Untitled Texas Attorney General Opinion

hnuary 11, 1952 Hon. Homer Garrison, Jr., Director Texas Department of Public Safety Austin, Texas, Opinion No. V- 1385 Re: Authority of the Depart- ment of Public Safety to extend the period for com- pulsory inspection of mo- tor vehicles under House Bill 223, Acts 52nd Legis- lature, R.S. 1951, through Dear Colonel Garrison: September 6, 1952. Your request for an opinion in connection with the above- captioned matter reads in part as follows: “Under the provisions of House Bill 223, Acts of the 52nd Legislature, R.S. 1951, ch. 141, p. 240, it is specifically provided that the Department of rub- lit Safety ‘shall cause one (1) inspection to be made in the year commencing with the effective date of this Act [September 7, 19511 and annually thereafter. The period of inspection shall be .fixed by the Depart- ment. The Department shall have power to make rules aa d regulations with respect to the periods and the character and extent of the inspections to be made.’ “The Department of Public Safety has hereto- fore designated the period beginning December 1, 1951 and ending April 1, 1952 as the inspection period for the first twelve months commencing as of September 7, 1951. “Because of the limited number of inspection stations in this State and the fact that there are more than three million motor vehicles to be inspected, in our opinion it is impossible-for all vehicles to be in- spected prior to the deadline for registration for the year 1952, which is April 1, 1952. In this connection, your attention is specifically directed to that portion of House Bill 223 wherein it is provided that ‘no li- cense of a motor vehicle shall be issued and no trans- fer of the title to a motor vehicle shall be made unless Hon. Homer Garrison, Jr., page 2 (V-1385) such motor vehicle has been inspected under the terms of this Act within 12 months prior to the is- suance of such license or transfer.’ Mdill you, therefore, be so kind as to advise us on the following questions: “( 1) May the Department of I~ublic Safety legally extend the inspection period heretofore designated from April 1, 1952, to and including midnight of Sep- tember 6, 1952? “(2) If your answer to question no. 1 is in the affirmative, then may motor ve- hicles be registered for the current registration year and transfers of title be effected on motor vehicles without an inspection certificate up to and including midnight of Septem- ber 6, 1952 ? ” House Bill 223, Acts 52nd Leg., R.S. 1951, ch. 141, p. 240, amends, among other things, Section 140 of Article 6701d, Ver- non’s Civil Statutes, the “Uniform Act Regulating Traffic on High- ways ,* so as to provide in part as follows: “(a) It shall be the duty of the Texas Depart- ment of Public Safety to require every owner of a motor vehicle, trailer, semitrailer, pole trailer or house trailer, registered in this State, to have the mechanism, brakes, and equipment upon such ve- hicles inspected at State appointed inspection sta- tions or by State Inspectors as hereinafter provided . . . “(b) If such inspection discloses the necessity for adjustments, corrections or repairs, the mecha- nism, brakes and equipment shall be adjusted, cor- rected or repaired before a certificate is issued . . . The owner may have such adjustments, corrections or repairs made by such qualified person or per- sons as he may choose . . . “(c) Official inspection stations appointed and supervised by the State of Texas shall make all inspec- tions pursuant to the provisions of this Section . . . The Department [Texas Department of Public Safety] shall cause one (1) inspection to be made in the year Hon. Homer Garrison, Jr., page 3 (V-1385) commencing with the effective date of this Act [September 7, 19511, and annually thereafter. The periods of inspection shall be fixed by the Department. The Department shall have power to make rules and regulations with respect to the periods and the character and extent of the inspections to be made.” (Emphasis ours.) Acting pursuant to the provisions of paragraph (c), your Department has heretofore designated the period begin- ning December 1, 1951, and ending April 1, 1952, as the “period of inspection” for the, yearly period which began on September 7. 1951, the effective date of the act. Because it has now been determined that it is physically impossible for the designated inspection stations to perform the required inspections on the more than three million motor vehicles in this State within the designated inspection period, you desire to know whether you may legally amend the designated “period of inspection” so as to extend it to and including midnight of September 6, 1952. The above-quoted provisions of the act make it clear that your Department shall “cause one (1) inspection to be made in the year” commencing on September 7, 1951. It is then pro- vided in clear and unambiguous language that the periods of in- spection shall be “fixed” by the Texas Department of I-ublic Safe- ty. Under the plain wording of the act you could have originally fixed the period of inspection at any time within the twelve-month period beginning with the effective date of the act on September 7, 1951. Having the power to fix or establish a regulation carries with it the implied power to modify or amend the regulation. Rail- road Commission v. Shell Oil Company, 139 Tex. 66, 161 S.W.Zd m (1942); 42 A m. UT. 360, Public Administrative Law, Sec. 53. Furthermore, we think the Legislature used the lan- guage found in paragraph (c) with respect to periods of inspec- tion being “fixed by the Department” advisedly. Unquestionably the Legislature had knowledge of the more than three million motor vehicles traversing the highways of Texas which would have to be inspected under the provisions of this act. Having this knowledge, it obviously desired that the fixing of the pirriods of inspection be as flexible as possible to the end that an unreason- able, unjust, or impracticable consequence would not result. The situation now facing your Department demonstrates the wisdom of the Legislature in leaving to your Department the power to fix the periods of inspection as circumstances and conditions might re- quire. We therefore agree with you that the Texas Depart- ment of Iublic Safety may legally amend the regulation designat- ing December 1, 1951, to April 1, 1952, as the “period of inspection,” Hon. Homer Garrison, Jr., page 4 (V-1385) so as to provide that the “period of inspection” shall be “from December 1, 1951, to midnight of September 6, 1952.” We will now consider your second question relating to the necessity for an “inspection certificate” in order to regis- ter a motor vehicle for the current registration year or to trans- fer the title thereto. Article 6675a-3, V.C.S , requires that the application for the renewal of registration of a motor vehicle “be made not later than April 1st” of each year. House Bill 223, supra, provides in paragraph (e) there- of as follows: “(e) No license of a motor vehicle shall be is- sued and no transfer of the title to a motor vehicle shall be made unless such motor vehicle has been inspected under the terms of this Act niithin twelve (12) months prior to the issuance of such license or transfer. After the period designated for the inspec- t-person shall operate on the highways of this State any motor vehicle registered in this State un- less a valid certificate of ir@pection is displayed thereon as required. by this Section and any inspector or patrolman of the Department of Public Safety, or any sheriff or deputy sheriff, who shall exhibit his badge or other signs of authority, may stop any motor vehicle not displaying this inspection certif- icate on the windshield and require the owner or operator to produce an official inspection certificate for the motor vehicle being operated.” (Art. 6701d, Sec. 140, V.C.S.) (Emphasis added.) It is a cardinal rule of statutory construction that all the laneuage and every part of an act must be given effect, if rea- sonably possible. Texas Bank & Trust Co. v, Austin, 115 Tex. 201, 280 S.W. 161 (1926). Likewise. an act must be construed as a whole, and all:its na’rts harmonized. if uossible. so as to give effect to the entire act. - Popham v. Patterson, 121 Tex. 615, 51 s’.WW.2d 680 (1932); Citizens National Bank of Hillsboro v. ‘Graham, 117 Tex. 357. 4 S.W. Za 541 (19-D County v. Thompson, 95 ‘I%%. 22. 64 S N. 927 (1901); 2 Sutherlaz, Statutory Construction (3rd Ed. 1943) 336, Sec. 4703. Applying these rules of construction to House Bill 223, supra, we think that if your Department amends the designated period ofinspection so as to extend the time for inspection to midnight of Hon. Homer Garrison, Jr., page 5 (V-1385) September 6, 1952, a person will not be required to have an inspec- tion certificate prior to or at the time of making application for registration of his motor vehicle for the 1952 registration year. The same is true with respect to applications for transfer of title to a motor vehicle prior to midnight of September 6, 1952. This is true for the reason that the act specifically authorizes the De- partment of Public Safety to fix the period for inspection and makes the operation of an uninspected, but registered, vehicle unlawful only “after the period designated for the inspection.” Moreover, it would be an impracticable and unreasonable construction to say that the Legislature intended that a motor vehicle which is required by law to be registered on or prior to April 1, 1952, could not be registered on or before that date without an inspection certificate when the Department of Public Safety has by the express authority of the Legislature extended the time in which to have motor ve- hicles inspected to a date beyond that fixed by statute for registra- tion. Cf. Huntsville Independent School Dist. v. McAdams, 148 Tex. 120, 221 S.< You are therefore advised, in answer to your second question, that if the Department of Public Safety extends the desig- nated period of inspection for motor vehicles to midnight of Sep- tember 6, 1952, then no certificate of inspection will be required in making application for the registration of a motor vehicle or in making application for a transfer of title on or prior to September 6, 1952. SUMMARY The Texas Department of Public Safety may legally amend its regulation fixing the period of in- spection for motor vehicles for-the year which com- menced September 7, 1951, so as to extend the desig- nated inspection period to midnight of September 6, 1952. In such event, no certificate of inspection will be required in making application for the registra- tion of a motor vehicle, or in making application for a transfer of title thereto, prior to midnight of Sep- tember 6. 1952. Yours very truly, Attorney Generai CDM:b wi.zT, p2!7s%y Charles D. Mathews First Assistant