In Re Benson

NOTE: ThiS order is n0np1'ecedentia1. United States Court of AppeaIs for the FederaI Circuit IN RE GERALD M. BENSON AND KENNETH L. SMITH - 2011-1311 (Se1'ia1 N0. 1 1/O61,327) Appea1 from the United States Patent; and Tr'ademark Office, B0ard of Patent AppealS and Interferer1ees. IN RE GERALD M. BENSON AND KENNETH L. SMITH 2011-1312 (Seria1 N0. 09/515,978) Appeal from the UI1ited StateS Patent and Trademark 0fHce, B0ard of Patent Appeals and Interferences. ON MOTION IN RE BENSON 2 Before RADER, Chief Judge, DYK and O’MALLEY, Circuit Judges. O’MALLEY, C'ircuit Judge. 0 R D E R The Director of the United States Patent and Trade- mark Office and the appellants jointly move to remand these appeals for further proceedings - The Director concedes that decisions of the Board of Patent Appeals and lnterferences omitted ‘-‘not” in the final sentence of the claim construction section, such that it should have read "and not otherwise surrounded to any extent by replicated substrate 7O." The Director also states that the Board has confirmed that the omissions were in error and create inconsistencies within their respective decisions. -- _ Because the appellants opening briefs rely on these omissions and the appellants join these motions for re- mand, we grant the motions to allow the Board to issue corrected decisions lf the appellants timely appeal those corrected decisions the docketing fees for those appeals will be waived Accordingly, lT lS ORDERED THA'I`Z The motions are granted for the limited purpose of remanding these appeals to allow the Board to correct the above-noted omissions. FoR THE CoURT 2 8 /s/ Jan Horbaly Date J an Horbaly Clerk F5LED - v.s.c0un‘r F mls ron mr FEnERALPc1Rcurr N0v 28 2011 .|AN HDRBALY CLERK 3 oct Sandra K. Nowak, Esq. Raymond T. Chen, Esq. s19 Issued As AMandate: c c NUV 2 8 2 lN RE BENSON §