2019 Opinions – Supreme Court of Georgia
Skip to content
2019 Opinion and Summaries
2019 OpinionsWeb Editor2019-11-14T15:16:07-05:00
DISCLAIMER:
These opinions are subject to the parties’ motion for reconsideration, the Court’s reconsideration, and editorial changes made by the Reporter of Decisions. An opinion designated as “Final Copy” is the Supreme Court’s official opinion as published in the advance sheets. Please Note: Adobe Acrobat Reader is necessary to read the following opinions. You may download Adobe Acrobat Reader here if necessary. Thank you.
November
November 4, 2019 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S19A1086. HENRY v. THE STATE
- S19A1109. HOWARD v. THE STATE
- S19A1129. GUERRERO v. THE TATE
- S19A1171. MOORE v. THE STATE
- S19A1264. JONES v. THE STATE
- S19A1332. MATTEI v. THE STATE
- S19A1436. HOPWOOD v. THE STATE
- S19Y1156. IN THE MATTER OF MILLARD C. FARMER, JR.
- S19Y1329. IN THE MATTER OF JOEL S. WADSWORTH
- S19Y1553. IN THE MATTER OF NEVADA MICHAEL TUGGLE
- S20Y0079. IN THE MATTER OF WILLIAM LESLIE KIRBY III
October
October 31, 2019 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S19A0535. THE STATE v. BEARD
- S19A0597. RICKS v. THE STATE
- S19A0644. GREEN v. THE STATE 11-14-2019 Substitute opinion issued.
- S19A0684. DADDARIO v. THE STATE
- S19A0769. RHONDA J. MARTIN et al. v. FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF REGISTRATION AND ELECTIONS et al.
- S19A0789. SHAW v. THE STATE
- S19A0803. EBERHART v. THE STATE
- S19A0825, S19X0826. FORD v. TATE (and vice versa)
October
October 21, 2019 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S18G1326. LANGLEY v. MP SPRING LAKE, LLC
- S18G1419. DEKALB COUNTY SCHOOL DISTRICT et al. v. GOLD et al.
- S18G1546. MOBLEY v. THE STATE
- S19A0541. LEILI v. THE STATE
- S19A0557. THE STATE v. TOWNS
- S19A0658. COLLIER v. THE STATE
- S19A0682. ANDERSON v. THE STATE
- S19A0705. MOHAMED v. THE STATE
- S19A0721. POWELL v. THE STATE
- S19A0749, S19A0750, S19A0751. SMITH v. THE STATE (three cases)
- S19A0755. THORNTON v. THE STATE
- S19A0908. MCKINNEY v. THE STATE
- S19A0953. HENRY v. THE STATE
- S19A0957. CAUSEY v. THE STATE
- S19A1352. DOS SANTOS v. THE STATE
October
October 7, 2019 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S18G1149. GEORGIACARRY.ORG, INC. et al. v. ATLANTA BOTANICAL GARDENS, INC.
- S18G1189, S18G1190. ROCKDALE HOSPITAL, LLC v. EVANS et al. (two cases)
- S18G1495. PENNINGTON v. THE STATE
- S18G1599. MCCLURE v. THE STATE
- S19A0530. RODRIGUES v. THE STATE
- S19A0533. FRANKLIN v. THE STATE
- S19A0554. MITCHUM v. THE STATE
- S19A0590. VELASCO v. THE STATE
- S19A0616. MYRICK v. THE STATE
- S19A0696. BENTLEY v. THE STATE
- S19A0785. HOWARD v. THE STATE
- S19A0820. BROWN v. THE STATE
- S19A0936. SMITH v. THE STATE
- S19A0937. JACKSON v. THE STATE
- S19A1042. SCOTT v. THE STATE
- S19A1204. COLQUITT v. THE STATE
- S19A1394. JOHNSON v. THE STATE
- S19Y1546. IN THE MATTER OF DENISE F. HEMMANN
- S19Y0527. IN THE MATTER OF SHERRI JEFFERSON
- S19Z1117. IN THE MATTER OF JOAN PALMER DAVIS
September
September 23, 2019 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S19A0594. GENO WEST v. THE STATE
- S19A0655. POLO GOLF and COUNTRY HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION, INC. v. CUNARD et al.
- S19A0699. THE STATE v. DENSON
- S19A0866. HILLS v. THE STATE
- S19A0912. HAWKINS v. THE STATE
- S19A0975. HERON LAKE II APARTMENTS, LP et al. v. LOWNDES COUNTY BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS
September
September 9, 2019 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S19A0489. MARTIN v. THE STATE
- S19A0491. SMITH v. THE STATE
- S19A0591. RIGGS v. THE STATE
- S19A0681. DAVIS v. THE STATE
- S19A0762. REID v. THE STATE
- S19A0913. RICHARDS v. THE STATE
September
September 3, 2019 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S19A0540. WALKER v. THE STATE
- S19A0613. THE STATE v. HOLMES
- S19A0654. HARDY v. THE STATE
- S19A0661. LEE v. THE STATE
- S19A0688. SEABROOKS v. THE STATE
- S19A0707. WILLIAMS v THE STATE
- S19A0722. THE STATE v. HAMILTON
- S19A0747. BRYANT v. THE STATE
- S19A0784. COWEN v. CLAYTON COUNTY et al.
- S19A0795. JACKSON v. THE STATE
- S19A0860. WILLIAMS v. THE STATE
- S19A0927. BENTON v. HINES
- S19A0951. VARNER v. THE STATE
August
August 19, 2019 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S18G1644. SCOTT v. THE STATE
- S19A0490. MCCAMMON v. THE STATE
- S19A0559. HOLMES v. THE STATE
- S19A0603. THE STATE v. COLEMAN
- S19A0618. MOORE v. THE STATE
- S19A0635. MARTIN v. THE STATE 8-20-2019 Substitute opinion issued.
- S19A0659. COOPER v. THE STATE
- S19A0683. GLENN V. THE STATE
- S19A0694. SMITH v. THE STATE
- S19A0695. DANIELS v. THE STATE
- S19A0715. FOREMAN v. THE STATE
- S19A0723. JACOBS v. THE STATE
- S19A0791. COX v. THE STATE
- S19A0801. BLACKWELL v. THE STATE
- S19A0818. WALKER v. THE STATE
- S19A0854. FOSTER v. THE STATE 8-19-2019 Substitute opinion issued.
- S19A0880. DAVIS v. THE STATE
- S19A0924. WORTHEN v. THE STATE
- S19A0947. MACK v. THE STATE
- S19A0954. ROBINSON V. THE STATE
- S19Y0873. IN THE MATTER OF CHRISTOPHER JOHN THOMPSON 8-19-2019 Substitute opinion issued.
- S19Y1128. IN THE MATTER OF PHILLIP NORMAN GOLUB
- S19Y1192. IN THE MATTER OF CHARLES EDWARD TAYLOR
August
August 5, 2019 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S19A0508. EVANS v. THE STATE
- S19A0509. RHYNES v. THE STATE
- S19A0598. SCOTT v. THE STATE
- S19A0611. GUDE v. THE STATE
- S19A0643. DAVIS v. THE STATE
- S19A0646. THE STATE v. JACKSON
- S19A0665. DERRICO v. THE STATE
- S19A0669. CAIN v. THE STATE
- S19A0686. VICTORIA v. THE STATE
- S19A0739. CHEEVES v. THE STATE
- S19A0741. ABNEY V. THE STATE
- S19A0765. LEWIS v. THE STATE
- S19A0809. COLLINS v. THE STATE
- S19A0819. GLYNN CO. SCHOOL DIST v. BRUNSWICK-GLYNN CO. JOINT WATER & SEWER COMM.
- S19A0846. WELCH v. THE STATE
- S19A0861. JACKSON v. THE STATE
- S19A0868. CHAPMAN v. THE STATE
- S19A0882. GRAVES v. THE STATE
- S19A0886. SHUBERT v. THE STATE
- S19A0899. MORTON v. THE STATE
- S19A0985, S19A0986. MOORE v. THE STATE (two cases)
- S19Y1164, S19Y1165, S197166. IN THE MATTER OF JEFFREY L. SAKAS (three cases)
July
July 1, 2019 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S19Y0608. IN THE MATTER OF EDWARD NEAL DAVIS
- S19Y0709. IN THE MATTER OF CLARENCE A. SYDNOR, IV
- S19Y0977. IN THE MATTER OF CHERYL JOYCE BRAZIEL
- S19Y1168. IN THE MATTER OF HAKEEM BERTRAND BROCK
June
June 28, 2019 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S18G0976. BUDHANI v. THE STATE
- S18G1136. BOURASSA v. STATE OF GEORGIA
- S19A0209, S19X0210. THE STATE v. MONDOR (and vice versa)
- S19A0331. ELKINS v. THE STATE
June
June 24, 2019 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S18G1022. MERCER UNIVERSITY v. STOFER et al.
- S19A0018. BOYD v. THE STATE
- S19A0042. VASQUEZ v. THE STATE
- S19A0047. BRANT v. THE STATE
- S19A0069. HENRY v. SPIVEY
- S19A0116. FLEMING v. THE STATE
- S19A0146. WILKES & McHUGH P.A. et al. v. LTC CONSULTING, L.P. et al.
- S19A0166. VENTURINO v. THE STATE
- S19A0231. JACKSON v. THE STATE 6-25-2019 Substitute opinion issued.
- S19A0373. TAYLOR v. THE STATE
- S19A0418 . BANNISTER v. THE STATE
- S19A0460. CITY OF COLLEGE PARK v. CLAYTON COUNTY et al.
June
June 20, 2019
- S19I1232. PEEPLES v. BRAZELL et al.
June
June 10, 2019 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S18G1007. MCKIE v. THE STATE
- S18G1354. THE STATE v. BURNS
- S19A0118, S19A0119. BROXTON v. THE STATE (two cases)
- S19A0164, S19A0416. DAVIS v. THE STATE (two cases)
- S19A0360. SWANSON v. THE STATE
- S19A0367. CLARK v. THE STATE
- S19A0605. COOPER v. THE STATE
- S19A0674. TOOKES v. THE STATE
- S19A0790, S19A0907. STROZIER v. THE STATE (two cases)
- S19M0969. DUKE v. STATE
- S19Y0792. IN THE MATTER OF LESLEY ANNIS
- S19Y0823. IN THE MATTER OF ALEXANDER E. KAHN
June
June 3, 2019 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S18G0699. ADAMS v. THE STATE
- S18G0876, S18G1107. MILLIKEN & COMPANY. v. GEORGIA POWER COMPANY (two cases)
- S18G0947. NORDAHL v. THE STATE
- S19A0095. DOZIER v. THE STATE
- S19A0172. RIGSBY v. THE STATE
- S19A0177. WALKER v. THE STATE
- S19A0185. THE STATE v. WILLIAMS
- S19A0224. GOINS v. THE STATE
- S19A0289. ROWLAND v. THE STATE
- S19A0343. JACKSON v. THE STATE
- S19A0366. BLACKMON v. THE STATE
- S19A0378. DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY OF COBB COUNTY et al. v. STATE OF GEORGIA et al.
- S19A0428. BOWMAN v. THE STATE
- S19A0565. GOLSON v. THE STATE
- S19Q0249. THOMASTON ACQUISITION, LLC v. PIEDMONT CONSTRUCTION GROUP, INC. et al.
- S19Y0706. IN THE MATTER OF JONNIE MAE GRAHAM
- S19Y0959. IN THE MATTER OF PRESTON B. KUNDA
May – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
May 20, 2019
- S17Y1532. IN THE MATTER OF JOHN DENNIS DUNCAN Reinstatement issued.
May 20, 2019
- S18G0944, S18G0945. CITY OF GUYTON et al. v. BARROW (two cases)
- S18G1316, S18G1317. GEORGIA DEPARTMENT OF LABOR v. MCCONNELL et al. (and vice versa)
- S18G1338. IN THE INTEREST OF M.F., a child
- S19A0066. SPELL v. THE STATE
- S19A0149. COCHRAN v. THE STATE
- S19A0173. GOODEN v. THE STATE
- S19A0279. STROTHER v. THE STATE
- S19A0297. BAILEY v. THE STATE
- S19A0308. DAVIS v. THE STATE
- S19A0324. COLLETT v. THE STATE
- S19A0348. WILLIAMS v. THE STATE
- S19A0384. BRADLEY v. THE STATE
- S19A0409. CARTER v. THE STATE
- S19A0419. DAVIS v. THE STATE
- S19A0440. CARTER v. THE STATE
- S19A0443. MOSS v. THE STATE
- S19A0634. GRIER v. THE STATE
- S19Y1076. IN THE MATTER OF RICHARD SCOTT THOMPSON
May – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
May 6, 2019
- S18G0994. THE STATE v. ORR 5-13-2019 Substitute opinion issued.
- S19A0068. JONES v. THE STATE
- S19A0101. JONES v. THE STATE
- S19A0157. THE STATE v. TURNQUEST
- S19A0276. WILLIAMSON v. THE STATE
- S19A0346. WILLIAMS v. THE STATE
- S19A0351, S19A0352. HANEY V STATE (two cases)
April – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
April 29, 2019
- S19A0012. KOONCE v. THE STATE
- S19A0019. OLIVER v. THE STATE
- S19A0031. HART v. THE STATE
- S19A0100. LUCKIE v. BERRY
- S19A0129. WOFFORD v. THE STATE
- S19A0138. MOORE v. THE STATE
- S19A0158. OUTLER v. THE STATE
- S19A0174. BELL v. THE STATE
- S19A0243. PARKS v. THE STATE
- S19A0361. LAY v. THE STATE
- S19A0374. THE STATE v. NEWMAN
- S19Y0645. IN THE MATTER OF LAKEISHA TENNILLE GANTT
- S19Y0980. IN THE MATTER OF DON SMART
April
April 15, 2019 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S19A0027. DOZIER et al. v. WATSON
- S19A0038. CLARK v. THE STATE
- S19A0041. BURGESS v. HALL
- S19A0065. BELLAMY v. RUMER
- S19A0250. DAVIS v. THE STATE
- S19A0323. CASTILLO-VELASQUEZ v. THE STATE
- S19A0392. JONES v. THE STATE
- S19A0439. CARPENTER v. THE STATE
- S19A0457. COLEY v. THE STATE
- S19Y0671. IN THE MATTER OF MELODY YVONNE CHERRY
March
March 13, 2019 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S18G0524. HOUSING AUTHORITY OF THE CITY OF AUGUSTA v. GOULD
- S18A1073. DEBELBOT v. THE STATE
- S18Q1233. FEDERAL DEPOSIT INSURANCE CORPORATION v. LOUDERMILK et al.
March
March 11, 2019 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S18G0364. TYNER v. MATTA-TRONSCOSO et al.
- S18G0517. FIRST ACCEPTANCE INSURANCE COMPANY OF GEORGIA, INC. v. HUGHES
- S18G0563. LICATA v. THE STATE
- S18A1052. YARN v. THE STATE
- S18A1074, S18A1075. ESPRIT v. THE STATE (two cases)
- S18A1090. THE STATE v. ROSENBAUM et al.
- S18A1137. THE STATE v. TEDDER
- S18A1158. THE STATE v. SPRATLIN 3-27-2019 Substitute opinion issued.
- S18A1282. BROOKS v. THE STATE
- S18A1295. WARE v. THE STATE
- S18A1321. DENNARD v. THE STATE
- S18A1467. WEST v. THE STATE
- S18A1562. JOHNSON v. THE STATE
- S19A0180. COAST v. THE STATE
- S19A0430. BLAINE v. THE STATE
- S19Y0337-S19Y0340. IN THE MATTER OF NEIL LARSON (four cases)
- S18Z1232. IN THE MATTER OF LAJUAN MIGUEL CERTION
March
March 4, 2019 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S18G0756. CHAPPUIS et al. v. ORTHO SPORT & SPINE PHYSICIANS SAVANNAH, LLC
- S18G1033. HANHAM et al. v. ACCESS MANAGEMENT GROUP, LP
- S18A1045. MCCORD v. THE STATE
- S18A1071. TYNER v. THE STATE
- S18A1121. CONLEY v. PATE
- S18A1156. FULTON COUNTY v. CITY OF ATLANTA et al.
- S18A1211. PARK v. THE STATE
- S18A1273. OVERTON v. THE STATE
- S18A1322. CHAMBERS v. HALL, WARDEN
- S18A1396. CARTWRIGHT v. CALDWELL
- S18A1394. FAVORS v. THE STATE
- S18A1491. PRICE v. THE STATE
- S18A1593. BECK v. THE STATE
- S18A1598. JACKSON v. THE STATE 3-27-2019 Substitute opinion issued.
- S18A1609. STANFORD v. THE STATE
- S18A1610. CROUCH v. THE STATE
- S19A0296. TUGGLE v. THE STATE
- S19Y0552. IN THE MATTER OF ALVIS MELVIN MOORE
February
February 18, 2019 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S17G2011. BELLSOUTH TELECOMMUNICATIONS, LLC et al. v. COBB COUNTY et al.
- S18G0695, S18G0696. BISHOP v. GOINS et al. (two cases)
- S18A1030. IVEY v. THE STATE
- S18A1048. RILEY v. THE STATE
- S18A1060. GRANT v. THE STATE
- S18A1204. ELLIOTT v. THE STATE
- S18A1231. WYNO v. LOWNDES COUNTY
- S18A1234. WINTERS v. THE STATE
- S18A1252. BEASLEY v. THE STATE
- S18A1275. THE STATE v. JOHNSON
- S18A1299. BENTON v. THE STATE
- S18A1428. GOODSON v. THE STATE
- S18A1429. MOORE v. THE STATE
- S18A1440. ROBERTS v. THE STATE
- S18A1445. BATTLE v. THE STATE
- S18A1519. MILLER v. THE STATE
- S18A1538, S18A1539. VIRGER v. THE STATE (two cases)
- S18A1622, S18X1623. MORGAN COUNTY v. MAY (and vice versa)
February
February 4, 2019 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S18G0078. LA FONTAINE v. SIGNATURE RESEARCH, INC.
- S18G0365. WHITE v. THE STATE
- S18G0493, S18G0499. STATE OF GEORGIA v. INTERNATIONAL INDEMNITY COMPANY et al. (two cases)
- S18A1031. McKELVIN v. THE STATE
- S18A1145. McDANIEL v. THE STATE
- S18A1154. BIRDOW v. THE STATE
- S18A1209. FLANNIGAN v. THE STATE
- S18A1221. WAINWRIGHT v. THE STATE
- S18A1302. CURRY v. THE STATE
- S18A1425. GROGAN v. CITY OF DAWSONVILLE
- S18A1464. HOLLMAN v. THE STATE
- S18A1468. YOUNG v. THE STATE
- S18A1512. THE ANTHEM COMPANIES, INC. et al. v. CHERYL WILLS et al.
- S18A1559. THE STATE v. HANNA
- S19Y0498. IN THE MATTER OF JACK S. JENNINGS
January
January 22, 2019 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S18G0146. PLUMMER v. PLUMMER
- S18A1040. MONDRAGON v. THE STATE
- S18A1195. SOLOMON v. THE STATE
- S18A1208. MIMS v. THE STATE
- S18A1212. WORTHEN v. THE STATE
- S18A1215. RINGOLD v. THE STATE
- S18A1236. CHAVERS v. THE STATE
- S18A1307. DE LA HERNANDEZ v. THE STATE
- S18A1328. RICHARDSON v. THE STATE
- S18A1340. THOMPSON v. THE STATE
- S18A1357. MCDONALD v. THE STATE
- S18A1391. KENNEDY, WARDEN v. HINES
- S18A1434. JORDAN v. THE STATE
- S18A1589. PARKER v. THE STATE
- S18A1629. BARNES v. THE STATE
- S19A0039. STROZIER v. THE STATE
- S19A0153. BISHOP v. HALL, WARDEN
- S19Y0266. IN THE MATTER OF HEATHER E. JORDAN
- S19Y0455. IN THE MATTER OF NATHAN E. HARDWICK, IV
- S19Y0466. IN THE MATTER OF SHANNON DEWAYNE PATTERSON
January
January 7, 2019
- S19Y0028. IN THE MATTER OF SAMUEL WILLIAMS, JR
- S19Y0122. IN THE MATTER OF MELODY YVONNE CHERRY
X