Opinion and Summaries
DISCLAIMER:
These opinions are subject to the parties’ motion for reconsideration, the Court’s reconsideration, and editorial changes made by the Reporter of Decisions. An opinion designated as “Final Copy” is the Supreme Court’s official opinion as published in the advance sheets. Please Note: Adobe Acrobat Reader is necessary to read the following opinions. You may download Adobe Acrobat Reader here if necessary. Thank you.
November
November 2, 2020
- S19G1138, S19G1140-S19G1143. ATLANTA WOMEN’S SPECIALISTS, LLC et al. v. TRABUE et al. (five cases) 11-2-2020 Substitute opinion issued.
November
November 2, 2020 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S19G1612. QUYNN v. HULSEY et al.
- S20A0820, S20A0821, S20A0822. THE STATE v. COPELAND (three cases)
- S21A0115. Woods v. The State
October
October 19, 2020
- S20A0767. SWANN v. THE STATE 10-19-2020 Substitute opinion issued.
- S20A0781. HILL v. THE STATE 10-19-2020 Substitute opinion issued.
October
October 19, 2020 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S19G1478. JOHNS et al. v. SUZUKI MOTOR OF AMERICA, INC. et al. 10-19-2020 Substitute opinion issued.
- S19G1645. CRIPPEN & LAWRENCE INVESTMENT CO., INC. v. A TRACT OF LAND BEING KNOWN AS 444 LEMON STREET et. al.
- S20G0192. GRAY v. THE STATE
- S20A0718. MIDDLETON v. THE STATE
- S20A0786. HARRIS v. THE STATE
- S20A0847. GOINS v. THE STATE
- S20A0872. RAWLS v. THE STATE
- S20A0887. HINKSON v. THE STATE
- S20A0939. JACKSON v. THE STATE
- S20A0986. HENDERSON v. THE STATE
- S20A1019. ATKINS v. THE STATE
- S20A1399. SHARPE v. THE STATE
- S21A0030. RHODEN et al. v. ATHENS-CLARKE COUNTY BOARD OF ELECTIONS et al.
October
October 8, 2020 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S21Q0068. Kemp v. Gonzalez
October
October 6, 2020
- S19G1265. GEER v. PHOEBE PUTNEY HEALTH SYSTEM, INC. 10-6-2020 Substitute opinion issued.
October
October 5, 2020 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S19G1236. GLENN v. THE STATE
- S19G1265. GEER v. PHOEBE PUTNEY HEALTH SYSTEM, INC. 10-6-2020 Substitute opinion issued.
- S19G1491. PREMIER HEALTH CARE INVESTMENTS, LLC v. UHS OF ANCHOR, L.P.
- S19G1619. FULTON COUNTY v. WARD-POAG
- S20A0714. THE STATE v. STEPHENS
- S20A0758. THE STATE v. WHEELER
- S20A0767. SWANN v. THE STATE 10-19-2020 Substitute opinion issued.
- S20A0799. HORTON v. THE STATE
- S20A0827. LESTER v. THE STATE
- S20A1128. COATES v. THE STATE
- S20Y1435. IN THE MATTER OF DANIEL LEE DEAN
- S21Y0002. IN THE MATTER OF DAVID GODLEY RIGDON
September
September 28, 2020 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S19G1095. MENDEZ v. MOATS et al.
- S19G1138, S19G1140-S19G1143. ATLANTA WOMEN’S SPECIALISTS, LLC et al. v. TRABUE et al. (five cases) 11-2-2020 Substitute opinion issued.
- S19G1486. NORMAN et al. v. XYTEX CORPORATION, et al.
- S19G1516. EDVALSON v. THE STATE 9-29-2020 Substitute opinion issued.
- S20G0018. MASSEY et al. v. DUKE BUILDERS, INC.
- S20G0020, S20G0021. AULD v. FORBES (two cases)
- S20G0472. BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS OF LOWNDES COUNTY v. MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF VALDOSTA et al.
- S20A0597. LOWERY v. THE STATE
- S20A0734, S20A0879. LUMPKIN v. THE STATE (two cases)
- S20A0781. HILL v. THE STATE 10-19-2020 Substitute opinion issued.
- S20A0802. LOVE V. THE STATE
- S20A0884. GRAY v. THE STATE
- S20A0878. SATTERFIELD v. THE STATE
- S20A0963. MEHEUX V. THE STATE
- S20A0967. GRIFFIN v. THE STATE
- S20A1010. WELCH v. THE STATE
- S20A1014. BRIDGEWATER v. THE STATE
- S20A1258. EGGLESTON v. THE STATE
- S21Y0081. IN THE MATTER OF PAMELA STUDIVANT STEPHENSON
- S20Y1503. IN THE MATTER OF TIMOTHY WALTER BOYD
September
September 8, 2020 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S19G1026. INNOVATIVE IMAGES, LLC v. SUMMERVILLE et al.
- S20A0632. PEREZ v. THE STATE
- S20A0697. MARSHALL v. THE STATE
- S20A0719. THE STATE v. ABBOTT
- S20A0785. LONG v. THE STATE
- S20A0812. ROBINSON v. THE STATE
- S20A0826. PARKER v. THE STATE
- S20A0856. HARRISON v. THE STATE
- S20A0870. BUTLER v. THE STATE
- S20A0880. SCOTT v. THE STATE
- S20A0910. RUSSELL v. THE STATE
- S20A0934. SNIPES v. THE STATE
- S20A0941. BARTON-SMITH v. THE STATE
- S20A0942. SUBAR v. THE STATE
- S20A0984. ELLISON v. THE STATE
- S20A1004. FISHER v. THE STATE
- S20A1186. WALLACE v. THE STATE
- S20Y0607. IN THE MATTER OF LEIGHTON REID BERRY, JR.
- S20Y1261. IN THE MATTER OF WILLIAM LESLIE KIRBY, III
- S20Y1352. IN THE MATTER OF DENNIS W. HARTLEY
August
August 24, 2020 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S20A0642. CAMPBELL-WILLIAMS v. THE STATE
- S20A0709. HODGES v. THE STATE
- S20A0727. CLAY v. THE STATE
- S20A0855. HARRIS v. THE STATE
- S20A0863. PERRY v. THE STATE
- S20A0865. KIM v. THE STATE
- S20A0873. ANDERSON v. THE STATE
- S20A0895. BROOKS v. THE STATE
- S20A0988. ROBERTS v. THE STATE
- S20A1005. REEVES v. THE STATE
- S20A1024. STUDIVANT v. THE STATE
- S20Q0843. SYNOVUS BANK d/b/a FIRST COMMUNITY BANK OF TIFTON v. KELLEY
August
August 10, 2020 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S20A0580. RINGOLD v. THE STATE
- S20A0583. STEPHENS v. THE STATE
- S20A0633, S20X0634. THE STATE v. GRIER (and vice versa)
- S20A0648. THE STATE v. HINTON
- S20A0668. STYLES v. THE STATE
- S20A0688. CLARK v. THE STATE
- S20A0713. BLACKSHEAR v. THE STATE
- S20A0717. CROSS v. THE STATE 9-10-2020 Substitute opinion issued.
- S20A0721. THOMAS v. THE STATE
- S20A0725. HOOD v. THE STATE
- S20A0726. AGEE v. THE STATE 10-5-2020 Substitute opinion issued.
- S20A0739. McDOWELL v. THE STATE
- S20A0766. RUTLEDGE v. THE STATE
- S20A0780. REYES v. THE STATE
- S20A0782. BROWN v. THE STATE
- S20A0789. GRIFFIN V. THE STATE
- S20A0804. HILL v. THE STATE
- S20A0852. POWELL v. THE STATE
- S20A0859. YOUNG v. THE STATE
- S20A0874. RODRIGUEZ v. THE STATE
- S20A0943. MILLER v. THE STATE
- S20A0946. HEYWARD v. THE STATE
- S20A0966. FINNISSEE v. THE STATE
- S20A1006. GIBBS v. THE STATE
- S20A1021. CLARK v. THE STATE
- S20A1027. ARNOLD v. THE STATE
- S20G0123. SANCHIOUS v. THE STATE
- S20Y1265. IN THE MATTER OF VINCENT CHIDOZIE OTUONYE
- S20Y0869. IN THE MATTER OF ELIZABETH VILA ROGAN
July
July 15, 2020
- S20Y0637. IN THE MATTER OF NEIL RICHARD FLIT
July
July 2, 2020
- S20A0035. DAVENPORT v. THE STATE
July
July 1, 2020
- S19G0852. MIDDLETON v. THE STATE
- S20A0196. LOFTON v. THE STATE
- S20A0441. CALMER v. THE STATE
- S20A0470. POUNDS v. THE STATE
June
June 29, 2020 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S19G0494, S19G0496. BOWDEN v. THE MEDICAL CENTER (and vice versa)
- S20A0013. NELSON v. WILKEY
- S20A0078. WILLIAMS v. THE STATE
- S20A0088. FRAZIER v. THE STATE
- S20A0107. REID v. MORRIS et al.
- S20A0119. SMITH v. THE STATE
- S20A0167. DUNBAR v. THE STATE
- S20A0181. RAINES v. THE STATE
- S20A0216. BURNEY v. THE STATE
- S20A0254. STEPP-McCOMMONS v. THE STATE
- S20A0270. STRONG v. THE STATE
- S20A0328. FRAZEN et al. v. DOWNTOWN DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY OF ATLANTA et al.
- S20A0404. BARBOZA v. THE STATE
- S20A0444, S20X0445. PRIESTER v. THE STATE (and vice versa)
- S20Y0957. IN THE MATTER OF DON SMART
June
June 16, 2020
- S19G0447. FRETT v. STATE FARM EMPLOYEE WORKERS’ COMPENSATION et al.
- S19G0931. CROWDER v. STATE OF GEORGIA
- S20A0064. HEARD v. THE STATE
- S20A0125. SCOTT v. THE STATE
- S20A0133. GLOVER v. THE STATE
- S20A0134. MATHIS v. THE STATE
- S20A0161. S&S TOWING & RECOVERY, LTD et al. v. CHARNOTA
- S20A0177. REDDING V. THE STATE
- S20A0191. THE STATE v. PAULDO
- S20A0227, S20X0228. GARDHIGH v. THE STATE (and vice versa)
- S20A0402. DOBBINS v. THE STATE
- S20A0409. NEWMAN v. THE STATE
- S20A0505. MEDINA v. THE STATE
- S20A1277. TUMLINSON v. DIX
- S20Z0712. IN THE MATTER OF JAMES CALEB CLARKE III
June
June 1, 2020
- S19G0499. DALY et al. v. BERRYHILL et al.
- S19G0967. THE STATE v. HEATH
- S19G1000. GLOBAL PAYMENTS, INC. v. INCOMM FINANCIAL SERVICES, INC.
- S20A0185. SHEALEY v. THE STATE
- S20A0245. THOMPSON v. THE STATE
- S20A0259. NEWTON v. THE STATE
- S20A0355. STINCHCOMB v. THE STATE
- S20A0410. TREADAWAY v. THE STATE
- S20A0414. ROUZAN v. THE STATE
- S20A0483. HAMILTON v. THE STATE
- S20A0500. NORRIS v. THE STATE
- S20A0536. LYONS v. THE STATE
- S20A0857. DIXON v. THE STATE
May
May 18, 2020 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S19G0426. MATHENIA et al. v. BRUMBELOW
- S19G0802. NEW CINGULAR WIRELESS PCS, LLC et al. v. DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE et al.
- S20A0039. JACKSON et al. v. RAFFENSPERGER
- S20A0118. MAHAFFEY v. THE STATE
- S20A0170. WALKER v. THE STATE
- S20A0288. CARSON v. THE STATE
- S20A0309. SULLIVAN v. THE STATE
- S20A0343. HOOD v. THE STATE
- S20A0457. JOHNSON v. WILLIAMS
- S20A0482. HAMPTON v. THE STATE
- S20A0504. THE STATE v. ROWE
- S20Q0374. SAN MIGUEL PRODUCE, INC. v. L.G. HERNDON JR. FARMS, INC.
- S20Y1078. IN THE MATTER OF HOWARD L. SOSNIK
May
May 14, 2020 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S20A1029, S20A1031. BARROW v. RAFFENSPERGER (two cases)
May
May 4, 2020 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S20A0007. EVANS v. THE STATE
- S20A0022. CARTER v. THE STATE
- S20A0103. ROSSER v. THE STATE
- S20A0171. WHITEHEAD v. THE STATE
- S20A0195. COLLINS v. THE STATE
- S20A0217. DAWSON v. THE STATE
- S20A0236. STYLES v. THE STATE
- S20A0258. CLARKE v. THE STATE
- S20A0285. HILL v. THE STATE
- S20A0356. BURLEY v. THE STATE
- S20A0489. OLIVER v. THE STATE
- S20A0871. SPENCER v. THE STATE
- S20Y1015. IN THE MATTER OF TIMOTHY PAUL HEALY
April
April 20, 2020 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S20A0006. KELLER v. THE STATE
- S20A0056. SULLIVAN v. THE STATE
- S20A0127. RICKMAN v. THE STATE
- S20A0158. COLLINS v. THE STATE
- S20A0176. MORRIS v. THE STATE
- S20A0241. WILLIAMS v. THE STATE
- S20A0247. TURNER v. THE STATE
- S20A0265. ROBINSON v. THE STATE
- S20A0344. MOORE v. THE STATE
- S20A0364. MILLS v. THE STATE
- S20A0380. VALRIE v. THE STATE
- S20A0399. HEYWARD v. THE STATE
- S20A0563. SANTANA v. THE STATE
- S20A0819. HOWARD v. THE STATE
- S20Y0754. IN THE MATTER OF D. DUSTON TAPLEY, JR.
April
April 8, 2020
- S18Y1385. IN THE MATTER OF RICARDO L. POLK Reinstatement issued.
April
April 6, 2020 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S19C1565. HOLZHEUSER v. THE STATE
- S19G0473. SRM GROUP, INC. v. TRAVELERS PROPERTY CASUALTY COMPANY OF AMERICA
- S20A0082. THE STATE v. HOLLAND
- S20A0104. McGARITY v. THE STATE
- S20A0153. DRESBACH v. THE STATE
- S20A0159. ROSEBORO v. THE STATE
- S20A0202. HATNEY v. THE STATE
- S20A0218. HUDSON v. THE STATE
- S20A0226. FRAZIER v. THE STATE
- S20A0251. WATTS v. THE STATE
- S20A0252. ENSSLIN v. THE STATE
- S20A0268. HALL v. THE STATE
- S20A0273. MARTIN v. THE STATE
- S19Y1450. IN THE MATTER OF MATTHEW A. DICKASON
- S20Y0209. IN THE MATTER OF MUHAMMAD ABDUL-WARIT ABDUR-RAHIM
- S20Y0312. IN THE MATTER OF JARED MICHAEL ARRINGTON
- S20Y0814. IN THE MATTER OF BARRY WAYNE ROREX 4-6-2020 Substitute opinion issued.
- S20Y0815. IN THE MATTER OF ANDREW DAVID TAYLOR
March
March
March 26, 2020
- S20Y0421. IN THE MATTER OF MARTA MARIA NORIEGA-ALLEN
March
March 13, 2020 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S19A1130, S19X1131. THE STATE v. GATES (and vice versa)
- S19A1163. WILLIAMS v. DEKALB COUNTY et al.
- S19A1253. STUBBS v. HALL
- S19A1410. THE STATE v. REMY
- S19A1506. WATKINS v. BALLINGER
- S20A0026. MATTOX v. THE STATE
- S20A0027. WILSON v. THE STATE
- S20A0058. GLENN v. THE STATE
- S20A0115. MOORE v. THE STATE
- S20A0173. BUNDEL v. THE STATE
- S20A0214. CORLEY v. THE STATE
- S20A0232. SIMMONS v. THE STATE
- S20A0248. THE STATE v. GOFF
- S20A0372. JONES v. THE STATE
- S20Y0679. IN THE MATTER OF MARC CELELLO
February
February 28, 2020 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S18G1436. HILL, KERTSCHER & WHARTON LLP et al. v. MOODY et al.
- S19G0278. BOWEN et al. v. SAVOY et al.
- S19G0422. DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY v. RAGSDALE
- S19A1052, S19A1054. BAMBERG v. THE STATE
- S19A1098. SMITH v. THE STATE
- S19A1120. WESTBROOK v. THE STATE
- S19A1341. SAWYER v. THE STATE
- S19A1361. McELRATH v. THE STATE
- S19A1363. THE STATE v. HAMILTON
- S19A1403. WILKINS v. THE STATE
- S19A1404. JOHNSON v. THE STATE
- S19A1411. CALHOUN v. THE STATE
- S19A1448. HOGAN v. THE STATE
- S19A1474, S19A1475. DEBELBOT v. THE STATE (two cases)
- S19A1496. HYDEN v. THE STATE
- S19A1498. PARHAM v. STEWART
- S19A1577. EDWARDS v. THE STATE
- S19A1579. TOLBERT v. THE STATE
- S19A1580. KILPATRICK v. THE STATE
- S20Y0065, S20Y0066, S20Y0067. IN THE MATTER OF JULIANNE WESLEY HOLLIDAY
February
February 10, 2020 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S18G1549. LEE v. SMITH, II
- S18G1638. COEN v. APTEAN, INC. et al.
- S19G0005. THE STATE v. WILLIAMS
- S19A1044. GITTENS v. THE STATE
- S19A1145. THE STATE v. BRYANT
- S19A1147. MITCHELL v. THE STATE
- S19A1182. HOWELL v. THE STATE
- S19A1203. CITY OF ATLANTA et al. v. ATLANTA INDEPENDENT SCHOOL SYSTEM
- S19A1257. WHITE v. THE STATE
- S19A1261. MORGAN v. THE STATE 2-10-2020 Substitute opinion issued.
- S19A1299, S19X1300. DELOACH v. THE STATE (and vice versa) 3-13-2020 Substitute opinion issued.
- S19A1330. MITCHELL v. THE STATE
- S19A1424. THE STATE v. LANE
- S19A1503. THOMAS v. THE STATE
- S19A1520. WALKER v. THE STATE
- S19A1571. NAPLES v. THE STATE
- S19A1588. TAYLOR v. THE STATE
- S19A1637. LONDON v. THE STATE
- S20A0306. RICHARDSON v. THE STATE
- S20Y0257. IN THE MATTER OF MELVIN T. JOHNSON
January
January 31, 2020
- S18Y0350. IN THE MATTER OF CHRISTOPHER AARON CORLEY Reinstatement issued.
January
January 27, 2020 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S19G0125. WILLIAMS v. THE STATE
- S19G0394. DAVIS v. THE STATE
- S19A1148. SMITH v. THE STATE
- S19A1250. WILLIAMS v. THE STATE
- S19A1256. MANN v. THE STATE
- S19A1261. MORGAN v. THE STATE 2-10-2020 Substitute opinion issued.
- S19A1266. ALLEN v. THE STATE
- S19A1301. MOSLEY v. THE STATE
- S19A1302. REDDING v. THE STATE
- S19A1345, S19A1346. STEPHENS v. THE STATE (two cases)
- S19A1397. MCCLUSKEY v. THE STATE
- S19A1432. DAVIS v. THE STATE
- S19A1476. TAYLOR v. THE STATE
- S19A1492. RICH v. THE STATE 1-27-2020 Substitute opinion issued.
- S19A1518. RAMMAGE v. THE STATE
- S19A1570. JACKSON v. THE STATE
- S19A1592. WELLS v. THE STATE
January
January 13, 2020 – SUMMARIES for NOTEWORTHY OPINIONS
- S19A1004. WHITE v. THE STATE
- S19A1005. DOYLE v. THE STATE
- S19A1079. THE STATE v. STEPHENS et al.
- S19A1151. FLOWERS v. THE STATE
- S19A1187. DAVIS v. THE STATE
- S19A1284. GASTON v. THE STATE
- S19A1298. DRIVER v. THE STATE
- S19A1427. SWIMS v. THE STATE
- S19A1493, S19A1494. FLOYD v. THE STATE
- S19A1551. BANKSTON v. THE STATE
- S19A1572. HARRIS v. THE STATE
- S19A1573. CHAVEZ v. THE STATE
- S19A1641. PERDOMO v. THE STATE
- S19Y1650. IN THE MATTER OF RICHARD M. COLBERT
- S20Y0434. IN THE MATTER OF DAVID GODLEY RIGDON