delivered an oral dissenting opinion.
For affirmance — The Chief-Justice, Knapp, Mag-ie, Reed, Scudder, Van S yokel, Clement — 7.
For reversal — Dixon, Parker, Paterson,- Whitaker — 4.
delivered an oral dissenting opinion.
For affirmance — The Chief-Justice, Knapp, Mag-ie, Reed, Scudder, Van S yokel, Clement — 7.
For reversal — Dixon, Parker, Paterson,- Whitaker — 4.