LANVLEHWAHY
NO. 28l75
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF HAWAfI
MAUNALUA BAY BEACH OHANA 28, a Hawai‘i won-profit
corporation; MAUNALUA BAY BEACH oHANA 29, a Hawai‘i
Non-Profit Corporation; MAUNALUA BAY BEACH OHANA 38,
_ a HawaiH Non~Profit Corporation, individually
and on behalf of all others similarly Situated,
PetitionerS/ReSpondents/PlaintiffS-AppelleeS,_
VS.
STATE oF HAWA:‘I,
Respondent/Petitioner/Defendant-Appellant
98 =\ §§ %~ §;i§`“¥? Uii`§l£
@EV`"H:J
CERTIORARI TO THE INTERMEDIATE COURT OF APPEAH§
(CIV. NO. O5-1-O904-05 EEH)
ORDER REJECTING APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI
(By: Moon, C.J., for the majorityl; Acoba, J., dissenting,
with whom Duffy, J., joinS)
Petitioners/respondents/plaintiffs-appellees Maunalua
Bay Beach Ohana 28, Maunalua Bay Beach Ohana 29, and Maunalua Bay
Beach Ohana 38'S application for writ of certiorari, filed April
22, 20lO, and respondent/petitioner/defendant-appellant State of
Hawaii’s application for writ of certiorari, filed April 26,
20lO, are hereby rejected.
DATED: Honolulu, Hawafi, June 9, 20lO.
Paul AlSton and
Laura P. Moritz, for
petitioners/respondents/
plaintiffs~appelleeS géS:z"Wé”`~` H
l i f Justice
Girard D. Lau and William
J. Wynhoff, Deputy Attorneys
General, for respondent/
petitioner/defendant-appellant
FOR THE COURTj
1 The majority: Moon, C.J., Nakayama and Recktenwald, JJ.