Mullins v. Cavallera

NRS 11.207(1) (providing that an action for legal malpractice must be filed within 4 years after a plaintiff sustains damage). The instant complaint was filed on June 3, 2010, and is thus time-barred. We conclude, however, that factual issues remain regarding whether appellants' malpractice claims based on Walter Boyle's life insurance policy are time-barred. Respondent Henry Cavallera relied on a letter sent in September 2006, memorializing a telephone conversation that occurred on August 31, 2006, in which Cavallera stated that appellants had acknowledged that their half-brother, Kaniela Boyle, had spent virtually all of the insurance proceeds on items other than Dorothy Boyle's care. This letter suggests that damages were sustained by this date, and thus, the complaint was required to be filed by September 2010, which it was. Cavallera nevertheless asserts that the letter demonstrates that appellants were also aware of the basis for any legal malpractice claim by this date, which triggered the two-year limitation portion of NRS 11.207, which requires a legal malpractice claim to be filed within two years of when the plaintiff discovers or reasonably should have discovered "the material facts which constitute the cause of action." NRS 11.207(1). Nothing in the record, however, conclusively establishes that appellants were aware of any negligence by respondent at the time the letter was sent. Consequently, it is not clear that appellants were aware of the material facts underlying any claim against respondent, or whether respondent's conduct constituted concealment under NRS 11.207(2), and these factual issues preclude summary judgment based on statute of limitations. SUPREME COURT OF NEVADA 2 (0) I947A rn Accordingly, we affirm the portion of the district court's order dismissing appellants' claims based on the denial of Medicaid benefits, and we reverse the portion of the order dismissing the claims based on the life insurance beneficiary designation and we remand this matter for further proceedings consistent with this order. It is so ORDERED. Gibbons cc: Second Judicial District Court, Dept. 8 Nicholas F. Frey, Settlement Judge Kenneth J. McKenna Laxalt & Nomura, Ltd./Reno Washoe District Court Clerk SUPREME COURT OF NEVADA 3 (0) 1947A