m' 00
10’110,%.00@ 0¢190~00_¢ 150100111¢¥.£1¢ Twe/ Suemw Faom wsm-mine
Skn¢m», 11_1)¢1)00~1\/00, D'rm’fum~\ A<"L.¢>¢4 E,v\ow¢e,§/com 'T\x»<»r
. L”u¢rr°_l>\poe.knm’; BLW€Q’FM 16 Nonb OFTWLmech)w_mMmt
111’&\4, l§;moxvn 0101~1'1' 1112 17\¥,,€000” Dr"H'ou) ”,"11) mm’,' hmo B~r"ulkom',”@s
,Evmmcbh)m'l”e EW *_u)mm”h..})é 11‘1 Du,wc,azo.
TMAALNO Cmer\r»lunbbv mwsls?ura$wxM '1'0 Ta,x»¢< Lo DLDF mmuw_
Pam,m)u Am\¢,u, 38 . '-1 1 ANn`/l’w\e Av~e N0_1',v510¢<0,1.10¢,2‘1 : 1»1PD C,m mr-.;_.; 1,0¢09\»<40&1'
- Ruomé?im,>sr\*\fo P\MLEMTM 'Fai/\”'m.wmm 0_€)!11>041100, P\\zmw’&
0110141=.,@0¢¢»03041.5005»0» 001 1_.~5* 1055 0300@1 wm wm
1 15meka wmbl.mamow 011 03/7,1/05.50100'?%15)<*10:01.
‘ Memoe OFTM.RLmlmDown/Lw»rmmn FUP»PWF.P~MM\NB DP DNA< '
1,':,\/10011£0,1°§110 BY ’1”1%2‘)1_#<1£0\0,111 DFTMAFPMM` 1}1170l LNm£/LMZ»MDM
1 Runms _ ` ”10 RML._E,_C:I ”-P& F\\?/AL,Gus/»As A'a,umr,. ` \ '- -
1511 Lmz,s 18 hmo 251 Dp“rme whom/11 DF/suu_ee/s TumE»/¢DmAs ¢` DAL-
SEK\.\u> ENvewPu;Laaw"_Z_ Buu.ku 500£¢0¢5 Fao m‘/\"YRbN@¢_GEAM"'Umew
Nm |Mvr=_mom_,o.”( BvT&LH?D C/Nmu,LAc€f»¢ lam ‘5’1/<11£,$_ U'Mom 153-mixed 'E&LLAB 1a 111 PDs‘z umw
CBP " BNL€a/N,w f,\~x\re/Lopc, Lkom.a,o" 7_ 6000)2¢1. kae-z '\¢Kz>m’l”~(rznm.BM~t
0001@01100 1101 111,\/01\1’10&1100(01 111>_0 mmc 1_00)._ |F”Ims"f:vmww
' 84
l/ 1
11_11>.51~101 0001~1001§211~1\/011102101> 11120 6001.0 521 1204 K1~1_010 1111ka
11 13101)20101~101 110111211~1 '7 ~
‘[111100 15 110 F\ummw 102011ME1/ma)o0 1001~1110~/1110 1`1111110025 02
' 1_11:1102511\10 6112111 132 60110 01 221=102v11-5 1702_502111'60 T.C;C,P_ 2001
` 313 ‘12"1'1121 sz-,wue, 00 Te@?&m>m?mmum, 2010 D0wm011121101~1
30201200 111111011 111<1101,1112 D.N2_6v1001100. 1‘10 Dc)wmz)~l'fkrf 1011 012
11)11102011 1’_21110\¢20111 11111110 11 611-010 me 02 111100 600000100 120
Puapomm 6211/1000 , 0110~1 '1'1121 11 1025 K0wv00 011 03/22/05
, F11121.`1_\11D11 1_1110 31 211='1¢1__2111 512105°1'1 PD 112111101,2022102~1 R000205
Fumm 2190110’& 1201 1_001 "111_1<1 TM0V10 E,vmmx, 11_125131;1021100
15 10011?0 1110 mm Rmm 511'1101120 600110 02522101151011 07/7.1/05 "
300201001>'1'110 2050000 OF 622111 611&)11001 212102v111 02 2111 01002
”1'112115102 1111 E,v 10011001]00011101~112110112110*1'1102111211% RM02100 1150
' 131>'[110'1'112111" 221>022’1’0 Rm,wr "'11115 211102v1116 1~101211255 0221\100
, 601 201 `-.255011\1>1101~1 ”
2311510 Fam’l”Mxm 1110 211121~11 11121\01 110 111011'11011 02 1111=1 Ev1001100’5
‘ "'11111”'115 100111001~10 612-621 1101111110 20001 211 0121»1002’1. 00020,<1<0 '5
17101<1110 1_11> 1110 521111100'10 '11);2115 1 1210 100111100110 612 11 s R11:10211
;me 100111100110T0T110 61111~1101.25 ’1’110 2?10102111 2111-1120 11011022000
C151121 020 0111.1 2110010’11110 21112111 15 202121<1110 10 1110€211011217 _
P201>02111 200111. 1200 1311 5010101 21>2102111 2101/02 K11001 "1'110£1/1001~11:0 .
1120 LEH.
011 17200(02137,2<1=07'~11 15 211 02011~121_11~11202111200111200021,” 1\1011
P001,1011100»51011P00100D1u>1. 010011001’\0?021111101001111\10. 030211500511 l v
5001»01111011 111.00151501»1'1,01110111 1\12202111/01"13000010111211011F02
’1'1021101»02611¢ E.v10011_00” R01>112011`00 1305 500‘1 D210DF 120002§'0'
03/2‘1/05 1311 HPD'F 60022020 17 21211160‘3 R01;011/11102201101_'
100111100110 311 m 130'5:101 1311 031/m /051 921/10 Z)F 2011)211' 502112,
130501<.1011011 2010 C01101/1101~1 DF 132/1001~1001’12_3 602000 E,1~1v01.01"0
601111<1111110`7_ 600021.' §1.1205 620111’[~(20110 1510221 " K1~101011
Ruumc/r., 52011_>001 _13_@_0£00_1{300"1) 1\1221120~15151'{0000¢5100
‘1“11102?0 021/10 L2021¢1021 Ev1001100 2000205 2011021/11 60111211~15 110
' 1’\1,1020100'10’1111,|001111111110 mm< 12 500 24 1)01021000 1’)~1’1'.
130022020 N02D005 '11101»\170 C21m0 1202/11021/ 6\/10011001{100020 '
2111021¢11 600/1201 22010201100’€5'1’110` `R010211’ '011”.1111 Ev1001101 51
2001 20011011 61111:1' Ukt ’1'120110011001 6,21m0 L20 RMUME_D 1216 .
Euv101_01’_0'10 '1'1101>1?0 1310?0211 R500M 1311 137/21 l 051'1'010320110
17201>00111 1300111'11121 2000201110"17:>’1'120’510021121'+1021/11,2110
2902001110<-1 T11110R0001105,N0v02211010 1110 E,v101z1100 1120 6011 6)2
13151‘0111100
~ 011172110(6,131% 2Px75)1522006102?00100D0PT 62110
P\m>mu 1)21100 0'~1/21/13 6260110 030"115605 1911 611~1£7.5 10"` 6260
11015"1..11107,0 2201 110112122-2500’.’ 61:>11»1*2111011)¢1
2 b OHO, 512105/ 600211011 310200111 60me 65 R010` 30 511002 FOZ
60000011011 D210/’11m0f 03/11/1005, 135 7 20025, 600000100 1311 3_
151_2112 1 60000011011 60021101~12 13021121 17202201110/61)1)1111111/’{~??02
""11101"01.1_001110110111 1025 6011_00100° 1 1' 13100001021_1)01211_
D0s01111>11011 l 30002_0 510/2155 F20w1 102011101302251. 60000011011
19021>050:111\105110211011 ’1'0 "1'110210111 01¢'1'1101720000011111
133 0011>/1 1011 15 1110 1121111 10111111111 1101211011 1701 11211056)11 17110@021\/
22 1
1?102-3011010’1"1115 HPD 62101201>001 51210€` 1 11501 B1o0001021_
601_1.00100 ON 03/11/_2005 13571126.
' 1311132_00( 6R1‘11121P11 100) 1521_201361@021 _F20m 1D011110'E,1~1E/”
2 60111221;1 F02011510T0-51111 0 6202210 1011 F02'1‘110110051011 '
2001001)0111. 1111111 2 60110 21511)211 DF 601112111111211011, 1220-510100
1201>021$ 2110 101020 P0R'1'0s11110P0000001105. T201K017021 15 132100
11\2~1 10 2005. ’1110 600211011 611=‘1”1115 626 2000 2011~10 To 711021>02059
'01~1”5101301>021 15 5015 K1201/,50110 300,1»101)51011,’1?0<20 77005
11 51210’5_"['1101;01.000111101101111 1002021120“1'-000: 11211'1 11011100_2
15‘1093011510211116‘1032 1510133 211015‘106‘1. 11 312/106
`V~r,001v00 F;Lom” 111 19021011 1120/111 610022020,"130001\/00 6)1~1’
615/261 105 /1"12¢201'5 N0 111011'-11011 021)00um01~11211011 612 \ B000.10 ”
601205 F20w1’1`~1’20110502211' ” '1`110202.20 1~10 622111 02 601100‘1’ y "
2<1'»2102\/11¢11’1)2602111 "11)"1" 6 6 P 221 53 1-12,. '['2020221€,1~110
60011010`210 00 211204516 P02502111 1016 6 P221 38 211
011 1>220(621 1-1'-1 21>11 01_)15 211~10111:021_20 1311/2021 F20m 1
100111100110” ’1"1>10‘.121110 601112201 602011610 ‘1“0511110 6201121021’ _
1011112 601115 1115102=1' 00601112111111211011,1‘20511>100 13011021§,2111> _
101220202’1`0¢,1111& 17200001)200. ’1"11101301>021 15 D2100 11112~1' 31',2005
110100\112 1110 6002/11011 15¢'61115 620 2110201110 ‘115’1'11021>02055
011111017\01>001 15 7“100 F21111111 61111“0 11501 1101)5101171'0)125 7705‘1
’1'1115 600211011 15 1101 0111,11 2011120111111 §1111101 11 15 6002100 111
911
¢XN F:r \~Am»_:f D\FFE,REHT ZLP (/Ot_>e,. '
~’|”m¢, P\e,bom §'IME/:»:"""Y\ae/Fm_wu_)mt: \'tE/m€ blm
P\H?\\.\¢ze.o: I'fr/m Nume\z,_a‘\ )-SQO 601 l§QDBf._[-§qDBZ |590'6_‘5
\S qp%‘+ Pmo lb 1 q Z,L>f’ "Fm/ LM»: l»re,m fm fm Cou_um\~L \eDMM£D
Ae` EQM)SL.S;\¢)AQ$ FRon/\T~{RI>N¢;_,E)'W#" RLFMLE,§AMPLE, z
P\w,c,u\re_n?&om |H PM$DN hom/§ BD&RRF_P~D ".... RE,c/E/lv£,b OH
D§/’Z._‘J/ 05 . ’Ekw\r»_;|¢, Nomm»n,or~¢ 05 E)A¢rLCporu R’LZZ DRRBOD.
' PLmse,No»r'o s’fme' Re.aor<;-r Pu.eo Pukpor#o\-/c,"_ \u Vmeou Fcu> m"lT
lsuummm R:;wvz,b Bn DBILAIDS,Y`TM AP\LNO rl£,a¢$ 16 Pua.euecm "FD TCC)PQ:P<£. § B» "f l P;Hn”\'etb&£,&&b 140 fhle
Bvcucnoo\rwms>kv\»té R)Mu/;m ToTC/C/PAM.BQ>. ¢»lL.
\Hlxoovr\om'l?> \/\A7 APx 74 ), '
Tvm lsTM-,%owu,mc-m NMW\\/L, Dooumm_'rmlm FDRTMNSF£,&
OP E,v'mmr.z,¢ ’Em, umwa ’Feemo fe A C/MB’.’ A_H\>" R:w,,lvmaf Aa/me_)¢':~. lbwmc,»ma,
Ew W\_.®L)/,aax E)H 05/7_4105.’_’ "l' mls Nalmmw>n 06 'De,ukue
E,vmu¢_e.afh ’l'um Dw¢mzm Loo.mmus . \n F/xL/\ me DLH Dpéwumuv,
"l*rmNuMBMS" DMT\§@\oENT\&MLLABRE/PDM(CR.\"}‘NAP»¢&)?_’), z
50 ka161=1 150 ANMWL 1
' qu-Lxr>m PRD¢)r-.&Dow mm¢mlm la lm¢>mmlssmw. ,
, ’[\,km>§wo_uw dewme .
mcmann IHT\M/ DTMMRL)LU Or
PWLLLME,VMM,DM£. R_uu,?)q. 5 (@). Comu~rrs' \: UHL§,% ’|LE, ‘ .
Pmlm Dm\ r.»uxrnf|”vxa,\'»mm 64 IHTM,APPH,MLKMAD McF., Cop\z,e Cg\;'l'u¢e, _Feu,ou)l 14 cv :*%. A_m' RML)LW |
F05F11101110‘) Br ka /5<110 C01101.0610116 OF L£usL_w/M
Om111ho.6 600 C,R£E 3 f’I_E/m$ 3) E,vm‘&eov eu"lhhkpr>huw1 m,thA:
1 59me own Pop.auawr 10 ‘Ve,ms Row.s 1515th hFe;o_c/h/oo 511_,1R1.11_h
2)°1 S(G), 6091>1,1)1101111111011'=.(1 l¢ARhu,\/km' [1hm Hks E)u_11 Om111ho
'F“r>\o mTuhC,um/\e P\uonoz’['lx\¢ Tm11, C0051 61th 0 meh,
131/10101 Anol?u.h 111T11h fwth 60051 151 501701,1011,111 honmmn&
Tkh Omr1111eo 1111/m (510//\?¢77¢ 67thw111h1.h/%’11`11,R1.001§1 11)1@\0111)5£,0
Phhl>hah 1~11311,\11*¥111‘1` 511:115'1 0001111>.<1,/§<116101,5' \§ 6101111?10 A§ Fuho"'
101111 Tthkaams Cou111~r 01115101 hhm% 011 1011><1. 60111_ A110 /éthPuN
liu/mds 510111<1050/D)nho |Z/H/|O Am> 1911 Po11>11700) l§ ix ammth 0161,110101, 610110> 51 A§41s1111111 D1§15111A111
5011101< 1111.1_ D);`/\w lZ/|“1I20101l
011 911th (Pw ), 600 L1H057A110 8 [1)1111011 51)110 111 A00111011‘VM
thwn` 1105th 11 Chhoa.*mm AF.@1,101>1111 Awwho 15)91111 6001~1<0,&14
mm 2510 2005 11)00~1’\'111/1711/>1"\'1/>1 1016 DRtho. 50061)1111,‘1 ¢
_ E\cmaw A Dowm 6111.01 bmwe 111 Co50\10 1111§ FKM 1511 13\1'011)1111019 Th111m011~1 ALo110 10111.1 _
9011011)511 1110 Com@ewmme/xcow, £11»<111
139 60610011'.
mahanan 1110 Dooumu+-c. 51Mh‘1 05101111¢15<1141111,5"_16 51101111111
‘1'0 1111»<11111111011 DFTALQ \»\ouowhh€oum, 16 595111¢10111_1,1’[0 E)r<’Fhé1 051>10511/,0.’"
111,»11 |1(051011><1>11~1)'1“151\/\11<01111 511/ms 511\1 hOP"l”hm§
' Rm15101h0 DNADMA. DH UNL\D;°CDLLQ¢1@D E)~r j'» Pm_mr~.o W P£,N,Y TRA_l-N\':,D LN RE,mNm@ DNA `
wmva Cnu_e.c,uo\~\ VADM/Dua.% N~lr) T\X_m ‘l'm=`» F\m*lmv£E/D DNA`
SPwmaN LL]xs'TL<\M \u fpm Pz,lMlc/lb L\)L'f k CU RR.M'£ D PS kuloc,wL£/$.”
du L.\Hu. \,\ a `-@& tamm l\lkma/’ 11 l',m¢, furs/3 1aum COLL.LMN£¢
kemm ks'\"uz,` \»\P k¢. Pmop D¢lmzmlw Db\ E,vuw Dr-lk
S_Amm,e. Cou,s,c:n`ou. Fut> Usmcv PmDPDPh>m/l 11¢.
PML( Cm?>|»!§?_.. l>»r NOT waz,
_ wm F/vwmc,r» bonwa Té ms Cm,,Bu/r mm fmc NBVE,R l»m)
l>uw'T\&v/|r\é Dowmm/l.mlm lN’~l'\xE,Rn,coRn mmompc_w O'FT\)@,D NA E,v\omc/LTAW ON YV\A~< 25120053
- Tm le No Mmm»~zxnm lmmest Dp haw lim bfka Acrrme,! 4
lnw)m_n w l\\mmm, wm RPD PR.)> Puu~!, Nmmr~ze¢ Fr-mm $XPD tamm
La<.n ,Nmm¢~lc, me- lr>,m¢\w¢,»a,. No»levmc, lian t»\.» Bm\m,ma, Oc> Aquf¢/m t No flu/am Br> C,u‘noo~f
` 1 Nnomvm 0&1><:4~¢ lhwca APHDAVW> O&€m_'rmr;ms £z>:~\m\m,
Tm,h)kvwouqs-DFTRLD NA, §pcnwu,‘Fmui, dou,\wlmn \1zw,‘Vl¢t, va.oan le€umf -
E>PbOMLD
ch>mm Dv' wm DHTm/Cou me D'._,m»uru Fu~ln$ Tl»\A/r ON
. - q » ,
_. 1111le '240054~"1"11114 C01v1914011410141 ’s\/001141>1145111'0051A 0111140
Fe101v1’1`1114 00m1)140114111041‘0 P014111141, ki101140000 1Y1011¢4F110111‘V.1414
14140111 11 E)14000 131‘14'1114 CDMPL40111101411 D;?01111%1)14141014 01»"1'1100101>14110411
1110110 11 F011P0¢.1 C011\11e411014 ?01¢101'>1€4 D 1\1/1'11_4411140 1510104 ' '
900011011400111;114 01'1110&41/101114£14£014101111140 101011114140110 01
[`4)<1)‘1124 1\10101%5“1.
’111114F0141 1»'1'1"1114£01101 1100 1301140 11'51]141411>11401'1 1504 L)NRLMAML
1112-4000 A141> 0111011414£4114'11101 11)00140 [51_14114001111»11 0011'4 111 Arw 000 .
01 1401-1 111’1'11104510et14£11T141L00,D1110&01140 ’&1’1' 1114 1000 60 014 01
010/1111014 17000401)1)1114 A141)T11111141114100s RuL£/, 0?01011414014,
11101.14101110 1501 1~101011\11111,0 10‘ R.U_\,L-lO 3 1111 FL)NDMMMAL
ERN.>MN Ctum111014 015'11451 R111414‘-10 5 E4x1:41_41151014 00 R10414v0141
0101411014014501141>41014 60001409 1100114‘101 R14111011114111114141 01 '
M111111111F10M1014 0100414111¢1£011014 1 Amou0 W\M~\j\{ 01111141°0
1111 1504 61100141111£0 F0_`c41 '111'01 DNA E41r11>z414£41141¢1 6\0011)111-1\14 _
1/\1111: 01'»124\/101~.41~_10411,"1'1)101 11040011<£4!31011)1114111114011011 0010 1001411¢1£4011014
111111’[0 50100010141140 014141 51 900on 11.11'10 ARFJI” 110111040 A_Mb Cvd\r"\tw
|11’ 10141710111.1).1)0140111114141011011 /3<141) 110141>1411111 001'1111 501141.'41014
E4v1011411014” ’l' 1101 6001 0011144 30&01400140 011\`51'114¢1014&0001406
E»<‘flou 1\|01 E4\/11414 "['1»§11051011114 .
001 9011111/1414~1 1’401~1141400114 1111'410'6 Dl\ll><~’nrw 1101/14’1`1»44.1140 00 041/1411
1131410 '41)1~11.>1’1"1101 1701‘11145$
_ 500’111011'4- F0141.=10110 01414011.0114 1V\0111011011140 1`40141401 1410.1°1
DND1501111>L114 1340 141_114011;40 1311 1’1’10~1 2451 1005 £401)140 1\101 1514" T00»0110
11110 mclka 900¢)1;01~1' Room 011 03111[05.”//‘11)§11‘<601111>1404
L0114_.wre0 014 W101 15 1005 11001_0 \~101 1\0vs41?)14111~1 R114011411/e.051
'1”11140\13D 00111114 1400001010 1314 03/7_?4!0§.”/1DNA §011101414 ,
1"_40141_54:411'_0 014 1111/111452005 01010 1101 1110vr1413104`n414" TM§F&RRLDTo ,
00101{140141\/1_140 3110041\014141141511 W\, Buss'zx 1314 03/74@1105 " -
P_15£,°¢5
11116111150 FTE,ms DQDEN 11' 1 U$@DFTHL` 51)111,‘ 5 1110111>1~1
Rzaur,mne foumr To Dm~z DNP;’I'emme” 11 111\/101.A11011 DF‘Vm;,
‘T:xp1 1111111<1~11,15151111> 11 AV101,1<1101~1 OP` 1511/1101 V. 1111<1111)<110 ‘
373 U 5 33(1°1113),@51)1.111~11111~1 A\/101,A11101~1 01'/‘1'111,.1><1°01111_./1111‘5 '
'1§11,111 10 Dubpmme OFL) 51A1e`,5(`/0N 51111)111)1~1.
'Tvnz, 1>101>1¢,1111111 11)11'1.61111)111 151 5111151 PRooF inman 111 ‘1"1>.11
01>1'»101"1<1_`£11,@&11‘5 me"D¢‘FmL Loum C#<516 ARL. 11.')1)111‘1111¢J 1100 1101~1' PoL,l memem1's
C,mm,bp111¢111(.01111<1;1/1 Fom.nsm'l” 11/111111, L)*1”1111,\:11<51 '1"111<1 1119 Lvmrm 011,/11)»<¢,
Fru 11 01115&,
61 ’1'111,0?1»0111101~1 01='1'111,/§1001,11,&111‘§ Bvrpm 111111111111 /111 1?1>¢11
Cou\r11,1`101~1 m111,¢.T\)<1¢_,11111111/1~11101~11<1_ FA1L1)R12TD 1311 1/1;011,
’11'/1@1.1, Exc-,u 1.1)1<10&1 wcc/11 11~1"1"9~1)11111 k 111111,1£,101)‘1 V\owMn~z Vio¢',kuow 0<1~11)
ADam11/151511 11)1\1'> 111<\11,0)1111. .
1 To' Rmd_lzla, Tkx<'Teru,E/v1oma,b Uss~.n 111 5 malum k 1_’_,1!)1\111101101~1 11
1111’1><1:1 FM,:) 11'»11,1>" E/vl'owc,b,k 11‘1'1111,1111D1)11 111~11>1,&’11111,1,111 '1?1
lmmmmwf 13151;1.0111.'5)<1'1 FA¢m,/‘ru. (’\",¢ woome Pm>c, P&R‘~¥` }\.07).
dam mae l>'Consls'rmm 61»101,11)04.
’3' 3‘ YV\&.\XNMM)N ¥»\ke F/m¢ammTku/Fzm |'¥P./l+s MA/llwbc)ué.ln th .
‘ Rw>mmmn D»= Doaumm'£mo& Aup tim P¢);¢mwlm kmmmn fn Dm.u¢_,
f 'v\r_r<. u)u.¢_-BLLU»< 'U)L‘m No F,stz, wm Tm.,é<;ar>a/LLM~VI C.Lurw_u firrka 9 MRrrs \"MJ> E)“f TM,N'@Q.LM~\F,W\¢L.HMMDN '
S'TP¢L Co_um A(PPA 1¢~{'»{\€/0 `
Hu us E,L.”Tw R.r¢,pp~n,sw»f '\”m/Pwuc)¢m F_o &Twr», P.um)aza, E)F Lhe
o»nm~\. ' ' , ' 4 ~ ,
Pa_e,¢>;sa,l~\o»rbvm w W\a.. L\ms>rou \»b¢s (’,o\~ls o wu ous ur Dmvr»l¢m
'Ywe,DP. Hn,Doa/. blm u)a.q~\»r E> koo’lB*Ek,me
the kumoun.wmm¢ uaw Lo.~urj\”me M_mm»e W»<@ 5er h)a C)n' “7/7.01:7_, AmoDmlan fin %/91113.
'Tw\s mmio~ blm ONTm,Dou¢n/c F'orL_(Dvm F<\¢’E,M,émr> kw A¢.~m _l&ko
\¢r Nm E)w~\ FD&TKLMQ£)LLKM€ VM» ‘Sn/_(_`>B:Iwmu 119 N\uu) rise
C.:>mn~\uu~cc,&/>, `ML@\):I h),n,u,%m¢.E»rL/$I»Hu~l e,’“l'mvr)`a,. (Sr.c,kar,»ums.m
y DN 155\)€,“ ;'))., `
-___’_`__"A¢Lom-MLYTQ‘HM,S1ME,‘5 Mo'non'l"o Dmv. 5,5¢':¢10¢4 I,"Awur,mm
|_xu)." financh me/l\z,x,(,ooe, Cmm P_ao¢.(@q . 0 l (b), (LRUSA¢>\<%),. '
` memuo D.\~L L'~,mr<}{%" l»\ou)rwm. k fowlebe 'PM€QH,MM `
Rmuem Foams m, D N PTL_YLDPPM/,cfl"wm 14 TM.E)M 14 DPTM/ fatwa '
` qa ~
Cm1r101101-1
§0031110'(110511<101¢1111>1 11 1709~1111113010“18 01<91101,120 1130
Ur~los.wr\1031=`0011'»10 13111<11001 01'»"10111,(’1'110111030 D_NL‘{ 1,/10
1931/100101011,1 031\11)11100”1'111013%111101111111111\_111051/11111031
1_.311111131¢0 05‘1'1'0'1£0001.1303113 17300113:1 b‘1 0l(b), 11 1\101 ~'FRAQ1»_<11 1131 011103 111
"1'111 01me
600 100111.0 111 L1301V1)<1~11103£11’F1105111101 §0 /)111,0111108’11) 11'\)<1.`»1~111¢4
' T11101311131110F0111~10 Ol~l L11~105, 13130011,~1 1301,0111 T11051)1101 1)1001z
‘111011_1031>` 1'11~101,1°1111> kol\uou)¢.an£fr;,,§&§l§ OF ‘THE, LRALLE,NH,D
0011V10T\0N"P&1T11100P&3M1110101011\1 KNDTM,PAM ’1'110’)1310,
- 1511 11 1 1301101\1'/1011~1 F1<01 001~1_~1 111).11100, 1131" 091/3110 130D083”
FBP~TW&/ APPMRN'»E To 1306111 1330111<.110 151/031 LL,Nm ’1"110 613'10
111111<1/. 111’1"11013¥¥101101~117\£01101111~10£01)31 '18 1303 F03101110 D1~11°1
T0111110, 1130 111*1‘111>11 1730001117111 1101~1031¢01.0 00031 11111.0F1111) 01
DL3001 001¢1.011400’10’1'1111 633011001)1' 001~1\/1011011.
11101>1139010111*»19011 6013/10110\»1 Dt\\k/ 105111~1 016/110
1’3011100 1><11 0811=.1~11)01311 11_1111011101 D090~10 311~11 W\)3 01>'1'11003?01110 "
50301&1_£)0110\/ 61»c10 2_55 511)301 '2_32_ 33
111'1'1101100030 111101. 000331,~1 53011) 131 T1110‘%1M0‘1 011111
110001110111311011 ’1'121051/_><10£,1>¢11101 13000»:30 NH 01>” 1110
111/1003100111’1"110€1»<10'1 P011061'101~111 1113)111 11 11 1703903100 10 130-.
110311 11 9061121001‘03 11<.1~1101~10’18 11011101~1110‘<10"111»11711011V10111400
1031 10\'0311\1’1'110?30903 0011011101~1 T0 1131/05001~1 Aoml¢)sm
1\~1 331 Coum 01 1310 130031110 0\'» 1110 110111111011100 11’1 111>£<10)<0 /<111~1!) 13 1111 1':/\11011~100.
'1"1101>§1990101<1~11 111\005111191:1§30110'1”0 11101101131 11511\10 DNL`( 1110
.E5v101_151\11;115 601111<1111515 11111115061=112516<15 bbmam Rmm 110101116
911€16101¢1.1_1 lm1606611115115 F0161T1115\»\0 116101~1 PouLLDUM°
Nm 1/\1>1\115111111151119046 1/5611111 1611 11115<111111506'1”1115?11111>15111151>
‘T15611N&,N06. CDULD L\Av15"101151111c11_11115”|7066115666506£1~11 DN6<
11\11115111111_ 90115»0651150'~1”15 111<1/11'515151111 111115651’1>11156<111 611
11115 6101)11515156.<1~11 11611.1_611.6066111€¢’['0"\."11\15 C,c)m°ct ‘6 k11£5141101~1
’1"1211<1 611 ’l'11111566111115 Pe,¢uoo 05"[111115 6<6 T1115 61519151.156111 6 D 1465
1'5\111>_15110115 115155 951511~11¢1&11~115151150, ’1'1<115“|' 6<1'~1116111115 |)11610111 0 16 1111/
161151511111 176111511,01111 6 611111 cmmn, 1511161 616 wm 616 'F1115 15111111,
D¢>wmm1anxu1)11101~1 05 (’5&066 C50N16/\1501:11’1"1561111£¢ Pmawum6,-F5mm50vm |61 *1'11165
1’0111151~1610'\'”16111111 Lxem'[oa~€" luz/111 16»151~1115',’ (1_)1>106 15 616<11011111
91151511111115615 16<111-1111) 111111'15061 61115€5¢<15151611111 611151~11¢ 11111111'1"111111
1’51:1111\)<151 10 061511»51115 616 6\\{1111>011\¢01111115 6111 06 L\1)061011
(65-515 619?¢11~1015\66»1’-)
5151<15615'1”11151{115151)615 \6111<6 515111 M16mm1111110 616 wm 1 6<1~10
T1115156115151,60111515W11<1111>1)1.M10_115 161 1155 OPrw 616'1'1115|)1611°1101
6511011111114 611115*1'1151511\,<1~10111515151165 00'-1'151151"1<1516 U61501¢10111:5111611\15115
fmc 1”1<1.11511151115"11’116 mo 110 m151<116<151)115011591101~1. 69115 5501511615*1” 1151
/ 061150 T1rt'-56§5 \~’\1101111~1 F61'15611’»1€61110N6 PM<.»<@ may 656 F61e51 111 'F11»15
61151115'6 W\151101~1 115 011.1»1 061611115611111116 111 116 115151'» 65 Dn51~11615
0¢>*[11115&?01111151~11'6 57116111 10 DULPaooz/%
“1`111151\'10»1101~1 1115151111;56111111» found '1?5 DMW '1’1115 6<1>011515156<111 6
`1'Y\011m1 For\po‘n 65011_\11151 1011 DMK'ELHH~&& 16 61\/‘101.'1511011 DP’VM
11006501@111111?1>5015 61111 1101611115~’{1116?;?1611110:1 6§110161115~(-‘ 6 01¢_161@15,
1611 11 6 °LJ6L DP K1~10u11~1 FM,61F1065110116 chf 1156 311/1511 '1'1&115
611>@11,11)1111 'F1115 Kmm 115 61151\11566 ’T'1x1156115 151115611~1’11115 611>61;6<1_ 65
'1'1115¥)151\111>115 016/1111561191>1151.151¢1116 Mo11111~1 FoP\ 19061 @0111/1£7¢1011
\:01°116_51~161£51) NA:'T\ZA‘HN&. ('IBLRL)LMD¢ E\/lomoLRuL.L| 076
15'\'1111'15£1511111 1130111_15 PL§.)'<6115516515(CR1|3 11_1610\1'-111 653),|1\1'/`11_115
516<1165‘6 Mm1011 ‘1"0 Dw~z. 655¢110111|1,1’5\/101151~1015 |11 616<111/6’
P0660661111\1"(UL116' 117 610¢1‘1-56) Tere$'r/>ccz, C,¢,/x1m6"1111151 5661150
011 611161»1,1156<\111 016 306151>11 161111_ 1601)611:)11 9011wa 9606151111‘
AMDRW¢\D¢L<)HOW1M4 me 014 05111/05 54 111me &xl_a/m14\1\11‘1'1111,130111,011014 €)P L\PD F’w>m~( Rc)om."
\F’l'\m,fouki 11)01)1,_0 Pl.laasa \l4<101aa1(€,|\15% 1549470), 1100‘11014
Pour;)aDm P¢Lo?um) " ’1'111, CGUM 6001 _
011101 601 T111,£.1141,N11 11 30415005 14 DMn/T»m
1.1:. BRACOOE, P\Z)OD." ~
11 1414001»1»<101 Fo 1640 C011141 'fo HAvra/>< C,Lm |)14010401»<1401110
0va "M'e.a/lxww_»s” OFU51140 F/`> Blac,msa
'Tma 0141:1 E,vmwc,a, 1101401,110 1111111*1‘1111 (Lksc,-- la D 1401 154/mama
ANQTM,\$MD»sz/vmmalal \1 16 imouuuvca "\”11~1 11 Bal$ cwulz.as. 5 11101:[) 1421
Ev1011,l401.\1 1141/16101,1_,70" 1110 1\11<1<00 bna-1 11 wallace 601014111¢10
P<11014 114 D&DM’Fo lDE,l411FY |1' 5
N\)cm (’.c>r»xc>c>s\mm¢.,l C/oh_vLM mcfl'wu,l§mu_w_ Evmme,&/'&> P/xPF/K
Emew'lm'lor~\ . .
DNc,¢z,DNP/apm¢ SL,LQM C¢m~lwz |M lom»rm.em,s le P'/) E)Mc,ru U'aru) Rapml'ftvn,b‘¢',
C,ku P»rL, helm Dvlmmom> B¢Mc~ UN’»IM\ME,Q EM.¢ ed mr ’(i&_£/
RMuL:I E)mms. blum §omw~_ml=» Lm)_’l”o waE/Ta BMA<¢/»r, le -
Pc'a,»mku:l }>< GW/ubu 1 ~D`RMM b)ues'l *l'kh'£/ low/'ILHA_/e,;,d,mkm%
fha `Cbmz, L\,mms 11 ‘To'€)&',."l'ms [',Dr~l€11'ru1ci/» k NUw ForL/$cu '
maxim @u/>100\( A\~lo §'nuc)c \é</>¢u.le.c,@, 'PRoc/n,ourc.m{ccxb Evmmo£,
Pcm> him Pp\om\\:c \w\mm W\w? va,ms Twm&1%4 Sbm/>¢¢¢s” ’FHM le .
Tma. l»b k R£/M muka //
PWQM YY\L&M ks L,," wm [,\}\z,\z_g,‘l~\'r 'thx U’)b\) l|~l_*l'g¥l.é OMLQ
~’\'m-ls \N_ FN_:L Om,‘c ONLDc)wm¢z,m lm_~'l’\,kv,l£ml&n, Omu_M.
. C,u:,m'$ _Rm(.‘Tms la A_ Km Dow mri/041 \/‘m r»¢mm-
"I'e_r\z,lmr>¢em@ mm (Br»"l‘wv,§wm,'s _CML AHD’FM,\R /é' . ` \ l
' _BE,L»LNMNG» LL)HM Do`c,`umw»r( (iR.lZ>_Q,`kPND), W’[l,.m, |kou"flo¢~t -
Pc)¢_lc,a, Dn-M; P¢mpz,m~¢ AcNo blowquwa mm wTM¢,`»`DM\L
’I`)!>N m,"E\/m T»wucrurEme.s_c/mm)vt DF -
T'¢e\L E$'I her 'l‘) K"§ M\,)A¢L,R<,caum Krl '{ k Rrw@o¢~l_ecc\c.a/
?m> B\z, A\/mu' lmr>oktm~\»c P\m OF
, 917 `
5\1101.111,1=, 1111an L<&m»c mh)m 1511,1111"1711<11,11‘1& 111§111111,
14 Cmm,o 1\\1:>'1 1515 61 111 00061.
1101111.\/1,11. ARWOHKN_LPM§¢>N CDULD ég,m;.xo'~t A@L:" 111111:)
E\Lorc
131111;,1.1\651<11_»11-111€,&‘?:’
171.1,1¢.1,1\11111=1,'11111,`151¢&£_01>1,51111<1,1& C,ou,umm 1111’{111
Lm 6101,1`)1"111,1) owrmm 1»1 le 611@7@ 61¢1<*111/?011?0$1/ 01
.. "1111, anbonr¢ 6111/1\1,&15 1111 mo w Fo 1151 1111 Aow MM,TMC,»QNL¢ _
Ar~m 101.1~1111¢10£:'1101~1 01 E,\r\omc/a,. 171,11,1><§11, NO’IL’FM, 6111'\£,1>011,
6110<1,&“RTT cl "13'1`0711&, LFVP*I DPTM,DMCMMDN"%,¥ML
keekum 161»1. PLeQ” 1611me 01’~1'111,1)1/§1,1111>11011 ‘-`Cu:>»rm 3151<15)','
11'1'111,1101101<131,1,£01114 11_101_11_.-11 P1,1=1/><61/1~11>111,'1"1111C1>11um1~1
Dlr§m:m,~r 1151wa 01>‘1'111 00me 60111111111110 ’1"1111, 1511
§10_01,6111,1<11.~, /><50\/11,"1"111,£011,1)11111 16’1'111/ 111110 11111411,11
“1\11?17 '/1'§1,1.011) |11m 1117'111£1>1.1.111111115 111111/1 Am,/»¢Aé 73
151=_,l 1111\~11> 11)1\1»1111,11 " E/Z 274 '~ ’?/11116 CAHHM 1511 bowme
DurL_, 11> |511,11~1& (`/ao%w 01)1.511/1,01117111<'1 16 711meme
"TV `Z.S 5 PR'_ND 111_<‘) 151/m Compw;{m:{ Sc,M/utp,b 001 E) V 11/11~11) ’
1°>1~.11>1»‘1'111>¢1 lsTHE/Ll.p,ka. 11111~11>11)1@1141:;1~1 1111/ma DF` "'.L‘{Z.
'T“LAWMU¢M Bn,ue,vrbs TumAu% Rr,)T11131an11>1cm1m~1 '1?> 151=_,1)11111_1)1,1 A~r 1511/11111»1\10'1
lmmssmu,,lo Dmmrmm, E,xȢml.~e 1111114 11 ls Am) bucer
1110 011111/1)14111 R\z,eAr1,111_1 LmL FOR.TM 11/1~1111>\{111&
DN,A E,wmwc,z,, E)u~'r Moan,L\u./u)&m 1101‘&> Do. '1111;, 01~11_~1*
71111~111'11115 Do cum 5,1~1'1 Cue,)141111 Paoc,w,ouarb
` Lllkq ND'F FO\.\.ome,n
lF’l'111;[,oum 11101)1.1`)'171,1/11411/1\10‘11,11))<111%(£1{13¢1 155 Ao\¢}§@_'7_i1
"\'1115 16 klPk&L§uppmef N1M1v1z,” DP 1111/mun 1\11».
030‘1151'¢»05N.DI<111/D¢6uP171,12/mm~11.3/7,6/05.
' 11~1'1‘1)11,11\101,1,11/01" "1711:.151 Pkms. (CR|B‘-l) 16 "1‘111¢. 61mmm11
`1><1 1111.1&113111»91 DFDmc,FAM &11111,»11,1@1?1{”10‘1|1| 1111 ‘
1:01_1,1:)11_)11~1& lie/m3 LL)ERL/MQLYZED ” PLE/)<~c hamme
qa _
pmm/nm TQ’YM/\fm~r N'a,m €1Mbmmf 1 ` OH_E/ SE‘,MAL /?`<€zkuL:r
Cvu>u~u;£,\/\rf ( BARCODLRTTA), FRDm COmPLA<\N'rm~\‘V
P>_m»m¢~l\r wmc . . . ” T\xz,b;ppwgm mouu> Dm§,m/lw floum‘z ,
behme ’I.`L~, k&m£oon/h~lsma;“l”mz, PKr\p\~\/fms\a §wmlue Tma/
Ll>m~m wilbur H\mqv& OPTKF_,SML)K\. A:%P\crf'/émn
SL¢~\QL’FM,RLARLN@ Cwl?lcmsf, 09 A\povw'r's flame |;‘,/>;B &MoR‘¢"s
` \vaH| ), PM§E, MMUM, 5er '
E.e>m»<$*rw<¢,`& Foe¢` ,C¢.m mmr (~5 BM»§ )”l¢. wm_~z mcewen
" RTTE)" No/r` RTTC,' . \T h)o¢)LQ I\lo'r Balom OF uNr.“F-o& A
P\s,ksm~me.\,e Pmo\~lTo bcsl&` l»{ow C/Az,& AH;>L[.M@_AND
\bm11vlcegrlon 'Dr/. Blm,ochL DNA Evlorz,l~laa, mls»rm<£ l
§65' Em.lx`C” ?`ujouu> \»r E)LP\&A$o;~\Ae>Lc» FDM< F\eA§oH/ke,a,e _ 7
PF,P\;;)¢~\ ’1'0 ket\C,P\\/\MJM§§E/vmmc/E, E)cz,w *I"Mv\ P\:,Rr,o id me _
DR_-meru'\~w'kv.'. . ` ,., _ .
web Rmurm 'E>Tue:‘§upm,em Nmml'v; U’_R\?H AP¥S%)
q‘|
Pl,msz,Nn/\F,Tm(’,owtw% DFTM/ 551 uA As"'|~\o< U'sw B‘c_ l»_\oém“re\u_m r` En_,kc,w Pzw'lom1l¢~rlntr ‘1'1&\4` P\wz/
DPE,\/mm~\£/L. pr$E//\_'MQ/ NM'LL»LOFTM,CHME/Mu~l“l` UNDD.LNRD.
NM \Nvm'mm&of’ - j
Pc.mae Rs;rum’l'c> (C,R l?> 9 AQJU). me§\i/TAIC \\lD*flc£/ DF
’\'WL DNL.~t " BP<& Cooz,§#nu%” IN ’l'ms Doc,um.cm` le _
i\’\?_lz" wm mama/w m mmmc,m§ To kc Ez/z<\m
Tms Evloumujks"Unopmmi blm \\~lvw»r.mum',' |»\ow Du> H
Lm\/L‘Reo, lXoL)-'m>u Pouc,E/DMT. PaoPm:t AND E,.v,L/r_) mm Room
m A "Sm.ue,o Evaon/,'Ae wax ,` R'Z ZZ Am> ANm/m
Pvr TM,\XDUQM 9mwa CNmr/KAMMDM, 611¢.¢.`
" l_\uovmu) NM luvzmoéu€,b'; 501 l-\A'¢, Be,c,oma/'CL,£/Psm:{` P\ZOO?'/
. '\.< REMMAQ l\L*l”beLl’/bc_bgmmé~ \'mmé
mmPSHAL~rLF_n./' PLALASL NMLT&QTE/Nw` b_}E,NL/AHKLYZ.E/D”
P\>`[€)li,z,u Lomm_mw. ‘
PLE,Q@P_', No'c €.'I'Mf)~cmmzm `AngHE/$uKm£oov,RBOD) L)”"i, E> uar,»<¢. 6 w»¢e»s F mm’£"~rmm,
E>eme"-Uuovwm blm lnvz,mc> men 7 us»r'r.o \mmz,om s.z_~r .
ky'rmTwe/`\Nvm»romn kearns FaomTkz"§mu/&L, éss,e¢u m KH."
§mc,a‘fms` OFFl_c,lemm:f zF./o. (.'r'g@|hlowc¢la/m, D N k émm.r-/ Lljm)¢ou»r _
OP"'mmczTa/'e. EuvmpLTHM E.L')N*rz>¢`>c:,ww~l'l L<\:.M ku_um<,o 1b (CR|S 3»&57,~
/’_u>x (o“l- "lo7) le ’['M:`§'rmz,'s Prznpqsu> ch>mcrs OP F/xm DN fare
Coup:c 's 'Dmua, DFD HA'FEM\N &; 05 P»<@L ('crus‘l.~ Ap;eo)
- lsTwLC.mup.4‘s OADLR CWLWH~L¢Y '['»er=,` F\Nm¢~u!rs 0¢¢ Fxc,/'L' ks _¢ .
Ac:ruw__" Fl>¢e;r'\,f Aun, M ble R_lc¢m 79 AQPEAL A»~m f,ekkLch@»e/T&L
Cm~\vmmn 160 \s‘TM,- AWMH% them % Du¢ Pn,o_or,ss \H V_ ¥
n . ` Rmmwcf\'m,\‘m:-rum_&,»v u~\c-,»T'w Tms thrion £Dupcr ’Ukk'l l'r le TML
. fowle/um Oc~\ u)mw |rhe ndme |’.’op\ pan (’.m\mc:r 1014 meelc
D\\Lk*-fw\¢~\e u_))s¢, E)x¢.w, le U]`Lkm CM~(NM 61/2¢~10. l'r ls t~\m
'\”m§(¥\o'uou" \'rewTw»aTnv,_kP¢ wm le §wuu& Rlu.w,\¢
Ano kwm_m E>u,c,»<\IML,A<@¢.LANI>T\K,\&U-,Nm/|km 11 le FA¢:ru/zd_, Cnvu,s Trtt,
km/LLAM ’Fm RL@¢H 10 mucz,irgr \1\<, blm 6¢<%0 DN
F)Bmm)Hous»zo»a Por_\c/L_Dwf.
Pm)¢>m~f Psm> womu,|lzwm>. PL§,ML»NME,’I`HDL
51 mack mims'rva, Oevmue donzusma~t, 11 ls Ll,u<¢u.% mmcm
/>xsu>. ON " Fxc:l ",'.:Kw:)am r~l cr 70
, ` lOO
110100}@15‘1), ’1’1105'00001> 1101 3000 000111¢101> As "Vnuv_, Pa~m
00~1001‘.' ’1”11011 00001101110‘1”0 100610111/‘1 01-1)11 Dowvm,mmmn, _.
'F\a:v/u)mmr 131/100000 1101 3010 /1:11001010, 010 1110 01101
1_0010)<1_ 11010011011\/0,§011100140 1510¢"1'0mm0 11]1111 00
J> 111 '”1"1<10$01<1)00 1061 001.1 E,Vlomu.l§t'l ks <
\1011/11§ 1&1~\1111)1~1 50000’.'
1311 901.»01_' 01>'1'1111`001¢1011<0" 5000&1,(0&1?>5 APx7? 1,
FDuNo 11~1'\'100¥1'\11)01,00?'10013/><0011 111/11 §TME.MU~H
51 011~1£)<1°\0 1001 1110001:0001'1"110/1&1~|00!1~1 130000( 110m K) HRbm
T11_10 0001171.»<11~110~11 501111<_111 ‘immx,”
’\`1101~10111 1,11~1061)<11%` 011@05111011 000011>01100"
501_1'111’\”1101 11111061010110111" T110F01,00111110 1101111 ARL
' 5000 001011~100 Frmzm 111/1110 00010<10111 "AND from 000
1111 1300&11011\1 A<01 1_0001.00
51 ‘-l 51 1011¢1.111""2.110~1`“131 001111~16»1‘00111/1110000100
PSR£A D\¢Turb Pkt~wla,s "3 51011~1_0)<@ munime 1(1~10111)\1 E)Lot>o
v 111§11/1|4) me“l'uz,(iomm,mmMH 51011)<111 $m110.” "L1.
L` 15001_01_5111005 FRom"'V~rR£)NE/BM~¢’ 1/§1~1001) $Q¢,Pu:r`
Rrwm;,uc£, 601~10101.” 500 0000 R 500.”’F11:0L011 51010111001
011/11111R09001‘»"AL00110_11, 1101/111 OF E,v10010011]10_50 1. ~
5010111100 'l”@ T110P11000a111 RM>m 111 T1100P\10u~1»11.Pb@1,0111011 110011»<111/0' ’-01»0 01101\1 1901,11_01)01@1 0FF01110
50011\1 hon/1 100100111 1\10.(550 4 l5' 1005 1\1 P 66111611 123 RPD° (61_)0~\10"
"611/061111>1 1011 hmo 60110111011 DF 6\/10666'
“\ \ ‘3610,60 6111161.0@6 60111»<1111116 \16)"/11 6 \/0011~11<6‘§1111¢06
"" \'Li !><110\16111` R 171¢111161 60111110“5"1<5" ' -
`2..§11);1,6> 611\1_61_0116 60111011\111111 51611161¢110 mamme
6001111 61000 (116111 1&1 F110w1 60010.»<111111111 66114011 611111'11,’
".?1 561<1_60 6111/61_01>6 60111,1<1111110 2`61106/.1<6 §1111<0§ anm
Tvmo 1~111, 66061” K11011111 661606116661111111>66 666 60 06 KZOO.'/
` D `1~11><. bmm_\ms 6601166160.”
’\`116?11151 \110/11 131111161\6§1 611'1’111690011016111|~5 116111’)‘|
61 'TM/` 6\/1061166 66110T&1<11606,K&60”er Nmu 66601116 6)1\16
1161111‘11111111110661661(16\16116. f 661?15&0<795 11 161/111 “|61111"’2
1»\10¢6 1100 66 601116 \16111 *| b1110 611/1110 §60<1,60 7666111m \11A
611161.656111,61 61111'1,1006 60111»11101:0 1><1101111;11 6011.0661?>
F011_0111 [)511<01.19060 176006011116, 666111:111111» |11 900011<01,6
601111111/1111111011 616\~6<61/1061166 6610661116 1116$6 116116 As
\ 511$<0111165!<151,6" .
111,6'11/11,‘)?6611¢1.1511161111011 10 1161/11 “Z 011 616
" 6000111611)<11011 Fom’l' 111<11¢1066 06 E,1/10666’,' bca `361>¢1_611
- 61~1\/61.006 601111><1111110511><11\16@¢60 YV\»<06F60M1&11011;111
1610010 (\1611\§')FR11111601111>1..1¢11110111 661111<1»\1 6011111.” 1166
1156 bmi/610 66"|}) 566 C/l.r;)'1”116601)61 115116 N010 1916106 11110661 "1'116
_ID?_
` //
' "‘L!'saRbpm~:rs” Fac)m \Du~mcrtu~ta, (CR l°l\ |“I‘-b sz(oD bd
Pvl ’Fm.=/Top Br»"' 116|>1:66 DN 66611 Dr“l”wr,sr, mama \s 1116
11~1\1'61~11061 Ru,uve,o" |1~1 Pmeoc~\ anm'l', kumar/ao E)H
03/29/05'1\1)61 Tmle Nc> mmmc>NOF" Z_ 666116061~1\/660156
[’m11111111ch 511/1 1~1661\11 Faom two 111 E>woo(t him 141me
Cc)mc'LMn»r/v\H Bm11m1 ‘Sm\'m,”
Ue>m Fup611111611411011 DFTMQFM 06 6\/1061~106
16 666m1c111~1\1"¢1 Rmus/n FDRDHA< /&1~11¢6%161 AMD 666#<1161
11161.111>65‘1”1&6 §11>1111€141411 WLADrL,FN>M 1<11011)1»1 Bmoo (l1m|<)1
Tmle `l\lo ANAL~MM hamm DP\M1 PUMM(Y\€,MM 01c
’fmsl1a1m01>"E/v'rs.'f1o1=,1~1€, Morm Dowmr.mm PRL)O F DF
Or» ’1'111'6 CAm,m‘) (V\ 1611/4110 61111 dr DP 151060 mem D r~l/& 1
E,vloru~loL.
10661<56 RM’CO( 611 137 mw), Do 1,11m6111» mmc 011 03/24/05 51 HPDT 30614146140 PR§" 11160£
MUVLN&AMM° 1001116'61~16 Bv Wl 60466~1/ 011 03/7_<1/05.
DA16 D¢ R61ur41~1’$ 111 ?D ( ©L_
D6¢10141_ P111:)1~1 wm 601~11>111@>1~1 § 6\/1061~166‘
’l" 1166011»111 11~111» 15 ’FmAm) 666»<1\11'¢1 6011161111111\1 0FT116
b11101\\ 06"1'11166)1/11:>61~166‘ '
;¢.~l ’ SE,M_Ln 61\1\/66096 CDN'rku~tm& \'rm L." \//> 11111\"|’\ PN~1110=,CL1111H1'1 ’3' x 3’.
AML)M_, 601~1 01110N‘1 PH 01\16’1.”111/16 2_ 569M6P166690P
6\1101'11~1661 l~lmu P»<_um 1160 111 011651%6617 61~1\/6601¢6 Foa
61'~151)141 Ls< 601~116m11~1m101\11®0wv111u~11u) le_up.£‘ro
611me Rnw,¢_>mm.
yQ_‘.$ 56»<661:1 611\}660¢\6 601¢11/><11~111~1£¢ STQ<\NCARD FRc)m KNowN
36061>(11611110\¢1111111 CDMPL»¢1111141~11 561111.»¢1\» 6111111.1
Am 1146 (’_1>1~1011101~1 1 061”/11_~1/>(11;),1 691=1*1"&6 l»h)us‘tbu Po 61¢16
DW. imm6l.k£1 P\s L16m *‘L 501 NE,v\mkm\\/m 1511 1116
Damu\\mo\~\ 1061~11111»61~16"01~1 03/1‘1/05. (1;1;\'»1\ 1441 '
m 6012 1 _
163 6666¢~.1> 61)1\1660¢>6 601~111411111~11:1` ‘L 60“/>16§11111<121§ F¢mw\
Twmc~la, (Z)m~r” \<1~111<111~1 Rn,vmum$mm. Bm_\_(lme RZ>OD
103
-.D¢mum_ f_oum¢r'm\~l f NDM E:)Lts"rm*r. PL¢,Q<<,¢,§F,£/( CF\ lB kp_xH ),
"`['me le ch>wmu_m Ra,c,nnmm¢Tm, Ml__“? L¥;,LLLLMLO,
-P\ND PN>PLRI_;\? CDL.L¥.:L’LE.D Fon.u~ls\f_,]) 't~\A-. RE/PLRLH cagum |N ’l"b-\:E, »
'E.N»rme,?\m.om i’mz,"§wc§,()p'i'ms Rze'rpwrw `D l~l ks DM_Am M~€oMn/MNMM}AS '
human Vouas_,bs,e-r Panauu 'OvTMt/Pswu\rk l. DRPoé~zz/Awm F*EKL,OMLY
Lc,(zm_uc O,P`Paz>@z.w_~f Cou.\wf€,u D \~lA Rm€)hr.,NC/L§AMPLL,
TPLM Rc,¢mo us mLL
, ?NL` fou.u'm~lc¢ Tm, Dd4 L§_'r' LMLL:¢ 0 a Pm>m_zm_.~l C.o L.LLU-uw
Fonnm 1L,DHA' er,w~lr>e, SXMPL,:L |\~1 ’F».YLE/\~L‘-ML\X 1540 P¢c' DF
C,wer,\~\o IC>L%ZH. BY_TMROW u éwom AyPlDA¢\-/rr_( cit 151-132 ,
m |5‘|w)DeuLARs,TH/ac1 No~‘r DNW Dc>"'l'uu l\LOT PM:»M;€ A:~w
Evlowe,s_,RMm’lé moment No. 304-\5605, 601 'Ekm 'T'u¢zx |kas.
Nevm E',vm Rn~,w.mm AN°{ PMPc,_m’¢( D& E\/Lc>wc,p luTm€ E,A¢Sr,.
la him .Tvxt,»&\lu' D'rm Rf/vumw,&w.uome‘{uwanmwm
’sz,|BOfw DLs-m cf Coua»r_FoR,‘l»/Mf,krwsw‘{o§oe>mn’l§ P; D NQ<
wmm,z,€mm,ls NM E/v¢u~\ Fou»w in ’L’M, mem,[;¢.aq- Pé£s‘) Nu lDl°l 634 C'z-_’I”ms
\`Oa`u<\uxc_ Mswm"_ h)k_s P¢u>ouc,w m GPPoémoM 19 "1'91¢/ Pos~t _
Co\~\\nm\ou P\Ju,tu= B¢,u\ur Sc)uc¢%b). \u \1“[1<2@/61¢<'1@ C,L,eg\ms
` " h¢kbc)mou ’M,Remnp MA_MA 14 CAMTu-M Acr)ml,zm ¢Wmm) ,/
wm Cwusu_ C>M mm 15 , 1005 wm Tmz/DN.A<'VLH wm Onomo. '
' Pr.c¢m‘¥'m/AF@M»{MLM 500 usa uj&s Pm$_s,»~n Am> N£)u)
*Exml)\n\)cm \,M Ua$ 190/hme Pi hmw/cm form DPTMLCLWS
Rn.w\o C¢ €v'¢u~l
Px%m me u)\,u_ CAMHAMTMM -’llm/ A SAmPu'_, L’,ou,cz.¢;tm\~) DF
TM,./?Muw |M "THLBN‘I\RLRMRD,- AHD
DTMATWTMJ C,Ou.wlm»\ \»r¢,E,LF, R»\c>¢>mm'r Pm>\m/_» Bw»m\qo Mém~lmw
_Dmm DPFM.¢,\F\@ .F\u¢uouw~n Ev\omcb B\e *\'HLPlW‘-z Lc,m_
\mw\m.s\e.\m~< D'r/ lis)wmcr" T)/v\IDS O|k MLXZLI> Elem-IML, (C/F~l§"& /XNSB) _ OH
531 Z,%I 051 OF\’\`WQEMD EVLD mob(__£,?\l§? Apxb?>`§, DH -
{53[1°1| 05, OR RFLLWLD EVLDLMML (C.R\"{'-+ I>zr DlD
No'l E/\Lls/r`LJH‘flL, DSIz_S/D£)'. _
` 512/m suan/ ls N_D Dmem~'tM-IOMDF blm JUSTTM/
" ml%mc¢“’ 64 mmc/m Mkov,\lm>m\ F@m’l'\wtkovnm?o_c.,mL/DGM’$
CmLLLDN<-rom ’i'c> \ow»m;u+n, DH 03/1¢1/05 Sm‘:>v)mcr 149
` RMUF~N lTM.&~! Rmu_lm\~la./ \1"6 E,\cLLuslor~l DP<'ADWL_\<)~H¢. 004qu msu Fop:£m|/\ouo-zw’l‘o _
\`P\ssum¢,” \4 u)/>0 ~_ `
. IDS
DomemLoH DP' kw DFTW.D Nk< E/v-mmoa/‘s Rmum /Lo R`PD,
m Lk)n,’¥o P&'>éuwm, k’l'z<\c\» C/A:B' blm Unm_w 10 PLML\'¢ UPAMU
‘ Dwv\m \»r ”?
'Yv<\¢» ls 5).<_1:> ONL,\£ %1ws1mLTub\moMMANo Nmo‘E>
v bmwe Uuswmwm:\_<+ /1'¢> *E,Jc\z.$mm firm umw |r~\ Vu_zcmm\~v, ‘Pw,» BF E/w-.\ PM¢E, \‘)Ac 210wa " l'm,m blume,m'.’DM '
qu, 3m l`,lHr=, \`N f"/KL\+BD>¢ l¢» kim HUM@LA 1540 34- / .
"I'\uz,` Dc,-'»c,mp»uon" @F\'In,ml~lo. l$‘?OB-LJ,STMEATM§ l'l`ai/m la
Bru" 'E>ua,es:_éwm_s L)<\z\;L,z/o"|?)mH/Q<'E,V\l>m£/a,' ls DP €uo& A¢;/ wmme B~(
5er Bumwm,s mmpmcc~,o EW Mmlwwus Dowmw»zmmm
“F\m/ Pmc,muam Fo&“(ws,(`,omw‘l RM~lr>uma» wm
~ anm\w'tm\o\<\ DvFé)rmnch_,D NA< E,vmme,r¢. bcnb§vw)m~r _
m pump bow DQ@TOT\<GTAur_uvcm»t
Tma,‘)mm &mowmns Rz,ubr,_as hva P\wz,£)r» E,\rmwuz.
_ C'oNNn,mr:,n blm u/Em¢, quz,As. L)se,uw¢,, lh~LAom\ se/zm_£,
CAMA¢,m`M-.__» _ / 1 '
'Twe_, Om_x P\u,e, GFF,v\_mc,E,\-N luna E,mm,£ou.ww mm
10b _
Dr» m\au¢r)(fm, 111¢401,\11@ ,Doc_/u_mm»tme,kum.~€ 1111 a<, `
lu'thm/'t-n~lcrk)~lo w.m¢Lc/mmc¢ Fomwe 10 1311 111 Lv'lowaz,
1511£>1:1\0 1311 @NLY OHE,Pke-n/'Tnaoowrou~»t TM/E/mmlz, RP.£DN>,|§ -
(UU%¢ kozl‘|) k DNIX Smru/ 1101/owl 1011 PWomz/D 154 ”VM.
ms£oum~r Sl&umw‘sbnm 'Fbmsu mm /E `”1'11€, ON L“f (.009<£
hamm SAW:L ('.`c)u,mmr~l \/11um\{ Tmmm. '
' Tmls 110 61111@&£01)1¢1 Dapm DP~SWum/ _ `
CMMMLQ) Oanmmr 0&@<1)4 kowmmr’l`&e. Cowwl 1014 DP
k DNP: 61¢“1>_'1,@ Pr<,u>¢dp 5/1.5/05!><14%\111&1\!¢ 1111/mm ”\'uc€_,
DW\MM_RMAN> Rr/C¢RRNH£¢TMS (;'A'_)L.
T\xe,mm:,. wammeer 1190 17@@@,€<1\( 15<\~1:> Ewowab
Rnom,Tuzr¢/LWD mmc\,mmoqd._ Auon/Foam`acoTaz/.uuo
L», 101,141\1¢111@,11)@09¢19’10©5)1§1)¢¢¢1_ §wms Fru> m’l,"muz,
@mk~€ '11%12;€?@¢1¢41 \/mxam\z,n 1147 uf D|u~ll\i/$ Ac$ E)EAN&/ 1115
Du)u-, 111 koomon%'liw.- kean/um Or/ Pao mmDoc/ummwm
'F@&TM. Cou,wuon A Rmmmr Dr» MM@MT%$LEMHW,§
Pum>om 70 Po%v/)s le 111 adam swan kuomm@’ETuE/Tuemmmlov~_l's />wa 1115 wm 61:~,0110111\11111 AMD’VW, 11111
-kmwomw'r TDTm,Umn/D 641¢111¢. Co~¢§mmml~@. ,_ _
kacoar)mc/Lo (C.FL‘\B\AP)¢\S) lq*l"m,`- Evlo,r£,_uc,¢z/Rr¢wms
P‘(',06400‘{ wanger `
DRDowmamm con Fom'msm Bplbm wm DP» An~l-€wmbn
Tm,Rn,wan 61~1¢:~10'"['\¥£:1 ibm RMRMU~H lum-0me
CouL/c:uua’r kass/alva ¢TM,HM‘. Com~t»t% §\&FNPP'§.DE/Pt. Diu.ummi), -
lk»w¢c~r kamp Emowcn,l uPDC/lerp l;g/>crz fm hmw/mb E)R
uaw hawk uaw/um C/Umpuu> Fo&FM/Pr<£) PMHMD¢,M& bF
limech NA E/v\mz»w,a. .
"|`\xe, Fk m lsc éa gamma *Vo Tu@Ta/xA/_s foam 017 meu~lA/L.
_Panc,\z,vum Aamw,a, 35\-15,`“ Ev\owu=.t~lm Té _E>k,~ USK,D " 16
E,vm~¢ Sl.Now lwm’l'm,%ma/ Poés mm .’Fw@/SLMPL,LTRUM
Le 1 PmeM/% bnade Hm) % Pmpua,v, Evm mm l\~l Rp,vmec/,' .
te,'»\i)eumr, wm umwa Eouua uaw
E/Mu)t E)rzm'~\ Fo(.uow uo,lr' Tmuw A'Mué<:_uf |?>M,H k Cv;lmui/
Cemma11m. _ , _
in 6m1loN]I D\'¢/lwhmm% Mo1lomRLQui,~’-»1la€& 110 UM%
D'u~\~a D N'P<*[Ls~a m 0 :" E>xcw&ouuo'i \ 'LOob ¢ PaP»cm/é;i]vrwl lr`re §Muke,ksswaza@c= A~s Commn,mw»z 1¢~\ 'U&vfl'ms D»LH. O'F CmmmA/L,'
me,s/ \Ne~1L/imroraanwmou. '
"’\'M,Rum,ou ’l'\-Ms ALL¢,M~H 54090§,0'1'1&,"|'@1¢¢ 1 PLM_ CENMH'\X\€-éa'r10a:§\m Ld) u)mw£)’lm, h)m:) le éomcr%’h€’m¢? Acwms'{
\£ou\T\xv/G\ML'» (someTo_ Bmuwc~,l»\mf)m%dfl"M/§/WE,% , '
Fms'l Y)Ul/ms,%ws Am" DNA§ F/wa,ms”bv mm
`£oor>\ Owu. D\~{k E/Qms,@vm~£'t mva "llwt' SK‘{ bd \L.a. B¢;,
Cz)mu>mn 55 F&r:c. ,~ v `
T\Am,/)e,u,m'r "l'm.o L\n§ A'l+!om\\wTO ASI<_Tet;/§'IML\F utu
C»>uu>§lcrr\ ?0&:"1"1)(§,(0_‘€%6@~11wam;)r Hkb 1911me s'i;q
Oww.o (LR 15 A¢>LB| )' L¥a, Cm f§mléwn SA¢m 'mm UFFM
LUM., kla> l.or~\ m" DM ’\LaL/Tx@w” An~\n fm wme €»<\r) "`[P % v DoM
TMau,a Lh" P)o/:
'HM_ 1419 `5 mom-wu mass ucopw§. DH ’l'aw, D)' A;~\r) E)~# Pmmu~w 001 TM,D\$WUP»\~!,..le A@szl'o Paovbh)um lrkn,kbs¢e
Mklmé¢mm FMMf/L'aez,Da~a OP kle £amam`
’l'ew,,bappa,wkl~l'l A;Powmz¢% watsz Rz,Prr/T¢%\vzaq ve O¢¢ '
Dr»l»wvu~uffb Lo'o D\rr¢,& f>r-M a_~r flaxman \,\e,.v v b v ' _ '_
5 lr’Tvcn/Lou¢>cl u_)u,L`P¢,u<<_.s/TMWNME, OP( L R_\l? k¢>zvao ).
*'l”ms le PM¢§ DPTm/` 6154\¢.}5,'1/\'\0110¢4‘70 Dwa". lm’”[iaa_ ,, *
.?JN> p)'w UNDL&T&@ u'mauce"@ka/K£r&ou`\~mf’kDA .
bba Lu'l'lm cg Frcom,Taea, Eomm,uwae¢m’;
qu
, ?kmuz,s¢_‘u\ S'c»amc,k&l> m_koa, FROM‘T%\LMBMM Bl,ooo OF T\z\:&,
_ Cnmm.x\méw ANDTL»D B)uw\w Sw~e>sComMHmar-THLDM\)M%
SM_`a\/k Smouz,s [UFM,TMHSFMD'TQ T\»re_' loan uer -
Lma.mor)¢f FORDNIX .£r>uuuurl 0015,600$11>\~1 Pc>a,aw/Dw’r \Mou>nm Rz/Fo M k /
NomamDZ)O‘-USEOS N A/m Or~l'l'mz, €L)mr>¢,.bmr> "Fm-, Commlm,)¢~a 10 .ZOo§ low'uc(m\z, Fomaslc,_ ,,/,
Rrwom* 67155 />.s/m<`mp'fon ND l,Dl`ltJ/E,& mmr/s W\u~`HmM OF k ./
"6’1»<1.\~101>4<17 W\o.L,kl\\i\'IAN-‘{;
B\_M umw NDL\) E)be/DW\P." TL&F/@Dm PL,A¢\N wm Bwoo
OP T\w€_ompa,e<\mkm " DlssApF,/xr\s E,N Roam£/ F¢Pac>m“l"wz,
\kous4o»?ouc,z,0¢,ver Cmm\;, mamman le Auor~l, Buc,r/M, §wws me-_w
nn
E)P\m/lm% §11\11111 5141\000 111/00 RWMM, 66011>00 ,
1940/0011'00 FRom ”[1~1 \?011<,01~1 PP~om/ 11 60014(4_0&6 Rzu»\q,\\rw
611 65/2,@1/05.'
P00».1¢10Rr-J>0& [.5/101`070 (6{413“1L 61'¥53) 1014 le pmm/l
60600010010~1/1 001‘1‘ 01= 111010\0~11 No 030‘1‘156051\| UN1>100
T1101\011m110 61> 60990011011'1 Nmmwu, le T 110 |Nv0H1oa~/”
01'1’\106010110 699/1101 601001100141»1 T»\0~1‘ s HosPH/KL 111 P\00M11)1~1 ’Fo ‘\' 1115 6600. '['110 ls ’1'110
5000`\11\11-11~1100\1 ”’1'1`11(1 1110011000'1’110" 141101)11 601110 '
1111/11 143 Fmv\ (1)111011 6 611111~1011¢<1> 1164 W\Ao 0 F611 D 146
_61~1110\1~,13 “l"um 664 500 50600»1'10~1 D14<1100/11000
?1_01<00 {3\\/0 _.‘)TNU\' ATT_E,NTIOM "|'0 110/mg N 660
60 ‘\'110|11\10~1'10&~1 0161 \4001"1\|'1'611,110 510/1013," NM
156qu 66501'161_,.['10)/“ 6 l§~\own 5601v1¢ 51066¢,."[\16'1'
Ue\u> Ew 60401»11¢1_`,.” P001>140,R000&'TB (CR \?)5 60079)'\'1>11€ le
, P1¢001 61>'1”110601>1>011110114 NAN\M 100 OOH
U1~\Dc01=\"\)1‘>1°66 1'-1_1611 610(?')1:1001~100, 61’\0'['161115 L*Ll."l;kLs
\6’|'1<0\1~1\1101~1‘106~1' 631’/ 6\/100_11010[30'11~10 PNvPNR06 Ft):’([')@.)¢\~l¢,i¢116w `
T@ `11>11,111100~110" F66®M6 611/110151<, 6N0 601/1106111661\1.
141/m46 3 16 \00~1'111¢100 6< 6 §/111<'11~101<61> mwrr, Frmm
Nu>mu B0001> Lt‘rrz,m 140 F&m»\ Tm. 6001@0611~1-'_161~1'1 BRHA61~1` 066051060
111011\ NY 0&6" 140011115110\/1¢ §11110.§ (.\10111 6]” 501/1060
"I“We T0x1¢4 611100N011‘ 5 60¢,191’100[>006 [\101 06061°_¢<1_ 50161%011'
5001\10$101¢00 \1~1 110011>~50)1 11606441101:1 501001001411$
11 111T110,6op00011111‘s 601>0‘1”11111‘1'110600¢\1 11)1~1.0 60010
T\zcos'\ \1'7\`110§11<,'10 U)Ia1<11001¢00\01910 |09111111 6161-1,1<»106~1 "U;u 1"15 1 6ng 1001 1016110 £5?_)-,
'1'1110=,061107. 100111100110 16 1301111>1111 11)11'1116 001111 614100¢1
001"11.1,-510101) F\r>F06-1‘1, 6011/1611/11111¥_1101\1 6110 110060_191.6 ‘1'1.011'1113/'
19001001)110,1,601501>0106-,130»100 111/1111 16,11?,005,6110 (1/11<,\1 _
§1,1065 , 505100“1”1101¢60'{ ‘1”1101@\0 16 N0'R01:0001100'Fo 611~/
` §161116)<60 1'1'\000?110¢11141101011 5000 0 1 110111_10 1"_')1'/ '11166611101,11111‘16111'
Bru‘r'tku~l 51111111'," P1.01-110111 500011061)1101 L1100_00
601/10101 -61111'111. 6111111>1.0/1~11>0. R01060100 6)<1111>00,
Ra,c,wu Fm>m: 111 1300¢,011 60011151'. 6001-\100110 1 6001/1000 611:
05/2.‘1[ 051 _ . ' , ` '
"1'11151»1 1111000;11011151_1' V\11__011)11 111 611)11001<1. 101160"1'0/1`111<
651?60611>100 61111)0100.6110 1500010401'1 1165 5001~1 F1000
111”1110 01»11010 01'1”1101)14_’1610’1 600N4 190 1160016 60011/1~{,`1”000‘~
1111 6050111V160M1011 607101¢1<‘»170111)<0 600106 '
61111111 111000~1 \1‘.’5011116011 121‘1 1131 '~177. L1 611(51'11001<1<16)
"14 11 1110105'0110110"11111§1 *f111$11¢r011'1~104 60111100’1?:> P111,s0111
Fm_¢,s, E,v100110101')11 611010"1'110?00001111(11011 6F_F11<0606v11>01100 ~
*1'0 60 U1~_100&00*161>.” 500 6101-.,10 V. 1111/100 511¢111_/,,"'105'1)51591153,
511 "7~6‘1.7651`1(05 1 31 L. 60. 211 1011 119701 61111111 1\|61>110\/1 111,1'111015,-
300 11521,11, 751$.01.1175_. 3 1_01>.111161(1‘-’15‘11 6110 111001101
\/.11000111>_111"1,‘1‘1 116 103 6;~6+1. 311 7@11,.01> 7‘11 (1¢15_5),
111 6001/11011 To 111¢11110 DU.MM§.D 61~111 6000161111*( -11_1111<`140 011/011
6111 DPTW\§ 61100110011\1¢111@016110 ;‘F1211._L010 601/1 611 111’1111016
wm 1 0011111'1115 601-10 1026 710 116/0*10<,400 610 1011011011.1>
DN6 'me 56111?005 1'1 111/110 1111/904 1.61,01¢0601'110111'§»?059000610
111401114011111)064101101:011*1'11011 10 1110/011’\1¢,'11¢_1<011 6 601/1111 06110§ -'
15001501;01¢1.-611600. _ -
__ ’1'1111'1 11 66661.1)'1011\11‘/01101000?&001= DP FA¢L§\F10D-611'1001100
11)111011111’61111 Rmovn,s 610 6000_1010111 01> 61/0011 P1000 611
6110101100 111‘111106'11»10‘3 170-11 00101'1,11/11 1111311‘/'( 6000/101
111-
D\sm&,b l'le>., To pran 'flsw» h)R_bNMuL.-\,' CoNvle/~'uol\!.
_?MLR€,@UBKU’E> (C,P~l'lQ. .KP¢SI)'PA<@ b DFT\KLS"¢ma/’s
Mmlo\~\*l.”oDmY P‘l“o ’l’»w,ln P¢»¢m
Cm¢Ne\_z/s Irhs Uev_, Dr»ujn¢ms Fm>m" %MM£//j<&o W\xoe/ sz>m
Kuowu E)wo\> DPTM Comvmm‘tw ” _*f’o ` Tm, 60 m¢>`_z,».m>-s; KMMc/L Bucc,m_ §wmz,s Laee,c,w
E)_F~\wa Lmrz,w) Barr'mw£ §m \'lw” Hu/Mlu, ONM laws L"VM/'
boo¢,'[wm Tlust¢L,emw E,v~mw@,a, (JJLu__ 236/iers srw. _
60 me’l'ms?olm Fowm. E/vs,e¢c mem ADAH f ' c)HU‘m,é
le } lkurm, Ov'msjm'nh rm CoN'tm._UL§
‘ To- QMP@BME,TM, L\L,E,Mpomw 7er AW\LM#§ Cou»tm»tm~
Dr/’[wb§'lmn/e mome DP"VM/xe Coo;/OPCNMM=L Hzowpuru,
hamm Z.Ol . Duzm.s OP Dle»uum P;140RHE_)€ AM\>TM, mlu,m,
DmlN_Dan@ /é\ lr\b l.,vrr mE§PTwz/\Ncmmmmmc¢
F»¢m cas TM'TM$ @x@osw £DR&L)M, Fosuw 510 L‘f\u@mmons¢
\»\_k'z 615¢>05€,0 ix Su.m'-I wmka R_mpm_§mo R&AuL/‘I_$, 301
_ E)rz,c,zusa, DPT\A+., |N\e,r/ u»c¢>P
E;vLoa,Nc,L¢ Nc>»t k‘$le/L,z,- anP~D fhaka Rz/PD&1,RW\NC(TMQ
Pe,uucr Cc)uNa,cz/w,o T'o P< f’/R.mem.bwwzz,,
Dov» Nm CARNUE,SMMMI BM OP td\uc¢w/r. ' .
`*”l’mf‘\`m»< `Prmnlm&/Fo ¢mmmeammw Ruuz, q 0 l. RMUL€\L€ P\ Pzz<'c><\4)<0104141104 k 011/1111 OF 6041001
11/\1<‘1 BwR§/&m@~lw’\b 171101110"1111141'1"1101110111 gmc/nmu 24111<1141_
14T11054w1001~101111400v40111‘1.."1106v0~114 1411'14110 Ll\¢i,11114011:1
14011111’1"111,110411014 01 §0101111v10’164111~10 k P@M 61114111 01
1104100~1 111061 1506/41400141110.”
10110_14\161410 1931 601 517?10
0014111110 *1'1)401101)4101~1 1300010 1301>4<14111110111 601110 105ch
k4 14" 61 14111041"\0 11141101¢4001|<110011 Bu>oo 1110111§11*1\001 1110
600140411114<111 131qu 61111111 "km> knle 0 k1 '1’110\¢04141910
'10411110 045@410311,100~11101010 ks 1500040 611)404 1,.1400_00
611111<111 51111411. 6441~11101 6414001411 k, pmpa/114 6111>4111 0461141001,1"
1101110v100, 11 6411 km> 1)0\04 6414'00141`¥,F440'11P100 6v1001~1010. "
v 1901/040 RM%{CR\\% 4411452), 60011.011 l OF T1110 514/1105
11111111011'1'0001~1 />\Dk 1141111»101~1 §14104` *1'1101)001041~11 14
1141 E111110011 Tp F011411410D Nk’f041111€v'.' 151/040 410 1114/11141400141/1
1414me44041v101 6v1001100£1)4.4 11400 1\101 01101 '10 C0H1411’/I,
1501 111 110111111000404 Uv11000“f£100)m114vu0 6011\/1011011,-
501051~'110 kvv0001<1~11 1500041~1 5001411\10 1>0%1 60Mv10110NRw0F
601141411411101 km> D11_11140110~'1 511~1010 2001 k1111 614 1114
0)111400_\¢41001\0‘[4 131400'0 410‘\1114 \/114401111'»01411144-11011114 ku
10101111011441_\{100141101~1 01" 114101101 BM4000% 11110014 .
'1'1447101044 1101141 11011411~14 10011000©11060011011 10 kurz/1110
"1111 5 1111£11111‘311110010 |‘-1111144010~1111110~114 ’{0‘1110 U"1111140
51441104 601141110110141
- le>< 11141111)1011 13014 011'{1-1 51410"111’11114 6440171\1194’1"04111~144
1044 130114014111411111 1005 1204 140110041011 170010001001 600/110
` LMARMDM kan 10011110010.”°1’1110!§;1>4>01_044111 1144 §0410111
1511 k P1>10p41111141444100 01¢'(11061/100100 601114111140 111 1110
' "(511101440 Rws_m”)o\\n 1344404401> 1311110§14;1101 10 1110
i|*'l
human Pmm. Dm>r's Cm_w\z L»d_sm~m' kuhva H:o mem PDL\c/L
Dm'e Panpm~z kan E,vmmc/e/P\oow\., |N ADo\`»rmN 'E'TM;/Fm.smr;mwt¢
DP E,vlowo£,‘\:kulfu! l»bSS COM“[MNNKI EDN 1 PKBéE/HM, OF '
Pm>s,\\ m m DP Cus'roo‘{. Aasq.uw 0\> PM_P¢A w1\¢1ws,0¢ ,
Pmms\e kwo’\'v h~l NE,F_A) 13 Pvaz, AN~HLHM `
' -Fuv 'P&ovmo. k quasonkw. l‘.uLe,l.\-woc>o Ol> R§,suc:rs "Hem kan
momk¢ouma, ANDPRMMNLTMM Tv Tu£,DmE/_Dr>l't's |‘.lunc¢. .
` \'1 U)MTMJRMPMMBLM»H OPbmpmN/im Com~l<,»u.To CORRw-M '
Amwn'H¥s/Mo'rw\~\ baum L¥mD\=JuOrz/M»m/Fbcu.u/LLTQ Do 50 le No
hour DPT\w-kcv@e u.)m/Ls.( Se,;;`, Arurumw'z Fom\zsup; No. _?.)- _ _
W\R.\»\zmnu Pm>`s\~( A'Paemn mm c,L 0 r>;Tmz, E/vu>wuz, {T\xz,'F/>\um UMA\M 613 "l`lw.ou cru A_r)o mor_~m`»\_
_ DNP&'Y\:,$'I\N&.” _ _ `
\4 \eTLk\'z/Appumvl's Comw.’FRL
Amworm\w> T\m wm|\\z .Vc,m/ |u 1005 k\m r~lm \¢»¢e,mumzo
Fb<\.¢,a, E,vmw a,\¢,, Rko°Eu/hmpwmer ‘s Ou)u Lm~zruo` blm L/\u>
10 km> BF._:[M~€F_D R'\.s OWH wm*-n”l"\><&x>,r¢, bJe>uL_D Ni»vrb&,l;¥kn
Bwu k C.nN\/Lmlo\~o \r~\ Tu¢b Fm_<..~1_ Pz..ku¢,. A'No N@. 2 : W kan 511 NM 0011_1
l'\\~.. FMwaz/‘\B D\su,040 E,\cwr,v»domr Emom~\;.z_,, 501 511 1311/1 \41~100111111
1010 10101-11001»11. k110mo1 “10 101 F1101 £0010011¢1_€,)<1:01_90100_~1 v
E,vm ¢.)1~100 kv 1501 Fr\o_m/lwu 50 156110~11 110_ 1131/mm d101=Pr1,a_1'1_`0 k/= k _
131ch 131/3001 01'1'110 101100111001)<\_. 0000111011'1 le k0101111,&\1‘101.1<1 1011
0110\1»¢ 91111<0 1000 ku0101)<110,3‘1 10 5, 00010101_. 0Wms10u.
" |_)01000’1”11051011)10 001011_11011,\1_1010 T\M»)Fa_e»m 001101~1 110
61100110011)111011?00v11>vs‘\'wmkpm00u Commrcs ku 131>1111<.011¢, 140101111010 `
Tme\ ku 1111101101¢11001 00 DvP\um_Pmuu>\u£r la 1300101010 00111 17000110<6
11000500\70100111‘) ku~¢Rr.wm>,~ 130000111111 00'111\11011)1111/ Ku0c1)1,1.000
`0011'4 14111:>1»1~_1 kuc> M110\N10u1 10 kFrz001 'H0€00050 000011_0010(30
Tvc¥vluvm#u 011-1 1001 0013000000111 0 IFT%LJHK Bmwa!£ 7001‘71111401~1 011
Pmeou'>Bmm/e'l'o 11)11001 ku M100MAM1< 110 Fé 101110101\11.1110011001 00131100000101 01”|'11011 1110
_101001\/\1¢1 krusc, [1)111:1111,0‘1”1101§<010& 1011111000 Tum 5000 bvu)c.uu. -
knew ’\’11100011~.0010011‘510101\11/010011011 00 130101,01>1)10.’"
|.\Jm_ormp V’)'rmm, 1151 510 3055\153 Z(‘Taickrép’fc,nm blow kP/>.5‘1,
kuo k2101,1 1015 ’1'1111100=1 0111101.11111010 100?1<01
'r'wer 1101 00101 1010 ADk` 111<010»1011 k110011>»11110"l"0 kFrLM 1110 _,
0010001001»1<11` bmc/1110 P000001>1010” 501 Musku k000m1>1_100'
lu k56001010305110011)001,o E)0Do014100 101111. kWn/u-Mn . 1
'\'110'\'0)1015 Pn,\um, iam kuummw 300110'01 37 D‘?,
131um 010 11]111)( 001¢1<011101:1101 0 Puu<..wm. Ev 10 114001 S1m10 ‘
(001 k P00sou forum 119 ku 13 111040 \F Kuoeu 1010'\`111<1 ku
lu\rmmc¢A/lmu D&Dmc,mz. PKD00001010 11 1301101010 OP; 101 17000110€6,
(1),k\:11&0'0041001'¢, 00@00100»11.6150~1~1 1300000 D001)m0011 00_
111 _
\
'Tmm,» ld\'wc \N'ru\'t"l'o \mr»Ma. H"s \/.w‘r 41 LwleiLi1"+’ DR
bavku_kmuw I>\s E,v mmc/rp m"l"'wc,_ lwe/511 emma O¢L.DF¢lukLmem&;-' ‘
DP~.,(?_), Mw u)me \N1w1 % ch-Fuf¢ Tws_£ma:z.
Q¢\Du»re.o`m\z,. OQ/TL§bluth lawton [3?~6¢¢1¢.1¢¢1. Pao e/o,s.ou~w "
' (c§:. ku Dwm$\;,UNm€u©élL»noN (,0.)' fe DS`FILLON‘\' DPTt-\§J;'>Rb DL(¢RLF_,.
_ Du Pwa, [CR\ iq RWSZ), PQDP< L\;mc>'c'on‘;'rmm 1a TM/Mmlod
Rmur.a'cmer £’,wm To Du~\~l D\~lk”[wm £», €wlow I.,°, T\A'&.
Du»mmw le Nm wm L,Lo To FoamN»<@LL Poa A Rmso hamm 17a/mem
"l,'o kela`, P<¢`» l>\ 3m DLMFMM DFHLMné/R,S\Aouw K!Dk
\Nc¢r-_A W\.` L\xrv\Ho¢~\ E)E. bule Tb Pm»uc.&/ \_km ?” ~
kDP;"\/¥Mnmw 61)<4§/> s"'l'vce,’D\‘/r»mom (L)<\~mo'r Wlu;r
. 'wae Bom>m." W\&. \kwv\P/mu b)ou\,o .B lame \me//>T¢> Rmx daemi DN*I'M, Cou\~l€u.fb@ammw "E> kim B~e ’Exa, v
l?)D'rH Dmr\m foam OP Mxis Couu44ffr>¢xé. ’l”u» Am\wlw la 611-w A‘F!lu, CBL)MM
_ wm P\LL) ma crew bowman Mmu,gm am 5 flu, Apmmu
T\,m Covms As?lm ' 55 lu’fuu&§e,mek Fo&d'u§'rla@, Nm No'l
DuL.~{ DDMTM,RP@M% mem 'Fms Dum>m, \)spJ\/\_xs
Dvmwlxm.vv\mcfm 60\1¢2<55£,0 H. \, _
W\a,\)cr»mmnu films OM B~c’§'rmmcr! him \FTm/Dlwt~ -
. Rm.»<:mm{?.vmwwh)m"mmw\m 70 DNA< ”Fm11n&'»sz¢woM41
F/><\ m To 61)<01».-¥\|0&1)02/, Dca,, Evu~l _éc;um i/\e)w .AH~J Pms mm
KML_M U)mu> E,xc./L)L;QKILWMFMMTN$ C&lmrv{’ ~ _
.KR\;MQ\\K@L£,PW:N {’_ou\,o ks »C` dam E_/xe¢m w `Dor:,
MA.HMPMN mem b_)mm RF,'_S'IM m "’l’m_/ mm -P\m~z>m tv T-o”l/HE,OPPIG\LL RLLOV~D
\¢, 541»\¢44)><01&\\10 l\\\ Ew./PMMQ wm 0\¢"&£5,€1»¢1$,"['\)<2,<4 -I s,
Exm'l FoAONu/Kr)f Plu/L .'.l.`wquNut Lr¢L `_ -.
Tm‘> ("424\144104 1024 1404 Ru~uvw E)~r HFD Pmm~¢ /§;HQE)/M,_
14 like N04 Rxwmvw E)‘f 'erb \WD CMMUCBRMOM, |‘( EL)MS
1404 R@wvm 64 1144 F0m14410‘Vm41u4 meoaw lomlc¢mu
\1~1\’/¢244 1T\k4/VW wmc/4 Tum'-r "’"L'oo\a 1414 5001/1000 Nom
' C1401rv14T1104 N04 01101 D0T1104 010490444444\4,114444 4244
NE,\/mpc>%n/>’mo \4.
004/7 |’\/\01 141<01¢401~1 4 040 DPTM1M00044 ’F141<4 MM
ND §01~1441[1~\0102<4&,'1"102<4 44\§1~100)4 115er RM>J>DHM'/ Lo THL
_O._HL‘1’ 914/044 Or/ EM04401044T12¢<4P<£L01LD1111;/‘E>T 114/0¢9101.21_
Rv wm 14 YY\1:>411~1@?
\01 F\r40044 214’1`0’1'111'4§1400110 k\m 6 PTm/$4K4rz/mm4*i4m
mcmahan/4 VV\& \341<41/1<>401~11&+101114504444121»10#40004 M14411~119
Evlomor¢,"mkt L\-lz\‘> No'r§|muuw 440£11~10»¢~14 lelL,e 10 SLtow
N01\D014,4 446va kuma»li, Ucom b;\w 9044L004,RMU1;[ lilan
blmme ¥\1~1 me'le¢s 6P\1m£,.
No.\'. R(z)mmu> Fo&Tm€owRWML
Dr» PRMMMN@ ANo Fu,uwr k 9044 6000/10410\4 Wlo4101+ F0RF01<4_N141(’4
901&'[144411142><1210\4 140 P1;01-44 DFTRLM@umw 4 le 41<10
0440@¢101 1410101><0»<4110&14144001014 /§4124101444 64 01 (Q) (M),
h)\>¢ou 5404144 |1~1 P¢>!"*2144 101 150440144 OFTM/
mls/1104 ”
'[1214&1='@4411,21~14 l4 w_nuAm 0:4T1x1<4 ’V 1244 \1~14141~141011111_144
Dc-,r»~em1v44m0410u P114440 001 1504 wm uJ124 D00m1> Fm;
'FmL,L)RBTMjDM \4 MK‘SFM,LD.
010 74‘ "|'1.>:14?04000 1ch §41241411441~1/ W\D<
140<\114>401~\ Dovs N041J¢111£r mom/'TMce OFTML
/'lxw>.w¢ k -
CeN\-n'c:l\om DPL,F.J>< E)k¢S§), _
Pk¢;a/BBr/TWLMMLON *lfb Duw, Smmm~£§l, [’.0\~&;,¢_0610\~1_.`
hamm kDA~l)mw/mn L's 51@51%09$1% town L&/L/,»¢z,u»¢~m's Fku,un,'l'b |'V\wl"~Rn,Q mmm~l-»r< "` DF 'chs
Coo\€/Dx>£mmu\lm. Paoamunz,' P<\_ar,»osw l»hms up IXHD hhs h_)L¢_Ln~lmi/é§
’l`o Pm>»,c{mu, ALJL[N Nm ~DNLY’FWL'FA¢L$lP\;A/um~e 0\: Evmmu.' _
' Bm TM/CDN f',_c_~AL,m`m'f Dr/ E,Vlm:,Ne/E, FM/omL,B/TD “Mn,
- ‘l>er/;rm.a wmawa Commvm.'§ur>m,e,mw/lmmu Ot>\'»he bmw
E,vlowc,e, AL¢MM¢A ans§,u"»,\:c)rakbb< L\reTmL km>\w..m'c. - \ \
` "\'\§Ju€»\ KE)M¢D\€ Vus marlow P mm § \’r‘$ PO%LSSM>H;
(Z),. ‘[’m/ b)vr&».run E,vlomu.\e Fz>¢/orum¢.@p lukLTmM,(OAPaoomu\cr) U)bm_p Rkvs_,B&,bH
,D\-\=r/FMK"_CFHNC, U.)E.BGV 51ML 251 511) 50110°1111‘-4('1`&,& Ck\m
- 1110 '2_007)."1"11¢\'1,&11>¢,111, 1’1111¢1 Bn/an,ma611/50011@\011101.
91qu lmsw.m\vn,O¢ 1111/6000 FA1111 D& L’).Au,ze DFMMML¢LULDU 1,»11))<1~11 1416
F\Mom‘hw 41. 40 A/. Wskm \/. STML 435 511431| 403 "40&).
1111 1111.14@ zoo 1).” mm umw §1111, 305 511 31311,
. 111
1714141&.&1:0141§@4109
104041>01,411<111 11)11.1.1\111v\10\_y PWT1114 011`1141 10 lm@wmmr
'11451141)01111,110 044 A` Dubpmess 504011)41\1>‘; 041-10 P\uug, 011 1004
C/».<.ae', 145 504/1031 094115€, 1110 A@p&LL.xm 1444 6111)1111~1 15£,~./01~10 ANY
, 11441>4401114014001101 04110 111 N0 0002,1419411~1’1"51411/14 140141<4
540111400 1411 15110141110114 00411411011011 01 €1'1141101,01110‘1111, ’1'011<1_
Dmm_ 011415[)110?1<00044 lHF4101LD 11141~1110111<1'_1,1 UP01~1 1411/1
15va 0411’0\1~1111\0111 01¢ N01 014\£, 1501 Tu)o 0\110141191’5 111140 001101>
, ,1\101110111;170441011/ '1'14141111111?041’1'11411151.4v04’0> 114¢0_01511011 '
44019~1\1\ 4401/14 0414\1'414£14 141111109411~1’ 1410 1015111111£,011. 1500
0414441111‘11111 1311 \561155” 411<110"7_)
'1'1,\15 04?1>0944' 005 1101 151/011 '1'01141100 011 1110FA1,1 00 1110
’0004 15114111 Dmu>¢ 01¢ 4111511`04, 000/170 1114 \111@1401>014 AHD
11_1.10111111»110 14011) 0120<11011 01 0 11111114 01 1110014 foam 01 1110
100111 6001011<1.1)1511411;1 Coupd OF 140141415 1100111~€,'1'5111<4. 0411
0401411,111€,1\1 01»"1'1414 04541?11<014’1”0 111€/‘1'041/41. 000141 11111_1__ 0111.‘1’
131401,01101111011101/119401,4, '\111>41_ 01 CovamH F011110 0111:01_41¢140
Evmem,a 091111\101511<1~111. ‘
C1111~114 K£UD/ \/. 61941£. 21 ‘-1 514}311 5071530 1 1014 APF04115111~12000)
" '1110011013400044 0001140 01”51‘111,1“1111 01111£111>1111_111 ‘1?>'1'1115,
11111100 5101§;) 001151111111011 RE,&L)\RE/.) E,vuw §11110 Cmmml_
Cm+v\o 11011 10 1510 501=1»0¢41£,0 151 E,\/\c>u~l£,£."mM 04 Rmcbum_
TK\F,RDF 1501/1 COL)LD 010011/1 014 §11¢?10111,111’17> P&ovc, 0414_'1'14& ~
Eumeu14 0P1110 01101141€, 001sz 1301/000 01 Rr,/x40111> 3°17 06 5501<130‘1, C10 5.01.10100,
' 25 1 130 21 308 (1‘170) F14104\1 5010 135151117.12‘1£§,1
1502 (’1€,>4 11le APF 1(1‘13) 300 112,)4945 P A1_ 1_00£_. 2. 01(1.11&51 2003)
1111<140 \/ 511<10 11 5 501_51 2714 271 049<1911140 2000 1110
R111._11105 110 01~\1><110 01~1 ..
"UN'0014 1141/1411 04011_1411)11101111 '1'110'19<41401>."1'110011041_111€,
l`L|
' 100014115 10 0011510_014041_1001 711101§v100000 111 11101010111 10041
F94101>414010070 7110\('0?40101 0sH0 1)011/1940\1110 1P04Hv RMlL)HM_/I`£lm
011:0401 0001_00 1104\101:00110 0010110 01 140)44011.14000 001101011_1_01
7110 0550111111410010011111114 01 111001101140.” 11waso11 \/.
\/114_011111>4 11‘~13 115 30714151"1 ‘1‘1 501 2781 0110£0 20 500
(\‘17‘11 5241100?45 \/ 519410 1101 510 301 919141 020(7014 0141111041>@
' 2003) CANJ£NM \/ 51960 30 501 301 304 337 7071=014 Crum
l041>1> 20001 Kw100100 1000141414140 1\101 F9<01 F111 011/1145 0014
140104,14711041 01 04 00071100444 41410011»4140, EH50mN0 0111_1 700
K411000u11 0171107 1141014 01 Fk014 F11101110 00 1110544011'11941_
5000/1001 017110 0FFENSLB'01/o110 04F\`01450n 1411110101)00 01 ” 500
11101010\/ 5114140 755 511 211 000 0071101 01111 1411 1100
' 7110 141)1101.014111 14 011101 7141111117> 1410111010111 771'15 _
140110141410100 000141' 5 001111014111 " 11 15144100 011 0\007110£\/1001100
04R014401~1140101 10101000 4111141 111041 6111014'191\11 04 141/450 11040100
D01101 0171100011110041~11'5 011)1101, 00 0171<010045 1200011405 771/151
M0MFM0 0\11001>401/11404411101101111111 01 0122101119410 / F15110P4
351510 20 0941 002 00011110 N9414\/0412\/1 51/4*10 070511) 211
11151"125(70)4 CP\_\w\ 04111> 101‘121 500 04150 6001/040094 V 510410
' 152 510 311‘~15)4-1 '-1‘1(70)4 CNm.AW200“1.1R001/144011 \/.519410
110 510 3111511141105(70)4 001 0404111~1 2001:>) 01111~11;1 101415011 \/1
519410 917511)21190‘1141 3"1(11(7014 Cmm AFP10‘1177110100149410 '
501110101101 01 F0\/1001100 15 04 000411011 01 10901).” 0
- 04R0044011140100,7{14110111410 0014_014 1000100 150 001&0<1400
151 711071411410 0011141’ 4 1491101011114 01 11115 0050 17001441150071\/0
0414141111\0111 011144114/1”c ‘1 0010*5
_ 740 C0014/1 09411 0<1050 §00711141 111 0100111011 70 7710
_ `1‘111011105 011¢14015 154/1110 0<01007 10 140100 110 011410010110110
11111_1<1400\1014, 11 1111<4 001 0101)410 01 014014011011 F01471107111914
1?.?_ ‘
5 fook/1510 1100 0010100’|"110/11 1316 60011 500 1100 mem 1911
' \%01'0 5
F1m1uus 0 1101 \/1)1\140111105/5<11101’0 1100 P\HD D101~111\/ As k
001>¢1 11100101 010 DM/Rw\0101101.0 U11001»\'/' 1110€)1<1110
' 51»110111\0~3 010,0110/5<110?»<0101><060010101101. ” Fm_w \/
011100[)110?)1<110 Hk 585 510 311 bL1L1(’FewaL10051011(11D111)
101?_)
\\101 010 010 \00F1001003 0?1:/2<01 |11011000110@1301;01100,
151/001 511101_0131000 DP 01/1001~100 , BP, 1'_0111110014.00, 0111¢0500,1 0000100 10002<1.1_1, bow ‘ _
N011k11\10,1~lo1 0110511101.0 \1011/1,\1 lu P\H\./ 0)1\11711101~|1 10 509106011110-
1515 11va \1\/>111`1 LLGHlmMF_-/ 010&101¢|_,211.) '
011111< FoLm’-=` No 001001100 0\»11.1_01~105'11)'\'1101,00<0
'_5011¢10101101 0 1110[‘/1/101;1100 mm A1~10 mm 01101 50 51)-‘]1/2<111100
10110111101§1,¢000 91601.0¢,06 ONE 001110F01_100101110 5111)/1110116: -
' 101 k L0111@1_010 Am0110, 00 E,\r 1001010 OP P\\/\m_ Fo<01. (b)1110
001’<1 \¢1 flamm 151 RuL£/} GF 000 000 101/1001100 FP\om 1111/1110
1 1000111 151110 01101 01/1001~100 01;001<1100 15 1701/001 V‘11/10 010
(C1T000v1001<100 010/mw 10 001/0 A<\/11A¢0 001 16 No W\m=\z,
‘ T\xku A mm 501><1~1111_1_.1>¢,11)11100¥“0»<115/11111¢1’ Juams 0)001.0 .
|'\1>1\10 10 [10095 Tum \/11)<1_ FAUI$ 01111 00 (J] |110€/v101;1~100 l
0411<01151106 0)1~11.1_06 1v01__~_1 TM/GPFMH 0 OPTm/\/HA 100<011”
_ \:0100~1 \‘1 131 [,1<50'1\11>¢1 le 1300-1 0 U$w H01 500)1<050 l1 511110115
bu~\~r 01111001)1<100100141101 01>'|'110#1@01;01¢11 5 0<",0, 301
Exwe\vw |0611010 L\ow_‘H)(\s V0m 0>01111»\)><6 Ru\.w 011110
5010 1000 163001 ASTHL AWez/u)\1 1 1110 /)§?1 L\Ll/\»<65K116F11,1) §§1_1. §ou&OP
'§1)¢¢?\\.1,€11111§1,1) LF\\WF\\Q<, §§110 bca 600»1,/|11&001»11§0@1,’&116
». l Cam§k¢.\°\uum BLHMLLY,TRLPMPURr/mww FDRLMA¢L
\1~\6111>1'»11,111,1~1¢,6’ i6 P'\e,m) mm Bv `JL)D@¢/Mm~\ §01@\T111/§§n°ru11m1”
TWL l§§we.LL/xm l»\b¢c. §§1.6.0 LLM McDouerrTM TM/)'rms./
` [»\1><6 \{1_01.1<1m TM,§ P11=§11 017 '§11,€//|€,)¢1¢4 CODE, OP Cmmmm_ _ 4
_ . Pac)c,wum-J §§Mm» "L.Ol Du'1111~6' 01> D1611>§11,1 §1101'»~111)1$1.11)110
1\1<11;\11011<111> m1 V. 1111<1§111110 373 116 133'(1%3), 1101
011L~1"\11T111,YY\011011 Rmuu;#m~m Lou@<~r_ To De/m Vo¢n
Couv\mmu 'DN/>§'\’MM 1111,'?)1>1 111 7111,611<11/'5 §1110111116 OF §1<¢1
|11/111§,\31».1»1 1111. 0FT11~\‘V\1111011, D§HQ 5111£,1¢/’1'1111, \/W \110@,1@»1 1011
01'/'|'111¢. L,/><ée,.
61111111 \»\1><1111>1011 \(161)611@ 3b 511) 3d Q)O?)M 612 (Te,>c
Cv§\m §§w ZOOZ), Thz, \wmpv\n§c<11011 \6 5111\&1,1,~1 D1FFri/Rf,111 §Rom
~ 'Tm, §/01161111)110111><1. R»§r-\m<,w, Em&§%r\om> 3b1 001 111
» '\'e>me Ku 1114 OP P§P@eu_mr, Pv\o owuae R_u 1,1, -"W 2 (O) ’Fo
F\uo Re,vmsmu, F/P§MP;UNDK Bmo\f §110 Baec,w, .A .
» DUF,HMm W\u<'rt 5 1101§1 Titm.'£‘ l. '/1`11551@<111,§9<11.@ /1:'> D\sc.t.o‘za
§/v\’omcj/ Rz,cre§m)w% 0FT1)1'1,PA0611,¢,01101~1’6 Gooo §£<111)1 6a
E>b 51/11>11,110@\6§1§Mo §§ 'F)¢1 161/1'1)¢111\11/16 §§ .
P\:»Mme<1_ 11)01)1_0 R»1011)1>101<111>11 01T110 §1>1>1=_,10§111'6 111011011|¢0&
17061 0011\1101101~1§01<01~1110 DH/X’l'1061111£<1 §§ 1\100) 011/00 111
'111060100%1011 00 00111011\01§§1<106 11)1111111 1110V1<0100010sz
01¢1001 1001=§101110 §10011¢16100 001)1§1 l§§1>1>0111100 000111110,300§1110
§11)§110 01\1 1010 131 1101§111101111011§1_ 0011001>101/110111 01
"111050 10060600 §§016, 601/1 §1<0 5010110 1510§01 11110 000100§§10
00/611100110110131111101011{0/10011110 111 000000011§ H§§m 711
’\'1111, 1191»01_00111 1. ’0110 0191>01.1,§111 1/\§6 01019~11111000111101_1/ 5001>§66017
§11\11’05'11000 15011011~1.
` '§11011§&10 1106 151014 0011\1>0011000 B‘./ ’1'110 130011><111 511§111
01'_»'1"¢0\"'§1190060111§11011 BY 1§\01 01101501 1010 00RNJPT AHD
111161.1§01110,111101111011 110 §1016 015001/0§11011 011/1010
L10011600 01110111101/6,111110 1»1§\/0 0400 |1110`011101§1_ Rw>no " 111 A
1111<010101)6 1010 1700:11)0101111_ 11/1§11110§, 0m1111111`T110F§01 01 y
000§00~€ §§0611100, 1111611§110000, 00111§111111§1111:>,0011/111101_110,
001110600,1\110 1111<1~11)1§011)§00 E,v1001100, ANoT110 |11101~111011§1,
0m16610116 §\1<01\10111111051111§1 01 1110 1300160§1>1110 \/100§110116
111/1110 1311>1>010§111’ 6 001161111111011§0 A111) 011/101§101116 A110 §1§1
0110§1111_11611)10001,0011011011011 0151)61100.
_ 11011) 10000’13)1161 01\ /§§111 R0§¢1011§01,0 000101,§0§10'1’ 1110
- C§6015m’§0/ |110-“[1'<1§1. 000 1011 AF10&11111110611110 F1R61 11»'<1117
' "§11101)£191_0§§000 001101)01 AHDTWL 11111§011)1§011_0 Pw€$lc§c_
- 0111001100'1111060/111)0 111111~101’§6 1\§v01’1.0v1000'§0 71110§11>010@111
' §110'1'111<, \5101101<§010 00011, §§0§1115171101115001/05 _§111> 01§@001
11101’10 1100/0 0111~1* Fonm 01’&0)61 \1~1 011111’_ 0101101~1 1311/111 000101 '
115
0001.0 19065101)1" ’1'§1§_0.’7 -
03§01°\01"0§0 1110 §91>000§111 1111 11101.:1 P§§~€s” 1016 110110§§000
000§1 ’1§1<0 000 013110/1'1110 000§10‘1 01 §0'11011 §1/§101<0001'0’0110111
'~1<01110§1200 01 7110’1'0§§4 00005 01 §01>011_§1017§01§00§0 R111.0
511 113113 0§51.0(10 _
R111051 0 111 300001110111 00 R0v0§41<1 123 11)11011 0§10
' D\‘»m\ssu> 151§1061` 11)11011 '1'110§1>1>001.§10 000§1 Rw0§506’1110
1000 0011§1'1 0001111110111 §110 0§00§.*1'§0 0§40’10 0001111111100,
T110 0010111:1§111 |1|11 0011001’ 0’\1111 00 011011§§1<01), §111> 1110
130§11110§ 0§00§0§/'131101<01110111 0F 1110 l§1§1_ 000§1 11 11000$1§§1,
- 0§ 17101_051. Z( 1011 110000m0111 01 §000111§1_ 11111011’13110
' §0>001.»10 1011§1 17\1)110§601 § 1301>001110111 §110 0§1>0§1'11100010110§11%
§000111§01”11&01)010110§1111 11111 006100‘1’ 10051 50 1316011§§000 §110_
N'0Fu1><1110§0§00§ 0§300§01110111 0F T1110T§1§0 001)§1 13 1111004€§§1. "`
11 16T1)10 110111000 19101>0 0131111 §11’01,0§111 T11§1 T 110 110110§§010
0011§1 §§§00 1111111 11101§011111 00 11110 ' " P§ocpzs 11101011 le § rV\0§0
_ 0<>0$ 1000 11 1101 00017§000$6." ` 1
311/0 §m,LL§H'r 1110000’1'11§11§’1’ 110 110110§§000 001)§1 Fo§"l,'m§
11\061 0§§1101_ 00111100§§11011 Tu§r 0001.0 0110 01100 §110 Fo§ Au_
- T111s m 011111110111§1_- 1110011100.
//
1019
'C`»<§E, 1114 14.14.00;1344 m
C,m>;mmme DF §E,P\\nob
\T#MMLE)&RM 'l'om*‘ 151080§ 0 /m>w,m \Pa'o SL,DD l»\mm~e
fb&41w*11144 A'Fm,lmo Comm Cow 014wa Aa%u,eLRL=,POM€»\;,TD AH hamm E)R\@F 1444 BU,H Dwvn,rzm
`To T%@chb@¢ Du/o 11 AHoa/P\eou TH\L l'\AP\m C_011r14~'( D\s4r<1L4
A440KNM 144 llO\FWmm 501411,&)00, P\ous4o11’1be4, _
77OOZ O14T1114/ |14€/ lquAY K>P FFJ@RM&;’ 2015, B#l_) 5 I'Y\ML.
’FHMNKB¢VPM W'Y§(@‘BOSD
' />,W¢\ ‘_
.)
11141>\1\»
admin '
19/11\0@¢1\4{”@,@§
4 cuARGE_______ w a§§é£`%
/é
F l L
CHARL
ES
Di.\"!ri("AlB (_~(':A utu-555
MAY 1 1 2005
Tr'm¢ _ 7
sy- arn; collqu _rer” .
NROVED'BY TH.E COUR']`:
_ wage having
6-_//@§
DlSTRICT CLERK
10 Mk};§§j.;&©@§/
»<£»444[£#4
w MM,
@Q 1
(Sigm'n`rr_:_) Auor_n`_cy fur Dd'_r:ndam
7/2, jl/Lf\'~ 1543/ch
jj£wnl'~ WAM], d
1<1<=4)° '“ 735 Wrzp;
(Sr`alc)
, //211%BZ0
__ MW§O
(B:rr CardeFN qu_n_hgr)
“As a condition of release on bond,
all defendants will be required 10
submit to random screening for the
presence of controlled substances
Refus_a\ to submit to testing or
positive test results will cause bond
to be revoked
1 1
\\>1@5`?3
\1>151_1,3¢,5
CAUSE NO.
' THESTAEOFTEXAS
~1_§1\@ Q\N+ 54451_55
M,_§m Qa¢@& C/W(
___74 /7
5 § _: D1s1'R1cr couRT
vs_ _ _ oF HARRrs couN'rY, TEXAS.
11\1'01\4. 1 f’:\
- AGREED SETI'I_NC
The undersigned Co;un_vd busby ZJB§$ this ¢=_3§¢|5 R§¢\ for
man
z 1`Cn`y) 5 l (Su'x=)
5 (Signm'r=) Ancm¢_y fur D:fu_id:m
714 mw~»:? 351 42
¢sm mm I
]`)4 77591
F ‘ n
553 ,_
C“ARL D\¢\rlct “A(S:\":\ (7/3) 118 gjw _
1 211115 _ ""'"""""’"*“’
m 2 ' 5 ,7/6/@?»> _
/"'_“::::_. (an C:nd/SPN Numbcr)
Time“`"is co-,,nty 7
men BV'M
Fmsiding 5 n 55
<,L-c_;/ OS"
h¢emln'r r`~._'t' an
"‘4['\51'.'-. CSF:"5’ C559 Ui'; _.-_..\ 01"15'
a_{! defcc-:' rents "1»"'.’1` ne req=. lred 10 '
141`:~)7“11! to r»_‘ 7-.-;10.'1‘- screening for Lh‘e-
prc-se 1c_ -`~ of contrr:-Eled substances
Re-.- ‘usa| 0 submit to testing or
oositi".'e test res u_1_t_s wil! cause bond
:be rev oked
1`0`
HI_ESTATE oFTF.xAs 7 1 D.A. 1406 vam£a:loss_sss`
vs. t _ cns ramme No.=90357ss444.1001
. waoNE BERRY -41°49196_- BY: vM DA No: 00170_11'66
- . DoI;. BM 5-24-66 AG_ENCY~_HJ»D »
DATE:PREPARED_ 3111/2005 o/R NO: 030415605N
_ 7 _ ARREST _DAIE: 3/11/05
N_cfzc c"oDE; 1100 90 ' REL.ATED c~AsE§s,: ' . ‘ h cig
mnNY' CHARGE- sEXUAL AssAuL'r- camp _. \b!_a __,lPage AXGM
cAusE No. 4919_494 BAn.. sNe-Bem"’é.¢oc)@
HARRIS COUNTY DISTR.IC.T COURT NO: m 130 PR]OR CAUSE NO.-
.FLRST .SETI`ING _DAT.E=
l'N THE NAME AND BY AU'I`!§!ORITY OF 11{£ S'I`ATE OF TEXAS:
‘ me duly organized ama Ju'xy gram councy. rem twan in me Dism'cr com 011-lms comy, rem am in Hmis comry, Tew.
TYRONE BERRY, hermqu styled chc Defer:danL heretofore on or about FEBRUARY 25', 2005, did then and there unlawfully, ime_ntionally
and knowingly cause the peneu'ation of the MAI£ SEXUAL ORGAN of BR.ITIANY SMI'I`H, hereinafta called the Con)plainax;t, a pa'son
younger t_ha_n sevenmen years of age an_d not his spouse by placing HIS SEXU_AL ORGAN m the FEM_ALE SEXUA_L ORGAN of the
Complain_am.
01511111 115
11."`\.|1~3`1’,| ‘$
_ . . , . -. zao'~ FoREMAN
AGAms'r 11111~:1=1;1€1: AND mem or msmm - »
FoREMAN opm-camp JuRY " ` 7 5
leCTMENT n 7
'APX -LL l
,. _Ba==,
sine §§ §§._mhi`bited serua_l_ c~_tnjit_i u_¢i);
(F) TEX'. P`ENAL- CODE § 30t02(d_) (Birrglary of a Hab_itatio_li);
(G) Ti:x. Pi:NAi. Coar. § 43 05 (Coi'npelling Pr'ostitution); `
(Il) TEX. PENAL CODE § 43.25 (S_exun_l Perfomiaoee by ii Cliild); _
(l) TE-x~. PENAL CODE § 43_.26 (Passniar_r ar l’rainatiaii of Child Parrrogr~apliy).
Scctioi'i_ 41 l-.l47.l of the Te'x'as Governr'nen`t Code' directs this Court to order you to provide to a l_i_iw
enforcement agency one or more DNA specimens The'se mcimens will be iised t'o create a DNA record.
Accordir'igly, this Court OR`DE_Rs the defendant to report immediately to the appropriate division of
the Ha_rr_is County Shen'_f_t_’s Oflice. The Coort forther ORnERs the defendant to provide one or more DNA
specimens to the Sheriff‘s Oflice upon request
Th_e Court also ORDl-:-Rs the C|erk t'a serve a copy of this Order oi_i defenth immediately.
\l\
Notin"t~.'u§ititi§'f ' " k d 7 "` h Eiin custody t _ _, ,
H sCou'nty Sheritf’s Office `Hanis County Sheriff’s On°iee ` ` "" " g
Identitication Division Inmate I;lousing
1301 Fran__klin, l" Fl_o'or Testing _ 1201 Coniinerce/ 1200 Baker St. / 1207 Ba_ke_r S_`t.
Hoiiston, Texas 77002 Date /701 N-.- Sa_ri Jaci_nto ` Testing -
H_ouston, Texas 77002_ Date
The Court Oiu>eits the Glerk to send a copy ofthis Order to the Sheiiii` of Hai'ris County or his
designated representative
The Court ORnERs the Hn_rris County Sher_ift-’s 0£_5__c_e to indicate` in the space provided above the
date a suitable DNA specimen was collected li'om the defendant 'I;`he Coiirt F`lm"rr-iER ORDE~RS the Ha_ri"is
County Sherift’s Ofiice to return a completed copy of this Order to the Cle`rk"s OHice for inclusion' in the
Coiirt’s file. __
n Datesigned-:il§_ as §2$ d . mh
rings Preiting"
nemmers/cc y _ ' 7
;eouRT
Argument
A ' d b f 11 n APX 7
__ _ An'ers ri_e s genera y _ `
_ /o U_Wn /ro R_r_tet,ww Ru,om>
An attorney has an ethical obligation to refuse to prosecute a frivolous
appeal in re Schuzman, 252 s_.W.sd 403, 407 ('.rex. Crim. App. 2008).,1£ an
appointed attorney finds, following a professional, conscientious evaluation of
the record, that a case is wholly frivolous, his obligation to his client is to seek
leave to withdraw. Anders '0_. Califomia, 386 U.S. 738, 87 S.Ct. 1396, 18 L,-._Ed.Zd 493
(1967). Counsel’s obligation to t_he appellate court is to assure it, through an
A`nders brief, that a complete review of ;the. record has been undertaken and that
b<_wsl\xm Pc(.’) NM ll;~l N~H PD'-as law ll"lw»\ 13 »lcm:ut,l)¢§c emmm¢.
the re uest to withdraw li`s well-_founded, Id.
l q - TRLMD€MP.MLHHFW$W
A wholly frivolous appeal is one that ”1acks any basis in _l_a_w_ or i_n_f£t_.” .See _
McCoy v. Court of Appeals of Wisconsin, 486 U.S. 429, 438 n.'lO'-'(1988)4. A reviewing
court must resolve doubtful issues in the appellant’s~f_avor. Id. In the brief which
accompanies his motion to Withdraw, counsel must make references to the
appellate record as well as to.any applicable statutes, rules, and cases that lead
counsel to the conclusion that the appeal is frivolous Curr_i'e v, Stlzte,. 516 -S.W£d
. 684, 684 (Tex. Crim. App. 1974).
The appellate court does not make a decision on the merits of any issue-,
PX
except to determine whether an appeal is wholly frivolous and that there either
are or are not arguable grounds for appeal Anders v._ Cali`for"nia_, supra; Sta)j‘ord v.
'i/n‘l"m_{"nt|a_'{ q AR l'.`»iJM)i
State, supra. An appellant may challenge a holding that there are no arguable
grounds for appeal by filing a petition for discretionary review in the Court of
criminal Appeais. see Biedsoe, supra at 827-828, fn 6.
B. _ The appeal in this case _is frivolous
This A-nders brief only asserts that there are no legitimate issues to be v
raised regarding the trial court's findings of _f_a_;,ct,_.__entered on September 16, 2013.
' ames fo minfoallim‘icscc RJMo‘)¢,OFlHuu anita
/-')'
‘iil\'to‘ze,-i;kum l¢z'lltlt
L\lteu'i At. Crim.
App. l991)t Counsel is not required to make arguments that would not be made
on behalf of a client who has retained counsel for the appeal; counsel is not
required to make arguments for which there 'is~no merit. Cur'rie v. Sta_te, supra. If
counsel concludes that there are no arguable grounds for _appea_l, then counsel
should so state and should make references to the record, statutes, and cases
which support that conclusion. Staj'ord- v. State, supra; High '_v. State, 573 Si_W.Zd
807 (Te_x. Ciim§ App. 1978). When discussing the record, counsel must discuss the
evidence introduced at trial and must provide the`appellate court ‘*mzitl_i ready
references ton the record."' St_ajj‘ord v. State,- supra at 510 ri.3;- High -v. _State_, supra.
Conc_lusory statements in the brief are insufficient Anders v. Cal__i'fomia, supra;
‘ High v. Sta_te, supra; Currie '0. Stat'e', supra.
Counsel must furnish a copy of the motion to withdraw and a_ copy of the
brief to appellant and must advise appellant of his right to review the record and
to file a pro se brief. Counsel must certify or otherwise show the appellate court
that appellant has been furnished with a copy of the motion and brief and that
4
At the time of trial, it was known that the Appellant could not be excluded
as the DNA donor to the major component of the mixture (C.R. at 144). TheA PX[O:
statistical likelihood of the DNA gleaned from the major component coming from
an individual unrelated to the Appellant is less than 1 in 51,000,000,000,080,000
(c,.R. a1144)-. `
Though foreign alleles were found in the sperm cell fraction taken from the
complainants panties, a defendant cannot meet the requirement of showing that
he would not have been convicted if exculpatory results had been obtained
through additional DNA testing if exculpatory testing would only ”rliu¢d,c_l_y the
waters-.” Bell v. Sta-te, 90 S.W.Sd 301 (Tex. C'rim~. App. 2002)(th'e presence of
another _person's DNA at the crime scene W~ill not, Without more, constitute
' ' ` commits humanme '
t w _
n
affirmative evidence of appellant'$ imo€€nce)'~
.ln li ht of the facts available at the time of trial there is no a arent'
g ___T"~ aims/1 kem/imaginative filman
W§
argument by Which the Appellant can establish that further testing would prove
g
".
§§
exculpatory (C.R. at 144). Further, the Appellant failed to offer anything § §
C
r~ §
suggesting newer testing techniques existed that would provide a reasonable §§
l_r»,M-i E)eae's Ri,seeusis\mw P.' l
§§
Sta_tement of Facts
Mr. Berr_'y was convicted of sexual assault in 2006 pursuant to a p¢l>ap z H
bargain in cause number 1019634 (C._~R. `at 76-78).' 'I`he 180th Di_strict Court
sentenced him to ten (10) years in the '_I`exas Department of Crim-inal-]ustice, 1
lnstitutional Division (C,Ri. at 76-78). There was no direct appeal.
-the trial court appointed counsel to represent Mr.
Berry for purposes of filing a~Chapter 64 motion for DNA testing in cause
number 1019634 (C_. R. at 97). Biological evidence was tested at the time of trial
(fo¢t.s\_\’_'\t.b
4 by both the Houston Police Department Crime Laboratory and Identigene (C.R.
at 134-135, 141-142, 144-145). 'l`he Houston Police Department determined that
sper_matozoa were detected on the complainant's vaginal swabs as well as the
cuttings from the crotch area of the complainant's panties (C.R. at 135). The
vaginal swabs and cuttings from the complainant's panties were sent to
Identigene for further analysis (C.R. at 141). The epithelial cell fractions from the
t from the vaginal swabs matched the profile of` the complainant in this case (C.R.
at 1411). The sperm cell fraction of the vaginal swab showed a mixture of`m_a]e
and female DNA (C.R. at 144). The Appellant could not be excluded as a possible
contributor to that mixture (C_._R.. at 144).
On the panties, a- mixture of male and female DNA wasag_a-r..- c-_.._
_ from the sperm cell fraction (C.R. at 144). The DNA recovered from the major APXL
component of the sperm cell fraction is consistent with that of the Appellant.' s -
DNA profile (C._R. at 144). The report available at the time of trial reflects that
' alleles f£r_eign_ to the Appellant and the complainant were also evident in the
minor component (C.R. at 144). COHT'A*M wmde
n Summary of the A_rgument
There is no arguable ground to be raised in this appeal o_f the trial court's'
denial of relief following a request for additional DNA testing in this case. The
DNA testing _at the time of trial imp licated the Appellant (C.R. at 144). His DNA
vt then \m\>uommA ZN> \m)tvmum.dumww
profile is consistent with the major component found in the sperm cell fraction
taken from the complainant's panties (C.R. at 144). The presence of multiple
possible additional alleles in the minor component below the threshold for
analysis does not negate this fact. MM‘OH CWWMHMM.N M
'l`.h_e undersigned thereby requests that this Court follow the procedures
prescribed in A»nders z).- Califo__rni'a, 386 U.S. 738, 87 S.Ct_.. 1396, 18 L.Ed. 2d 493
(_196_'/') and Step'hen_s a State, 35 S.W.3d. 770 (Tex'.App.-Houston [1st l'Dist.] 2000, no
pet.), as discussed infra.
Al'>>t 1541
x. v\ r. n\. .\4
F.o
aid _,_E.>>on ,
YEEE
§§ § »S:i§u §_t&~_<
vm B;`u:u.iom
._...££
op organ EE Em.:£ 055
.E£ §§ swa § §§ s
253 >E._ .m:w.§om EEQU
>w=uotn E,mm _._~Eow umwa
n am £:oE mi pu=~ao ma
3553 E.w:mu dow _v$._
4 . .nm_.w£"§
~u:c=ou£~= u_£mwou ~:onm
cormEu£c._. .8.* uw:n:u§
§ .£c:§ 554 mci
wages
.com.~nwzmw>=.m
named n § =5 2 »vE,S
-~m,. vm:&vv ucc UB&EP&
wma,.muuo>>=>>on£ 3 F$ov
Ew:o.§"m§> §Uu.£u£ w£
§§ coc£waw.~ w£ ~:m
.~§..Etn
\E=o..w~u`§a..v:£§=- 3
..§~.»E._b § 3 ..E»SESS
§ §E§S EBE §§ 2
Bog£o>ou t
dBUEMQm 303
quac,uw.~vn E:o>>
555 2_ uv~um==ou ,Bm.£
§§ ibpqu 335 .~o
wechs&$m£r:_u£_»~¢$
mud 5 Eu~nm:m.vw§~.o= 3a
uu§m.ouEO m%onz< §§
.»E russo star age
".EouETmuc
..~o an §§ watea:§¢ uaw
v§vvvoadvaoa§ .w.i.b
wo.mv=vo~>w vua_£:o>> 58
.m»mww>£ ami cas cw=wvu
E:o.$ on 553 mxwo>>
tch tenor 2_.6£>.3&
.Q=O
.:v. mE uv_=au .£$£EE=E
.w_um¢o.EU ao#.=o.$
~£ .3 sues wE.¢ uo.s£>£
donee screwsng _1.=.§
.E him § 2 windoqu
635 v£ Eo.¢ ms ~om 554
wm noon mm cu_ csa .wa$
s...£ 23 se se ease
153 550 w£ 2 mE_EBm
am 23 co_wwu:@a 39
>~._sx E.owm._mm ages we swanson c_ tag mcmann .
.b_:£ H_B...c=:£ mg m::m
253 mm£oo=o bus 238
§§ 22 §=8 you .mw>>
ma 322 vs 3.:Ȥ=3 95
22 §§ bee §EEU.£
22 Q\Etu myron =Sm:om
ii __w§,.__w>o §:.5§
E….§oa 393 m.¢m.mm.$ =
m_uowo¢ E£.§.>N
.mocmom no wn,ocd_ common now =mu op
>m..c,cotm mmcm_u_mb mbmw_r c,o_pm__w>wm
_|
AP><|Ei'b
§§ §
0.808.~0.8.8.=0._$\£00 ..8088.58,8
E&.:EQW@EMEM.§._.S
_880880808_88808800
_05.=8.8 >880 800&80 8o88 00080
888 .88880 ..08088889808880 003
8880.w8800>888 0888.@800 08.8
__,%80800888.
.805 88888888 8 88880 is 88 800
9888 803 08880__8088.8= 883
808880U =.8.0.080 0888 885 am
805 088088 8000800880-0.8888.88
80880 8808800880..088888080 80880
800308>08 080 00=8888 08_880.
00880888 .80880 80:_808 08 805
8880.&0888 00880888000 3880=8.
0 8 00om 805 80880 88808.50.80
-00 283 080 880 .000888 888
0888080~80 voow 88088 >0§_.
.:.888<888800..8.80.80880.88
003 808 05 080_.8088 0.880.50.
8,088.80888.8 008888 8880:.08.8
>88 88088088088 003 08880.8 w888
.8888=008880 8888008.800>888
05 800 .88880888.50 080880.8
.o.8 80888>80 0888 .8o 88008_880
0>88=00080 .8088.800 880D
. _..0805=,80_8 805 88 308888. 8.88080 8_.
_.88800 08m00 ..888080.wq8
.880080 0888 m888858.088.8 .0888 880
088,80..& 0..088:008 1088 8:0.88003
o.r .8.808 05 .80 00.80 080.808800
0 888.8088.803-00 0,,8880.8..8 308_ 05 .800080888
.w880.83 m=85088 805
08880.,8 805 800888.088880888 088
.88888 _0~0088880880 .80. 8888888.00
w88083 05 8800= >880880888808
.,=8.08808088803.0080885880_8
805 88880w0=0 05 8880088
898 88088 >088.8088.0. 088.8`
.0000 0.880.880 _088.80888~
___..8.008>.8088:0
0888 8 088888800 805.05 583
088008 05 888»:.0.5 883 0880
05 0_0_8.8 .80:8:800088.88 88880
8880000=0 8.=0880 0m._ 858
.80..80800 08»00 w0.80 >088.80880
,.__80.0880800 0 0.088 .>:m.% 858
_.08088.800.8880. 0. 888 .08088=
.8808.88.8888.800 880880w5
-00>888 05 088883 8008§800008
2822§28 0820=83$0~
88888_8 588 .m.88o.83 wc8888o88
805 8808088888008 808888o.8 05
300 8808.8.80880 0..08880..8
.....800~8888808800
003 80888 808808.,8. 05 880800
781..-..... ct . . . . ..
-0.8 8,858.80 080.888800 8.80§.,
.888.00 >0888088.0. 00880.8088 05
_8_800.8030880 w888>088 888 880800
.808888 0.8 808 08:8.80 05 80888
. 880880.0:88 0 8o88 .08 .0888,~....
.80=80880008888 .888280
88880580.8888 08 0w880880080.888
.8_88_88:888..888 08880_8.80.880 8 _00¢
..E 0.05
58000:80.8880m _8.880888¢.888 05
080w8800>888 8 5088803 _088
.08808888888800 n808 0888880 .88
88300wu=0 388888:88888
..8.0>8§
8050 880.8. 8..0`88& 8050 8:0."8
,...88 w=.880 gm 0050880 0805
08.. n888800_ 088 ___.0.80_88.800 8880
8 3088 =0E_ munoz 085
880008 8 88088 08800Eom..
.50>80>888
880088 0>088 88808888 0880.80888
-88008 >880888 3088 88880.880088
..8088.888888 808888..00..8¢ 100-8000 08 283 _888&8.8 .0830~8 0..§
>.8.80.8 u88=88880888 .80888885008..=8 8808 08888.80 08&800008 .80
08888080>.0.8 .3 880800.¢0 880088 0>0.88 00000 000883 08880=0
_ 008._ 088 0.»00 .8.~08 .08888.885& 8880.80©_>088..8380 0088.0.80@8
20_=2¢_0,=208: \ 0_=_§ 03__0_>_
, `
..l. |.» 111 ...>....J.)...>.2):>828>= 8 l888..8=8:.=8\.. 88:.5:>:
.80080.8 05 00088 88008,888800_00
.0 3078..3_00 08~8 __`08088880.0_.0
8.00.88880-08 8088880000.888 308
-80.8 8o88 888:038800.8088 0 805
8§&8005 82 028 §§
.888.808.0>08
05..80 08803 05 888 880»880880
0803 008:8800?888 m8888080080
8§280 .._8§2=8 8.~=08§
088 8888888 900 0880888808. 88808.8
m888888o3 ..8808 05 80. 3008
>80>88080.8 003 08880..8 80888
080nE0E 8.8028 8888 08_80 .
.8808030
.880 08¢ =._0_088 .088008 880
880008 0>088 58=.03 8088,~...
=8.0.8088..53..00
038 05 88883 88880080>8_800
05 88 8:88. 085 888888800 880
885 8088880.8 0.>088 03. 8088803
3088_. .508800 808.88880888 58098
0 68 088:8. 880 203 05 8
0>0m 08¢ 805 08.880~8. 8:880
88880888000.& 0 u£.§.D
.m =.808< =o 88.88.6.8 8808808008
-8o0 080880.88_.0.8 =0888>80 05 8
mar 88808.8 _800.8.80.8088088 003
8808 8808888688 >8808888808088
05 .80_88888080>0 _880888.0880_88
.8.0 .800>.0.8805 0.80888 80¢<
.8808808888880888.00
0 wifan 583 80080800000
_88803 088880 .80 888._0 80m 8 38
-800.8.800888 8008 05 388 558
805 880808:00880 088@
_ .588288
08888 8088800 88880.§8.800
88808888800>0© 80008 0808808
.0.88 8880=$8 0888.80 m888800..88
.80.8028 080 08~8.0888.88 88.008
.880 8808 88800 ,008868.88008888:0
003 08.8 80883 Eo8.8 888080.8
..88.88 08008.8880880..80 88058800,.0
8800= 88088 088 805 8880.88808008
05 80.$:&008800 8888 08880..8
805 800808 05 80¢0 003 .88
.8880_8.:0=
003 0080.8808883 _800808 0 80
802 82...8.008=3 §§ ts.
. .08 0880..880. 8088.808888 05 8
w=8888o000 .<8_/80 .8o.8 108008
.0803 00888080 >8000808 880
08008888808830.0.8._08883 888…0000
88880000 88080>0.&»0 880»08 805
.88000 05 80 8088800 05 8<
.w£.ocmco.§> >880
88 588 80880888. 8 8008888,00_80
8808883 .`8.888.~ 80880.8» 0 0.8.8088
505 8:88.8808883 .008.=0 0_>088
-8880.808_.880880 05 8 880>8m.
0803 .08=08 .80.880_5&8800>888
302 688 00089888 288
880»880880 00.8850098&
......080.50.888 8 8000088..,8:0
080 08088880_8_00 80888 0.088080
-880.8080888 880 00088.88.0.8 05
583 50800..88 080 8808 08888.80
0_888 800 8008088888800 08008 0888
80888 08880880 80>088 8800_8008.8
..80 0.
88..8080088.8808 ..08.88088.80.:8 085
..8800 805o waoE0 .008803>0
880 80803 w88888888.880 003
.80¢.8 >8800_8 0h 805 0880 8080
.>08 _aoou 888 .0888808 Eo0
w8.888888:8.w8808 _0.8_..88080>0 .8o
00:000n 908 8880_888.80080@
0088008 8880:08.8 05 88380
888880_ 8 0>088,.8880 _08.880.8080_
85 0_8800.80030880.8 888008888880
0..08880»_~ .888 88988080>0.8 088,8.
5000 80?:8..88
80888800_ 0 888 8808.808>8800 8088
.E08880m 0_»88880 =80888.&85008
0< sava E£`,aw.tet<
EW>OU .UI.__P §OEL _
id
°° .
.,.~._.. ,.
_. ¢-’i' 913 9.`:1.¢5'<73 *':‘~
n“b-i`-> tv w l u.
03 mt-..~“_¢-pn-...,. .v.e
,.
_ |nvesti'ga'tion finds
‘ procedure and tampering
evidence of lying_,
tampering by `
ex-Lab technician
By.B_,i'iap Rogers
Scors of_ pending crimi-
nal cass and past convic-
tions-could be m jeopardy
in' the wake of revelations
that a former _Houston Po-
lice crime lab technician
resigned alter an internal - 1 .
investigation found evi- _ '
dence of lying, improper
withaiiom'cial record. - . ' ~
1 Foriner DNA lab techni`- ` .
dan 'Peter l;entz worked on
185 criminal cases, includ~?
ing 51 murders o'r capital
murders, according to` let-
ters smt out by the Har'ri_s
County Dish'ict Attorne`y~'s
Omce and obtained _hy the
Houston Chronicle through
anopenrecord_srequst. ~
"It’samess,’-' said Ger-ald ".
Boui'que, an attorney who
has several cases in which
Lentz tested the DNA evi-
den`ce, inc_._ludingtwo capital
murder cass, one of which '~
went to trial this year.- “If-
yoii"re not following pro-
toco_l, there’s pot-tial for
contamination, hansfer~
ence, aillcinds of stuBl" v
Thi_s_' is the latst. m a se- ~
ries of problems to surface l .
in recent months at H.`PD.` A
city- -commissioned study
showed the department
failed to investigate m,ooo
HPD convinces on A8
»u.
DDmeg¥A.-l
crimes with Workable
-leads.
Earlier. this yeah Harri$
County prosecutors-identi-
fied nearly two dozen cn'm-'
inal cases that could be in
jeopardy after they linked `~
them to a Houston homi-
cide detective fired for lying
l ` and conducting shoddy in-
L¢:-v-_ir'm
iit
s_
he
w-
cts`
tos_t
__.'s of
lto'f-
;Qals.
` e_not
';ben-
)have
__aders
,...`Ul€n'
_ utthe
- l. the
’ l )olicy
k said
- "AAis
ier im-
vidu_al
.over-
eni a_t
ustry~
mti¢‘*`_l
ntire
inu-
,~` for
v h'_¢,
vestiga_tions.
The disclosure about th_e
technicians resignation
comes as control of the pe-
rennia_ll_y troubled lab was
transferred in April from
. HPD to a civilian-le'd.boa.rd
ofdirect_ors.
Testing suspended
I.n 2002, forensic testing
at the lab was temporar-
ily suspended because of a
number of serious manage-
ment, employee and s'ii'uc-
tural problems including
a leaky roof' that for years
dripped water on stored
evidence 'l‘here was also
a backlog of untested rape
kits-, which at one point to-
talle'd 6,600, and persisted_
until A`ug'ust 203 when the
work was outsourced.
HPD spokesman Victor
Senties said Le_ntz worked
forl the lab from` ]anuafy
201"2 until he resigned in
March 2013», He said the
department investigated
Len'tz and forwarded the
findings to the district at-
torney"s otiice. He. said the
department would not re-
lease any hirther informa-
tion about t_he allegations
against Lentz or'comm`ent
on the situation .
Le`ntz could not be
reached for comment
The district attorneys
office in April and May sent
notices to alert defendants
`and their attorneys that
lentz falsified a worksheet
failed to recah_'brate a _rna-~
clrine and was untruthful
A`Hams' ` ~Cmuitygrandiury
investigated the technician
‘i'_'rr" §amjr\a'-'i"\rv mich n nm,lj. ~
By the numbers
1851 cases affected (172
feionls)
511 capital mu_rder/m`urder
cases
57: guilty pleas
1201-still pending
inay be aEected.
One of those defense at-
t_orneys, Bourq'ue, sched-
uledahea:ingThursdaY°n
the issue. He is expected to
question pmsecutorsabout
whether there are other
cases in which protocol was
not followed and about oth-
er possible problems with
the_technician and the lab.
Bou'r'que questions
whether anything'_ Lerrtz-
touched ca`n be use&as evi-'
de_nce, even 1f 1t is r_e_tested.
"I don 't know how they
can rely o'n anything,”
Bourque said. “lf you can’t
eliminate that there may
have been contamination
or transfer, what difference
does it make if you retes_t
it?.”
Asm"stant Harris County
Di`s,trict Atto_mey ]ennifer
Falk, who has two capital
' murder cases that are. af-
fected by the allegations
including Bourque’ s, said
the otfice' is looking a't all of
the technicians cases and
retesting anything it_ has
doubts about.
"Ifthe evidence has been
tainted to such a degree that
we don’t have conhdence in
it, then of course we’re not
going to use it," Falk said.
But, shesaid, she expects
most of the issues with the
DNA lsamples can be rem-
edied by retesh'ng.
E...l. o . .ght
Lastye@nMayorAnnise
Parkei'- received City Coun- y
cilbackin' gtotraiister‘ma'n--
agement of the scandal-
pla'gued lab from HPD to _
a government corporation
-.- a nine-menin indepen-
dently appointed board -
aim-d '_-nvalro` va 'Fnc-n'ru.'ir emav-i-
~AP)______ _o__._o.___ ____o_ 3__5:~___
. .._ _._. ... ___ U~@m@m.&
_____5 _____55___55_50 _vm o__ ____o
__2_:_5=__.:__3>__5£§_ _
_______5…>> o____ ___5_.___ _5__ ________o_ __5____5_____
________ ____ .B>__Bt_____._______.»_s
5....5_55_ __....____ __5___>> 503 _______
2_5__ _____5_.___ _.=5__ __o ___._55 ___5
-______8__. ______wo__ _._._05.___5_ 528_5._
555 ________ ___§¢o_ 5:._5__
_ _ ____ ________ w_._______§__¢ _.;u___ov_w
_ __ _ ___-o m__.__UEQ
_. _ _.B____uuo_____._o _
_____5& …_._>o._______ ___________ _.55_. 5_________.5 _
o____ Bv_._>>__¢§._o.__o_v>v_ .>5_ _
5_ 553 w_____w> o._o___ v__,___
vo___uo____ o__._.____ o__ __.___._9___5059__ _
._o_______o_____wn_______ _~_.__o._ ___o.____u__
_9>_5____ __o__ ________ u_.___m .1_5@__5___
.__5_5 ___o:.____o._ 553 ___v___
._u__.____ __5_ v_o._u__ __5._.___9.5_
m_________ .._8______ _______ _____________
.5___5____3_&5_ 55___ __w__o_.____
_._o 35055___ 825 _5£ 538
m_...___._ _____o__o._ _o__od____ .___5__.__5
_ __________ ____________ _B___o__ ___<__
__o_____._ _¢_o_u_ ._o______o>oZ .u._____
__w_o_…u__ ____.__5_________5__._ =oo>>_om
. __5_.___ ___5____9_
_______ _____________ 55___55__&3_¢__
_5 _._o.__._ o____w___o_ w____ __o__ ____m____ _
_____.5_ __5__0___5___ _o________u 5_.___5_. _
-___5._0____.____.5___ 55=555____:._<
…_ _.____Q.Eoum____wo.___v._o._v__mwaa
___ q 585____§&__5§5_32_5_§
____ E_a___.>__._______._..=§__ _
_ . __... .. __. _ .. _. ..._._._.v___.om__.=d£;_____
_ __________ .__v 54_.._5_,___5____5___@_
_ .__.____.__ __________ o__
xa__m
-~_e.___ w______o_ ___.Bo._ ______
_ 5___._5§5 ban 5§_§__. _
953 5__o___u_>__ou_ ______.Boo
5_._._5_._ ov- ._o____o__<
_ _ ..5___o__5._5___9_._o._5_a__5.
...__.._____.__ ____o__.__._ __oo__u ooo_o§ _5
___v>_oov_ __o____ ____.______.__.o>> _5_._,__
.wu_________n__:w ____=o..~____o.u_ 5_ __o___
553 55__5___>5 .o___ _._.2so___5
___ ____55___ _________5.___.._ __._o.__v_ __5_
_____ ___________3_ .____._w______u_______ ___5_
9_____._5___.__ m__._:m___ __vu__u___ __.._5____5__
__u___>>___v_
u. __o__m___._o.____ _o.____…_
_ v._o__>> 5,.__________ m___w__a__u
_af.
,_ 5§ 5___¢.__0..____5___9__.2_>> 5
_55.55__.__
.._mmu....r:._ 73 _.
w_____._ouu__ ___5.___5_
-5__.__ ______s __._55_ ________ ________ ___
.5__._0__5__ _»._____5___ o_ ______o_._
25 352 ______ 535 555
_ -55____ 5._25 5._5___ __u_..__s ____
_5~55»_§__05._809__535_>
.5_.__ ______ 5_._5_____5__0
_.BK_EB_.___&Y_£
-5___o5 ______ _________Bo_.__ o___
___55555.0____ __ __5__.5__5 __________ _o5
_...._25 .._.._.._____ 5555_5_____ 5.__>>__ _______
__ 3____._5__5_ __5_____5 _______ ________55 __._5
_.>w _.__ _..___mo_u 5____55 5______ __.._____o.__
_____________ 5__5_§ 5
_.__$5__5___=__5___ o___ 5____$.__ o._o______
______ _m___._._=...uo 5.._.._3_ ___5~_______
______ _____.55_ ________ ._
o____,____w____o.__.__._o__
__
..._e_ _…_.vm____u_u__ w___ __5_._._ 5__ __so_____.__
5_8__5.__5__9_5 _____on 5_._
_______ 5___ _5__3 .___55_550._0
_ _5._o__55___5__5____ _______ 55___0
.__5._ ___o__ _555“__5.__@ ._5555_ ___
_5.5_30 _w__.u___wvn_w_. ______u__.__w___._ _
._____ ________5________ ._o coo____o____
.__5_59&__ 5___ __._5..__ _____ ___m .__~_5
__u___$. _____________ 5 ________ o___ _om .
lhwcon am va~uu~>=ov §§
_5555__. 5__.__5_._.__._ __ 5 ._5__.__.__>_
ou__u=?_ .__¢___ _vu____¢__v
____ 558 5_____5
BEARCH
none views l=oon illule sc"ltEeN_s
`
ARTS & CULTURE
DAlLV GALENDAR
SPEC|AL
AP`)< l 5b
L°G l|| l EEGiSTER
PROMO .ADS CLASS|FIEDS DAT|NG
illuslc Pol.L eALl.oT l view vEAR'S twice l wise Lis.i' l l=iz`s`e week l ins'ren amicus Movis ni'GHT l A'c'cAl.E\ioAiz nev l iifewsL`er'rees
news ood
Top 10 Loca`i ,e 2014
'Stories: The top
10 Aus¥ih-Arhl
Storles
l Tactes We
Cou_ld_r_i't S_tnp
"i in`uslc
. The Best
Albums of Ou`r
' lees - and the
arts
Top 10 Cmativo
Thingn | Lucked
low in 201'4`
' screens
T_he ¥ear in
Fllm: Chrnnlcle
Crltlcs"_l'hrow in
v lar Boyrrnnd
»l
news
'Justice. l‘for HPD Lab Victim?
J,osiah Sutton waits on state leaders to clear his name
BV JORDAN SN_||`|'Hl FR|.. APRV|L 15. 20_04
Harris Co. Distn`¢':`t Judge Joa`n Hl.ifl‘m`an on ‘Ap'ri| '12
recommended the Court of Criminal Appeais'vacate the
rape conviction of 22-yea_reold Jo_tilah Sufton, who was -
iaisely imprisoned for four years for a rape he did not
commit before DNA evidence exonerated him last year.
Sutton was convicted based on faulty DNA testing
conducted by the now-infamous and recently
reorganized Hous`tnn Follce Department crime lab.
Although Sut`ton was exonerated and released from jail,
he wm remain _a convicted felon unless the CCA or the
Board of `Pardons and Paroles steps in to wipe the s,_l_a_t_e
clean.
State Sen. Rodney Elllsl D-Houston, ap'plaud_ed
Huffman's decision and mastised the BPP for its failure
to act on Su_t`ton's behalf --th'e board "`has chosen to sit_
idly by, claiming that it is limited by seifeimposed
. prCedural guidelines." he'said in a press release if the
court and Bi»=`i»=` fai|`to ad. lawmakers may come t_o
surren‘s al'd, crafting legislation to erase his conviction
similar to a move legislators undertook las_t spring -to
clear the records of 13 defendants from the infamous
Tu|ia drug sting. "The incarceration of innocent persons
is a'threat to the integrity ofo'ur entire criminal justice
system, and we should therefore take all steps to rectify
the problem.' said Ei|isl while re_newing the call for
lawmakers to create an innocence commission to study
cases of false im'p`nso_n`ment. A revenue-neutral bill that
would've created Such a commission languished in
committee last spring.
http://www..austinchronicle-.-com..
Nal¢e_a city
' H-dl'ines and happenings from Austtn and
BV MIKE CLARK-MAD|SON
Bitter'Buzzlng in Bee Cave
Loc`ai politicos. enviros sting each other
over controversial mail project
ev A`Mv leTH
To,riiatow'n Suits Go Forward
A_'Travis C_o. judge declines TRMPAC's
motions inv swnn"ii_ry judgment
e'v M'l<':l-lAEL l<'lN`o
Whlch Austln Cnngressman?
.Wi'lic_h Agm Coog`res_s_man?
BV MIKE C'LARrK-MADISON
Carichola, HcNelll Trlumph l
Cal_td'lo\a. MdtaH'Tnmnph
ev MiKE c`LARK-MApisoN
lJu,stica for kle Lab Vlctlm?
Jos`h Sutton waits on stale leaders to
cle'ar his nai_l_'i_e
*BV JCRDAN SMITH
Jim Bob. Gortln' Fald Again
Tirn'es may change but Moiiea‘s.
_ garg'a"ntuan salary remains a constant
ay RerRr B`R'Y`cE
Scei_ia’s Dirty L,lftle Seerets
The iu'stice‘s favorite kind ot gnven_vnent
is one you cent see
BV JORDAN SM|TH
AlSD Bond Debate .
is the disiriel.really gruvvlr-rg? And will
$420.rnillion'b`e sp`anl in the right plaoe?
BV RACHEL PROC'TOR MAV
Ta: L'aw§? W_l'ia_t Ta_'a Laws_?
Corp_o'retjons s_t_iil vel very gentle
treatment lrorn the iRS
ev JoRDAN sM'l"rH
Texas to Wnrld: Drop Dhad!
'The wortd.counlsides with Meiiican
nationals on death row
BV RiTA` RA_DO,$T|TZ
UT Bua Battle Turns Naaty
shuttle drivers rlreri ailer rating pan in
stude_`_nl solidarity protesl
B¥ JORDAN`S`M}TH
RRC1_9
FoLL'owUs
§§ ®E'
mcmann
it,_EVWQRos FoR `THls sr'ol`z`v
stiah Siotqn, monc_erch commission Rndnei Eliia. Bdard ~
ai Pordons and Pamies, com or coninai`Appeais, .ioan
Hufi‘man
`MoRE llews
Awalting the Ne'v'v Rule$ at TCSO
Shei'ifl‘s D_lfijw awaits ii_'r_iple_ni`enla`_tioo al Prlcrlty
Erdorcement P
rom cmu_. FRl_.. .lAN. 2.21:15
News ARclliv'Es ~
MORE BV JORDAN SlMTH
\ 'C\\n'»me Undergrolnid' Goes Clls,nll: Car
I'll`ngtil\‘g
Motoreum'n Vis.lt 5 Antol't`io lalk_ about the biz end unfair
reality 'l'V debut
mu.. my zz. zo`u
ALL sroRlEs Bv .loR`oAN leTl-l .
NEWS `ARCHIVES ii
1/2/2015
'\
§‘EsT`l'=t'lc:-'1TE"i3"'v
DNA DATABASE
ii weir W<~Pm P'-°'-'-‘f" APX M
mbprrrl . .
nnsr.’i'umar= . . wong
2, ~..,,.S.),Hr 0453%14¥
S)Sa:'t?:- me UFe_ma|B 4)Raee: U_Cauct_asian
Gmimerican
gotten
5) sources parent aim Q_§'rQL\ »l_til _n
el pate sample ccilec¢ed:- § 'Q.§r 05
10) collected By'_- ST_`,L.%£¢ Q/
' `(Sig’rianite)
lherebycertitylhatlhavebeon ptoperlynainedlnrestrictedDNAsanmiecollel:tior'
procedures and that this restricted DNA spec_t_mer_i was taken incor_npli_ance ruth
meritDPSg'iiidelin_e's.
whoever-umc BHL@D_-_-@O___SM-__
-@&Wm,m/rl_z 155 frady
mrwc`.t run
18
“E'v'u).ENCE RECORDS AFFIDAVIT'” A F X l 5
`Tyronc Bcrry _/ Cause # 1019634 `
S'I`ATE OF TEX~AS )(
com or HARRIS )(
MY lime is Q- ThigP`¢l\-
l_am_ employed as tli'e property and/or evidence records custodian for the Harris County `
S`lierif_t"s Om,_¢ei my addrss and telephone number is 601 lockwood Dr., Houston,
Texas 77011, (713)‘967-5709. ln i_ny capacity as property and/or evidence records '
custodian, I have care a_nd custody'of those records for Harris County Sbe'rifl’s O[H'ce
Evidence[Pmpeny Ro_om and l certify that the following reflecw tire status of property
and/or evidence related to: Bo'uston Police Department offense report number 30415605-N
and/or cause # 1019634 in the l8_0th Dist'ri'ct Court. T_he olTense date is on or about
02/25/2005.
(_p!ease select and complete the proper category)
ETM records of the Harn`s County Sheritl’s Oflice reflect that the Harris Coi_'tjnty Sl\erist
_Oflic'e never received and is not presently in possession of any property and/or evidence
from offense report~#. 30415605-N and/or cause # 10196_34.
(contj_nued on page Z)
131
“I have completed and read the above ailidav`it and have found it to be true and correct to
the bestof my lmowledg_e.” _ ' f
\. _ -¢, y raw \ _
SI.G.NED:_ / ' '. . _. "‘
v `\ ... e__
SUAND SWORN TO before me the undersigned authority on this B_day of
~ _ . , 2015 _ ._ 4
rUB`uc FoR °"coUN'rY
LYN')A_LL )<. eARR
{i‘;;)'i:lry .°_.it:l'i_c
S'.ATE OF TEXAS
commission szp. ti-qs'-zoi:_
’¢-~¢.\'~'" l '~vl - -'
'132
` ANN LE_E MOSELEY A ‘ 7 ».
Attor`ney and Courtselor at Law ' px l ‘ l b
1425 N. Durham, Houston, Texas 77008 '
.'phone: .71HW;0765 taxi 71.%77-0'754
LEG_AL MAIL
April 28,_ 2014
Tyrone Berry, TDC] # _01368050
D_ibon Cor_re`cuo_n,a'l Cen_t'e_r
1604 South First Street
Diboll, Texas 75941
Mr._' Berry:
Enclosed you will find my Motion to Wlthdraw from Re'present'ation and brief in support
thereof. I am also including as a courtesy ,a copy of the entire record from this case, ‘which..
consists of one volume. Final_ly, l am including a Moh'on for Ex'te'n_si_o_'n of 'Ii`r`ne Within ‘Which to
File Appellant’ s Brief.
After a thorough review of the record, I have concluded th_ere.is nothing of` merit to argue on l
appeal regarding the'trial court7 s denial of your request for additional DNA testing. As such, I
have filed what is commonly called an Anders brief.
You may still file a pro se brief in this matter l have included the record so that you can review
it and make a determination whether to proceed with a pro se 'appeal. This should typically be
done within 30 days, however I have provided you with a Motion for Extension of 'Iime Within
Which to File Appellant’s Brief. '
Onoe the Court of Appeals has issued their opinion in this case (based on the A'nder‘s brief, or on
`a__ny pro s_e 'brie-f’ you ii_le), and depending on the outcome, you may want to continue to ask for
review by filing a pro se Petition for Discr'etionary Review (PDR). A PDR is filed with the Court
of Criminal Appeal‘_s, asking them to~review the Court'of Appeals decision,_
Be advised, though, that the Court of Criminal Appeals will not just review a case because you
ask them to do so._ The Court of'Crir'ninal Appeals will only review cases for error if there is a
disagreement in the law or an issue of constitutional dimensions
If you choose to file a PDR, you must do s_o' within 30 days of_ the date the Court of Appeals
issues their opinion in your case, or the day the last timely motion for rehearing was overruled
by the Court of Appeals had one been Eled. Texas R_ule of Appella_te P~rocedure 68 sets forth
guidelines for filing a PDR. '
A PDR_rnust be filed 'in the Court of Cr_imina_l Appeals, P._O. Box 1'2308, Ausu'n-, 'l`exas 78711.
n Si.ncerely,
,Ann Lee Moseley
l"\l' .I\ '|` l
'iZ
Thus, because there is no arguable ground to be raised in this appeal or me
trial court’s denial of relief following DNA testing in this case, the undersigned
believes that an appeal of' the trial court’s order denying retesting in this case is
wholly frivolous
A copy of the entire appellate record (which consists of one volume of the
Clerl<-"s Rec'ord), and a copy of this brief has been mailed to the-Appellant on
.April _27,_ 2014, aswell as a Motion to W`lthdra_w. See Anders v. Califomia, 386 U._S.
738, 87 S.Ct. 1396, 18 L.Ed. 2d 493 (1967) and S-,tephen'-s v. State, 35 S.W.3dy 770; 771l
(Te'xi.App.-.Houston [lst Dist.] 2000, no pet.)(motion to Withd_raw pursuant to
A_nders brief is properly directed to the appellate court, not the trial court).
5hould this Courtl grant the undersigned’s Motion l to W`ithdraw, the
undersigned will inform the Appellant of the result of his appeal and will also
inform the Appellant that he may, on his ow`n, pursue discretionary review in the
Courtof Crimi`nal Appeals. Seey Ex parte Wilson, 956 S.W.Zd 2_5, 27 (~'l`ex'.Crim.App. '
1997).
V` ' - ` AP><; 201
PE'I'I"I'IONER further requests that new :buccal swabs from him be obtained pursuant to a
new warrant signed by this Court and that the taking of such swabs be done only in the.presenee
of‘his undersigned attorney ofrooord; Leah M. Borg
. l . VI. v
' l FETl'I'IONER therefore requestst_hat this Court set‘thi,s matter for a-heari_ng thereon to
determine , ' ' _ '
1-.\ that evidence,~sril_l exisrs_in a condition making D. N. A-.. testing possible and to determine:the
enlisted connor information moose-mo ofall.sooh memos _
2. that the evidence -in possession off such entities hasheensub]ectedto a chain of custody
- gilmin to establishes it hastoot.boeo mmpo__rodwah, roplaood, or altman oay.¢oa;olial
ESP°°T;»
3. that identity ls an issue in the underlying cti.minalcase;
4-. that PE'I]'I‘IONER was the lone accused and as such, would not have been fo\md guilty if
exculpatory D. N. A_.-.tes_tingiesults would have been obtained; l
5. the request-for and performance of new D- N. A. testing wouldnoti unreasonably delay the
execution of PEHTTONER’S sentence or the administration of justice since PETITlON`ER is_
presently serving the sentence assessed in the underlymgcnmmal case;'
6 the I_.ab Repoi‘t E'om ‘Ide`nu`gene, Which performed the original D_. N A, racing in 2005,
indicates the possibility, if not probability, of contamination in the testing procedures
PE'TITIONER requests that this Court, should lt determine and order-that.PEl'l-'I'.[ONER
ls-noroo'ouoo to now n N. among aod.dooioo mo muefroqomoahoreml that this com make '
written findings of fact and conclusions of' law at the conclusion of the hearing in order to A PX 2_\ '
preserve any issues for appellate review
WHEREFORE, premises considered, the PE'["ITION`ER prays that this Court grant all
relierre@estetl heteio end for such and-othetreiier; whether generator epeeiel, at low or itt
equity, to whieh this com deems Paiii'loNERjustly ehotlett l `
v ' Reepeetfttliy~ suhmitte.d;
LEAH ~'M_.aoR.G ii
, ATIDR.N.EY FOR PETITIONE TYRONE BERRY
874 YORKCHES"TER No. 123
‘HotisroN_, TE_XAS. 7707'9
TEL & rsz- 713-468-.3618
i'r'.XAs BA_R_N.o. 02667800
cERi:LF~lCATE or salich
I hereby ceir'ifythat .a true and.correcr.copy of the above and forgoing hgg_rion was malled/
delivered to the:Assistant Disrri_ct Attomey, Baidwin Chin, on theyzy__ day of `July, 2012, n
LEAHM..BORG- » 0
Ul“) il\lL/i L.~l-"VF\_,|. l\l"../tt.» -i\. _ -
_ lKl>tClll_E_,£lr Pht;uat¢`;% CR-lhtl Dlv
l/F\m\ 11~{911., \_lU")/ii{,i; CE/H.’Y€,R v 7 APX v 221
1101 Fahlll\utl l'Bthl,c>nh '
9004-101~1,.1/1,1</><¢1 7701§1 _
` Rr/‘- "`\:llhrhll/Bwel \/.5111¢11,- OFRKf.he
LDkNo1l‘lel.:5'Q034- C.& _ .
Thth hhs 111 l~lo.|Ol"-`lle§‘l 1313111'1313'1hla1 foam
Dahhmh Powr/l‘\s -
l_`shrmtheo!l l'hottt,"hho Le11ehl’111114\1’1)11 ltlTh birt/31 61 l
llehmh 91111> §1>111'11. 19111\ li)l-\l111111 too‘\'ooh'~l 'H>A:tl¢ llhhl
illopr 9110Thh~loth11 ibiht-,Cot)m Or> 910%111_§ Foh‘(lf
Fhur 016/lth
Hahl\thi/Thht flewer Ut\lTlth/@th)h\l 019/510111151, 2015
hiltreh't,’llhre 971/11 ttotttth‘e monell Fo hPlie 1 60111111;111‘>1\1 Fohiiloln
D`l~l191"ll/e1l1lh lllheDtilltco lmth 130111911110\112,1 Court-1 UF
. limit teetth Pohttlhm'fo mail/1113 Rl)uhs 01/9111>1,1,1.1111,
Photirntlhlr,i)\llt,t, 3"l G(bll l
’lht; heet,tt;htw 311,1,~111,\11,5 l1lolh1hh1h111va’l?1h1 |911,
. le 9mm/ho C tool/tit lhel> 111/1 1111 Ettl11hlh Ri,l>ot>dl,h%
liteman isham llctht/ lo E‘11h1'211,1€l11 Bxhl'/1th" hith
Thht~leathhh 911€1>1113 Llr,hhlt\le/ lhh1 Dt,l\llr,o lite l’\/lMloll
Ft)l>\ 1970‘11 Lti\lvlt:l 1011 Dl\\ 91TKA11NL< -
- ’l'ha 911101<1~11)1 01 Re.e,ohr> Ot\l haar/hi ls 9\,111~1 ftca
mohr/ul 9\1101>\1~111)1 911\11) Laill~lar,l.l")h 911 thl,rljmi il/lh\l
tinfoil/lamm 9\1 \‘i 15 N Dtlhhhlh,lil>tis'roltl'lim. hs
77011@ 191111111,1\11 713 1177 11711.5 hot 713 1177;£117511 `
991 mO-shl,n\l fill table hahn 1111 lClltlFlhht/ lllh1 ill
ll 91777.13331~11 l`3 l'31f11111731~11 91110 l3E_1~1/11113731)T11 91th
ll137»/' D7Th»73l7\137137<113a3 `R131,11hl3 h3h1131'1 l'/=3 113 l71573 l7.h113 Fca
’F 11711111311 l:/1311133 Dbarvm;l 97\1311111'711,1”30111~113’ 3 (113117__131313?1111133
911”31_73111~11.`/ l. R 91 9 l<131313 730 l (Kl
52’.5113`\1111>;11 111711711»1111:173 9\1~11> 511'11117111»1<111:73”5113
' R1,7137\11a3 R1,3131113l3 llr 631,11113131)111~11:1 Fh313 1111<1 l:hh` 813
l?)7113131111/1 'l'13 1113 9177733h113 l’.301)ar F1)a_l7\131/113111x
’93./111113@137\3111313113 l/lhalh'|/hl:,' 9177131313131~11 lll 1313
50771373€)\1 l-/\13 l1~13l11311,11~1 lo E31»><1313131,1 Fh1313 lina
1§.:3\111313’1’11111 Chll 01113~1 1313 rhoth l11 111»1315137137\1113"3
wall
”l1111,93¢17_533 l:1la/ 17113 l._h113 R1311111351
(1373’1’1111,&313131311 913 911>73131,7131 1 3 C011731 19;17171311111313
911117\111131 Elh3 F1131=313 931 911111'1375 57.157 l11 11113 1311-313
91311)’l'11l1391771331h111 l3 Frl31113 91@a0 §13D1a131/1 91?77311113
’hh 911>773131331111 3 l\lr,u> F07(l”1113l{1331l7\13 l39_111 lla1113111
.l3~')131~3l711011~3/011)D Bit Lll‘) Rllxlhr ’lo Dllh/ Pao-LU,§ 911~10 '.
' lm71313a1b3 11113 Kwo713a ’{l;> l731<1151(1111711;317\37307\13 911
` lha 13117\1311331 l71l331131373 Cohv113111311773
lhl1 91111_-31\1111>11 lllT9113
l111713a1h111 93111'1> Ual§r:l\w Lll@h13 1l/l.91/l173a1
l51,31 1713117<171133' ,
91'“~ /9””.>
111111111131313117¢1 9131137513
w MNDHWM mg D1131'3133 ("1:)11137131113111313 1373111137
111111113 731311111 1>13111131 1117311 lqu 500111 Fr7\31 611
91311_11,1331'913312131311 9331371~1131 k Dll§ol,l_,“l'wh$ 75€}1.||
` Kathleen O’Connor'Powers, ' . A
Ofiicial Court Reporter` PX 24
' _ 180th District Court \
1201 Franknn,‘ 1 8"' Floor -. '
Houston-, 'l`exas 7700_2
Scptember 16; 2014
Tyrone Ben"y 1368050
Diboll CC S.\ First Sf_-.
DibO]] TX 75941
RE: Trial Court Cause No. 1019634, St_ale of Texas v Tyrone Be'l“ry
'Dear Mr..Berry:
ln response to your inquiry postmarked ll SEP 2014 and received in my office Se]§tember 16,
2014,_ there is no reperter"s record for_August 9, 2013_ for the above-referenced case.
Thank you,
Kathle.en O"Connor Power_s,
Offlcial Court Reporter
CC: Court file Cause N,o. 1019634 -
AP} §§ mo E ’ 575/1401
WA|TT|
weis mmi/54 7'¢@7,\1¢: 352/ix /4;7+ /71)¢//1725#“%§>
DAFE 1N'TERVIEW11ME BEGiN 1NTEvaEWT1ME- END
` 340/acre _ _ ' 40»1 *'é'_~f<'l` ' " 5'1?0’10"3 [‘f*”’!»' 57*”‘-)»_.
F'/>’#.;w/z_ . _ 1 0/1,7 239 ~01_ , 3'1~0\0/3 ‘/i‘ao¢»_-GBM/
/o'q» ama - 3'13»~1'?7+ ‘/"/5 024 l ~ '
vz» //)#M'L BM» 313@ iam . ._ . , \
WS\’W'T lA._S " 7500~§§ ` ' . MEMAML'E.S [|¢,b
D_ATE iNTsRviEw'nME - seem ' 1Nrsny1§w nME.END
5>'31> »§;m_ -. 1/',20-3_0/1,',"7~.';0~30/?~ ', 7'0:_ -30_/_2`:_7 ', ` //-¢»zo/z ', /z~ /91-1_0/_
\V
2'5”3~03, 5 15”3915 4-/¢7_- 30_/3 §'_/’?',,10/3', 5-;;,_,5073?' `_7.§/___`2 '~,,-ia/_g'
v 7 J
41 f .1_.?> '. 8"7'0?°/3 . _ 7 '/"_\7.
' 7 REc-oRDs RESEARCH _ 7 _Z 1157 rt¢$£
nA'r-E ’aEGiN T_1ME ann jr_iME ": DESCRlPTloN oF AcrlviT_Y
2'/7117;1_0)'1_7 7//;3»,.- l/M ‘“0,’,_‘,,.-`¢_7_ 771/ia _"` ‘
LE-GAL RESEARCH ' ' 517-inez
oATEv ai-;_GlN T1ME END T1ME ` 4 ` _ GENERAL ToPic L"_ . _
3/,23<,11>.2 em/ ,_.,4~ *"“1“"‘ f ear wax ' '
4-21~1013_,_-777 04»~ 901/m ’LS;”“” M75*§$"§,;’7 {7‘_”7‘"_"‘7’77’"7 _‘,3.,
reasoNAi.iNroRMArio. . __ _ .
osial$:cu.riiy Numbcr (la.si4di§is'only) Tcl_=phon_= N\m_:l'._vcr 'B'lr Card Nu.u"ibcr
x_xx -x_x' '75’% ()13)§€03"3$/@"7 pg[lp?_£o_d
Mni]ing. Address (Numb_er, Sme'e_t, Si'iire Ci!y Siaie Zip Code) w
394 (40§.1;,¢1455re_¢ *‘\gg 1_§. @ .sv~o.)T§< __~_7'7?_77
CERTH"[CAT!ON
I, LE# /1" /M ~' 30@6’ , swear'or affirm that the Harris County A_uditor may rely upon the
' information contained ab'ove to make payment according to the fee schedule adopted by the Bo_ard of`Di'_strl_ct
Iudges Tx'"ying Crin_iin_al Cases pursuant 10 Tean Code of Criniinal Procedure Art. 26.05.1 fin‘ther swear or
. aflinn thai l have not received nor will l receive anything of value for representing the accused., except as
Appr°"¢=.d
/‘f e, Presidin.g Atromé a§j,aw (Siguanire)
3 § LEArr /14 304a-
otherwise disclosed to the Court in writing.
swonnre¢@sca?m_//___ BEr-.oizr. ME oN rims T.Hr 506 DAY or%? b .
msmci?¢l?n@;gé;!= _ Ammy wm ipn'm again
AF)<"`
32
APX
73
3
0,.<~\.§»,_ _q.§o§ )._ow §§ §§1§ §
mv;lw§m Q- 53
long Q\UT> § Q\_»oi _w_
_ QW\E\FHQ fwth §_ §__Z=a._
§0§1§\ vw gee 5 §
.\ q . ,
..eoEEm § 8 com$$&og oz _.nozm>> _meaa.¢...v
§§ es ANMH§§W s ca3 s sense
o _
1,.\§\5\ §_._m..__.mm. um§@__%§% § __=BT _%..;__ __e
QW%§.S§Q1 R/e
..~.¢.DOU \.Mm:.. h.C. .m.¢m=w¢o J.<.¢.N.Z..HU
r` ~¢_.'_.
Harris County Crim'ina| District Docket Sheet APX.
THE sTATE oF‘rExAs vs. SE'RRY,'TYRbNE ` ' ednd; sso,ooo ' ' v -
cause`Ne.;- 10196340101<)3 corr,rt_;weorrjr Next sening; 54
Offenses--SEX ASS~LT CH)LD 14-'\7 Level: -2n'd Deg're'e Fe)ony ease Dis~p°smon: Disposed
Charg_ing lns`trument: Fe}ony indictment case Staws: Comp|ete
Deiendant staiu§: Disposed
GENE,RAL ORDE_RS OF THE COURT
a =.~rrr ,,__-r', w ..,.
52;2005 l f P\e`a §umy And Sen1en_'ce`d.
hhc/2012 Detenda`m BERRY, TYR< § § z ila
LEAH M.- BoRG 57[0) \; a §§ -`5
ATT_oRNEY AT LAw as § q- s
874 YoRKCH:EsTER No. 123 §§.\__._ § §
HOUSTON, TEXAS 77079 .'3\.-» § g
TEL. & FAX= 713-468-»3-618 3 §§ gas
- z
é§a§;
¢*P*§
Tyrone Berry § d § 2 § \,°.
TDCJ# 1368050 ` >Q'. 35 3
George Beto Unit \.‘.] § §§ §
1391 F.. M. 3328 _ §§ 5 § §
Tennessee Colony, Texas 75880 y ' Dec. 17, 2012 § s_ § :§ ._
Re: Cause No.1019634_;l80th Disnl'ct Court of Harris County, Texas; DNA § §§ 7\_" ',
Motions `, § §‘é:`_:‘
5ea§§
Dear Mr. Berry: § c§‘_§\; d
§ 3 E' '=‘
This ls to let you know what happened with respect to our last scheduled court 107 q'l" f§'g': \.l€'s
appearance on___Fri-,day, Dec. ,_1<_,1 20~12.
On Thursday,' Dec. 13th, l was called by the Court’s coordinator and was adyised §
that the D A,. had indicated that he still has not received the affidavits in your case, \._
_ The coordinator said it was not necessary for the D. A. and I to go to court the next §§ d
day, since there was nothing that could be done. flaum limit (:¢g>mj[fyru_p¢q. 01 ~ § 3
lv"rlicm, \l § el
Therefore, since we are still waiting on the affidavits lfrom the various agencies 3 (-Z
that handled the evidence in your case, your case was reset. ...§§ §
v \°
l,l_'r, These affidavits are solutel necess g because the are su ¢ sed to advise » ~ § §
Court of several things reth idence. Fol-' example: that the evidence still
exists, that the evidence ls in good condition for the taking of additional DNA
samples-, whether DNA was taken from the evidence, where the evidence ls now
located, etc..
)'u‘lm` ijle Obviouslya until these agencies provide the affidavits on your case, we can ’t get
any relief l. c new DNA testing and you remaln convicted
I can imagine that you are concerned and wondering why _it is taking the various
agencies so long. Franlcly, l was concerned enough to speak with the C'our_t’s
T‘(/U’ hibi/tim Co\) m VV\M lockout-m ulmet
Y\rus¢n 144 r.' FN)-m MML'P§HMJ@D D.p¢¢‘z
"LM/KWA/[lohl “A$`:)MJ‘\R rlw./ }`le/\.JL)\.¢\ uuv\.
y Our next court date 1s Feb.8,2013.Hope1iJlly, at that time, the D. A. will have the
Av x §/(b) § §
coordinator and 1 asked her whether she thinks this is unusual for it to take so lon ng ."5 z
The coordinator advised me that she has noticed that these DNA motions are §§ §
taking a very long time and that your situation was not unusual with regards to § 3
length of time. ci\\\»m§rw‘/V\twvc'l mt
icmLRer"’
\\
~ disclaimeth
tom a.r.,. hal
LEAH M. BoRG »
ATToRNEY AT LAW ' AP)¢ § 7(¢,)
874 YoRKCH:ESTER No. 123 l j
HOUSTON, TEXAS 77079
TEL_. & FAX: 71`3-468-3618
Tyrone_B'erry
T.DCJ # 1368050
George Beto Unit
1391 F.M. 3328 l bits DA({L
Tennessee Colony, Texas 75880
Re cause NQ 1019634-,180“’1)1$111'¢ court omeis county, Texas, DNA
Motions
Dear Mr. Berry:
This is to inform you that l have been appointed by the Court to represent you
regarding the various DNA motions you have f11ed.
l have read through the documents you filed, as well as the Court’s iile in this case
and have read through several post-conviction tiles of yours regarding various
writs you have filed. I have done this to best understand any basis for post-
conviction DNA testing.
Of particular importance to me was your statement that your trial attorney had
advised you that the DNA testing revealed that there were several sperm donors in
the sample that was tested. If correct, this would be extremely important i_n getting
new testing done.
I have obtained a cg)y of the report from Identigene which did the DNA testing in
' your case in order to ascertain whether there was more than one sperm donor
The report from Identigene says that:
l. samples were taken from Britmey Smith and the panties which she was alleged
to._`have worn'; MMMQ, a hill DNA profile of Brittney Smith was
» obtained_;
l\lb \\~ir»aammioil Masiiu~u; Nt,ii"\ti;um liu as
was laramore l\~\“‘fm/Mmioti.
2. a buccal swab sample was taken from you and from this sample a full DNA
profile for _you was also obtained; ` ` " A .. d)
a _ Fx 5 7
3. a mixture of male and female DNA was obtained from the sperm cell fraction of
the vaginal swabs and you could not be excluded as a contributor to the mi_x_ture;
4. a'mmre of male and female DNA was obtained li"om the sperm cell fraction of
the panties alleged to have been worn by the complainant, and you again could not
be excluded as the DNA donoi"-,
"\
5. although the report says DNA is obtained from at least two individuals§ it means
that DNA was definitely obtained from Brittney Smith and from you;
~;._M/iwid miqu spwirr,) wm
W-'G\/M 51 B,Ld(? w\~\UdW',)~do i~\iW"‘m}a\ cnm')vgqui"i
719
|_.’_.
6. and, that you could “not be excluded as the DNA donor of the major component
of the mixture obtained from the sperm cell fraction of the .pan'ties. The frequency
of the major component of this mixture from an unrelated individual chosen at
random from the population at large is less than 1 in 5-.1 X 1016 iii Ai`rican
American, Caucasian, and Hispanic populations CFBI database).” (Tliis is like
saying one chance out of several billion people) '
The report says nothing about DNA from another male source being observed in
any of the samples taken from the complainant ‘ ` '
ama if wi citde wing
Because of the report, I need to know from you whether there is another basis for
attacking the DNA 'results, or if you have any facts that I can argue to make
identity a_n issue and get new DNA testing done. __ _‘
I have an unpublished opinion from the Court of Ciiminal Appeals on a' Petition
for Discretionary Review which I believe I can use to argue for new testing to be
done. Therefore, it is important that you provide me with any facts that_l can ar&i_' e
to the Judg_ e_of the 180th to get new testing done. ` ' '
Al;so-, I did see that you have alleged what could arguably be called a “set-~up”l by -
Sgt. Washington who was having an affair with your wife. Can you provide me
with more information regarding the “set-up” so I can see if I can use tl_ia`t
information? ` ' _
_ . __ _. .-\ u o rl\`h-,l-M1 '|\ll/ 'LH¥".mn n]rc`j 91 NWQA maj-\Yi
ll
J
I am also checkinth see whether DNA testing techniques and methodology have_
_§hange.d sufficiently since 2005 so that l can also make the argument of newer and
more accurate_testing techniques require re~test§ing. Further, Identigene is no longer
2
4 _
- § - till-1a howe Or>lsvi_\.i~i.-'('
N\' h&iw(l\.xnumu.kim\nu~rtwi la 4
if
based in Houston and has merged with a company based in Utah. Identigene is
now known as Sorenson Forensics. l ain hoping that l can also use that to your
benefit and get new DNA testing done. NX 57 (€)
Please write and give me whatever information you have or you think l should
y know. Also, if you have any questions, feel free to ask and l will try to answer
them for you.
On April 20, 2012, the DA and I have a status meeting with the Court to see what
is happening with your case and whether it looks like there is a basis lfor requiring
new DNA testing this is not a hearing on you motion, but rather a meeting so the
Court knows that we are working on your case. l anticipate that at the meetingthe
Court will likely give us an actual court date for the DA, and I to make our
arguments I will certainly let you know when that is occurring
l look forward to hearing from you_.
Very truly yours, _
M 37 /'
, , - / / /l/ :_
ij
‘Leah M.'Borg 4
AP)G 57.£¢)
' LEAH M. BORG
_ ATTORNEY AT `LAW
d 874 YORKCH'ESTER NO. 123
HOUSTON, TEXAS 77079
TEL-, & FAX~: 713-..468-3618
.Tyrone Berry v
TDC.I # 1368050 4 _
George Beto Unit » _
1391 F. M. 3328 ‘ No `J(t.
Tennessee Colony, Texas 75 880 .
Re: Cause No. 1019634;180th District Court of Harris County, Texas; DNA
Motions ,
De_ar Mr. Berry:
d Enclosed please find the writ documents you provided to me for’review. You
understand that I am not appointed to represent you for the purpose of any pending
writ, but for the purpose of the DNA motion. ln other words, I am trying to get
new DNA testing done for you.
I did find the State’ s proposed findings and your notes interesting, especially with
regard to Nos. 27 and 59-60.
I have a redacted copy off the DNA testing that was done by Identigene and have
read through the actual unredacted report;. (I have not been able to get a copy of the
complete report yet because of privacy rights of Bi‘itlney Smith)». W-ith respect to
No. 27, it appears your tn`al attorney examined the report from Identigene and did
not notice that the testing done on Bri'tt_ney Smith’s samples were dated May 10,
2005 , so when the report states that there was an “identiiiable major male "".`
component of unknown origin’ ’in the sperm cell fraction of the panties, I believe it
- means that they did not yet.have a DNA sample with which to compare it since the
lDNA sample taken from you was not tested until May 31, 2005 , three weeks later.
With respect to Nos. 59-60, are you saying that the DNA sample (buccal swabs)
were taken from you at court without the presence of_ your attorney on June 30,
.2005? This date is nearly one month irom the date on the Identigene Report!
them am tit ha chthi 011 ct ill ab that 10 1~1 lsi/mai tow 111/nw
1 \'( hlt¢. iii-wo ila fluia'l.)lk‘(.
E)u~il)m'l\lm §"1)01111"1 pair l"\l/t‘/li')=t iON.
' before court begins and take the swab? Please provide me as much information as
'_you can recall a_bout what happened on this day Depending on what you tell me
case, l noticed that there was a statement regarding the testing done on the vaginal §§
swabs which said there were: “ Numerous possible additional alleles below § a
threshold. ...” .I do not lmow whether these alleles (like portions of chror_nosomes) D ;-3
are attributed to you or whether they are attributed to an unknown person(s); the 12 §
report is unclear. lt is my intent to argue that the presence of the alleles are § `~._/_ j:
indicative of contamination in the testing procedure and therefore you are entitled -Z 5 §§
to new DNA testing @ 3 ~'~"
cn>) §
3 'S “-‘
l will keep working to try to get as many arguments as possible together to get you _, \_`-'-' \]‘;
ne_w DNA testing due tl'tmiai~i aka mar firm F-ii.r'n ‘~`;; § §
a _.~ v
l also wanted to let you know about a meeting I had with the Di_sm'ct Attomey 2 §§
assigned to your case with respect to the DNA motions.. He is obtaining addition § \}: §
. documents and has requested specific information ii"om HPD about the “property” "‘ ` `,_ j
or items that they may have retained for possible future DNA testing He also § § §
indicated to me that he MIGHT (please note that this is not agreement on his part; d 35 3
only an indication that possibly/maybe) agree to fi'.ltu_re DNA testing We are "~Z F m
l.
Purther, when the sample was taken from you (whether it was May or june 2005),_
were you in custody or out on bond? Did you see or get a copy of the search
warrant (autliorizing seizure/taking of the buccal swabs) that was signed by the
Court in order to obtain the sarnple? Do you know why your attorney was not
present? Was he in trial in another court? Did the officer give your attorney
sufficient time to get to court for the taking of the swab or did he show up early
‘t"z`
l
l
happened, I may be able to use it to get new DNA testing for you. l have always
been present'when buccal swabs are taken ii'om my client so that l can observe the '
procedure that oflicer uses and can make sure that no contamination occurs and
nothing “shady” is done. I do not know whether the absence of your trial attorney
alone is sufficient to get you new DNA testin but I can add it to the list of reasons_
lam develoin_. 111 ii _ .. Hi
Also, as l indicated to you l would research the present methodology for DNA
testing for any advances that have occurred since May 31, 2005 when this testing
was doneLI did find quite a few scientiiic papers that discussed contamination of
the samples among other issues.v When l read through the Identigene report in your
-Ai tilmci\hiel'.oum misc Prsocrven heater DD 'D/r
tai-1101 100 ‘5’1!><'1\1,'> Pvix,i>o\~i/.r.
currently set for anome;MmLtmg_at court on July 20 2012 at which time l
will know exactly where he stands whether in agreement to or in opposition to
future DNA testing l will keep you informed if he agrees to DN_A testing before
that date and let you know the outcome of that meeting
mimi`¢
55 Ar>x§l
135
F, 4__. ancillth FEES EX_FENSE CLAjM " ' sma °-nly md:{mm:‘-pdcmm l | v J _ b
7‘4 u,\~'ogi_r )I.)ii]rici.ss.rmz_€ol;. cc`gl:]£lcz>zrs:i-r?\f::tx;§c£pcu jim '”7'""-“ °‘7'-’ b° °“"’°""‘L eci "77'“ "`“'“ h mld highly in i"'k'
pma mm dame pr§;dse N:oicl`>f: a:w°m Cli'ai'g_e 7
_ _ 1017033) w Se>¢ flewg
TOTAl,
P_osr c'oNvicTioN PRocEEDiNGS §‘.¥: 5 days or 'l`ranscript > 800 Pages, Preparation $75 7 $4,500 7
of Motion for New Tr~ia_l_ __ _, , _
New Br`ief After PDR Granted 7 7 ` . w $75 _ _$1,500
APITALA § 7 7 7 7 7 4_ 4
§§ . 1:1 ca Pena._ty No`t o_ght, Prepara_tion of Motion or 5100 $4’_500
`Appeal-Death Penalty Sorrgh_t_-,v Preparation of Motion for 7 5100 $18 000 ‘
Ne_w Trial _ _ __ _
NeW BtiefAftei' PDR Gra.nted _ ' $100 $72, 0007
Non-Capital 4 4 7 _` 7 7 _ $75 $7507 7 7 77
Capital 7 _ ._ 77 _ _ 4$100 7 $1,000
_ o'RAL ARG‘UME=NT‘
Court of Appeals ' __ _ a _ / a 7
Non-Capital '_ -$75 $450
4 Capital _ ` ‘ _ _ 7`$1007 7 36700
C_ourt o`f Crim'rnal Appeals _ , _ 77 _7 .,
Norr-capirai " ' " ' siog _ 3600
Capital Q.§>p_e_al, Death Penalty Given $100 4 _ $l,SOO
t Capital Appeal, Death Penalty Sought_, Not Given ~$1070 v 3600_
4 Capital Ap@l_Death Penalty Not Sought $ 1007 7 $600
Tr_avel Expense___s __ , _7 77 7 7
ln Austin (rio receipts required) _77 7 7 7 4 7 777$200 7_
In Courts of Appeals other than Houstoni 7 7 7 7 7 77 7
Prior approval of Judge required (re_ceipts
required) _
DNA MoTIoN 12 75 rra-5 + tit "Jl».)es er ¢Ww»ee 575 , s#ji'so :§r, __i ~;~'
11.07 WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS_ _ $7"7_757 $2,250 l
HEAR].NG WITH TES'I`IMONY $350/day 7 7
5THER ' " _ _ ~ ' __ .
_ _ , , _ TQI_ALS 7$'_§..1§
bear seemry Numb¢'r here 475 'rs enin 7 '7' ear card Numb='r` `
xxx_ - xx - § 0200 730/3
mrsimgAdarerscNumber sheer sure ciry stare zip`c`bdé)
5’7¢/ Hp A)Lc;_res?a»_e
LEQH' M $b£é' , swear or affirm that the I-larris Countyu Auditor may rely upon the
information contained above to make payment according to the fee schedule adopted by the Boa:r'd of District
Judges Tryiiig C_riminal Ca'ses pursuant to Texas Code of Cn"m`inal Procedure An. 26.0`5.1 further swear or
amrm thatI Ihave nor received nor will l receive anything of value for representing the accused, excan as
otherwise disclosed to the court iri writing; and l wrote this brief and l am solely responsibl for its contents
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBE_D BEFORE ME ON THIS ‘-I'HIE DAY OF ML‘Z§`A. D. 20 /}j
mere ’ /VW"' _
/ / ' ` 4" An`omey Law ignzu`n'é)
REcoRoERs tantamount - ' triable M 4_ Bv/€L, z j
Ai:orney Nam'e (p`riiii legibly) `
O`QURI‘
Cod`it Ng.gmb_er C'ase Nrnmber Defend'arit's Name `{.Ph§}~ -(I>\_U`l`a~r'n
)§’o`“f“' /QI%§<,"P Wzv»_a kay
'Cow,;,nbdezl€_é 7b b @,' wm '7‘1>61' _.)£> ’ 3’.7§#¢1
' DATE lN`TER_lew 11~15 seem infEvaEleME-END w_Arr 1 \
y 3"”’30{7-. . VM S~f/f _3_’]/_)»5<40_1'3 '[Wn- S'~F/\ )
f'/§.'.;v/z l M/ 21.31>~//!\ 8")’
\ll " '
w /,L wi 713-fm P\ F'X ~
32
v@»i.-zow. ':3:3»¢4 ¢/"/_s iii
' 306 ¢/i"3 »L 3 S',;vrs ¢/-/e- 2013 §-
7',;5/3 ', 5-;/',?0/3 ' '{).?/; nav/3-
/
41 jj 906 '
`BEG|N Tl_ME
5’ "7'~ 30/3
RECORDS RESEARCH 1 7%,)§1+25
gun jT_uvj\E ` DESCR\PTloN oF AcT\'vn"Y
DAT'E
W-M Eozxmh_;¢ 0/6 iv /¢v"w
49»1/\.1’_!-|':7 ..
. ./};35}§ `~'
WMQQA`_
/_\
LE-GAL'l RES EARcH 7
END"nME ` '
` DATE 7la_l=,_Gll~lTnviE ` GENERALTOPlc
/Q w_-krrs,:;n
3»23<`,2&> z_ 3m W/;
_me_/ztl_; dfw g%/¢W"UD_DD
__/.2_1‘¢3.'¢ ’_,/'.1/'!/» ' ' . wm iqz¢»XijJ»/WW
7/0’79/4!
OTHE'-R" 7 _
BEG|N `TiME " ENDT|ME `
4 fn ~ 0,§50__-_/»1
5 ~{w'i~ 9 )@-{}-`
' DATE
’)"'/ S'Siv. z
~{,¢¢Pv6 A'b k c
`_ ' ' 7 3 §'mz:» 2
DESCR|PT|O_N OF ACTIV
&';w'f'w 73 pn- 7¢_5+,.5,_
Lg/uv M.§#J'c'\/ /¢lvflh~p 49 iw?
PeRsbNAL.wfonMAnoN
' Bar éard Nu.n;\bzr
D.Z&é 73”~0,,
ocinl Security N_m'nb:r (l.u\ 4 di§\s only) T:_l_q':hon_= Nun_:ber `
xxx - x_x' "75)0¢ (')!3)§€¢3’ j_J"é/v_"
iMai]ing Addr€ss (Nmnbe'r Sn'e'e_t, Sin'xe Ciry Sn_xce Zip Codc)
g’)‘/7 Up@#.cH65T6/z “.jé,_§. H_dz¢.svv~) 73 _ j)_')v“f)¢;…ml __ __ v
, swear or afiirm tth t.h¢ Harris County Auditor may`rely upon the
information c`onm¥'ned above to make payment according to the fee schedule adopted by the Bo_ard of Dist:ict
.Tudges Ti";vmg Crin_iinal Ca_ses pursuant to Tean Code of Crimi'nal Procedure An. 26 05 I further swear or
. a.f}'mn that I have not received nor will I receive anything of value for reprcsénting the accu`s‘ecL except as
oiherwise disclosed to the Coun m wn`ting.
.. - CER-'HFICATION _
LEAH» M- C/Saec»
»'/'_
disinchng y
, cou'R`T
‘ ,'.Prsiding
ZE./irr M 30 ,<é`-m©h (S’M)
BEFOREMEonIsT!-LEO€DAYOF%;Y P__. .
Amm:y Naziie. (pxim le@l!}
AP)<
z
3
§§ § §§ .
.§ ..§F§ L§i §§§
§§ Q\UT> § C\_\.: 5
. vr.um§© Q-m\~$ § §§~§
J»BS§§ § §§ : z
.l . q . .
;._§cm& § 8 §§§_ oz _.322> 335
_=WH»° O>dv H§§. co ____DUD 8 §D§
»__=s u§..w».».¢. E£E=~Y_£ro 2= E=§.. 53 9 .__._.
» d .. E=ou.u=a mo BEBE ._$Ezu_u
Hérris County Crimina| District Docket Shéet
THF. sTATE 01= TExAS_vs. BE_RFW, TvR'oNE
Cause'No.:‘ 101963401010-3 001._111:¢18011`1
Offense».'-¢SEX ASS~LT CH|LD 14-'17 Le\`/e|__: -2nd Deg'ree Felony
Charg‘ing |ns`trument: Fe_|ony lndictment
GENERAL ORDERS OF THE COU`RT
Bond'. $60,600
Next Setting:
Case Dis`positi_on; Disposeu'
Ga'se'$tatus: Com`p|_ete
l__)e_fendanf Staiu§: Disposed
"°1”~11=.»
sra/2000 1=1ea oLmy And Sen1enced_ 4/20/2012 09:.00'/'\1.1 ower
420/2012 De1_e_nda`n_1 BERRY. TvRoNE appeared wim edwrse\ BoRG, LEAH M..
v 4_/20/2012 ` 1 Reee1_ ByAgree'mem 01 sam Fanies 7201§0_12 09:00 AM omer
' 77202_`012 R_eset By Agre‘er_'hent 01 éoth Pam€o,- 920/2012 09:00 AM Other 4
923/2012 Reee1 By ceun, 11/03&012.09:00 AM omer
11`/912012 ` Defendam EERHY,~ TvnoNE appeared wim munse1 BORG»_ '1__EAH M..
11 110/2012 nese1 By ce_un 310012013 09300 AM ome'r `
v 2.'8/2013 l Defehd_am BERRY TvRoNE appeared wnheounse_l BORG LEAH M.. 'H
afa/2013 ceminued 3103/2013 09: 00 AM o1_11er ` 7 l
3/312013 k ` Detendam BE`RR¥, TvRoNE appeared inn compel aone, LEAH M.._
313/2013 Rese! U_pon Prosecu10rs RequesL 4119/2013 09: 00 AM Ou'»er `. w
1110/2013 Derendam aEnn'Y TYhoNE appeared w1_1h counsel sons LEAH M.,
1019/2013 nese1 ay com 5)17)2013 09 00 AM o'1her ' g
5/17/2013 Def_enuam BERRY, TYaoNE appeared w\'m counse1 BORG_ LEAH'M_..
_ 5/17-/2013 Res'é1 U0'on Deten`se Fequesl. 6211 2013 09:00 AM 011~1121
5121_1201`3 peserrdam B_Enm, wéoN_E appeared 'w11h edunee\ 301;-1<3, 1_EA_1-1 111§-.`
521/3013 Reae1 ay oeun§ 1112/2013 00':00`AM other ~ ‘
_ l'7/.1 212013 0e1er1dan_1 BERRY, TY`RDNL= did ne1appe`ar.
n 7/12!2013 Rese! 'By Agreem`e'f,1101801h P,"ar\ies, 7/19/_2`013 09200 A."J| Ot.her
4 7/19/2013 beferidam BEF¢'R'Y, 1“11301~1‘El appeared wim eoun's;ec Bons. LEAH M` ` " `
7/13‘2013 H,es:er rey conn 0109¢01“3 09;00 A.M order
seems d 0e1en1:_an1 BEH»RY. 'rvAONE appeared wm eeur_\sel 13`0136. LEAH M,-. `
Page1011
103/2013 SZ¥SSAM
APX
34
_ Ai>)<§h
- LEAH M. B`ORG
ATTORNEY AT LAW
874 YORKCHESTER NO. 123
HOUSTON, TEXAS 77079
TEL. & FAX: 713-468-.3618
Tyrone Berry
TDC.T # 1368050
George Beto Unit
1391 F. M. 3328"
Tennessee Colony, Texas 75880
Re cruiseNo.1019634;180.“‘Dismcccourcofiiarris counry, Texas; DNA _
Motions
Dear Mr. Berry:
Enclosed please find a courtesy copy of the amended DNAmotion which I filed on
your behalf You will see that i_t is more precise and fact-specific than the motion
_ previously filedint`hisj case-.- ,. - " "
. .\»1 ...r
As you know; the _DA rand I_-_- were set for a status conference in your case on
Septemb`er 28, 2012 Unfoitunately, when I arrived in court, l was informed that
the DA was not in town and therefore was unavailable for the status conference
Your case has therefore been reset the new date" is Nov. 9', 2012. Thist` is not a
hearing date-only a status conference date -
I still have no information from the DA as to whether the DNA samplss previously
_ taken still exist; where such evidence' is located if it does exist;' or, whether the DA
_ will be willing to agree to new DNA test`mg'.
1 do suspect that the DA is still waiting on information &om law enforcement
agencies to provide him with the proper affidavits regarding the location of and the
chain o'f' custody regarding the evidence in this case. I also suspect 'h`e§is" still
waiting for- .-the same from Sorenson Forensics (previously known as IHentigene)
_-Uutil he gets these aftidavits`, the DA cannot take any position in youi' case, other
than to assert that ev _. .- . ,`, _ g was done properly and be opposed to new DNA
.\‘~,-'.
4 .. '.{ab_
_"‘ 0 c ' n
~ AP)( %§§1§~&
_ LEAH M. BoRG §'7[0) \§ a §§~"->`
ATr_oRNEY AT LAw ea § s- s
374 YORKCH.ESTER No. 123 §§.\_: § _
HOUSTON, TEXAS 77079 .~3\_ § g
TEL. & FAX; 713`-468-3618 3 §§ 5\_:=
as - al
Q£§W§
Tyrone Berry §§ § § § `§'.
TDCJ# 13680;50 " >Q‘. 33 5
George Beto Unit _ ' 113 § §§ §
1391 F.. M. 3323 v 4 §§ g § §
Tennessee Colony, Texas 75880 Dec. 17, 2012 § 31 § § §
~_) ’;"""
R¢ cause NO.10_19634 130th Dism'ci Court of Hams Couniy, rexas; DNA § §§ ’\- ré_
Motions § 32 §§
s § >`~
‘ 33 \- §§
Dear Mr Beny: § 553-ij w
s s d
This is to let you know what happened with respect to our last scheduled court §§ 35 §§‘v‘ ucs
1 appearance on Friday, Dec.14, 2012 »
On Thursday,t Dec. 1311", I was called,by the Court’s coordinator and was advised ' §
that the D.- A_. had indicated that he still has not received the affidavits in your case, \__
The coordinator said it was not necessary for the "D A. and I to go to court the next \9 _
day, since there was nothing that could be done. flaum timm (_5@“¢,‘1”0*1'¢_,(_9@-{. 01 §§
lr‘ri»cm, \3<1_¢1\~101 P\Mroi~iom MMI:DDM, foam film Pru)aw) lo 194 05 meai,r'_w' § 1~1
Therefore, since we are still waiting on the affidavits hom the various agencies t § 41
that handled the evidence 1'n your case, your case was reset. d §
T.
`_
l,_tq, These affidavits are absolutel nss _ because the are su . sed to advise »~ _2 §
Court of several things rearding the evidence _`F or example: that the evidence still
exists, that the evidence is in good condition for the taking of additional DNA
sainples, whether DNA was taken horn the evidence, where the evidence is now
located, etc.
mm iii/lug Obv‘iouslya until these agencies provide the aHidav`its on your case, we can ’t get
any relief, i. e new DNA testing and you remain convicte_,d
I can imagine that you are concerned and wondering why _it is taking the various
agencies so long. Frankly-, I was concerned enough to speak with the Court’s
T‘()CP 54Mre‘? CD\) c\./t W\Mi lockout-no lilau/Dt
Y\rusem»vit liab-m atmt,‘,bswuetoo D.w¢z
_ Our next court date is Feb. 8, 2013. _____Hopefully, at that time-, the D A. will have the
_ P\_v)< §/ (b § §
coordinator and I asked her whether she thinks this is unusual for it to take so lon ng .‘Z z
The coordinator advised me that she has noticed that these DNA motions are 53 §
taking a very long time and that your situation was not unusual with regards to § 3
length of time. 5
parole before you sought new DNA testing so, if'you find out that you are not \§ z
being released on parole because of this pending DNA motion, you will need to -3. § d
decide whether you wantt o continge win g gng DNA testing or whether you 3 \3 O
want to di sgiggdnue our efforts and get released on parole: (I mention this because I_:\£ *" §
have heard rumors in the past that pending post-conviction matters have delayed jj § §
the release of inmates on parole, l do not lcnowif this is true, it is just what l have § 3 4
heard. )
aMdavits and we can get the Court to order new DNA testing for you.
Uiifortunately, you will have to be patient for just a bit longer.
Pleas'e write if you have any questions or concerns Further, if `you learn that this
matter is preventing your parole out and you decide to ve u ursuin new DNA
testing, you must advise me of that decision in writing.
\\;U_ A’l’loailt)f
Vje@/ §
Leah M. ‘Borg
i’[BWW'\
/
¢)
`l‘:'l?i.»f\M-c_r ‘Co C.D.f>t\t laura Ci,l\tm
mo Daown~wfmol? N;Pi'ft-')imt»-
,,.._b-
r'¢"'\
Ap(>ou~t»ta,d)rwcllvuuvcl mt
"DPP
~ l.l\kw‘§rat,wa§
mt-
tchthcow"'
hom
LEAH M. -BORG . »
ATTORNEY AT LAw ' AW j 7(€/)
874 YoRKCHESTER No. 123 j
HOUSTON, TEXAS 77079
TEL. & FAX; 713-468-3618
Tyrone.B'err-y
T.DCJ # 1368050
George Beto Unit
1391 _F-.M. 3328 4 hhs bic/cgl
Tennessee Colony,_ Texas 75880
Re causeN<_>.1019634,180“’D1$mctcounofHam's counry, Te_xas, DNA
Motions
Deaer. Berry:
This is to inform you that I have been appointed by the Court to represent you
regarding the various DNA motions you have filed.
l have read through the documents you 'flled, as well` as the Court’s 'iile in this case
and have read through several post-conviction files of yours regarding various
writs you have flled. l have done this to best understand any basis for post-
conviction DNA testing
Of particular importance to me was your statement that your trial attorney had
advised you that the DNA testing revealed that there were several sperm donors in
the sample that was tested. lf correct, this would be extremely important in getting
new testing done.
l have obtained a copy of the report from Identigene which did the 'DNA testing in
your case in order to ascertain whether there was more than one sperm donor.
` The report from Identigene says that:
1. samples were taken h'om Brittney Smith and the panties which she was alleged
to_`_have worn; W a full DNA pronle of Brittney Smith was
obtained; ` '
`i\lo liqtoammmtl linn/mma Nm”\watu tm cs
blm \Hc\.,uf>t.v l\~\’l'\w/flflmtot~t.
2. a buccal swab sample was taken from you and nom this sample _a full DNA )
profile for you was also obtained; ' " A -- d
~Px57(
3. a mixture of male and female DNA was obtained from the sperm cell fraction of
the vaginal swabs and you could not be excluded as a contributor to the mixture;
4. a'mixrure er male and fema1e DNA was obtained nom the sperm ee11 aaerien er
the panties alleged to have been worn by the complainant, and you again could not
be excluded as the DNA donor;
t‘_ n
`
5. although the-report says DNA is obtained h"om_ at least two individuals, it means
that DNA was definitely obtained h'om Br_ittney Smith and from you;
hhl’“’”d WWIU spw'm wm
mmi/ll 91 Mj,¢l(p wua<)“m~dotuw;"m},u\oamvgqm§q
6. and, that you could “not be excluded as the DNA donor of the major component
of the mixture obtained from the sperm cell nact'ion of the panties. The frequency
of the major component of this'mix_ture from an unrelated individual chosen at
random from the population at large 'is less than l in 5-.l X lO16 in African
American, Caucasi_an, and Hispanic populations (FBI database).” (Th'is is like
saying one chance out of several billion people)
The report says nothing about DNA from another male source being observed in
any of the samples`taken from the complainant ' ' '
amm;m otth wong
Because of the report, I need to know from you whether there is another basis for
attacking the DNA results, or if you have any facts that I can argge to make
identity an issue and get new DNA-_ testing done. _ _ ..
¢ nw»+-MM\I|/ 'M`|'y|"|_mnn]'mq1 quo,\ mmsd
I have an unpublished opinion Jn'om the Court of C-ri'minal Appeals on a' Petition
for Discretionary _Review which I believe l can use to argue for new testing to be
done. Therefore, it is important that you provide me with any facts that'I can_argy_e
_to the ludge _of the 180th to get new testing done. ' ` '
.-,_¢ nn n
,"M
ll
L.’.
w
Also-, I did see that you have alleged what could arguably be called a “set-'up"’l by
Sgt. Washington who was having an affair with your wife. Can you provide me
with more information regarding the “set-'up” so I can see ifI can use that
information? `
I am also checking to see whether DNA testing techniques and methodology have
__£hanged sufficiently since 2005 so that I can also make the argument of newer and
more accurate_test'ing technicmes require re~testing. Further, Identigene is no longer
2
tfsvuiw'(i 1
‘ alma txme
~\' lh&iw(l\znumtpam\'owl't~r k. t
ft
-£(
based in Houston and has merged with a company based in Uta.h. Identigene is
now known as Sorcnson Forensics-. lI arn hoping that I can also use that to your
benefit and get new DNA testing done. N ¥ 57 (e)
Please write and give me whatever information you have or you think I should
z know.. Also, if you have any questions, feel free to ask and I will try to answer
them for you
On Apri_l 20, 2012 the DA and I have a status meeting with the Court to see what
is happening with your- case and whether it looks like there rs a basis for requiring
new DNA testing.. .this 1s not a hearing on you motion, but rather a meeting so the
Court knows that we are working on your case. I anticipate that at the meetingthe
Court will likely give us an actual court date for the DA4 and I to make our
arguments I will certainly let you know when that is og_mnng,
I look forward to hearing nom you,
Veryrtruly yours,
'Le'ah M. 'Borg
AP)G .7)7@)
- LEAH M. BORG
_ ATTORNEY AT LAW
874 YORKCHESTER No. 123
HOUSTON, TEXAS 77079
TEL. & FAX= 713-468-3618
lT_yrone Beny _ l
TDCJ # 1368050 _
George Beto Unit N
1391 .F. M._ 332_8 . ` o WE,
Tennessee Colony, Tean 75 880 _
Re: Cause No._1019634;180th District Court of Harrls County, .;Texas DNA
Motions
'Dear Mr. Berry:
l Enclosed please find the writ documents you provided to rr_l_e for review. You
understand that I am not appointed to represent you for the purpose of any pending
writ, but for the purpose of the DNA motion. ln other words, l am trying to get
new DNA testing done for you.
I did find the State’ s proposed findings and your notes interesting, especially with
regard to Nos. 27 and 59-60. ~
I have a redacted copy o'f the'DNA testing that was done by Identigene and have
read through the actual unredacted repo_rt. (I have not been able to get a copy of the
complete report yet because of privacy rights of Br_"i'ttney Smith). With respect to
No. 2.7, it appears your trial attorney examined the report from Identigene and did
not notice that the testing done on Brittney Smith’s samples were dated ,May 10,
2005 so when the report states that there was an “identiiiable major male `."
component of unknown origin” irl the sperm cell fraction of the panties, I believe it
- means that they did not yet:have -a DNA sample with which to compare it since the
lDNA sample taken from you was not tested until May 31, 2005 , three weeks later.
With respect to Nos. 59- 60, are you saying that the DNA sample (buccal swabs)
were taken from you at court without the presence of your attorney on June 30,
2005? This date ls nearly one month from the date on the Identigene Report!
E)trtl§lo'l\lot §omh\'t part l'\)/l"/ttl-t \/ON.
sham am L,lt/ keim/001 0111,% h ab that 10 11 lsi/wsm tow umw
14 illt¢. 1111/ce 1111 imc/Onoe
Further, when the sample was taken from you (whether it was May or lane 2005), .
were you in custody or out on bond? Did you see or get a copy of the search
warrant (authorizing seizure/taking of the buccal swabs) that was signed by the
q Court in order to obtain the sample? Do you know why your attorney was not
present? Was he in trial in another court? Did the officer give your attorney
sumcientl time to get to court for the taking of the swab or did he show up early
` before court begins and take the swab? Please provide me as much information as
you can recall a_bou't what happened on this day. Depending on what you tell me
happened-, I may be able to use it to get new DNA testing for you. I have always
been present when buccal swabs are taken from my client so that I can observe the `
procedure that officer uses and can make sure that no contamination occurs and
nothing “shady” is done. I do not know whether the absence of your trial attorney
' alone is sufficient to get you new DNA testin_ but I can_add it to the list of reasons
I am develo_`in _.
0 'DM'¢,
t
Also, as I indicated to you l would research the present methodology for DNA
testing for any advances that have occurred since May 31, 2005 when this testing
was done. I_ did ind quite a few scientific papers that discussed contamination of
the samples among other issues When I read through the Identigene report in your
case, I noticed that there was a statement regarding the testing done on the vaginal
swabs which said there were: .. Numerous possible additional alleles below
threshold ...’~’ .I do not know whether these alleles (like portions of chromosomes)
are attributed to you or whether they are attributed to an unknown person(s); the
-A1 ttl.mcuTwe('.o\-)r'1(01)‘5'11><'111,"> huston-sa
F\L.t._o Dr~l'l'l».\leD.‘o
"V\w>iw‘
ATToRNEiz:A:r-t:tw _ " '
874 YORKCHESTER Ne 123 - 1 ~l>l?¥57 li}
HoUsToN, TExAs 77079
TEL. & FAx=. 713-463-3618
Tyrone Berry
TDCJ -# 1363050
George __Beto Unit
1391 F. M. 3328_' `
Tennessee Colony, Texas 75880
Re: Cause No. 1019634; 180th District Court of Harris County, Texas; DNA
Motions
»~
Dear Mr~. .Beny;
Enclosed please find a courtesy copy of the amended DNA motion which I lfiled on
your behalf. Yo_u will see that it 1_sir_i9re precise and fact-specific than the motion
_ previously tiledin this case. ,.;_. i.i.__,. , ‘_M__ ~'_. = . .
A's you know; the DA and _I were set for a status conference in your case on
September 28 2012':` Unfortunately, when I arrived 1_1'1 c_ourt, l was informed that
the DA was not in town and therefore was unavailable for the status conference .
Yeur case has therefore been reset; the new date is Nov. 9, 2012. This~f' is net a
hearing date-only a status conference date.
I still have no information horn the DA as to whether the DNA Samplés previously
taken still exist; where such evidence is located if it does exist; or, whether the DA
_ will be willing to agree to new DNA testing
I do suspect that the DA is still waiting on information from law enforcement
agencies to provide him with the proper ahidavits regarding the location of and the
chain of custody regarding_.__ the evidence 111 this case. I also suspect he is-: still
waiting for the same from S_orenson Forenslcs (prevlotisly known as ldcr'iti’g‘erie).
*Uiitil he gets these aHidavits, the DA cannot take any position in youi case, other
than to assert that everything was done properly and be opposed to new DNA
-l' ."
[.§..` :- -_i .
testing This position could very easily change though, depending on the .D&P )L j / l<))
information he gets from law enforcement and Sorenson Forensics. (I recently
heard that the DA on your case had gone to TDC to obtain swabs from another
individual for DNA testing, so l l<:now that under the right circumstances, new
DNA testing can be done for inmates out of Harris County, so please be patient
and remain hopeful. ) »
If l get any new information from the DA prior to the next status conference, I will
write and give you that information For now, `I have nothing new to tell you-.
lf you have any questions-t please feel free to write.
Very truly yours,
- Enclosure
P. S._ You will see that, in the amended motion, I have requested that if we get new
DNA testing, I specifically want to be present for the taking of the swabs. I lmow
that the DA often goes with an oHicer to TDC for this purpose in order to avoid
bringing an inmate back to Harris County, If you are OK with the swab being
taken at TDC (with me present) or would prefer to be brought back to Harris
County for the taking of the swabs, let me know your preference, so that l can
argue that to the Judge, if necessar-y, on Nov. 9th.
"*i.~_
l PETrrloNER would show ihefonowiog: NL 2 0 int-z
O/€ la- north
\ M\./){l~‘-f (635
CausevNo. `1019634
moNE.BERRy_ § INTHE msch com oF V<é
v. § HARRiscoUNTY,TExAs k 38
niesrmi 01= TEXAS §. ison*mmcmr, Dlsmcr' ' PX a
TO 'l'I-IE HONORABLE IUDGE OF' lS'AID COURT`:
COMES NOW; 'TYRON'E.-BERRY, 'PEI'I'II[ONER in the above entitled and numbered
eeuse ssd prssusm.¢o chapter M.of'rhe ims code ofcrimiosi Proeedirre;hies this “Fhsi
Amended Motion for _Foxe_nsic D. N_. A. Testing,'" requesh`ng this Honorab_le Court-to grant
_ - D
' approval of'D~NA.. mfihg ofevi.dence'pr€viousl'y obtained iii t_@ ¢Lls§“`§§mpon Whmo£ the
. "s . ~-
" g§»\t`ric\ mem
Tim`e‘. isd¢iE\C°-““~‘*'T°'as. . `
.PEI'IHONER‘asse.ns that asa person~convicted o .. `. _\ t§“fighas the right
under chsprer 64 ofthe Texss code ofcrimiml' Proeedure, 'ro reques¢rieipost.-eooviesioo
forensic D.N.A. testingbe done for die following reasons
' 1... some evidence was previously rested.io May 2005, bur riow, injuiy ~20'12, there are heuer
ways to ted:for D.N.. pt rhsr eould provide mores_eemsie remisst die reside ofthe previous
test(s).. Further; lsome.o'f‘this evidence, namer buccal SW`&bS', is imported to have been taken
from PETmoNER orr Msreh.29, 200_5, were raises .wiihom the preseoee ofPEnnoNER’s
attomey; Rick Detot_o,to observe and'make'cezta_iii_ that the “w_anant” to take such evidence &om
PE‘rmoNER was s vslidwsrrsrrr, and `fmher co drake eerioirr thai-me methodology and
'AP)¢§B}>
proeedures utilized by H..P. D. -ofiieer T.. Gi_ieirero inrai:singthe`swaoswere eorreer and wirliour
question _
II" .
PErrmoN_ER hether asserts thatiliis Honoiaole conn should olii)ER.new n.N;.A
testing of all evidence ti'oin which D. N. A. may be obtained forthe following reasons:
1 . Evidence exists that`b_y its nature permits D.. N...A. testing,_ namely panties alleged.to havebeen
worn,by the complainant as well as vaginal swahspuiporred to have been taken horn the
Complainant;
2. The evidence was subjected toprevious D. N..A. testing by techniques that are now
superseded hy'more accurate techniques that-are less prone to contamination fi"om imlmown
sources;
3. The evidence held by the~Houston.Poi_ice Department and/or Sorenson l-`ot_ensics, formerly
jimown.as Idenn'gene», should.be in_.a condiiioi_lzmakif'ig D.» `N. A., testing possi'ble;
-4. Thechain of'cu_stody'ofthe evidence by'the H_ouston Police Deparunent-an_d/or Somnson
Forensic's and/or the Harris' County Dis.tr_ict Ci_erk’.s QEce, _sl__ioul’d be sufficient to establish that
rhe evidenee has nor been substituted manned with, replseed, or alrer`ed.in any~rnarensl respeer;
.5`. Idenlity was and remains an issue in'th'e underlying criminal case, despite PETI'I'IONER"S
plea of guilty, because, .as the lone accused in'this case, exculpatory `D. N. A testingwould prove
PEH'HONER’.$ innocence ( see Blaekloeis v. stare235 s. w. 3d 23:1- ('rers_ crirrtl App. 2007_);
ANch
5. The PETrrroNi.-:R:is-presentiy~ in the eustod'y ofthe Tmras. Deparunimt. of crimimi Jiistiee-,
serving his sentence in this case, and therefore establishes by a pmcndera_nce of the evidence
that his request for .D. N. A. testing is not made to unreasonably delay the execution of sentence
- or administration ofj_ustice.
' lIi.
reimon asserts that as further evidenee in support orbit trust Amended Motion
for Fo'rens,ic D. N. A. Testing” .is .Ident'igene’s lab report # L05~3609; on the D. N. Aa mg
originally done irl.May 2005~, specifically
l. resting done May __10, zoos; evidenee obtained from tbe complainant the report states mar “_A
mixtrne ot-maie and female DNA_from at least two individuals was obtained . ._." rsi'r-HONER
asserts that that the SIHt¢m¢lil that'DNA join AT LEAST TWO IN`DIVIDUALS `is indicative
of_possibly more than two contributors and therefore contamination especially'in light of the fact
that Pcii testing-was done and Pcii testing is more suseeptible to eontamina_tion PETIHONER
asserts that where'ther'e is a possibilityof contamination, justice requires that new D. N. A
testing be done.
Z. Further in the report'.of May 10, 2005, is the statement that ‘~‘Brittiiey Smith cannot be
eaeluded as a possible eontributor to the minor eoinponent or this mortine. Alleier foreign to
Brittney Smith were observed iri theminor component cf this mixturer" `PE.'ITI'IONER asserts-
that the presence of'alleles foreign to the Complainznt are also found in the minor component of
the mixture along with Complai`na'nt"s, are further evidence of contamination in the testing
procedure thereby necedeth ne"w':D. N. ,A.. testing.
3. Addiiionally», in the lab report dated May 31, 2005, the renewing statements are made: “A
martino or male and temaiefl)l~iA_nom atl_east two individuals was obtained nom the sperm eeli
kit 58 cl
fraction of the vaginal swabs [159081_]. .’I`yrone Berry eannot.be excluded as a possible
contributor to this mixture However, .due to numerous possible additional alleles below
threshold,_ statistical analysi§ will not be performed evaluating the probability of inclusion.”
PETI.TIONER asserts that these statements indicate that two or more individuals contributed to .
the mixture, and, since there are numerous additional allel§ it is higily likely that the previous
lD. N. A. testing that‘Wa_S th_l_e in 2005 by Identigene was contaminated The interests of jusu`ce
therefore require new D. N, A_. testing be done.
IV.
P_ETITIONE`R requests that this Honorable Court order all entities iii custody of evidence
seized in this case, whether the Hoi;r;stor_i__l>olioe Depaihrient, sorenson l=orensios, the Harris
Coimty Disuict Cl_erk’s O$_ce, ojr any other entity-, presently unknown to PE-TI'I'IONER, provide
all evidmce obtained from the Compl_ainarit and all other evidence from which D. N.. A. may be
obtained to the forensic laboratory designated b`y this Court, for new D.N. A. testing and provide
to thi__s Court and the attorneys for PETITIONER and the State, a written “inventoty” or other l
written record and detonation ofthe evidence provided to the forensio laboratory for tmting.
ifthe evidenee requested herein eannot be presented for testing, the _PETII'IONER
requests that this Court O`rder all entities Uouston Police Department -So_renson Forensic_s,» the
HauisColmty Distr'ict Clerk's OEce, etc. ..) in possession of evidence seized in this case,
including but riot limited to the panties purported to have been worn by.Compla'inant and the
vaginalswabspirrportedtohnvebeentaltennointhe`cotnplainant,eirplaininwritingtothi_s
Court, why such evidence cannot be presented to this Couri.
M>< 596
PE'I.'IHONER fin'the_r;requests that new buccal‘ swabs from-him beobtained pmsuant'to a
V.
new warrant signed by'thi's Court and that thetaking of~such swabs be done only in the-presence
of'his undersigned anotney arm Laah. M. Botg..
` vi
PE'.I'I"I`IONER theie'fore~:~requests'that this Court setthis.mat,terforaheaiingtheteon to
intimate '
l. that evidence sill exists.i'n a. condition making D. N. A-.. testing possible and to detamine the
nitie's ( and contact ioformation) in possession of all such evidence;
2. that the evidence in possession of such entities has been:subject`ed to a chain of custody
stinisien_t to establish that it has nnt.hsnn tampsind.with, tepinnnd, at aimed in any.ntaietial
3.that identity .is»-an issue indie\mde_rlying criminal..cas¢;
v4~. that PETE["IONER was the lone:accuscd and.as such,. would nothave beenf.i>uii¢..l guilty if
exculpatory D-N. A..testing results would have been obtained;
5. the request for and performance ofnew D..fN. A. testing wouldnot- unreasonably delay the
session °tPEi-moNE~it's santnissnt-ths administiannn stinan since mmon is
'Pm¢.ntly serving the~sen.ten<=e assessed in the imderiymscnmmal case;'
6. the lab Report E'om- identigene, which performed the originaf D. `N`. A.. testing in,20.05,
indicates the possibility-, if'not probability, of.cantamination.in the tesingprocedures
PETITIONER requests that this Comt; shoiild.i_t-‘detennihe and order`that 'PE'I'»ITI`IONER
is not antitiadstn new D, N. insisting indicates tha taiieftaqiiasteihetein thatthi`scnmt make
P\v¢§@-i-
wriueniindiags of fact and conclusions of l`aw~a_t'the= conclusion of thehearing iii-order to
preserve any issues for appellate review.
WHE_REFORE, premises oon`sidei'ed, the PE'I"I'I'IONER'prays that this Co`ui"t giant all
mhefrequested herein and for sueh'= and other relief; whether general.oi-'speei'al, a`_t:ia'w or.in 1
equity, to which this Couit deems PET?ITI.'IONER justly eni_itled-,.
LEAH.M;.Boiid '
.A'I'.I?ORNEY .FOR_ PE'I'ITIONE_ 1 TYRONE `BERRY
' 874 Yoiu/l .
on die 7/~‘_\ day of' ' 354;431_* ,-20+2,_ eeme.robeheord“P "rioiier's '
Pirsr Amerided.Moriori for Forerisie D..NA. Tesiirigj’ ind die cr>~iiri,l having eoiisi_dered_ die
__ evidelnceand'arg\`im¢fllof'¢dunsel,is-oftheo_'F-.:'-'1~¢ ‘= otionsha.llb_e:
.GRANTED
ms memoRE oRDEREn nder an eiiiiiieeiii custody ofevideriee seizediii this ease die
Horrsrori Polise Depirmerii -soreiisoii'l=orerisies-, die Harris county msdder clerks omee,
Othet":
shin provide all suerr_ evideoee-w aris connor die forensic iiborsrory desigiiiedbydiis com
namely,
For new tbrensic- D_. N. A_. testing~.
rr rs FuRTrIER.oRDEREn mr ifriieevideiiee morris preeeritedfor iesiirig, seen enriry
in possession or~»cn’stody of such ev`idmce shall explain in writing to this Court'why such
evidence cannot he presented`for new D‘._N_. A. testing,
l desist
I'I` lS FUR'I'HER ORDBRE'D 'llHA'ItheSt`ate shallprepare anewwarrantfor‘thetakiagof'a D.
N. A. sample from PE'I'IIIONER TYRON'E BERRY and that a copy of the warrant shall be
timely provided to the attorney for PE'I_'l-'I'IONER.
rr ls FURTHE_R 0RDRE,D mm 4tiie~r‘iir'irig-of the D. N. a ssrriplei'roiri ratinon shall
be conducted.in the presence of the attomey' of record for PEI.`ITIONER, Le'ah M. Borg.
IT I_S FURH{BR ORDERED THA"I-`:
signed AUE n 9 2313 - ,2012.
JUDGE PRF._sn)ING ware Brown
lowe
L\rsiit
CatrseNo. `1019634
mont B_ERRY § :n~t iiiii msch coURT or
v_ l ' §- HARR_iscot_JNTY, texas
iiiiisTAiE oi~¢ TaxAs' § 1-st)'-‘*'JUD1_C1ALD1srR1c':r'
_ _ isn
On the z{"‘\ y day of` _ H‘*,~I “Sf` .,‘__2941'!-, came-to be»heard ‘~‘~Petiioner’s
Piijst_ Am'_end_ed Motion for Forensi'd-D»N.A. Tesiing” and the C_o_u`tt, havingconsidered the
evidence andarg\mleat of'Counsel, is~of'~the ~.-.'~- :.'e- .- o.~ions'ha]l'be:
ms Ti:iEREFORE oiii)ERiiD mAr' sit contietin otistoriy ofeviden§oe seizedtn this eese, the
Henston Police Department sorenson Forensies-, the Harris county nisnietcierir's_ oftiee_,
Shall provide all such evidence-to this Court o'r the forensic laboratory designated_by'th'is Cou_rt_,
mmely~, 7 ____ __ __ __
Po'r new fowosic~`D. N. A. tesing.
I~'r is FuiiTHi-:R.QRDERED i'iHAT iftheevidcoce eannothe-pteiented_t'or testing, each entity
in possession or'-ci'i_'stody ~of' such evidence Sh_a._ll explain in writing to this Court why such
evidence cannot he presented for'new D.N. A__.tesnng.
M$€d
I'I`IS FUR'[HER ORDEREDTHATdie.Stateshallprepa`reanewwan'amfordietakingofab.
N. A,_ sample from PEH]TONER TYRONE BERRY and that a copy of the warrant shall be
timely provided to the attorney for~PETI-'l`IONER.
I'[` IS FURTHE_R ORDRED 'I'HAT the‘taki`ng'of the D. N. A_. Sample ‘i'om PET[HONER Shall
be conducted _in the presence of the attomey of record for PEHTTONER, Lea_h_ M_. Bor'g.
I'I` IS FURTHER ORDERED THAT:
signed AUG o 9 2313 ~ ,20'12_.,
JuDGE PRESIDI*NG Marc Bi'own
\°)\Qite
7
pilo'f 1014
procedinesutilizedby H.P. D OiicerT..Guenei"c taldngtheswabswerecorrectaodwithoiit
question t l ` - Ap)<§q
lI.
estimon anrher osserts thnt this Honornht_e court shontd o_RDER newi). 'N. n
testing of all evidence iam which D. N. A. may lie-obtained i)r'the following.reasons:
fl . .Evidence exists thatby its maine permits D..N. A. testing, namely panies alleged.to havebeen
9 worn by the Complainant as well as vaginal swahs,_purpom't_l to have been taken’fromthe
iv complainant
2. The evidence was subjech toprevious D. N.Ai testing by techniques that are now
superseded by'mor`e accurate techniques that:are less prone to contamination i'om unknown
S°\lIU¢S;
3. '_I'he evidence held by the Houston Police Department and/or Soren_son Fbrensics, formerly
known as ldeni_gene, should_be in a condition making D.`N. .A.. testing possible;
~4`. The chain of`custody'o'f the evidence, by'the Houston Police Deparnaent- and/or Sorenson
Forensics and/or the Harris County Dis_tric\ Clerk’s OEc'e., should be su$`cient to eita_l>lisb that
the evidence has oot ban snhsttoned, tampered with, repinoed, or niteredin nny~rirsteriii rcspect;
_5`-. lde_n‘i_i_ty was and remains an issue mtiieimderlymg criminal case, despite PETII'IONER'S
plea of `guilty, wause, -as the lone accused in this case, exculpatory D. vN. A testing would prove
PnrmoNr-;R's innocence ( see mg oct v. siste_z-ss s. w. saa-31 (reic criin App. 200-7);
* ltl\l'mt~\ir,§r\t/WWVLT \’T
€am¢tr)`ilm unuRit/,ow”
APi< Ll§
fLEAH M. BORG
AiToRNEY AT LAW
874 YORKCHESTER No. 123
HOUSTON, TEXAS 770'79
TEL. & FAX= 713-468-3618
Tyrone Berry
TDCJ # 1368050
George Beto Unit _ . 4
1391 F. M. 3328 1 _ Mb DML_
Tennessee Colony, Texas 75880
_Re: cause No. 1019634; 1130th Disni_ct conn oanrris county, Texas; DNA
`Motions .
Dear Mr. .Berry:
This is to inform you that I have been appointed by the Court to represent you
regarding the various DNA motions you have nled - t w "-°`5
I have read through the documents you liled, as well as the Court’ s Ele in this case
and have read through several post-conviction liles of yours regarding various
writs you have liled. I have done this to best understand any basis for post-
conviction DNA testing ` ' '
Of particular importance to me was your statement that your trial attorney had
advised you that the DNA testing revealed that there were several sperm donors in
the sample that was tested. If correct this would he extremely important in getting
new testing done . .
. I have obtained a copy of the report ii'o'm Identigene which did the DNA testing in
your case in order to ascertain whether there was more than one sperm donor.
The report nom Identigene says that
l. samples were taken ii"oni Brittney Smith and the panties which she was alleged
to have worn ' 4 - " v "`lel a full DNA profile of Brittney Snuth was
ohtain'ed;" " ' """': ""
l"C'au_seNo. 1019634 N>)( Lf(p ll
sure or ri=.xAs § iN me i so“‘ olsch count
v. ` . § Oi='
movie BERRY, ` . ' .~ » § minus coUNTY, rex/ts
Defendan_r
srAm*s Mori_oN RE_QUELINQ count 'ro DENY DNA g s'i'iNG
COMES NOW the State of Texas,‘by a_n_d through the undersigned Assistant District Attomey,
end, in response to the defendnnt’_s request for postconviction DNA testing pursuant to chapter 54 of the
'I`exas Code of Crim'inal Procedure, respectfully requests that the Court deny DNA testing of evidence in
the above-styled case and t`or good cause shows the following:
L
Procet'_liiral Histog
On May 2, 2006, die defendant Tyrone Ben'y, pled guilty to the felony offense of sexual assault
_of anchild in cause number 10|9634l in the 180°' `District Court of Harris County, Texas. Pursuant to a
plea bargain agreement entered into after aj`ui"y had been seated and the presentation of evidence had
commenced, the defendant was sentenced to ten (lO) years confinement in the Texas Department of
Criminal J`ustice .-'-_lnstitu`tional Division.
No direct appeal was taken in this case; however, the defendant has filed eight pro se applications
for writ of habeas corpus, cause numbers lO.l9634~A through lOl9634-H.
The defendant's initial application for writ of habeas coi'pu_s, cause number 1019634-A, was Eled
in . . . .. _ , t , "‘-a‘*$*le
51* , on Octoher 27! 2009, and was denied without written order on February lS! §012. ,Ex,parze Beny, No.
heed wn-is,si 7-os (Tex, ctitn. App. F.ebnte_t-y 15, 2012). '
The defendant’»s second application for writ of habeas corpus, cause number lOl9634-B, was
rk?, filed on November w while cause number lOl9634eA was still pending and was denied without
written order on 'February _lS, 2012. Ex pma Beny, No. WR-73,5‘17-09 (Tex. Cr-iri_i_. App. Februaiy l$,
2012).
113
ANN
The defendant’ s third application for writ of habeas corpus, cause number 1019634-C, was filed
l on January$_§glg, while cause numbers 1019634-A and 101963435 were still pending, and was denied
without written order on l»`ebruiiry15z 2012. E_r parte Berry, No. WR- 73, 517- 10 (Tex. Crim. App.
February 15, 2012-). '
The defendant’~s fourth application for writ of habeas corpus, cause number lOl9634-D, was filed
)$'Li°n FebruaryM, while cause numbers lO'l9634-A,M34-B` a_nd 1019634-C were still pending ,'
L§¢ar end was denied without written order on inni_re_rylp.201 ss parte Beny, No. wR-73,5'17-06 (Teie
en Crim. App. January 18, 2012). l
'lhe defendant’s fifth application for writ of habeas corpus, cause number 10196344E, was filed '
ygon Febn`_i_ary 15l 2_010-,- while cause numbers 1019634-A, 1019634~3, lOl9634-C and 1019634-D were
still peri_ding, and was denied without written order on January_@§l_£ E_f parte Berry, No. WR- ’
73,5|7-07 [Tex. Crim. App. lanuary 18, 2012).
,}.(p The defendants sixth application for writer habeas corpus, cause number 1019634-¥, was filed
wh on Septeniber 1'7, .2§1`_0_, while cause numbers lOl9634-A, lOl9634-_B, 10196_3'4£, 1019634~D and
1019634-1:`. were still pending and was denied without written order on February _peny' Ro¢rn, the Harris County ’ 0
Sherifl’s Ofl‘ice Property Roorn is not in possession of any property and/or evidence i`n connection with
772 State of Texa.s v. Tyrone Berry, cause number `1019634, or relating to incident report number
30415605N. See May 23. 2013 didauit of Q. Hig)e_n, Harris- County Sher_§`j‘"s ojice Prope_r"ty and/or
Reco`rdt Cu.rtodian, attached hereto as _Stgle ’s £rhibil D.
IV.
_fBa _ nod
On May 16, 2005, the defendant was indicted in cause number 1019634 for the felony offense of `
sexual assault of a child, alleged to have been committed against fifteen year old Con_'t'plainant, Britta'ny
Smith, on or about February 25; 2005. On May 2, 2006, alter ajury had been seated and the presentation
of evidence had commenced, the defendant pled guilty to the offense of sexual #sault of a child and,
pursuant to _a plea bargain agreement was sentenced to ten (lO) years confinement in the Texas
Department of Cr_i_minal Justice - Instit_utional Divis'ion..
Prior to the defendant’s plea of guilty, and in connection with t_he investigation of the offense in
fhi..$ case, the Houston_ Police Department Crime Laboratory analyzed the complainant's sexual assault kit
for the presence of DNA_. Spec`itically, on Mar'ch 28, .2005, J`uli _Rehfuss,- a chemist with the Houston
Police Department Crime Labor'atot'y¢,l reported that ‘-‘sperrn_atozoa, cellular constituent of semen, were
detected on the vaginal swabs (item L) and the crotch area of the panties (Itern R)." See Supplemenz 14,.
Hou.r!o`n Police Department !mident` Report Nurr'r'ber 030415605M attached hereto as S!dt€ 's _Exhibi! E.
On March 29, 2005, the complainant's vaginal swabs, a cutting from the complainant’s panties, a
staincard made from the known blood of the complainant and two buccal swabs containing the
_.` __
defendant's saliva samples were transferred to the ldentigene laboratory for DNA analysis and
comparison See Suppler_r_rgn_r ]5, Houston Police Department Incidezrt Report Number 030.41'5605N,
attached hereto a_.'_r Srare 's Ezhibit F.
5 g 117
On May 'lO_, 2005, Identigene released a forensic laboratory report containing the resuls of the
DNA analysis and comparison performed on the complainant's vaginal swabs, the complainant's panties,
and the complainant's known DNA profile. See May 10, 2005. Identigene Foren.ric Report #67135,
;___ "_-;-'= :'r)-`
attached hereto as State' s £zhibit G.
On May 3`1, 2005,` Identigene released a follow-up laboratory report incorporating the results of
the initial DNA analysis and comparison performed o_n the complainant's vaginal swabs, the
complainant's panties, and the complainant's known DNA profile with the results ofl the comparison and
analysis performed on the defendant's known DNA profile See M_ay 31, 2005, Identigene For'en.sit:
Report #682 72. attached hereto a.s- S_tate 's Exhibit H_.
ldcntigene’s forensic DNA analysis and comparison of the complainant's vaginal swabs, the
complainant's panties, the complainant's known `DNA prolile, and the defendant’s known DNA profile
yielded the following results:-
Corn la'nant’s V_a_ ina| wab " -E i elial Cell l-`_ract'
o a full, single-source DNA profile was obtained from the epithelial cell fraction of
the vaginal swabs
0 the DNA profile matched the DNA profile from the complainant
9 the complainant cannot be excluded as the DNA donor to the epitheli_a| cell
fraction of the vaginal swabs
Complainantfs.Vag'nal S@.'_ s - SgeLn gell.Fraction
_ 0 a mixture of male and female.DNA fi'om at least two individuals was obtained
from the sperm cell fraction of't`he vaginal swabs. _
0 the defendant cannot be excluded as a possible contributor"`to this mixture
o due to the numerous possible additional alleles below threshold, no statistical
analysis was performed evaluating the probability of inclusion
0 n_o conclusions were made regarding the inclusion o_r exclusion of the
complainant to the mixture
o the same full l)NA profile that was obtained ii"om the epithelial cell fraction o'f
the vaginal swabs, plus multiple possible additional alleles below threshold, was
obtained ii'or`n the epithel_ial cell fraction of the panties
0 the DNA profile matched the DNA profile {i'om the complainant
9 the complainant cannot be excluded as the DNA donor to the epitl\elial cell
fraction ofthe panties
6 118
comgininnnrrs Pn_n rios -`sp£m‘_ con ago_n'o_n y ‘ AFX ' '
0 a mixture of DNA ti"om at least two individuals was obtained from the sperm cell 52
fraction of the panties ,
o the DNA profile of the defendant is consistent with the major component
o the defendant cannot 'be excluded as the DNA donor to the major component of
the mixture contained from the sperm cell fraction of the panties
o the frequency of the major component of this mixture horn an unrelated
individual chosen at random from the population at large is less than l in
51,000,000,000,000,000 .in A_frican American, Cauca;sian and Hispanic
populations `
0 the complainant cannot be excluded as a possible contributor to the r`nin'or
component oft;his mixture
6 alleles foreign to both the complainant and the defendant were observed in the
minor component of this mixture
See May 31 . 2005, Identigene Forensic Repdrl #682~72, allached hereto as Slate"s Eri':'hibil H.
`V.
Thenpefendant, is Not Entitl_ed to FoLelis. ' ic DN_A Testing
Aecording to "lE_X. CODE CRI_M._PROC. art.- 64.01, a convicted person may request forensic DNA
testing M of evidence that was either l) previously untested,_or 2) previously tested, but could now' be
subjected to testing with newer testing techniques that provide a reasonable likelihood of results that are
more accurate and probative than the results of the previous test. T`EX. C|UM. PRQC. CODE art. 64.01. ln
this case, DNA testing was performed in 2005 by the Houston Police Department Crime Laboratory and
lde_nt_igen_e. The defendant makes no showing that there are newer testing,techniques available that would
provide a.reasonable likelihood of results that are more accurate and probative than the results generated
previously. _
runnennon.-, to be entitled io any additional DNA zoning mo defendant n_nisr also show darby a
preponderance .of the evidence, the defendant would not have been convicted if exculpatory results had
been obtained through additional DNA testing TEX. Cor>E- CiuM. Paoc,. art 64.03(a)(2)(A). The
defendant cannot meet this burden. Even if the only remaining evidence were subjected to DNA testing,
* defendant fails to show, n_or does he even allege, how any possible result would exculpate him from this
crime.
7 119
P\P>d 55
V'.L
Ma!
Tyrone B_erry, the convicted person in the above-styled case, has failed to meet the requirements
of T`EX. CODE CRIM. PROC. art 64.03. The evidence in the defendant's case was tested prior to his trial
and subsequent plea, and to near scientific certainty inculpated him in the offense for which he was
charged.l The defenth fails to show how any hypothetical `DNA result would exculpate h_i_rn from this
crime or prove by a preponderance of the evidence that he would not have been prosecuted or convicmd.
As such, the applicant fails to.carry his burden to obtain DNA testing in accordance with Chapter 64 of
the Code of Cr'iminal Procedure. 1
Wl-[EREFORE, PREMI-SES CONSIDERED, the State of Tejx'as respectfully requests that the
Court deny DNA testing in cause number 1019634.
Respectfully submitted,
Inger M. Hampton _
Assistant District AtIomey
C_onvict_ion Review Section
Harris County District Attomey’s Offic.e
1201 Fran_k_lin, Ste. 600
Houston, Texas 77002
(713~'_) rss_i 570
(713) 368-9225 fix
S!at¢ Ba.r No. 2404-1051
'1 20
kp(>orma,¢;)r\x/lltuq-Ve"l 1~\1
£\
tamm-c tim cchrM w'"
~ hi\>mr¢$m,i)is
LEAH M.BoRG » D&P>< 5 Li
ATI`ORNEY AT LAW
874 YORKCHESTER NO. 123
HOUS'TON, TEXAS 77079
TEL. & FAX: 713-468-3618
lTyrone Berry
TDCJ # 1368050
George Beto Unit
1391 F. M. 3328 his D ,é<{t{_,
Tennessee Colony, .Texas 75880
Re: Cause N_o. 1019634; 180th District Court of Harris County, Texas; DNA
Motions
Dear Mr. Berry:
'I`his 1s to inform you that I have been appointed by the Court to represent you
regarding the various DNA motions you have tiled. " 4
I have read through the documents you nled, as well as the Court’s Ele in this case
and have read through several post-conviction files of yours regarding various
writs you have filed I have done this to best understand any basis for post-
conviction DNA testing
Of particular importance to me was your statement that your trial attorney had
advised you that the DNA testing revealed that there were several sperm donors in
the sample that was tested. If correct, this would be extremely important in getting
new testing done.
I have obtained a copy of the report ii'om Identigene which did the DNA testing in
your case in order to ascertain whether there was more than one sperm donor.
The report from Identigene says that:
l. samples were taken ii'om Brittney Smith and the panties which she was alleged
to have worn; W@Ll§, a full DNA pronle of Britmey Smith was
obtained; '
P
case, The Court rescheduled the court appearance for February'd,
2013. The State again requested a reset and the Court reset
the appearance for narch. at the States request, the court
reset appearances for April, and again for May when the State
petitioned the court for another reset. In June of 2013 alone,
PETITIONER‘S cause was set for appearance three separate times
with each being reset at the request of the State. The current
scheduled court appearance is set for July 12, 2013. PETITIONER
objects co futher resecs and/or delays by the State.
II.
PETITIONBR asks this~Court to grant this-motion to proceed
in lighc of the State's adequates time it has had to prepare for
the Court”s July 12, 2013 appearance. Another continuance does
nothing more than delay, and in facts deny justice to PETITIDNER
who asserts that forensic D.N.A. testing will exonerate him of
the charges he is currently serving time for.
WHEREFORE, premises considered, the PETITIONER prays that
this Court grant all relief requested herein and for such other
relief, to which this Court deems PETIfIONER is justly entitled.
Respectfully submitted _
W /S», m»»r /13
Tyrone Berry
3572 F.u. 350 south
Livingston, Texas 77351
5'#¥'
"’caqse'N-o. 1‘019634 4
srATl=,-or Tt-:xAs -' . _ ` § ' m ms 180°‘ msch count
v. ' - . § 01=
mont BERR'Y, .¢ - § HARRIS coUNTY, TExAs
Defendant ' .
COME_S NOW the State of Tex-as,,‘by a_nd through the undersigned Assistant District Attom_ey,
and, in response to the defendant’s request for postconviction DNA testing pursuant to Cha'pte'r 64 of the
Texas _Code of Cri`r'nina_l Proce'dure, respectfully requests that the Cou_r.t deny DNA testing of evidence 1__n
the above-styled case and for good cause shows the following:
l.
l P.roeednral,H§` _to\_'!
O_n May 2, 2006, the defendant Tyrone Beny, pled guilty to the felony" offense of sexual assault
of a.ch`ild in cause number lOl.-9634 in the l80th District Court of Harris County, Texas. Pu_rsuant to a
plea bargain agreement entered into after a jury had been seated and the presentation of evidence had
‘ commenced, the defendant was sentenced to ten (l(_)_) years conlinement in the Te'xas Depamnent of
Crim_i_nal Just_ioe '- lnstitutional Division.
No direct appeal was taken in this case; however, the defendant _has filed eig; pro se applications
for writ ornabeas corpus, cause number§ 1019634:-A through 10'19634+1,
The defendant' s initial application fo'r writ of habeas corpus, cause number lOl9634-A, was filed
n%*zw
t \.on October 27 2009, and was denied without writen order on Febru'a'ry 15l Z-ng. Ex parte Berry, No.
:=é=-==*
W' ed wR-73,.s17-.os crst crim. App. F¢bnmy 15, 2012.).
The defendanf’s second application for writ of habeas corpus,_ cause number 1_019634-8, was
fail filed on November_;§-,-ZOUf while cause number‘1019_634»A was still pending, and was denied without
written order on Febru_ary l_5, 20th Ex pole Berry, No. WR-73,5,l7-09 (Tex'_.- Crim. APP._ P¢bt'ua_l'y 15,
_ 2012).
113
S(aq
pq
b /XPxSél>
The defendants third application for writ of habeas corpus, cause number lOl_9634-C, was filed
Bon lannar`y$_gg$g, while cause numbers 101963.4»A and 1019634-B were still pending, and was denied
withoutwrill€n order on February 15! 2012-, Er parte Beny, No. WR-`-73,5fl 7-10 (Tex. Crim. App,
Febnmry 15`,2-012). l
4 'l_'he defendants fourth application for writ of habeas corpus, Cause number 101963.4-D, wa`s filed
Mon Februaiy 4, 20_10, while cause numbers l019634~'-1L- lOl_96_34-B and lOl9634-C were still pending
Ol‘? ~ _ _
crim. App. many is,; 201;2_)_.
The defendant's find application for writ of habeas corpus, cause number 1019634-£;, was filed
» § on February `l.")l 20|0l while cause numbers lOl9634-A, lO'l9634-B, lOl9634-C and lOl_963'4-D were
still pending, and was denied without written order on JmumMz. Ex parte Beny, No_. WR~
_ 73,¢517-07 (Tex. Crim. App. .Ianuar`y 18, 2012).
w The defendant.’s sixth application for writ of habeas corpus, cause number lr(_ll96'3;4-F, was filed
mvv on ~Se`p`te`inber l7, 2210, while cause numbers lOl9634-A, 1019634-.8‘, lOl9634-.C, lOl9634-D and
1019634.;15 were still pending and was denied without written order on Febri`iary §._Z,Q,Ll Et pate
Beny, No. wR.73,5"17-ii (ret crim. App. Febnmiy 15, 2012).
$.7 ‘ The defendant’s seventh application for writ of habeas corpus, cause number 1019634-6, was
`,_/( filed on N_o`ver_nbei_' 12, 2010, while cause numbers lOl9634-A, 'l'0l9634-B_, 1019634-€,~ 10l9634-p, n
M’ 1019634-£ and 10`19634-1-` were still pend_i_i'ig, and was denied without written order on Febru 11
ar paris Bm, No. wit.vs,s 174)2 (r¢x. crim, App. rebmary 9, 201 i).
}?)-
The defendants eighth application for'writ of habeas corpus, cause number 1019634~.
while cause numbers lOl9634-A, lOl963.4-B, lOl9634-C, lOl9634-D, l019634-E,
1019634-6 1 re
`QM`W _1_2_0,11. E_x parte Berry, No. WR~73',517~04 (Tex. Crim. App. Septembcr';:l,,w
The defendant subsequently filed a motion for postconviction forensic DNA testing, and the trial
1019634-F and still pend`in_ and was dismissed as a subsequent writ on Se`ptember'__l’_l,, j
conn appointed counsel to iepresent the applicant for the purpose of 'l_iis motion.
114
her 6 in d
.]I[. '
MM-
The ~State respectfully requests that the Court take judicial notice, based on the official trial court
records, that the above styled and numbered cause is associated with H'o'uston Police Department incident
Identigene case number §ll__3_§;
Accor'd_i'r_ig to the records of the Houston Police Department PropettyfRoorn, the Houston Police
Department Prope`rty Room is i_n possession ofl the following evidence in connection with .Ihe Stqte of
4 Texar v. Tyrone Berry, cause number 1019634, and relating to incident report number'030415605r»
0 one sexual assault kit and clothing '
0 two buccal swabs from Tyrone Ben'y
See Ap‘ril 22, 2013 aji_davit of Joseph Hr`II, Hoirsion Police Department Prope"rty' a__n_d Evidence Records
Custodiml, attached hereto as Sta:'e '-s Ezhibit.A.
According to the records of the l-louston Police Department Crime Laboratot'y, the Houston
Police Department Crir'ne Laborato'ry is in possession lof the following evidence in connection with The
stare anew n Tyrone Beny, cause number 1019634, and relating w incident report number 030415'~605
and/or laboratory number L05-03609:
0 one sealed white envelope containing:
= one clear _Ziploc bag labeled “2_/3" containing
o one clear Z_ip|oc bag containing
o one sealed brown envelope labeled “ltem L: vaginal swabs #1-4;
item k panties (cuitin'g -3”3~3") 1/3"
0 one sealed brown envelope labeled “sta_incard*_r_nade from known blood
(Item K) from compl. Brittany Smith; known 2/3"
0 one parafilm tape-sealed microc'enu'itiige tube labeled “Ber'iy Tyrone" said to contain
“DNA extracts”
See Mar"C;h 19, 2013 afidavit of Vgne._ssa Alva'rez, Houston Police Depwtment Crime Laboratory
Custodim ofRecords, attached hereto as Staze ’s £rhibi! B.
According`to the records of the Harris County District Clerk’s Office, the Harris County District
C|erk’s Offiee is n_ot in possession of'a.ny evidence in connection with 77ie S!ale of Tex_as v. Tyrone Berr"y,
4 _116
hrx$(@e
cause number 10`19634. See March 22, 2012 ajidauit ofBarba_ra Anderson, Sem'or' Exhr'bizs Clerkfo`r tli'_e
lHarris County District C_lerk 's O.U‘i.€e. d_t,¢dched hereto as State ’s £zh_r‘br"t C._
Aeeord'ing to the records of the Harris County'Sheriff~`s Off`ice Prope_rty Room-, the Harris County
Sl_reriff`s Office Propeity Ro.om` is not in possession of any property and/or evidence in connection with
The State of Texas v. Tyrone Beny, cause number l019634, or relating to incident report number
30415605N-.- See May 23. 2013 ajidavi`t of Q. Ihig)en. Harris Coi_m_ty Sheri`fs 0_j_ice Property and/or
Recordr Custodi_ar, attached hereto as State' s Erhibit D.
IV.
Ba round
On May 16, 2005, the defendant was indicted in cause niunber 1019634 for the felony offense of
sexual assault of_a child, alleged to have been committed against fifteen year old Complainiint1 Brin`an`y
Smith, on o_r about February 25, 2005. On_ May 2-, 200_6, after aj`ury had been seated and the presentation
of evidence had commenced, the defendant pled guilty to the offense of sexual assault of a child and,
pursuant to va plea bargain agreement was sentenced to ten (lO) years confinement in the Texas
_Dep"amneni of criminal rusii¢e - institutional Division.
v Ptior to the defendants plea of guilty, and in connection with the investigation of the offense in
this case, the l-louston Police Department -C_`rim_e Labojratory analyzed the complainants sexual assault kit
for the presence of DNA..' Specifically, on March 2;8, 2005, luli Rehf'iis's_, a chemist with tl_ie Houston'
Police Department Crime Laboratory, reported that “spermatoaoa, cellular constituents of semen, were
detected on the vaginal swabs (Item L) and the crotch area of the panties (Iteni R)." See Su'pplement 14,
Hou_ston Police Department .Incr‘dent Report Nwriber 0304]5605M attached hereto as State 's £xh_r'bir E.
On March 29, l2_005`, the complainants vaginal swabs, a_ cutting from the complainants panties', a
l staincard made from the known blood of the complainant and two buccal swabs containing the
"_` _____
defendant s sa|iva samples were transferred to the Identigene laboratory for DNA analysis and
comparison See Supplement 15, Hou_r'!on Police Department In_cidem Report Nit`znber 030415605N,
tutth hereto as State '.r_' Bhibi`t F.
5 y 117
AP\¢§®¥
0n May 10, 2005, Identigene released a forensic laboratory report containing the results of the
DNA analysis ajn_d comparison performed on the complainants vaginal swabs, the complainants panties,
and the complainants known DNA prof' le See May 10, 2005. !de_n__ti'gerre Faren.ri'c Repart #67!35,
attached hereto as Stat;:_£,r;r’l;it ;:`
On May 31, 2005, Identigene released alfo|low-u'p laboratory report incorporating the resuls of
l the initial DNA analysis and comparison performed on the complainants vaginal swabs, the
complainants panties, and the complainants known DNA profile, with the results of the comparison and
analysis performed on the defendants known DN_A profile See May 3!, 2005, Identigene For'e`ns`i'c
Report #682 72, attached hereto a'.r Stat_e '.s Erhi,b'it H;._
identigene’s forensic DNA analysis and comparison of the complainants vaginal -swabs, the
complainant's pa;nries, the complainants known DNA pronlo, and the defendants known DNA profile
yielded the following re'sults:_
0 a` full, single-source DNA profile was obtained from the epithelial cell fraction of
the vaginal swabs
0 the DNA profile matched the DNA profile li"`om the complainant
0 the complainant cannot be excluded as the DNA donor to the epitlielial cell
fraction of the vaginal swabs
Com lainan?s_..'\"’a_ 'nal wabs-S ' 7 'l ra ' n
0 a mixture of male and female DNA from at. least two individuals was obtained
from the sperm cell fraction of the vaginal swabs.
0 the defendant cannot be excluded as a possible contributor to this mixture '
o due to the numerous possible additional alleles below threshold-, no S,B._fi.$'ti¢sl
analysis was performed evaluating the probability of inclusion
0 no conclusions were made regarding the inclusion or exclusion of the
complainant to the mixture
0 the same full DNA profile that -was obtained from t_he epithelial cell fraction of
the vaginal swabs, plus multiple possible additional alleles below threshold, was
obtained fi"orn the epitheli_al cell fraction of the panties
o the DNA profile matched the DNA profile from the complainant
0 the complaimnt cannot be excluded as the DNA donor to the epiti_\el_ial cell
fraction of the panties
118
D@)c$é€>
Vl_.
Cooclw‘ _o
Tyrone Ben'y, the convicted person i_n the above-styled case, has failed to 'nieet the requirements
of TE-X`. CCDE.~ CRIM. PROC». att. 64.03. The evidence in the defendant~’-s case was tested pn'_`or to his trial
- and subsequent plea, and to near scientific certainty inculpated him in the offense for which he was
charged. The defendant fails tol show how any hypothetical DNA result would exculpate him from this
crime or prove by_ a preponderance of the evidence that he would not have been proseemed or convic`ted.
As such, the applicant fails to carry his burden to obtain,DNA testing in accordance Wit_h Cha`PtP-l’ 64 of
the Code of Cii'minal Proeedure.
W}EREFORE,- PREMISE_S CON_S]l_)ERED, the -State of Texas respectfully requests that the
Coun deny DNA resting in cause number 1019634,l
Respectfully submitted,
In_ger M_. 'Ha`mpton '
Assistant District.AttOf`n¢'y
Convict_io'n Review Section
Harris County District Attor`ney's Ofiiee
1201 Fr`an_kl_i__r_l, Ste. 600
Houston, Texas' 77002
(713__) 755-1570
(7]3) 368-9225 fox
Sme Ba.r No. 2404105\
1210`
md 7
Kathleen O’Connor Power's,
Oflicial Court Reportfer
180‘*' Disi_r__i_ct court
1201 Franklin, lam 131er
Houston, Texas 77002
September 16, 2014
Tyrone Berry 1368050
Dibo]] CC S. Fir'st St.
Dibo].l TX 75941
R.E: Tria.l Court Cause No. 1019634, State o_f Tex_a's v Tyrone Berry
Dear Mn Berry:
`lri response to your inquiry postmarked 1 1 SEP 201.4 and received in my oHi'ce September 16,
2014, there is no reporter’s record for Augus`t 9, 2013 for the above-referenced case,
Thank you,
Kathleen O’Connor Powers,
Offi`c`ia.l Cou`rt Reporter
CC;: Court file Cause No;.; 1019634
\
\
P
innerlltl\ll\nrulnqurrnrrrnunrur\llonnnnlrruin\nllnlilnynu¢ln»lnnnlnl\nu-- ......
oarc:t'\`_m. rN_FoR.MA'rIoN REPoR-'r No__N-PuBch
mindso»\linnlulnrnlnilorgxnnnra\\lcaguiar\lllu\nquéc\¢q\nn\unr\uun\nununn\iuu\uq
uous'ro_N PoLr`c_r-:'ncpmzmr PAGE 1.001
O!-'.‘I-'ENS`E REPORT- Inc-ident no. 030415605 N
luinnlrllrlllrinlnnornl\narrnnul.o`r`ulunion1\lnanru_nrnrlv_`nllrlln¢llnulllnnrull_¢llllnn'll k 56
suPPLEr-xem(s‘) `
NO-0014
offense- st-:xt`J`AL AssAu_L'r (`lt'A_PE) (G-x_ILD) msz 14 YR)/BY sonILY FoRCB(JUv
Street' location information
Number- 8000 N.a_me-TIDW_ELL 'rype-RD Suffix-W
Apt no- Name-osooo 'l*ype- Suffix-
Dat:e of offense-CZ/ZS/os Dat.e of supplement-03/28/05
C_ompl(s) Last--SMITH Fi_-rst,-BRI'I’!.‘AN¥ Middle-SuSANNB
LaBt-'-
Reco`v`ered stolen vehicles information
snored- by- _ph#.~ looo) ooo-oooo
office`rl-"JUI.._I .R.EHFUSS E_@#°lll!§l$ Shift-l DiV/Stat~`ion-CR-I_ME LAB
supeme R_ARRATIvr-:
Rer-*.EREN€E= L05-3so.9
sUsPP:Cr(s): mens amy
A'r ms nx-:QUBs'r oF orrr<:c'n M. GALLA<:HF.`R, PR# 1691;1.1, Tir_i: FowaING I'rEMs wI-:RE
ANALYan: ' »
ONB SEXUAL ASSAULT EVIDENCE KIT (BARCODEr: RTTA) FROM COHPLAINANT BRI’ITANY S'M"ITI;I
CON'I’A`ININ_G:
I.‘I'E?"l A:- VAGINAL S_M§EAR
ITEM B: mla SMEAR
chsmn. schemes - N`o'r Us- ‘aY noserm
FING'EmIL swABs - ‘No'r Usen BY HosPI'rAL
muslims aac L_.ABELLED llamax PA_'NTIEs-' coNTAer-ING Pmres
means coLLBcrroN' szBLoP): - No'r Usz_`x) ny Rospr'rAL
ITE'M c= oRAL sMEAR - N_o‘r usE_D BY H_ospr'rA'L
rm s= PuLLsn amc HA_»IR - No'r usB_D BY HosPI'r`AL
rm c.= Hr:An HALR commcs s No‘r Usr-:n ay HosPI'rAL
r"rr-:M H: PULLE:D P.UBrc ma - No'r Usl-:n BY‘ HosP'r"'rAL
I'rl-:M J: PUBIC HAIR coMBINGs
r'rEM 1<= mem amon
rm L= vAcI_NAL sums
r"rm M= ram swiss
I'rE:_M N= am sums - No'r esso e`Y HesP`I'rAr-.
rm o; mem sALm swAas - No'r Usi'.n ay HosprrAL~
P:
Q:
R:
5:
ours strange ENV`E_LQPE _(BAP.coDE_: noel LAB`E:_'LL. "-2 wean swAB_s noia mens B.=;RRY"
- unopmn,- No'r mmonreo
m
oNE sEALED Box (aARcoDs; R'I"rc) LABE-LLED icmm:ING (3 -aAGs) !' E.'RoM coume
1 34-
AH 53
CERT|,F|CATE OFTHE' C'|,.-ERK
UE STATE OF TEXAS ` IN THE' 180TH JUDICL¢\L DISTRICT COURT
COUNTY OF HARRIS ' OF HARRIS COUNTY, "I'EX_AS
I, Chris Daniel, District Clerk of Harris County, Texas, do hereby certify that the above
& foregoing proceed`ings, instruments & other papers contained in Volume I'Pgs. 1465
inclusive, to which this certification is attached and made a parttheneof, are true and
correct copies of all proceedings, instruments and other papers specified by Rule 34,.5 (a)
and matter designated by the parties pursuant to Rule 3'4,‘5 (b).in Cause No. 101,9634
Sty|ed TYRONElBE-RRY vs_. The$tate of Texas in said court.
GIVEN UNDER MY HAND AND SEAL of said Court, at office in Harris Count)'§
Tean on October 9, 2013.-
Chri_s Dan-iel '
Har'ris_ County District Cl_e'rk
By: /s} N. salinas, Deg_; ury_
166
Tuesday, May 10,2005
rlaoo-c>NA-WPE
H;‘B"T°" P?"$hl>;:;"m*="-‘F rev 713-mom
H`Du.s'toh-. TX 77002 ww.lder\t!gsne.com
US`
The lollowing itemswere oriolyzed:
item
1 ,
1 l 4 T.
l59DB4 " , . , ' Guenero.
For the ltems fried above, DNA was extracted and amplified ot thirteen polymorphic PCR locl lD3S1358_ vWA. FG_.A DBS1179 D2-1Sl`.1
Dl8551. D5$B1S, Dl&S$l 7-, D7SBZD, D168539. THQl. TPOX, and CSF1PO) and Amelo'genln Th'e DNA proma of the evi_aence samples were
compared to the DNA prome of the reference sample
thretrrz£rAnoN
The reference bjr_tccal swabs lpbeled “Brlllney Srnllh" [159054] produced o fun female DNA pr"ol'rle.
A full sl_r\glesourr,:e female DNA profile was obtained lro'."'r_\ the epithellal fraction ot the vaginal swabs [159080¥-. The same full temple DNA prollle
with multiple possible additional alleles below threshold was obtained nomine e'pllhel_lol cell fraction ot the pant|es [15?0&] Thls prol_ile matches
the DNA prame obl_dmed from the reference-buccal swabs labeled 'Brlltney _$mllh" [1570841'01 al_l thirteen Sl_’R locl tested. `lherel_ore; B`rlllney'
Sm|lh adm-sol be excluded as the DNA' donor l_o the epl_l_t_rellul traction of the vaginal swabs [159'080} or the epl_lhelld cell fraction o_l the partner
[159082|.
A mature of mate and temple DNA from or least two individuals ms obtained from the spjerrn cell fraction el the v.uglnol swabs [15.9081]. No
conclusions wil be mode regarding the lncl_uslon or exclusion al Bdttney S_mlth lo this mlxture.
A mixture of DNA lrom at least two mdlviduals_. with an identifiable rhoior male component cl unknown origin was obtained lrar_n the sperm cel_
fraction d the painter [159083]. Brlltney $mtlh cannot be excluded as a possible conln`butor lo the minor component of this m'odu_re. Alleles
foreign to Brttlney S_mllh were observed rn the minor component of ink mixture. '
Ex_ljractlon and PCR DNA controls were_ tested and gave the correct results
misuse va _FcA ` ` east 179 b21_s_1_1 onset 05th n`_r'as;rv orsazo presses ram rro;r csfl!'o _
.$¢`:rttple
159084
Refe`re'nce buccal swabs labeled
"»‘Brlti_r_tey Smilh” .
159080 _
Eplt_hel'\al traction ot the vaginal
swabs
159031" _ _
Sp'erm cell traction of the vaginal
swch
159082
Epithe|ial cal fraction ol the
panties
issues
Sperm cell trac-lion Qf_ the panties
' = Possible additional alleles below threshold `[ ] = er component al o mature
\
lD_G _‘7!1$
At:e!ot'.llahhllcql!`¢dl_hr= Mll. "NC,BQIE_EC 1702.£` N\'SD°H, m .\S_CLD- lll` ~.__ _
Thank y`ou for this opportunity to assist you in this matter Please make arrangements to pick up the above listed lterris lrorn l_den Qe n@cll your
earliest convenience t_t you have any questions please teel tree to call us at 713-798-'95\0,
L j ro Gohn. Fh.D.
DN_A Lobor'otory Director
§“TQPY
~'_~."’ ""
|DG,_UH_§ 2
hedman/mm lAAll mcs l_$°/l¥€' \7(!25. m mrs BCl.b-LAB
1 42
1135er Gl:Nl_:'_.»$; "~"l_j'
7 Feoc`e al Minr_:t Through DNA Te_xlin'g -':""$ ' _
1 ' v " Arrliz"" mm
f
Tuesdcry. May 3l. 2005 . _
' ' . pit 303 sure mo
' - rrouston T;x 770.$4
|-dn`rl UNA r‘/PE
Houston Police Department ad 7 i.r./oa»i>s is
' ' www.r`r:tentigene.co_m
1200 Travls. v2litr~l Floor
Houston, TX. 77002
Fo_r the item 16l926. DNAwas extracted and ampitled ot thirteen polymerch PCR loci {03_`51358. vW_A. FGA. DBSl 179_, 021511 018551,
DSS.SlB 0135317,D7SB_20, D165539.TH01 TPOX and CS_FtPO) and Ame|oge'_i_‘i_h-. The DNA prot_ite at this re|erer"i'ce sample wa_s
compared to the pro_mes previously reported M`cr_y 10 2005 tn lde_nllgene report #67135 "See ldeni'r'g'ene report #67135
rNrEnPRErA-norl
`he relerence buccal swabs labeled "Br\ttrrey.$mit`l'i' [159_084] and reference buccal swabs labeled 'Tyrorie Berry" ft 61926} each produced a _l_ull
DNA arena
A full single-source female DNA_ proti|e was obtained trorn the eplllrella_l traction ot the vaginal swabs [159080]. the some lull female DNA protile
withrs-_~_.ulllpre possible edginonal allela below threshold was obtained trprn the epllirellal cell traction GHhe panties f159082].°1liis profile mtch'es
the DNA profile obtaim'ed item the relerenr_:e buccal swabs labeled*`iritl_ney_,$mllh" [159,054] ot all lh_'rr‘teen'STR loci lested_. Theretore Brtitne_y'
Smith cannot be exduded as the DNA donor to the .epilhellot fraction ot'the.vogh'iat swabs 1159080] or the eplth;ella.l cell traction ot the panties
1159082].
A mixture~oi male aad.lerrrale' D`NA tr"om.at least two individuals was obtained trfam the sperm cell'lro`cllon at the `vag_lnal swabs {15908¥]. Tyrone
Berry cannot be excluded as o possible contn`bulor to this mixture. However_. due to the numerous possible additional alleles below lh'reshold.
statistical analysis will not b'e performed evaluating the probabl_§tv` ot inclusion No conclusions will be made regarding the inclusion-... '~' e_xcli.rsion
or arr`r`h_iey smr:h rp mrsmme.
A mixture ot DNA tr'om a_t least two individuals was obtained tro_r_n the sperrr__r cell traction nl lh_e panties 1159083]. The DNA proti_le obtained hom
the reference buccal swabs labeled "Tyrone B_er`rv' h£tm] is consistent with the major component The_refore, Tyro_r_r_e Berry cannot be
excluded as the DNA donor to the major component ot the mixtr.rre obtained trpm the sperm cell traction ol the panties [159_083]. The trequenc-y
ol the major component ot this mixture trom an unrelated individuatdrosen at random from the population at large is less than l in 5.1 x lo"in
Atrtco_n American. Cauaas_ion and l'l_l_spanlc populations {FB| database). Brtllney Smith cannot be excluded as a possible contributor lathe minor
component ol this mixti'rre_. Alleles torelgn l_o both Brtltney Smith and tyrone Berry were observed in the minor component ot this mixture
Exrruclion and PCR DNA controls were tested ond,gave the correct results
§ .` _/;.-.PY
- .
M_‘BZT'Z
A_c:mdll'¢tlatg`g/Carm=dlanz AALL IESTC. ED/|EC t?m. NYSDU_H. T!BN BE_b-LA_B
.'14.4
_'oas'rssa va_A` rail oas~rr"_n nzrs`rr' msssr
os'sa__rair>ts§srz bisno messer mar
. S¢lr.n»le
161926 ' . .
auccol was labeled "ryron'e g g
Berry" _
rso.oaa`“ _ '- _
Re_terence birc’ca.swobs labeled
“Briltney Wh'
‘r.r¢`)¢rao~ii _ ' ' ` v
pltheiial fraction ot the vaginal
, 5` _ . _
159081'~' __
LSp'erm cell fraction ot the vaginal
1590823-
Epithetr`al cell _t_'rU¢_tton oI the
pq'.'tfies
ll , .__
$Perm cei tractbn,ot;ihe gahties
' = Possr‘ble additional alleles below threshold t.] = Min_or c;'omponen_t ot o mixture '° =-.see ldentr'gene-report #§713$
Thanl: you for this opportunity to assist you in this motter. Pleose make arrangements lo pick up the above listed items from lde_nrlge_ne at your
earliest convenience tt you have any questions-please feel tree to call us c'r't 713-798~9510.
Sin.Oel_'€`lY.
Forensic o_NA Anolysr
R bin D.eVllle Guiclry
sever Forenslc DNA Ano_rysr. reoh'n_iool Revlewer
- _- r__' of '
.'\. `
l
\' ‘» _.¢
"~~.l
D§_N.m ,
newman/comeaux me narc. rso/rce rms. imer r_`rr`l')`rs Ascur~uo.
145
P
-.,.."ll.~\\n\»`n\l_\vclu\nu`r¢n»lulllllilnnn\_:l\x\d\nlul¢nnlalur¢nl'nu»nnnn»nunnllung-n
. ORIGIIDL' INFDRMATIQN REPQRT NON-PUBLI'C
nnun¢\v\\\_n'l¢l¢nlu'li¢lvn\n\lq!l\ll1lpun`nn\llru\l\nonvllglllnlll\llounwuno\nnnwl'lnn'il`o\\
HoUs'rdN P*oLIcs osPAlz'rMm_rT PAGE 1. 001
OFF~ENSE R£PORT InC-i~dent nO. 030415695 N
llnnnlllllv\i\»nlnnnlnl\_n¢ullll¢llllnn¢nn\\llnlnlnnlunlllnllullullnnnolliodnnllnnunn
SUPPLEMENT('S)
No-OOl-S
O_ffense- SEXUA.L ASSAULT (RAPE) (CHILD) (OVER_ 14 YR) /BY BODILY FCRCE(JUV
street location -information
Number- 8000 Name~TIDWELL Type- RD Suf£ix-W
Apt nb- Name-08000 Type- Suffix-
Date of offense-OZ/ZS/OS Daté of supplement-03/25/05
Oompl(s) last-sierra Firsc/-BRIT:ANY uiddle-sUsANNE
Lasc-
Recbvered stolen vehicles information
Stoz`ed-- by- _Ph#' (_000) 000- 0000
1Offi¢:El’.'].-J'U'LI REHFUSS E_l_\\p#'.' 113315 Shift- 1 DiV/SEat~ion- CRIME LAB
s`URPL_I-JGNT NAR.RATIVE
'oocum.'rA'r`I`oN ma 'mANsm or mcmas-
R£mec:: Los-ss,os v
DATE or RI-:LE`ASE~:_ on 03/'2'9/05 BY HP.D, 'r. Gu?ulmno, i=l`z# 121608
ascs-wmc AGl-:NCY: IDEN.'rIGI-:Nz-: R`Y M. BUsszY oz§ oa/~`zs/os
oA'rF: or mem 'ro HPD;
bE`~smz_IPTIoN_ AN_n coNDI`TIo_N oF BVIDmCE:
1. sEAL:-:D~‘m'£ml>s coN'rAI;NING ITEM L= vacfrfm swABs # 1-4.-Mb IT`EM R= PANTIS,
c-'UTrING -3' x -3'
2. S_E'.ALHD ENVELO`FB CQNTAIN_ING STAINGARD HADE FROH ICNOWN BIDOD (I'l'~EH K_,) FROH
comm BRrr'rANY _sM;T-x .
3. sv.-:ALED~ EHVBLQPB coN'rAIN;NG "2 BuccAL -s'_wh`Bs mon-munz BER.RY'" I' ' @ The Court finds that on Mar`ch_ 29z 2005z the complainant's vaginal s`wabs, a cutting from
the complainant's panties, a staincard made from the known blood of the complainant, and two ll*)_t_r_¢:ca_.l
rato . for DNA
swabs ccntaini'n y the defendant’s sali_va _sam les were transfe.
analysis and comparison
14, The Court finds that on May `l_O,.2-00.5~z Identigene released a forensic laboratory report
Li/LURW containing the results of the DNA analysis and'cornpari'son performed on the complainant's vaginal
swabs, the complainant’s' panties, and the complainant's known DNA profile
l$. The Court finds that on May 3 l-, 2005l lde'nt`igene released -a follow-up laboratory report
incorporating the results of the initial DNA analysis and comparison performed on the complainant's
vaginalswabs~,.the complainant's panties, and the complainant's known DNA profile, with the results of
. the comparison and'analy'sis performed on the defendant’s known DN`A protile.
l6. The Court finds, based on the ldentigene"lab report, that a .ful'l, single-source DNA profile
was obtained from the epithelial cell finction of the complainant's vaginal swabs, that the DNA profile
matches the DNA profile of the com_pl_ainant, and that the complainant cannot be excluded as the DNA
donor to the epithelial cell fraction of' the complainant's vaginal swabs.
l7-. The Court finds, based on the Identigene lab report, that a mixture of male and female
DNA was obtained from the sperm cell fraction of the complainant's vaginal swabs and the defendant
cannot be excluded as a possible contributor to this mixture Due to the numerous possible additional
alleles below~threshold, no statistical analysis was performed'evaluating the probability of`inclu'sion= and
no conclusions were made regarding the inclusion or exclusion ofthe complaith to the m'ixture.
.18. The Court fi_nds, based on the Identigene lab report, that the same full DNA profile that
was obtained from the epithelial cell fraction of the vaginal swabs, plus multiple possible additional
alleles below threshold was obtained from the epithelia'l cell fraction of the panties;» that the .DNA
3 _ ' 155
goss Arx W
T'HE CLERK lS ORDERED send a copy of this Court’s findings of fact in cause numbers
709814 and the instant order to the Defendant’s appointed counsel, Leah Borg,- 874 Yorkche_ster,- No. 123,
Houst_on-, Texasl 77079; and to the attorney representing the State of Texas, lnger Hampton, 1201
Frank`lirg Sui_te 600, Houston, Texasl 77002.
BY THE FOLLO`W[NG SIGNATURE, TH`E COURT A_DOPTS THE STATE'S' PROPOSED
FIN_DINC¢S OF FACT ON T'HE COURT"S DENIAL OF DNA T.ESTING.
+L\ '
signed on this m day of C,_°f°i~_?m£ ca5 _,.2013..`».-'-~"".'~“~-`
" \AARR/-S "‘-.,_
HONORAB LE M_ARC BROW_N
PR.E_SID[`NG JUDG_E, 180"' DISTR]CT COURT
H_A`RRIS COUNTY, TE'-XAS
5 _ 157
cAUsE NIMBER 1019634 'TRYONE BERRY A?)d G€
AFFIDAVI'_I oF ,1' osEPH HILL
(sTA'rE 01= TEXAs)
(COUN'I"Y OF HARRIS)
Before me, the undersigned authority, a Notary Publi'c in and for Harris County, Texas,
on this day personally appeared J. Hill, who being by me duly swom-, upon his oath
deposes and says:
“My name is J. Hill. I am employed as the property and evidence records
custodian for the Hous'ton Police Department l'n my capacity as property and evidence
records custodian, I have care and custody of those records for the H_ouston Police
Depart:n_ent, and certify that the following reflects the status o_f_ property and evidence
related to Houston Police Department offense report #030415605, that is dated on
Febr-uary 25, 2005.
Records of the Houston Police Department Property Room reflect that property/or~
evidence was tagged i_n the Property Room conceming' this case Recor'ds were checked
through the Evidence Management System, 'WinET ` computer system, active and closed
Out invoice Eles. Invoice records detail the following-t
One sexual_assault kit and clothing were tagged into the HPD Proper_ty Roor'n on 2/28/05
by O£ficer R_. .Gonza]es.The-'iisted property is `ifn the possession o_f HPD Propert_y_ Room.
Two buccal swabs from T_y_rone Berry were tagged into the HPD Property Room on
3/11/05 by Ofticer M. Ga_llagher. The listed property is i_n the possession of HPD
Property Room.
l have read the above statement and find it_ to be true and co to the best of my
knowledge ”
MH-il]
‘l 23
bowl
SWORN AND SUB_SCRIBED before me, under oath, on this the ;)A'D day of
April 2013.
n ARY 'PUBLIC in and for the v
state of Tean
~ ' worms
vs mcmmasoN _-,_
"r ior`i?l?°“
M`y commission cxpire's: /a%? Ja/ 3
124
§§e££e ease §jss.c§ §a§§ ,_ §E%act£
a issue &_oa__aheos§§& made dusen §§ ge message §§ .a,a_c. anez£.
doe .Em¢§§a.$§t& , t . t
._e:`sc`.§_.sou .
mmv. .
gill
._`r
tr . ”. .,,.,.a.w.~w....".,..._. d law ... n
_.2¢ domain >=< .§§_Sw ._cuos_ .E_¢_>_ .>=E»:O.. ...£_B...om¢n . _ .o._¢=m eeoc com w%wo \/ m
. .a.Ew c .,.§w a..§:o.e._sa£a . 0 age n =a: 2.%3_ saw 0 u§owr\o 33 a.@¢,..e%ac_
.._ dea o 222&& score _ §§=33 . . . %S:o
§§Ezal \ t o_€\\_ M.ltéaz ».§.E.o §=§m.a lieme li .. 5 B~._§e=<
. §\Xr\\dul . l . . BEH>O` a_€cu . . ` ` .. . ., osz .eoam:m_
§§ § .QEF \ .~ two Aw~%. NG comm.:. ncaa \Ml@th/\M\v%md% . \l,.HM......Sz memo
lm eeo >t,oeo.§ EQE:_Q co ®o=om co»o:oI ..
kw 71
“EV]])ENCE RECOR-DS AFFH)AVIT”
Cause _# 1019634 // Tyrone Berry
sTATE or TEXA_S) (
CoUNrY oF _HARRIS)(
My name is `V_anessa Atva_rez_l l am employed as the property and/or evidence
records custodian __for the Houston Police Department (`HZP_D) Crime Laboratory..
My address and telephone number is': 1200 Travis, Room 2621
Houston, TX 77002
(7'13) 308-2600.
In my capacity as property and/or evidence records custodian, I have care and custody
of those records for the HPD Crime Labomtory and I certify that the following reflects
the status of property and/or evidence related to offense report #030415605 and/or
L05-0_3609, dated 02/25/2005:
T.he following items a_re..being~s`tored in the'Crime La'_boratory:
One sealed white envelope containing
One clear zi'p`lock bag labeled “2/3" containing
One clear .ziplock bag containing
One sealed brown envelope labeled “.Itern L: vaginal swabs #1-4;
Item R: panties (cutting -.-3’~’x ~3”) 1/3”
One sealed brown envelope labeled “staincajrd made from known blood
.. (ltem K)‘from compl_-. Brittany Smith; known 213”
One parafilm tape-sealed microcentrifuge tribe labeled “Berry Tyrone” said to contain
“DNA extracts’_’
HPD Crime Laboratary records appear lo reflect that the following
evidence related to ojense report ~# 030.4]5605 and/or Lab # L05-03609 was
received by the HPD Crime L,abomfory on "03/22/05 ":~
o “Dne' sexual assault -kit from complainant Brittany Smith
v One sealed envelope labeled ‘2 buccal swabs from Tyrone Berry ' -
unopened,-' not inventoried [by the HPD Crime" Laborato)y]
»; 0)'1e sealed box labeled ‘clothtfng(.? bags) ' from complainant Britt_any Smith
- unopened,' not inventoried”
HPD Crime Laborato_ry records-further appear to reflect that the above evidence
was returned.£o t}_re HPD Properly Rool_n by the HPD Crime Labo_r'a!ory on ‘~‘-0 7/21/05”.
126
Cause #1019634 // Tyrone Be`rr~y ` Page 2
AP)¢?§
“_I have completed and read the above affidavit and have found it to be true and correct
to the best of m_y knowledge.”
slGNl-:_l_): _ 5/§,_¢ @V; .' _V
' NAME
SWORN TO AND SUBS.CRI_BED before me t_he undersigned authority on this the
_LdayofM*_f l
. v .' ‘ ~ 1 f ll
1 27
P
lincolnlonvllll_nln-onlnl_ll`\¢lll.\\llullllonnnlllinlnlou\.nnl`\lillvnllhwl-onnol¢llnlllllln_ulll
ORIGI_NAL IN_'FOMTIQN RE_PCRT NON- PUBLIC
llnlllllllllll|l'llll\l\llllll\¢lllll’llllll\\ll'll|ll\llll\l\lll|llllllllllll||lllllll`lll\l|l".llll\llll
HDUSTQN VPOLICE DEPARU{BNT PAGE 1_.001
OFFENSE RRPORT _ Incident no; 030415605 N ya j?
navarro\\`\o¢lulolo¢nlln\ull¢n\l'_nlu`n'nirn\\llu¢n»nnlwoll\u»\nl\n_nu'l`\w'nn¢unonllllu¢nn '
SUP'PLEHENT~(S)
No-OO].S
offense- smcum.~ assisqu (RAPE) (CB_.~I;LD) (ovF.a 14 YR)/BY eonn.Y ponce(:mv
street location information
Number- soon uame-'rznwsn;.. 'rype-nn suffix-w
Apt no- Hame-DBODD Type- Suffix-
Date of offense~OZ/QS/OS 'Date of supplemene-OB/zs/os
CC>m`pl(S) LaSt-SH!H Eii’Et--BRIT.IANY Middle-SUSAHNE
LaSt'-
Recovered stolen vehicles information
Stotéd- by- Ph#- _(000) 000- 0000
foicerl-JULI REHFUSS Emp#- -113315 shifc- -1 Div/scatioh- -CRIMB LAB
sUPPLmtE`.NT mansz
nocm`mN'rA'rIon son 'numsr`aa or va_-nmca
RBFI-:R'ENCB= Losiasos
nA're or RELBA$B: on 03/29/05 BY t-n>o, '1‘. G`zisaamo, FR# 121603
aace:~v'm_c Ao;=._N'c:»Y= tamm nw M. ansss¥ on 0_3/29/0.5
nara or sam 'ro HPD=
nascaran m coun:'rron oi= 'EvroaNe-E=
1.- swan envelope comrn`tn`o I'r-E'M t_,_; vAGINAn swaas l 1-4 Ai~_m rrim a~= PAN'rISs.
emma -3“x , -3'.'
2. SEALED B!WVBLQPB CONTAINING S'IA_INCA_RD MADE FROM KN°WN BI.DOD (ITEM_ K) PROM
COMPLAINART BRIT.TAN'¥ SMfTH
3. swan awvsnops coN'rAINING -2 aoc'cm. sms non 'mv.oNE al-:RRY' mower names
swann mcooa.. Rsoo
ona ANALYsIs aeouzs'rI-_:o
supplement entered.by a 113315
Date cleared- 03/10/05
137
4/21/2_?13_ __ _ _ ||| | ||||llHl|||ll|ll||||l`|| |ll|||l||
-_Houston Police Department
Department Case Report
Department Case Number: 030415605 M 75
Rel.at_ed Case # "s
Case Information
Cas`e OEcer. [9376?._]
Ollense Datl`.~fl"un`e: 02/7_$/1005-14'32|~1::
Ol_¥em'e location:
Oll’ense_ Type_:. 02004 - Rape (Sexl`lal Asa'nll_)
Expirlltion Date_: 02/5/2015
Juri`s`diction: City of Hol'lsl.on
Court Dale:
Disposition:
Disposition Dale:
Case Commenis:
l Nam'e 'l"y‘pe: Complai.nant _ 7 h _ b 7
Nolllo= aRn'rANY, slvlml ' ` ' sole 'nlloo= nonl l_l"olllo`rllollo#`:
Atldrss: IDI:
Addiiional Name lol’orrnationz _ _ t b ' _ _ SSN#:
\N*'“`=W'S'BPM` . ' ' , .- l
lime TYRONE,.BERRY"` ' son kaoo; nom nom model ' ' ' '
A¢ld'icioool Nam'¢ nlromliom ' ssN¢'=
_ _ Case ltems
litemwame , . _ ., _.
_ Container¢_: 26,940 7 l l ' ’ Prllhd¢_for investigative purposes
sums/uaw slolod ill Lo¢=llioll - cs Row 30 sllol_r Foz
Colloc¢ioll nolorr'llllo: 03/11/200_5 - mall-lo common Plll-poso= lovolllgalloo wapa §
collected By= _ 7 l 961 UH
Collemon hamm
Paclmginngnantity/ltem Typei The following item was collecte'd: - l - BlOLOG|CAL
Deta'i| Desuiption: 2» buccal swabs from tyrone berry cm n ,\j
owoel-. le`_n»l Blu'TrANv 6 Ll'
serial #: NoNl-: V\’
Item Notes:
Ln”olll.l'~lolllool-' '-:Rrrs>\n”" r'rA _ _, _ ,_ ,_ ___ __
containeth l ' ` ' ' ` ' Pmcess: H_o_ld for invesiiga\ive purposes
Stams/lacation: Sl_oro_d in Loal_t_iol_l ~ R_K Ro§v 01 Shelf P12 _
Collecdon Date'l'ime`: 02.{28f2005 ~ 1433-im . Colledion Purp_ose: lovesli_gation y _
Qo¥ W‘"‘l‘
Colla!cted By:
Collectio`n llol:ahon:
Poologlogollolllllymolll Typo= Tllo following ilolll was ool_loolod- . RAPl-: / sequl. Ass-Aul.T l'_'<_a's, in cause number 1~019634 (the primary case), where Applicant was convicted
pursuant to a plea of guilty fo_r the- felony offense of sexual assault of a child. The court assessed
punishment at ten (10) years confinement in the Texas Department of Cr'iminal Justice -
~ __Qoxrcctions lnstitutions Divis'ion. No direct appeal was taken. _
Applicant-’s previous applications for writ of habeas corpus, cause numbers lOl9634-A,
1019634-B, lOl9634-C, 1019634-D, lOl9634-E, and 1019634~F are:~cu'rrcntl'y P€.I_l_ding.
_ nu n
The State of Texas denies the factual allegations made in the instant application, except
those supported by otiici_al court records and offers the following additional reply:
REPLY 'ro,_Al>.PLchN'r's' _Fms'r _'rHRoU_GH Tu'l__lu) GRoUNDs_-FOR RELlEF
Applicarlt alleges in his first through third grounds for relief that coln'l_sel was not present
when'a DNA sample was taken from him. .ln_his first grolmd for relief, Applican_t alleges this to be
- Aa 7a
'a violation of his Sixth and Fourteenth Amen_dr_nent rights-g i"n his second ground for relief-, Applicant b
' alleges that this violates his right to counsel; and in his third ground for relief, Applicant alleges that
this caused.his conviction to b_e obtained `by error of the court and counsel..
Applicant fails to cite any authority for his claims thathe has a right to have counsel present
upon the ordering of a DNA test or the taking o_f a DNA sarnple. Furtherrnore, Applicant does not
allege that the taking of the sample was improper or that it harmed hirn in any way. l_n addition, the
record makes it clear that Applicant appeared with counsel on May 2,5', 2005 when the DNA test
was ordered;.; See Sta'te ’s Exhibit A, Docket Sheet Er"ztry in cause number 1019634. Applicant has
the burden of alleging facts which if true would entitle him to lrelief. Ex parte Mald_onado, 688
S.W.2d 1-14, ‘1 16 (Tex. Crim. App.. 1985). Applicant has not met his burden because he is unable
to demonstrate that he was harmed in any way by the ordering of a DNA test or the taking of a
DNA sample. Furthennore, Applicant fails to allege suf§cient.facts to prove that counsel was not
present Therefore, Applicant?s first through third grounds for relief are without merit and should~be
denied z
III.
Applicant raises questions of law and fact which can be resolved by the Court of‘Crimi'nal
Appeals upon review of official court records and without the need for an evidentiary hearing
n AP)\ 7[@0
IV.
Service has been accomplished by sending a copy of this insu"u_`rnent to the following
address:
Mr. Tyrone Berry
# 1.368050, Beto Unit
1391 FM 3328
Tennessee Colony, TX 75880
SIGNED this 14 day of Decemb_er, 201`0.
Assistant District Attoméy
Harris County, Texas
1201 Frankli.n`, Su;jl¢ 600
HOuStOn_, T€X`as 7-700,2
4 (713) 755-6657
TeXaS `BaI I.D. #24049201
ims/mem <>”1 1014 _»
timm Coum\t Distru m C,cea\c APX 77 G
1910.150)< l‘| 651
lineman/lemke 77110' th>§|
V\e-.Tmuc%nm»/ "‘13¢>%050
CDANO 'H' 15 ' 00 @‘+ LR | imbler/der
Tntttam**ro\%za taoamema
”E>Tuettmoaauca §4»<¢¢ OP'I'm/Disimvt Cucm/Cs Orpr¢,c, /
BRE,M!N M. \ Wopc’rmz LMtt/R F\Hoa iam Y\’lumb¢t,RQF lab
§/ri Reauc-st le W\av c-Pu asu am 15 lit/Tmas Rewa.octnuaL Apu~xc¢To Kuu, 34. 5 L'L,Lmd$ Rmoru>, (G).' Comw‘r§.
`L)N\,e,s~s'|'u@?m¢\£s Dmem~\'me'l'vw, F\uucv$ lM‘l/M/Apau..mz,
P\woao B\r Aemmnm Uuome,n,/,§‘i . l Tnc, Rbc,or¢L,PLM OP\DLH,NS LMMmN "[”P< OFBU\LTY O&Noc.o
Eemwowq, HASBW\\ im mm, AH~¢ Boa,um ama imc/wm
FAPC\’\&LPM\,A¢. 1
(b).' AN~r Rmu.wn Fop\meNcrs OFF/.>M. l
(b}: Rw,cnums4‘F0&Aoo\410N»¢L l?[z:m$ (Z)'f Rmu&,TBL
§op,c,\\¢\c,:"D\-Pw
|u“‘l’r¥r; CLE.RJC$ V\‘E,LORD mus/\ §Pn,-a,lm,p.a.u( DL€¢NI%LTHL
l~rm\ SOTW ’H»L CLmLCA[H Mn LLH 10 mm z Fw' H. _’VMCW\\L
h)lL¢_DlsP\§/UMD k (5&»1 \UAL, Dr FiLE.T\Jomgu-A01 RE»\D 0000 ON YYlM 2510,
1005 'l'me l10w\ l)\)ou~w 310 AM @RO0RF00»M’Y00 00 001
DP\DU>~\NLFFMD\z/Pm\lmmm COU,wlol~\ G~PT\&/'>ct l).@s~£
’lltv,APDOL0/.>r,ras 00 100(`_'00001 DM Lm0 Z OF
1101 bowman laTA€DM0§1mP” DP YYl)<~: 705 2005 011
L\Nekl 01 lmeDDL,umm l¢»Tw:, l»l¢ml> blmmq HM/mlm\\,
" DHP§’V§H O&D0RFJ0’.
Tlr0 l10m‘)?w1\0m001 B\s,mo Rmuwrw 311/ims Amu.»m1 ’Fo Ru003“l 5 [b) OP
’Fm’lm»e-, Rm_0¢, 00 0101’0100)\1 0 900 000 000 ,l MAD:> 11 m 0 15
Sm.\1100\1r~0me ill .Dm 10/101‘7 011100 lm onmc,e',
Foe\“\'m){& hamm A1101l11011 "Fo Tle ~lmPoMAT»\L| Ll1elDl=~,1m01 CDA
wm er.WloseLe-.w' Monnez,lal.kw
.£>:m_m __
w mx_._=w=
m
m
_ _ . __________0000.0 .mmwoz<§_~§z€
OHZHE _Q.WU_E$ Qw _H=_H .GQC-.,_~.
§
_z><. ~m~§
..m__m_u__m~_§___
. .- __._ Ih_.»_.\§i,. .. mp
__z_. _mm.mwoz._ §§ _.§ _ . vi `
P.Y_ § \0\\_`\@®0§_
w_,._._______._.==n!z=z>_.5___=___6=__0.50____0____0__=__S.E...,a..___: _ 23 . _ _ _ _E;§
nnn.olluolnll\\lu»non\\¢`llunuulnl\llllrnnnlrl¢rn¢unr`u)"rnluuynnrlnun\uulunl\\visuan
Incidenc~no. 030415605 N omnss ngpch * v_1>1¢\.4.'1_£ 1.002 Ap¥ 73
llnnlll¢ll1ln|ll\l-lllililllionllonni\'lllllllrnl|nlllill`l`lnn\uv-llunan|nl\lllln¢ull|nl\wlrandall
snr‘m\m smr"m - uNoPr-:NF.D,- No'r. INvi-:N'rc>'r_z`_r"_s_n
REsuL'rs oF ANALYsIs=.
_NO SPERMATDZQA WERE DETEC.'I'E_D ON T!-[E VAGINAL SMEAR (ITEM A_] NOR THE ANAL S'HEAR
(ITEH B) .
SPERHA'I‘OZQA, CELLULAR CONSTITUHN.TS OF SEME_N, WER.E DETECI'ED GN TH_E VAGINAL' SHABS
(ITEM 'L) AND THB CROTCH AREA OF THE PAN"II,E_S (ITEM R) .
No 11ch PHost-IATASE, A non'spscI-Frc cdnsn.rmr op sm.=m_, )_Non P.so, A sem-
sp::cn':c co'NSTI'rusNT, wm ns.'rscrs'n on m Amu. swAas (I-'rm M).
No mca EvI_m=:m:E was oas!-:Rven _r'i'v m marc HAIR, courses (I-m J)_.
A STAINU\RD WAS MADE FROH THE IQIOWN BI.OOD (ITEM K) FROM ‘I'HE COHPLAINN€T BRITI`A_NY
SMITH.
DISPOSITION OF EVIDENCE:
'I'HE FOLLOWING .I.TEMS .ARE BE'ING RETAINBD FROZEF| IN .’.["HE LABORATORY:
ITE_M L: VAGI!DL SUABS IJ\.BE_LLED SWABS # 1-4._ BY ANALY'ST
ITEM R: CUTTING PROM THE CROTCH AREA OF THE PAN'TIE_S
S‘_I_‘A CARI_) MADE FROM KNOWN BLOOD (I_TEM K) I-'ROM THE CQ_H_PL`AINANT BRITI'ANY SMI'!_'H
"2` B CCAI:' SWABS FROM mQNE BERRY" KNOWN SUSPEC'_T R_EPRR-BNCE SAM_PLBS; BARCQDE:
R-3OD
ALL OTHER ITEMS OF EVI_DENC-E WI_-LL BE RB']_Z'URN`ED TO THE PRDPERTY RC_OM IN THB
ORIGIRAL PACKAGI'NG
hump-
supplement entered by = 113315
Date cleared- 03/1_0/05
END OF PAGE TW_O
135
175
mwmn\l
MBO
oRpLR
THE CLERK |S ORDER.ED send a copy of this Cou_rt s fmdmgs of fact m cause numbers
7098!4 and the instant order to the Defendant’s appointed counsel, Leah Borg, 874 Yorkchester, No. 1`23,
Houston, Texas 77079 and to the anomey representing the State of Texas, lnger Hampton, 1201
Frank|ir\, Suite 600, Houston, Te)`c_gs 77002 .
BY TI-IE FOLLOWING SIGNA'I'URE, THE COURT A_DOPTS THE STATE S PROPOSED
F[ND[NGS OF FACT ON THE COURT’S DEN]_AL OF DNA TESTING
...~-.'- “""'"`-~.,,,-
signed on this lie day of C,$“°i§m, 1334 ~ ,2013_.____
“ y\P\RRIS "~.,
--="` ‘< 00 `
z z j 0 ~."". '. "-_4 n "
HONORAB'LE MARC BRowN '
PRESIDING JUDGE, 13;1“‘ DISTRK:T coURT _
HARms COUNTY, TExAs ‘a :'
unani!-,“'
'l
¢-“"'
157
Court Coord‘uiatnr No. ~Z-A
blm 8{
\Dl¢lei?g _»'\T).»,-Q GDHc(Z