—
I concur with my brother Goldthwaite, in reversing the judgment of the Circuit court. But as it is unnecessary to determine whether bills or notes illegally issued could be collected by a bona fide holder, for a valuable consideration, without notice ; or whether one conusant of the illegal issuance, but receiving the bills or notes from a bona fide holder ignorant of the violation of law, may enforce payment, I decline an expression of opinion on these points.