Sturgeon, Paul

-- NO. _ _ _ __

.J:.IL1.1H£ t.tJLJ'n.1 /Jf l.P1MIA1AL AfptA~ {)F fOib

['i_ f1Jp_1f: ?nuL .5'7diftr:>.U
l~eLATDll I AptlJt!.LJJJ7

OAJ ApphtA1/oiJ (/Jf_ IJJPIT /Jf MAMbAMLLS
!.oli!JL 1110. Jl'iW1!3-A tfhuiJIJJJ /i;12. Willi of HAu.m ff;lfm

App 11t A1loJtJ fot IJ.iJZ, Jbl MltlutfAmm
~liJLtJ£). I~IJ723--JI J[tjg fh P61YJt] &u'it fltJililis fa.JJu7!~1aA5
1

RECEIVED IN Pall!!:)JLJIUL>ili
COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS 'ReiA1bQ_ '&..se_ . .
MAR 19 2015
IDfJ j1 J?~SJ
l!JJ/ tAi2ZA
. '130t.J fhAlf !bz
.Ee-ewi/e., Ji~/15 11/t?z.
 .' IJIJJ .J)lilAA ha Auf,')'Ti lil1""'J , J&. fez_, 1"u !hdhwd> !uitAa't ,
f. , liJJ£;, 't
~illS, iAJ:hrJuJ follthL Thivd dar~L lew/ £1/oor. d Jhtf'l. J!J,._..zvt!Jt7mu~7
lt..FD rLs , \,
DJJ j)p_ AhDul .5efllMha t.!J 1Zrl 1'10/bJ i/1.1 lkRRis 61-'!Lf} ,7fAFL<)1
1};1//_<, '7uJ?1{f)AUfid 1hw OtJti fhat UA!/~t~AJf'u//y fflOj}LiA k_
hy A~fuilliLJf JAJd Btl!'illlrJJ9i'PA111d /)VER filf£12/y,
A!IIMI'.'l , IJ11e MIJ7odt!u cle.. !JvuAJ«i h b.wj /_,_jj UJ!I!Jc.
or
/~Jut lflVillfJJJlJJ7y T!JOLL5AIJ! r!ti)AJD A!Utlli;udtl. /Jiue_
1
HuAliiwl Th1Jll5RAJr/ dol/A RJ , vudh 7ht!Ailw 7 iJ de;n ve_
LhLIdy Leo! f)/ !lvrn f
1
OJJ."JuAir. 'l!JiliJ//; tftu/.5 'ruilfM ,/J,fbt fAib !lruvitltd()/' !hL 1hiRLI tk/il!:e
/1/cltlst. d' 1httlIJ! A!PIP 6/n~L f!IU5!RLJ1 ,PitlJJ~} hy /)pffi;_ lw7-A-tAi
UuMdf ll'n I ) Af!lu£7t 'Jht~l LS AM !Jududuf /t;J 1hr..1JJdidMP.uI. 'Au 1.5 1TLJrt/'o.u.
1

1.dAIPL JJA!> Jw 1w err/ 1o /J;iUL f£/JKJ I1.1 li1L f Dd::l DIJAJd /llie:,5u_/Jl
N;/uL 7h!JL1SA;ud rJpf/AJlj /)ill, ·'
(}JJ .JU/Ift 'Z3, lDIJ, 7lt_l.tfoL '!Jitlf..ly !Jfuf A /:dLtffw A/tJ/Ji:.~ ~~A;r~a/ JIll f'otL5L
ND, /l~D7l1, DIJJzliuq 7ht fJftLJ/5 fkrL15, AitvJ £1/JdtJoiL~ vdi1.5 dLJ/nJIEiZED
t!y
~hAl liJ115 AVAdA h/c_ A: Ttii,L ~I lZiKI. I!Jm Ai11r:l~AlljtJt.Sitou/1};7 Aove.s Peli!of'!.
At1u~tf.LiJJoL!.P.Jute_ . l!Jr /llc_vJt f);.J/!LJvnEd fiiJdL;dt:.e._ /Jut.iurlt.5 lhL
ID{IDI!Jiltif; ·. . ·. - . .. .
1J fhL 'JJur!Je]/iJlJJf II•-' /?AUSl ft/p, Jl%1J7l3 1 vdhJ()J LJ fovc/USJ'IL
tV!fit,utL tlul IJAJrutJkDtJJibiy ~vt. j l£/rikt.'J Aclu!lffy LtAJf_,t!LAJCL,
fie !ltdIll bl _<:;/ut/ A ltJI!J !Jluf fiwl fJ1mllln.JJ'
 .L) 1hL t!PmfiAJiu7 1/kt! hy 1!7L !Dmf~AiiuAuljuJuL!y 1/LJ/, /J;u /)tf, 1,ltJ/f1
/AJ f'AU5l /l/p, Il%iJ1Z'n 1hJ~ 1 ~ foJJI' /wivt flflfiwa 7h.,/ l/IU fU t.5 /1DAltl hJ
7-Rovu !hAl l!.tLtloL h11ri tlfec7Ji!t ftoJtJJE;LI 7 vi lhc. 0JJtiJJt2 )f;uc/
~tfAfoK J ~;luAf11JJUOLLJUL,- '; 711L &mffAtitJ7 £L/itfs _'
. 01u AtJ7'tJ/ l!JdfJ!oAul.5'ru171'£JtJ, flwld A!t/P l;/,d.
frpz,j /}')1fs1Attf1 !fum fJoffAl f{;A.Jt-JJ ·{Ap. Jhr.. f'A~ }/JA.\
btJE h~ttA DJuJEflE!Hhtz/tl!Jio ;hu7 Jht. f!A7 hAt! IJDI
bttJu ftluaJtf! /)l iotA ftLI :
72uu:11-/ Alj Rton e."'JI ( fJJ,J l'w 7JJb, Y~JJ1'/V?Jf · l!kn , tlmKIy
b}Dft) i1 . r ~· · L
. Aptllso,J UJMMd\ '1ht!J1 /) "_jtilvitt ll1 llthl/7 h;iloLII 7tJ J/Vf)icl
f.oymuJJ ftrL5e.tWJiL Jhul Atlo~ fw/Ju15l~ /mv;J,j OtJij foL
[!JIJ1ft1U SA fJo,J ;
.;) fltNe !'.ou7Pol OII£P lm.so~ctAI kri'ty uNrlu fA VJztlloJ foul~/
AqRt.t.mtto!l), 7hdt7m hYJ!dJ 1he Pr{)(Xllly heybAit! 7hc o/_fRJI hoAI t1
1hL lcJJJul A9l(tfYltJd! l!Jtfhv/_1/ lhtlffr-J:J,·ve_ &Ju.5Jt'.JJ7 v/7Je../)!JUA/t.L
/)/ Jhe ktodf' AIIJ;I !Ails 'JrJ I'¥ 1ht Ajy!hUJhk Poul;J! ChAFLJc !Pe
lDK ~7/Jf£/lfj. . ~

1tt.ll5 fu ltJ !t1.fllf f!Ddt_ .5f.L,J!.O) JituJ lli£4s lJuJ 'fo !J!JffAt · bJJ-A ·{A,t j}jJ)
!Jti, Jj I lf)jf). • .
 , ~) .''IJ£,~.J!y DveD vtillO '' Elfttfntc.£ 'tnuht'1Lt1 Atft;ll!tJ1 DrJJtl fPiiJPr/1/J,
r
?,.irlth UclI J,; Ddlol' Kt~.-d-A -CLJ K o/lirJ i/:, 1Jtm/!Url /Pz ~ymtA //. /)JJ 1Jt7 7,
l010. 7hi> . il fDAltfWJVE. fVtrft,J~L JhA/ U!LILJULSJIPAJ!Ij}v hPVD iAui.J'ruur·Ai~~.
~~lA loB AtluAlLviJI!tiut.t, lull fAa J) ~vts. 1

A) lhn) Dv!lrtt ~u1 ~A lA2 hAd 6ssruto1u ()/ lht. lt>J;;,t!Ad~R£1
fJ1mIAur 0/J IJl};cftJilL [Je 7. 7Jp//) bu.rw.'.c_ Att.MJ,u 'fv {bid lad
j. j r
?nymw 7ii dt.IJJAJJdvMJJtif //flu !he feluJUu £17hL ~ lt?£1
Vthit/e_,
111 b.Judy !&I !l!mm,l!alf12Juo/ ilk"' cShe. Al!trr/1 Jiu ha
&mf11'1J7 1h~t I 1/r &L hAd AJti htuu le.!uNaltfJJ laA!ul
_jJ_

.AtiA1bi

l. oI _ ?l!li IS>~1"'~ ~Do-1!>li{}, 11 /SIP.SJ, b Li!llE.v 7~1 :l.tiCAll/LilA letlliu lhc.
1
1
_
1tirt~ Dtfl ~~ b.JM.:Jw/. ~J_J1 J /1JJvzA ftl~tan,_'l.3otf J:illdfmz. &, fhutLht;

l;a vt!IL , bvu 1:6/tJZ.s · ·

IJJt Kt!Aioi, h,g ExhAuJ!td hb k.mu-.~tu AI£/J };115 AlP tJ!ha._ AJUjLJJ'I fL 72uwcc!y
AJ iAJJJ

7~t A,_~ !JIJ11? h1 7iPbe /;;mjldluf 1.5 M,juf.j TEl!AI, FJPI dbfl(llPA.!Alj /iu M7urc
U..t. ?. Azl, J/.o7/ .5LC.. g(l) fu;m&.) KtyoAJJwl 7P AAAU AfjlKDflilllt fAJR;/ItAJ
fJJJrhliflj /J/ fOcJJ lrAJtf f1tut./Li_51iAt-LJ IJJ jfi,1d /JLICALJJt JJuvll%0723/1 JtJplfAJ£1
LfJtf
 je_e_ L 1 lt f.st (JJlfl. 10 , 791 .S.1o1,3d l'lK ;and /;ihsDLI/ lL Dal/o '> &uu1" De·)Rir..J
lltlL. Z.1S s ltd 3d tj]J
I

'ra !'.oiL fJI !'JJ.iM. ha_. Mlll.ot fllftily Pwt\ii:¥J 'P.eiuli'u7 7P 7hL
IJJR/J of !lahltLS 11Rpu.) ()!Jus/ be lOVbiably toAJ.)}WdfJ i~U {)u}t_ll To qive diLLf
1P lhr_ ft.mtdj OAJd lw!eL 75, lht fir hJj tJilhL lb.JoLI .5J'dLiJJ9.lt!ie! LIAJda
1) )_stL u/Lilir iron, kf5.W3L'JI'L) [ TtA t.'liM·Aff· '11>b7) 7ht i!Jl(itN:. o! A
I!JRJI o/ ffliheo.s !nyns b 1P Ob7£JAJ O¥_erdy riAid dkcJ;yr_ IIJurftto 1iod
Df f1 fltbo"' ·J 72./[Jh IJ To £fmzu hou IPvY/1 t!IUJIII i.tJJlll,A.J/ 'J Lei/!Ill1 Noc.klcdf
lL AUM"' ,~3/ tiS ILl /l2.S.cJ . LldUJZ Le.did J!Jk /en) /IrJhe Vay !1JRfose_
of 1ht l!i.hd {)/ 1/obtli I IDy;_ul [z.S] Jo Ou~uod [j las~JJ fmdvm lko/YJ
Dtlw 11ou -/1.1 Vto!a!JoJJ {)/ i!oAJ51du /k,ud ftffrliw lCL'> ), . ·

. . ..liJ 111L.Li1lfiu7 lffir_jf.J(Jiti_\ Arphr~J'o'u hl~Lin;l o! !ltt!JtLL5 !tJzpm I!JA~
~v,&lrf! hy JhoJ 1e. t/IJJrl1hdLJ'" Vttlw111Rl.JtJ 7/71_.5},.. ID f)uf tiullI J/wvua
{J

!1all1 fho1wJJ 'lt1ut:-,hu1 Dt\J7,'JAJ,L/J /)fbsut~ '; '1hG5Mt.. dtJ JJt:i ,
Kehu IJ AlrJt dw/. "P.du/vn_::, LYtJiM 1 Aliid £UoJ/Illcl [:,) f'u_ P.Jref l2xiJtchu
r.s,
feb lol J )JJlJ Jl'oL IIAhtliJ I'm ]At fat/, 711dltdtAyuLrJ uJifh 7lelu Joz
Allid '1ht..7Lidlt'lJtJAtd.J, !YJokDMtd7,ht.. {pili.) Jp ()lldu ptJi:J,UAliPtJ of 15sut.J
7o fx_ /2t_ \DIVed V~Alihur ?t!a IDD k71J1r I.JMJ/JUJUCL - Al'l {l 1hL iJJtJ ilif7wr
CmiiiJ "&VitvJ of Kda/ol[; IJJNI o/1/[Jlxo.c, &Kflij A~t~d JhL.!)tr!U A.tL5iAJcLi
, Jh( fwt7 lw, fowd &ru7Jt!.JVtiUtd h~JJO 'Rf'lj~Kt.li~tiJ.Jht~Ah~ !)/
1JA IoiLJ lA.JatR.awkotJ luJd 'fhm AI/eJ , lsstild JJ.s '/)v/tk 'De:,,9AIt1-It~u1
ls5ut5 fDJJl) 1/Jr_ &JJl7 })Jt!JJJJI 1Jl!le2 JJ hetJJZJiuJ /JJ
71J bL fut)vtLI
1
7hi I i!.AJL 'Jhrul'vu, 7hdf) !A vJ!ufly Per;IJ1mJ, if lJUliM 7!o l !f. l Jill J!IJII
-StiJJPJJ g{e_) .1/J IY!It 1L tflifM IL fldiJ/ w IJMchidJi 0/fAel !ltud ..
 lhJJdu.; JD1J tJf LAM I lirlll-luiu if< ciA f of/u_ :JA1U., zt, mf.<.) 7hc_t:~/c_ 'li1L -
f.b,Jilitliu9 l!ou!ZI bcrfacrltis !Jl/ltK. f),_llfJNAiiu/ iH;Jt..S foJJiJ,
_1M 1h j_<, Ctue_' 1k 'Pt.ltt!PL h/1~ IIAJ J.A/7£F13 I )IJf 1hL t,Ai iiii:1JJU/ .&,71-:.s
Cf}m fh A1Un ~. Mh 7he.. It! v,; Jtl5u"•J Ito TC t,?. /IV. /ib'JI..Si!L/KILJ
..).Ol 1o dn-/e._, "tlai/JK. hn1 l2e_e.fJ·,,e._JtdtJ 72LSf/:/'u.5e_fwiYJ fgjff>J;jeluul lJ~AuhiLff(
Tl.tspoli.uft,J I'<, lAfli fJw fl111 cliiuJ' o! ltd Aut! t.Prutfu i 10 ,,;.5 oflo JA 1 hA 1/1'u1
fllou bJiEllkcftiti !.AuSL 1ilo IZKD115-A , ,

3. ()?; . Rt'foP.lde!!.l f 't, _72diliA I 1~ i!fJmf Jy lAidh U t.. P. /I'Rf. Jf.pfJ s,._Lf<' {f) '" 17cJz!m..5
lJJ, Jh {he../), .s iFil:..i t.Jales/) ulf 7P 11Z!W 5mif 1ht fft;Jn:o ho,,_; A1ud fl1c
1.Jalul t.lbidJJJ f'.Awe_ Jt.ip it'to712.-A. 7/; 7ht /};uilf !J/ 6z.ih1J;,MI Affl'£1/i.
:P/Ilu 1he.. !JJAJ i!Jt.hiu1 &lluh 71 i:YJt_ Liru IA hJJJJs hnJ Bfivul bttAuse...:
A) lu ii'J OkLIU fb,JJJII'!Jitl7 15suu {{)D1) 7ht iPAJIIJ"-'7w1
durzJ Pldwrl 1171'. hi.LdJ.
 ~ 7RAyl2 foK ~dlif

WfltREf!JRE ;fl£M15( !.DAl!JIDt/2tl) JKtiATt/RJ i

7flD .5L 1..optLIfully /.n,ut.J .J nhiudrJtJ7 1/v:; J fht l.ty:o,udi'LI/ fur, iiJ!uJ Rdl15u!
1b bJmp~ Vtlilh U}tJ. A£1. J/o7/..!Jec_ '6' (1) bv /o;ftvr,/J?r/J/!,JLIO 7P IJ!AiL
AppllDfPitJk UlilJ!!w !lJtJtbiJ1_s ~~ /},e} LIAJd &Aic.!mJOJLLJ f)/' l!wJ ufd.lnAJ
rhe. '1iiYit bnu!tr!Jit'Ji.LJ AIIPJA.i ~.sUde.!Wilhl iJ (IS dtp Afla 7hL!.hlc ThL
!.nud Dlltiw.J Defwu,iu,d/o,J f)/.Lw/'5.) lhme.hj ./ai/iu9 'Jb la>fi!IW1 //.:,
lniAJi.s/a.JA/ buke.J. AAJJ hiDH!/y hilt.ICillZJi11 7he_ bi5hud thl f)/i'tJu,21-
!Kom hizf}Jil.mi"J1 Ji5 f}jjll1f5ftll!LJI /)ufJ;s.'MJhuJ 7ht Pe:tJJJw'J hdu/
1o 1ur~tly f'YIA iL Jwwp iL1A lali!Ju' JJLii liiud!Ju/lf)/'!'at! AMl/otit./ID /ow
P!Lav.!. Pt:fMdW/ vPI11M fn~dy ih!AtVUI ib 'ftr! JILJihOillft !1!~.1£1 . .
Juwd, a, D,J litl i!JiJ!, L Ji./{) Iltt/18-A. kiAitJP-luliluL. 12ttm'5 I tdtRJt:.li~Uf
fhu J P.e 1u I[JjL hPtJurh1 lhrJ Uhrnhou l!t1fn~hcl fujIh OJut! h}'/j
!Jub-"1;ut/7-llt I Iy fte vmlui. !!do /oiL 1£¥ ~tJL IV.J bid/a dm !iJJ1 7hc
fhLDJJhZJd e./aiL !J/ !lt~llJZJ') I!Dullitll 7/J DDWH-i2£ls the l!oLJiZtJ {Jjdt"R
~h!bJJ,ur 7hc f!Jal &M lPA!IPmJ/1;»7,1he ff/Jljh£1ii Jhld111/RdAJu!
DJJtumtJJ7 #J '1hc 6u£..1 d i!JJM!I.JAI J;ftA!f JWLi'!had/Ja,/)flltP
'fht. f!!aJ liJ 7WJ5!Yii I lb '!he /};u£1- f)I t:R!AtiMAI J/r;ftAis, fhr: tf!Jbt !11M
AJJd '!hL fiJWJf }til llti!LJ !lr/ m t!tstJzJha! }Ji} lt,e.l.Ali //.f)lI .!let:' g(DJ
~-1.{j 1£1!./fu/1 ,jLJ.iJJtJJfifL}
 .I, tJnul.S 'Tu ~1t/JAJ, do .5wm P Lwda ?Will 1)/Ji.D,Ilj_ 1hullheJ'uds
ly
~1.1d All1hoJLJ~ iJJ 1hL AhovL Aff/,t.!Jhw loll 'PI IJJAidd!lmuJ A1L
/T2l,L UA.Jd tlJuec..'llo 7k ht5/ tf'-fl!y-iAJ()/!JiufL.

. ~, PfJUL..S7u i.if?o'h do lltuhy, f!.a.U'y fhd {J 7WL c11ud f!ouued. y i//tty
lht Abme_ AppJJt'_u/t!J,J /b;l VLillil ()/ MAu£1AmLLJ IAJA_'_LStivtL! f};J ,
1he. lL1fwdeuJ bl' P!.ttt"uceAtnt.. Jiu 'JhL liAII}ec/.Sfalcl IYJAJiMdaJ.9YI
ri1L t1ctl of7hL ThuJZJ of LJUIJJIJJ!tl
Appfll !J ol7aAJ I SuOILIYil &uv.f bkltu fflk.t Wt> IAush:v' 1t.,w 78 l.ll
'i(

. lJiu'1!Jl5 7he / 0~ cft!'yf_ lltv.c b mh