.; Mi \o t~adALL ~. \"li\\l(tm~-A\~ e.Jo ::.tf \121'2.-1..~ - 'Bi\\ ~~ ~ / <1~ Sf?u\(~q) ~~.q ,?_06 ~'<1-l'ln ,-re:~ L"1t1 loTJ. \o~ b..E:R.Kd~E CGUIToF ~A-~ fu ~ \uce) Mi-kll s-\Gv-\-{on \RECEI\IED iN 1\-uz.\-in 1 --r~ L_'fltfl f ·) COURi OF CRiMII'IL\l APPEALS {lE ~ Wx-~\ o~ ·tJ\a~ NOV 12 2015 \JffkV" \-\o'<"'.Aent - -\--c ic...l C.Uuv-t- Judse i'f'l fuE- 3 Z0-1-h . D\S-\-'\ \ (_~ C6U(-\- \ 'DI'S-\-'\\ c+- t£U'( \-~\A~. s.+e' 4 ~ ' So\ s~ ~; l\ mo ce. I . ~~Y'Il::.L~~\ \(') ,l0'kCL'S. [lq 16\.J TA~LE Ot= L.of\J\E:;~TS . Lis-\- of Aui-ho-cl\-\e.s . S~{A.:\·c MeV\-\- 0 ~ fuse . Su~e.c. :\· i\1\ct-1--\tr Cl ~ -r5Su.e L5) . 'U03.C.,'(\{>.\--Ion o-0 MeMo anA 0-P.:rfJ::r:o~ . S.+CEQI..l\(2.E RulE" \2.6 a.. - bZ-.tl.~ ) f l lb -re!-V\5 RuLeS OF.t.."":t..v-..LL.PR6C£ ru~E 'ell~ rz_qf..D ~ 'Lttl 1 8>,1D 10~ C'l.U.U::..S OF-C:lv.J:L ~Du\2.6 fuLt -z_CC7 -~ -1~~ R~ O:f ~AU12C.t:Eruf2E~:U.u;;·IILJ7 -3 Ll. $ . CJf\ LA-w ·-nnE 7..50 B l333 L_() u . s c._' A I CiJ$ Lcua · _A-K.\-1 oo~esetLs 6c-a..~.\- v, o\.s:Y) , Z\ .s\u~ 1c1 . L -rex A-PP, A-us-t-t \i\ ~) - S, B+v-o.d()._ v, :s~ I l£..\~ ~~3d 50~ - ll :rv:n:e:. 6.S:n\-TE o+.Judd , 1\ 5u-'·"3d 43LiL L\e-~A-t?t>£Lrt>~ ,qqq) _ _g )Q\iw)i:>Q,'fl "l tech*,~<{ LLS.,4s~.Llul-l£ Lt'f3S. -1o .KSt0G:t Jt\xcY> 1tec_}j ):r.oc.. v. 6w;>\e~ I 101 5u...>,3d ~q~ -- q N\L4t~G"r \h ~~Vl I :S~ ~u...:>,zd 'fZ.L-<730 - Lc>dl M\1{\~l.A.S \t .• \S'JOJO>Ci\'l Clct?-~) l\5 Tet. S"3i I~ $u.)oleQq - ~;3 Nl.AE.C.£5 leu~ v, DtA.\e \.-\o.Q+ , \ DS 5 w ._:H ~ ~~\\A.. v, ~v\c.. ~ i'e\ \1-L 5lJ-'.3d ~.s I 1 .Sen.- uS (_ -.~. Cx- \if\'\ . A-t>~ • 7.Ue>3) -3.. :"[e'Lel:) P?Rt· of Pu.\o\ ·,c.- Sct..fcsr ) 0'\\ Ma."c11 Zl, 'lD\L\ \Le:\oJnc fur-au~'n fuinl ?d.rt'i ~\6'<\/e:.mr . f\\~ a._ 'K.e.wes-\-'Fo·c-SPeLcC<-\ A-Weom\(\c.e: L0r~-lt\ A~-{2icb\Ji.\- A+kched ~ :r:D --rhe 3'20+h '0~~6 mu'Kr ~oTIEK Cbll~ rtFX~S 1 l0nlcln . \e:su.\-\ed iln r'to"-xe:s£13nsE:\ Ju.reL., ·miLl Re.lo...-kx- furaue\r) Thlu--d .~ox+i J:.l()-\t'-\0 t2 f'O t --e·;\ el a_ ?e.t--1 -\-io\f\ ~--r uJ 1r It of Mo.t/\damll~ wr\\A .me 5£\feY\-\-\t-1' 'DI.s-\-v-\c\- ~nuf+ oC 1\~PEa\s -a-\-· fuma\l \\o ~--re-~ . . IY\~ Se"~ 1),'~+t-rcJ- C.OUd-o.(:: A-PPeai.s dlsmisseA +\ne oti~IV\u1 . ?r-ot..eecho9S (bc\Ualflt- o-{2 dUrisA'1cJ1oV\ . 'Kda.torfuroue~ 1"\r\trd . Yo.\t-\...1 :TV~4£~\b\or {'l\ed n. +e.-1-!-\-\on foe ID,~-1- 0~ t.J\o.l()damus wl~ . -t~ -lei as 5i.x9rerne Cau("+" meTe:A.GS SuP ren1e 63-uct den 1cd . +Vle 'De.-\-\ +-Ia'() t:OI( \1\.\"~-\- 0f ~us LDtitnvJ· vJ;c+\Ev\ t:J\d&\ . . ?\esen+l'-1 '+his Pe+;.\--iof\ tor-\\\),~-\- c* tJhX~Lk\M\AS l:S lce1ffi .QiW . wi\Jil fue fuur+- oG Cx-\ W\ \ (\Ql A-~\.s . Sunjc:c+ MaJd-cc o£ :C.ss ue {s) . ·:r:_ss tle.. 0~~- mi5 15 o.: ?e..\-';-\-\o \f\ \br \t>-..ki\- d 0\a~mU.S to CoMPeJ . Lblf'\ Emerson in t\rle .31Dfu 'bis-h-\ cJ- Cuur+- ·,(\ a~d \or?Ln""tB<- . r'_row-N , IE~ As .to Pro teed wr\-V\ fue \LeR.u.cst- .Qe, SPe~_JcJ . APPaa~oY\C£ U..i1+\r\ A«lda.\fl+- o+\-a.ckd ?teoliln9J, r'h-i(J\~ffi \ffi . .Su.b.'lec..t l\Aatkx-- an~ Jo' t>ecYK\Q\ J~~rl'stl \d-,'a 'f\ :Pu..'f:5u.an1- \8 ·r-e:ws .12:.\\le-_s Q~ U\fl\ ry,oc_eAuy-e Rule-. \w Cl. Tc2:~oS 'K.lA.\e:S oQ. A-{1\)e:\\a\-e I . . ?rC>te:dU.'fe ~u1~ s~, 'llt\e: '79 §, \333 Cl) 'u.s .c_.A I. \LcJQ:\-o~ .'nn_s t2X\\tLLLS. -ted_ \\ t5 temtndt..tm &\\"'\\~{\ Ko'\ \co.._tfovl See~Y\~ . ?C6-\--C.on\f\·c+loli\ \\abB:Ls ~ Yl6 re\re.G' .\2m«'' a.. ~\cn.'-l . tOO \J \ c....\1 c Y\ \ Y\ -tY- ·c n.,\ Coo.'f-\-- ~ VlllVV\ 'tY2:r ss , 2Ll <-I - n. ~ "- . See~ ·1~. L..o\J E c.RI\'1\ . ~Roc .Jt\Ml-1 • AR:I. \ \ . o1 (_ v0as+- ~\1\f>p, -zn ~~) .. Vclf-~·{GVl ·~'(·iUlY\,\-e\-~\'\~\\d-Ten ~ 11 . We: W"t\\ ojsm\ss "'\S S+a+eroeV\t ·of ~\l\tr.st\w:\---i oO . ·::en nn on~,no..tc~ ~~ o._ 9e.\-\~(nf\ i2or wr-rt-of. MQ.lf\c\a..mus / . :-J'h.mA\~ Q\"s+ 'be: ~'\esel'"\ted -\6 o...Cc\xr--t- o-r 1\f'Peo..\s LtV\~ thBrn . \s o_ Co'M (Je\ \\ n~ 'Cea.So'f\ ()13.\-- -\-e O.o S) I 11 4)0-d ~l \a.. v. s I . tJ\c., Do.l()le\ 1 \"2.-L.SJ.N.:Sd Bos, D 2--'Z.J-\ -C..V • \l{"'o..cl.\\-lo'<\Q)\~ 1 The \1\J\ri-\- of \-\o..b~ Co~~ . wa..s. ·-to P~ lu. o...so.CI(l.st- ~'\\sd\·-\--\o'(\o.J c\~.Qec.-ts a\(\cl ctns+ihdiCVlcJ. . \/t'o\Qt-i'o\C\.5 Ac.G6~\n~\~, The\e;""'k.OS ~llt>~ Cau.c.t-, «has , i , \ct\ d fue '\!Ale fu.o..f' u.)\t&-e th~ fuUSJC OJ~ b..ci-fo~ aVId \6~'--} . ·~o~ \t~ etlfurCeMevrt-o..re de-\ \fed 1 \\ot ~vG'VYI +ne CoxnMoV"l LalO . . b~.A~t \2ruXY1 -the: St(4kw\-6 1 the .5-ta.-f\A.-torl 9ro \fr5\cV1S' a.(5 VY\ctlf\dCL+er-/ . and ex.du.SI\/e o\Jld ffilASt- ~ w!-th i'ec.r-al ~raVlu._ . Wlt\{) ~f.rcduvrt- a+ta.dr\ci''. 1he -?roV\S1oV1.S ~laJ.e, l.J:led LD€-t'C . 5-\-a.t-vv-\-o"~ Provl.stoV\S w'n\m ave. mav\cbJor'--1 avrl. 6Xclu..siV£ . P\.l!}~~~\- 1-o '\e""-, 'K· C.\ Vtl , f', n\()d 1~t, t<., f\PPJ ? . ,~ \M . llt.J- so~'nt ie 'ae 6JW\\)el \E!l \s. \rvtlf\ t<)tet-a.l V'\c\- d_(sexe:+WV\a.\r'-'1 . \V\ \lui-tAre ' \Ze \.oJor ho..S C..\taJ\e:n3ed fue -h-eed ~'\'\--~ . ~llv--\Sd\'d(~Y\ \'Jo\-\A su.~~c. .\-~OJr\<1 QersQ\f"\CL\ , 3 . ~ \o..-\-cv- Y\o.s ~~CAO\S\e(\ ri-LL ' C.oux+ OJcr +.ne . \>e:~CSO'() <11\ \)m~c\·'-l o-G -\he. ciE:.~~V'\t en t\r)egr-auYlcl-\V\cd-Sl.\c~ olf ?m?ey--.\-4 f5 net- oro.eno.\o\e: t6 ?roce.-ss rssVLEd 'b~ma .Pa.rr'-t . ~rtS QJQ fu.lS ~-\o._-\e:_ ... .,_. ·DV .~' :1{2 th~ Ccrurt- sus-\ei.\\'\S -\h~ dnJ~ctrav\S -kl ~\1\l{lsc\\c..,\--tcv\ a\fl· . aO..Qxo'f>\\0\.\-6 or-Aec-·s'rlaU ~ en\-ex-EA, ·u tnedcJect-rms. \6 .~\.l'rfSai&talf\ fS ·o\l'e.'\'("0\ \eA , -fue ob.Je:chffi ?Qr-W VY\(L~ +h.e.!4e: ffi.tcr- . · . o..{).Q fue &u1(-\- to s -\o,Je 1' \<.J .. , . At+er C0(""..\!eds u(lt( \ a.C-tcr- Y1E- \nQs f~\QJ . \n 1s ~\ rs+- \\101. ·m l1J'n'tc..\A atnou.vtts to a Su.'o:J-\-QI()4-r\16 due . ?r-6U:SS. \J1D\~-\-ion ~ ·~~\a-\<:K '<"e5ill.e:<5t::S ~a.~da.w'\ll~ 'fe\le.'t .frcXil i\s)~ . tru~<+- . .I S5UE 1\t\lo~ -n?i.iks 'RULE60\= APPELLAIE 'PKOCEDL\KE RULE 52- .AS .CK 1~iY1aJ ?t-~t n~S. See:.~.:,~':\ ej.:\-ytAO'Cd \I()Cl'\ led wi-\-\r\ -~(\ttl\\ \fes(Jcc+ , o" ~c..-holf\ \~ (\o+- mn1V\-bl\no..'o\e _ll . Sec ~\.)\", n3u s \J, \iliad lt..J (liz..~) \ \~ I e'JC. SSI 1 22~ Sv-J z.d ID84 \ I . tJl c.... Cd \e.~'( \J. tJo w ~on , SoliJ £vJ. '2d q-2.2- q36 CwCAco \ . Re.\o.+or \!as Challen&:d Wh .Su..bJec.t- MoJ+er oncl Pex-sora...\ . ~u'\i.Sd \ c..\-ic'f\ \ n \\Je \(_eq_ues+ ~ r 5{'Ec\a...\ 1\-Q{)eo.(a'f\<:.Q..., !he . ~+ fG("" S S-\o..-\-:Ll\-"CJC--\ .Y~o\I\Sial{\5 G( \\lela~ Klh.~Es u\=b..VlL~uLf\2_t L..vernar+~AY\n.) . . Ku\0 \?....60-. I me- t-u\eS Ult'ld.€'-r 1-n IS -{/roV\.S Ia VI • ( 1 mus+- 'a? eomol ied . 1 . W(-\--\rl ~"·a\\. res9ec-\-S .... • 1\ie- C'CLL\.Seotac+toV'I cHid 'fe:med4 .ror i+'s II . . e.'<\fo'\tt'(\{\e\(\k ~ c-·· a~ W)CW\dcd--e'("Ll 0.~ 6PEARANCE w~ MCitlCAu\-\--ot 11 . f\ssc\te'\o..~\0~ Q{\c\ v-\e~\ ·d-s tlui(0D5e ·,s -1-D de:~ea_+ o... C:c.LUSe c,~ o..cJ·ran \10'rt-Vlol.A:f- . '{'e:., ~Cln:i +-o \D\neA-heY +he: Cla.[«tS QSSe~c+-ed DLl\J~ ffi~r~+ .'' NLXECE:J . . LJm.n\1 vI uALE ~ot::~ . 'I() +\ne ?re5€\ll+- &se +he C.O..LJLSe- o{) .o.t-461ll \JJ~S ~nsrd~re-d Q trtV\!Jln.aJ Prnc.~ertt\1~ and cJcnrYlS ,Q5SE:'C-·h::~d i.JJe:..'\E: N\ll..'('de\ under ~e1.CS'PenQl Cock. A-r+. lq,62_, Ac.u'tAiru\l.\, iJ.)\t\~ Cho.\\eYV2li()3 ju,y-r:sdic.A-~·ol() ~tx:clcJ!'-1 . ?er-scw1a\ JL\I(i5d\·c..~lan \ 'e.eto...b-- UV\u.s.\-- ~a~ o. Sf>eciu.J AoPea'raoce:. ~ o \on~ u..Jt \--h an u~~\~a.\fl.\- o'\ Cec..\CA~i-\oVJ (C.Olelk~~~n~ ~1<:: \h..c__\- . . +\lQ+ Re\CA-\-o\ \~ no-\- llW\eno.'o\e: to --\-ne: ?x-oCQ.S~ ot- ~~~~ cbur~s) . ~~-~ .'?u<"SU0\1-\- -\-o 'RL\\~ lm c>.. -r~ms11Z.ule-:s c§ t.1u·1 \ +>n~cc..-dutfe: LT. \2., C.1\1. . 11 . '?roc_.-) &i\cc.6~di n3 t-G l.cAt.U 1 0'nruld 4-\ne:: &u\rt-+lna.-t +he: 5(1ecroJ . AP9eo..'('a.\\c:e: \A..)(]_S o~-\ed I\'\, Jti,'-1-t\'le Re.Que~t- "Fe\ SQec\cJ . t~Q~eo..'tane..c 1 T\'te: \2..eS,ct~x· \Y\L\.5~ X'e~-s+ .9o\'"' .:F;·(\dtYI~ G~ . ~0\.c-\s and CL:nc1us1o\l\~ o~ lllw "', rJ~'\. DG\\1 E-n'\ersan ~a..:s . (')6,-\-'hec de.n ted oc SUSbll()~ +\1Q \eq_ocs-\- \'-o(" sQec.\o..\ . . ~QQro"Ci'(llk,, \\!e. Lo.w Q!A~~x:- Shte~ , ~'Ylovtlcl -the: C.OU.r+-- 11 . (\o+ (D'('()<\J\L\ i-Yte ~~c}.J-oc- muz:rt \)v._~u.~ -\-'rle~ exlt-1.\-~e:-rne:n+ un~ ..T. 12.._. C-1\/ .?'""-ac . K.~\.e: L_.q~,-2.41, lD'nic.\n l.:s -h+led tr tJcr\-::rc.E or=:- . ?A:SI 'DL\"E 1==AG\S ~:r:~L)J:.NQj 'l L:\. Ku\~ -z,q-rl &c~ f\A'(, . tbf\ Sroe6GD \rlc\5 ncA C.6\''fl\)\ \e.ct \JJ\\-\1\ ~0\\Q: l1.0o__, ~e_\DvtO'r . ~{\(\D.\- e:'f,.erc_csc. e.Cl-\--1-\-\e:me.h-\- U\l'lclc Rll~~ Lq{ o.INl/0r R~k::L.ctf.o, . . o \en~ \J...)·lm ILu.\~ ll...CHJ-.. ~ ;g,u\· F --z._q{_u , ct:r·t~ erN ~ 1-'("1E:d. in fue. D1.s-\-~1c.-\- er (1)Lw\+~ ~1[+- . . uJ i.\-hQ)\Jtt ~ ~lA_'\Y , 0\1'1 Vo..\r+-'-1 r·ncd 'Ce 1e~o.::s ?~s:s Qll(\)cl ~ lt·bo-u\t- the ?r--e> Pe r . \E:S 9cnsE ~-c-Gm N\v--. L)a() Eme.c.~'fl , :Rec\ec\o~ IS 'Dlac.d. . a+ r1tSQ~ \fo.'e\\o__-\e: Ccux-.t- -rev\~0-)'S 0\._~\Q\ Cou.v+-'s . . ~u l\ (\~ 0'() 6. V\ea_ :r--6 --\ntJV\.x-i~\c..-\-ICif'l uruer d.~ '(\0\16 Stundan1 . Q(' '{""6\}[eu-::> '\J-~Qa~S£ uv\Ck\( f-A15 R~'e, -\D fu\e L.-~LC2- \ZQ:loJor-- \S en-\-\ t)ed b K.eR.LLE:S·f- . 'Pllr-SLAL!\r\.,l.-- :a ~\ndt'<19S oC ~ o.~ LbVJ~lcV\ ~ l.cu.0 wi\v\ln L..a da_y.s . a:Qte__r :JuA~'meV\~, ""3:6. \, R.,C..\\1, ?'fOe: .. \i\f\('. \J:3n Emersal{\ die , . \lo-\- ?'«J\J\ck CA r:\e:ar ...J~~iffieu\ + In ffi£· AbovE: Co..~ c~ . a.c.,\-tcV\ • \Yve:re to\1\ 'ae: \'\0 '\e4.lle:~ ~\" o... :M0d \(1<::) c-fhldS .()~. C!JI(IC\us1~t\ oQ lAw VJ\~ou~ Q ,1\.;\.c\~meht-. -rhes~ am . S\-oJ-u.,-\-o\'-1 Pv-o v \S 1o\f\~ --\hclt O..'\e:. \'Y\Cl~ato\~ a~ e'iclu.Sf UG * •. :-ISSLLE-"\t-l1Z.EE: A~~fflent PrG'<\Dl,\\lc.ed bY ~ Cuuv-t u.Sr\-\Jlo-u-t 11 atficn x-E:\ea.~,, .. \l .Ja\Aif\SG'() ·v, Le'<'"~'S\- , '331..\ u.s. 4"5~ 1 t((aI, . '1 V!.~ LICJ -s~~ . 10 Re\Q-to, nas cn~\\en~ \y,u_\ Cc)}'ftS ou.mo~~+-~ \-6 ?coruv..\f\ce .. . JlJt6~'ffien+ \'{) eo.~ if\u.W'\\nE-r- ~~\ -z._l\4 -\J. i( A- c.Y\a\lense-t-o +n:: .~U\r,So(c.J-t or\ ().{) fue. CD\1\x--t- ~~ '<\0\- \.ln\ vcd \o'i {b_d u\re: +c 'ci.rse . 4-\-\Q: 1'SS ue: ' n h-1 cJ eou~rt- 0' o'C\ 0.\ \e:& MAeal ': .ko..u. .\?mo.\(\ v . . u\.1-s , , ~qq u.~ l ?.11, ~-z._7_, . 'Re:\Q \a'\ nus ~c~ fuo._.\- Vle:: \S \\cA 0.\iYex\a.\d.e: -\6 \e-{0-S . 'P1l)0=SS dULe:: -\a Lx\-\~(")S\r\\9 2-\-o....t\.AS' \4::\a..\-o<"' \='o\\C>~ . 4\\G~-\a._~\orl 'ProV.\S\DV\S a_(\d_ \'\\\\0~ CA-~liSe D\ ac.-\--tcV\ . 0\1\cL x--e:Med~ u\N!LQ__r- \Z.t1\~ ll.O ~ ~ ~~~ *\-oVISicro 01[6 . IY'tOY!doJ-o'\'-J a\\td E:keiUSivt: ll J.-LL .M. ....:..:·~c...;;..::::hcf¥s-L ~~ \JJA\.~-M~ ~La.. ~1{\e:,~\ c..\o.lf'i .3:tt19a.~C-\'-I ·:rnwest · ~<"\Jero-i LlV\OJL'\--:-~tll • -:I:\\1 'Vw'?r \CA.. ~e<~~" ~'-I -·\<'1-~--\--, cJ~::> il:\"Ll-11....1..q -GL\ \ c\eroe~-u~t q(..wl 5?U\~Q.\ ~W\CL'n1.\l!.:> '~ 6 q \()(] II Fa2.~1\1E M.UDtRMJALE-\~ tESIU'I. &ut::\J.:re~ taLrt YUA:-r:ro~ . ·""3.--, ,\.1\.-\ \6 ~x-ac\ole: C)~ \\re ~~\J\~ \}. .h \\lo.W\~ -lA:\\ , ~'d ¥a_~ . --r..~'Y\ed 'A-0\>\\C-c.L\--~o'() 9o r U-Jf (+a~ . ~\{\~~\1'\U.S cur~~ C\\f\6£bl(,ec_-t- \-6 --\-re \res+-- o~ m'-l 'K¥tawle-d9S. . L ZCB US..C..U\ \t<-H.a..\ ~LL.Gcl1~~ \'·h ·-x.- \'\Cl\JE:J~ 11'\-t o.. w\A.-e_ 01i~ . tDx:-'\ec..-\ eo\)~ -\-o ~'\ \ LbV\ B~Y\ at ; D f'5+r L c.:\-- Co1A.v-t- ~\d~ • 54-e 4 ~ ") 5:3\ "S' 1--~\l mo'fe.. ' AvY\ai d \6 'T~ Lt ct l o I "J. . v t r;;..__ b I\\ ~\ e.-Meu\-\:S ~~\ ~\1\r\ . J:s I