For the reasons stated orally at the hearing of this cause the second and twelfth claims of the patent in suit (No. 68,426, granted September 3, 1867, to Hiram B. Everest, assigned to complainant) are clearly void lor want of novelty. Inasmuch as no disclaimer has been filed, it is unnecessary to consider the validity of the other claims. After the term of a patent has expired it is too late to file a disclaimer. The suit cannot therefore be maintained, and the bill is dismissed.