Brodie v. Commissioner

Van Fossan, J.,

dissenting: The processes of reasoning by which the payments by the corporation are construed in the prevailing opinion to constitute income to petitioners seems to me to distort the reasonable intendment of the statute. The cases are also indistinguishable from the well considered opinion of Judge Leech in Raymond J. Moore, 45 B. T. A. 1073. I therefore dissent.