Baldwin-Lima-Hamilton Corporation and Edward E. Simmons, Jr. v. Tatnall Measuring Systems Company and Budd Company

BIGGS, Chief Judge

(dissenting).

The court has extended greatly the patent misuse principle. This extension, applied full force, could prohibit a pat-entee from employing his invention as a component even in an apparatus of his own manufacture.

I conclude that the test body is a material element in the claimed invention, as the court below first held, and that Section 271, Title 35 U.S.C., may be applicable.

The issues involved are of such far-reaching importance as to render desirable rehearing before the court en banc.

For these reasons I must dissent from the order denying rehearing.