Commonwealth, Kentucky Board of Nursing v. Sullivan University System, Inc.

NOBLE, J.,

dissenting:

I dissent from the extraordinary relief of vacating the lower court decisions. I agree that the case is now moot, which allows us to avoid the merits of the case. But that requires only that we dismiss the appeal. Mootness does not require, or even allow, an appellate court to dismiss past orders or judgments. Because we conclude that the case is now moot, the decisions of the lower courts are not properly before us.