Magnum Magnetics Corp. v. United States

Summarize Case

Related Cases

/s33    "! !! "!!!!   "!  !   /%s16s**  8  "! !!  )*24))11s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s'744@=<!/@  K'744@=3&C:7<5&3?C3ABL$& & J  #<>@7: !/53 &C:7<5&3?C3AB/<2=;;3@137AAC32/AC>>:3;3:3NA&3>C0:714@=;67=@/B7=<=<'1=>3&C:7<5>>:71/B7=<4@=;/AB3<3@A4=@ &3B/7:<1,20/s'744@=<>@ $&  3BB3@4@=;=;;3@13@3&/E :3F70:3!/5<3BA4@=;B63$3=>:3NA&3>C0:71=4673&C:7<5&3?C3AB /AB3<3@A4=@&3B/7:<1,20/s'744@=<>@ $& A33/:A= 3BB3@4@=; '/<2:3@(@/D7A&=A3<03@5$B==;;3@13@3&/E:3F70:3!/5<3BA4@=; B63$3=>:3NA&3>C0:71=467=3>:3;3@ $& &  #<>@7:  =;;3@137<7B7/B32B63A1=>373@  $& (63$/@B73A47:32B637@@3A>31B7D31=;;3:3NA&3>C0:71=467=@/B7=<B=&30CBAA3@B7=3 &C:7<5>>:71/B7=<4@=;/AB3<3@A4=@&3B/7:<1,20/s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s)5;216)16s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s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s/<2=;;3@13NA23B3@;73&C:7<5B63';7B6*3AB3@<'1=>3&C:7<5/<2!'1=>3 =C@B"=    $/53    &C:7<5E347<2B6/B'744@=:/AB71A63:427D723@A/@3=CBA723=4B63A1=>3=4B63 #@23@AL31/CA3B6373&C:7<5;33&C:7<5/<2B63!'1=>3&C:7<5B63=C@B 1=<1:C23AB6/BB63A1=>3@C:7<5AE3@316/::3<532AC447173@=13327<5A/<2$:/7@7=@A1=>3@C:7<5AE/A@3/A=/B J 343<2/@7=@A1=>3@C:7<5AE/A@3/A=@3B7<5B63A1=>3:/<5C/537<B63#@23@A'3334/B J  (63A1=>3:/<5C/537<B63#@23@A7<1:C23AK4:3F70:3;/5<3BA@35/@2:3AA=4 A6/>31=:=@=@>/19/57<5B6/B;/G=@;/G<=B034C::G=@>/@B7/::G0=<232E7B6 >/>3@>:/AB71=@=B63@;/B3@7/:L/<2B633&C:7<5>@=D7232 =;;3@13E7B64C@B63@5C72/<13'>317471/::G=;;3@13AB/B32B6/B7B@3:732=< B634=::=E7<5/3&C:7<5 ,(s63A1=>3NA>@=D7A7=<B6/B@/E4:3F70:3;/5<3BA1/<030=<232E7B6 K>/>3@>:/AB71=@=B63@;/B3@7/:=4/=A7B7==73=4B63,#@23@As7<271/B3AB6/B 7B>3@B/73=4 B63,#@23@As(6CAB63A1=>3=4B63,#@23@As7BA3:47<271/B3AB6/B/::47D3 1/B35=@73A=4@=2C1BA/@3=CBA723=4B63A1=>3  73&C:7<5/B  (63=C@B=0A3@D3AB6/B=;;3@13>:/132A75<7471/6/A7A=<B63 4:3F70:331747327<B6347@ABA33 >@=D7A7=<<B633&C:7<5=;;3@1323B3@;7<32B6/B13@B/7< @3B/7:6==9/<2>/>3@B=E3:;/5<3BAE3@3=CBA723B63A1=>3=4B63#@23@A031/CA3 B63;/5<3BAE3@3/BB/1632B=;/B3@7/:AB6/BE3@3<=B4:3F70:33 &C:7<5/B =;;3@13@3:7327<B67A1/A3=<B633&C:7<5B= 23B3@;7<3B6/B'744@=@=2C1B7A<=BK4:3F70:3L031/CA3B63>:/AB71A63:427D723@A 1=C:2<=B03>6GA71/::G;/<7>C:/B32E7B6=CB2/;/57<5B63>@=2C1B2C3B=B63 0=<27<5=4B63@/E4:3F70:3;/5<3BAE7B6/>:/AB710:/2373&C:7<5/B  =;;3@1323B3@;7<32B6/B'744@=@=2C1BE=C:2:=A37BA@3?C7@32=>/17BG/<2 <=B@3BC@<B=7BAA6/>3B=4C<1B7=</A/A63:4=@5/<7H3@74AC0831BB=>6GA71/: ;/<7>C:/B7=</<2B63>@=2C1B031/;3K4C<1B7=3=4B63#@23@A A>317473AB6/BAC0831B;3@16/<27A3;CAB034:3F70:3=;;3@13NA@3:7/<13=<B63 3&C:7<5E/A@3/A=@7=@ A1=>3@C:7<57A/>3@;7AA70:3A=C@13/<2>@=D72325C72/<13B==;;3@13NA =C@B"=    $/53    7@3B/B7=<=4B63A1=>3:/<5C/53(63=C@B1=<1:C23AB6/B=;;3@13NA 7@3B/B7=<7A@3/A=@=2C1B@3<23@32K4C<1B7=3=4B63#@23@A $:/73&C:7<5/@5C7<5 B6/BB633F1:CA7=<=4B63;3@16/<27A37<B63!'1=>3&C:7<5E/A0/A32=<B63 :/19=40=<27<503BE33</;/5<3B/<2/<=B63@;/B3@7/:C<:793'744@=@=2C1B B6/B0=<232/;/5<3B/<2/<=B63@;/B3@7/:$:NA&3>:G/B J 343<2/3&C:7<527443@32/<267<532=<E63B63@/ ;/5<3BE/AK0=<232LE7B6/<=B63@;/B3@7/:34NA&3A>/B  =;;3@131=3&C:7<5/<2/5@332E7B6'744@=<B6/B B63>:/AB71A63:427D723@AE3@3/4C<1B7=@=2C1BB6/<@/E4:3F70:3 ;/5<3BAAC0831BB=B63A1=>3=4B63#@23@A73&C:7<5/B =;;3@13 <=B32B6/B7<B63!'1=>3&C:7<5=;;3@1323B3@;7<32B6/B7<B631=3A!1@3/B32/>@=2C1BB6/BE/AKAC0AB/:/AB7147:;B=/@/E4:3F70:3;/5<3B>@=2C132/<7B3;B6/B3F>/<232 B631/>/07:7B73A=4B637<1=@>=@/B32@/E;/5<3B2=;;3@1323B3@;7<32B6/B '744@=</2232B63>:/AB710:/23A7;7:/@B=!NAAC@571/:2@/>3B=/@/E4:3F70:3 ;/5<3BB=1@3/B3/>@=2C1BB6/BE/AAC0AB/3=4B63#@23@A2=;;3@13@3/A=<32B6/BB631=;07:/AB710:/23E67167A@7572B=34431B7D3:G27A>:/G@3B/7:>@=2C1BA=</A63:4 /<2B63@/E;/5<3BE6716>3@;7BAB63>:/AB71A63:427D723@B=;=D3=</;3B/: AC@4/13E7B6=CB:3/D7<5@3A72C3/::=EA'744@=@=2C1BB=03/A63:4=@5/<7H3@7< /@3B/7:A3BB7<5B6/BA3>/@/B3A@3B/7:>@=2C1BA4=@27A>:/G'3372 *67:3B63#@23@A2=<=B7<1:C23:/<5C/53/0=CBE63B63@1=D3@32 ;3@16/<27A3;CAB03/0:3B=1/@@G=CB7BA7:G 037<5/@/E4:3F70:3;/5<3BE63<B63@/E;/5<3B7A0=<232B=>/>3@>:/AB71=@ =B63@;/B3@7/:B63=C@B1=<1:C23AB6/B=;;3@13NA@3:7/<13=<B63!'1=>3 &C:7<5E/A@3/A=3@;7AA70:39 A=C@13B6/B/AA7AB32=;;3@13E7B6 7BAA1=>3/@3B/B7=<7A @3/A=@=2C1BKAC0AB/3=4B63#@23@A(63@34=@3=;;3@13NA1=@7=@A1=>3 @C:7<5A/A/9 A=C@13E/A@3/A=3:/<5C/53E63<@3/2B=53B63@E7B6B63 9 A=C@13AC@=2C1BAB6/B 6/D3033</:B3@32/<2@3AC:B327</>@=2C1BE7B6/K4C<1B7=@=2C1BAB=E6716/4:3F70:3;/5<3BE/A/BB/1632/<2@3<23@327@=2C1B4@=;/@/E4:3F70:3;/5<3B  =C@B"=    $/53     7&56%16s%/8s()1')1%/95s5 *63B63@/>@=2C1B;33BAB63C3B3@;A>@3A3B7=3&C:7<5&3?C3ABB=723@=2C1BAC0831BB=B63A1=>373&C:7<5/B J "=B/0:G$:/73s&C:7<57@3BA/<2/>>:73AB63#@23@A 7</;/<<3@B6/B16/<53AB637@A1=>31=:/7<:/<5C/53/<27A B63@34=@3C>=@B320GAC0AB/@=2C1B/B7AAC37A/>:/AB71A63:427D723@E7B6/@/E4:3F70:3;/5<3B /447F32B=B630/A3(63>:/AB71A63:427D723@1=:/AB710:/23 53<3@/::G(=@ A6/>32/<2/@/E4:3F70:3;/5<3BB6/B7A/BB/1632B= B630/A3=4B63>:/AB710:/23E7B6/</263A7D3B/>3(63>:/AB71A63:4 27D723@ 1/< 03 1:3/@ =@ =>/?C3 7< 1=:=@ =@ ;/317471 B= ;33B B63 3<2 CA3@AN <332A  (63 ;/5<3B 7A / @/E 4:3F70:3 ;/5<3BB6/B7A23A75<32B=034:3F70:3A=7B7A3/AGB=1CB/<2A6/>3  (63>:/AB71A63:427D723@7A23A75<32B=A7B=<@3B/7:A63:D7<5B=/727< 27A>:/G7<5 ;3@16/<27A3 >@=2C132 0G 3<2 CA3@A =4 B63 >:/AB71 A63:4 27D723@(63@/E4:3F70:3;/5<3B/447F32B=B630/A3=4B63>:/AB710:/23 =4B63>:/AB71A63:427D723@/::=EA4=@B63A63:427D723@B=03@3>=A7B7=<32 =</A63:4E7B6=CB:3/D7<5/AB719G@3A72C3=<B63A63:4  (63 >:/AB71 A63:4 27D723@A /@3 1:/AA74732 C<23@ B63 /@;=<7H32(/@744 '1632C:3 =4 B63 )<7B32 'B/B3A (')' AC063/27<5     E6716>@=D723A4=@K:31B@=;/5<3BA>3@;/<33@;/<33@;/<3A /<2 A7;7:/@ 6=:27<5 23D713A 3:31B@=;/5<3B71 1=C>:7<5A 1:CB163A /<2 0@/93A 3:31B@=;/5<3B71 :74B7<5 63/2A >/@BA B63@3=4 $3@;/<33@;/<3=A7B35==21=3&C:7<5/B J 17B7<5'744@=3&C:7<5&3?C3AB/B    /<2 (63=C@B=0A3@D3AB6/B7</227B7=<B=1=B7=3&C:7<5&3?C3AB '33'744@=3&C:7<5&3?C3AB/BBB A163;/B71A=4>:/AB71A63:427D723@A BB >6=B=5@/>6=4>:/AB71A63:427D723@ABB />6=B=5@/>6=427443@33A =4A63:427D723@A/<2BB 0A163;/B71A=427443@33A=4A63:427D723@A(63 =C@B=0A3@D3AB6/B=;;3@133F/;7<32/227B7=>=@B7BA 23B3@;7@=2C1B7A4C<1B7=:/AB710:/23@3<23@A7B 7<4:3F70:3B=B633FB3C:/B32E7B6=CB2/;/57<5B63>@=2C1B 73&C:7<5/B 17B7<5'744@=:/AB71A63:427D723@A037<5 03:/AB710:/23@3<23@A'744@=@=2C1B KAC0AB/3=4B63 #@23@A72/B 17B7<5'744@=3&C:7<5&3?C3AB/BJ 7<1:C27<5BB  >6=B=5@/>6=4>:/AB71A63:427D723@ABB >6=B=5@/>6:/03:32K!/@93B7<5=4 =C@B"=    $/53    $:/AB71'63:47D723@A/<2BB>6=B=5@/>6A=44:3F70:3;/5<3BA/<2'744@=6=B=5@/>6=4>:/AB71A63:427D723@A/A =@5/<7H/B7=:/AB71A63:427D723@A037<5036=B=5@/>6>@=D72320G'744@=<=4;/5<3B1=;>=<3:3>:/AB71A63:427D723@73&C:7<5/B J 17B7<5'744@=>=@B327BA23B3@;7@=2C1B7A =CBA723B63A1=>3=4B63#@23@AE7B617B/B7=@=2C1B 23A1@7>B7=@=D72320G'744@=<B63=C@B1=<1:C23AB6/B=;;3@13NA 23B3@;7>=@B320GAC0AB/@=2C1B7A=CBA723B63 A1=>3=4B63#@23@A7A7</11=@2/<13E7B6:/E/<2AC>>=@B320GAC0AB/@=>3@:G7C@>=@B329 /3 23B3@;7:G /B J  =C@B"=    $/53    343<2/:/AB71A63:427D723@A/@3E7B67<B63A1=>3=4B63#@23@A 031/CA3B63@/E;/5<3B1/<03@3;=D32A3>/@/B3:GB=03>=B3/19/532 /<2@3A=:2/A/@/E4:3F70:3;/5<3B34NA&3A>/B J  )<23@/9 /@/1B71/07:7BG =4 A3>/@/B7<5 B63 7<A1=>3 1=;>=<3/19/57<5 =@ @3A/:3 1=3/@/B7<5B631=;>=<331=;>=<3/@32B= B63;3/AC@/0:3D/:C3=4B63;3@16/<27A3/A/E6=:3/<2   (63C:B7;/B3CA3=@4C<1B7=<=4B637<A1=>31=;>=<3:/AB71A63:427D723@AE=C:223;=@=2C1BA/@3 E7B67<B63A1=>3=4B63#@23@A031/CA3 A3>/@/B7<5B63>:/AB711=;>=<3/19/532=@@3A=:2/4B3@A3>/@/B7<5B634:3F70:3;/5<3B4@=;B63>:/AB71 A63:427D723@ B63K;3/AC@/0:3D/:C3L=4B634:3F70:3;/5<3B1=;>=<3:/AB71A63:427D723@7AAC0AB//@32B=B63;3/AC@/0:3D/:C3=4B63>:/AB71 A63:427D723@/A/E6=:3/<2 B634:3F70:3;/5<3B7A/133 &C:7<5/B =;;3@1323B3@;7<32B6/B7BE/AC<<313AA/@GB=1=3&C:7<5/B =;;3@133F>:/7<327<B6373&C:7<5B6/B7B27A/5@332E7B6$:/7/19/532=@@3A=:2/4B3@A3>/@/B7<5B634:3F70:3;/5<3B 4@=;B63>:/AB71A63:427D723@2/B =;;3@13@3/A=<32B6/B@3831B7<5 $:/7>@=>@7/B3031/CA3B63@31=@23D723<13A6=E32 B6/BB63/263A7D3B6/B0=<2AB634:3F70:3;/5<3BB=B63>:/AB710:/23@3;/7@=2C1B7A<=BB63A/;3/A/>@3/447F32@/E4:3F70:3;/5<3B E67162=3A<=B1=@=2C1B7AA67>>32/A/E6=:3 >@=2C1BA=B63@/E4:3F70:3;/5<3B1/<<=B03@3;=D32B=03CA32/A/A3>/@/B3 >@=2C1B2/B J  (63=C@B/5@33AE7B6B63=D3@<;33&C:7<5;3@3:G@3A>=<232B=/<2 C:B7;/B3:G@3831B32$:/7@=>=A/:B6/B=;;3@13A6=C:21=<2C1B/9  /@=2C1B7A3F1:C2324@=;B63:/<5C/53=4B63#@23@A7A0/A32A=:3:G=<B63A1=>3 :/<5C/53@3/2B=53B63@E7B6B639 A=C@13A/<2E7B6=CB/3:/<5C/53E63<@3/2 B=53B63@E7B6B639 A=C@13AC:/AB71A63:427D723@A(63=C@BACAB/7:/AB71A63:427D723@A/@33F1:C2324@=;B63A1=>3=4 B63#@23@A/A7</11=@2/<13E7B6:/E/<2AC>>=@B320GAC0AB/=<B63 53<1G&31=@2"= 7A23<732/<27B7A4C@B63@ B6/B=;;3@13NA73&C:7<57AACAB/7<32 C25;3B3;03@    "3E+=@9"3E+=@9