,~ C....o·..;o.<"~ o~ C£,A,<--..~ P··~ ~ <...0....\s ~~; s : \..l ~- 8\ , \.\ ~ '3 - o \ ) \.J \\- 8\ , '-\ '\ '3 ~~'L~3-f4;
~··· \J"--8\, '-\~3 -03 l \rJ\\-6\, '-\'\'3 -o~ ; 'vJ\\-8\, "\-\ eo~{~ tJ\)~~: c'\-o'L\3\-cV-.~ ~1..11- ; o'\-D1..\3J...-<..,~~-t-12... 1
00..-02..\~~ ~ L~~- "2..'7'2- } 0'\ -C1.\ 3'\ -C~ -'L-12..} 0~ -01.\)S·-L\\.~- 1..12 •
§
§
'\1. § \tXAS w\.).\\\. o~
§
'-s'~"l.l'..f \"..-1'\
Or;)..u ~~ ~v\('\a-.\ ~v..(~ l "'"' ~""..~...-'-". ~\-..~ so.."\~ \);~QJ\ "'o\~ \-'rut...
f~o--\. ec~r\.- \-o ,('~()(~ \\va-. 'Jv--.b-'\~o..\ c)..~\~ ~0...~ ~{((,.. \(N,.J~;A\\1
* '\.\-
\
('~...u.~.:~c-~ '\,.1\~ov-...\ '\1\~\o...."\-"\~ ~('\.\ $~o-.~~5 l ~....,..:,~~\~!\< \~ \).~,~ S~o-...~~ -* ~~r\ '-o.- •
RECE~VED ~N
COURT OF CRtMINAL ft,PPEALS
MAY 08 2015
Ab~AOOStl, Clerk
--·
'"!:.~ sv....cx ~~'~
v~ ~~.s <'~"'-<2...-S·~ ~ ~()...'"-~ ~""'-\\~'<'-~ "{~"2C~· Gv.."-\1 \ (L.)(OS
\.SS'V\.~ o...f\. or~Q...( Oi'\. ~~<" ~ \0~ \ "2-.0\\A. ,V". 0.' (..C)( ~0..~\...L.
v\~ ~ \uo-5 Lob.~ iJ~ c..r-,~w,c.-.\ Xfo~v..rQ....--, 1\rl(~<-\~
3ra . '-\s.
~ .) ~ \.,_Xo...S Lo~\L. 0~ (.,.{\~\"-o...\ ~{OL~V..f~ 1 J\<\,t_\g_ ~~ · '-\5
~\ve.-5 ~\...~ ~v..r~ \"'ll- o..v-..~of\\1 ~o s~\. s~-~~~'_'- ~o-.~~;~5·
,~ LQ...\+\)..,f'\ ~~ ~~ b~ LC..S~ ~'~ ~fL. S~Q...C,~\<....o...\\1 o"""\-\,,.,_~
~ ~~\\oW'S ~
• r -_~--:")·
' ' - Af \ . ·:; u.u .'-\. .5· t.v~ ~~Lc,.... \)~\(..;..\'\ !"\.<\ a<
<"'
·1>~s<-r\b~~ 1\b~o...- 0~ .")(" sa.x~\ ~6.\A~lr ~ u._ '\_;~\~
o-r ~'\ t"\\:)f ·•
(o.:') 'D~r\":) ~ '-Ov..fS~ c~ 0... C...fv""'..<"--0..\ "'Q.....U.S~ ('.>\
~rO~~t"\~ 1 ~-Co~{~ ~1 <'0~ ~"'-~fl....- o...vo-:-~~\11-.r
or w.\ow ~ \oe....- ~o.Ae.... o-.J~~o.b\~ ~.::>-\' LOCXI'"~ 0'\
~~ss~~"t>..\;o" ~ ~~ ~v..'o\~L ~{';::,~~(\10-{' ""-O...~~o.\ ~
( 1.) \\....o..\- \....oN\\~·Q...S t_~'\\~ ~ti'\.o~f'o...~ '1 l ~
~uc.-r\be."~\ U>~Q....)
1
(2..) -~ '\'<'0~~\\)"" ~::>SScz•••.SS\Of'\ "~ ~~"""- '\·s.
o-f"
~ro~~~~~~~ ~~'V\ Su...V,.::;"" '-\'"?,'26\., ~(\.a-.\ l~~ i vr x
( 3.) ~o.;\. \) ~ QJL.'('\b~~ 'bl Su.M ">1'- '2. .5 1 <3(
Ar\-\L\.,_ 3<6 .01\ ~\.. -\~,\ (....~~"- • .
(b~) '""""~ ~~\- .S""I:l\..\\ ~\~'-o... ~{·::,~~t~1 ~r ~~~~~c...\
~L.5<-r\~~ 'b1 s~s.v-\-"~f' (_~ -C"\~~r s~\ ~ ~ ~r~
o·('. v~~L.\v-..5'\ G"'
r::>~ ~ ~c-\~~"-<.>..\. \-..U>-~\~~ ~·r ~ro(..JL~~ •
(c.:)~ J\~~O{r--~'-"'S sh.o..\\._ b~ ~r:>J,~~ ~(.~S"S -\-:> ~~
s~~~i"'-~":.o..\s ~ o..(.\.':)f~tQ.......-~,~ ~~., At~3<\~~·-·
\_~\\...o.- C...o"""\- ~'r,~ ~~- s~~~ ~roQ.C" ~~~ \"~\-\--:~ s~ -- . .
C..)
'\'\.~ ~()..t~ \\J~ 1 LO\'\ s~''"~ \:)t"~Q,' ~ \~'<'Q...'\ <...o""{~
:)<.LQ...~~~ .\~ t>..."'-~"'of\~1- .o~ '-.,...(.....~,
Q...
1 Ar\-. 3~."'\.5 ),,z...c;_o...""'-.S~
~~ Ci'~~r \<"-L..-\v.-~>!..~ \\-~J ~ ·'bL-- Sq_~~ ~o-.~ 6-.o N>~ fi'\CL.c...~
~~ '-..t\~Q,f\\)... ~~c-('\'b~ ~ ~<\--- 3~ ."\5 LS-5'1 ~ S~o...'b\Q.,..-
'fl'\...~~"''' ~s • "'~' ('' ~'\ U>~t ~ \s5~~ o..~ o-.~ub~co1.. SCl.O...\\~ ~
~t'\1 \~~ ~"'-Qo.,..~ .'\S ~~~v.,S~\~"\ ~.
-.
C...Ou..r\- ·r\9"'-~~"'-\\1 s~~ o."\1
• S~o....\~ ~x~~\\ t-1
• ~~f..s -E-~~,\,;~ s ~ s - ~ ro
.. • S~o..~u ~)(\\,'b\~ S)
.. v..~~cr\-u;- \<..u.o~ v~\v..~w \) l \\.\ l \5
(. .) "'e.. "~~ucw <'t'\.~~~r-,o-..\:) ~""-~\- \~ \r,~\
s~e..~ ~r«- \"\s~ ~ ~\\ovs ~·
C-Dv..c\ v-.f\.~v...,S~\1
• ~.\-u.-~ '"E.-)(\;~-« <2,_~ - '1'\0"'-- ~,\\ll-_:)~\ SC..e..l\~ ~~::>\o.
• S\o...\-u ~~,\),~,0- "~Y'\-\\\~L.~"'-\ ~11'1''''~~\c..s ~"-~s.
· s~~ "E~h0o'*- ~\ A~, - ~:)'"' "''~~~),..' ,~~::>\o.s o~ ~~'~· "M.O~~.s.
• S~~e..s '£.)(\:~,\-s \OS·-\ 30 - C'\.04'\.--,\\~L...jo-..\ ~"~~ <:>\. ~f~f\ ~o. ·...!~
""~ ~ "~~':..~ v~ ~ ~o..r~~l.\\~>v.
·s~u ~~~'~ ~ <32-- ~ ~0 - ~':>"'--,\\~o..'\ ~~~\os i)~ ~--\~ s~\
vJro v./o-.S ·c-::.A \Wz_ ...i~~' .,. ,. .__ ~ ~· ~\.-
c..\..o..~~ Q~~Q...- •
... S\-o-.\~ ~,'b\.lrS ~ \\~- ~ \J....~- 'l\'::I!V·,\\~t..~o..\ 1 \'\Ot'.~v"\0r'.."'- ~~o~~.l.
• .S~o...~\!.5 u\-.}o~)r:S '-\ '\ A-~ ~ '-~· S,s~s .c...·:,-~~~~~~ o·.,\1 \~u-.\
.J,O-~~...cU ~~ Q,_\..~ - ~ ,\ ~~\ ~'\.\re.l'l.~.
• 5-\o....\u Ex"",\:;.\- \0~ o.. - .:-~. ~~sY", ~ f'o.C<\-;\\~~..rj~\ Q.J.(\-ro.N...o'-"s ~"'\-w.
• 5\--~\-Ls f.x\:~«"' \OC\_ - <-.9,.. ~·\.5~ o~ ~~"-~\\~~~\ .~...:,(\-f<)...1\.'U).J$ ~~i\..\.-.
• ~Q...~u t.x\..~'o~\- \~\ - '-~~ 6-~s"' o~ \JL~\ ~~~ 9x<\ ·..Ao ~ 'f\-o\-
.\~ \1~~1""'\. o\ ~~ c."-~,9~ ~Q..<'\S"JV •
• S+~ ·"£.x\.;,):),-\- ·~ \0\ - r\\2. - c..~, &~~"'--~ o~ u~~(()..'(\e_;:)~ ~:0. ~~
-\\-.a-\ ·wo.:s f\.o'>-r o- &.o..r9~ (...f\1'1\,~('o...\
c.:>~~~\\.S~' O.C\.~ ~" ~:,~..-\..., ~ ~~o~\.-.
~~~'\..._\q}._ <).{~ C"\.t)\ ~It- ..i~~~ ~~ ~Q... •
• S\v.....\-~ "E-)(~:0~\-.S ss - 5\c. - ''L..\'' 6-Ct.S"-\o.~ \.::.""-~~fc...f l O.f\.~1('\,/\1\boO~
. \o..~:::>~ (.,:)..-_~.~~ ~~f...~ U)."~'"u.\
\ '\ .
~'::5\~Nl., "*- .J\~~~t\
Q ... vo..\v.."V.
f·.) ·far ·~ AC\'V...AL ·y~ocr ~~\- ~Q... -,~ \~s\-~ 0\..b.!:)\Jv o..ttt
("\* \\\~9o..\ 1 0'-C\.~ \\...Q..n ..~·~<" ""t::>~ s:~~ ~L~ \0 \,~!'\9 5~\~ l t~~:t-c
~ ~ ·~!;)r\-"\~N ~ ~~ ""~~t)\~Q.AS -·~·~..'-0(~ \('\ ....~\~\... .~ "\o\\~Q....
0.,('\~ ))~\<"':."-'~ A\\vr1'\~ ~h.~s~\...Ju t\01"'\3...'\ ~· "('\!>t"'- \\\~t.~o..\
f\.~\-\JI..t'~ ~~ ~ ~S • \of ~...,_~~QA' ~r.~~, .s"\"'~''1 Q..l)('~;~~:V ~
Q,J.j,~~~ \~~~ o..\,~~. \\.Q...~i::~{~W ~~~ ~I..J\.~U o...(e..,.- oJ;. ~:>\\o...,/5.:
®
•.
""'" 0 ~~ \\
']_ ~v..../3 1 \..c-.. '\ - \\,q,.... "'-.H~\-\~ '\~\'_'-~ 0~\LQ..\ ~~~~ ~k\-
. -\~ Q...')(.\-f O>..<'\~ ~\.o\-o.S O..{Q..... f\O'lr ';.\\~o..\ •
• ·2 ~~ 1\.\, t..(\. \\-' s - os.~-,tR..f ~~:.~ ~~:;)\o.'i o..t-v- <'-0\. \\\~a..\ ..
• '-\ \\\\ \L..) l \...f\, ~- \3 - 0~~-,uu- ~"{(~\~~ ~~~·~ ~:\-ro....i\W"'-S ~"-.~
~('~ NJC'\- ':.\\~')cA.' ~~ ""-<'\o.S~U. ~"t:)\.a,S •
• 4 Rv._ \:,S '\...t\. (\- \5 - 0~-:.\...Q.\ Q,...,(~\\)..~ ~\~ ~\\o-.~Q.Qv-...\ v'~o\oS
o..('e_ ("\'Jf\-\\\~a-\ ~~('1\<'\o-,.S~L.S ~~~~ •
• s ""' 1:\l' L". ca- \1 - ""\\...ll.- S\A\"t:.S 0\~N 'Q.f'\ ILX~\\).."\~. ·~~'~
~e...
((
"2.\
,, .
0....~~
I( ' - '-
~ ,~~~
,, '
c...>""'-~---'\CU',S ""'o.
.l... "
N·0\_ ~r-.~1'\ AN'i \\\~t..~o...\ t.ol'\~~~~"'s.~ .._,;,~('\Q...55 &~<'\'i~t~\-~ ~;;:rv.J ~
q_.,(\,-o..f\fl.-ov..&. ~\...-::>\0~ -...Juq_, .::/~ o.... ~e.t"'o...~
~o ~ u~ \~o.." ~~v - ~:.\- ~"-~IU"" O..v..S o..."~
6\,--.~'-.;::)~\1 ('\.;::)C\- \\\'l..'~:r'-· QX"','o\~~
~~~s~~ \~-<'--\)...\ <...ou'\s
"',\\ w\\\ ~'.J~t¢... ~\...'!,., ~~~\.::>~~\ \~ ":.~ o...~~~'>t- -\o
\t'"~~~,~~~''1 ~--:."~~ ~~~ ~:::>s~ ~~-.J~~,of\ o..cx~~\~ ~r~<-R..Ssu •
· \_). \-\-.Q...- \f"\~\ (..o..,...t~~ S\l...~'..~ ;:)~ ~ Q.~..:·,~\~ '\~ ~w&er
1
t""--o..._\-(Q..S --_\- ('1\Q~L ~--~V,t...v..\"'
~~- ~~
\. - ' . ~ .
~\?....\\.~o:\.~
·\-D cv~~(\.Yrfo-..\-~t-
( ,,.J\~ o...<..\-~~\ ~\...1s~~o...\ Q.')(~~\~) ·~\...~t...- \:>.A- o..~~ \('~~\ ~\~.S
Ov..\-to...~Q..A.......S"\1 s\()..."'t)...~r~ ~s~ ":l"'+ "'~"'-'! "t~~~'~"Q..\ Q •••.f,~-~.,"-UL
~"'\- C~~o,J'~\.~ "{'Q...'.lv....~'.. <:-~ ~ ~-.)...'f~fS o..~~;.'<"-..S~ -\-\...Q....,
"?Q....\~v...~~~. \\~~ \-~·'~"\)...' u~~~ ~:;:,\- '\rJ('<)~~~"'\\ sQ..~~ ·~
1
Q..x\..:,\:,,.}p ',\- ~~~\~ V....o..vt.- <"'--~ -~ ~QA~\-,ot\QSS ~~~~'- 'C"'.""-'-~
s\c-~~jQ...{' 'b~~l2.- ~ o.-~o..'\.. ~""-IS"\~""-'\. v,<"-~~\Jl.....-- G"""r\-- -w\\\
\~...,~~'~o..~ ·~~ <-\~~ ~· ~"""" '\\-.s -.Jt;)...\"'~~1 , .f'~U-0_5('\\1:.~ '\.+s
<"'Q.,t" \~
1 0..<"-~ ~ 1''1>.~~- ~~~ wfi ~ \- •
S)t= LLA~AT-l_ON
Pr5 \~ ~~-'\~"'\~(\\U'" o~ ~~ '\,./{~'lr- '"""5~\~ \\\:.vr ~o."\.s l
l '
hQ..f~1 s·~c..o...<" V..t'\.~U ~""-t'\.~\~1 v~ ~Q...t~~t~ l ~~\- ~\\ ~~ QJ\...~
.,~\)\~¥,Of' u:>f"'.~~~Q...o..... \-...uct.A~ o.N,....- ~t""'-q_, O...r'\.~ C.:>\f~ ....
-s-~\-\<"'. vo..."-_~ ~\\J~\.\~~2.
~e-\~orO.... \,)..i\~~
'2> COt\..'\ S~-\- ~ \\'"-''1 . <\Davis, Justin
Combined Opinion