,~uise Pearson Clerk
Court of Criminal Appeals § Ex.Parte Shane T. O'Grady
P.O. Box 12.:308 § RE: Cause No. 58863
capitol Station § 412th Judicial Court
Austin, Texas 78711 §
§
Dear Clerk, at this time I find it necessary to request your assistance to the
following.
·Now comes Shane T. O'Grady in Cause No. 58863 in Pro Se status in a Nunc Pro
Tunc Motion that was originally filed in the District Clerk's Office in Brazoria
County on May 07, 2015. He now request this clerk pursuant to Texas Rules of Court
to perform his ministerial duty of serving the District Attorney Jeri Yenne 408-A,
111 East Locust St. Angleton, Texas 77515. O'Grady has no use of a copy machine to·
make copies himself to send the District Attorney's office due to his incarceration.
1) O'Grady objects to the District Court's ruling on or about May 07, 2015 by
judge Denman in the 412th District Court. Enclosed please find one page letter from
Judge Denman dated August 25, 2015.
2) In accordance with law O'Grady had asked for Judge Denman to Recuse himself
from making any rulings on these motions because of his relationship to the case.
3) Please note on pg 1Lof 17 that Judge W. Edwin Denman Recusal himself in this
case at hand for being for being disqualified from case/cause No. 58863. See now
argument.
4) O'Grady will now ask the Court of Criminal appeals to review these motions,
and either rule on them, or remand back to the District Court and order that Judge
Denman Recuse himself from c~use No. 58863, and order anothe~ Judge to make rulings
on motions enclosed.
5) Pro Se Applicant kindly request acknowledgement of recipt of my filings by
returning applicant a stampfile copy (my motions and this notice) .. JPlease find a
self addressed stamped envelope enclosed. If any filing fee is needed please notify
O'Grady of filing fees.
RECEIVED IN
COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS
SEP 15 2015
Abe~ Acosta, Clerk
This document contains some
pages that are of poor quali~ ,
17 of 17 at the time of imaginSJ~ --~--"'
W. EDWIN DENMAN
Brazoria County Courthouse Houston 281-756-1915
111 East Locust DISTRICT JUDGE Brazosport 979-388-1915
2"d Floor, Suite 201 412th Judicial District Angleton 979-864-1915
Angleton, Texas 77515 Facsimile 979-864-1918
August 25, 2015
Mr. Shane Timothy O'Grady
#1614317 .
McConnell Unit
3001 S. Emily Drive
Beeville, TX. 78102
RE: Cause No. 58863; State ofTexas v. Shane Timothy O'Grady; in the 41ih District
Court, Brazoria County, Texas
Dear Mr. O'Grady:
Ms. Rhonda Barchak, District Clerk of Brazoria County, has forwarded me your letter of
August 10, 2015 requesting that I sign Orders on the Motions that you sent in May of this year.
I had reviewed your Motions right after they were originally filed. However, I found no
merit in your Nunc Pro Tunc Motion, so I could not sign that Order. In addition, I no longer have
jurisdiction over your remaining Motions.
Since I no longer have jurisdiction, I cannot either grant or deny the relief requested in
your Motions.
~tru~
·- W. EDWIN DENMAN
Judge, 412th District Court
WED:lmk
58863- O'Grady ltr 8.25.15
•,
IN THE
COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS
AUSTIN, TEXAS
EX PART~ SHANE TIMOTHY O'GARDY § FROM THE 412th JUDICIAL DISTRICT
Cause No. 58863 § COURT OF BRAZORIA COUNTY, TEXAS
Pro se §
REQUEST FOR LEAVE TO FILE "JUDICIAL NOTICE," "PLEA OF ABTEMENT
AND PLEA TO JURISDICTION" AND "NUNC PRO TUNC"
TO THE HONORABLE JUDGE OF SAID COURT:
NOW COMES SHANE TIMOTHY 0 'GRADY, also known as Applicant Pro-
se is currently incarcerated at the McConnell Unit of TDCJ-CID,
#1614317, Bee County, Beeville, Texas and files the above refer-
ence cause number, moves in Pro se status as follows~
I. "JUDICIAL NOTICE"
Judicial notice of adjudicative facts pursuant to art. !I.-
Judicial Notice, Texas Rules of Evidence, rule 201. This rule
governs only Judicial notice of adjudicative facts. When judical
discretion is the best system of law wh~ch leaves the least
discretion to the Judge. This i~ an advantage which results
from its certainty. See now, Burton's Legal Thesaurus, 5th ed.,
pg. 19~ and. the Texas Lawyer Criminal Codes and Rules (2013)
at pgs~ 1.113-14. "Judicial Notice", on appeal should be taken,
if at all, ~Where necessary to avoid an unjust judgment." (at
456 of) Watkins v. State, 245 s.w.3d 444, 455-56(Tex.cr.App.2008)
cert. Denied, 555 u.S. 846 ( 2008) ~(Ca.vt' 0;Y ?j~ ~~ f 1 7)
1 of. 17
,.
...
k£/Oo.s/.J/1. S7/ft't:1 ~'// jaj-s,i_ fo{)_; · (;,~(q(, {rkld, (f/l~Jm.
• - d' 4 . Q· . . .
t1#J. .:IZ0N_7a !:J~_/l_Z-$.t'Lt!;;_l/i?(J__
.If Pt._Ef}_/j..; f}etfTFIJ?e.lT;__"Jlj ChAI/GJUGt;~ 771£ 'PL/1/~T,~J. !Jie~M~5_·__
. l3y_flllEGiJJG 'i11oT6 oe&---a~!JF T/k_? fJwiJ'DW~s ~/!@o).IU 7JLe__
. · Sufc-_cBAJAltLl . Go· =i_oR);.JIJfG[j ~AJ tis ~G"AJL , Ck!JJil;J;,u p 'tSf2?c,11fL
. E?ie£P"J1~_'1 _k, _1/_i?l/_fct£ USE_"@_f.JD_'bR.E-as_{)a~7JUE. /)~~5',_._
!Jddlless.rltc:-IJ()1~&-J}i:Jt3:ci2_1lPPIJfbcJJT o.uiJjE'-~Ildz &_!2/.HIItJJ~-,.- '-._
· '' ·Pu:-e_ i;J IL13M~ _ /k /4;;1J_/(_/.G" ra_!lddl{£~~-~-·~-c1J:£ fla!J~
11
J~C:J$1 f}ddl(£~.s£_S_G_:Ditc!z:l ;iJ PU/l{)IVG_ TJ./~T Rt£_~;ges Bll~
D . /.) ~ D . . , . ""-::>
· {)ti[SJI)F @_f!L£11/j)/Yf;, T_Jld;;__JiBfJU.I_RES~GZIJ/lt:MC£' ~LIJ€" ~~-·_
I •
. 'PLB~D1JJG
· '-:
"' L____!J
II/) /). e, . ~ . .,
__ ~/J~E!Jf-;~_1/IJ)f-Li/_;JJ&J_/I_&!_uZi~_AA/ lkL 'tP/2._1/~IJt-
4) . t!J
. I G~;vT lvt{o L41Js_B£eM___lvllt!A~-Gc D o~ l$~8_8@L lij ''B£-l..vl-~~-
.·. Til_c7 RBJ,o. beGJlJ_EtJD oi ~-t!bu&T!£ o/J;~ii)A:J ~~·: UJJitu77~tJR_-_
1
. ·izt?tJ_fdcTS
' t'-' . . ·1 .
{P!L c~~J_e_tlA2
I 6 I
& e&fJ~a:EtGiZEo_·/IS_ El~fL-
M . . " 1/ .
. .JL~~!J_L o /L_.-. i!JIC~bU L~IG-.. . lfft? /fzJw T_Jic_, ~G-ut&O.~I.S:_/LE~Jh /)t; ~ 8
C!.1i'IUIJJ6. wtW;vG ~ LJJJJ1LS_L_ro e_fia,j_£_/)~1/&ilJJ.l &1 II '£VJ~;i::_
tt; ]]ft;-:_{lB_tvJJi_b_EotG_PokiiUIJtCE"" ~ IIPJ6T_i/Ef6_;_Suuf~!Js· C!n)_~~
I UT/';;t::.,_'/1_ WR.iJ/UG~AlOI . -~fl:/l..J~#.-·~51~ oe LE6/)_i_~,/ :ZJJOtR,£111~--
e/16_~ lie:_ I/1L£G_E5 TJ.Jcd tt~ Hontf!GilBec~. JkiJbELA.t_t~J~' ' ;
·' b?!V/1/l/VJ Pu,/LE_Qs_G_'lu_t.,_L/j_ /J8usc:-D ~ ~Ti/v/UTf_~&·Nb_
.~L ·JJ.-p1LE1_i/&2_A./a_.4-uT,J./6.etrt O£/e-72. .P/20C«t1;N§S ~_dfs--·
·IJcTioNs~;}_Q.C AJUlLiif f1 lj__E O~es A.llf'JLBa:ssess -t:~-;ScftL8_:::_
. l7LJ Q~11 t-'rf/c,!J_71~AJ.5 (o Ba~ T_i/;E . f?11 fJII c/Tr_1 oR_ ;::l~Jt/ilz ·~y_~~~-:~].
~ ' . A
~
...
..., ~
.
/) v~-, .)f7X'-"> , ,
t:J
':[)- . , "-··
~-., , , r r-t A.
.. \ ·
~tP' :)Lf,:~ ' .
. ~S?eultLI~IEtl__T_IU)YJ r'IJ/Z:f7~ut_~/V r!&6_bc_c.(&-21_E~~:;~~:I[}.
fet,/[[j~AJ:sti:P 7D e!b_e_:__.t)IL P1112rl.,1 m~.s e.onbuut__ fiJ~z!Jit:cc~_
!Je - c5' c9- I 7 . . 't, ,:;,,
tr:BJvo ~tl OJ 77J1c---, ~o121A!OlF J41J&b'J W" EiftJJ;:J /)eA/IYJ-EiJ
. .~IJ5~tzaLLaws: Juo&t? .DG~VfrJeJJ tuFtS fJR.EzSe;:T7otG-bW!..J
. {j£_11)1.)1/J :T~tj__;il_D;CCfrJtNL' ?i~t.J~'-i.:> rtl_p ~z-tiu· ~IJJ~
PB&:~e-iJJ =fo/l, THE J.u~U~al)i_et_r_ r;f}_G_u;Lr'f_ P£HJLt611:MetLL./ ·
·tLkeD_f3_y_ TJI·l? "Ju.JLif-~_O_Ee voAJ t;)t_/j;fj_~f~{JJ_ g'fl_!_tl_:::-_8~s~ellflz;~!')_
"" . . -" ' . - .
. ~-LJJ/J1i.t-rf'4E/J__L__f1PJtJ__Gkf/_L~tt~~1;3-P§S· IN. . . /. . ''8 II
' t:i!Q_ ' .. I
_ _· /2_!j~--~
J'Ul)1.c;ii; L IJ1sTi6~cT &u~ S,GtvE_D_E_'f-_/&.2" a:iwJAJ /lG"w/Pt!JAl__
fkEs,~,~c:, JUIJ~e. Pwtfse-. ~ril_e--1_7Jl8_t?, ~ ~ll~--~
{!_eRI11-n3-D-.&_!!_,e_s o1 oeJ8-,N11L _f}_Pf/L,tiiMLIJlaw~.Rr~~:-.-:~D_
f) II /f(J; C£.£1) 5 1/_Z_rER. Jl)ov., I~ ,;? oo qJ. 11 i3E IJ,f;lf{t:,{) !1
~ 1/l'lA - · , . ~ - "" _ , J.. s '1/1 ll e-o· II
~ ''"bliOIJ To/2 du{)(.::Z,ncllJL 1vUNu r'llO lUN~·
r.,
~ fJuaeas.e 07_1LJUDG.lYJD-lCA}_U/Ue lfu;IuiJG ts Tb &1V2€c;C8._~RL~IIL
. · ~R.Ror< i~UTI/c ..ui.Y- G/UJ&Al_LJ zon..IJ M6!/0AJ ~{G_Lt.#:/.illJcNZ· VtiAJG/Itlf_
.·/JJII()t:· IN· lft~a_ER1/Jb JittJG~a . .J7L, - ~. .
0 . 0-· . . . _,.-.. .
_ _ _.___r/fff 1/J~u,n.it 110 fl_&_ce_t2J)#J6_?o£_£Lcl.l~l)611'1eiit
. /I)_UJVC P/UJ /u,viv IS Lv#ilr J[!_IJ6 mc-,.v/ ~/Js JFAK)~-ij)}PA!o-r' .
.,_ _··~~ .t-Wllllt.""
. . . .
;}tiiJ6/YJe~
.
Sl/oatd ae· .rn~6Jtr~
. . · ·
8EG"A1
·
R.e_•-:;«1).!~.~6-~-~:
·r'·' ;.. ·\ IYc~r:A 3\j>.;-
.f.
'<
. . _:z?L_, , ~tWltfJ.~ll LoPGz, 1 P788 Stu'· 3d_ /~ /Bs:_F~~~*·'~-jt
. .7 - [ I • =7 . iO . n ~·) . . ·. -r::; . L' Jl r;;. ,~~, {7... :~/i)!o.·- ,-:.r'v
~f)7l:)P .·.Jsr/Ji5T:j_ P/e>0~1 . /JO t;?t>~ ·-.'-~i_veAILf')A..lS".&a£ll.f_lQ~/·-··.__
'· ·..·. . . · · .re~ Cfot.J]l' · : . · · .: , ·. : ·\::;.q··
.... •,
/:'fwc:J~73 '/82(te".t1. .9~- a-P/;!o .;l~e>JJ.Jo ~).
, Cl . ') . --;d'-
# .. ..£K..-1' .p
"--/-/i_ J;L.tJtct#l._, efG,eoiG oecu~GS W/fci'J ll/_e~~II)B"R;;S__
AA.J /S,Suc I?~Uc? /J?/1/$:(£"-J_/l~ G"/ZR_p;Vccu.s Pt-ci;L;,AJ" s~.(!p/Y)~i r,
/lUtM,i.JJ&JI'J~C/2'_r/. Dif3ReLLr!/50_~k/ :SYo1 58-QJ_@£. l'htjl_
' ..:z:i IS IW 6/2R.o fl._;_';.;_ Rt?~L~6.LII£~.:Tu.u 1/. {uePc-YG)_L/lisE?o£-k'k}-f"lE£~72Jd/'.rmP,Qv/ )),~A _
1
· .;Ja_o 81!1.3d_~3_7rS:.'f_3_(&.t:A~ -lee_Adi~N/i_:;J.oob,~ /f?r:i,_"
------------------~~~~£EL~MO~~~
. L~~-~~e-~L,;._;b 1J frlo7io~_7_4/L Jld;tbM££lCAiuUG_/ND_7i2Al_c,"$et:= .
~~R~:s_ ~ f!btCEL' e/vl L_~c£~ 3Lb__!_lllc; /;ZEJEd/ab~/1__
IYJtililw ~og_~utJGfl/J~L_ NUJJG ~ Tu~v~# BG-.~~-15. t:b.o~.
..1/llEll_.~ r!o~EL · LC!sG"s_/!i.-FAJ/I/6f-_ f:bc.ve-& oe~~-~Jj}l)~
. . ~ £;v,-e-~ tl. _fOe,;t}R.£-fL>t/€£ ;:J~_fJu¢· t:}:Qpe_tf?67 :z;vc,.7J2h ~
~ _£a-gL_ 0Bq6.8Z (~;t;.._~~-t~o~~,v_Cisi-_ j)~iQ_JfjtJ_~ 1.:/0IIJ!i{)-:
.· (:r&IJ607t"}-3LIJUALG fk.o ]2;A)y, C?~AL-86 £~EZL o,vL t~&fl:gl¢__··~
rlie ~u~ Lo~e-s ·Pt e:A.~,1/0~/b_~~J ~ ... · · ·~p~Tile~n:_
I
51/~ut../) /J1p{)_.;l_'f__ 771£" JfL_t;_(;l)!)~eiiL Bc-:c&_L/dK t'l-ts ~~&ott/Uiq-;:_
. .
i /J, ~~z "tiM___ TilE lb.WC"~ 70 /Y}o{);i_~_7Ji£,J~tl~CML/l6
. ~ . /(s~;£_/?tEll)_,~_B-@2/J~:/-_ /i,cUCFR- ovc:_/G __TIJ& J~GIYJe#l;-
to,_
._. _
.· ~.s=--~~. ,€ O,~~ f!. i?Pl2Li3_J_{_GJ (I L. /)1. lk::"'lJLr/it'~ :j:NC, i/.
_el!i~As;. -.2~1.Siv"Zd_(£t/~_'lii3-'N{!ff){. L'l%),_.LI/Ale ii.a#kF"~u/fL_
1
eo i/, Sm iiLs~ ' E_tY-u i AJ .::INc. .. I- . I() 5{,() ~e,. 3;·~{12?~-~eco)(J_
0
. .
., ~
. .
·.· . --z IL-r-:-A
' '
/2e"t;atll/L_GIL!iND_~gjf_ 7 ~72M_fiJ_I;igu__~litv_---'---
.. .Jal)_/_c~A-6 J>Jsr~izr &u£1; 8£6uv /JA/()_~LIJ eJJ wlTIIJ~ .1/pO iPil r11~ _
',\J. ~a/Jf_t__ ol i3R!Iw'! 11 AAJ0 LEro~ STII re 0~ 7'€k'AS_, ~cY_t>aEiii£ !ltrn . . -
t!)R IJ/IJte;;- tu, EIJtu )A) L>_EA./fl'JIIbl; :7UtJ6C lkE-t2i1JiN& tu111~ H k-7zm_
t&-6/JA-J OAJT,H~ _d~ Dft!L~_Ji;JLU~~-/l_.,j)~) dOlO A,u;tvi(J{di6titri_
_- ~ tJPc--R,IJTlaAJ 6) Ll)aJ 9/V lllc ~oTI/ J)~ o7 Jull/e; f).,,L), 0Jo;~ Tit£_
7
9tJltfXVI~ ~-(]1}-tkfltr d, sea~ 3 {l_,tj_/Ut£ ~r~17
~~w~-~4~/.u6 , L"O &JilL. 1t
SrFJr~:; (8_16=K_'*5 t/s_, SliiJALe-_LiJ17_o.TJI~ O!&ll_/1~~/~ T_J/£_{};~7724~ · .
. . ~~61 ifiv;zoR#; f!ou;V!!J? 7.i.e'-ts~ti/2rii.JiL.:J~f:./;f{__, /.);;T~c,L . ·~-
.. · (!,{)u€/? ~ Q 1 GllliLif_ /Uaw PR_e_seA.LTS EK;/J&;_./:s_JLpm/J€£;5__
. /-1]~/is· ?-_Qilf?t.US_Tlill_l et.e_"l_~L'f__SI/_~ws/Ilie 'tltTif f!ouil:T
·· \kaGc- /lt?tJMl)_tJ_fkt;-d:aiNb1 ~!l!GO /I;VtJ. R~CEo eN G'b1~
• ,~~-Tiil£ it-NOIN(; lJJIJJ~_efill ''fie 4Lso 11 1/€:/1/lLJ Tf/e ~-
. o I· ;. I ., ... . , , 9_..r; - -
.· I/~_EVI.IJ6'NC(:f"_:}f.M!."m_ t;luL.; SlaiU i!omPL/J/lUIIJ6 LvJTAAF$15 ~
. . ~~ '· '·
:i0J
\
. ~M:S_zfi;_t;_~--eu£y_ &-61J/J o,v A/ov6::Mge-g ~ O?o"~~"
~ I /i · A } - - . '-> LJ /L -r;- "...,. 'i ~~~ )8,. 8t?~-· i.
. · . 7 au.Gow S ~ tL)_T~ I'H/TJ &'t~I/IL D;:;r::l'Otvv C!cuR/T;;liJ S6t::7A/PtU . • II
PI ~~s,
\.__ j_/:¥tl'-!D_'-L. 8___
. , A . • II '' ~ - 4 I - .-.-:· r ~
_.XE~G &Ltrre 7_71AS 1.s
.
/1_
.. -.:1 .._
/l
C!Eifftz_te v_eoPlf_oz___
Of_#I~IJ L 7_:,/E)__Ji!JIIII.Il'(_~~} OfDtJ 7__, . .. .. .
{J.)_Jiio..GE_~mf1JJ lvH5_fJRG-:Je-;;c!__2cJ/l rltt:: JU/JC:/hE~T~u J};_/l!/_ J/aLT.
Diz;~ it Ga; L-rtj__ PuAJt~-1/;JV}EA/lZ!fLet:J. "it_ JiJ!Y/,~L~JSe~/Jvu.J t?tt/_J/hp
· B~3_::_e~,
14
7;1(-t- ~3Rti Jip]/c;/16 w C!o41(ilSi~Af-E1J ~?Jf- . .o,;r&·tc:r
LV_,_ £!Jtu iJ.J ~tN/J!J.IIJJ_fJlEiLD..~ <'::l_J[~_6_&,_fli__;_:S__LS_~ lSG> {!££Tl~tPD &if_
r>J_ oR /N~IN l}_~f:_J~LE"!)_Noflt"Mf6B/G I'?~ oo 7__ o . ---------,-
; (3JJuDGE0e=;-;viYJf/!J tv/1'6 ~l2GMT' 1h e_~.s~L'l.Jo. SB8b3 '/n5flt.>V7b
. &:voK~ tltJ;L_~IL I~ CIL~61: :BI9t<~l- ;P TJI..E l/IZT_#_, SEE AJoiu(JJ_ eo- .
· Jl,a/r 11e '' q~ ..BJs..
II cSo ¥e (?l eJtfi.,~ ~T'll ,., 1-·Pg., f!uaJ;b;m tfi___
. 1011/LJ .· .- c ('f) ').;qfc£ !! ~N_(J;c.7li1w_.t:; ''., $1( Tiff,- ~Lti
&upT!f GI21JMJ_Jttllltj__i_M Tl/E_t.fJ Z.l.I/~V_t"{)'c'IJ. t- /li6_T~,c;_z · ~ veti£'/_ _
.' . . . 0 .
: . · J2 6"~{(_€' J)I6Tfiu::r_e_t.Elt..t7__7_~l£!J_=iEB_"1 _1_jrXob '1_, ./YJI);{£_.o_ o£_fJ6.0tlt:_te_@__
\.,;!72)~~ Y,ivtarll'f_ 016/UliJ.'/-- ;:;.L(!lG/lJkl[3~ ~ # 71/- ;f1~6Lt:TlJ~ 7i_)'h,._
77 S:L~- f!_e: (!,~S..t£Alt># 588"_3 - ~t_Z_JZ£)_t6tliL, 0JsL'&1uL__{!t:!u14t-: _
.i;JJW"tu ('/) £Xtil-e it ".j) 1-P.j-1• . . .. 11 ...
. {f>-LJJm~ rfL'9_1JJ&3~ JC.eL 'fe12t1E tl!l,fh,iJIIL JJ,s'-rp.:r,LII&Rnff-
. BrcllztJRill &~.~oMT!/~n ·/YJIIR.f-:__7JA.Lcs_,~[0q~l)r~J?/;;_Ti--t;~~rwd_ ;Al__
:. 0 1bRIIDl_f-6:__t!__/l§_e /{T. ~--(rk/;_6 S!k>ws 71/_e_:., JJI/Itf" df~A/IJI/. 13_J_;.o~t_l TN£_
· ~11¥ R.ea_IJs ;_e_tt~t? 8c /.l{)visF 7~ TifE:U:,·
. . . I' ,·,'
Is .£1
*"~,;;·~ StTi~
TilE 'fiZr_f/_JUIJ,~/;;t., /Jtsr~'Gt &"fGt -;,c;_£, Alt>V_.. '? ;tc;of_.llL_B;~o!ltll' ·_
1
ti>R..~JIE IJ/!;ou~---:{!~tiEa T~ k 'f__ou '2)oA} §-mtGkL;); kv:r:i:r.S;s..7J;ii1~"@-'-;:_£tq;
/Jif4£~·~See' Mow {5J e-Kttt'tJ;r"c: .:1-f!(js. ~~'AllfTC ;7'!/_l:, ~~~'6-
ls ~ti~IJ~ .&c~s~ 0 1612/hoi/Aj TM_2 ;;}~lzc(~ ·Se-t?{ilJE;!tf!BI£·118~
7
3 Pf)s, TJ.//6 Is (k{n!Jl_eCf"'€6 Ia THe tEl7./lltvuffliiG ~~u/J;JJG rii_/)eii~Ji{ill!&/litJJJI~
. I ~ . . ,, , . ,, ') / . . .. II - . ,/ /i I . fl (L. il \ J.
L/~1,) ~~tarr. ~'1..-g:.:~d.!eJt /):/-L~l e~fi1/iiT &;'.~ ef)E~f(\!f}ff!iJ~.:3.,
tloi~VCtl)t::.S W!TJ:l __L"Ifi2_· :L/O_£:kL_Q..u/l_l/l'etL_I- fb~9 ~-liff(~/[:f_l(l~Ji
- "· ... · • -. A. f\; . · ~ . C::.; f-: ,J:r;f;l i,,, · )J·,/
J~~IJ..JC1_/1_6tVI:>Tlt.ttc-T- U/!..UE/''6 So {)_~;::;~VIAJ0. · · · _/~f"'\:~ . >r·;. _.
. ' . f&. _·7 o:Jl7) : }" 'i:~(j";
• <
{7J;E7 r71c~ /J1o-rt0i:J 72 &va~/JtP~~ Mls-1/YtJ'J ~~ 9Jzr!l
' . I -. . , .
,~JUIJI c;ltL JJtsT~ fk>ullT) Lv#tl:C &JtfJL/lA/IJT;;IJ (!_/JM 11/Ci ~07G/v6''
. /_¢ JUo~ bBAJhlfltli (lc?N~allC_ ~e: ~aJ (Z)ck'.I/J~i--'G_ '151/)~.. 1-31
· ~fJoll.Tt·aS·- REUJ£fL~L . Lt!l_f; Yi&itL ,a~EP el)u~p ,t6,oBa_j3_- 'llZv~ _
JltDI~iJLC[),i_r_l(_i_c,_L_{!o~flL,' S',~AJtD_llr-: J/Lt_; 7/<,'ell&LLII_s ~ t8_j_t~iAL
&~ll' . fiE~pflrGR.~•. SEE' llL$a_eJctL,Id/rs_,e_(!jJ_ G"ltti;/j_~/·':t '' lfp/'t(. b/1(~ ~
P?· teK:ttl/a_:f:? "'·~~-P8f_:;u()_GiYICAl12'~ rl/e Pl'3M JU~ic;i_.q_L /k,tiu:P~
7
IV _£;J-t,J6G: /Jo~ 5:8.803 S1 GJJE'D "B 'f__Jltt;t;g j)c-Nm /YJJ -· PbF.!t$_6;..: tfJliPi:, _ __
1 ' ... •
1
I.
. 171~ ~ IJ CeRJil.~~e.o ~Ptt_ o9_0£Lli!Al. II(_, I I 8\_,_l/_e ~/JJTiDMs_JL_
11
.
II · V ' ~.:7 "
/31J~0-·_-~~~J7aJ&6k.Mtn.IA.l 4 t/e.e~~f?-ae:m/nu#-4/E~_?Q?Zbtl~
. _S ibws lk ls. pll£~i/j_/AJ_c,__/AJ ~- t!J;ufC[~(TJfE 0 ~-rll //,;, Sntf), ~~:--A!bw
,_ (lB!J s;ft{d;r_'f/_~ /-·~&·. /)(o/vt;, tv/T/!1:.._~ E~;;B_fr-~' i1'1 ~IJ&/HetVT(AJ TJ/15 ~!J/U(___
. "JU·DttJ)}(_ J)J$r&~GT &Lt~ /AJ. t!llu.sc:_M_o.. See ,~_S_/6PblJ Ji46E ~t?PI>1i9;J__ _
i {qJ ~ Tlie- e~t:/J1t~ll-L 'vocl~>c.hT 'tiHec 1 · eJti/IPir'I ::_'1-Po.s. lltst> ~e rELf=':lij'_iL"i3 '1 ,IbdG~-v,iJ
i. • /fie ~'3&/_JQI)_jc,_;l/_t_,_),$;;£...1.~ ~ttR:Z:_~ ~A/P~SB8_C;_$_dl~lJ/~f)__
·: · i3'/folJ6.t? /)c-;um/1/J ~ - . · V.f!l/1.s. ~1Jp6.e- &__i_f_fJ'J£/9/fi/.lR.._~
. Tlfc=':" v/,ot))n~~ tJ9 _Tilt 1?/JbT~Yc:rtbr::;- "1:1/GI),f:/<. t5 J!.tso ([btCi./;AJt'l_.OL~ /Ut:fg_#/Jl.
: 7<'" 1/ IYifsbE~IJ.NtiA.. of)_ 7eto.u'l____5e-E{!v_ e-_.ut:a(;- '':J'' f-ffj.,#t>TJ~ ·
,_ lo 5~ 7ifYlCJIH'i_ OJ6!!11~Y- dJRTtfi)~O_e;pt;- t?l ~ ~ 007 · th-/ /J_I/-~_3S__-.__
1
Sl~ro: 835Jtfs_i>~~S~ 77hotrl_'{ O'blltt Ro~M ,A/o. 3d 1- f) . o2_ Tlli3' .ePu/l }_ lku:5G" jJ..) /l_tv6ltf'rot'1 f>Mw~lt}__
(touR:r
.{luaP_T'4 -Te.r~~· . (ILl 1 ~e REc.~o-:-~{i.t:HPS -z:11e . t@l![t{~/f£ .
. . k'lil~,-}vt, J o..y tf}d~~P.Do2_ ·/M TilE ~z:rll/N _7R;6!_G~~~-~~i~t·
~~ s-8 8k3-- /IPPs 11/ll:c &u~t: t!IJ-v~F Aide~ I~ o2-oJo3~~--~~~:1;:-,~lL
.M>ii~ )z,~66 lkNM.9Al ;)Jrrw~JuuNG /tkni;;_&-f'_,'___#_L_f#j. 'j;r:q~'1f~;
. /J~ 8 a:; 17 / t;"-.l''
01)eunl::~ . . "' . . ..
.
· . ~ IJ7TeRf.Joo~ LJJ()/e..s IJA.JO C:R.vTlEMI-JAJ, ·rn·r uflm£' 16 Ed {)eM'fl!fJJJD
.. .- ~
.~ :..Tuok~ o7 TJit? 41l.T41Lh;ritv-r'
.
t!Du;;z->
7
/JAJ() ILL i}_E ~'l?SI~l~
.
oW(f._
rJL/5_~~ 56i9filow(!!J EJcf/;/Jd-- 1/ ( '1 ;l--~s. 8j~lo9Z.R£PoR:re-Ris Rc-·
_(!A~ . /bt:. ~t> t>9 6- /I()Ltf/J16s 1/.J T~ e~u/OT ~_Aio_,6:8_863_ ,ljP- _
{J131/IJiWJ r!PuR/T·~_//P,_ij!_-~-~~o3_z-c£~&/Lzorc:_LfJ_(!_pu4!$___
.
SG"i=..:. ft_l ~ . ~ tit '") ,.::) . , s:
---.'20~ . 17\-~-1:J.t'~- -,tiM~?~EKf/_tliLiT-__3 . . "/[' . . .
'
.----
j . .
(!J.) 711_~_· REcq_l(j)_/s lle9..l/_{J€itS_If!U€ . /3_e_c__A~d 7_1/_t: 'DEt6MM£Ji:i:{ etec?-__
;~,v oAJ PuAJ;s-1/;fltEPD w~-~ iAJTHE"" lft~-rjj:_1 ~/iLTl/pu~li Til£' ve@iaz ~
~-~)£~ /;b(J.)u /JJTJIB d.312d JbiJiG~tiL {/out;A'SiW£{) ~f-_.:JliiJ&c _
.iJEAJM/iJJ_( &uLI) .I Be- lu!CovG f:_)_(LEr Me- f.}AJsco~ 11/ot)l!!iJ!!_~
·. 1/P_£,/m::_~Lt /v~o.oJ L- 41oe>O ,J.
SEe PoW {!BJeUII';e[r_ "L 11 l-f!jL-IJ N!J__ _
(}?>J e;!Cij)Bir ''fo,_"___Ol ~s. P~ . /H ~ 11
1/&/YJ:·c..-rHGa;~1!J-:~111e Cf:R~G" _
t:iJ -IJ6t;;R/Jt//JTGO /i_:rs/1-u<-T:_~;s eti_f)I<..Ge/J__fiJJ. 7'M_~ 1/J()Ict m£AJ7: $;6pl?[j
-,~'! AJul?l'lJIIJl} &(./6~~DGt:;-.!. &-~;fl~& JU!lo/0 'P~T€'7,~t!fl_AllliL~-:s;~~2_-c
. v 11)1.)~· ~u A o::; ~ I~ cJtt/}~ir''~'!--IL~Il(l;c_-cwir#~/l/LeG//II~MSOt
~~~/r16Jt , _5o ':112s_-_ _&so 5tj/f~ ~'9 AJo£M-9_U ~b6£&_::~Arb
·, JZ£o!L V/IT~? ~t~~Alllt&_P.~ ;loo2 /A) L11-.~~J.~~~-;!u1J;c,1L, ((vu/bJ
· · · · . • ~ ~ /' .EXJI,.t;JIT· ~-·IYJ j r6G• · _ . .·
. ~G.i7/kJ.JMA/J fkes,bLIJb; 1
.· . Lltf~p; t/OL. ¥ Pj. 3 -z-. tiL JU~~ o-v. .
1
1 fJuv_JJ_/lJMGJLI-_~JJ::._u~- ~~ fj.s. 3~~r~L~~3.~PLGo__JJ_o:-cGaJC'-lXTo _
:.. Tr/e cfB_t-AISI?:.c[l /J66R/JvlllEi)_· '*-5~L?.;_Illl(yq 'I~ fL . /3~: ·&u~t7fj__
i · cfl fl0~RIJui/T£D IJ~iA-4Lt.,_/JbtJ Go /?;IJC;k 16 G".ftl_l.8iC_ (/_)_''t;_ '1 b·S_'i~~
1
. {'SJ EYI{;/j;f ''N 11 /O Ps.s ..~~ btuJ/Jedoc~A.J/J€/:J T~~fl_PPt.tc.~ ~ J
: /YJust TuibAJ ~ bt.i.Ju Ji,L(Jt~/A 6. e),/)~~£rs ~ lk:L# /)')i? tt/U{)tFI2a:bt_~
L aJ t:lu.V J~ ClMd ?/l6J?? Zllk'-' J'&-~atLVV /};AJ-·
. bL9~£ T~ !u_t:cK~_-:;.al/aJ:P/.d6. II/I'J/J11£L) /%.7¢:k.uJ ~?J~~ -'--
. -'' 1 · "~' '' . Alt~w/-&IV~
,~t:r__LJ,L
1 ,.,r!7flE ·"au S6Lt'~Te£J im/}tA/1£L(:i'"LJ ~-:~_-~All.
_P-,_~_ . 7----- . \ '?¥\ -~-\ .J \ ( ' • -·
· ,fs_L/1-e J]J.£J f:_ ~d~ lilt? --zp~_oi_ r_/t€ ;!J_8ovt? A/ii/J/)/3eIG~zt;~~'!£J!Jiq.{r~~j1
E.u77i:-te./J ~ .Wl/;6/f_ /6 d3~ 1/ti_~t~hf:_, ));.;;Ho:0-i;"1~'®:;"_
Po-- 1 o:; 11 . ..·· . ; . · , · . ,. ___ .·
·((6J~ \ , . ..'.
.
;11 •()7_;} /()· "
iS
-.'d.~ .-Jlt_ /J
1 'I"" v· 'c../-r SELCC;PJIJAJ
_ SU$/C,AA
7' '"I
/)04/t(Y{,. AJrJ/YJ6/ //..:; () Z-
_
.
: o 'i---'-/12-.
.'~ &u~&T
.-=j~- .
DIITE .' 1/-·I'JZ-· oljl 0/JSG'.:'_ J[t{)&E iJe#MI/A.J
. )---
·
. ~_L/__ /)fir£"' l1l~ 57i91YJfJG"O _t.J,u /UOV, di Jl bo 'j__ 1 . . . .. - _ _ .
~. , " II 1/ fJc . . ~ .) ./&
(/IP) Extt_~_8_~_f_· 0 ~-"9-:S.J f§.*-l~_t_ L -.£12t2~.1:l£1GS--~/Pl_G'"/h&p_T_lt_·L ecoRIJ
. 1/e>t . lvt {_ l/oL4/YJtS t!~ po, 5"~ 863 /IPPc-J//JTG' lJoa/l/P ~17 1
1
· · Po. _!_'f_- c 2_- o;o ~z- C/l ,_-t/i 2 r__tt_ JUIJ/c; II_ L i;>_,;/Jl.;;&.72_ .DJ__/j l6EIVGj_ ·. __
}/e~~ 1~_,_/}l€~-~--=-Al'iit"l= OAJ Pa-" ;;/ b1 d : /; UG/1/Jl_'l_ tu~b>Pe~A,~ .:;/;,.L),}.;G/!__ -
~ /uiJ---r-' ilt ~ .By:_ Ji;tJ68'" j)e-u/J7AN, 1 T#'C.It:#J6/nt;-,;;;rt/i)oti.:;J
e;u, ~~o ~ 7_1'/sT" 7imb"~ ql 5e~A.ll&#c~ B~ JUI/j'_/ See- @J E:.t:ltr;B.;t:_~
- · ' 13~ ~ UZl_E:kll/g;r'L~ I~- be9GNIGfJt@~e to. 6::/a.J;~ 4'.;U~~ _/IT· i~tLols-~-··_·__
_;;;;:· ~u~ Vi312l>;'z;:- lnusT 13€ f,~~/)J/111~,
·. 0 '' t£'6f/L,*lrlio/Gifz'c:~s ~~.) Setit t!liO_C oiG IJ:J/l tf,_ /e-..({, f1mltJ. ·
i . 6:3 L~_bllv;_s_j{. 5ta::/:£T!/$~.5£~--
. ~
I:SSue /hA~ tk R8/~~iJ ff· t4Nf2]inb-r._Ji::s..us /J?'Jta/AL~~ Glrm~"Z_~
S1-ai:v 1_]37_~zd 3;~ (!'1'37_71:;!. {!R1M. dfP. L':!/6 ~<;a_(#o,oJO-g~).
~~ fJJJ/2.-rc ~-'f-fl1clJo;uiJ_tc/_ '1109~-z-d 113 (1111 Jfi?£..· ~ .. ~.,. 1.8~15::__
I .. lh:l 7 fi)o.- 'I~ ~ozl ~·: ::ri·' ~ 1/PP/Itee/t.ITT.~ f;tw IE~lst19T0£6 w;jp_-
1/t:>Ti:-;o 7i>,e, if /~4()~ -,;;
c;vsu~EF" -;-l/6b· (!;R,iJ.u»a(JJ;m~ w&
~d/itJJ;J;;TG'Ili?L)_'f_/l£E f_/UJ7VJ 6/8S 6/G ~~~ fl!Pe;91(1)pCAE~ t>J B-)~11-·_:._
\..../ f!~/.£6 2}/I.Qii:,_iuht~Eiicii.IJ_j(,_ r;-adi.,} .J. 13 ~ ?d ~8s::...?,.a3_(/g.t~cbl,diii._J
Af'P. .:1 ..,;,e) L~.t.Ci - 7" o - A/o. PV .:. crlL3 - o2>_&MD3 :;Ill/ re:s /_/lose ,;q$7!/~JC€5 I~ tul/i'c,f.l (/_Jitt:J6€ ,_; RE.{2u//l.~{)-~ s-gp b()().}/J
. ON /nPTJtJ';J o7 tl__/3_i91lTY-_ fp,e REIISovs OTH_eR_ 7_~ 7/tosG EPJUMb~l'£/)_
lh fJis((_uiJL;tfiJJG_· /N Tl{c. ~-5Ii-~Ti~~, . . lu/IL/1J14· tJ. k;LG/JI(L;~ I i
. # . • • . .
:kNP1 tc"10 i3f(ft ufft o/~ul}~ J_ilciiTioiLJ /IIJ() Re.s usIlL, a) ~6-~·--·
17p;; PJ11~5, L,;T. 5"9'1__(/'iet;,.)_~ Guc.illllla,'7imt IP/l~tT
6~1_/t_ 70£UeRJ$ Bs-a ~7dS0~ 1 So'J_ (-rc715,_/i!P_-/36Wuh1~Aft Jf?~_
I . ,
~RJr- ifl~ALtEn)" 5~€ Ai_utU ll I I €kt/_/13its_/ ~ . . . .·.
-------=e:--~12~-~o£ *~~-:I:/J.J~J9-:-Jit~!f_ T~ ttifu lS_Sut£~ PLIVI/eJik(
ll Oe-19LJL!J WefJP~>;..; tv~ t..tt>£D oiZ e~I.I_)/Jitt'D Du£;~6-L."IJ'£_(!,Jtrlln;~,;,tJ
. dJ T__}/1£ o;;7_etJ$e-;~L~_I)JJ hSU$ df_?__lld'" W/i_t_Ci{,_~8t-~~~;ftt{J?}~\f-2L7JI~
-. ~7-a~ ·fb_eJtet.us,;,.,c IJ~)~tt.IJ1,;.;ff;~,J ~ tf'K /),t}fl-re ~~.··.·~.l~.~~:~,;i~~.~_}
"-.-/ /.." . f)l on c ~ ' .> ''L v,e l· ~~ // \
.9_l>6" 1 b~~Te-1?.. ·(}£;in. rr. l12z_, ~/Pet /.JPB_EJLIINk ~"'<~Ji~q,~,r;/Efj~
1
. .I " ..) • ~.&.( p.."r:,{q.:, '-y"
11 Ji,t~~-t:ilff:r~ eou,(JJ/ ~ /Jo _,§uT_/io£1ft-, 7b rYI/IkG:i;:.~~tiY~;:·5~--
.. . ,. -
' .
. A8 . .n or 17 . -v ..
.
.... -
.
&"/JRo/2 #c;t end;,
A=iJ,f<,mfffh~t? ?/iJIJ,)Ji )f:J.d: f}PPetiiJNT'. weo ·/1 oo"Tit)L,f_ JJE~IbA.}:,
' J)IJvis Jl, .ST1Jt:t; 1 ·Bq7 ~.791 7~-3 (Tl?KJ.tJ~.//11 .• ·/IPP..l9fiS}:rG"~ctJY- ~· tA}'7J~_itt_/l$__£~l}J~- ~
Ous 8E~/Iu:$6"" /h ~ Au(;T 8 ~ ~S's_f}u;C.L_ 3£ /dh~ titlb€' cl__l)_-_
7JiR£..1)_i :t9pG)
18(~S7JJ~ruto~'l- t!J9?£"~£ES_~()_ (Jh/JilGG' IJ//~WED_t;la;;_ ~ 7iJ anv~77
J)e?E"k'IJ/lAlttdiTi/t:>&t ~u~iv~6 71/e JUR..,j:'__ /c) t/v,-9v/mousLY-._~RA!ft;? e~A/ ·-
. wAt::J#E~ck~Cu~J~~p-r ~tJm.LJa:t!z:cb ;466~d/lr~!) · ?a0tY- i;v~.4§1hd?ti_
ae lls9£1Jt//lrt:_/.J 1/s.sl)u tr_·8y 71//2~/t_;_,_~e- AJptiJ B:l/.;b_;_f5_,~{/) 'rt 'I~-
\_jp52· C!.JJPTi;,L;h Tfl_c 'IIZ:TI:k_1_,{_ii)JuiJG.tn6AJToA.J Juh.l( J/e:~tJ;C/7 oJJ Gtutl!/__
/- , ~ 8''.3 R:.. . 1 3 j ~.-I~· A
11
~-
~) eJq:/_,8_t_L__ _. _- -as_!_,_{j_)_g-K.I/JB_ft''M!!_,_~ ~ cfllJ J CC_
c:l./ltt /1 . . ~ ..
3 . -LL(L'()_~:f!hfilL _
I
. -~- . . J, ' I I II . . J , ..
. ~.t (V\_!_!__qfh~t/t£a_DI,~l IJ..l 'fiZ.L.fl-j-\ISJ 13-k_#_,B/:t· 'Al'1 10f&6 Ols3/1d~JU11£&et.£.t,;t'uil!J-}--
9
Q7)_t;..1CJi;_e_lr-_~1P11 SPes~''c~,.E- tf}_r__~ (Jo~ii:t- ~3/U, 1iLetJ_&tJfl, s_j:.££J 'Z2J_1::.~FeJ...._s_Ltt_q_~
I//) · 1 · 1 c' c . '. s J
r'R.E[Jf1(]13.~_, ~ ____&E!/!.3.~'/_ JAJI/o/;:jAJ(; T_lfe ,3_U:~-SJ.~6~_c2J~/tttl!1_L61fl:!/-_·
G.OD /HE_ 11:-o f~~-- tf7 t:iu.J. 'Sr.IITE t>1 7l?~/f6 1 oo o~oA;'iJ b'.uq esill8-
1
L/sl, /His ~sr/r_un~tJ ~ · .jjf_~JI/£.. 1-o~~iUJhb onft:,;,&Jis 71/e
/"6n:J_()g,(l6_t.E_}jj~fo._£__J!!" G-/W/AJ J!JENIYJ/JA)l_ _/l~~ /Y),4~/( 3_,_(}§_A.It% 1 ~
CJMd ~;g-~ t),Sr/lid! ~ j)o~ §7£/c-/;'.LJA.J-_'l1/U_'"'ll2_iN-
. . ~ ~
. !_S'Tt:fJ/#L _Se~~"'"---------tU.i..)__~op;t£__d}_ .7l;-~~ _ ',
OJ -~ . 8 '1 .
T)/_EI£~1tlti~
4 0
. . . p lj
·etm_bu.ld~·: ~--Tiie.~/flq!lei!J.G/JlioAJS:iJ 1 &A-ows r~. r.~. l:>oAJr__·_
. . ,-~e_r~~ r~~e ~~floa_!_ 1:-J'f_- A/da4EZ_4d_~~~;e5ry_ :!h;~.-~1/l;F _
\.J . I , :p _,a. /. / ' /~ _. .. - . ~-:-·_;":./, .- .';
. {»()A!,$n,.t . v7 ~.tUIG~:~:i.)IJeSS::. p .,. o ... · r,._ •.. :,,. "' ,:-:0<} •. :
....~-·.-----·.=~-~~d~'G~1_'.i@~ c~c13, TO ~&_=J:e_tfz_AIJJ/ '·''
->.f . . •. .' ' -c;· f$,11 ~ 11 '. .· !, •
iurYJ i'La6il;-;:)
..
l!.lm7:' .
·t161fr'-yp ~ ;fk e,L~ J}N,;~-tf~eo tlviJe,e ~:7 ~~
,p . •
. _1 !fl_~-~~~----~SJ"'i77illt1A»''~g~~/26 1_-z?r2U~ /:0
. ?£i.l#s-=--
"Y·_,{JIA~fPS a? /l_ff_~!I4TG:_ ·f'~Wet.ou£G' -~~"--(~; .:z;.; ~i{,;~---
/~atf- is~l/__2~e:__/!_IU!{!§_2s._i/t~i&-nP.i/ _,~_r_il/Q__~ &~~ ·
0 !6~_tJM._,f€e_tL£ISpi',[) _,1?:--z~~ /!_U/l5tti/&L_ 7Z> :;E(;_I?IZtl(. ~_/fdr~
D_ue:_ _ _/!/ll2cE~_G_~_ ~ o . /uh1-1TLEft_ J!,_S72iiz ~9L(~W-_?d_ ~-~ 7~~7~-(iut.
7
1
C&l~/le& /!i9_7)! ____J!:fc:_JJ/pb.J 7'i--¥.._f!Elff~ fl_we_:!____L5__Lq / 71/£~
~ U ' I
~b-~ &u~tf__(!t!f~~~ _L6_AL_G/}_/CL,f_ i"d&A/.7ilil-_LlJ T__lif__-Jet ·· ·
I .
&gz_
· · ~®Cb.~6._eL(fu6_f£ __·tY..b.i~_fl AJov/~s ," ~- swr.c5/lltil·IJ1~ke- 6/( e!Wo~-
t!:t: /liJ'f_Ufu2_WI/t.~!f___ ~/t~ /lde;IJ&F 7JiE fkiv/Lt'fJGe_s .o.e·:hJt!:_1wJ/ile.s_-
.:- • .. . 0 : .
dl Ct71_2e~·-s___.___ol ~:C---~JJIT6D__Srdi:YJ7 ..A!PIG a/kP -~ sri:iib ~P/Cn/Er
A_JU~/J-11!/.S~P- dL;l~;; 1 __t~_id_~~;Jj_o~&_,Oe:/b1X_, 4JfLJj_c'JUT ))~-~C£:$$~~
L~__ e .·. 4J!:S._._Wls_-r;~ll.meJUtl_kl_~ 1;~.: /VI})LE:. -r,ff_'i,i~-~ ll2ut-
tl ..
. , . , ~ 'L '~1 t?t. ,, ,fi
llVJ /6 7i~u/lll!f___ 2)_!_1._t_E£§'N7: ~T'ki::._Lf-_ E1c-Lc?£2f? u_u_t['-___·~'OU£$€ _OI/k~_
Ri. .
II . fJ2o 'I . "' .. · 0
G~__ /)u£:__ ____~~;ST_ LU€.:__Rt-6,J}__gLJ_~6G 7if'llll1:S ,1s tu1T__Ii_ou£ IYJEYJAI/AI69ui_
. . LJ.ifi/tJ(!;/j;u !_/}2~/L~&e~-~ e,Jx_ c¥ &tp~~- 6~ JEJf..i9_S W ~ r'.5-~&2-
BCIB'i!>ll:_fb ~ R~s,~_a:;flLmt1/b4P 4 &ct£~U/&Il~-~/Mmss 1 ~.:·
! . ~7&uft!J ~AJ/iilj 't(#:>t.UGO_f!on7ePJ,IJu.U/lj(_ -JE{)~/_ /)UC;- /IM~-.Jf}~:;::
!:: lti?S.~/}Je;;/lJ6e10 .l_~~..J_,ft --~s·~-~:3 ,. L/AJIU . ot_!E£e_'LflL~IJ~ Sc-h_.._ft T~_qd/ifdU_
1
: Cj,;;&;.f'iJ"Jrli.J. 16'), ,ll_ly}jpuG.// 6~_B'/ 9e-IJe.llJj)llB ,/lzoc,p3:; ::JU,e;$-
Jar
: · ')_ fl/lut£JC;.Jce· ~I..II~--~19$-e;_j,y_C. &ns;~t-:-~ 7t:lJtF!Ml ~~lkc:-7:1_7;2~jJ_s:_tillli_o ...
i (J(?{)tJ~-/I{,__~/1;P._t;.Gs~___7A_8i fl:~S_u_~SitAf7·/tdz::l/oLiLf-ld£/l!_t_~~C2_ Pt-1~
Due_· ~6: dfLftE)_~illl~e~ ~ . :Z:A/ .LJe;z&;;;_~T_~ .Seofe .([i--------'-'--
/1 ' . - • . . .. ~
· f'/la7ii.G"k:1:t2~lJ8.eR.::EY-,_I~ZL~G.t ~ -~ALLJ.eg T/ff_-=t~~g'Tec-~T__J./_/I~Eilb.clill:__' L · ·
' . . . 4· . 6 ' J
·. /Jp7_1!/w__~~-~~/)/J~e- _(/&>u/l:Z:.~-~ 7]1uf ~ l;·;Se_/G~ /IV~~-/-·
_.-_Qep_o.T.es_Ml[}l1ERel.}/-_9-uetJo!J1_"7_Mn!J & IV~£~Z.~e t&J
1
I · · .Pfj. II/ o117 . · ·. ·
I.
de'PU06/;J) ~ ... , .. , :
/1.(:._6oM;iJG 7b T}/7;;' 1)/Cil;Tjj:-'b o9' OA/6~ otvu en-Jsof~ h';VO L~ ~
I' ~/Vi{f<--
/111'/__ 70 EAiTof_ 7l-k$_g ..&;v;LcG~~ L~"J/V~_&;c,o(;,oi?§£1. ~, ., ~ ess:ewt---;,;t__
·~ji_·r_l£ cfl1Je/bl::f!_~~l?$urjt· o9 ~~e$~ JJr
t~ meP'.::::....!:·~--
. ~:-.---~---.-~-~- _13_~/dfl:IJ__r;]__/(EGEAfr:s_/.& Re~_!lo '0_ t.< ~ ~ IJ:P S.l~;--
lf,g S~ Ct. di.:l~7_Q_(p:9__1_{t(!..~e~wl:J& OJ_t'f_e~ Kl.Je.-8.12/1-Sklie. ~h~_i/:S, 3f.l!;_?n,_
'fa..$,_vt~~;.s;_,:dl:l1.. kl_t.~ f#., /IJt/~ {lr:J3), · J
~lllf/21? Tlit:7 Rec~/J£J.. Re VeiJ.ts.A7t./RMetii!JP /llisad-AL~/ OAJ T_lte_· ~1Ztfi fUe
/kLJSt:cac/o~ e~mf!e~&lXO...B'tliJJ_if/l/2l2A..8£P~_Tn.id_tpaQll~l~AJ~Ijoe~_-_.
S~uuf' Mtr1.2· · ReYJt:tl/aL.ti..~fuui.l~t?...!!J~G.ulfz;/ ~-12i2~_/!evf~i~w~,_
I .
A//:ll~.U~Lf_SI/Qu4d.. LIIJ~ Be $·t;J 1.!2/J.lf'llE -we REu,~t.iJ r.~a-~· t:# il ~-·
. .f/lb;~6Cj~/u0c_'!..i. __/l.f.?&R_;;vtai=·Q_£s_suCi7-~;u~e£f)~~c.ULII:tdit__,;;__
~a_L/L.'f--~.a~f<.·LL/!ux.;G"s_ ~ t:~IJ!J6,ul:: bi_S@I!_~ b5u,t:?Z_ZlhJ__lS___
t(u!i_L;lfiJl¢('/- iliii.E!UA!.Lt-~_llG.&Rilli/JT'e;D_Asthti]Ptvl}ifl_/}eiJi)_i_t/_ ,___
' l~~·Po AJ / /.M:;:-:_11/Uf A!'?.C_~n.K·__7li GBQ_t!.i./k.J(L/l_/lJ£Yl£t/l/ltt/Y£. TZJ__~~&ztt.zf-
. , . A L c ,P ' - . , . -4<1.-
. \ J f)2lll!ffll.l8:.(.;_,_1V£lTif~/ld_/l~ 42t3 5illJ.PLf--~IJ~€o_wJ1!16_/LlllJtu/U7_71J fYJ~M:;~
' ~-_L ~ ' ~ ' , ,
/)l:ialc§u4B:_ -:-lt~~~-----d._/J4... __'ll!j:,_ /u. 1/'l tve /l/L£. enlJ/2dl?Te-/)_fu;7_fi IS /1__
. /)u~t/)ose~~·
. .
lfll.sftf!f!~~?il£'/ITZP:U dJ 111/_ QZi_lc~;~k$-~?>/iJP$14l&_~--~ .7/ff;_·_
. . ~~
·. R~t. ~_1o/?_T/Iff.!!lis.c_IJiltd.IJ6c· :;,VTfl/6 ~6l~_/i6_ r~~/Jl-L- o7~~
l~dvto_ ORCI}f§T.Ill!r_t;;Li_T"t_k fJ1_lsl(e-/JR..Ed€~?~~A1 to10 ~~~1/:lO.R.L'ti t,U1LJV_'f,_
__ ~,l.~_fu-c~J.... V!.._rrn.r-.~J~S?e:?\· ftv&~ oiZ~ Vf7o/l£~ ~ .. ~~ __
·
.. teJ46 'lr_z __)Yo~__'f._~_2t>~---_(YJ1t'L_~)!J_7~, e ~ .
·--·.--------..'1 fkt;lff?/S lj ' .
. . . ' . . .~· ,
, 1~£-:-?:.1fes_i:::£e:fbi_~A/.$r9'btZ"JJJ.f.- lls.is~VIb.-;o ~ 7(2 56· {L.7~:cS:£ /JUTPipMS__ .
'~UiJi{:-;trL Ah7iie_::_f!~..etJ ~rJ ll/di/Tb/JiEA.iL_tiA:8t9 7lJ Ok!l;6~iJ/£l:vJJ'i /i!V(J..,lf~. ·
~~_TuN~-~-~e;~_tl__/~~/E__///1!() ltl-fEil.TIJe Jk:!f~'~-; b/J:4ai!Z /ils~f!t~S
4-))T~ l)j;pf(c;p_f{,~p~----~~c..Tw~. (!p_;vs:':.;:rtud:'tvi[/!1_ T~ L/?W # til.V L-4MO
. "AMl2 GJJI:f~/lf!ll>_6t~Awt/ 7lfE' ~et~i:&:_ i'le ~~ . '::,·~'
\J .
----·---
Certificate of Service
I hereby certify that on this
and correct copy of the above and forgiving request for leave to
file "Judicial Notice," ~,P.lea.oL.Abatement" and "Plea to Jurisdiction"
and "Nunc Pro Tunc" was sent by regular mail to the Court of Criminal
Appeals, P.O. Box 12308 Capitol Station, Austin, Texas 78711 Louise
Pearson Clerk.
s
"UNSWORN DECLARATION OF SHANE T- O'GRADY"
"My name is Shane Timothy O'Grady, my date of birth is 7-25-69
and my TDCJ-ID #1614317 I am presently incarcerated in the McConnell
Unit in Bee County, Texas 78102. I declare under penalty of perjury
that the facts stated in this Document in the aforementioned are
true and correct." Executed on ~4tb<'r' t)f 2015.
dA:l~
TDCJ-ID~#1614317
McConnell Unit
3001 South Emily Drive
Beeville, Texas 78102
16 of 17
CAPTION
THE STATE OF TEXAS IN THE 412TH DISTRICT COURT
COUNTY OF BRAZORIA OF BRAZORIA COUNTY, TEXAS
. At a regular term of the 412TH Judicial District Court, begun and holden within and for the County
ofBraiofia, Angleton, State ofTexas, before the Honorable W. EDWIN DENMAN, Judge
Presiding, which term began on the 24TH day of JANUARY, A:D., 2010 and which ends by
operation oflaw on the 30TH day of JUNE, A.D., 2010, the following cause came on for hearing to
..wit:
' ! CAUSE NO. 58,863
,I THE STATE OF TEXAS IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF
I :
vs. BRAZORIA COUNTY, TEXAS ·
'I
I SHANE TIMOTHY O'GRADY 412TH JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT
~ .. \
!
I
·,_..
_, (;Hf'tl · me wn R"W ntr r 1 -, 1 ttr m tt
.··.. !.
No . .5l!t3 BOND$ 8.5;(J{}Q . ·~ ; .. - .·
/i!{[ffl;j r!Jc · . _·-t~ ' ·j
. I
THE STATE OF TEXAS V. SHANE TIMOTHY O'GRADY . "·'····l~~-
"{OfJtJ _ . :. ~~~V.A
CHARGE: AGGRAVATED ASSAULT· ENHANCED
'- ~~2~ :.o':~..
WARRANT: H080207 (Control No. 2008-08573) e8.~. -~a
WITNESS: NONE
~~"""-"'-'-------------------------'-"··-· . (~
~-~if~~-, :~ .
IN THE NAME AND BY AUTIIORITY OF TilE STATE OF TEXAS: -·~
TilE GRAND JURY, for the County of Brazoria, State of Texas, duly selected,
empaneled, sworn, charged, and. organized as such for the District Court of said County,
upon their oaths present in and to said court that SHANE TIMOTHY O'GRADY,
hereinafter styled Defendant, on or about the 26th day of July, 2008, and before the •
presentment of the indictment, in the County and State aforesaid, did then and there
intentionally or knowingly threaten Amye O'Grady with imminent bodily injury and did
use or exhibit a deadly weapon, namely, a firearm;
ENHANCEMENT PARAGRAPHS
I
AND T~ GRAND JURORS AFORESAID do further present that before the
commission of the, offense alleged above, on or about the 4th day of November, 1998, in
Cause Number 33,7,22, in the 23rd Judicial District Court of Braziria County, Texas, the
defendant was convi¥ of the felony of Robbery;
(I)
~- Pff
11 1
/{
,, FILED
JUD 626327
NOV 11 2009
NO. 58863
Texaa
. THE STATE OF TEXAS IN THE 23RD JUDIC EPI1TY
VS. DISTRICT COURT OF
SHANE TIMOTHY O'GRADY BRAZORIA COUNTY, TEXAS
. JUDGMENT ON JURY VERDICT OF GUlLTY
I :) PUNISHMENT FIXED BY COURT OR JURY- NO PROBATION GRANTED _
~ J . •
Judge Presiding: W. Edwin Denman ) Date of Judgritent: November 3, 2009
Attorney Attorney
for State: DON STRICKLIN for Defendant: MARK B. JONES
Offense:
Convicted of: AGGRAVATED ASSAULT
Date Offense
Degree F2 Committed 26 JUL 08
Charging
Instrument: Indictment ,.
Plea: Guilty
'
Jury Verdict: GUILTY Foreman: ·NORMAN BEVERIDGE
Plea to Enhancement Finding on Enhancement
Paragraph(s): TRUE Paragraph(s): TRUE
Findings on Use
of Deadly Weapon: YES
Date Sentence Costs: $305.00
Imposed: November 3, 2009 Fine: $0.00
Attorney Fees: $0.00
_Costs covered by time served? YES
Punishment and Date to _ ,
Place of Confinement JO Years Texas Dept of Criminal Commence: November J, 2009
Justice- Institutional Division
Total Amount of
Time Credited 99 Days from date of sentence Restitution/Reparation:$
Concurrent Unless Otherwise Specified
Notice of Appeal: YES
IMAGE6
'
r- run· 626327
IN THE DISTRICT COURT, OF BRAZORIA COUNTY, TEXAS
23R0 JUDICIAL DISTRICT
JUDGMENT ON PLEA OF :NU1-ielLTY- PUNISHMENT ASSESSED BY JURY
THE STATE OF TEXAS CAUSE NO.: 58863
vs. TERM: OCTOBER 2009/MARCH 2010
SHANE TIMOTHY O'GRADY DATE: NOVEMBER 3, 2009
(MoiO!sllk~~~
SY'--~~-
THIS DAY this cause was called £ trial and the State appeared by her Assistant District
Attorney, DON STRICKLIN and the Defendant, SHANE TIMOTHY O'GRADY, appeared in person,
and his counsel MARK B. JONES also being present, and both parties announced ready for trial, and the
Defendant, in open court, pleaded not guilty to the charge contained in the indictment herein; thereupon a
jury, to wit: NORMAN BEVERIDGE and eleven others, was duly selected, impaneled and sworn, who
havi~g heard the indictment read, and the Defendant's plea of not guilty thereto, and having heard the
evidence submitted, and having been duly charged by the court, retired in charge of the proper officer to
consider their verdict, and afterward were brought into open court by the proper officer, the· Defendant
and his counsel being present and in due fonn of law returned into open court the following verdict,
which was received by the court, and is here now entered upon the minutes of the court, to wit:
WE, THE JURY, FIND THE DEFENDANT, SHANE TIMOTHY O'GRADY, GUILTY OF THE OFFENSE
OF AGGRAVATED ASSAULT, AS CHARGED IN THE INDICTMENT.
~NORMAN BEVERIDGE
PRESIDING JUROR
Thereupon the defendant elected to have his punishment assessed by the jury and such jury was
called back into the box and heard evidence relative to the question of punishment and thereafter they
retired to consider such question and after having deliberated, they returned into court the following
verdict:
WE, JURY, HAVING FOUND THE DEFENDANT, SHANE TIMOTHY O'GRADY, GUILTY OF THE
OFFENSE OF AGGRAVATED ASSAULT, DO FURTHER FIND THAT THE SAID DEFENDANT IS THE
SAME PERSON WHO, PRIOR TO THE COMMISSION OF THAT OFFENSE, HAD BEEN CONVICTED OF
THE FELONY OFFENSE AS ALLEGED IN THE ENHANCEMENT ALLEGATION; AND WE ASSESS HIS
PUNISHMENTAT CONFINEMENT IN THE
.
PENITENTIARY FOR JO YEARS, SAID TERM, BEING LIFE
~
OR NOT MORE THAN NINETY-NINE (99) YEARS NOR LESS FIVE (5) YEARS.
/ WE FURTHER ASSESS A FINE OF .JQ._, THIS BEING AN A AMOUNT NOT MORE THAN TEN
l3:J THOUSAND AND N0/100 ($10,000.00) DOLLARS.
• .. 1/
~H;Bit 13'1 fQo
v~\-z-
/
CAUSE NO. 58863
THE STATE OF TEXAS § IN THE 412th
§ FILED FOR RECORD
vs. § DISTRICT COURT OF
§ lOOq AUG 25 A q: 43
SHANE O'GRADY § BRAZORIA COUNTY, TEXAS
.
. MOTION TO REVOKE BAIL OR INCREASE BAIL 2--~~~~.
6f.l~~!!li)!>.\~~J~'>
COMES NOW, The State of Tex~s~ by and through the undersigned Assistant Criminal District cJl.{-1'
. .
Attorney, and files this Motion to Rev~ke Bail or Increase Bail pursuant to Articles 16.16, 17.09, and
17.15 of the Texas Code of Criminal Procedure. The State respectfully would show the Court as follows:
I
I
.
1. This case is currently set fortrial on September 8, 2009 at 9 AM;
2. The Defendant stands charged by indictment in this cause for the offense of
Aggravated Assault - Enhaqted, which is alleged to have been committed by this
Defendant for· intentionally or knowingly tlueatening Amye O'Grady with imminent
bodily injuiy by exhibiting a'deadly weapon, nan1ely, a firearm;
3. Ms. O'Grady wol13d show the Court as follows:
a. She is the estranged ex-wife of Shane O'Grady. She has in place a two
year protective order which includes her daughter Macee; ·
b. On Jtme 7, 2009, Amye O'Grady witnessed the Defendant drive past her.
place of residence. This home is located on a dead end street On June 17, 2009,
Ms. 0' Grady made a report with the Clute Police Department against Shane ..
I
('--. O'Grady for violation of the prot~ctive·order. On August 4, 2009 the Defendant
was arrested for the aforementioned violation of the protective ord_er;
!·- .
4. At the time of the filing, this Defendant remains incarcerated at the Brazoria
Catmty Detention Center. Regardless, the State is filing this motion to prevent ·this
Defendant from making a bond on the violation of the protective order and upon release,
posing a threat to the victim, Amye O'Grady;
5. Pursuant to Article 17.15, Code of Criminal Procedure, a judge shall consider:
"The future safety of... the community ... "; . -
..."" . ~
-- .... _ . ·._ -·.
----- - -;;~- - -, ~ '
~~~~--------- ~-====it===.....,=""'""'·-fn..m=....:·~-:'~:..!.:£:!~""'··
__ _.:. ,-.;.....;.;;;...,.;.·,;..·=--=· ,.,_.._" '·:. .i:;.-~.-. ~- kb- !~;.=-·~;:. !. : - '-: : ·-.;1~:.~:,~ .,ciz::\;;,.6',0;_.~'"-·~. . ~,.".-*'~-:. . . . ~'" . . . ~.UO.Z 1~- -
--
'z:,r,·.:r:!:1·
...
' '
,._ __ _-;--
-------·
.. ~
WHEREFORE, PREMISES CONSIDERED, the State requests that a hearing be he1d and the
Court revoke the Defendant's bond for his bail in this above-styled and numbered cause, or in the
alternative, deem said bail insufficient and increase bail. Any and all available general relief in law or in
equity is requested.
~-ed_,_-_-·_·________
Donald A. Stricklin
SBN: 24003018
Assistant Criminal District Attorney
Brazoria County District Attorney's Office
111 E. Locust, Room 408A
Angleton, Texas 77515
(979) 864-1230
fax (979) 864-1525
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
l)1ereby certify that· a .true and correct copy of the foregoing was placed in the USPS mail
certifiedreturn receipt rezested, apd regular mail, to Mark Jones, counsel for Defendant on this
f}--5 . day of J)rl $t-, 2009. · . ·
. /
~
. .
~:
-- .- 0021.
.~ -~
CAUSE NO. 58863
THE STATE OF TEXAS § IN THE 412th
§
vs. § DISTRICT COURT OF
§
SHANE O'GRADY § BRAZORIA COUNTY, TEXAS
ORDER
The Court, having heard the State's Motion to Revoke Bail or Increase Bail fmds that said bail is
insufficient and hereby revokes the Defendant's bail· and sets bail at
JUDGE PRESIDING
(6)
.... ('· ;) n,,·
U J .,._.,. _,--.-
~
at
...._..__ - - -"
, 'cJ . ,
0. ··~
_____ ,,.,
a.~,
1-\ Ut.,.1 1-.
1
'> (i~ 'll.
'-
oc•.
CAUSE NO. 58863
§
§
§
§
SHAN;E O'GRADY § BRAZORIA COUNTY, TEXAS
NOTICE OF HEARlNG
The State's Motion to Increase and/or Revoke Bail is set for hearing on the 28st day of August,
2009, at 9 A.M. in the 412'h District Court.
Respectfully submitted,
Donald A. Stricklin
SBN: 24003018
Assistant Criminal District Attorney
Brazoria County District Attorney's Office ·
Ill E. Locust, Room 408A
Angleton, Texas 77 515
(979) 864-1230
fax (979) 864-1525
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that a true and correct copy of the foregoing was placed in the USPS mail
cert~ return receipt requested, and regular mail, to Mark lones. counsel for Defendant on this.
-~"--_,___-day of Jh?c;
!) cvt: , 2009. '--<}-- V 1f1- ~51 H I I t
(3) . ~ .
IMAGE6
002.3
·:--··--···-..-.-....,._,_, __•... .:.·:.-.•
··s, .•
626327
NATE MOORE, SR. BRAZORIA COUNTY
CbierDeputy I 11 E. Locust, S••· 500
Angleton, TIC 7751 S
JERRY DEERE
District Clerk
www.brazoria.couaty.com/dcluk
February 03, 2009
/sbane Timothy O'Grady
121 Clements #711
Angleton, Tx 77515.
RE: CAUSE NO. 58863, 412th DISTRICT COURT
t'
THE STATE OF TEXAS VS. Shane Timothy O'Grady
Dear Sir/Madam: ~
You have been INDICTED by the Brazoria County Grand Jury.
We are enclosing a copy of Order for Pre-trial Hearing and/or Setting Case for Trial, Indictment and
Attorney Contact Form.
. .
You need to make an attempt to retain counseL We have enclosed a form for yon to use entitled Attorney
Contact Form. Please complete this form and bring.it with you to the pre-trial bearing in the event you
are unable to retain an attorney. At that time the judge wm require yon to fill out a financial statement.
If you do retain counsel, it is your responsibility to give your attorney a copy of tbe Order for Pre-trial
Hearing and Setting Case For Trial and Indictment. ·
Enclosed is also a form for you to complete once you retain counsel and mail it back to us at tbe address
on tbe form as soon as possible.
Please be present on the court dates as specified in your order. Failure to appear will result in your bond
being forfeited.
Yours truly,
Jerry Deere
District Clerk
CC: file
/ ACE BAIL BONDS/D.W. GARR.ETI
417 W. MULBERRY
ANGLETON TEXAS 77515
{'IJ DC LET INDICT DEIT-FORM 15219
f"kdtAir: ffJ) I/ J- Pfj.
nnn~
11/13/2009 10·44 FAX 9798841525 BRi'.l. 0 Rl.U. C0 U:\ '; :. ;· i.' ! ~001/002
'\•,
JERI VENNE
. CRIMINAL DISTRICT ATTORNEY
BRAZORIA COUNTY
FACSIMILE MESSAGE
DATE: November 13, 2009
TO: Mark Jones
RE: State of Texas v. Shane Timothy O'Gi'ady Cai.M$~~ No. 588{:)3
FAX NO. (979)-848v8378
FROM: Don Stricklin, Assistant District Attorney/Krystal Brooks, Secretary
BRAZORIA COUNTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY'S OFFICE
111 EAST LOCUST, SUITE 408 A
ANGLETON, TEXAS 77515
TELEPHONE NUMBER: Angl~ton Area (979) 864-1230
Brazosport Area (979) 388-1230
Houston Area (281) 756-1230
TELECOPIER NUMBER: Angleton Area {9"f9} 864-1525
BrazospOQ1: .A.~"~·~;~ 1~~1~-r;J:~ :{:~f~ -"~ ~~:,.~
Houston Arc~lf.J.~flt\.1l£.¥J.~~.:;..·:r:tr.n-wu:.•·•-,.q;.t.,.,,·.·~·~•"'•'-·..._.,..~·~
11/13/2009 10:44 FAX 8788841525 BRAZORIA CO OA OFFICE
Rlehard Maonvss
Rrst Assistant
Mury Aldous JOHN BLANKENSHIP
Ctolef • Criminal Division Chief lnVIlstigator
JERI VENNE
CRIMINAL DISTRICT ATTORr,_u;;:Y
BRAZORIA COUNTY
November ·13. :?.009
To: Mark Jones
124 West Myrtle
Angleton, TX 77515
Re: State ofTexas v_ Shane O'Grady Cause No. 58863
t
Dear Mr. Jones,
~
-____;.:>~ Please be advised that there is a hearing set in the 4)2th Distl'kt Cmui for November 17, 2009 at
8:30a.m. for the above cause. If you have any que:ruo;t~ ci! v.m::~:.m. d.:;otlt tiu~: maner please feel
free to contact me.
Thank you
Don Stricklin
Assistant District Attorney
(SJ
COUNTY COURTHOUSE'., 111 ~.LOCUST. SUITE 408A. ANGLEION. TEXAS n515
Angleton Area erazosport Art'!a Houston Area fax-Crimimil DivisiM Fax.Civil Division
(9l9) 86<1-1?.30 (979) 388-1230 (2H 1) 756- 1230 (~)79) 8Ei4- i 525 (979) 849-8914
;creen P~int from AbleTerw 9ession(TSG)
------~--~---------------
;ause': 58863~
;t"yle: Shane Timothy O'grady
)ff. Aggravated Assault - Enhanced
Date Time Hearing Description Pri Cause Number
c=::=o~r;__zg_o~~~o-8 =~-=-o~.J ! '
2. 03/18/09 · 09:00a Pre Trial 100 58863
3. 04/22/09, 09:00a Pre Trial 100 58863
4. 07/23/09 09:00a Announcement Hearing 100 58863
5. 07/27/09 09:00a Trial 100 58863
b. 08/20/09 09:00a Announcement Docket 100 58863
7. 08/24/09 09:00a Trial 100 58863
8. 09/08/09 09:00a Trial· 100 58863
9. 09/24/09 09:00a Announcement Docket 100 58863
. lO. b9/28/09 09:00a Trial 100 58863
11. 10/22/09 09:00a Announcement Hearing 100 58863
·12. 10/26/09 09:00a Trial 100 58863
- View 1 I TAB to select All Hearings --- Page 1 of 1
Selection: 1
'1 '- Exi_t___F_2_-_A_d
__ d _____F_3_-_F_u_t_u_r_e__F_4_-_S_e__
t_u..._p___F_5_-_A_t_t_r
__ n..._y_F_6_-_P_r_l_·n__
t __________________
'(to)
..rtJOt=)t QufJLi.;tetG
!-P!3
·... _
" 1 REPO~TER I s RECORD
2 VOLUME ' 1 OF 1 VOLUMES
3 TRIAL COURT CAUSE NO. 58863
4
5 THE. STATE OF TEXAS IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF
6
7 vs,. BRAZORIA COONTY, TEXAS-
8:'
9 SHANE 0' GRADY * 412TH JUDICIAL DISTRICT
11 MOTION
. TO REVOKE/I·NCREASE
. BOND-
13
141 i
On the 28.th day of !August., 2009, the fol'lo\-ving
-15 I proceedings l
came .on to be he:ard in the above;-entitled and .
' i
.1 :
16' numbered cause before the HO:norable Edw:.ln Denman, Jud9e w.
·I
17 presiding, held in Angleton ,i B.ra~oria C.9tihty, Texa$,
18
( t-J) P:toc~edings report~d by !'-1achine· Shorthand Met:h,od.
np:1
Ut -;
.. \,'
'
c If\{
. 1\ f
r\,._.""_; ! f' ' ' c--
•' .
~
..
' 23
,,z,;lL=-·========,p=================~ !·
JTLl:i FRIEDRICHS
. : :. ::;~. . Offi¢~a] Court. Rep6±te~
·.·.· .412th. Judicial Di.strict court:
·~
2
1 APPEARANCES
2
3 MR. DON STRICKLIN
SBOT NO. 24003018
4 111 East Locust, Suite 408A
Angleton, Texas 77515
5 Phone: 979-864-1230
ATTORNEY FOR THE STATE OF TEXAS
6
AND
7
MR. MARK JONES
8 SBOT NO. 00786002
124 West Myrtle
9 Angleton, Texas 77515
Phone: ·979-849-8076
10 ATTORNEY FOR THE DEFENDANT
11
12
13
r· 14
15
16 ( 1j
17 e~tl /13 :t 1t(2 11 3l/Pgs~
18
19
:;. o1 3'/
~;:;;:•:ll;"- :r:tu;:;::;a-t•:~; ::;;;:;; :::a
20
21
22
23
24
r\
'
25
JILL FRIEDRICHS
Official Court Reporter
412th Judicial District Court
3
.1 INDEX
2 AUGUST 28, 2009 PAGE
3 Appearances. . . . . 2
4 STATE'S WITNESSES DIRECT CROSS REDIRECT RECROSS
5 AMYE 0 I GRADY 5 11
6 JOHNNIE LEWIS 21 23
7 State Rests. . . . 24
8 DEFENDANT'S WITNESSES DIRECT CROSS REDIRECT RECROSS
9 SHANE 0 I GRADY 25 27 29 29
10 Court's Ruling. 32
11 Court Reporter's Certification . . 34
12
13
14 EXHIBI~ INDEX
15 STATE Is EXHIBITS
16 NO. DESCRIPTION OFFERED ADMITTED
17 1 Protective Order 6 6
. 18
(1)
19 (;X.Ht0lt I{ b I/
23
24
25
JILL FRIEDRICHS
Official Court Reporter
412th Judicial District Court
4
1 AUGUST 28, 2009
2 THE COURT: On the record in Cause No. 58863,
3 State of Texas vs. Shane O'Grady. We're here on the State's
4 motion to revoke bail or increase bail.
5 State ready to proceed?
6 MR. STRICKLIN: Yes, Your Honor.
7 THE COURT: . Defense ready?
8 MR. JONES: Yes, Your Honor.
9 THE COURT: Let the record reflect counsel· for
. 10 the State is present, counsel for the Defendant and the
11 Defendant are all present.
12 You may proceed, Mr. Stricklin.
r-·· 13 MR. STRICKLIN:
1.4 would call Amye 0' Grady.
Thank you, Your Honor. The State
15 MR. JONES: We'd like to invoke the rule, Your
16 Honor, since there will be more than one witness.
17 THE COURT: All right. Whoever is going to
18 testify in the case, other than Ms. O'Grady, if they would come
19 up to the -- is there anyone else going to testify?
20 MR. STRICKLIN: There ls two witnesses, Your
21 Honor.
22 THE COURT: All right. Both of you come up to
23 the rail just a moment.
24 (Witnesses du1y sworn by the Court.)
25 THE COURT: All right. The rule has been
(7)
JILL FRIEDRICHS
. .,-=-cu,~,y ?JJn
/.?Jfii;~Jt/ <:z () '1 r[y!>. Official Court Reporter
~~~~==============~ 412th Judicial District Court.
'i o} ~L/
5
1 ipvoked. What that means is that you may not talk to anyone
2 about this case except the attorneys and unless you are called
3 into the courtroom and you're testifying here on the witness
4 stand. You can't read any transcriptions of it. You can't
5 read any notes about it. And if you violate that, you could be
6 held in contempt of court or you could be prevented from
7 testifying. Do you understand that?
8 All right. The witness you called·was who?
9 MR. STRICKLIN: . Amye O'Grady.
10 THE COURT: Ms. O'Grady, if you could just come
11 around here and take the stand, please.
12 And if you would stand outside, we'll bring you
13 in when we're ready for you.
14 You may proceed.
15 AMYE 0 I GRADY I
16 having been first duly sworn, testified as follows:
17 DIRECT EXAMINATION
18 BY MR.. STIUCKLIN:
19 Q. Would you please state your full name for the record?
20 A. Amye O'Grady.
21 Q. Ms. O'Grady, do you know the Defendant in this case,
22 Shane O'Grady?
23 A. Yes.
24 Q. How is it that you know him?
25 A. We were married.
f'·
'7) JILL FRIEDRICHS
Official Court Reporter
412th Judicial District Court
6 ..
1 Q. Is he present in the courtroom today?
2 A. Yes.
3 Q. Okay. Could you identify where he's sitting and .an
4 article of clothing he's wearing?
5 A. He's wearing orange, right there.
6 MR. STRICKLIN: Let the record reflect she's
7 identified the Defendant, Your Honor.
8 THE COURT: It does.
9 Q. Ms. O'Grady, are you divorced from Shane O'Grady at
10 this time?
11 . A. Yes.
12 Q. When did that divorce become final?
13 A. August 12th, '09.
~ 14 Q. Okay. Is it true that the allegation in this lawsuit
15 is that Mr. O'Grady threatened you with a firearm?
16 A. Yes.
17 Q. Okay. At any time after the incident occurred did he
18 threaten you in any other way?
19 A. He came by my house, drove by my house.
20 Q. Okay. Did you ever have to get a protective order?
21 A. Yes. Yes.
22 MR. JONES: No objection, Your Honor. ·~,;
23 MR. STRICKLIN: I'm going to tender and offer
24 State's Exhibit 1.
25 {'7) THE COURT: Exhibit 1 is admitted.
JILL FRIEDRICHS
Official· Court Reporter
412th Judicial District Court
7
1 Q. Do you want to thumb through that? • Ms. O'Grady, if
2 you could just quickly thumb through State's Exhibit 1? Is
3 that the protective order in place between yourself and Shane
4 O'Grady?
5 A. Yes.
6 Q. And under that protective order what does it mandate
7 the distance that Mr. O'Grady is to maintain between you and
8 himself?
9 A. I believe it says 500 feet. No phone calls, nothing.
10 Q. Okay. He's not --
11 A. No contact at all, not to go to my house, my
12 employment, my -- our daughter's school, nothing. No contact.
:l-3 Q. Is it true that you and Mr. O'Grady have a daughter
14 together?
15 A. Yes.
16 Q. What is her name?
17 A. Macy O'Grady.
18 Q. She's how old?
19 A. She's 4.
20 Q. Is Mr. O'Grady permitted to visit with Macy in any
21 way?
22 A. He's supposed to have supervised visits at ~he Women's
23 Shelter, and that was stated in this order.
24 ' Q. Okay. So what does that mean to you as the mom? What
25 is he allowed to do, basically, if'he wants to visit with Macy?
r 6) ~================'
' ., _ tl ? JILL FRIEDRICHS
~=~===W=;=I3==Ji====G=='='==:J='/=·=A~~~~=.J Official Court Reporter
412th Judicial District Court
8
1 A. He has to go to the Women's Center and it's supervised
2 and he's supposed to contact and give 48 hours notice and after
3 five times of not doing that he's dropped from having even
4 that, even having supervised visitation through that.
5 Q. Since the incident which is the basis of the
6 indictment,. that is the aggravated assault Mr. O'Grady
7 allegedly committed on you?
8 A. Uh-huh. ·
9 Q. Have you felt threatened by Mr. O'Grady in any way?
10 A. Yes.
11 Q. Would you tell the Court how?
12 A. At the beginning of June I was outside with Macy and
r 13 my other daughter, Kayly.
14 . Q. June of this year?
15 A. Yes, beginning of June.
16 Q. Okay.
17 A. And I was outside and I saw a vehicle which I
18 recognized to be his mother, Carol Sheffield'~ vehicle, and I
19 was like -- I wanted to double check and make sure who was
20 driving it and make sure that that was it. So I kind of walked
21 a little bit farther down the driveway and I live on a dead end
22 street and that vehicle made the circle and came bac~up and
23 Shane was driving it and he did this. He did like a double
24 ta.ke and then looked and made direct eye contact with me and
. 25 kept driving.
rev JILL FRIEDRICHS
12KI1 /e.;r uG '' J;tt P1;5_ ~ Official Court Reporter
412th Judiclal District Court
~~.:_ ..4
9
r 1 Q. Okay. So you're telling the Court you're absolutely
2 positive that was Shane driving that vehicle?
3 A. Yes.
4 Q. Are you aware of any reason Shane should be on that
5 street?
6 A. None.
7 Q. Does he have any friends on that street that you know
8 of?
9 A. Not that I know of.
10 Q. What street is this?
11 A. Crestwood Street in Clute, Texas.
12 Q. Is that where you were residing?
13 A. Yes.
~·
14 Q. Is that your home?
15 A .. Yes.
16 Q. Was that did he make that drive-by after the
17 protective order had been put in place?
18 A. Yes.
19 Q. Have you had any other incidents with Shane that you
20 would feel were threatening?
21 A. Yes. He called the house, called my house a couple of
22 days before he drove by. My mother spoke with him, ~ohnnie
23 Lewis. She answered the call.
24 Q. How many times are you aware of Shane calling your
25 house, your mother's house?
r('1)
JILL FRIEDRICHS
Official Court Reporter
412th Judicial District Court
.. 10
i. {_
1 A. Twice because I recognize the number on the caller IO.
2 The first time somebody called and hung up and didn't recognize
3 the number. And then the next day my mom answered the phone
4 and I noticed it was the same number and it was Shane.
5 Q. It was the same number that called?
6 A. Had called the day before and hung up, yes.
7 Q. Did he ever make any kind of other threatening remarks
8 to you immediately after the incident about whether or not he
9 made bail?
10 A. Yes. He said -- you know, he didn't want me to go to
11 the police and he said even if I did --
12 MR. JONES: Your Honor, could I ask for a date
13 and time on this because I'm confused.which bail he's talking
r'· 14 about.
15 Q. Let me break this down a little, Ms. O'Grady.
16 A. Okay.
17 Q. I'm talking about immediately after the aggravated
18 assault that's pending in this case.
1,9 A. Okay.
20 Q. Wher~ the allegation is that he threatened you with a
21 firearm.
22 A. Right.
23 Q. Were there any remarks he made to you as a part of
24 that incident which you felt threatened? ·
A. Yes.
JILL FRIEDRICHS
• • tl
Official Court Reporter
12kt-/JBir G ''
412th Judicial District Court
11
1 Q. What was that?
2 A. He said that if I went to the police and he went to
3 jail that he could make bail and if he did, he would come out
4 and he would kill me .and then kill himself. He knew where I
5 lived, where I worked.
6 Q. Did you make a police report based on his driving by
7 the home, the violation of the protective order? ·
8 A. Yes.
9 Q. Okay. Do you know what happened with that?
10 A. They said they were going to get a warrant for that
11 and arrest him.
12 MR. STRICKLIN: Your Honor, I pass the witness.
13 CROSS-EXAMINATION
14 BY MR. JONES:
15 Q. Did you give a statement to the police in conjunction
16 with this~ rna' am?
17 A. With?
18 Q. The protective order incident.
19 A. Did I make a statement with the police?
20 Q. Yes. Yes, ma'am.
21 A. Yes. I filed a report. Yes.
22 Q. Now you filed a report, I believe, on the 17Jth of June
~~
23 is when you called the police about this, correct?
24 A. Yes.
25 Q. You're alleging this incident occurred June 4th or
.r'·(7J ~==============~
JILL FRIEDRICHS
ek:ftt~lr''G II 31/Pfj_S. Official Court Reporter
~===========~==========~ 412th Judicial District Court
II o? ~'f
12
1 6th, correct? 4th, 5th and 6th, roughly?
('
2 A. He drove by on the 7th, I believe. June 7th.
3 Q. Why did you wait so long, ma'am, if you were so
4 concerned and in fear of your life?
5 A. Well, I wasn't sure- because, you know, in the
6 protective order if, you know, driving by or if he had to like
·7 stop and have, you know, contact. And, you know, I wasn't
8 sure. So I called the victim's coordinator and they said you
9 need to file a report; and I talked with my divorce lawyer and
10 he says, yes, you need to file a report. And so that's when I
11 went to go.
12 Q. So it took you roughly ten days to do that?
13 A. Yes.
(' 14 Q. So you weren't that afraid because you could have
15 immediately called the police and let them sort it out,
·16 correct?
17 A. I was afraid.
18 Q. Well, ma'am, you could have immediately have called
19 the police and let them sort it out, correct?
20 A. Yes.
21 Q. But instead, you waited ten days, correct?
·?;;.r.'~>
22 A. Yes.
'liS,
23 Q. And when he supposedly drove by he didn't hold out a
24 f~nger like he was going to shoot you or anything, diq he?
25 A. No.
rev~======~==============~
JILL FRIEDRICHS
Official Court Reporter
412th Judicial District Court
-= r:::e==- ,
-· #"ll =lfMHJ:i :!Zl'l:
~ ~--···' . '
13
1 Q. In fact, he's been out on bond for about a year, has
r'' 2 he not?
3 A. Yes.
4 Q. And you first said you recognized his mother's car.
5 Then you said you had to make sure it was his mother's car. So
6 you weren't sure at first~ correct?
7 A. Well, I·had been seeing a lot of those cars around
8 town and I always look to see if that's -- whose driving the
9 vehicle. And I wanted to make sure. Because .I think it has
10 tinted'windows. I'm pretty positive. And I couldn't see very
11 well because I was way up on my driveway.
12 Q. So you walked toward him, correct?
13 A. I walked just to like the barely middle of my
14 driveway. There is like a big tree, and I just kind of stood
15 and looked.
16 Q. Now when you got the protective order it was a default
17 against my client. He did not appear in court that day, did
18 he?
19 A. No, he did not.
20 Q. And you have no evidence that he even knows what's.in
21 the content of that protective order, does he? You, have no
22 evidence he's ever received a copy? ~
23 A. I don ' t know.
24 Q. And for the divorce also on August 12th, 2009, that
~ 25 was a default against my client, correct?
rc~ ~==========================~~
J
to /1 II '2 i /)
JILL FRIEDRICHS
.:!!~~X~Jt£J$:!f::..l-::!:L==L?======~=~=f'!j5.of f i cia 1 Cour~ Reporter
I
J ~ o:) ~If 412th Judicial District Court
14
·4 A. I believe it has a statement in there about the
5 protective order visitation. I'm not sure of the exact
6 verbiage in it, but states that that's the visitation in that.
7 Q. Who is he to call to arrange that visitation?
8 A. I believe he's supposed to call my lawyer or the
9 Women's Center.
10 Q. And he didn't stop driving. If it was him, .he just
11 kept on driving, according to you, correct?
12 A. Yes, he kept driving.
13 Q. He made no overt signs that he was going to do any
r' 14 harm to you, did he?
15 A. No.
16 .Q. And in fact, you said there were no phone calls . Does
17 the protective order say he's not to make· any calls in a
18 threatening or harassing manner, correct?.
19 A. Yes.
20 Q. And he did not speak to you. He spoke to your mother,
21 who is. not covered by the protective order, if he did indeed
22 call, correct?
~~
23 A. Yes.
24 Q. And who owns that telephone number that he called
25 from?
r{?J
JILL FRIEDRICHS
Official Court Reporter
412th Judicial District Court
.. - - ------------
15
1 A. Who owns the telephone number that Shane called from?
~--
2 Q. Yes, ma'am.
3 A. I have no idea. It just said -- just the phone number-
4 showed up.
5 Q. So you have no idea who called that first time, do
6 you, rna' am?
7 A. No, I don't know who called the first time. I just
B compared the numbers.
9 Q. And is his mother allowed visitation with the
10 children?
11 A. His mother?
12 Q. Yes.
13 A. We don't have any orders in place, I mean, whether she
14 has visitation. She's never contacted me for any kind of
15 visitation.
16 Q. Have you encouraged visitation with his family?
17 A. No. I don't talk to his family at all.
.18· Q. And you said you were afraid because ·he originally
19 said in the incident if he made bail and was arrested he could
20 get out and he would kill you, correct?
21 .A. Yes.
~~~
22 Q. That's been almost a year. Has he made any~airect
23 attempt to carry out that promise you say he made?
24 A. No, until he drove by my house.
· 25 Q. And once again, if he did drive by your house, he
r~~========================~
JILL FRIEDRICHS
' ., Ll I1
£klt1/37[' G?l/Pes-.. Official Court Reporter
=============....:
/6- o:j 3 'I 412th Judicial District Court
16
1 didn't threaten you that day, did he, ma'am?
~ 2 A. He didnit make any signs or anything like that. He
3 just stared at me.
4 Q. And you still waited ten days before making the police
5 report?
6 A. Yes.
7 Q. And after the first incident you waited, what, about
8 two months before making that police report?
9 1
A .• --q'c'~think it was a couple weeks, I believe.
10 - _-Okay. And in fact, after the alleged incident where
~ -
11 he supposedly threatened you with a gun in a motel, you went
12 back over to his house and left your child with him that day,
13 correct, rna' am?
14 MR. STRICKLIN: Your Honor, I object. That's
15 irrelevant for the purposes of this hearing.
16 MR. JONES: I think it goes to the credibility.
17 THE COURT: Overruled.
18 You may answer the question.
19 A.' Can you repeat the question?
20 Q._ After the day he supposedly assaulted the initial
21 supposed -- after he supposedly threatened you at the hotel
22 ··with a gun, you_.- went over to his house that afternoorr, ~correct?
23 A. -To his house?
24 Q.- W~ll, I'm sorry. His brother's house?
25 A. Yes~ After the incident, yes.
r L'~J JILL FRIEDRICHS
Official Court Reporter
412th Judicial District Court
--
17
r 1
2
Q.
A.
And you left your child there overnight, correct?
Yes.
3 Q. The next day you picked up your child and you said
4 that he threatened you again, correct?
5 A. Yes.
6 Q. And you still waited several days to call the police?
7 A. Yes, I did.
8 Q. And if the police records show that it was actually
9 more than several days, at least a month, would that -- why
10 would you wait so long, even several days, ma'am? I mean he
·11 threatened you, threatened to kill your child. Why would you
12 even delay?
13 A. Because I was scared and when the police came to my
14 house -- because I had made a _9-1-1 recording when he had me in
15 the hotel and because I was scared to death. I thought there
16 was like GPS on cell phones and they could track me and find me
· 17 in the hotel room and I had it right here by my leg and, you
18 know, that didn't happen. And they went .to .my. mom's house and
19 my mom was like, you know, she was around her ex-husband. He's
20 volatile. And it was somehow -- the communication got messed
21 up between·clute Police Department and West Columbia Police
22 Department and l.t all got messed up.
23 Q. Well, wait a minute. One again, you knew the police
24 were concerned about you. They were involved because of the
25 9-1-1 call?
r'[1)
JILL FRIEDRICHS
Official Court Reporter
412th Judicial District Court
18 ,. ; . }
1 A. Uh-htih.
2 Q. And yet you didn't bother, after this threat was made
3 against you and your child and.you had the child safely, to go
4 to the police and say, hey, protect me from this guy?
5 A. I was scared. He had me very, very intimidated.
6 Q. Once again, ma'am, you didn't do that?
7 A. No, I did not. Not right away.
8 Q. In fact, you waited quite sometime to even do the
9 protective order, did you not?
10 . A. I don't remember exactly how long. They got an
11 emergency protective order for me when he was arrested. That's
12 when they said that they would obtain that. for me.
r- 13 Q. Okay.
14 to them finally, correct?
So the police could protect you when you went
15 A. I'm_ sorry?
16 Q. So the police could protect you, is what you're saying
..
17 now?
18 A. Yes. I was afraid but, you know---· because I was
19 afraid to go. And then my family was like, look, you know, you
20 might as well have -- either way, he's going to intimidate you.
21 And if he does something to you, you know, at least have the
22 police on your side. You need to go. You know, bec~use I was
23 very, very, very afraid.
24 Q. So this original incident occurred on July 26th, 2008?
25 A. I believe it was July 28th, 2008, when it happened.
~(1)
JILL FRIEDRICHS
Official Court Reporter
412th Judicial District Court
.· .
19 ~
I
1 Q. Well, ma'am, if your protective order application says
2 July 26th, 2008, and you swore to that, wouldn't that be a
3 correct date?
4 A. I'm not sure.
5 Q. If I'm reading from it, ma'am, would you agree with
6 me?
7 A. Okay.
8 MR. STRICKLIN: I'm going to object that he
9 .
should at least allow her to read from the document .
10 THE COURT: Doesn't she have the protective
11 order?
12 MR. JONES: Not the application, Your Honor.
r
.
13
14
Q.
A.
Here. Take a few minutes to look over that.
It says July 26th.
15 Q. ·And when did you file charges with the police
16 initially in- this case?
17 A. I don't recall the exact date.
18 Q. Was it in August?
19 A. I believe so.
20 Q. And he was arrested, according to your affidav~t,
21 about October 23rd, I believe, correct?
22 A. I believe, yes.
23 Q. October 28th. I'm sorry.
24 A. Okay.
25 Q. During that time while he was on the loose did he
~~~==~==================~
JILL FRIEDRICHS
'Official Court Reporter
412th Judicial "District Court
20
r 1 threaten you any other time during that?,
2 A. No.
3 Q. And in fact, one of the reasons you met originally is
\
4 because he was behind on child support and you were upset about
5 that, correct?
6 A. No.
7 Q. Well, once again, he spoke to your mother and not you,
8 correct?
9 A. Correct.
10 Q. He did not make any threatening gestures toward you?
11 A. No.
12 Q •. He's been out on bond for almost a year, has not
13 . threatened to ~arry out the threat you said he made originally?
14 A. Yes.
15 Q. And to your knowledge, he doesn't even have knowledge
16 of what'~ in the protective order?
17 A. I have no idea what he has knowledge of.
18 Q: You have no knowledge of him ever being served with a
19 copy?
20 (
A. Do I have knowledge if he's been served with a copy?
21 Q. Yes.
22 A. I don't know.
23 Q. Has your attorney or anybody else ever told you we
24 sent him a copy?
25 A. She said that they served him, that they sent him one,
~0)~========================~
JILL FRIEDRICHS
6>tfttr&f(t (1 11 ?;l/Pv-s . Official Court Reporter
~======~==========~~ 412th Judicial District Court
~-wLf1N,:i . ?'/.
21
1 a certified copy is what they told me.
r 2 Q. But you have no proof of that here today?
3 A. Not today, no.
4 MR. JONES: Pass the witness, Your Honor.
5 MR. STRICKLIN: I have nothing further.
6 THE COURT: Thank you very much. You may step
7 down, Ms. O'Grady.
8 Call your next witness.
9 MR. STRICKLIN: I call Johnnie Lewis.
10 THE COURT: You may proceed.
11 JOHNNIE LEWIS,
12 having been first duly sworn, testified as follows:
13 DIRECT EXAMINATION
14 BY MR. STRICKLIN:
15 Q. Please state your name for the record, ma'am.
16 A. It's Johnnie Lewis.
17 Q. And do you know Amye O'Grady?
18 A. Yes. She's my daughter.
19 Q. Do you know Shane O'Grady?
20 A. Yes.
21 Q. How is it that you know Shane?
He's my ex son-in-law. ·:;w
22 A.
23 Q. Have you talked to him in the past?
24 A. Yes.
25 Q. Would you recognize his voice?
r1~)
, II JILL FRIEDRICHS
ex.l{; 16.rr Cb '' Official Court Reporter
412th Judicial District Court
Jvo o9
22
1 A. Yes.
r' 2 Q. Okay. Do you recall an incident where he called
3 Y,OUr -- do you know whether or not a protective order exists
4 between your daughter, Amye, and Shane O'Grady?
5 A. Yes, there is.
6 Q. All right. Are you aware of any phone calls that
7 Shane made to your home after the protective order was enacted?
8 A. Yes.
9 Q. Okay. Would you tell the Court about that?
10 A. He called on June 5th. I believe it was a Friday in
11 the afternoon. He asked to speak to Macy and I said, "Excuse
12 me, II
because I wanted to make sure I heard it right. He said,
13 "May I speak'to Macy?" And I said, "No, you cannot. " And
~-
. 14 he -- I'm sorry. I'm nervous.
15 I told him, "You ~ad to a chance to see her" --
16 in his previous order he could meet with her at the Women's
17 Center, supervised; and he had five chances to do this and he
18 failed to do so and he said that he thought ·he couldn't see her
19 because he wasn't -- didn't show up. And I said, "Right, you
20 can't see her. And you need to read your papers." I said,
21 "Have you read your papers?" And he said, "No, I haven't."
22 Arid I said, "Well, you need to read your papers and ~ollow it."
23 And then I hung up.
24 Q. Do you recall an incident where Mr. O'Grady drove past
25 your home and your daughter saw him?
~('!)
~XJ.t ;q }-r'' (; 11
311Pfj6-- JILL FRIEDRICHS
Official Court Reporter
~J o:t '3tf 412th Judicial District Court
~~~
23
lr----A~.--~Y~e~s-.------------------------~------------------------
2 Q. Was this phone call you just testified to, did that
3 occur before Shane drove past your house or after?
4 A. Before.
5 MR. STRICKLIN: Pass the witness.
6 A. It was just a couple of days.
7 MR. STRICKLIN: I pass the witness, Your Honor.
8 CROSS-EXAMINATION
9 BY MR. JONES:
10 Q. Now in the police report there is no statements saying
11 you saw my client allegedly drive by your daughter's house.
12 You didn't see that, did you?
13 A. I didn't actually see it, but she --
14 Q. Okay. Thank you ma'am.
15 Now the protective order says that he can't speak
16 to your daughter. He didn't speak to her that day, did he?
17 A. No.
18 Q. And he's not prohibited from talking
-··.
·to you, is he?
..'·
19 A. No.
20 Q. And you said that he needs to read his papers. You
21 have no personal knowledge whether he ever received those
22 papers, did you, ma'am?
23 A. I'm sorry. I did. I asked him, I said, "6id you
24 receive your papers?" He said, "Yes, but I didn't read them."
25 Q. That's not what you testified to originally though,
r' (11)
t- , JILL FRIEDRICHS
ICXfi 1 fl> iT G ' 1 '3 'IPgs , Official Court Reporter
~~ d1 1'( 412th Judicia~ District Court
-- _z;:
24
1 was it, ma'am? You just now added that in when I questioned
2 you about that, correct?
3 A. No. I thought I said you need to read your papers.
4 Q. You said you need to read the papers.
5 A. Right.
6 Q. You didn't mention anything about him having received
7 them, did you, rna' am?
8 A. Maybe I didn't just now, but I did ask him. I did.
9 Q. Didn't threaten your daughter, didn't threaten his
10 child, did he?
11 A. No.
12 MR. JONES: Pass the witness, Your Honor.
13 MR. STRICKLIN: I have nothing further, Your
14 Honor.
15 THE COURT: Thank you very much. You may step
16 down.
17 MR. STRICKLIN: State has no further witnesses,
18 Your Honor. We rest for the purposes of~the .. bond hearing.
19 (State rests.)
20 MR. JONES: Your Honor, I would like to put my
21 client only on for the limited purposes of this bond hearing.
22 THE COURT: All right.
23 (Defendant du~y sworn by the Court.)
24 THE COURT: You may proceed.
25
r'(J)
JILL FRIEDRICHS
· fX:vt :10 ·rr "G '' Official Court Reporter
412th Judicial: District Court
25 .l .
1 SBANB· O'GBADY,
2 having been first duly sworn, testified as follows:
3 DIRECT EXAMINATION
4 BY MR. JONES:
5 Q. Mr. O'Grady, on or about June 4th, 5th or 7th did you
6 drive by your wife's house?
7 A. . No, sir .
8 Q. Now your mother does own a gray van, correct, a gray
9 car?
10 A. Yes, sir.
11 Q. Now did you call her residence, asking to speak to
12 your daughter?
13 A. Yes, sir, I did.
14 Q. Have you ever received a copy of the protective order
15 in place?
16 A. The protective order that I received was from actually
17 when I was ~rrested, which I was -- my understanding was the
18 90 days. .:·-
19 Q. That would be the magistrate's emergency protective
20 order?
21 A. Yes, sir.
22 Q. But you are aware that another one -- you took a
23 default against you?
24 A. From an attorney, I believe.
25 Q. Mr. Wilsey?
r (1)
JILL FRIEDRICHS
2k51'l)~ h; d C:, ,, Official Court Reporter
J./1 o1· 1J/j 412th Judicial District Court
26
1r-~~Al.~~Y~e~s~,~s7
i~r-.------------------------~----------~----------~
r 2 Q. Sir, there is a 4,000-dollar bond based, I think, on
3 this charge, correct?
4 A. Yes.
5 Q. You're also on a criminal trespass filed by your
6 mother's apartment complex?
7 A. That's correct.
8 Q. How much is that bond for?
9 A. That bond is $80.
10 Q. Okay. And you've been in jail how long on those two
11 charges?
12 A. 28 days.
r 13
14
Q.
A.
Do you have any resources in which to post a bond?
No.
15 Q. Your mother has not bailed you out, correct?
16 A. No, sir.
17 Q~ Your brother, I believe, is in SAF-P?
18 A. That's correct.
19 Q. And you have no way to -- no collateral to put up for
20 bond?
21 A. No, sir.
22 Q,. Are you asking the Court to deny the motion~'to
'• ~~
23 increase bail because you did not violate the protective order
24 and you have no funds?
25 A. Yes, sir. I have no funds to post the bond.
~0)
JILL FRIEDRICHS
~~~uG '' 1>L{Pgs~ Official Court Reporter
412th Judicial District Court
(t6' c1 ~~
. : -,-;...~~·
27
1r-----~--------MMDR-.-,J~O~N~E~S~:~~P~a~s~s~t~h~e~w-1~.t~n_e
__s_s-,~Y~o-u-r~H~o-n_o_r-.--------~~
2 CROSS-EXAMINATION
· 3 BY MR. STRICKLIN:
4 Q. Mr. O'Grady, I want to hand you what's·been marked as
5 State's Exhibit No. 1.
6 A. Yes, sir.
7 Q. Which is the protective order which you had allegedly
8 violated. Have you ever seen that document before?
9 A. Yes, sir, I have.
10 Q. Okay. When did you see it?
11 A. I was actually given this -- I believe in February
12 14th.
13 ~ Q. Of 2009?
. 14 A. Yes, sir.
15 Q. Okay. Did you read the document?
16 A. Yes, sir, I did.
17 Q. Do you have any problem reading the English language,
. 18 right? Did you understand the terms?
19 A.' Yes, sir.
20 Q. Are you telling the Court that when -- you heard Amye
21 testify that you drove by the home in June?
22 A. Yes, 'sir, I did.
23 Q. Are you telling the Court that she's just lying about
24 that?
25 A. . Yes, sir, I am.
r-(2)
JILL FRIEDRICHS
~xlb ,'a rr'l G II
Official Court Reporter
412th Judicial District Court
28
1 Q. That you did not drive by that home at any time?
2 A. No, sir.
3 Q. Did you call the O'Grady -- did you call the house
4 that Amye was staying at on two occasions in June?
5 A. I called -- yes, I did.
6 Q. Did you know that Amye was stay~ng there?
7 A. No. I haven't spoke to Amye for over a year.
8 Q. That stems out of the arrest on the case that .you're
9 indicted for in this case, right?
10 A. I'm sorry. I don't understand the question.
11 Q. You haven't spoken to Amye since you were arrested?
12 A. That is correct.
13 - Q. Do you deny for purposes of this hearing that you ever
14 told Amye O'Grady that you would bond out and kill her?
15 A. No, sir.
16 Q. Or that you would find her and you knew where she
17 worked?
18 A. No, sir.
19 Q. Have you ever called her at work in the last year?
20 A. No, .sir.
21 Q. Have you ever called her on her cell phone?
22 MR. JONES: Your Honor, I'm going to object.
23 That goes outside the scope, Your Honor, from the pleadings. """"I
24 mean, we're fishing at this point.
~q)5~==========~T=H=E==C=OU=R=T=:===S=u=st=a=i=n=e=d=.========================:d
JILL FRIEDRICHS
Official Court Reporter
412th Judicial District Court
29
1r---------~--~~M~R-.~S~T~R~I~C~K~L~I~N~:--~Y~o-u-r~H~o-n-o~r-,~I--p_a_s_s__t~h-e--w~i~t-n_e_s_s--.--~
2 REDIRECT. EXAMINATION
3 BY MR. JONES:
4 Q. You said you saw this order on February 14th, sir?
5 A. I actually had just gotten off from work. ,
6 Q. The 14th the correct date, sir?
7 A. Correct. I was served that.
8 Q. Okay. But this final order wasn't issued until
9 February 24th. So you were not at th~ final hearing, correct?
10 A. No, sir.
11 Q. And you never -- you received a copy of the petition
12 but you never received a ·copy of this final order, did you,
r 13 sir?
14 A. No.
15 Q. Okay. So you had a petition and not the order?
16 A. That's correct.
17 MR. JONES: Pass the witness.
18 RBCROSS-EXAMINATIO~ _.
19 BY MR. STRICKLIN:
20 Q. Did you have an opportunity to show up at that
21 hearing?
22 A. If I was, I wasn't aware of it.
23 Q. Okay. Well, you certainly got the petition, didn't
24 you?
., 25 A. Eventually, yes .
r-('7)
JILL FRIEDRICHS
Official Court Reporter
412th Judicial District Court
30
r 1
2
Q.
A.
Well, you got it in February of 2009, right?
Yes, sir.
3 Q. Did you contact -- and I don't remember the date.
4 A. It was February 14th.
5 Q. Did you contact any legal counsel for the purposes of
6 that hearing?
7 A. No, sir, I didn't.
8 Q. Did you contact the Court or the District Clerk or
.9 anybody to figure out when you -- what you needed to do or what
10 you needed to show up to?
11 A. It's basically what's in here. That's all lies.
12 Q. And you could have gone to that hearing and told the
13 Court that at that time, couldn't you have?
14 A. Yeah. Yeah, I could have.
15 Q. But you didn't?
16 A. No.
17 MR. STRICKLIN: Pass the witness.
18 MR. JONES: Nothing further-of-thi~ witness, Your
19 Honor.
20 THE COURT: Do you have any objections if I ask a
21 question?
22 MR. JONES: No, Your Honor.
23 THE COURT: Mr. O'Grady, did I understand you to
24 say that you did not know that your ex-wife, although she was
25 still your wife at that time, was living with her mother?
~ ('])
11 JILL FRIEDRICHS
£Kii; R> Tr G 11 34 Pa5 · Official Court Reporter
;;ttj rT} ?:> L{ 412th Judicial District Court
31
1r---------------T;uH~E~D~E~F~E~N~D~A~NMT~:~~I~w7a~s~n~'t~a~w~a~r-e~t~h-a~t~s~h_e__w_a_s-.------~
2 THE COURT: Can you explain then you admitted
3 you called the house asking for Macy, correct?
4 THE DEFENDANT: Yes. I called to speak with
5 Macy, my daughter.
6 THE COURT: I mean Macy.
7 THE DEFENDANT: Yes.
8 THE COURT: Why did you call that house to speak
9 with her if you didn't know your wife was living there?
10 THE DEFENDANT: Because ·that's the last known
11 place that I knew that Macy might be.
12 THE COURT: Any follow-up?
13 MR. STRICKLIN: No, Your Honor.
14 MR. JONES: I would just like the Court to take
. 15 judicial notice that in a protective order a respondent is not
16 entitled to representation under Texas law, since it's only
17 a -- is not even a criminal proceeding. It's a civil
18 proceeding. So that if he appears he'llcbe repre~enting
19 himself pro se, unless he can afford an attorney. So it's an
20 unusual critter in the Texas law that you have criminal
21 consequences, but you're not entitled to an attorney.
22 THE COURT: All right. The Court will~take
23 notice of that.
24 Thank you, Mr~ O'Grady. You may step down.
25 All right. After hearing the evidence I'm going
~ ('7)
JILL FRIEDRICHS
Official Court Reporter
412th Judicial District Court
'\I 32
· 1 to find that the bail is insufficient. I'm going revoke bail,
2 set bail at $45,000, plus additional conditions of bail.
3 The additional conditions of bail are that upon
4 release, Defendant will report to the bond supervision officer
5 within three hours. You will not be released on a weekend or
6 when you cannot arrive at the bond supervision officer within
7 three hours. Have no contact with Amye O'Grady or any member
8 of her family, including Johnnie Lewis. You'll have a curfew.
9 I'll have to find where your house is. You're to remain there
10 at all times except when going directly to and from work.
11 Mr. Jones, I'll ask you to get me what his
12 residence is.
13 While out on bail you're not to commit an offense
r 14 against the laws of this state or any other state. You will
15 obtain and procure and pay all monitoring fees for an
16 electronic monitoring device from the Brazoria County Probation
17 Department and keep it on at all times.
18 Mr. Jones, I'm going to as~_you to go over these
19 conditions of bail with your client and additional conditions.
20 If you have any questions about them I'll clarify them. If
21 not, I need your client and you to sign and acknowledge you
22 have seen them~ And you need to fill in where his address will
23 be.
24 (Discussion off the record.)
25 THE COURT: All right. Mr. Jones, this appears
~
G )1}JJ-4 iif ~t(, '1 JILL FRIEDRICHS
Official Court Reporter
412th Judicial District Court
i__ )
33
/··,
1 to bear your signature and your c Does he
2 have any questions about the terms of bail?
3 MR. JONES: I do not believe so, Your Honor. He
4 does not.
5 \ THE COURT: I think we're set for trial on this
6 on September 8th; is that correct?
7 MR. STRICKLIN: Yes, Your Honor.
8 THE COURT: All right. Anything further from the
9 State?
10 MR. STRICKLIN: No, Your Honor.
11 THE COURT: Anything further from the defense?
12 MR. JONES: No, Your Honor.
13 THE COURT: Thank you. You're excused.
f 14 (Proceedings concluded.)
15
16 (r?)
£Kf/;~;f G '1 j q PfJ5
17 11
J
18
19
21
22 ~
23
24
25
JILL FRIEDRICHS
Official Court Reporter
412th Judicial District Court
1 TH
COUNTY
I; Jill Friedrichsj Gfficie1i Court Reportc=r, in ami
3 for the 412th District Court of Brazoria County/ State of
Texc:ts 1 db heteby certify th~t: the above C~,nd: :fqregqing' C::Of!tcdns
4 a true and correct tre>nscription o:f all portions of E;:Vidence
and other proceedings reque$teq ,tn writing by coun_sel for the
5 parties- tobe inclUded in the 'Jolume o'f the Repe,rter's Record,
in the above-styled -and num~ered cause, all of w_hich occurred
6 in open court or in chambers and wen~ reported by me.
. ~
7 Ifurther certify th~t this ~'eporter 1 s ({ec(:):r-d of the
proceedings tru-ly and correqtiy reflects the exhibit-s, if any,
8 admitt~ed by thE: respect:l ve 8art'j.es.
"i
:t further _certify #hat the :total cpst for the
preparation of the original tand one copy of the, Reporter's
10 ~~~i.6<~~ r~l?\,Q -~~ and :wajs paiq/w,il1 be paid by
11,
3 § IN nn::DisTRJcr comn
. STA'd:OFTE¥8 § OF BRAZoRIA COUNTY, TEXAS
vs. §
• E)I1At-Je IJ'YY'()'ft. 06rto. ~'/ ~"/'';-:;,,__ ·§
CHARGE: &:; '1 n P.}t>.-n!,:fl O:t>&;.. T~:f?i},t?r"::!1~ J .......... ~ J.J.~Pf 8~5-.t•••" • .
-.,_.ve .•
[ ~ Defendant JS prohibtted from. commurucatmg through any means,. mcluding verbal, written; electronic, another person or 11-.v'.
otherwise; with A ~e. Ot~ ir.. ... I)>J . On. f.l~v mem IJe.fL of ht..t ~I~ ~ ci}Q z4
7 I .. -p-= . :
I ~o~.ue- (eMs
[XJ Defendant is prohibited "from going within. 500 feet of the residence, _place of employment, school or person of
. A""''(€. Q'C.rtP>d'l Q~~~eb.kv~,~~cfg'~ 1 !ld"~=~
[V] Defendant bas a cl,lffew and shall remain at U 0 (,? ll"-~.. $1 , 1....1'-S'l(..;)\,.J.,./114,'!): ,
--,--...,-----""7'""County, Texas, b ~ ,___ .J.o ~
" ~ ~ (!A-~ J___,. L
~ .o/( v '
~- /(141714'/IJ£
...._
"/ ~ Jl,.,/1~
- ntJ,,_.,f)
.,.I
,
IAA
.
••. , .............. J.<'. --
-·· . --·-···- - -- o .~
8\A. e-~ we;· d~.
I
· ~ ~~ ...;,~-~.r)· .j{) <;,...J: ,"; '""':. ... .... -·..)(}_~-)
V (I
.~ t/
tJ~"· '1·-~~ -~ ..,.,~--~~~~ 1. 1{)- el)~ ~
• I
o.M.I_A T T r .... ..
5.J.....1'";.) h.~,. . J(}(A.~ /.' OL&-): \0·. ~ ~-;}-; ).S-. "' - ~JJ ... :J.:3o-
A
II
- . - . I .lJ I
Jilt 01""· ,o,,•..:-r...... "'" ~ tJOLA.J~ ~~ 3:oo Ptn- ~ ~ 3. 31:>- ~ ~~,.:. ~
I L
t'f_ZZI~
11/?J.
v {~ ...~-
A
~ 't :oa,
- 1J
~~-•A .
-
I
r ..o.-c.,
4
s~ frv ~- .~ ~~; A pP~..__.tJA t1Pi ~--t- /~ -
•
- r '
II
fJ ~
S-m:fV ~A~---~ ~-~" 5~
. -' c,.e. ..... oeA ,./2.,..4
I
Cf,'/1) ,· ,.JQ.~~
,
..
, -- ~
(/_
..,_-- 1
-"'I
~ ... ~~(.~ '1.'12; 5Ttil:i_,~ ~J..- 1o:..3o t..·- ;....J
,7
tkjAI../J'Aa:J:;-q; 3 p~_.o I A.. ~
l1
l 19 : '"\ :;' ·, I • . ~();4 .. ~ VYl/L- ~ A~• t~~ .-r~ .0 j &...;t
f
l i ..
T
-4!. - 411!:1
, ,
~ 0~ ~ ~~ aa;-~ • ~ ~ ,__.) ~a:k
0,...0 ~ s .k~-r;,_
--
' ' {l:oo~-~~ /J; 1'1; C"J- 11 =,s- n..v ~ _ reQ__)I. ; ll·:so~a/1-
lfJVJ.M ~ I Ptn · \\~ h~~-~ oUt S17&D ~+c. ·J; l !I)S' oY:
--
A~ ~H ~ orol.~- .. .. 1 ·• -1 • ~.
'1>-f'i: /:2. 3 .
11 ;_a_a:t
..... Ll ,.,..o ~.... &CkA::> u.
I I
-- r
0£21. .... -~ 1".v I;~~- ~-C.)£4 .A~~ 5P~~t ~ . .L_ _J:l. 4; ~-cK-~
\J II I ......-,
U7 I f . (/JI
lluu4 UAd:d I: tiS""- ~ ~ ro P~.u~~, ct ~-.
. I
1:3o- 6 tl..t.4 4<7
(qJ LA...O ~.,, -g;-~ ~· .~ l..,.u~ _aA Z{J-;).. -e..,- ~ .f-,:
/J.~ /}£
............ ff
IJ .C' ~ ;,2-f - -
-~ ·"' . ;.:::,
L ~ "Jl,;.l., • . ~ -;r
---.:z:·~ .. . -- ~~ ~->£-A t, ~ "t :>~~ C)U
~~~,.·~-~ ..... ··-,~~-
• - 7 .' I C.., • A • - J I
~.
.._·J.I,J? l] - '
!::» , .::-J- , tl
~ t:lfl/' h·~~-h~ ~~~.Wk.- .3:J-l j ~ (U.A«<..Iu.4«..~(/.
~: ~.•• : ....-b~~ ~~~ -rll.<4-TO~- ~.•. ~
fJv· ,!!~ ~ 0~5-.d<.>~;.t.... (Ui.lu i 'ffo:t:; 4:34," STMe Res-rS ;.J. D>)M~--~;
•.
626327 ·CRIMINAL DOCKET Case No. 58863
Number of Case NAMES OF PARTIES ATTORNEYS OFFENSE I DATE OF FILING
58863 AGGRAVATED
STATE OF TEXAS JERI VENNE State 1 I 22 I 2009
ASSAULT- ENHANCED I
412th DISTRI<;T Indictment or Information and
VS.
COURT I Complaint
SHANE TIMOTHY
I MARK B. JONES Deft. I JP#H080207
O'GRADY
DATE OF ORDERS ORDERS OF COURT PROCESS
~
-~~~- ~~
~k~
~
~ ~rl.hA
i\u,V-r~ ~ ~ ~
·~· =. "<~~-:...
m- toz.IQ527
(:)
,.,,iJ'··
• • 1.... \..J.
CRIMINAL DOCKET Case No. 58863 ~·-!
.--~------------------------------------------------------------------~----------------------------------- ~~
. Number of Case NAMES OF PARTIES ATTORNEYS OFFENSE· :~ DATE OF FILING
58863 AGGRAVATED ASSAULT-
412th DISTRICT
STATE OF TEXAS JERIYENNE State
ENHANCED
1
I 22
I
Indictment or Information and
2009
COURT
vs. Complaint
..
Shane Timothy O'Grady Deft. JP#H080207 _:l
DATE OF ORDERS ORDERS OF COURT PROCESS
01/22109 Indictment Filed 0
01/22/09 Bond Set At $25,000.00
02/03/09 Notice to Def't and Bondsman
..
3·h'1S \ IO'i ~
v
{)r... 0..
V
-l-c..-'-4
' I
- (AJ-(..I..,l k . ,.tt
VV
r'I_.,.,.J I
I
y. I 2-009
.
~ ~ .... "' " ,
.
~ ~ /r, ,..,_.;. '~ A.p...:..Q 2.'l; -zoocr · wrL!w~ -~ ~t .., ~~
v
-
.e4. ~ .4~-tt: :> ~ ~~
v . ~
8/'l~loi . L. ~ Irk.~ ,jp. ~ 4-f I 1-n,ut.~.o ~~
v
. ~ ~~:..
I
,(). Ud.iJ j CJo....., o...
v
.~A;
l
j ~ ~ Q~ ~ ... ~tJ/~ ~ 0 dlu,...,._; ~J .,M.L-.h
'·
~ -~ · A-Ct ba.J..a% 45;.ooc ;:RA.u;~_b;t;:;..,...r:.J c_o,.-Jl.t1:i::;-~ ~ ~.. 1/prj; &?A'
{?AI'- Cof.l.,.h',",_
..-.ol"lAL.C, ~~
.. _ --·- ~...,..-.+n
..- __ _ _ fje .1'2.1'-/...il>~
·- . -:-- ___ _ D+J 4) "A' ,fl (9.-v
W~ht-~~-~·~~~~~~
(CZ) s.b ~·'"-JE i\ND COURT COSTS
ARE NOT PAID IN FULL THAT DAY.
PLJi:ASE BE PREPARED FOR THE POSSIBILITY THAT YOU MAY BEL\ COVRT PROCEEDINGS ALLDAY.
Joyce Hudman, County Clerk
Brazori'
9 THE COURT: You may be seated.
10 The record will reflect that counsel fot the
11 State, counsel for the Defendant, the Defendant and the jury '
12 are all seated.
13 Mr. Beveridge, has the jury reached a verd:ict · on
14 punishment?
15 PRESIDING JUROR: Yes, sir.
16 THE COURT: Wa~ it unanimous?
17 PRESIDING JUROR: Yes, sir.
18 THE COURT: Would you hand-the verdict form to
19 the bailiff, please?
20 Mr. O'Grady, would you please stand?
21 "Verdict: We, the jury, having found the
-~....
22 Defendant, Shane Timothy O'Grady, guilty of the offense of _
23 Aggravated Assault, do further find that the said Defendant is
24 the same person who, prior to the commission of that offense,
of a felony offense as alleged in the
JILL FRIEDRICHS
Official Court Reporter
412th Judicial District Court
38
1 enhancement allegation, and we assess his punishment at
2 confinement in the penitentiary for 30 years, said term being
3 life or not more than 99 years nor less than 5 years. We
4 further assess a fine of zero dollars, this being an amount of
5 not more than $10,000." And it's signed by Mr. Beveridge as
6 presiding juror.
7 Do you wish to have the jury polled?
8 MR. JONES: I do not, Your Honor.
9 THE COURT: Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, I
10 have received and I accept your verdict._
11 You may be seated, Mr. O'Grady.
12 That brings to a close your involvement in this
13 case. I want to thank you as the attorneys have thanked you
14 for your diligence, for your long hours and for sitting on this
15 jury. You've heard it said that this doesn't function without
16 people like you. We thank you for your service.
17 I had previously told you that you're not to
18 discuss the case with anyone. You're p~if~ctiy free to discuss
19 the case with anyone you wish. Sometimes the attoxneys may
20 want to ask questions of what did we do good, what could we
21 have done better. You are perfectly free to discuss it with
22 them if you want. You're also perfectly free to t.ell them y~Q.u
23 do not want to talk about it. And I know the attorneys and if
24 you tell them that, they will honor that. If for some reason
25 they don't, let me know and we'll make sure that gets honored.
• • - /i,~
€K~1& f.'/y~,~,=q~~=~=~==============================================~
1
JILL FRIEDRICHS
fs, ?? o~ 9 Official Court Reporter
412th JudiGial District Court
\
39
1 In a few weeks you'll get a ~heck from the Corinty
2 to pay you for your service. You heard me say yesterday you
3 get $10 for yesterday and $40 for today, which is a pittance;
4 but that's what the legislature tells the County we can pay
5 you. So that's what the County pays.
6 If you would leave your badges on the bench
7 there, on the rail there, your ·notes you can leave here.
8 Mr. Kent will make sure those notes are shredded. And get yqur
9 personal items. If anything is left in the jury room feel free
10 to get that.
11 If you need something to show that you have been
12 here for these two days, Elaina will b~ out in the hall and
13 will give that to you on your way out. Thank you again for
14 your service. I wish you a good, safe trip home and you are
15 excused.
16 (Jury out.)
17 THE COURT: All right. The record will reflect
18 that counsel for the State, counsel for'· the· Defendant, the
19 Defendant are all present. The jury has been. excused.
20 Mr. O'Grady, would you please stand?
21 Mr. O'Grady, you came.before this Court and pled
·~r
22 not guilty to the offense of Aggravated Assault. She jury '!'.c...,"-:-
23 found you guilty of that offense. You then entered a plea of
24 true to the enhancement allegation, and the jury assessed your
25 punishment at 30 years in the Institutional Division of the
J-
JILL FRIEDRICHS
fs- if o1 9 Official Court Reporter
412th Judicial District Court
40
1 Texas Department of Criminal Justice and no fine to ·be asse~sed
2 against you. i..{J21Ji jJ()U. Z/lJ J
.
3 It is the judgment of this Court that the
4 enhancement allegations are true and that you are guilty in
5 Cause Number 58863 of the offense of Aggravated Assault as
6 alleged ih the indictment and that you be punished in
7 accordance with the jury's verdict.
8 Is there anything that you wish to say before the
9 Court pronounces punishment?
10 THE DEFENDANT: No, sir.
11 THE COURT: All right. Mr. O'Grady, having
12 nothing to say, it's the order-of this Court, having been found
13 guilty of the offense of Aggravated Assault, and punishment
14 assessed at 30 years, I hereby deliver you to the Sheriff of
15 Brazoria County for transportation to the proper unit of the
16 Institutional Division of the Texas Department of Criminal
17 Justice where you will be confined for a period of 30 years.in
·18 accordance with the laws governing the Texas Department of
19 Criminal Justice Institutional Division.
20 I note that you have credit for 99 days for time
21 served. That will be noted on the docket.
22 I do need to advise you that you do .. have a rig.l},t
23 to appeal. Should you be without funds to hire an attorney,
24 I 1 il provide one for you to assist you; and should you be
{!~J 25 without funds to pay for a transcript, I'll provide one for
- 3.-
JILL FRIEDRICHS
Official Court Reporter
412th Judicial District Court
41
1 you. Do you understand you have tho9e~, rights?
'<.} "0
2 THE DEFENDANT:- Yes, sir.
3 THE COURT: Anything from the defense?
4 MR. JONES: No, Your Honor.
5 THE COURT: Anything from the State?
6 MR. STRICKLIN: No,. Your Honor.
7 THE COURT: Thank you very much. You are
8 excused.
9 (Proceedings adjourned.)
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
&~) 25 ;' J.-
G%11:/IJif' -116./111===='17'=a==,~A~p;=s=.==========================~
-- JILL FRIEDRICHS
Official Court Reporter
412th Judicial District Court
i
I
~/.
133
1 and the members of the jury. We will -- the bailiff widl show
2 you how to run the tape. The volume should be up here. I have
3 it the same as I had it when you were listening to it during
4 the courtroom. If you need it further feel free to come around
5 here. There is a thing that says "master volume". You can
6 turn it up or down on that master volume switch. As soon as
7 Mr. Kent shows you how to operate it he will stand outside the
8 door to the courtroom. When you are finished just knock on the
9 door, let him know that you're going to go back into the jury
10 room. Then he will come back into the courtroom.
11 At this time would everybody please leave the
12 courtroom?
13 to
14 tape.)
15 THE COURT: All right. Let's get the jury back
16 in the jury box.
17 (Jury in.)
18 THE COURT: You may be seated.
19 The record will reflect that counsel for the
20 State, counsel for the Defendant, the Defendant and the jury
21 are all present and seate~ in the courtroom.
22 Mr. Beveridge, I understand the jury- has reache-d
23 a verdict in this case?
24 PRESIDING JUROR: Yes, sir.
25 ~THE COURT: Was your verdict unanimous?
... ~ ~·
JILL FRIEDRICHS
Official Court Reporter
412th Judicial District Court
I
I
134
1 PRESIDING JUROR: Yes, sir.
2 THE COURT: Would you hand the verdict form to
3 the bailiff, please?
4 Mr. O'Grady, would you please stand.
5 "The State of Texas versus Shane Timothy O'Grady.
6 Verdict: We, the jury, find the Defendant, Shane Timothy
7 O'Grady, guilty of the offense of Aggravated Assault as charged
8 in the indictment." Signed by Mr. Beveridge as presiding
9 juror.
10 Do you wish to have the jury polled?
11 MR. JONES: No, Your Honor.
12 THE COURT: Thank you. You may be seated.
13 Is the State ready to proceed?
14 MR. STRICKLIN: Your Honor, .if you could giv~ the
15 State five minutes to talk with the witnesses?
16 THE COURT: All right. Do y'all want to approach
17 a minute?
18 (Discussion off the record.)
19 THE COURT: All right. Ladies and gentlemen, I·
20 was talking to the attorneys about the length of what they
21 anticipate the punishment phase would be. We thin~, that
·.;~t
22 probably it .will take about an hour to get the evidence in arrd
23 get the charge to you for you to deliberate. That will make it
24 like 10 after 5:00. At that point in time we're on your clock.
25 If you would like to
..We;__ will stay as long as you want to stay .
JILL FRIEDRICHS
Official Court Reporter
412th Judicial District Court
135
1 go into the jury room for just a minute and see if y'all want
2 to recess for today and start at 9:00 o'clock in the morning we
3 can do that. Or if you want to go ahead and go this evening
4 we'll kind of go whichever way you would prefer to go. But
5 that's kind of the time constraint we would be under. So if
6 you want to step down and go into the jury room for just a
7 minute and y'all can talk about whether you want to continue to
8 go this afternoon or whether you want to start tip first thing
9 in the morning. So if you'll step down into the jury room I'll
10 let y'all decide which way you want to go_and then we'll
11 proceed accordingly.
12 (Jury out.)
13 (Guilt/Innocent portion concluded.)
14
r 15
I
16
17
18
,.:;.__
'I 19
f.
20 Exf/l!3if ''m ''
23
24 .
25
JILL FRIEDRICHS
·-- Official Court Reporter
412th Judicial District Court
---.... ..,/ -
.;.
SIJ
626327
CAUSE NO. 58863
THE STATE OF TEXAS * IN THE DISTRICT COURT
*
VS. * OF BRAZORIA COUNTY, TEXAS
*
SHANE TIMOTHY O'GRADY * 23_Ro JUDICIAL DISTRICT
/And on this the 2ND day of NOVEMBER, 2009, came on the fonnation of the jury
and from the regular panel for the week the following named persons, viz: v
MARILYN BELL . BERNARD PAVLAS
EMMA PENA MATTHEW PETWAY
NORMAN BEVERIDGE MANUEL CASACLANG
JOYCE HEINRICH MARSHA WILEY
CLAUDIA LEJEUNE BRYAN HEBERT
JOSEPH WILKINSON SEANTOVES
,_
J/ were duly selected, impaneled and sworn as the Jury for the trial of the above
numbered and entitled cause.
DC JURY PANEL FORM -15209
0065
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ::--::--'"-----·- ---:; ·:;: ::::.~-, :_::_:_:._:._:_:---=--=-::__:: - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
BRAZORIA COUNTY / ___ / JURY SELECTION SYSTEM -- '--~ PAGE 1
;> · Panel Name: 11/02/0·9/412 -~~-}.
-;~_, "· Court Date: 11/02/09 · '"-_J
..:::-9a s e : JUDGE_DENM.N:{;_12.:_4.5.P.M_CR IM INAL___j ..
------------------ -.- -...:._~----~--:- :.... -:-:--_-------------..:---------------------- ---------
Name ... , . . . . . . . . . . . . . ."-.. . . Juror #
41-_;R~OQ.lD~C;.JK~~~.. -ID*~t!Jl~tli.Y~NfEE~EA~'T'~OB'lltt-~----r166"'1~0o- COJ.l~
"•/;)
BRENDA SUI!: SHAI1~R :32~ St-
MARILYN BELL 22
A.:WGELl\ MARIE WILSON 1346 Sf.
BERNARD ALFRED PAVLAS 1297
'"'6· SI:IIWNOW L~~ ·IOI:Il\JSTON i!S? _$\-
_.,""'!,....._-_.,.CAR"""''T"'QrrL"'Oy'TNr-"''CMAR~rrt""':E~RI'T'0n::Bnt"FJNI't!S7'iQil:iNr---Tl'rTU-rl-,-/ ClUL ~
-·~6---'f'f'P.Orf'lrlr'l"l:O~:R..,.I"'f'C~M~ltR:rR-f'D~ALrfTFlB~R"fi'J!!~C'MM'"f''f'~--~/7f'472 C_tt.u~
-:::l2~~pe:s::~I:liln:as:;a''"5 =ati:lit=e:!f:e~r=aai=in*'e~t!BP!Hae:lfRt::::===~4c'l:'!5~; A, 5t
...,l:""'O,.-.__,..Q'1:1F.l"'I'E'T':L~S~E-nJ-\_,:R..,~~NmEA~~Bi'R'ET"C"'I'J:\:"11'~1tR:----"''-'7"'~-'7~6- C£Lu_ ~
....;;L~l;J.----1R~O~BB-lE~R~TT:SS"Il"E~PP1H[!J1EI!:'llr:r'l""'1E~SS'1C~O:JIB:TIARiiTf--E6~4r44 CcLu-~
---~i..;2~--.-'fil~mmrr HFPbJ:Al>ij)FZ 727 ·.A
,~~~~~~~!~I~~R~K±L~Y~MNDNI~lW1~l~L~L~I~~---------4~e~~~~
(\@ JOYCE ANN HEINRICH 1316
~ MARSHA LABAY WILEY 998
-3~~-~.~~~K..r:/Jl"z:..~R:-E:'SiNH~.~~il;t.~J~E--iiiiAAU~J'!FI:r.Hl-:t:-ItiERR------:1~2~4"'6rt C!.a..u-s.e.__,
~~~d~~B~R~B~liD~A~S~I•I~I~l~H~Hil~N~E~S~------~9~~ ~
q@ CLAUDIA ELAINE LEJEUNE 1340
~~~~--~9~E~R~6~IftOT;A~t·*'O~l~~~~·~~~Y~0~~~------~~~6~~c:Qlu_~
~g~-~~KM~RtM~~~~R~S~O~t~4t*4BHRr-----------~~~AHl ~QUUL~
~ S'fl! 11EN 'W RELSEY 556• .A
P}':IGB 'btl}'&l!i P&RR¥ 1252 .. .A
69 d'ESUS ALVARADO 956 .A
\~ BRYAN HOWARD HEBERT 1302
\\ U) JOSEPH IV WILKINSON 1247
(j,fJ) SEAN CHRISTOPHER TOVES 835
43 SHARON GARCIA HEBERT 1134
44 CAFQJ.YN :E!ONK~J LEUig se-6 A
45 AMANDA MENDEZ URIBE 428
46 CASI E LYNN PUR YEAR 1282
(;sJ
47 ROBERT MELINDER 775
GitJ;~/T
11
A/_I/
48 AMBER LEIGH MCDANIEL 4,37
49 WILLIAM WESLEY FORD 31
~55"0'0--il~EA:I~R~b~Y~·....J~O;l...JFS:CO~S~T~EUR~------·~"/~64 c. ttu_ ~
51 CLARA MAY LESHIKAR 857
52 SUSAN MCCASLAND POPE 1055
0057
-----------------------------------------------------------------.-----------
BRAZORIA COUNTY JURY SELECTION SYSTEM PAGE 3
Panel Name: 11/02/091412
Court Date: 11/02/09
Case: JUDGE DENMAN; 12:45PM CRIMINAL
Name . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Juror tt
53 EDWIN JOSEPH SORINA 1152
54 MARY DILBERT GREENWOOD 615
55 MACDONALD ANEGBODE AKHEIT 582
UAME
56 JILL HAGEN OLSON 1208
57 RYAN CHRISTOPHER TONEY 1341
58 JIMMIE LEBLANC SPICER 1311
59 MARQUETTA G DAVIS 1339
60 .AYODELE OLUBUNMI ONI 580
61 GARNER WAYNE LAMBERT 242
62 SHINY JOSEPH 1281
63 DEVIN ANDREW OWENS 68
64 LAURA FERGUSON GALINDO 862
·65 EZEQUIEL SOSA 762
66 FREDDIE JOE SCOTT 1102
~ > :RILl!::t BRADFoRD WE~'T 134'7 Qa..u...~
68 SHAUNDELYNN RUSHCELL BRIG 1326
HT ...
·,;.
70 CIRO ARMANDO BENITEZ 200 /~);) J "{} c ll II J AI
IG-A.I'flr.JJT IV
71 NANCI LEA GLOVER 60
72. SALVACION BONUEL MITRA 309
72 record~ listed.
0058
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -.- - - - (-'- -· ~:~..-:.. ~:: :.:~-:J.:: -: ...;_~~-:.··-- ·.~---~. --- - - - -.- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
BRAZORIA COUNTY , ,_----.JURY-: sErLECTION SY~STEM · .. ·' . ] PAGE 1
<..:- Panel Name: ""11 I 02/0:91412 )'~.7"·:_..0
r?J' Court Date: 11/02/09 ~~~-·> -
e,.C__gs.e_: JUDGE DE~ 12 : 4 5 PM CRIMINAL -,"::.':>
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -~-...;..~....~~r--...·~~··:... ~-:.. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Name . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Juror ff
1 ...-ReeSER t)W.~='/!n!i i:.'li~W ~9~9- ('(.
2
3
.EREHfflt SUE o9HAt1!::R:
MARILYN BELL
326
22
s-+
4 J;!NG'fi::bh HMtiE WILSON 1346 '"Sr.
5 BERNARD ALFRED PAVLAS 1297
6 SHANNOW bEE JOHNS"fOl~ 2::~3'1 -s+-
7 CJ\RObYn tp,RlE ROBHJSOH 1 Q-3:'1 <:.c
8 TOQD RICHARD ~KECtiT '14-2 cc
9
--::
_ffiHieK'~ l'HCOLE BONNER 4~5 s.r-
10 CHEL3E:A REtJEbl\ DECKER '178 Cc
644 (<:
11
·- FOBERT £T~PWEN ge;COBAR
12 -uM~CY POLl( SH1C 1 ETARY 692 ... C..c
13 EMMA PENA 718
14 SAliDR:"t HARE P;K!CE 1:678
51-
15 MARCIA ROLOF MITCHELL 1298
16 MARIA GUADALUl'E BARRIOS 641 ~+-
17 STEPHANIE MARIE BALLARD 853
18 MATTHEW TIMOTHY PETWAY 1191
19 S'fEf'HJ!dHE LiNN POTISEK 1337 cc.
BXlUJ!'I J:EJ.tQW H*bb B;J,Z! - ~-r
20
21 ~HENRY HILES 'FOllE'J.' 470 ~t-
22 NORMAN ERWIN BEVERIDGE 536
23 ·M!-WIS ,JOSFPW £T:Z\NKO. 3~7 ~
24 MANUEL I CASACLANG 198
25 WRENA ELIZABE'l'H OLAGUE 468 CC-
26 TINA MARIE DORN 1060
\ 0062
~~~~;i~-~~~~~--------------~~-s~~~~~i~~-s~sT~~-----------------~~~~----;
Panel Name: ll/02/09"I4T2------::::>
court Date: ll/02'to·g~
~-:~G_E-DENMAN:;, 12 : 4 5 PM CRIMINAL
--~-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Juror #
27. M~RY JAWE OOORIS ""187 :)-j-
28 NOE LARA HERNANDEZ 727
<9,.-~K:TI'AMiBB:EE~Jti:;L-:Y.f~Jtl~ffftlif--i-_~
~-court Date: 11/02/09 ".:-----;-_....)
. ~-:~~~;~1!"1 CRIMINAl:'--~-:-,
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - --- - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - .. - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Name . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Juror #
53 EDWIN JOSEPH SORINA 1152
54 MARY DILBERT GREENWOOD 615
55 MACDONALD ANEGBODE AKHEIT 582
UAME
56 JILL HAGEN OLSON 1208
57 RYAN CHRISTOPHER TONEY 1341
58 JIMMIE LEBLANC SPICER 1311
59 MARQUETTA G'DAVIS 1339
60 AYODELE OLUBUNMI ONI 580
61 GARNER WAYNE LAMBERT 242
62 SHINY JOSEPH 1281
63 DEVIN ANDREW OWENS 68
64 LAURA FERGUSON GALINDO 862
65 EZEQUIEL SOSA 762
66 FREDDIE JOE SCOTT 1102
~-1,. L1:"£"11ry"""""BRAbn"7r~F"0""R"D----r:rw"C'£t::!Srr1'r------,-l"'T7f34 7 Ct:_
68 SHAUNDELYNN RUSHCELL BRIG 1326
HT (15)
' ()" IIA J 1)
t;;X/1.P;>!f" fV .
200
70
71
CIRO ARMANDO BENITEZ
NANCI LEA GLOVER 60
p3 . IQ o1 10
72 SALVACION BONUEL MITRA 309
72 records listed.
~~~~~i~- c~~~~-- --- -;~-.~~---r~ ~~r=-~~~~~~~f~,-~-~~-~ir~-~ ~-=~~- -------- --~~~;--- -~
_"-. Court Date: 11/02/09 = ,_-1__
c::_s~~NMAN; 12: 45PM CRIMJ}1AL~
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Juror #
-±- RODGER DWAYNE EATON 1070
2 BRENDA SUE SHAVER 326
3 MARILYN BELL 22
4 ANGELA MARIE WILSON 1346
5 BERNARD ALFRED PAVLAS 1297
at 6.~ 0 ~~ ~~- ~
6 SHANNON LEE JOHNSTON 257
NOV 02 2009
~ CAROLYN MARIE ROBINSON 1017
- JERRY DEERE
~ TODD RICHARD ALBRECHT 742 ......
sv· _____
"""• . - _ ca. ~
ot Oli1J1ct Court Brazoita
.DEPUT!
495~
~ CHELSEA RENEA BECKER 778
~ ROBERT STEPHEN ESCOBAR 644
~ NANCY POLK SINGLETARY 692
13 EMMA PENA 718
l2 7 i 'l.
lS PtAR:CI:l\ ItO:tiOP f>U'f'Ci!Bbb 1:2:~~ :1
16 MARIA GUADALUPE BARRIOS 641
C'PBPih":dli:B tO'grady, Shane Timothy
Combined Opinion