I
IN THE CGURTur A^i't. ..,
I i;
AT SAN ANrON!<5^rrXAS 1. O
I 20l5NO'|-9 PMtell
Sf t
.|51 ^ o 'u Kk ^' ^
ij
M^iSi
M.
III ^v
•s It
^ ^^
^ V. >N. fS ^>|V S» ^
<1,
< ^
VI
s %^il|
I*^.® >- s V^ i I g I ^S? 1^ -ts
I •5- ^ ^ ^\['T r} vi "^Cii^Nj ^ v..
1^. ^1 ~i Jii
'Ni
i
<0 ^rV
*0 I
il^i-
o I '^^'§v
'5?'b$ V.J5h^
f lj^
NO-^2
-N ^
U
3 I
|4^ lit
^)N^ ^ .' |:^-N >
,Ci ^ I q ^'^•1 >0 V"^'J^ ^ ^
2 S ^ ^ ^ c».'^ 5 .5' -3 CL ^ H,
'tiSi-
^ V?
^ !«JS tvl
I
t/) iK
V-
. • * •
,0
^Sj^jcZ/V^Z TiXAi ryveo ^ :2V •7-H£ £^i'sr/iJsiii^£in. Sv-
\ *
Mcn'/OA^ -fo/i A/ttJ 77>/y/.//<(?r^£W KcJa'st^
MsnfdA/ To fn/tsu^ATT R. 7:^u.i/r-L\o^
To T-^c ssuas ^/-/^
Nolc) T Ro^fi^tSA,,, W^A/V/7, :iaj Tkz>p;^
TH^ t^^cu/Fit^TT TWA RqOiv STy^co /)/y^
^UCC? McTT/Op/ / Cy^/^i TA/l/.ORi- T^O &i>ie RuL.t jJX^ £>Ay.\^^7h
rfisS^A^ /^Oi4/l7'x Z^JIZA/Afil/' /biJc^. AfA/C TFc /^i>CL.£>i'J>/ri6
^J)/S' i4X>oC /HtA^. /^T^r/ytc
f^A 'ifz7t/^U- &€c>A//i MayjOAt 7^^_2>/ ^€Mt3uAzy^^rti/^uQ^CAyi£j\rr,
~Hu -^Tt^QLCA^sj)/!iT^s 72>
O^^-SAziCr y7'^^ /l^cjvn. 7^ 'foi/zje^i ys- yy-^fzschs^' ^/S CyM^ ^ff^sh
•^Xi F.lkL Si^ ^-^i-iAHfAA ty -^iz^cc /Miz/2j: ,A/ir /^/nycnsj y^'C ^A.A.Hli£> ! ly^Kry jySSuzr^ T^CT 'A/\yQ ClFlAi^Aftt! y ^ tXC-
y^eiwy-Sul-taC Twzy.
That /fau^e r>/' Act/oa/ A^^'k/sT AiZfi^A/c^AjT^ 2:^
72 , cy>/ J /^. OJS-A4A
TO T ^ Z > ^ yA^TTr-A^oy yy\o^
T/y^'tT\ff'scxy^r/{/3fXjr/y' /^utjr/ozy.TS /3yi^"c Oa^ yi /^/zaec^y
OA^ AamoA^T/T-y'yy /y> 70 /ty^is £fo/\/^r. A/rr. yc^^-o ^Aif>
7dj ^i'ODz^A^J/^/'cX's-i'O0/AX/-ci>2-/tUi£
^ck.TO Kcks£>a^szA^ a /^ArTt^-AXiij j y>A\/£r- /Ziz^//yr,Ay^
vyw, ybuA/o
X^ Ci^'lC>'OX^(y,X
t^i£vsj\-//k. U<. /y < R.-A AJ^ A
/<€ yTfK.rz£rD/y
_ .
SfS^/^'F.
•^I'i * -\.
«/3/'
70/^ T^cCl^SccAZ aA/ AXcfCi^^
3})Z0/O y/C> /Ac ^yCToBaf^CTjT'O^X 7^/7^/^,7,aJ/ A/z^
Wrtl^^M/cUJC TFt ^z\7v t>7= yXcce/^Qe^-^-yz.jZDc>C> ,
rMi/rrif-Tjuy/^s Jf^uxy /^fs/oAC t^s fou^
)
\ •> I ', v.-
\
•• !•• \ .. \ ' , ..i:. \ vV
. ' . ' n'V
. - -• (_
i vc\ . " '•••K'' / r--v
I \
i. i • r», • >
w-;'.
-V .< .J v.. /•
. * "i V *
V» . » -
. •. -\-J N \ ^
•.. v"" .> 1 V \ , ' . •» •'• .•• . • '.
v...>v \ \ ^'.Av,;-\ "• . V' V-
iAv'-V- ••. \ , ^ •. •• 'A ;'v.v-\
V- ^ .:.
. •• w I . •.' •A- .
.v;.\ ^
vj.:ir A V s - ; » i\ : - .
». , ^ -i
, • ! . I
\ . . • . \ V. \
\-
. ....A\
,- ,•• n\..
\ » \
• - \
• • r V- .A- \ V- • • - . ^
. •• r"
\
• V •-- . i
1
.)
i \
, V• - \
I .. \ •
ycLfO/^^ ^ /v/^ f^^/rrr,^
^ ^/i/7t^cocc^opy ^-0/ ^tyn
/h2a*3 ^A/o y^i^tAXT "^^VJ jfs TO /^bOifTTZ^S^,.
/o 7^/vc? yy>/^ <3'fTb-j ^A4>AiAo^^ <:3^r\a-^
"^' 7*r Tt^^uCJ^-::^0/cit^
j yiSSU^ '^'^O ^C>^^/ke 4
iHC-C^^L^y^2jD^ :^'3A 2Ca/. "JiCX^St
f^^i9£e>A4 Tu^o^ Yt^c (QxTT 0/c^
YA''^c /ffzxA^r /xO yfiyT/yi>^.,ry yo y^^r, ^oy^- 72> y^/^c
B^INC> V/^E ^7Afy^fP^iA Ti^yO yCJf^J^*Ml4i^/£W J'/X yo y/ytS -^/l/
/(erfoAj yi£>/^ TAfir //jyc>J3 ^/y
The y>y, z o a C a * ^ TAiyr }yOE-sf^3:^ t.oii Li?jl j i^f^v
C'h/ Q/^ pB^fiitcksPUt^jU ton iPh /iS-^30^ , d.'yTArtc.i^ncykJ^-oVdM,
C^d/zA/AAyrPodi^Anrd^PT pAtj^c-dJ TO /3^ *^ry P777>^d'yy
Bt.iT ti/}£. -^TTdrnfllTQ To PbATTPer MaHiTATied^ yyicjy&ZS 7t> AfO PtAjAtd-x
T^ yo^ /PA/rA>Jt /^d-o/\/-z2> / dJ>/io ClyJ^^A^z^Aiiry^aw
^ pAEHib^C/Z^-i-oAA/Tiy (3fPr /3d-£d3 w/vO yyi£.T y^/'tCC yfyzo T^ST^APtTJtTi^
Fort P/fcyiSsCf PzxaWcTT^ /^V/«J^-7>y <3uvtr/p/y^tza/ PfdL
Sz>/TcyH TZET£fytz>Hy y&y ^5 yd>
•^PuUi J3c />hpCj A^i/xc pPOHC/fT /SZf^^ A AJe^ jT^iApz^y p^/A/sryrdO
T^John E. Rodarte, Sr. v. Ralph Lopez
Combined Opinion