..
\N -rt\E
COU R-r. O'F CR\ lv\\N~L A??EALS
OF TeXAS
~R-771 577·-02
HAM\S t:t\A~b~1
Apf J; t--il:~~~f
Sei"A -/hQ.- lf/h Pi$/ri·t:-f Courf
Of Mc-l.~VIY111t1
{tJUvr/tJ 1e}(a.>
!vt {a.use No. 2012.-338- C 1
APPL\'-ANT1 .S FOR LEAVE 1'0
MO\\ON
F\Lt WR\\ OF MA-Ni>AMU.$
Coun.szl tf lALt\AR.T, \t:XA~ 7tto21.
APR 1 o2015
(~o') :24l\- SC,5.5
Abel Acosta, CIGrk
!rf f II c.-a V!+ Prb s~
...•
2
f~\~~"''). -\-o ~~tL·v-..\- "-.._~ V\1\.r:>;~'0\1'. ~< '((Lt:P"'~~Q..C~\c'l' ~ ,-"""iL (j~, t\rL
~O..,V\Ttl..\\1\.~ ~"' ~~ t2~t.~~"'-5\-:~\c2..~ ~~\ ~CL C\uY- h.~s ~"'-"\~ \-o ""\\ow
\\,~ hc...;JL iALLil->5 -\-o ~~s . ~u.c\ -:.,. ~r~S.fl-"'\, ~,s. \e.~~\- ~
f~~V'.S,~«u..\-\o"" ~>f \\:,s c...\o..,""S \~ ~'-S ef\.~\V\.t\.\ ~~~\q:o..'to": ~ o..
w., co....-~u...S tJ.V\ku R~Jl.. I~·~(~\ o.VI..$L ~IL \. s ~"'\~\-\~ -\- 0
VV\ ~ \1\:~ 0.. VV\V. -c.e.\, e.f~
>
W\\\:.Rf::"Fb~~/ "REM\St:.S CD~S\b:C~1 .,c\~~\\UA."'-\ ~\o.y> "*'c& 1\IL
[ou.-e-\- '!fo-.'1\.\: \t~:;. 'f\1\.olf,oV\ ~ \~va.. -\-o f\o.. ~~s w'l\\ "S f~Q..(\'V\.o'fll...
ij'ffA't\..\: ~":.. ~ N\.1;\.h.kA~V..~ '( JL\~ e.t..,
"E.'<\ c..\o ~k I t\-..cL. Co~(\- f\ ""~
":\--\-o-. ~SLS o... Lr. ~ '{ ~ ~ y~\\c.AVI.-\-fJ
w \\\ £_
b'<~~;"' A.\ "-m-c>V\~Y\ ~ f'\1\S\.ku~~oV\ of,/ *'.Q.. ~fl...'A.\1}..\ -\-c ij'CtJ...JS. \,e.\,~ \\1\
11. ~~l.u.«\ t~v'\ fe(' wr<\- et 'vv-.\..i.AS c..-o{ ~ v.5.
~._,~~M,-\--\..9..;
+\--l\_ M.~ s G'n a.:'r\ ~ ((_
\b~ \ g?... ~ ~ \ l
b~ "A.(-\- r-J~~-t
\\ "\5o F M t\ '\ ~
Do.\hiiUt1 \~ /'\D2'2..-7G.2Lt-
(St> t;) 2.ltl\- ghs:s;
A-rpfi &tH1f r~ 5;.;
3
\N -rtt~
CoURT 0~ CP-.\ M\ NAL. A\'?t:A\....S
OF TEXA-S · ·
..
~R-77, '577- 0 2..
H.AM\S · CHAtlbE1
,Jrp p/it, tli'rf
~e.e.\<\ "'5
tt ta.\oQtkS Lc(~U.~ R~ h~
U"'be.( Art~'- \e. \\. D7
TH"E: STA-rE OF 'TEXAS
PrJ . . ClfiAfertJ/ fh1 /fiA /)itio{,f {ourf
l¥ /vft,knnt~n Coimfy1 Te>'e~.,..,o·~ · 6~ ·
T\\t: I>E l'l \A\. TO ttR."~T {2.1:. L\ EF \"' A?~l\'A' \0 t-l
r:o.ft, WR.\,- OF \·h~:.8 EAS COlt·f US .. ··. · ·
CouH.>Il/ of Ret.orl for. Apph[onf~
+\AM\.S Ct\Af\\bt
\ t>~ \ '6l.g 3\7
t>ALt\A\t\ ll~ \T
\\ '\ S 0: F M '\ l\ ~
bALt\-1\RT, \1:. '/..AS 7~p·.2.1-7b~~
. (i>O.b)?.. 4"\ ~ $f,S'S
Appli?lflnf 11-D Se:-
.·. \.
;i"";;·rigir~~:~~~: ·~~\
Now Lc. \1\1\es . A ?~\\c.~V\-t \ V\ -\\~· a ~t>Vtl. ~"'-\\ \ \~i A\'\~
V\U\v\lo. . ~£~\, UA\u>V\ t".l{ \A.H,\ t)f ~~bel1S
cor~\AS \..\\1\JXU Ar~\.'-',\· 1"\\E
.·,:,·.·: ·: ;R\:6·~~·· ·o-f:. FA.\R:NES5 1 A:~.tr<··E~uti·r·Y. ·.' >·.. · .
... .. ·. ,. ,. :· .':·. ' . . .. . . ., ' .. . . ' . .. . . . ~
r-• • .~. ' •• • •.
A. G ~ u nl Ju >lice r:ett q;;ei }~~~ Mtt f/er:a,htm tf fhe {de
TWi.: i~'J'~~ t~~~~ ·o~~·. ~f.\~'~.~~r--.. A.~-~~\~ ,., .Yt~~ n~~£ ~.J t\.
:;~~"~f~t;~\ ~~:~~~k~._~ ~ i~ ;,:e~~~1J/1tlf~:~ ~r. .···. . ·
i" Lo "S' ~\-e.>t\- w '-\\., S\l.lo £;\·.. "'~ /.\.\ Y, ')1,.-\s •of yM-\y.'I_.>~ e. >fAe V. . ··
l{ernloVJ/.2\5.!>-W~ 3.J.. 'tO\, ~07.n.'. \7 Ctfl.)<~ &n-v\_-A rp;. :lC'tfi)~\h~S1 ~k
C.b\J..c+ h~ U>V\$\r'""-eA_ ihQ.. ~.tL')(A.S · Ru.\e..s of A \'~.~\\~\e... ?~(:)t.e.t>..""-ce.i
Rl.l\1?.. 71 ..·1(£) ~~ti :e~\Te. 4\,\J_:~-.~·(+J~ca Co~(~ ~~fA.t. o."' \~S· OL~V\~
\ ~v\-\ fJ..\- \ v~ re Lo V\.S \ Ae..f{ . ~~ C/A.5e. •./1 "G >< p a..rfe lv{Die 11 o;, ~~5.; ~~.w, ~A
4\'\ 4'J..7 (tjl~·C(-,M~Aff· :lDD<6).: 1""-~s \.> .$L'.L~ t\ Lti..>ll.~·"'V\\<2- .
o~~\e.~ S\t&e..> s\.\.~.~e~\e. Cou-(-t- ht\.~ \tt~t~ %i~-· A ~;,!•tL\i;_ . (f)' ~~._sc,.re.. tv·~\t\ .
.
'
...... '
/:~. -- "<~~--:;·~~.~..:. :::~;·
•' i~(.4.t- R.")(\St s unAt'<' st"'\a. \"w. -f_~Q._ Hit.) 5~ c.t. 1ll:71 ·:l~ ~11 1 b~ l- t~- ~! \"?5 (\~ ~D)j Atl-orf . -_. ··
)niv.st>~ v, )Dne.>/ 7'+3 F. 'l.A :Jobi l.o<& (:>t\\·: Ll(~. :\4 <6t.t). T~\ 5 .·
~ ~\,l\ ~' \ .V\ L\ \..lA~ ~~ R\,l\Q.> of ·.,A PP_"- \\llr~ Yy~(tL_ ~U.(tL(>, :~ t\~' ''?'tp • .
re G~>\1\.S, ~e-r -t~~ LC-\Se. · .'oy, ~~ (],~A- Olt\ __:)Y> o_w \1\ . ~\!\.,\(~~~ Vr<.. · ·. • ·
esp~C:\A \\y .W~~t-V\.. t.\\1!.' Ay~\\ C/J~'v\* -~\(~~~-..s\·s. :for~.':_; __ ;: .... '·.·.'~:·· ../ .
··:>j3_,·~ AptiJ'c~YI*: felleJ_.
.
on. fe v~~·, 7~oihf$.. ,Of.· er~Dr .:·::· ·. ·_·.·' · .;.. :
' . . . . . . ·.·· .· ' . ' .. ~··""'-.. .
..
. .
l11 ,. a.,..-,&,, .. i~ W~~ ~v.\a. 7'1,'),0\ •f .w~ Td><..:S ~(,&~~. tf
_Ay~~\\~\a. ~YbL€.1-~ce:l A_yy\\LP~~. ·. ~u~-~~.st~_ -\\;~~\;~ ~~\~. ~?'-L~~ . :· .·
re.~bV\$\ ~e,r 5re>u.~b{_s. bh12- _JA.~~ ':t1.~t>. t>f -~"s . .' V\.,~-,~\ ·\\tt~e.~" ...
11.. f ~\"~ L" ~ \1) V\ "- S .We_ \\ A..$ .'\\.._ Ji\~ ~'~ S S <+\ P( ~' S ,1~ fe. ~ b. ~~<~ S_\ ~U . ~ e ~a..'-". ~-~,.~"\~ of.~((~(~~ .. ·?f ,.)\.~ ·· l
\ v\,-\·; ,\-, h!A.\o~ £\.~ ~ ~~\1._0'- tq)V\. -~'~ ' 'f._f..~{).._( ~.\ \1\ ~ .f.~'.. (A._) -l:>.~~~~'.
1 \
.~ ~~ sV,\ "'\;o '" ...\ :\ ')\,\. -\-.> _5 "'' (- r ~ ~~e S~ .....
J\.U'f.. \"'~\:( v. c*vr>V\) [ :,)_ N~ e"'' t\V"\ ' " L \'- D~. t\S · .,
ll. ?n"'('f·t\\ ikL\~~~ L~.) \\\ef£k:c.\~~Q·.· ~s:s\~~t\\\Cf.·· -~fe-~~.?.--\ ',..
L-?~~.s~; (b)\V\~tfe-:- ·· :.
.f:~~. ~:?'l~~~~ss.,j :p~~~t:\ t;&~I\1 ('v~~j~~t~r-eiiL~(". ·.·. · ·.:
· o..r~~Q...> 1\\~\ ~IL. ,~ L·.Am~.t\~V\V12. -~ff.Q.L, I(· 6f ail bf --t\\.e.- ~(f~CS· · ·.
· 5uf'ra_ J":Y\te.~ ·hLY\1\' Au.FL .~re>·t,£,.>5_ ·ll-hAe-r·· -~\(~·--f<£0 ·.
Go\1\.S~\~lA\-\ oV\~ .SiliL ~haW~ bulAl Y1 'V- 5fp_f~, "\'\~. S- we" ?..J.; '--~Pr'?: 3 ~ . ;. ·.
(TiL~-u~M.A Vf· J~'\~)~-"' Y\\.\h/\ \o~< _of, ~--< (l\r~ _,: '(V\c~y :~~ f9\~Y\~·q· ~. \"'t"( ~.el-l' ,
lV\ -\he\(".. C-uM \A\~ r,.ye_ e.f_{~ ~\ ). . .. . . · 1 . :. ; ; >. :: ... . :·. , ·. ..,:, ."
._' ~ ·;' '" .. . . .
. ·~-I I :t/ _... ' .·, . . - ·.· ... ·."· ...,:··.: . ·'" ·..... <., .· .- .. ,·.· ·. , . .
,:.~~- T~XAS ~QUI!:t Or=, Cfi·~;NA:C,,b:\>P.{ALS .1':\Z~i~b~NT •
~~&\A\ Rt:: S ¥1 R\11-E·N. O~l>Efl 0~ bE ~-\A~ . . .
OF Rt.L.\~r .. /
h 1\_._ , sQ.(I ov...S. nk\~J-i'~ c>f ~e.. L<>v\::.s-\',\ J<.I. o v1 6c\: . ... . .
D u.;._
. . . ' . 'I I . I .. . . ' .. (. .. . . .
· '1\ o\t>.t\oV\ \ V\_ ih \s. ·:~<2.1 . ~~?.'\ LG\.V\\ _.t(sSi2-(·\-~, :th~t- _t\\'> . C.vv.:c\ ~ ·-..-:
·'
JcH'\\tA-\ of Y\,s ~V\\-\-~p...\ \'\_~\o~r~ o..~~\l'-~*~oV\ ~.tA!/fh'Duf.,o.. .. v.H~~\:rLV\
',I. l .. -:, . • ~ ·.. : • =".
,
. .~
I,
.· . . II :•
'
'',I
.'
'
. ' .. . - ....., . ..... ,. : '·.
,.-,··' I •
.
..:;.·.
. , t ,, • . ·. . ~-
,., ! .
. ...........
~...::::;··,!..:~::....:•.;' ~~·.;~ ':;~. •
. . ,, o(~u Q. ,c: \)\ £.~-~ h\ "'f) .f e '"So\'\ fo i( t-\e_~-1: A\ -, 5 ., \"' . Lo'v\f\\. Lt.S w;~ . • --~·
. t\A ~~\b..\ \1\~ 5/w 1~tt '' o-5 A. ~Q.V\e.(~ \ ~fo ~t>>~\~o~.
\ V\
·. ~,"~· fQV\t~\~~','j c~u.!t> oujhf fD rnllYifio·n ti piuiy.~ . ·;..,:. iL'jU.Mrt.Yif_{)nJ
t')(~ftt, Yl _why !f Ji),.~t,! tttiJt /1aVft,: i/1t . f~!'S~ASI ,V'f f~r·c,~ ftu~f fhrL
j:Jtll/rfy flunk> l f doe>.. 5tM$: v. ,ffAf~/ t\t\ S_-w~_-.3~ . bDD1 boJ(l"~x. .
11
ex;~- A~f~ 2.oo 3):T\'\~>1 Ap~\~LA~ r(L¥~s"'-~ -:~tl\' ~\$ . (bu.rt :-\-_o·., , ·· ·
w\~"'\.\oV\ \\\s o.-r5·1.tYv\ci.v\t ·. o..\f'L~ £?_·,(~\~;.·~"~: ~~~\\. "r.e.c.~~~-'·:&_~~~~~~"'· ·-~ .
1\A' s C:A:5o.,. s C> -\\\ ~-\- ~t \ q, ~ s.t \1\Q., . vY \'\\ ~ \{\' w . -\~Q. . r etA.. s. o V\ "'cz. ·. wt\.S. t}
UV\S~LC.fL.SSfu.\ OV\ ~~~ \ \1\\\·\ ~\ \'\O.~.Q.~) .. lA f~\~·~-\-(· OV\/:\ \1\~t~ i ~ · .
~ka. '\_~tf;\- -\-~ 5~Q..S_S ery A.~~~-\~\Q_ {\~ re.o..~~\1\l/ A\'\J.. -1-~eAe.\o Y'<\~\~\~\V\'
-'' ~L · \ \t\-\· ~-t\ r l\y_ .~f ~~ · >y >~·a...~ Av\J... , \ \1\J'. ~ (o v~ ~. .~ ~·~~ \\ ,~\/ D""' c-\' c Q. /
1
sfl{}, /!- t.~yV.~"'"~ \s- iA.& AQJ). · · : _. ., · · ·· · - .__ . · · · . ·' .;. .~, .
• • • " ' ~ • # • ~. • ~ • • • • i .. . . 1 . • • •• ·' ,. • .
. ~. . , .
I·v_ ... : . ·.
:~
·-·. t
:· ',,
. . . .. ~ -W+\t.~.Y:. Ft R~ ?R ~ l'A\.St.S c c N S\ Dt:RE~ I .,A·~~\\ (A~ .~.'<0-:l>"<
• I -t~ '"'{ -\l,, ~ •\-\ C> ~xqr;~\o\,Q c~ U,.(+ : • !
·t·: _Fi~A ~.'::\·.~ ~ 4~~_es~~\·~,_· s\'\o~~~~ ~\C\~ ~QQ.\1\. y,·<~!Q/ ·
t\" lA* -\\, e.,rQ.. \ > .o-. . (...~ ~(\ ~ .e. \\7, v:tA. f.ef\.S:c"" +.o '~:~\\ ~ Y4~ · 1~ ~\
~~· (~ 1.~(\.· \'V\..O..f \f\1'..~· ~o•.Vli \:~.fLV\ .. Lti.(·(~~:\- 0\1\. 'ti(~ .;~\v.~-~\ ·' .·,
-~\.,\. \r-
v \'\'\ ·\ S 5 \ 'D V\'
J · - . .. · ' ...
.. · ·. .. . . . ' · -
1. Grr~"'\ fQ Lo\1\;;~e_(A\\ ~V\. ··of. , \~~-~ . ,~(·~ ~\~,~\ "'A'v>ra~5
(11. ~ ~'' (.o.. V\ cV\; (A;\'\~ ...
; ... I
J • • •• ·I
3 ... •,
~ • I
·r:' . ··<.- •. ·
Ra.spa.£.-tf,"Wy S:u.\o ~~'tte! ·· · .
- ... W---£s_ •. .. •. I
·. ~ {\~, \. s.. C. ~0\\1\ Je2.
. •'
\~~ \g~~3\7
Dtt\ \"~t~..ct ~\"'"\-t
\\ ttS D. f f':A ·ll £t g 0 • • •
1>11\ ~o.-~~1 l12;j( ~s 7 'fo.2:l::-.7'-?..'+
(~o6)21+'\··-~bSS,
..
• 0
'•
' · "·
Atpllcanf . Pr/) ..f~
·' .
PRDOF OF St R\!\C. "E. ,. ·.
\ \.e- r!1-; ~,011"-l) . N\ o\, c 1/X · vJ b>.$ ~"""-1~-!. -\-., N\<.lt \\\'1 o.V\
, C<>.>A ~'/ . 1:>1 5\-(' <.T ~ t>co( V\rif r> Off 1C« !._. W "- '" 1 I""'"'-~/ ~Dy ._.· ·. • •. _..... .
r\tv:.\\J\5 IV\ lA ~ti~CV\ 1'\1\t.l-1\l"'j sys\..\v\ OV\ jAV\IAMj 1:1.1 ?..0\!:j.
-~~~--- -~·-·;---f~:·
.\-\ cx.vv\ \ s· C-~·~ V\J~
.. .. \:
. -~
.•: ·.
: ..' ..
Chande, Hamis Athoman
Combined Opinion