Z§{ Q)ZY
y IN H\€
T€XMR+ mo CA;m;/~r;;l A M(S
_3+_/5_1¢§_+_1`_/4_ PP
` Thls document contains some
pages that are of poor qua\'\ty
at the time of imaging.
‘ .JQ faa Siacv L. COA/N£)Q, §
_ v R&la+o/{, » §
V:L § CB.MNM»»&R»
7 D‘;er/z‘cc)L Coum*. @‘P APPP,;;-fs, § . .
R&SPM&M+_ _ § coum§§g§+lrxl§g_|§wms
SEP 1 0 2015
Awmm,€¥e@<
Mé ¢fc`#/+§%LM@
w h g ama +O\\JS. RE:S+M, n m JLM-£A(+,»,LM y
33 R§Q;R:ju:m§fs '%`lns/Q/#mfz’¢ M¢+zm 100/a l.£a»/£ 04" C"W,Q+ "
ama 72 Ol‘( "£xas Rule$ mo App£!la+£ PAoceAuR£ Rul£g£ 20 l
.l)! 314 sN SUPPOR`|' o`? Woulel S]!\QW Ht£ polfowe`/J& `-) § j
` I.
lp\<£!a}'c>£v 29 by 3 ‘
§ ` l 9 V£RY R£€)'SO/\/Zl)/£' 018 'l~, ~’l'¢b w n
1~01¢&9~% Cas aHas+€cl h 1>\/ +L\e accomp:a:v/:A& /X¥$M;a/:U+{>
ha ‘ ~ ='
` 13 a /JYMM, u/~lsclawl£d 0/2 fau&l/n“m /H»)/,whos`££l<$
-l_
. asher §`kom:+lz;s R£~O»m£d §a%ak£cp€& mo "|”¢‘><33 »m:spwol@,icgp
oNl'{ as 3 ian R£¢Soml, asz€»Q "FMS+ a++mp'kw£r anal ex'l?mus¥m‘& all
0+}1£)9 R£M£cli£.g M<`>'Ol£ Bvéli`/Jlol€ ?Lo }'NM~~\\F{ OlOs'i\/& SO,R&\EP{'DR
asks )DM 111/ns C"vu/hl’s `l;lc)£/{alhl\/ and Pa'h'¢wc£'; +Lud* lam
pa}.~+;m be Reez:;~¢@@l m all Haw@s ('a»cd vrew£d)_m{ as ;+;-3;
+O las cx¢;us£@l P¢>R amf pfaws on ;m|pa.ln("ec{io»l m paos£,'&m,ok kha+o£;c..
BRSW€.R v, CoH?’A/S, 857 S.W. 23'81?_, 8215._,4 pko 96 I',~rma+£$$
Pe+z+;¢m is 710 los vi£w£c¢ Wr»H\ `/r)o£-anl;+Y-aml pajr€.mc£'.
'RelJPO/a,)[`:/m)~/ bel;'av£€ Hw issuas he harms bell/ea H,;s +A:Lu.m{
(m bus pa%;¥;w voa/1 wahl mo mudams> JR£ Co&mzabl£ vfolazl:oA$
owe cous%hlu%;wa/ maQ/v,‘)lud£.'l'ha+ &£/J£k;[ FMPROPA:L‘:+;€S
ocean/nwa m S‘h#£ PRoceeA.-'AI’&S ))a~/£ c/ wah/kw find H/wY
aaa ."~ uHe/§ coA+/w@, wl S.c%. 173 (°1<230),~ Mov£s ira c@A/d/£ £x£mpljllem am/ Rulg O/g RgQw-Rm£,\hl
(lll£€au$£ 010 las lmca£ce£a+£cl $ilual;o»/) lz€ is q,\(gla[g ~`lj,
p/aovzcl£ 5 sucl\ as lh£,. ~qmlo£R me cop:es sabmz~ll£d, @A guy gm
l£al, Jrl'lal ma\/ laY ou+$rol£ lzrs Km>wl€d&£ we ;ézlzll le p£Rl`o/m..
OR
'Boaa v. MacDoM&;/H , 115414.31.3@4,70L.'Ea..é-@‘L§Si,w€3-\@+»70°699'2);
Pl£aoli/~I&S l:‘l£ol L)Y mdrvr@lwal»s kap/e£se,¢lz,m lll£ms£lves aR£+o lea
l\£l@l la less Sl/ acca/wl lms m£a&e/<
p£+¢`ltw\r as is, lo log pmpa/ah PRoc£,ss£ol a»lcl vf£v\_/£d wilhoqu
blam£ mm c/Ul:c;sm, w£/‘&Aéd so/e/s/ on llL€ M£R;ls confa,w£cl
lll£/é£w,~ a/’ ad¢l)l;wa/ ,Qg/;£-/’ la which lng
may R;@¢hllullv b£ éw£‘l/£¢{.
lQ£`SP£CH)ullY gul)mrll'£cl,
MQ@?
S'lacv l_. Co/\w£/€ >\
3
A¥`Pi‘~d a vi+
,AS a SuPp)€ML£/v} +o 1416 po/Q£GcGF/M~ .\:/d/r’¢?€p<° M<>\l?ON' pb/Q
l_£J\/£ o'F CouR+;/ JNd 710 v£/\IBE/él M£ `1"0 PR&L£€CI 1`/\! Tpo/Q/"ZE
lamps/us lay com,p)y,w& w:H\ +ke ma~)/ spec;f;e R£auz/A me +o lamle dam `r»/@l;&w¢a Y;
bacaus£ hL lacks cnao$`i}' looX£Sj 10onS o,€
suR£+:~as, up au+omob;-/£s 9 mo+oac.ve/as, boa+s, pla,\/£.s - - NQ~H\;,¢G[
n `o/DG¢`Z€ )Q)A HNY /'A/£oA/v€m'é”/Jc£ 0/€ bu/€cl£/J
.'{+..
. '. g /"lB`Y uNFN`lS/~llw/~lally Plac£ 0/4 lllél C`oukl level ll);$ 73 all TRLL£
awol ll221<2 rs l ‘lll€ F 000 do &l>wli l
°'/¢>R V£Kll`° °'CJ l£o/_\I <`Mol l'o l/LBlP l5ul0$`l`J/~Il'/`Jl£ ’v\/l’la'l’ ~F;.v£ Sv/olbl
210 FQlacllY allacl\ l\£,f\£lo 3_, SEX 369 mo»§l\ FAr~/Lal£ `lRuSl'l\w{¢l accouA)l
gl\OW;,-J[,, 32 always - a za/2L7MS l\ousecl al lll£ WlaRK
5+2 l23 U~:l mdsl`l`»§,eso~ C@w¢lv 72an clo 62:22 sole/01 03ll2 and
daclale£ (@Mlzl`v v2)22l`Y,' 00 slal£) mda/a pedall)/ 0l` 212/gum
ll20l ll2 accompaA/;/,M /2022/ 010000@»123:
/£Adff"<" Molc`o/~/ 200/2 l_£<'£\f£ 020 COMRl`, él)ov£ /ll)“p` clav?l' JNal llu€
P2l2l20»1 302 l\/Ml 013 l/lamlmus 2lS£ll (wrll» al ll 2ls £'xlol) ls)asw£||
as lhg copy 029 mv 52)< (`6>) mmth 20Mal3 lAusllu»nl 02200,2l, 322 all
TRUE Pwl$, R€SPMM*‘
31\£1\/11\/17»16110/°\0»/1 am 3011/£/{5£ Rulm&1o 21
` l\/\o}io~ 10 P\§call 1"1311@1:11£ m caus£
No 07 07 00/43~ cla Aase~+ad 7 1116
1 71111 D;sMrmL Co_u&+ op /-1991313 31/\~1@&1![0 T><
Pe+i+_id~ 1011 \A/R'i+ mo Ma~da~m$
_/H/FU€{'F R&|g1of\
§`1'3£/\{ L_., ee:¢/~ll~l£lp\.4
TDc#/M@F)L/@
Ma// oHa£/Q'Hza/~I 'H/los£
usi/ned m Hu; 03,;;%;@/\/' ;+3@))9 who 1414th have ahs ;/\7%£/{£37
70 ist LLHI:'»/mt£ who/na we co»/a,/MS;M)- wthL\£/e :Jr ha
)ECLH~J, '\CMJA/@;g./, o/Q` £ma'zlfo/JJ/, 771£/€8 a~alas v. §a€kS@A/,_ 15
610 S.w. 29L 73 2)(7£)<». )9%0) "
zB<,mnlc>/\J v., Ha/LM@N, |3
327 S.w., 2§*» 9#5, 977,94®5(7@><.,0/¢:»4./4%.»9?.2)
G§a/zci*a v.' V\as+/J£R FJAM,IM<:;, |5
77a1 S.w. zg‘-Ge‘a (7£><.,198?>
Heaol v._TWal¥`%L\ CDM+ op Appaa.ls, 16
311 S¢w. 221570,57/(7£><.19¢1)>
H€a|\{ v. M°/Mea/d$, v 13
894 s.w. al 772, 774 (m. c-.Q,~M._APP. 7994)
Hc>maN v.l~'|u&)?£$, v _ 13
703 S.w. 2d 449 (7@><. C‘/e;M./APP.)?B@>
HouSs/< v. McEl\/ea~., ' ' 16
243 s‘wa¢@% Csupp. 20035
./ .
'.$aco£)£ v. §7371£, ` - 22
; 715 5,\,/.3¢108 (/l{>p.@*h©;.s+..aoos)
\/_`
Ko‘za€k€ v. KNIZ£, _
833 S..w. 2¢ 760 (TexaApP.x\/aco H%L)
N'ol'al\l v. lRS'\‘/\S€Y,
733 s._w. 29!/2-12 (77:><.g zq?o)
Ramss v; Sua&,
730 5.`»¢..2¢912(!\‘>{>.,2 ozs+. )9%)
P\amos v., 'R:cl/aakdso~',
223 S..\A/c 3¢ 671 (Te><¢e_ow)
RFOS Vo C`§H’\Do/~!,
899 S.w,?_-d/QSY (Supp..l?‘IL/)
Rocl:/§i§';u£Z_ V; S`lla+£,
753 S.w. 3¢245 ('Tex. £/' Paso}
373/mel v. `f)aRKe/z,
CM§ S‘w. 2¢)14 ()‘797)
5‘73']7£ v. Ha/QAY,
-7>.)997)
\/i
13
765
12
25
165
iO
lé§
l?_
4`\/@hi KOHD v Ko£…£R
339 3 w 29 359 C£l 1333 i930>
\/\/5016 v M3Y5
639$ w 29 893 (1935)
WaR/~ia/Q v &}ass
i35 3 W 355 @3| 684(/ex 2004>
wil,a~i\/Ti)cj-ID
142 S W. 394/305 309- /0 (T£x 200+)
F£J 3a al C`a.ses
BR£\A/£R V \/»/lH/\iNSDN
3 F 39‘/ 315 320(5* C~,Q i993)
CRowc\£k v §i‘»iYa/ch,
399 i= 23 304 314 (5-*/“£ C~,/e. /939)
Dav?$ \/ (SoL\hiSo/~i
158 F 3*»»30@ 3m (5-45€,/{ 1993)
Hai‘hi£$ \/ l/\£RN£P\ -
404 ci 5 519 520 (797.2)
\/Ei
)U
70
_'22.
22
Pa 333
13
73 iLi
4 Hou$4o1\l v Lacks ' ' 22
43731 3 233 1035 34 2374 1311 111 2424/5 (1433)
Hudso/\i v.,vM£M‘-.~.l_l;a~, ' _ 1°1
533.11..331,112 S'i`34.445, 117 1.531.24/133(1442>
Hu&h€$ v Rowe qé./T
1315 34 173 (1433) ~
, l\/l°/ C’/ -
§po4v;443 v 034 22
144 F. 34374 377(544@;/4 1943)
\/iin`
.
M§_ pa 618 5 `
Texa£ @0/\/31‘;1/'“‘};0){, AA+@ 5 § 5 Ca) (Io) ami (c:) 4€;` 10
T£XAS §ool£ op CAiM/`A/&| pRUC€c!u/{£? AR+. 404 4
/3\|°\'1“i '+`5.0!3 20
`T£){-` Appa|la+a P,roeduA&,
Rul£ 52..| q
RM\£ 1015 ,55.7, 64.5 add 77.6 15
Ru\e 10.3 C;) (`b) 768
Rutz: 72 a»<¢| '7¢1.5 ‘?
Rul€. IB.\ , n
Ru\& q.?. ' 4 21
P\ul£ 79.2 Cc) 7£§?;2
Rul€ 7?,3 8
Ru!£ 73 U\) amf 100(&) 16
Th£ Mai`l|oox ]:M|£v _ ` 3'
\/¢`\"ii
S+a+eme)\l+ @4`»" H\e. Ea_se
Appel\a»}e cowls&!’s appo;,d~lw+ <€M£c+:ve?v singled wl
_ APR"{| 29,200? wz\£)! Pa»l£l `B op H'l£ S zs comex/qu ach-hug m lms own behah@, mo JZF,
R&|a]lo/§ b££¢d)\| l)Y 'P?l:/~S& wiH\ HQ£ S£v£/~hq/\{CWM d][)App£a\S
-~Md was Q/aa/\l+):@l~ +»Jo £x+a/Jszo,\)s mg alma 110 submz+ a M¢+,D,o
F¢A Rakea¢‘\L:o,l peg P\LMM;AQ.
N£z<+, Ra\a+oA mou~+a@l +}\a S+a . h 'H'\£ T&_)<+ws;'mds @P 'Hmz; m wl/m,l\ 110 p/zod»w,a lms Psl';,iz@~ va
D:sc/{£+zo/JSRY R£v;w (aas& No.?D~).zoLP~o?>./H~Pkw&k H~$
CIARK P@/a 'H\a CWR+ easpo»ab£cl w;H/\ va&a¢‘ add mss)£a@@wzz JJJ£S
H/\a+ w£R£ absolu+£l¥ fm P@ss:bl£ on paca \/a)ug a/oA/£, nL was
1(`:»1<;1}? 3£#}£01 ~ olle days pmpa 110 H\£, deaolh/J£ hLS£LP- H»JP
Sazd Pej_z,+io~ POA `D;scké;+;@,\ra/w Re\/:aw le¢l Lg, gm w we
he¥ok€ ‘ auuak? H,?.r)w.
' Sa+,zs Y,wG¢ H>a+ ORd£R @/< RaQu:Aeme/~){~) R£}mt¢& ,Pa/Lpa/e£ol)+):w
-¢,-)80\ m 3 zlimgl\} pasl\:\o,¢ "AP §Maml S'HCY L. €@,\ n
'R£/J'HR complied mill pu,~/@zlua}:i‘r‘ 110 Hl£ animus oRd£R;
Tl\€ packa&€ appa££N`HV R£ach€;) ?1£5 5188+»'/\(;1}?/'0»/, v/}L£,Q£u md
H\£ ~[»HL faa/nl 010 /~\Pp£al€ hal/11 3+1[`0/£ am u/~IK)JO\»JM pfi/Uooq 09 H»Q£
B£'Po&é: %;Rwa/Qd?/~S& ‘H@£ <£`A/IL/`R£ ' PDR <\~/h¢io¢_¢`l' £0/\'1'¢1£/~{+) '+o 'H’LE
`oMK+ by €RMMQ/ flpp£al$ fA/‘Au_$ ;/\/(. , “ _ `
”O/J \Jad~£sdav, MJ,QCL\ z'r,aozo, ~Hq.s C/M!< -Q,,e’ H»£ &u/ei` ap '
@/a,'mi)\la/ APp£a/S Laafs£ P£a£$oM, issu£o? a /lH?/£ wlq:%£ Pps+aa»ec[
1;_/§ Hl£ PR'»So/\‘ vu\'hl MAIH)QX v)/J Hl£ PR£'-U{~Bw/\{ Mo/Q/Jz°)\{€; 010
)
add/zessed h `R@/a~}o)a wl»mh s+a'}£d: .
` "_,O»l H/\:s dav, +L\e. Appe'lla~~}’s, PAD ga P£HHO,(
` zook d:sc/anl£ RECD,JS;J£RJ;'/"w~{ winch `H'\E £ouRlL§$) £/£RK
//
spo~+(;,q£wgl"/ "R£Su~%£d POR A;oN~aomPl;-a~@e.
. O~ 1413 V£/<~r day 619 A\gca:v;A/& mims mo 'ans `R£<§£'c}:w' `Rs)mlo/§
compos£d,H\E/J mazl£al, ` p£}r;'};o/\I£R’S ./Q’a 620 Mo+ra/J )ED)\ L£av’£
.~2-
Ol`l ~Coclkl` `lo /lrfl£»lol l'\‘i$ lllo'lto/\/ l'loR £/\/ Ba,~!£,. R&Co)\l£?cl€Ra'l’{'o/~l.ll
ll Su~l>sla»l l,-‘allV 'GRWA/décl naale lllalll\£ foual all C/Qrmmell
APFaals larl£df la sum/a we /<£spo/J¢:L la m amy wav. .Y£'l, :ll\€ 7'fig
m lR£lalok°$ l\u.,ml>lg
Cou)a`l me ./l pp£als -[
opi/m d ‘~_ [AR£malaR£lY:l
)`SSu£al 3 Mgmlal’£ zldl`l’ll£ £JS£~£\/£A “l'.lu>u&l\ 3 Val§cl' Pl££ld'f,\l&
was/is S~l!'ll pmcl`::»l& Cu~a,¢sw££€oll l:>e£l)¢>v
/lppeals._ . . ll\us, ll\eo/z£l;ca//Y £»/@l/"»f&
l'oR all llz£ PR££££ol:'/&& /€£a$o,¢s, Rgl@lo/
3 ll/VI(ML:°QN illo~ R££?ll`\bl‘l wlr.cln was cl€»l;£ol wl D£cem
o/zele& o~P H»e- SEV£A~ll\ D:sl)z:al lloqu cl
E)?l `l/l ll §
lR@:lalaR llm/ ~llr/ml a l`/lo m l-l)/e Exlf`/
l\'\olro,l afa R£ll£aR-m& /;s~l\e@l law
R
l£ lll€ .[,lou/€l o'l:l [l/€IM/‘~J¢ll
»R£/a'lo,e ’s appeal
? was £ompalleol la ll:l£
lacla/Lol l)£R£lv, /lPP£,~(cl:x,
low /4,2011, loY wk'.'l~l£»/
/l`:peals' (sa£ /lppe»lolzx,
Js:w mo 73~1£ lo -¢:lc
loil'lll€>ll> lJu‘l' ¢`l ll'oo) was
lal£ Cou/\>l’s elser-szon
wl Rul,wz;s made elsa/9
l@v You/e szslfk cw/~el..£l o/wlek la ma:~.l~
lam unila/€M;l‘( a/~wl 'lo }>Rol£al' 'l'l1£ almam 0
“l'l\,'$ lllp£)<é$ cloukl mo CR¢`m:'/Jal /lppgg/l$ is /\lo
anal sol l>Y uA/sl\£a'll)r»f& `ll\£ flzam:¢lal)l£
-3..
l spare mm L§uarsdn:l:ml
w /el‘.Qq:/Q£d l-o lea€ca@l&
blade 010 Ma/Jdamusq
S‘l'a le N\£~+.F@l? ¢Jukisv.:eljclim 4_
Tl)a CouRl cl C/zmmal Appsals lms ‘umsol:c .;0»1 ov£/{ ll\;s ._
o/Qil§;»)al pR¢>cwl;,J& m sceoR@la/Jae w:+ \/£R»/.D/st @Dus~l:lu~l;O,/
. o'l'l` 'll\£ glal£ own T€XJS /l/Molal£cl /lR'l.'ial£ 5§5 Cal, (lo) anal Ccl5
bY T@>2_, §-2_2.~109_, add §22, 22\.‘
Issues Paaseulz€al
/ l-l A'~l lmpeRlB/~ll ;`SSM€ implical'?iléc(‘l‘ll£ llolmi)~lZ-S‘!RB?L/`w{ op l
Suslree is p/eesml£d by +l\a S£v€mfk D;s~l/<:d Cou)al all /lpp&al§
m /\,»qa¢z;llo kwho alg~;wl R£lal@/ess `lVlDl:v/J la ~Re/;all Ma»da‘l£ l
wlL£/d :-Jll availaél€ 8\/1`¢1£)\1££ ~A/O?L O/JlY "’l£`R£/Y SupPO/llS, lod-
Ol;-cfa'l€£ 8xelaszv£l¥ "ll\al such mla-w SlQbul@l l>£ &M}£~@l as
¢'£l Nlal’l'£/{ o'll` /Ev\/.
/ 2.) /lr\lo'lll€!{ ?mpoRlJ/Jl' i$$u£_ implica'l')°»l§ 'll'»£ Aelm?/JFSISQQ)L,/`QA 010
Q‘_SuSl.'c£ was also pass£,flial lov`lll\£ S£ve/Jllz D:sl)z:~al llqu old App£als
v wlll£~*ll\£v ds~=£d "R&la~lokl$ 1/9’@€!€§ l\'lol'."oh) lok -l;,)<'la_,ls;m
all ~llm£, la F;l£ Pllo'li‘o»l “l~"oR lR&h£a/z;',~_{& l5va 'll\m&l\, .'ll\£ £Xpla/Ja~l:‘»»l
¢iww llm meader addrlq'@¢l,;l lung was emi/well ~"R£as@,\(a/l)la:'
..L!,..
3.l meal wpm'lawll all all ,ll/llll££ ass£sS:/J& all 'Hl\g ~llaal$ add
S¢LPPQR'l?/JG¢ €v,‘ol£~c£ m Co/%/{£/a'l'fo,\/ lo pR£c£olMl' dl/\{lcl +l\£ W\ar\l‘/
s~lalwlo/W laws which €¢ove/m +l»e isqu l:m ll\:s Cou.qlis opf»\ua/\l:l
was lR&lalD/e’/s lpa~l;~l;¢w '.»Q D;sck£l;pJa/z\(. `Rev:£w 'l:mgl\/ d'e/w£k£cl;
YF,S` ok l\l()§l l Tl\il»$ Sl`\oulcl lb£ Vl£v,~/SA 33 3 leMl/lllll€d,l@u£§ll`¢lO/\(l
al3 l)oll\ 'llacl' a/wl /aw fn o/Qal££ 7Lo maMI/HM uN;-#Q,,Qmi'l‘}/.
S'léa+£MENl' 010 Fac+s
\~~/£; owe m:&hl applY 'lowa/é@ls
ll\?s ll:i‘)"a,/c P\£A.>wszdg£al;m\{
ll\£k€ aaa l>£ ma cloul>l' we Qu&$l)*m ll\al ll\£.. l)ollDw:',J¢’;_ lll)a‘l;ko,(££l$
/Q)@Qjcl° Mo'l/l"D/\l `l’lD/Q l..£lél)/£ op CO'LLR'l' _l'(o /“lD/l£hl@l ln'lS ll/lo`l';l_©)\l ` oR
8/~1 Q)aAc llo\£ coasrcle/ealfo}l l was al ll\a v£kY l£a&*l llde Sul)m:lleol
a,J@l ,.’N keapm& wrlll ')Lll& gulos'la/Jlfal~‘>oellb/ma;¥bg cloc‘er,~le,-?;l was
wall GRo_w\lol£@l awol qui?l'& JPFRo/)Rfal'£ u,\ml££ 71le Qz`vb~f CJVLCMMS+J/JA£S.,
Y£l, llnal M£RF)LM/‘o us pl£adm& wasvsm£l/ww$l)£lv£cl -hl A£cawz£ los`l.
(QR l‘@/<&oll€al m H\A skull/aj al ce/a'l'aM/Y~ was /~/e\/e/< FROPe/el‘l awswa/<£@l
ma Aespoaol£_cl lo w any wav.~élll is,ll)z all vp/u/§`l Wf`!:l'l;h;»§l ll l\(lo\l»;o,¢ 45le R£&a ll
lVla/Jdal£ 'I'l]£. Appellal£_ Cooo£l) llow£va£j wa$l` 51 83 5 ky l d&?p?&;&/?L w
lllb P£k`ll°Rl"a/'JC€'Y `lll€""\ dulY wloew '?Llao»/.»;’oloi)~l;£.ol.,l653soll w\o:lzoA-= w:lllou`l,
EI. WR`ll'l'L`/U UPZ)\¢/`owl .@,Q £\/£»/ 21 Com,v\£,`/;L Ag§g/x{d;/J& )L)l£;,a ,01££7$;3`/& y
\ No:ll\o»z doow'lga woo 5|;5355455¢ joy 555 APPE,M£ CMR+,SOLV;OLLS
modili of l\:s valid olgad;aa?'llelalo/e sobm;ll£ol wle a okop£,e mbm
llok em ecl£/¢s;owr ol~l' lime fn wh,@h lo ll;l£ g mo{;b,¢ mo R£lwa,om&_,%.}h
\R€SBorJéllz>l£l €X`Fl'é)\!él‘l';`o,~l$ 518 `lLo wl*)\/ aolol;l-io),-/J/ `HM£ wa$ N£c£$gg/AY§
and al (+oo) was `olw;aol’ wslloool comment
¢Bll is wow,a~lllos poml m ;/o£, lloj Ralalo/§ a/£ozls lo sa£K
R€,l)'.el oc/zom +l\:-s §ala koepm ol 73an Jo/e:apwolwc£" l).y» wov op llos .
§><~laao/R WA:l~ oll/\/)5,451_5,%3.;L _ - 1 '
- Almum;~+ awol A o+'l\owlf'as
l lll&lalo/a woolol aa@ao£ wall/o aull)o,e.‘l¥llal log ololaza£d ll)£ l
R)`C‘olo+ land Pekm:ss;o/J] ilo PRas£mLa })clhl;oa lloA cl;scka)lzvola/€Y l
R£,v:~£w w:ll -r/ors v£AY food - l\,g 'll\£a'aolom:~l:lad los PDR ma
~lmal\( lasl);ow loY /)lacmt blm 'llz£ PmsoA/ uw,;zl_ ma,~/l)ox pRFo/;, .~ 5
'lo ils doe clal£. 5 ' " _ ~ `
'R€/le/Q CM @c)°v£ NO £Xpla»lali`w\/ OR /?£J$ON¢‘/~_-(£c 33 o,wl\‘{ ?l-l'ooK
d 159/4 Go) davs~`lo +Rav£l_. 'H/\£ pull l£/¢&Hl op 'HL£ $“la~/g mo Téxg.g)~p/RWL
Baaum@,d le llmamllo, a drs}a,aa£ el wall.c\/M *l-`:ve_`lw»ld~,'ze@\ [50@]
m;/es ,- O‘fkee~H/la,¢ -Hq£ %wo w££/£:A/& a Hma£~@la._v
, weeK£»/o\. kacws& mo `I‘Qa-R'lm Lak.llz££ Km& §/{.’S lof/z‘H/Ldav...
Tl’\rs ,`T€)QAS£ add SlkoA/&/Y oh/".“u on 143 vMV R£££Z-,<)l"" Sal' clow/nl a/M Compo$£cl 3
"MO?L;DA¢ »[;>,q 851 Q>a/Jc R€co,¢s:daw+:@,(,/a copy '~P w :@k eau l>l: -l:,u,¢¢l
611 H\A ad mo Hu‘s Pel:~l;.~»¢ 14de Ex-L\z-Lz,L"D"'. blm la Rewll Madda'l£
whz& cap/ms his mm sub-appener cogrkz¢w;»r& am .B<.)n;»?ozl No.'.~b';
l\/lo+zw ,oA 8/\1 Q>am; R&co~swlewl;@,¢ was `Rg§;c/Jc£o\ POR /\/m~complmc£
wi`l'l\ Rul£ 79._€>. Cc_) T..R. A.P./ Tl\?$ \R£l&l'o}§- R£Pu$££`lp '£~om_mg,¢+ o,J H;g
swu@b\cess @/a )QJI*MASS ap Hw+ Ru|m& allevle 110 Slal€, um£aq;vowll¥,'
H\a`!l l\£ i$ Nola Couud&€l bald //0?0€(:)" li'l?&a~l whos£ paPP/QS Sl§mlol lg€,
v:ew£@| wall l,‘LaRal;'/~/ and pa~l;a~c£; he should N@+ bg h£|@l la H\£ same
S'l/'Y_ )\!o/Q J;srwfssr»
`Re\a,+@/z’s `\Mo+;o',¢ §§ 594 wm Q\.<:c.>»)s;¢l£)ea%:a,`l; No :1»/:.1/1/5:$»@9
'H\a+ v,°JL}£ p\£;d:,¢& Was was macng ;/\\slzaal .1[ 0,\1]+§\£,: v£/?-al\ w&
humbl‘{ Su&ct£&+ was m cmplel£ coA//Pad;¢liws h RM!A 10.3,
-.'7._
De:l£RmfN,'N&.l/lol)‘o/JS 1 ~ - ' ~ ~ ‘ ' ' ' - '
(a) _T,~Nl£ log D£l£Am,?§[dlZQ/~/. /‘l ,Cou/i'l' »Slloulal /~lol,` A£JR OA
dal£mm&.a mellon u~l;l _)o days a~ll£A. mal;~m was l)l£d, » v
, . (l>)`ll£cwsrcl££a‘l;m»~¢@a mol;m¢ is cle~l.¢>wi’,\l£d PR£M»&l“Ml‘/s
amy pa/elsl aclweslgv a-Plec'l£ol ~)av A£Qw;$lll£ amd lo REco/¢sidm ila oRA£A.~
.`R@lalo/a,was $w\sl. so `av lle dwelj§ peem&~lwze
\R£$£Cl'z`a/J’ o'l`\» l‘\'?$ \Nlo`l`i°oi~l 'l)o/Q (£`/~l %¢JA@ R££D/\l$i`cl£'£€l'le/J .<“>l/~ld lo‘{
_ ll\£ plant la/~!-Ezua&£ alicl;l£¢l fm Rul£ 10.3 ('b) lz£ ol>'lamwl ll£
mlvl rla l`zl£ a success;v£ D~R saksg@uwl M¢l:@~/¢ l-LR nel£g)em&
okizk£éodSFJEQJl'lo/\(` \ 5 _‘ , _
' ‘llé;lglo/e,cl;`l`l`o»~l 'FSR lC/\l. B¢S)~IL' lR£C¢D.I\lBi`:l"l)" llole la R£cgll Mg,,;@la;lg)
llx€l\l look illil'S ow/\/ Jpp£/~lolfx> EX`l/Nloi`l‘ /~lo‘.$.»_ c . -
. .Reta-lO/<,azso wm m,A. P._ ma 7<).3 : .A M@+:é,¢ log i_
R£l\£aR;A/L‘r /vlav lee am£»icl€¢l 3/\/ Yl;/vl£ l)£lo££ lll£ p£Rfl>cl allowed lyn/l
l"?lmé`¢ lll£ Mo`.l'»°cw £Xp?~k£$?a~cl will/l l £Jv£ 010 fou/€l;- wl\ml\ accoml'$
log llg 'l;ll£ o~l..` llel_alo£’s llol;ms plus, il mm wake lb,g.,lglyzg
+l\g Numlo£/€~ ol"`clavs,, il would l:£ cl;a@@_v£/¢€¢l llzz,l llw llme»)¢l£@l
l‘/l@'l;cm Was lumg@l_ ov£k la lql>k:s¢w a'wllza,e_:l~££$ ¢;>N. gl'l;£ lill££/~ll‘ll (I$”i)
clay lll_al wall mglr@»/wwl¢l’ve.l>£e,l,l£&a¢/lxlc_lu£,, .. .. n/laK.z,/& ll
a ll"’l&lv "l)"l£¢l //.Nlo`l'l'o/~I WBR"l'l'W al l'l’\‘lS Co'u/{"l'?$: C`O/JS;?Dl£R,Jl'/fo/~f..
.,8»,.
' M& w,’ll\
T. R.A@Po 7?.5 ";l\ ll\s' fool/al olsl:vg/l-s lo/l;A/& ` w €x'l,egooeolwasv oa;/acuoa`s.laucss ..' ‘
Icl H.;`AQ;.[]£;'S' v. RQM£,~ /\/lov££ l’o C~o/~/Sl/Qu£ J /£`C:: R;&l[l: Jl »’s dss;&o£ol lo Mso/zs oll\ol s c;l;.,zw los llls
oppo/qu~rl‘l lo £X£Ac;s£ lz,-'s..oA lz£R l£&al Ri&lrls lo pR£s€»l a Q>.G;A/,_‘_zal>l£
(',lé!?I*/l lo `l'l\£ JPPRDPRFBl£ CouRl`E/\lcl) 510 ll'AJ¢l` ClE/`M 1'¢(>` MLQ¢?`!OA/°ou$p
lo l\av£ ll\£ Coukl_MaK£ a al€l£kmlwal»’w `lo llzal £~)Dl£lbl HNcl 'okal£/{
`l'l'\& JPPR<>’OR?'&]LE R£ l?€l:>
. Clss/QlY, a Sl/lo/J& case com sas)/V l>£ meals ll>sl llsls o/z’s
o/e:@:»/sl Mol;o,¢ llo,l Y»/ Ba,lc- Psw/lsool£/Qslao/J shoolol ,lo~l lull/s
loss/d `R£'$scl£cl los No/J~Aompl:a~¢£llooo'l ascepl£ol lay llu; &Ml';
lllsAl‘/zecs:veol g ls&al sums has/sol solle dol lle mwls ol" las slaz,q.
lived ll\ooo€ol\ ll:s cl;ol /~!ol acca/2 1lll>l.zllo/€ Sl:»l l Rsl;;,!£ol llLs AzAcle
`l'?> 'l“\;l£ “l`\)£l?‘lli'o/~/£RDS ,/Q?d& M‘w'lo`o/\l `¢>R l;£¢">l\/é` ap foul{l"l'o'AM£/~lol
_ los l\’lol>’o~ los é`/¢ %aola Re£o~s:olowsl?o~ 'aAol lo low £eceovsol
a `Soosl clel£sm,wal:o,¢ o~ lll£` solosle/¢s o-l~" los plea . 73 llo:s day
lll£s£ lms loss-w No Sooc§d$ €o/J,R‘l' alj CR;'»’~/llolal App£&l$', /985,_ `
Tlls ma gmo~olooo»ll lo 'Cloo/sl;lol;o,l co,¢llR/eeol opo,l C'oouzl o-
C,/¢:»,om;l 4/l,spsols powe/ls lo Qsa,ll sxlsaosol,wa/<‘/ ws)ls m assss
RE(`rchl?/~l& CR?,'~/u°-/~lal law Nldl'l‘€je$, l/\l JClGlF‘l}oA la PR£\//°ou,$l‘{ £`Xl"$`l'€/\ll"
Ms~olamos ao/ol aolor~l>r~l.-o,\/ galloner lo £~lo/acs ;ls owu£o£rsdrolco¢.
\/é»’;R/~lo')~lp$ AN/Jo"l'§l£cl _l:‘fX£lS CO/\l:$l'/`%ul'io»l ARl»‘L",l£` 5 §§o
glle sx sal Waols v. Nlowfs , os?sow. 291/893 0935)..
l \/o)\i Kolb v. Kosl\laA,Goqs.'»/.?_i 654 (l‘L Peso 1980); 'llo£ food
pool/ml lllabl Ma»/alamu$) wlul£ usuall‘l 3 Co°v¢“l A£m£olllj Coulol l)£
used lo /Q£&ul:~fl£ climb/al Psocswl;,¢§s,
'Tl)zs c:vzl school fossss»'lslcl lo ll\:'s coosl;s olss.~‘vsol poolsle
posl'~co~vre~l;oo/a/l¥ as was lng ops w tRool/zi’o?¢osz v. §+,;l£ j
253 84.'»¢.,3-‘12% (;rox.£L./°oso 2004); co,\/cs/whl& an issue dol
el ll\s aalual coAv/‘clv'o/¢, load )BRom a ss})€llal£ mall£/Q
`l'l'léll' ;l`.`l)'f)loo~olm ills lollow:,-J&
Appeololix, ;i'lis an a'ccukal£ -copw/ op ll\~£ `/‘/lo?l;»o,l `»'lo" ql“."l£call .'l`/laol¢lal£.l'
Wll;._¢l\ 513 ll\£ sub`;scl ol "ll\:s psl:-'lio‘/l.J;l~"s~d/{&oun£~lis<;h.ulo°j€o/'¢ezs€q ,
ss lo 'REla'lo/z.’s posi~l:oo/ a~ol. los s~l&o~&l¥ u/<&Ls ll»sl ;l lo£.ll\.vooo&l\l‘Y
sc/zo¢l;w;zsd m dsls/l;$lz&s, lll&l' '
l'\€ "l'i`/‘/l£l‘/ l"fl`€ll `-`l)£l'l`l'fo/~l£/Q 25 /(%§ (’/Q° l`/\o`l'r'wl pole l_l£`£lv€ all CB)uA`l"
lo Amsolol las /Vlol;ow o/l £/¢ l§>a~c`R£coAers/lal;owl ';w:ll) llo.:ls fookl’
ol" @/l;mmsl llp/osals, ao/ol »ll¢ol :l was oral/ss sespo,ldsollo “"#‘i`l is
£vgN./low, los all P.kacl:c;al Posposss, Sl;ll p£/de£c ['uMs»/sw£wl;]
lo£'l\ok£ ll\£ Cou&l'. ' 5 - o 1
ll m,lolals was zssoosol ;Al ll\e cass wlo;lé a l‘/lol;ow llo/z ll£lcca/Wa
was P£mlm€o, wlz:ol» ;s~ Gl:slmollvf co~lAa&Y 'lo sold M= viols‘l?ow\ w';ll1
laan `llul£.$ cl Appsll&l£ P/zoc~solook'£ /B. l, wlo:~ol/L $‘lales:. (m.peklhlsoll P,;Kl>
ll\e cle/ /";l.ol'l'd>/\l 'l`o‘ .
v i$ P£/ldl,l§'. C£r~’lplza£:s a`old£l;l)
. 'U.;s iss£l'o~lz/l>ls 'lllo>l 'llclalos’s lmle ~l»";»ll:ol "l.)sl;l;o,l£g>$
./QF@-H »l\’lo`l»‘o~ -l?o/<~ l_s-s\;£ al Coouzl lo lmon loss l\llo~l:~ow/ l%A
€N gal\lC 1R£[fD/\JS?'cll'l`l§<'l`ll"o/~l l\/\/c`»l¢§ 1`/~/ l’Jl‘/`l 3 \/Sllcll£&al l`/lo`l’lol~l 'co/{
`Rsl\w/Wco wll:~»ol_o was/is sl:ll ou m *olo/awswss£cl bello/ss ll\s~
lean Cooll\l ol C'/<;Mmsl A,Ppsals; lla£__`?jb D;sllvol C`oukl col ll.ppsal€
was acl-lola pMmaloo/§elYa/\lol sol ole/wol- coo/l,€aol:cllm ‘lo`l '
'a"o&£~/vwo)llo/laol s~laloll£ o)< sale ol~ law wl\w ;"l fssoosol a Maolcla,l£ m
- ll\£ Ca$£...lla€l/ w£/{€ J‘l lll£ v£RY l£o`lSl' R£Qw‘/l£cl lo rlo moR£ ll\A/d So"mplY
`Dowv" `Rslalo.R’s "`l‘lo'lio~ l<>` `R£call.'l\lla/¢clal€ :' ll\s/eel)o/<£o
ll\zsm‘oi&uou$ , /\lo Co/JSl'/€ucl?o/J b\/
Cooo/;&uous, C‘ooo£l ol ,C"'/€fm;olal
Appsals Musl &iv£ £ll£cl fla,plamm£a~';»l&,ol.~lll£ wokal$~owl£$$ »,clo.l;i:l&.
so would leaol lo al)soozol essolls..\/.T.C',/l.;éov£)wmwl[`ools§Bll . oil .,
..,2..
gamsz v. Ha/moA/, 8-27.3,.`\,¢.; 2 $9'45,.?~‘¢ 7., q+a.a(:n:x§ C`f/;
5131%@\ a~.»+l\e/<;wav,~ 31 3d wm iba Ra&a,e@l£`d 113 "1`~1.'1,113+211:;] ”
wham H\P. pack ake undisp._ui£ol a,¢§:l,'-_&;,v£¢¢., fhwa umdzs;i»a“£o\ `¢;0}3,
"1‘}\£ law‘c!ea)l|¥ Sp_ells md 1112 du+Y_ b B€psk£»/em,£c! .\ . ,fw_rHa wci/1 »
cgl{+;;,¢l\/ vilmL N'¢,Hl:',a£¢ is I&P+ 110 1118 £xaqc?se op d;sm£‘}m o,< iad&mgAh/l
5+3+9 ex.ReL Haalv v..V/'l~“'mw, 394 s.w.‘ 2¢7?2, 7 74 (Te><..\
C`Rim. AH>. |,‘?94>5. (Quo'¥?A`&'-'ZXJ£ b£'p+.f_ we £oRR£§"[§°oAIS v.; Dal£k?'|'£ ,
` 623 S,.W. 2¢.‘+20.,‘+2‘1* C`Tex. £R;M._App. )?8'|)).'
.FL dabadm& K@zaz;lv v. K~;~zz:, 333 s.\g/.:P.£L'~/@o C`Ex'.App.L/a¢a 1?__9‘1‘53
_¢ 'Hq£ ,€ouki]r ‘¢_w,,\{@l `.`Ma/Jdamus is gvazlalola.+o cok££ml iu@lzc;a,l `
_a@ 2011 H'la% 1‘&110/1£3_@\£3& lomdm&.pkecedm+ becaus£ 152le 344@¢£3
1110 ND+ @,\c;goy fkea@lom +@ z&/~/o&£ 1419 [a_w_ "~ - 4 -
lR€/l?}?tbk, bowlle SLL&&£»$`}’S `)'l\a+.d£'ile/l& 010 +`lll£@“/€£Nav/£J
M&rvljhe,es 01h 11th §jfa')L£”S APP££|.=}£ §.>u/ejrs, H\e\{ 1100j shpu.\@l be
Rmu;££bl ~Jro o\os&lz;v£ J/JA~ apply Hz£ law CDRR££V‘/ 133 p)aI-AN 5+&}€€\.
HMM v. Hu@,bu:s;, 703 S,w. 2_~@“/&‘%9 (Tex. €,Q;m..,/lpp. )?`%)).
_ vC`Owe+_ op C‘Rmmal Appeals has gumol:dro» 110 issu£ w/Q:%
' 01D mandamus m all cA;/vlmal MaH£/€S, £1/£)~¢ +o Comfx£l a [)DL.ML
O? APP€E)S +0 P£RpoR/‘”L F`ILS CI£JR S+J{'u`}o/QY Olu`ll)/.,
’ iRé{la+o/a,assaa+$ 14 rs €~~}:ealv j>/eépe& 10)€ 'H/L£.. &u/z% 1119
£/<:mma/ AH>MS. 1L0. axe/zeiss iu,e;sdza%;o»/ ,f';¢gus% such a Paslwo,r
WF'H`\ `H'l£ .iSSL{€ PR£S€A/H‘!l h£ipo'§£ `HL£M . 'R£Ll!`v/Q /13$ £thwg~££cl
..'3_.
.
all ¢+L\£/<.ave»m£s 04 +£a\/el ma k£m£d)z:s 1/£»10% awarlglolg 141 haw
J+M£S+a+£l£v£l=;.. 1_' .. 1 , .,. `
' |§) 2418 Saa&h+ .££/1°£10 vl’/€m '141£17.`&‘ 'D;'s+)zz@?t '@0¢_1/€1[\010 l
A}>Peals ‘.,1-/1~13/11110 L>v wyo-§ has ."`_|\.’\».~511:1>,1‘1L.>.Racall,l‘/.\a,¢@la+£' _ 1
_Csag'£xhibz+"D"> ` ~ . . :, ., :,,
2,) 41§ `YHL D:s+\m’c Coukjr 1943 A'Ppea}$ _ al§n\zao{ --wt~$o¢d“
.comm»/+ *'R£lzd‘o&’s `l\/lp'hm 1Lo R£A;l|-Nl@,`/Ag,qlg nggg El)(h;¢}j~,%?:q‘*>
' . 3.') Sa»zcl `-\N[o fm 110 R£call Madala+£uwa$ 3 R£Qu£$+ `}@
j)£/tl\@m a du+Y ‘H\zd’?s alwle R£Qu:,€£ol o/< owed m @RLLU{+Q
be :,1 CMPI:M¢£ walk law,z;,¢ ad 14er is WR£|Y m,'A:§JreR;al :. 1 - ,
Ham£$. 1a K£,Q,~/£A, 404 U.S. 51‘7,5?1€>'2|,[30 L. lid 33ly €15'~?.,‘73 S»' 911
S 3a compla;A/Jr,`hov./svek :~Aa/QH!LA\~! \ead£a\',
MMS+ {O£`l,\glol +,, legs 311/1:,\1§¢£/~/% S+auclaf€ds 4qu ‘¢o/%mai PLSAAMQS
de£d '.]OY ISW?U{S `ENA ca,¢ 0,`1]1/ 133 01;$'¢1(1783£¢1 100£1[)32[">1&€, 4'0 S£’a¢+£
a dam 119 111 ap.f)eaks \` 1|1>£1’@14¢1 011>`»11<1'} 413+'41£ Plaf»/PM OM eva£ 140 394
01¥1030.+$ 514 SMPFoAJr 010 kcs dam winch wow|o\ &N}?)Ll£ kim ‘rr> )Q£[‘I"£'p.:"
, W:+LL 1413 1113-wi case PResF/,J~HY L£pv&e 145 Cou.~a+. 111’3 Qu:£a c/zvs+al `
454 `R&\ajr@‘/< 1133 ;_l)us+/tzdwl a su~P\£:e:‘£AzL»m@asu/L£, 513 PJ@J§ m
l ` SL\£>POR-"¥ 1542 l'\?$ C)JI`M WLL¢‘(‘/l’l SLlo/,»\A C!£JRW £l~/"}'/"H£ l/\H’/l jo /{Eli€‘(".
`B&P¢a£ dosmcc%.~s twame @P ins 112-bhca R);l;jwa would 1,1\/;~}£,
mill SFJC£RB EM+hus;asm,M:s SMJQ:~AQ 1213/151 1Lo a -P@Wt\ al;gz;ug--
BFOA/ ov£R JN`Y ®u£$+iwf$ 14131 M;W_ have m R£):L+;m +o "H\£ ~ ;,1<5‘¥ ?SSM£
he bus Paesw+apl. wwc.h as Pke¢e/eab)e 'h, m advang aljvsma+:v»£.
¢1»1»
¢ §eco~d ;Ssua=
A‘?+£R '4\£ 7511)\;5+)4:¢+&.111{01(' App£a(s sia/dad am 11de wh,~@,]]
`C\€~i€c|' `R@\a+o/A*s `Me%;o~ 110 R£call. Ma~@la%£, ' (s);e E><~h:)>:¥ "A”’))
m ’°"59P"";@‘g.“l~ ok EXH:A/s:o~ op T;.n£ +o ma M¢Jr,fo»l fink R@l,\£gg;,\{& (ggg
EXL\`)\OF“}’"%£'), Wl'u‘ch 'H'\S, CouA`l' also `c|£/\;i'£,@\' w,‘{-zqo‘j gomM£'A/?L (5££ '
Exks']th "C")_ l f _ 5 “ l _ v' 1
\R€Llllok- “P/'/{M)Y Su&&£$+ H\£", _`LI£NFJ}I;@_P -)'11"$ Mo iqu M_' D(‘l£/A$'md ;
04 Tme was \1/01‘ o~!v m -aH£/§ co»f/€aalr¢%.-w +p_--pm£¢lmls s_e+'k\"/ 1415
T£xas gap/emg €Du/d -£vs,¢ +haucrl'\ saul mo%:o~ was ;,\r»aomplde
gompl:a»/ce 751 1415 d:‘c+a~zlas 010 72')<33 .Rul€s. oP/lppella%£..P/.e_¢p;qlu&& '
10.5 Cb), 53.7 CP>, 55.7, @4._5 wl 7?.6> - |1111+,;41£ .`Ql£._m-Jl ’ y
H'SBLP E(l{`€azL»"\/£l*{"cl£pkf\/£d R£l;nlo,€ 010 3 1/31§¢1 pl£ad;,/£¢ ._L)£\oo,j\£ 141£ vi
CDLLR+ ilJA £QLUJ+£S +o 3/\( 364qu £1o/1£$`]£¢"1,'1‘1)/@1/)‘¢S»S/_JL£_1310~'-d.£/\`)i'éllv cip
acca$$~+@-cowz+s wci g due [)‘Roaass vz'o}.;%,~@~,\»._ ~~ ~
\l£ explanal;w é‘xcusfw& appalla»dl"§ la:'luk‘£ ‘lo
`liw_\alv liil€ Cosl l>cmcl 1911/§ a-{Jp£zl. R£v£./€S£cl a/~wl /§£Ma/Jal£ol ,
‘RIOS \/, C`Slllbohl 3839 S. W. 234 257($¢1{)'0.£99'+>5
C'ou£l' all Al>pwls abused zls elrsa/zzl;@,¢ m ovz;RRulm& molel _~
app£llaml’s MOlr;a/J lok EX'l£/\/Sio»( 010 lim£ `l'b lil£ lwle §Ha£llg,`('l'
`\R£ELSo,~/a'lolY £xpl.;zm£¢l l N'££vl 100/1 £)¢°0/{9l
app£llal£ 'cw//< Rah£a/e;wf& dual la law 41£
Cour\l cl /lp_paals Rul£ c>»l i'ls m£)&fls:' (~£`m plusi's adol£d)
. l,'lous££ v. l`/lel§lve£~) 243 S..\,\/. 3d1 646 (Supp.&oo@);
`vl~l@ uaw was £A~l;ll£/l lo am £xl'z»/s;m all lm); .-‘-»( wl11@l/1l`o
..IG)..
. lrl£ luis Noli'ca o'l appwl, and llws +lna Cowxl el /lp,oe:ls shoulcl
,No_l' lms dismissed lms appeal:.' . _
.`R@lalo,q cv~'lerAs-< as 'll\rs ve/W.@w/§l 1~ls£ll l\as co»rc£d£@l,gwml
P,st.‘ouslv R»,LleLl- +l\al l1;s~ :~¢l:a£,¢'l'i,¢sca/lc£&alzd Slalug al@,J£j
coupled will llaalaul llm+ l\£ is 3 laY~\a~ unsch»ol.»;¢l oklau&ldf m
la»w,~ll>kceal la via lea luna m cm macl@@ual£ pmm law l,~l,/za/a\f,
wlzch.zs so peeAlY slall»‘£@l al pleased llwl Scla¢lulm& is awllm¢;
loud Rél;al>l£, class £a§z/\¢ .Qual;l`)¢ 33 3 `\R£aSoAJlol£ £xpla,lal;oA"
100/§ NE E Dl NG¢ w exl£»/S;-o/J al HM£..;N. wheel lo R£S£a'kcl\)c,,mp;l£j
ll\e~ l/\a»ml~w/<:l£ éw £ll£cl:v£ /`l@lim 100/l ll£llea kid&.lla;s sz~mj§l£
Raal:~ly‘, was/rs g cow/lmuws pae¢l:-¢wwl wlml, m lace value aloA£,
Sa'lisllas Co/§ Slwulel)a~v /¢oAmal Pe/esm’s Slawlcla»fld as § `Tkw£.Nee¢l'
lea edel:_l:mal lms m wl:cll lo l¢l£ a .paop£k Mbl:~w waAll/1.ll18 fwle ,
o'l" APpwl$’C-o/ds:@l£kalt:owl, and llwl kal' E-lousézl ilS. clisc/e£li:m wllf>'~/
‘ll\£‘( dew/leal l):s R£aso~alol£ R£auesl (s£e‘:)llpps,l¢l:x,fxll?l>i'ls `.`.B'T Jw,pl"'c'>
chl@',R£C‘oGlet@/\/ amd acl$uslr/\Ml;s Now /~/£ce`$sa/8{3!{8"
"llml Plawli‘ljl £a~ pima up sal al lack wheel/1 would g,sl;~ll£ lwmml'o l\&li£-l :'
H»\&lw,s v.`l)\ows,,m 5a1;-l.1'73(199a)5mov£$ lo cmsl/m€ 'll\:$ documew(l
l_?lo££€lll¥ w:-llq ago £Y£ lowaAcls lldl allai”A/m£nl el SubSla/~I'l?al gusl?c£ ,_
,_ m ozark la p)zolml 141£ appl;=cawl’s A:ahls anal alma maass all la.w, '
..,7-
. Tlxmal Issue:
'R&lalo/L’s £»/~l:~~lla:mml lo maAdamus kellel` llas loew Slwwhl)
+lms ~lgk,'l@ l>£» male alosblu.le awol MA;pR£'la,Jl:Ms wle well/ell
cor llle apprw?ma+e caa/al aA)¢l, il ~lll:ll clam rs Mcx,"~l@/<:ws,
lo l/\a.\/£ ll\l;' Cou/ll £vzHK£. 5 d€l£/€m;,\(ali_o/l la lluil £l`l[ecl J/\)¢l ¢A@lgg'}llg}
E'JpRol>R:al£"/l€l.»i£zo.' ` ,_ i , . ~
P>/<£Wga v. WAK,-l¢$o,l,- 3~/»'. 34 8~)_.@,» 820 .(5.‘9lL C,:/<.,, 1993);, .. __
~Fl ';s cleale £s'lalal;sl\eol -lllal ;.PA;§@_~€RS -l\av,£ a codslz'lul:o,lalll»
Plko'l€ol'£cl R£Qll'l' op J`£C£SS ‘l'o l'll£ la;lo_ \_
a Pnisouek 38 l'o amf ellle lizltz_e»l.~/<:‘so,l&l us.aa¢ll{.;s cli:vasl£"cl al lll& l`Ra/~lolaloisé, ‘l'l\£ Rl&lll ‘lo _
pile a could a,oli>o,l Slauols ., .. ._as ll;s -rvzosl `)@o,lolgmg~lal.pol;l:o;l
R*i'&lil§ lemon/ltvth pR-£s'eava~l?v£ op él'll' Az’(§l'll'$.' v
...EvexY slip o»z lacoa~l Ma~ove/l llel@lo/a lms l;kl:/l o/< M\/£Slell
S.wc€, llzal ole/vial C loY ll\$$ T£Xa$ Cougl' o¥ @Azmma-l /l.ppwls>
S'lsms ~l.`/§o.m. lllwl. alarm +l)al luz "Pel:l;o,¢ `l"oR D;sc)ea~l;o,lw R£vz£W/'
` Was o¢.,q.:l:maly whom 1'..~1 lkull/l il was N'o.+ uNl?M£lY».l loul~a.=PRoP£RlY
lamle leaal dowli as d:ol.zle:¢l loy llq£ laws o'l?`lll:s S~lal£ amd
+l\£ man c:~lwl aullw»erlr.»:s his Cou/rls l\av€ Ae~olm£ol mg llc£ -$ol$scl,
;~oloolz»r& _'llrosa lm~olaol clow/l lay ll\€ llo§.. Sof)/QL;M£ Co"o/ll.
Tl\z§ '?ssooa ;'o one d,;sli~c,l/V adol/zesseol m RBlaloA’s "Nlo ;o,\l lo
‘Recall -Ma~ola-lg" Csee Exl\;lo:`~l"b"‘>W.l/ooll~l/ws :ls’ owN\/lppa~olzx dual
`RSlalo/€ woulol o»/cl», ;-l W,;s s:a-o~zol l>v llla @/w< lime +l\a
v lieule ~Louis£ p£al<$o~ ,.
' ~1°l*
'lll:laloR j asks lll;\s- @oolox o,l ll)l: l£‘l`+ sr¢l£ ol
lll_€ pa.&£, wlo‘r.l\ l’~ol:»cal&s +l\e pakac;»,€apl\ o:l` ?,l~l£/<£sl -- $psc,=l;e.alll/
ll\g S£co»\wl .S£,ll€~cef (v££loa'lrm`)
\\Tll;`$ Pe~l;lf»o/l was clue l /l¢l /aozo a,lcl was No'l /-
R£cl:;v£ol bY llla Coo/_Ll / 2010 .’
clu£ l~l#l~é?_olo? R£ce;v£ol l'»ZLl-‘Zolo`§
D»‘Sm:ss£ol as unllmé:lY ll‘l€cl ?l
` C'l&a/zly, l>v gm eleml:~lo/W adolzl;o/l lllw: rs lool a loo flo") clay
ol;ll\e/le~c£ lo£l.wsw ll\o'sl; lwo ol..a:l£s, wz'~ll.;\,~l~pe)zl’@o+ compliance lo
`T£XJS Rul£$iol) C‘ivll P/zocl:alu/é£, Rul£$, Wlnc,l\ Sp£c;l£:£s“": _~ -
" l:»‘_`ll" a~Y clo_wmo~+ rs saul lo llls~ »lpAoPs‘/< clc/al& ~l)Y llksl~\<‘.lass
ll~;leol §lales Mazl m ao envelope ok w/eap}>e)z FRoPERlY alolol/lesseol a»wl '
Sl'amp£el anal ls deposzl£ol f__»l ll)e: mail wl `o/l below lli8 lasl daY llc/ll
_F:l;,la .samo,~-ll\£ saMl-;, ll"/<£c'a;vaol loy ~llle cle/Y +lll; cls/ll< goal olsemaol P;l@l
col fm&_:/ C£Mplza$,“$ a_rlpl£ol) ._ _
"/ll$o,`l'exas C`ool-£ ol" C/<,wzmal P,&~ll\£ pulll)oses ol"` . .
ll'\:s chapls-.Q a clocoma~l lo co~s,-J£A£d well lll£ol W;-ll\ lll£. C"l£/Ql<
~20~ '
(‘la)`lllg dOCMmEN'l?S OlgpoS/‘)l£cl wi`M ‘l'l'\£ l/l»\li’l£ol-Sl'&l£$
f posflal S£kw‘ci£, lola l";/zsl class .posla€¢£ PR£/)afal~£/\lv£lope
pkoos;kly adolkessecl lo ~lll£ Cll:/zl< o,l o/z loal"o.eacllw cla’l£ ll\a
' ,`Clollum££)~/`l' :’S R£~Qui`>/{£cl ltv l)£ l:f]£cl 'whl}\ lll£ €/£RlConner, Stacy L. AKA Stacy Lynn Conner
Combined Opinion