19~/ T\&§ \‘A\SM` 5\~9?§9?.\0'& b\%»\'Q_\<_;\“ CO¢.,~.(C/~\-’
09
C1€)\)~1~x\\\'”\ 90@ N-‘AQOC»\ O<'>C*\-l/`E-'§ L/Og 61('%;? .
'Z`>€§A-vc; c>@ T€\§HS
CW%E L)'o F\\/\c\_(o-?*B~OO'\
m._<€» -» (Q% .'~¢9,91 31- 0\ ,
l
word 0699,669)¢\\92.>9»§6»\ § 4 R§@ENE» 999
MM\L §§ \916 U\v\\¥ 9 couRToFchMlNALAPPc-:ALS
‘€:OLQD § \N\ Z>S \ \'\_ 9 ' § NUV 05 2315
%ecmw\w¥ T\Q '1'1'705
v . 7910 62 '
5'¢9§\’€,06 16 XA‘»" §._
»;.
. Abe9 9Acos9a, Qlerk
. ~/`/\6'9~90»9) RE~G\€ TM)C:» Z~Er+uéa§- ()r)v~r`r
`\'l> 94991\§9)~)9> /§»19QLGMENT 69?1\‘&(90¢9(. ?f°`PL)cHr/M § // 0 7
?a¢_,§\€a\\)\.)\c:r\o& Aa¥ea; Cor?us F!lom P/ovfrc, PEM)\/~/ @uwcr/m
'T6 9969\\<;91999611€ C69599L+
(`169~\9:§ mw ,,P(g §§ €§é §r;mek 9 "':,§`";'99,-“6629 …
\r\;> <~€‘9/9)\€4<\' 496 \19&9>9 65§ Co<,\.\r‘v m §9)19;10119€?¢/9/1'§9911_
”“"*\<6 6< \¢;\m\\ 2999>91\999~°9~\0~ z 9_\_ 0'9 9_/_\ ¥>66§ mme
”Y\<\\S \(\M\o~§<§\v\~€ C.Ou~\"i’ \Q~L{ \9~"& cuf\ CN“€/\f @V\
§GP \~<1\9¥\\3°19' \i~> x .L 9
' § §c.:
~66--°¢\¢996 coM+ has w P(€hm~¢ P@WQJ 90 996
?QX\X<\,OUQ‘(; N(BU\) \§ ¥QS\\\)W\\ L\r\\(\f) k\$ W\O`[`xc)r\/ a§
Qo\\o\.o‘v `.~ v ‘ '
s="~,‘."`.»"M" ~ , a\ S(
1 / . ' ':\Lv \S \c,¢ b:>d
"Y\\'\,. T‘L\ms Qw~\»;s gsr )Lr'<. Q.\x\< 'IEL.(.
' \,.*‘ 5§<“`.‘...<3§' § **‘>'€
Qv§\~§\<§ox\m€ l\§¥?§\`\€,€~%\§x » m `\°A~Y\q\\‘\ §"\\QA \(\?$ ¢Y?.`Cco-\n`w\ lex
6>\’\\0”`\ \x\a\>m$ co< ?\~5 got §v§~co<\ulc<\»§o~/\ rm\\\§ `\I\ Au‘w.s¥.},a>~'l.
Lw‘\mcwa\ bhd o‘§ Ama\s QvAu~QS \,\;'5 use 40 be. _qu-
%B` buc\L \v \¢\§‘> 5§'\~?0§ Cc>w\\'§ ql\ 'XL)~\‘( \$*33-0|$/ Silv\ct `\\~
\\g§ iowa \.@ \1<\\<\¥ *<\~A ~‘v’\»~e_ c\e\\.\}a\ av\ l»°¥'o‘% man me
\0€,&,\£\ Q,\Yf oviw§ .
Q§¥¢l¥domxs` S¢:-¢¢,& 0\€?\§£0\¥%0<\ §X@\g,i ~\“\,\e c-,\a;¢w~$
£o< 75%-111&%3»@ a%?§§vdm;€ o§~‘~ Cou~\$\<,d a,cr~l c\Q_QecLi\)e .`r\-
A:¢\<\_\-m&. T\\e_ C,r`\`tv\\m.\ §w,>:& §§ APPLa\$ orp\e.\g~eJ Wg
~\,\~w\ C,_o¢.x\- \o \>u\c,\- wo.\r¢o.n\' \ Pe:~i~\`{~c`m£,/\_ §M 4 ken 303
"c\' QAQA§ ¥g> @~\ -(»\M a‘z `\Mw~¢“§$c§¢&\\\ rer.\»\>.\nLA Lg ‘r"_DC’.K- <.,">T'/"l§.s L{n»"FW~/€
\?_o_¥\¥¥o<\e,€ » mag No¥ a\\ng& L¢> § o&¢§\reés or gt\`scaes _@ CownL +e> 5ava ‘
`\gm€sn-\' \/\}§ QT~(:\%§I\OL\ §{{¢O"I GPP/l`(a,('\`m\) bt‘c‘_a_u.L§_.¢ [r\_¢`s 'I~\_’"al*'
0_:_.,0\,,¢¥ \l\a$, Ca_ugc.g$ §rre ug(s{(l>(e.g,rrcsfs '1"(7\0~4 .` Coa[¢! mut /\M/{ 1
“ `°°“°"" -Ak“:‘?°°»~“&,§€“~"¢\ .V€arz amax PC+C~LGMR' €,n {-¢_v ~' ~
m\\ -/o-.`\
. .,v-» ‘.1.` ' ~\.»'“-"'.' :i'r~, ".' i"’“ " ' ' ' '
_{" '“'-””:”"\ """'?W°"' f"~"*‘“»*'€:¢‘“'*‘*"?`*¢»*‘§%‘¢‘?i;_`> '
» . `. \\.\ ll
`w\§s TDC`§. ~`Y\¢\£ g_r'§c_vo¢\e &v`~m~rj owe a~_:> §o{.\cw§»
. _7._, :_,,;...
?."! t" § ,
b ?g§:¥§uz\e<, Qg>@<>\»d‘ ra§v\a\ cgwr§ cord uc§€&
"@\ N\*~“\L §"<>'§M\L- ?\`.OCMM¢\J `) 61»§$€'¢§€_§\\`.5 ‘?r€$ehc.c `, ~H,\N\' h
-\¢\N, o. v`\‘d§~§' §¢.> `0‘€, ‘PFQ§QX\§ O.§ O~X\A §e §& 'vQR TQSQM\§QA §>~\
- Cc>L»\(`¢->QL\J` §J€..CM<,€ '§ § "`\S ;o\. c,c»`\~\§~>x\ Q.~;~g(,é;»l¢&\`/\j, 'Q\_A)
§§ QL§"\§`\G~<\QX »\ O\S=,Q,c§§ ~\’\l\l)~§' §Q`\c§ {\)M\\C_- Pro §\M\C Gfé_&i€’
‘Qm,\n`§ o\a\wu¢;§ \»¢. `Y‘DCX ~~@e,c¢~<~$$ ®'~`u is md um§(\ 5 \lws
1 o~§»§&¢ ~V\\c Am§~t o§ ‘\'\¢`~;Q J&m,\\c,` ‘?m §~,\\r~_c P(`oc_e.€c§§\o&l w§§ex\ `
\\Q Cc>r\§ixL§C§ 6\ §&Lu`\ 51 §/vow\ S§O\§e Co'u__v\§€§ §€)C MW§US
C,-‘>.Q.F.G) o.\r\¢\ \/\é\b\-:§“\)\€ O~IS&Y' §\®q~c,\>@_\ra£& §a' TbCTX- QQ(m"¢§j
§<\) K¢,§u\ ~§ez m\'\`~c,\c\`§)\r\e,\s\ cr \I\¢\M\"\“\`\ o\_§§z,rwaro§$ \`&CU\>~QC§G
’\\ . § 'u _ . §
`T\w~e'~-S\®' `.Fr\ Ua\s\m<\l»élz)\_g, s\/\_am\\¢\‘j. H:\e c\~»v\i€ z\/\
§§<»§u; §§ \f\`<§ C..< §_N\`\\c\¢\§ C.\(»(C»\f$ mm§§¢uo\t 9\4`1‘1`~§>"'|\`§‘/,'
~’<\,`§s <>\m¢)§ §N§-W€§c`\w~\(é§ cwr%.~ \*S~ .\¢~\ v‘~e`@(a§\\m al
_¢_§\x\‘§?§ 0§ C,\`.Q§'§L \w\ `O\CCOvc§d.u\c£ 46 'T€;Mf> Cf-f\`f\l\<“~r“a,| /00[€
< v +~v~~ca@/ dowd /\~¢(s M+‘
‘?c`esm\§¢a§ \Ab~\ mi§\\~@;\¢\ `c‘(\c§dc§w\‘e,u\§. §er- §\Nz {€.59&\{ mdu/1901
Q£§L‘<\¢se`o»; ro\)\v<»r‘l_/'_\*\r_\e.§§ \-c -H\¢._ »\Q,<,'(» Xl/_¢;l- \|€o.'rg:,,-L
_\,\‘\s ~.c~'mvm,v&§§o<\ m\¢g§g.\{\ Q.\:.~\‘\.r\a§<;g =Hv\¢ 4-4` face raw/13 ci\)l~
'\`\§~\f §§ ?vesex\§ m\§»;§\\g§w\g»\§ m ;ac.cc~,rJ¢nc€ +6 `f'wa$
Q<_\mr»A-QQ§-eQ.\MQB_W<~:arl:¢¢:\@ §/3`0.¢ 4,0_ pr%@m¢ah
`€@~§‘cc§‘\r\\ezx\§_ml'r\r\l¢\ § »~c'ém:s '£mv\ `f/Lo _J¢Lc 09 _~'H»e rm\m,`-
1
i
1
i\
><=>So~/\ ¢>§` <\’\\'e ~o~r§i.%§\g§;,".c§§§cn<€.
' AM>'*?o`\§a\>§€ w§~e,\r\ >., §Q,§§§~§MC 1_ _§¢§>m.`§§fo§ V\\`S R?P{ka'¢'c’bnl
@c§~é\\~m-)omé» ma§g._m\;;q§§'ew§ §o 're€c_fx')w 51 §\`§i¢\@”¢wj '
;m@§\'\;¥\\¢\‘; a m m\\ a;v\§ go 13 o§>§e ‘¢\>wqc. __ 910 §w\c 010’0/ §§w§
R§CQ.Q§Q§ §\s-°~-§Nu§ Coo;<\§, ?\Q,\r\cvc`i ?OWQ>X?? §O m§§§§`i +\'~E
‘PL§`\§U\Q,G,,~ CN\\)§<;,§C<:~!\.' `g&:`~r§\~c\r 4\'\0¢£.¢_ “H\_€ §v€w§ ro»r+ ?5 award
\\¢- `\§`S Q>L?er§~t‘>€ §-r\p§»\_e§% §§\¢A~ on KA/u\;_ phs \Lw/\c upon
Q,\;\\\\ for€€£§ \\Q.§L€t-ca§ grvp~r§ “;)
4 \`Cl"c\,, Q.\f`/b_i» }'.*
dow ~m& ama +w§ <.MA» :~; wm \m§ +
he Q_{\P\\cu§cwl
§.z_> owe,v\§ s QL§`\§IM\Q.¥ 1 \QI‘§'\\ 6.__\¢\ \\r\¢§§c,§\r~\€.n§' §?9( a
§esser"
\‘\¢\\\§Q§ 9§§@>&‘2 ..C,`§\~Q§-§ ./v¢>\b§u‘{§ *‘\\€_ "§~r.\`o.§ (o<,»r § veiu§&l_§
§§ ‘E>W\ § \r\`\~\ am v&\f\ §§ , Ye§~\`§§o\€r. §\as' w o H\¢.\/ remmer
ex\;o~`\‘\u\>\e §° \\§~\ o‘§'\v~e.< §\Nm\ §¢ r€%v~e¢,§~ ve\‘:_a§ £‘vm+\~€
Q.§ §n`\a\a§ Qc».t§ 'o§ A?P£a§§ 1;;_\(\4§9_,\< <1§§ \ § §§ .07 b\A§Q¢x.$ CNP.H.~S
gov YGS§“ '\CM\.\)€/,§\`or\ §~Q.\`\&§ §§\A.§ cwa §>£` ra,`£`=_?€po §;r ~H¢\c '
§§r~s§- §?N\€. 6u\ AQ§<;§~\NQ §¢\A§~C§\N\‘e¢:r\§ ‘,- .0¢\\ §r~§§c-HN~QA§
'§\._`¢§ @ua§\§ q Cmutc§~\'~m \Q)c /§B?ram§€d Q¢§)£u~f\ eq/_\§w\ce§"
sam ms Q\~KMMA §§ m ,\_>e)rmm\e.r, w a P/F.q ;,b@m>,
+\;\o.§¢qv~§§§€.l a ¢_§x\._a,_§§\|~mtv?o'r\ §N\a§\`a\€ ,‘,) 'Fd UI\.'L[\ l`$_ av\
QL.GU\§§-¢-§ Q§Q,,\tv\£-\r\§' §§ '<.”.&€'(4 o Ccm
9 _ v \)€c,§<¥~)r\§`er §)su( \l . » - 1 l
SSF‘~( * w
` \-A/\oc§ 0\§§ ~l§~€ &'SS@C'~H"¢Y\§ r"n }'\¢`;S
§§0`§9¢;§ `:‘:_;¢_.»uQS’\ cux\.z\_ a\§__ `\§l»€ qw¢dw§§ §'fév!~co{ ha 'b\¢§s Ana/'
\\s€$ § \;\e \¢\¢& AJ<;\§ 9,\_!\§0¢€¢\ \\rx§c a P-/c’a*~ é»rijqrh '/`n,l~e,l'¢`?m+/\/
Q(,. \k\now`ma\\{ om¢§ §>€/Me,g q>§ §‘§\€ ¢E-¢\a,§gov'f+$ \`~rfouer§)'l>lr
Q,\\_"rgr§ ) \1_\9 S§|_\ou»\§ \>£ l
P“N`N"\»¢-\§ L€a»€fo§ (`@¢.Lr_!~` \L.Q.S¢.~P!/¢»w)¢
\'\\‘.`) &<1! %\‘\ 01 A'W\\<_¢~’L’\»O‘{\ \(\ 091§@((>\@~6\@@' .X,.e A,()Q€LLATE .
,9\<~60@§16~\£1 T@.!§;§ 169\3€ ‘§»>»3’93€.\03\&\!\11€€3 10€66<-,€ 01 '0“3¢~€ \w'<~
6195¢',‘ \o\‘e. 001¢:)§"'~3 Cc\»\,<~,€§l 1003 `0'3)~0 1<\\’~<1\ 066~733' m q 31651('-
C(S_x\\)\c/¥\`1 396¢»~§01‘~3 §016¢661:313 31 TDC_;_¥~ 316(01035
`b\ol“)\`$\f'\ \5§.\£\1.¢ \ 1 11<`;1\0(-\‘?/{` \ 50\§(0\)1\(`(’9(3 "13!\'1 (j`y-<”S\Q.,\\" \"0\ \55
\0°\0\ 1901\'4_ 611 09‘\/\,\_%3033 `0"\'\€ 01§$ 5303\(.€ 63 o 5 fA~'(e’
10640-,0.\ 1101 631§01\0‘&;61> 1 Ct&jsc‘)~<` 1011 3 M3\c 1169 fer€ ) De,31~ may-153
`9<<:»\¢> §0( "C\:~_Q 11\\`\`911 30 501‘? 31003:,0\1\ \f\; §/3 07 0?3’31€@303
3 65 604\013»\§\301 \¢\ 80031€;>93~1\\>0( »963$' 1
CQXJY&\ \C&1F 01 SQ»`<\) \C€
§0\-»1`“?\6<\0< 1 C`Lc3 310§ ~3~3301- 300 3/\03<»~ 013 331‘°03 `3’3\€:
1063 3661 30@693 ~;19619<9 31 396 590\,90¢3 311
», 3\3\@39 691 0 0106\0 381,9?3>3 3106¢\3 \,_\< 603 §/3 c7 644/03 3\¢15 ‘
3301\.051\§10 `11\~9»3~_"`3\ 01 (OP"f 10 1104 3633&0 `5\~3` /3“35'4§31§3137€(30\’
`,`06933\1363 1110-63 1019{3 1\0( 303 10640'3' 34on333\ 3701313~3¢31
'30_\ 693@<,<‘1 3000<\%3319~23 1460 l<§‘©)/U@\cméarb;, T¥ 75'-‘7{1)3
f 6931\1\110 ~\“\s\e 310 \N\ 00 1661_\(3- 51 3@31°03§ 13€>,(3{@)<3 (m(3
_3319\ 000 16 1991 661 c91<09\§093r301\,/369L9A.T9 m
153 .
w\k~\§<§ dm 11160\,§§ \>y w\€. 00
'\€\»`~'~5 Q~No §M ¢;>; No\mw\\r)€x 905
ii .
Gibson, Tracy Ray
Combined Opinion