Bill in chancery. Bill demurred to; demurrer sustained, and bill dismissed. The bill alleges, that, on the ninth day of February, 1846, the plaintiff obtained judgment in the Cass Circuit Court for over 200 dollars against Elizabeth M. Bean — that on the 27th of the same month a fi. fa. issued on said judgment, and was delivered to the sheriff, who, on the 23d of February, 1847, levied the same on certain dower estate of Bean— that on the 20th of August, 1847, said levy on the dower estate was set aside on the ground that personal property had not first been demanded, and that said Elizabeth had a sufficiency of such property subject to the execution to satisfy it; the order setting aside the levy containing a provision, however, that the execution should be a lien on *493the personal property — that the sheriff returned said execution with a statement of the order setting aside the levy and that there was not time to make a new levy — that soon after this return the plaintiff directed the issue of another execution without specifying what kind — that the clerk issued a venditioni exponas directing the sale of the said dower estate, but that before any sale was made said Elizabeth died, and the vendi was returned “ no property,” &c. Said Elizabeth died insolvent, and this bill against her administrator, seeks the appropriation of the entire assets of the estate to the payment of the plaintiff’s said judgment.
D. D. Pratt, for the appellants. H. Allen, for the appellee.The plaintiff, at the death of said Elizabeth, had no lien on her personal property. We do not see how the Court can now create one for him. The lien which he might have had, had the proper steps been taken, was lost or never obtained, through his own negligence or that of the sheriff or clerk, or all of them combined. If by hi's own, he can have no remedy; if through that of either of the others named, his remedy is against them.
Per Curiam. —The judgment is affirmed.