Application of Robert Joly and Julien Warnant

RICH, Judge

(dissenting).

I am in general agreement with the views of Judge Smith as stated in his dissenting opinion herein but I have more particularly stated my views in my dissenting opinion in the companion case of In re Kirk, 376 F.2d 936, 54 CCPA

*910SMITH, Judge.

Notice of Withdrawal

The attached dissenting opinion shall be substituted for my previous dissenting opinion filed March 16, 1967.