Berry Refining Company, a Corporation v. Helen Salemi, Frank Hill and Helen Hill

SCHNACKENBERG, Circuit Judge

(dissenting).

I do not believe that there was sufficient evidence to justify submission by the district court to the jury of the issue as to whether the widow of Michael Salemi, deceased, and her parents Frank Hill and Helen Hill, defendants, were chargeable with the debt for which plaintiff brought suit herein. There was no evidence in the record to sustain any theory of liability against these defendants in this action. The district court properly directed a verdict for them. I would affirm.