MR\CL§§. mw=.ol;m\) a%@§z% Rauv\§€w{ 1_ 110© PN\ bfz zlr\wc~or\, 71 775@.5 m zz,va:> -RQM§§@:\ @}f\`juv\®\`“F>/@“‘@ CB\XPJV BF CRI”N\'\NAL APPEAL$ ` %up¢&c/v\®(§@w+ RECE iv Q`O' BSL\¢ZB ~ . COURTOFCR|F.'IHEB_HPEALS A\;SW\TTM‘I@>*IN . JUN 172015 R&`¢ AI¥)l/EM:S MN\SN\;&~UNQ}DK{ Ab@[ACG§§@,C!@m bears MQBU\+QP AppadLA/M ` Md dm ` CD - , ' 51)<( )mqesl ' €)ohlbv 14 ` MRKUU&Q:Y b;%w@ +My w ~;ke)%o§§éa/, of /<:)Sé M@m$ %\,LQL u/bmHQ 1 ,'1'. l/MQ QN\QXQSQA@{)GSHQQ/m*d io…,.»:%._oc’ ()M?@_w UC\»~ plj'(‘€ B}S+N`d' UM£OMC/ . W\E>/ m .@mme<\ @¢<\r€ss 'Q\o¢v\ \Ms %UM@ @@m\+. WMS 513qu - Pz><\ qme lim \T\GALUN\QQ.P€@&%@M s;%<\mp b€§€x@ %us £mwr\%&>pmds_ emdewv@u\k, f § §‘m,d‘/E w x ida PL@QS€ wQ€r-l\mAmy L`Lber¥y V\l&\“\' 'O,\Mo%~@OZB-"LE) '_ 1 d 59 v WR\'TNM). wlo'c>\\€)%~;£cv> . _ rn 1 68 350 )qlz§ mmr l\‘.\o. vom- 0\\@‘{~ JlP_) ~::N TH§ QR\MWAL FJ\PARTL=_ "\>\S~mlcj' Cou&“r MG, 5 Sc=aamcl< mcnamara UL\-HS CaumE/CEM_B¢?N N?PUMT\S gaome ANB QUUQNS coURT oF chMlNAL APPEALS 't'c Usw'l°€rl:‘$ KE%(>DNSQTO APPLl C)°€rlor\l FU+MB§H@ Ww\p€l\w\c{l\?msw¥dsl§lc\` wl ’HG“O\\%?> 391&&€\1 Mf\mayl€e gay a 165wa MM%€W\@,N\Q¥M\ pam\mo&v irma smsa on?lal/luag/§,zoll, l £*SM 353 wawaeaaaaa.aaaaaaea aaa a v was c\:§.x€ll\§'::`v:\ m\e%£;\\\l€ b€£!all$€ \\Q Pw:rlrd@h/ (§§E;\DW\S ::“\:RA§\§MV\\B ngaon w\\@)l\ memo R>m_l Gccm'§hbb ¥’Ikea vv\n\€\el/\s~&scm Mecaas@ 03 \=ms~c>;\§s:> al malley marx cause rec H‘B-H>z\z BNOKQ éU-Robb eagle +\/\E, ¥vr\ldwv\gy\jg \?mm cause l\los F\Q~%\l&% X) F®‘Q\l%\f b€Cdll$.€~W\EZQ §asv@e<\ MMMM€> c>v\c W“‘QM wl GF%H,M ems &ceima P'3l5WW° \“ @€5 isaa§?aaaaal§§a:sam aa§§caaaa caa\aas aheaaas§ae cw\m\\‘<@a ¢\PNQX uaasaa~ces P@c, ‘ n@)\!@a‘ 1ast Fca\ aea"ae§ae laa,a Calain la ;Salmsaw aalac¥a\eclav\u aelev)s lavcause was al=w\al maul laal duane/au x d _ §&qua;%+: mo\l€,pa (`am{ WI;¢\Q,+NANA h@m:b€§; mmw(§l‘§ppa€a CA\UW\ Ia:v§g)g§/vl§g§m a\\maec…o\aweaa\a; msse$a¥d¥rre uk\vlo‘rl’\\Y\Y\%U\ cbsqu mappme Tv:;€ 1<3§5\ OE§“W WQQY E§C:r:u;t.llum §§ wi€cl,(‘$ T\e:saaaacaav¥\§\l®%wwv\plammm licamL e%l\aageas wells m caq<\lr\§*<€>:l\€a€ ago mwan wm€ his “ 07 w Vl&<€r&%%©~)$l(\l` CNSRPME bellem$€@ avalon A{a>lmll\¥ plmll\i~uaas v\Q\)€ll` leC‘.Q MQ,Q gm a§\m.lq pol\ Cal,ls€ ram Flb~e\l@>`$ 31 HCYO\\B‘{‘~(-o ¥ajiNL/(`:;?§}:® AW\U;(\\'$ all€[> POGBSS Uq¢:§ law v\c)b\`\r$ C.WL l<`\ql’\l\$,¢wl/\d £'\15 ClAl’lS{‘blllaL)L aaal`adr%\/\aa Applfcalrla)as nal@c aacela¥@rl Meaaa/ m;;£s aaa l va b 10 \0@ 90ch 1~`\`3\@6 679 \r):>U/\ 91\1111611.\€)16' §CC>QS~ hewas never mqu ' @pwmmk,%e> yyay po§\'lmll m»e<~ 1`1195111 1113 1115 pth 43 511 examihll\c/W hal mm N\@ovmec§yo 091\13 v\<(\/\iS 313 emma om*€ms Ch@we,a~\d new once mm<,`\@o}ec§w\ amy \'3\¢3¥()1‘€,\111111\61\)1111\£<1] nees 131 home Sev~ <>Q@ey\€es 113 13 we:\ by TQ¥@§\M 3ee 1~311<;(€5, 13 17 21 215 1311 CBA\Q @lm ' m TFe"S¥ahe 60511\1361650 on am cause ms \=1151311@3 31 1=10»<>11@,1,1 1119 whhe¥&\exewexene§m arwjvwmde,wv\dnmlex‘cw\§/Mm dth The%\a\€,ha$ nei§m\e<\\s; 111 came 110.1“0%¢021?> Le;uuae mib/1111 521511:11161§ Ka&hbamqu€cl+he/Mw%clrmhhj my _ `BYQL\CNUT \,O’P('d QEM[EB EFFECIWE A'$S\STA-|\\C.F_, O‘F-' ma \\\\ \'\OLM\UQ'O\: UN\TED B`W}TE.% CDMS`U“UM'(QN AMEMBMEMT§ `SZI E`_\`f ih MCQMY 1\`/1».3*< %vslv 6€)16~1111"?»1\€1 th§r\\@)vH@ HCWY(UP “@\1<\1£1636 w\\he wex`€e“ 111 Shoée Ceux*r 23 u 3. c§ mac 11,\9_ 3\<1§1€,3<“0`\ wl lw\§>m\h€)e)m\ly 613\1\¥33@646'\9%161%\~@ SMehuan;wm 1111\`6~. Me%vlok va\c 13 1151€33<;1&>.3 l%mg 1¢111511\`\¢111/ CUNYMQ. 7, ?5`.1111131§ 103 poe§um&€:\l§§m\£m%\ah§w§{ ‘\qu JA(\(\Z/\([\'\(2)'€'><`¢'1,3'G{l €13111\1'0{" 0111»/)\ M€( umw tzv\ N\P.l‘h W\ SQF‘CE H'K \A(Kk\ion 01` aug ;®MMM 1511“1\¢,\9\03 1awa timelion U R(ch?ey:r 1313 61 173(201\> 211de / M…a& Te>LE)USQ O`{l`“\<\`)h §111\13(\12§‘¢@) IIM\-{me \h\e 1\3\`6\1§\31\ 636 *€Meneca&§w 1111/1 ~ _ ?1@\1`1 ()\Qhee>cclu§\we ems pha/13 901 gwme SGQ*`W‘ 4 g§”\;§£;;) CM (>»~C\§Q&Q§SM Q.QCNY\YY[OV\ klm GBIMS?,M di mod~ `{~ 13 UNl`/<§E%;\{,Cd,:+ mud g )e¢/.\Shcls me¥suqcle g+ej§\m§@ 019-1119 w,`A.mCM l‘“°'“y/ Q” °r‘/l€ SH€UP cum aa %h€¥m\ 1366 m\s:»\o&€c\ a1‘6 mmpp'lfe<\ ¥\/\E. lam lmer 6131v1`183111 511\€3161€1\010%13€111,51@115@%@11@1¢ 1111 111 hechwwvddae §\ go{l[¢\,o@@cpm\mqw(\wq)$vqh%®¥\%\d§? GQL FX\\N!V\ ", "_'Sy:yey m MLMM qu w 351 11 3 <130,¢133`12<>3'1)0\\0&11\<} 1156 when a CU\~’¢ 5 153 aq§mm 13 bo$€é x3`(\&€11/1¢11\ 1116 w§ASQNHBLE 11 C,AM ®c peém 1 iam 1011 wgyw;;x(;eg€y§lmlmw<()w AEDF':VVU ‘S€ 1~ L\ééiaeres), m: 1|>:%\(::>@§1\ 690 3663€,? c\Q)!\lM \11"6§<>§\¥\€( Q,\Qm(\ … MM‘€DS Qd£i@/ ‘Zo£ b _ p@piip{`r\q 808 pt‘:»ieiimv\ MAMQPMESS 100 ii %1 C0v1si. iimei'\'\09 "388811\;\ pp gm {'v\ 88 [AED\>A] 80\)880 wriUO jig vesir\\cii>vis 88580;\`100 2281 L<\\ 018 1`1\<1pp i\`wi)i 8 888188883 303 0{~` 1` m eieiuiwy amoi¢§8s mmi 801/190€‘33’ nienimn elias m 80 808 880 c08<\801pq diemch 80 300003`1\/8 888 iii`ii$ 1318 t 808 __,_,giipm 28 0308§22;1;88§ amply §§ §§ " e»ei\i Trems‘ 810 00 Ston Cidim$ iii>i€eg§\p@, w\i:i§tsi<\i\c:e 08001»'1881 is 00+0 irwiqu iinciii)g §U£i%$gdw §;€wvvlpimn 0900088}€/1835 0801183,}>019 18 a i817c1i clue§m) iiw\-M%+ be NU;M l v10110 ii\iie<\%i<\ies i<\ies.v‘. Ini%ini@ 004 v 33 378,38180@§ mg qu;§?`____s §;MM M 83 3 03 2ng 880 E\"\\+s \/ L'\l_c§)_¢ 483 u 3 387 ,3%0<85); D:@"p;@u%ziu .3 tiner iii nw -EN;:[S `8080¥\-8\8\/133805 iii\w\;: 800 m ,<1:08 inqpp §§HUSW \i'wii\q 08830`3 808100 18 813 Q.i€l zzhllmo [i\§op 3 55 m 11€;[§,€ §0¢3}88 108*\0§\'\')¢ i\{)i>i ph mi\it\c>wcil$:mwl$ 00 22 5969&§§%,€ li\(\ml£‘_&`{)@ ib`\\\e\ndi\i \B::\|i 'G£m$(l§ INF_FF i`_C:r\\iF_ i§é\<.m°it\i®& § CLMNSEL C,AW 18 0 588\8301\1 788_90&\1§0¢ \8<¢ 0\1 808`\8 iit/wis dolm 0308 083 808 wmuziiiai)i€_ 1880 pvemé>i)& W\in§w§&\§pi@ é\i1\8%\<':)i81)0l1l @’\Qif pmu1&i8 '~ Vippiici\i\i intii/) 388880838 \8\88 drewer avii900 488 v83\0i\0v) pi iii/18 U viii 888$ 8880&{00 00 88000\8\091‘ 00030\/0»8 880 §p:§ui\i qulii\/ ieipuy\ciq recisi>vci\o\€ 08805¥‘ \ic\ci~\if\€ -i\/Q,it\\cii C0\sx\'\' ri\ iii)i><\\i<\s\pzv i i\'\0 ml il\v\owv\ ~iilcli mqu <:0\11)1\883 Ceiimm '308300 3000§€5¥0¥0§\1/ PGBS\OV\MZ` M§§:i;iiwiq 1718 if amc 1 i\ iii v 80881008\=10~018'3 1181 1080 v N)P\ \N%DHO;Q§§§§;@MQS 0000108;€1838"9 l CA\m`i\ 0 mem pu\\p‘l§q 8088\¢9<»\8:\%303 QQi i0i\/18C8iv\pidihu0w\i`€d&€€it`€in@a8fiu$ii”§ ii Ml…i’\<>'i\€>,ie> i:ii‘;] Zt>iidaii;:€é\{ii\q 885 iq)\\ §§§UO~CLU OV\ \/\81` omciivtp MQLA \/\Qii 1018/80 8000.080108$888888§ 88838830`\/ i0i0i818 Miiiiippi 188 000 cwa idesiiv\y iiiisimoi\d\ m i8i`.'i'\i»3 €V\Qi'\ QSieéc€ am 308:;)\?:$@ ii`@vis€ OJ… <`€\101\%) \/c\><;wa¥/Ri:“;i`omj 0:'00;(3(;\1\/”00 635un lhs€,ou§’€§>tti€ c>'i` W\Q\ `\\8?0§`¥¢10`1 W@B°M 1000 000»1000 0`1,2€0100 1100 00011\ 26011011 605 0000 10 001 1100 0110010\0 2000 500\1'1 S~e>m\\d§ 1011st 1103 11002>)1 0000 010/100 03 101 212 2222223223332 3 223232223 2222 22322131332 2`" ` 0 300 0 `_ § 01§111\059/200\>1\2‘€€\2?5\*“\9>“93 \2\1§<@11111<“"@\2 "%\150 2111€0»§;100110 10<;20\021 1/111159 19001\ 0299®\`€11\'1,1’1\ 221\€\11@0~\ 101 1100 100110®1`\\1€, Cb\m`n 1130/1010<10 115111@1331/1 21101110 11011)€ 1391/21 00 900 001§0 1000 11100110:2> 210100_11 3 10000111§§3 222 2222 22223222 2222 2 '"‘ 21 1322 0 232 @9®1\ 5 MMQMM 0100010 12001%0011®1111 1100001110111013,111@1111011 1112 901011~`\/11192 0 011@11111@111)2001011101\15 1110 1012 1/`10111110110 090\001»00@005 312/311 ®11111\ 1111\301/\ 1\01/1€10115<1 1202900551110 020th 09 mm£ 1:; 1115 pad111@ +02\\103\2 1112 22010<1 109110 501 1500011 130101012011103210~011@5 10102 1=\0~01210*1‘1/1001)1:00§§$1{ 90000 310900 amy 0\111040_€9:€§ 211/1912 1/101)111~1)5§0\1/ 13000010 0000001 01>10\+`101 110012111<5 110{)111~()02011/130`11 10121',11£1@2¢511/ 612 1211110011110 100an 1101010/11»1>11`<010111<121101102002 1011M/ 00121\05002 0§121§2 1212>11 11111141110111111)0)1‘:\»&®k 1000 1101 00)0<\21)3911;1‘"1\1'1; 40 121/100 111Gq 212 %01)1 911/1003 2002&011011 €/151;1'€ 111 1001)0122>1’110 10 ®12002000 1011\125 uk(w 22110§$03,01\0 1226111110<101/\ M`QYHA\S%WQM: 1 03 15111031~10€0(1011??11100011®‘1¥\0 100\00 \11@23102)@011\ 029€@1@1:;292 1105&111,1"11 gahagan 111111251 §;:§0 1`€11“11/1€102\¥\€1 W\W\ 1211)()1\6111\2'[3 FG,M 10€0011§€ AFP11Q(\1\121130111<1 mpg/mag 010100900011110211103\ 211101100/111\100\01\ 111 110 goods 1a 1119 @,1111<11,5€,\11“/ $;:Q 961 0¥\€0`2’51.\31\\*`€€0 SQX O@€).{\$l€§ RPDYV\ CAUSQ MOS_, \="102011@5 X, {:/0_0[(@17¢/.(]”6 1a 11€01100100 021 '1?'/101`1100111{11010 202001 91011\ 0000 1002 2000>213 001103 0 1200 1011 111 1020110+/1101)110011\12 1\0101~ 010/100 011§<11,111 1100111111\11110101` 1011 <>1111/ 1212100209611`11$+ 1135 by 210 1111 12 2110 amy 1100 1<1\11101/11<,11111’w 0011100 /101020100¢111101101012 001001@ 111/10¢0§01/0>101’ pm11c111/103011`101021’11€1US KQU§§D;W§Y 105 012001 11021 11121100111/111@€/ 00111/11~10010 1/1+%0?1\&1100/1£{0¢;1% 1012/1300 /11110111)111@1‘121€1 :\11:1611(21:2>2112:2201( tdc1111121:1(\2§22"121'92101< 10231\0221/1 0250§2 0325031€11'111191\1%; 011\ 20001110>101 1000/1 100001\110:111)09010 011/117 111<1¢1151+05105110¢10 02 c11\11111 5001 page L1 020 071\1\{9>393199 9\06>15 55\i66 931 6 9\;0(\,\9 H(,JL€|@, \-ai 6511\1\6710715 139161 66669:6 1361/109 pniiii"
Wilkerson, Senrick Shern
Combined Opinion