CCAD ARX6 v. Department of the Army

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA MERIT SYSTEMS PROTECTION BOARD DOCKET NUMBERS 1 CCAD ARX6 DA-0752-14-0248-I-1 CCAD ARX6-2 DA-0752-14-0281-I-1 CCAD ARX6-3 DA-0752-14-0379-I-1 CCAD ARX6-4 DA-0752-14-0390-I-1 CCAD ARX6-5 DA-0752-14-0391-I-1 Appellants, v. DATE: May 6, 2015 DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY, Agency. THIS FINAL ORDER IS NO NPRECEDENTIAL 2 Rory B. Thomas, James L Vaughn, Richard H. Smith, II, Domingo Gonzalez, III, Paul T. Creacy, International Association of Machinists and Aerospace Workers, Corpus Christi, Texas, for the appellants. Kenneth A. Weeks and Mandy Muniz, Corpus Christi, Texas, American Federation of Government Employees, for the appellants. A. Katharine J. Kiss, Redstone Arsenal, Alabama, for the agency. Rosa Gonzalez-Smith, Corpus Christi, Texas, for the agency. 1 The individual appellants and docket numbers that are included in this consolidation are set forth in Appendices A-E to this order. 2 A nonprecedential order is one that the Board has determined does not add sign ificantly to the body of MSPB case law. Parties may cite nonprecedential orders, but such orders have no precedential value; the Board and administrative judges are not required to follow or distinguish them in any future decisions. In contrast, a precedential decision issued as an Opinion and Order has been identified by the Board as significantly contributing to the Board’s case law. See 5 C.F.R. § 1201.117(c). 2 BEFORE Susan Tsui Grundmann, Chairman Mark A. Robbins, Member FINAL ORDER ¶1 The appellants represented by the International Association of Machinists and Aerospace Workers (IAM) and the American Federation of Government Employees (AFGE) have filed a petition for review of five initial decisions, which affirmed the furlough actions and found that the appellants did not prove their affirmative defenses. Generally, we grant petitions such as this one only when: the initial decision contains erroneous findings of material fact; the initial decision is based on an erroneous interpretation of statute or regulation or the erroneous application of the law to the facts of the case; the judge’s rulings during either the course of the appeal or the initial decision were not consistent with required procedures or involved an abuse of discretion, and the resulting error affected the outcome of the case; or new and material evidence or legal argument is available that, despite the petitioner’s due diligence, was not available when the record closed. See Title 5 of the Code of Federal Regulations, section 1201.115 (5 C.F.R. § 1201.115). After fully considering the filings in these appeals, and based on the following points and authorities, we conclude that the petitioners have not established any basis under section 1201.115 for granting the petitions for review. Therefore, we DENY the petitions for review and AFFIRM the initial decisions, which are now the Board’s final decisions. 5 C.F.R. § 1201.113(b). BACKGROUND ¶2 A number of similarly situated employees from the Corpus Christi Army Depot (CCAD) appealed the agency’s decision to furlough them for 6 days between July 8, 2013, and September 30, 2013, and raised affirmative defenses of 3 harmful procedural error and a violation of due process. See, e.g., MSPB Docket No. DA-0752-14-0248-I-1 (CCAD ARX6), Consolidated Appeal File (CAF), Tabs 2, 23; MSPB Docket No. DA-0752-14-0281-I-1 (CCAD ARX6-2), CAF, Tabs 2, 24; MSPB Docket No. DA-0752-14-379-I-1 (CCAD ARX6-3), CAF, Tabs 2, 20; MSPB Docket No. DA-0752-14-0390-I-1 (CCAD ARX6-4), CAF, Tabs 2, 21; MSPB Docket No. DA-0752-14-039I-I-1 (CCAD ARX6-5), CAF, Tabs 2, 20. The individual appeals were consolidated into the aforementioned five groups. After holding a single hearing, the administrative judge issued one initial decision for each consolidated group, affirming the furloughs and finding that the appellants did not prove any of their affirmative defenses. See, e.g., CCAD ARX6, CAF, Tab 28; CCAD ARX6-2, CAF, Tab 28; CCAD ARX6-3, CAF, Tab 24; CCAD ARX6-4, CAF, Tab 25; CCAD ARX6-5, CAF, Tab 25. ¶3 The Board received two virtually identical petitions for review from AFGE and IAM in each matter. See CCAD ARX6, Petition for Review (PFR) File, Tabs 1-2; CCAD ARX6-2, PFR File, Tabs 1-2; CCAD ARX6-3, PFR File, Tabs 1-2; CCAD ARX6-4, PFR File, Tabs 1-2; CCAD ARX6-5, PFR File, Tabs 1-2. 3 We construe these submissions as a petition for review from all appellants represented by AFGE or IAM. The agency filed a response to the petitions for review. See, e.g., CCAD ARX6, PFR File, Tab 3. ¶4 Because the petitions for review raise the same issues in each matter, we have further consolidated these appeals to address the AFGE and IAM petitions for review. See 5 C.F.R. § 1201.36(b) (consolidation is appropriate if doing so would expedite processing and not adversely affect the interests of the parties); see also Prouty v. General Services Administration, 122 M.S.P.R. 117, ¶ 1 (2014). Accordingly, this final order applies to all of the appellants represented 3 Because the petitions for review raise the same issues and the relevant documents in each consolidated appeal are substantially similar, we hereinafter only refer to the submissions in the CCAD ARX6 consolidated appeal file and petition for review file. 4 by AFGE and IAM whose furloughs were affirmed below in these five consolidated appeals. DISCUSSION OF ARGUMENTS ON REVIEW ¶5 On review, the AFGE and IAM appellants argue that: (1) the administrative judge improperly denied AFGE’s request for an appellant to testify; (2) the agency attorney improperly “interfered” with one of the appellants’ witnesses by holding a meeting with the witness and the deciding official without notifying the appellants’ representatives; and (3) the administrative judge improperly limited discovery. E.g., CCAD ARX6, PFR File, Tabs 1-2. For the following reasons, the appellants’ arguments do not warrant a different outcome. ¶6 Prior to the hearing, none of the appellants was designated as a witness. See, e.g., CCAD ARX6, CAF, Tabs 13-15 (the appellants’ prehearing submissions), 23 (order and summary of prehearing conference). However, during the hearing, for the first time, the AFGE representative asked for an appellant to testify. See, e.g., CCAD ARX6, CAF, Tab 27 (audio file 4 of 4). The administrative judge permitted the AFGE representative to make an offer of proof, but she ultimately did not permit the appellant witness to testify. Id. ¶7 The administrative judge has wide discretion under 5 C.F.R. § 1201.41(b)(8), (10) to exclude witnesses where it has not been shown that their testimony would be relevant, material, and nonrepetitious. Franco v. U.S. Postal Service, 27 M.S.P.R. 322, 325 (1985). On review, the appellants speculate that it is “possible that some key information was not touched upon [and/or] direct knowledge was not made available to the [administrative judge] during this hearing that very well may have levied an alternate decision.” E.g., CCAD ARX6, PFR File, Tab 1 at 1, Tab 2 at 1. Beyond this speculation, the appellants do not identify on review any testimony that the proposed witness would have provided that would have changed the outcome of this matter. We therefore discern no error with the administrative judge’s decision in this regard. 5 ¶8 Regarding the appellants’ assertion that the agency attorney improperly interfered with one of its witnesses, 4 the agency in its response denied that any such meeting occurred. See, e.g., CCAD ARX6, PFR File, Tab 3 at 4. Although the statements of a party’s representative in a pleading do not constitute evidence, Hendricks v. Department of the Navy, 69 M.S.P.R. 163, 168 (1995), we are not persuaded that a different outcome is warranted. The appellants’ bare assertion that a meeting occurred between the agency attorney, the deciding official, and the witness in question, without more, does not persuade us that there was any witness interference. ¶9 Regarding discovery, it appears that during the prehearing conference, the administrative judge addressed AFGE’s motion to compel regarding interrogatory 2, which sought, for each working capital funded depot, how much money was returned for each “program” at the CCAD for fiscal years 2011, 2012, and 2013. See, e.g., CCAD ARX6, CAF, Tabs 21 (discovery for consideration during prehearing conference), 23 (order and summary of prehearing conference). The administrative judge granted the appellants’ motion in part, and she ordered the agency to provide information regarding fiscal years 2012 and 2013. E.g., CCAD ARX6, CAF, Tab 23. The appellants argue on review that the information “did not reach back far enough to show the financial consistency of the Agency.” E.g., CCAD ARX6, PFR File, Tab 1 at 2, Tab 2 at 2. To the extent that the appellants are arguing that the administrative judge improperly limited discovery, the Board will not reverse an administrative judge’s rulings on discovery matters absent an abuse of discretion. Wagner v. Environmental Protection Agency, 54 M.S.P.R. 447, 452 (1992), aff’d, 996 F.2d 1236 (Fed. Cir. 1993) (Table). The abuse of discretion standard is “a very high standard” and allows for “great deference.” Pecard v. Department of Agriculture, 115 M.S.P.R. 31, ¶ 15 (2010) (citing Lipscomb v. Department of Defense, 69 M.S.P.R. 484, 487 (1996)). The 4 It appears that the witness in question was the agency’s designated reply official. See, e.g., CCAD ARX6, CAF, Tab 13 at 11; CCAD ARX6, PFR File, Tab 1 at 1. 6 appellants have not persuaded us that the administrative judge’s decision to order the agency to produce responsive documentation from fiscal years 2012 and 2013—and not fiscal year 2011—constitutes an abuse of discretion. NOTICE TO THE APPELLANT REGARDING YOUR FURTHER REVIEW RIGHTS You have the right to request review of this final decision by the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit. You must submit your request to the court at the following address: United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit 717 Madison Place, N.W. Washington, DC 20439 The court must receive your request for review no later than 60 calendar days after the date of this order. See 5 U.S.C. § 7703(b)(1)(A) (as rev. eff. Dec. 27, 2012). If you choose to file, be very careful to file on time. The court has held that normally it does not have the authority to waive this statutory deadline and that filings that do not comply with the deadline must be dismissed. See Pinat v. Office of Personnel Management, 931 F.2d 1544 (Fed. Cir. 1991). If you need further information about your right to appeal this decision to court, you should refer to the federal law that gives you this right. It is found in Title 5 of the United States Code, section 7703 (5 U.S.C. § 7703) (as rev. eff. Dec. 27, 2012). You may read this law as well as other sections of the United States Code, at our website, http://www.mspb.gov/appeals/uscode.htm. Additional information is available at the court's website, www.cafc.uscourts.gov. Of particular relevance is the court's "Guide for Pro Se Petitioners and Appellants," which is contained within the court's Rules of Practice, and Forms 5, 6, and 11. If you are interested in securing pro bono representation for your court appeal, you may visit our website at http://www.mspb.gov/probono for 7 information regarding pro bono representation for Merit Systems Protection Board appellants before the Federal Circuit. The Merit Systems Protection Board neither endorses the services provided by any attorney nor warrants that any attorney will accept representation in a given case. FOR THE BOARD: ______________________________ William D. Spencer Clerk of the Board Washington, D.C. 8 APPENDIX A CCAD ARX6 DA-0752-14-0248-I-1 Abel Acosta DA-0752-13-3868-I-1 Adrian Alaniz DA-0752-13-3938-I-1 Adrian Alvarado DA-0752-13-2689-I-1 Alesandro L. Benavides DA-0752-13-2859-I-1 Alexander Amillano DA-0752-13-2843-I-1 Alexander M. Aguirre DA-0752-13-3409-I-1 Alfred Acosta DA-0752-13-4019-I-1 Alfredo G. Campos DA-0752-13-1722-I-1 Allen W. Bode DA-0752-13-2437-I-1 Ana M. Bosquez DA-0752-13-3441-I-1 Andres Abrego DA-0752-13-2425-I-1 Andrew H. Babin DA-0752-13-2773-I-1 Andy Byrd DA-0752-13-4607-I-1 Andy L. Conner DA-0752-13-3253-I-1 Anthony Betancourt DA-0752-13-1810-I-1 Arnold Canales DA-0752-13-3972-I-1 Arnoldo R. Acuna DA-0752-13-3823-I-1 Arturo Cantu DA-0752-13-2746-I-1 Arturo G. Andrade DA-0752-13-3581-I-1 Augustin M. Blanco DA-0752-13-3884-I-1 Benjamin Aparicio DA-0752-13-2278-I-1 Billy R. Bailey DA-0752-13-4712-I-1 Brendalee D. Cruz DA-0752-13-2708-I-1 Brian O. Bratcher DA-0752-13-3640-I-1 9 Brian S. Brown DA-0752-13-3926-I-1 Bryan L. Copeland DA-0752-13-3555-I-1 Carol-Anne Cox DA-0752-13-3946-I-1 Casimiro I. Arriola DA-0752-13-1461-I-1 Charles Chavana DA-0752-13-1226-I-1 Christopher A. Carson DA-0752-13-1928-I-1 Cornelius E. Bonds DA-0752-13-3589-I-1 Cristina M. Buseman DA-0752-13-3593-I-1 Daniel C. Cirilo DA-0752-13-2899-I-1 Daniel L. Barrientez DA-0752-13-2457-I-1 Daniel R. Clark DA-0752-13-3996-I-1 Daniel S. Alvarez DA-0752-13-4018-I-1 Danny L. Mendiola DA-0752-13-2447-I-1 David Chagoya DA-0752-13-2852-I-1 David L. Barbay DA-0752-13-3523-I-1 David R. Acuna DA-0752-13-2310-I-1 David S. Ayala DA-0752-13-3602-I-1 Davie W. Castro DA-0752-13-2844-I-1 Dennis W. Campbell DA-0752-13-3826-I-1 Diana K. Brickley DA-0752-13-3139-I-1 Domenico L. Benitez DA-0752-13-4287-I-1 Donald J. Alexander DA-0752-13-3232-I-1 Dora J. Alcazar DA-0752-13-2597-I-1 Douglas M. Brubaker DA-0752-13-3819-I-1 Drew A. Altenburg DA-0752-13-3616-I-1 Edward Alvarez DA-0752-13-1064-I-1 Edward Botello DA-0752-13-3572-I-1 Edward Casiano DA-0752-13-2713-I-1 Edward D. Cain DA-0752-13-3239-I-1 10 Enedina Cervantes DA-0752-13-3822-I-1 Ernesto Amaya DA-0752-13-1818-I-1 Feliciano Cavazos DA-0752-13-2312-I-1 Frank Armendariz DA-0752-13-3415-I-1 Frankie G. Collins DA-0752-13-2892-I-1 Gabriel F. Caballero DA-0752-13-4306-I-1 Gabriel O. Cavazos DA-0752-13-1066-I-1 Gary D. Axsom DA-0752-13-3991-I-1 Gary L. Adams DA-0752-13-2503-I-1 Gene E. Boatman DA-0752-13-2718-I-1 Guadalupe A. Cantu DA-0752-13-3646-I-1 Guillermno Calderon DA-0752-13-3784-I-1 Hector Chapa DA-0752-13-2674-I-1 Hector Contreras DA-0752-13-1922-I-1 Hilda A. Barrera DA-0752-13-2935-I-1 Hugo A. Chavez DA-0752-13-2637-I-1 Humberto T. Campos DA-0752-13-2628-I-1 Jacob M. Araujo DA-0752-13-2961-I-1 James B. Alexander DA-0752-13-3968-I-1 James G. Aiken DA-0752-13-2664-I-1 James W. Cook DA-0752-13-2694-I-1 Jeff A. Barnes DA-0752-13-3918-I-1 Jess A. Avery DA-0752-13-3790-I-1 Jesse D. Alvarez DA-0752-13-3425-I-1 Jesse D. Cisneros DA-0752-13-2821-I-1 Jesse O. Biayobzcki DA-0752-13-1704-I-1 Jesus J. Barrientes DA-0752-13-3788-I-1 Jesus R. Carrillo DA-0752-13-2769-I-1 Jimmy Cantu DA-0752-13-2028-I-1 11 Jimmy L. Conner DA-0752-13-1490-I-1 Joe A. Caballos DA-0752-13-3534-I-1 Joe L. Cantu DA-0752-13-2445-I-1 John G. Aguirre DA-0752-13-1063-I-1 John C. Andrade DA-0752-13-2574-I-1 John D. Alonzo DA-0752-13-4038-I-1 John H. Burch DA-0752-13-3780-I-1 Jon C. Cantu DA-0752-13-4028-I-1 Jonathan P. Botello DA-0752-13-2700-I-1 Jonathan W. Cloyd DA-0752-13-3417-I-1 Jose A. Castillo DA-0752-13-1065-I-1 Jose A. Castillo DA-0752-13-1809-I-1 Jose G. Bulcen DA-0752-13-2665-I-1 Jose R. Alvarez DA-0752-13-3689-I-1 Joseph G. Benavides DA-0752-13-3774-I-1 Joshua Ayala DA-0752-13-3634-I-1 Joshua S. Chappell DA-0752-13-3796-I-1 Juan A. Carion DA-0752-13-2814-I-1 Juan D. Canizales DA-0752-13-2644-I-1 Juan M. Alvarez DA-0752-13-3120-I-1 Kathy P. Comstock DA-0752-13-2939-I-1 Kay L. Corral DA-0752-13-2922-I-1 Kevin S. Bradley DA-0752-13-3420-I-1 LaShaun D. Chappell DA-0752-13-3573-I-1 Lamar M. Avila DA-0752-13-3427-I-1 Leeandro C. Alderete DA-0752-13-3837-I-1 Leonard E. Acker DA-0752-13-3628-I-1 Leonel V. Adams DA-0752-13-3886-I-1 Linda E. Bass DA-0752-13-2884-I-1 12 Lionel R. Cortinas DA-0752-13-3643-I-1 Lodie M. Arredondo DA-0752-13-2668-I-1 Lorenza L. Canales DA-0752-13-2612-I-1 Louis L. Alvarado DA-0752-13-2740-I-1 MICHAEL V. ANDERSON DA-0752-13-3642-I-1 Manuel Alvarez DA-0752-13-1612-I-1 Manuel J. Coronado DA-0752-13-2860-I-1 Manuel N. Alvarez DA-0752-13-2487-I-1 Marcos C. Betancourt DA-0752-13-1211-I-1 Margarito Barraza DA-0752-13-2659-I-1 Maria G. Chacon DA-0752-13-2460-I-1 Mariano T. Cervantes DA-0752-13-2846-I-1 Mark A. Bradsher DA-0752-13-3855-I-1 Mark A. Cahlik DA-0752-14-0317-I-1 Mark Bustos DA-0752-13-2565-I-1 Martin Benavides DA-0752-13-2907-I-1 Matthew Benavides DA-0752-13-3890-I-1 Matthew D. Babbitt DA-0752-13-4035-I-1 Michael Benavides DA-0752-13-1466-I-1 Michael Cortinas DA-0752-13-1496-I-1 Michael K. Byron DA-0752-13-4039-I-1 Mike C. Briseno DA-0752-13-3961-I-1 Monica Carranza DA-0752-13-3620-I-1 Nancy G. Burgess DA-0752-13-3845-I-1 Nestor M. Chavez DA-0752-13-2854-I-1 Octaviano Aleman DA-0752-13-3635-I-1 Olga Benavidez DA-0752-13-3624-I-1 Omar Bosquez DA-0752-13-3894-I-1 Orlando J. Almaguer DA-0752-13-2431-I-1 13 Paul Creacy DA-0752-13-2782-I-1 Ramiro M. Barajas DA-0752-13-3551-I-1 Randell F. Carr DA-0752-13-1464-I-1 Reynaldo J. Contreras DA-0752-13-3219-I-1 Rhett P. Butler DA-0752-13-3858-I-1 Ricardo Amaya DA-0752-13-3229-I-1 Ricardo M. Cruz DA-0752-13-3676-I-1 Richard G. Carter DA-0752-13-3235-I-1 Rikki Craig DA-0752-13-4605-I-1 Robert Aguirre DA-0752-13-3872-I-1 Robert J. Bean DA-0752-13-3586-I-1 Robert L. Anderson DA-0752-13-3470-I-1 Robert L. Castaneda DA-0752-13-3579-I-1 Roberto Almaraz DA-0752-13-3978-I-1 Roger D. Banks DA-0752-13-3594-I-1 Romeo A. Arriaga DA-0752-13-3471-I-1 Roy C. Coffman DA-0752-13-2897-I-1 Ruben Arreola DA-0752-13-3252-I-1 Ruben Ayala DA-0752-13-2409-I-1 Russell T. Brashars DA-0752-13-3433-I-1 Sammy Cabrera DA-0752-13-3571-I-1 Sara Botello DA-0752-13-2411-I-1 Shaunna L. Cavazos DA-0752-13-3648-I-1 Shea H. Adams DA-0752-13-2455-I-1 Steve W. Boxwell DA-0752-13-3787-I-1 Susan C. Caldwell DA-0752-13-3225-I-1 Sylvia S. Benavides DA-0752-13-2499-I-1 Theodoro Contreras DA-0752-13-2796-I-1 Thomas A. Brinn DA-0752-13-3230-I-1 14 Thomas A. Cantu DA-0752-13-3562-I-1 Timothy C. Corwin DA-0752-13-2291-I-1 Tina M. Cox DA-0752-13-3124-I-1 Veronica R. Alvarado DA-0752-13-3544-I-1 Victor E. Castillo DA-0752-13-2944-I-1 Yolanda Coleman DA-0752-13-3242-I-1 15 APPENDIX B CCAD ARX6-2 DA-0752-14-0281-I-1 Aaron T. Gonzalez DA-0752-13-3631-I-1 Adam Franco DA-0752-13-2667-I-1 Agustin H. Garcia DA-0752-13-2866-I-1 Albert G. Guajardo DA-0752-13-3650-I-1 Alberto Delgado DA-0752-13-3883-I-1 Alejos Elizondo DA-0752-13-3904-I-1 Alfonso G. Flores DA-0752-13-2753-I-1 Alfonso G. Garcia DA-0752-13-3469-I-1 Alfredo De La Garza DA-0752-13-2468-I-1 Amador Y. Duran DA-0752-13-2857-I-1 Andres Garcia DA-0752-13-2973-I-1 Andres Garcia DA-0752-13-1485-I-1 Andrew Garza DA-0752-13-3619-I-1 Antonio Garcia DA-0752-13-3444-I-1 Armando Felix DA-0752-13-2609-I-1 Arnulfo Flores DA-0752-13-3925-I-1 Arthur Gomez DA-0752-13-1807-I-1 Belen A. Epps DA-0752-13-3863-I-1 Belinda Gamez DA-0752-13-3939-I-1 Braulio Dominguez DA-0752-13-3931-I-1 Bryan A. Gomez DA-0752-13-2732-I-1 Cain D. Gracia DA-0752-13-3570-I-1 Carlos G. Garza DA-0752-13-2788-I-1 Carlos A. Diaz DA-0752-13-2937-I-1 Christina M. Gonzalez DA-0752-13-1071-I-1 16 Christopher A. Flores DA-0752-13-3424-I-1 Christopher G. Guzman DA-0752-13-2653-I-1 Christopher R. Green DA-0752-13-3609-I-1 Clemente Gonzalez DA-0752-13-3595-I-1 Consuelo Gonzalez DA-0752-13-1995-I-1 Corando Gallegos DA-0752-13-2799-I-1 Corey L. Gunter DA-0752-13-4033-I-1 Curtis Davis DA-0752-13-2834-I-1 Cynthia M. Garza DA-0752-13-3810-I-1 Daniel G. Flores DA-0752-13-3792-I-1 Daniel Garcia DA-0752-13-3873-I-1 Daniel L. Garibay DA-0752-13-2891-I-1 Dario Encinia DA-0752-13-2469-I-1 Darrell E. Easter DA-0752-13-3944-I-1 David A. Garcia DA-0752-13-3662-I-1 David A. Garza DA-0752-13-3815-I-1 David F. Garcia DA-0752-13-3134-I-1 David M. Fiorenzi DA-0752-13-3680-I-1 David R. Flores DA-0752-13-1070-I-1 Dee A. Espurvoa DA-0752-13-3993-I-1 Diana P. Garcia DA-0752-13-4040-I-1 Diane H. Fjeldahl DA-0752-13-3818-I-1 Domingo Gonzalez DA-0752-13-1072-I-1 Douglas Franklin DA-0752-13-4004-I-1 Edward R. Escareno DA-0752-13-2600-I-1 Efrain Garza DA-0752-13-3881-I-1 Elias J. Escobedo DA-0752-13-3824-I-1 Elma Garcia-Trevino DA-0752-13-2877-I-1 Emilio Guerra DA-0752-13-2831-I-1 17 Enrique A. Figueroa DA-0752-13-2927-I-1 Enrique G. Garcia DA-0752-13-3552-I-1 Enrique L. Espinosa DA-0752-13-3688-I-1 Eric A. Diaz DA-0752-13-3870-I-1 Ernest A. Garcia DA-0752-13-3249-I-1 Ernesto R. Flores DA-0752-13-3625-I-1 Fernando G. Flores DA-0752-13-2410-I-1 Francisco Gaona DA-0752-13-3807-I-1 Gabriel Garcia DA-0752-13-2571-I-1 Gabriel Gomez DA-0752-13-2439-I-1 Genero Garcia DA-0752-13-3935-I-1 Gilberto Escamilla DA-0752-13-3910-I-1 Graciela R. Gomez DA-0752-13-2512-I-1 Guadalupe Davila DA-0752-13-3835-I-1 Gustavo Gonzalez DA-0752-13-3440-I-1 Harry E. Falcon DA-0752-13-3464-I-1 Hector Garcia DA-0752-13-3936-I-1 Hector N. Deleon DA-0752-13-1216-I-1 Isaac DePriest DA-0752-13-1068-I-1 Israel O. Flores DA-0752-13-2577-I-1 Issac R. Garza DA-0752-13-3234-I-1 Jaime B. Garcia DA-0752-13-2405-I-1 James J. Flores DA-0752-13-3611-I-1 James M. Evans DA-0752-13-3121-I-1 Jason F. Edwards DA-0752-13-3880-I-1 Jennifer L. Flores DA-0752-13-2578-I-1 Jerardo Gamino DA-0752-13-3396-I-1 Jesse R. Guerra DA-0752-13-1497-I-1 Jesus Garcia DA-0752-13-2716-I-1 18 Jesus Garcia DA-0752-13-2453-I-1 Jesus Gutierrez DA-0752-13-3575-I-1 Jimmie C. Dennis DA-0752-13-3527-I-1 Joe G. Garcia DA-0752-13-2923-I-1 Joel Espuruda DA-0752-13-2757-I-1 Joel Garza DA-0752-13-2303-I-1 John C. Flores DA-0752-13-3227-I-1 John J. Flores DA-0752-13-3615-I-1 John M. Esqueda DA-0752-13-2726-I-1 John M. Garza DA-0752-13-3865-I-1 Jorge A. Fernandez DA-0752-13-2802-I-1 Jose A. Gonzales DA-0752-13-3974-I-1 Jose Dominguez DA-0752-13-2839-I-1 Jose G. Gonzalez DA-0752-13-3669-I-1 Jose Garza DA-0752-13-3637-I-1 Jose J. Franco DA-0752-13-4289-I-1 Joseph L. Danley DA-0752-13-3597-I-1 Joshua C. Gonzales DA-0752-13-3564-I-1 Joshua R. Everett DA-0752-13-2828-I-1 Juan E. Garcia DA-0752-13-2548-I-1 Juan Gonzalez DA-0752-13-1804-I-1 Juan L. Gonzalez DA-0752-13-2683-I-1 Justin Davis DA-0752-13-4604-I-1 Karl R. Gibson DA-0752-13-2781-I-1 Kent W. Goodwin DA-0752-13-1487-I-1 Kevin J. Easley DA-0752-13-3900-I-1 Louis R. Guillen DA-0752-13-3851-I-1 Luis P. Garcia DA-0752-13-3228-I-1 Mack Eden DA-0752-13-3463-I-1 19 Manuel Garcia DA-0752-13-3682-I-1 Manuel Gonzalez DA-0752-13-1231-I-1 Marciano J. Gonzalez DA-0752-13-3604-I-1 Margil M. Guerra DA-0752-13-2646-I-1 Maria A. Garcia DA-0752-13-2888-I-1 Mario A. Estrada DA-0752-13-2630-I-1 Martin M. Gutierrez DA-0752-13-2561-I-1 Martin R. Garcia DA-0752-13-2865-I-1 Matthew R. Garza DA-0752-13-3820-I-1 Melina C. Garza DA-0752-13-3888-I-1 Michael Garza DA-0752-13-3684-I-1 Michael L. Gallegos DA-0752-13-3994-I-1 Michal E. Funk DA-0752-13-3813-I-1 Micheal Esparza DA-0752-13-2902-I-1 Nicole L. Garcia DA-0752-13-2900-I-1 Norman S. Dozier DA-0752-13-1069-I-1 Olivia M. Dominguez DA-0752-13-3673-I-1 Ophelia F. Garza DA-0752-13-3598-I-1 Orlando Delacruz DA-0752-13-3460-I-1 Oscar G. Garza DA-0752-13-3806-I-1 Oscar Garcia DA-0752-13-4017-I-1 Oscar Gutierrez DA-0752-13-2553-I-1 Pedro Gonzales DA-0752-13-1921-I-1 Raul Garcia DA-0752-13-1230-I-1 Raul Garza DA-0752-13-1483-I-1 Raul S. Garcia DA-0752-13-2318-I-1 Ray E. Elizondo DA-0752-13-4529-I-1 Reinaldo Granado DA-0752-13-2898-I-1 Reynaldo DeLeon DA-0752-13-1462-I-1 20 Reynaldo G. Guerrero DA-0752-13-4009-I-1 Ricardo Galindo DA-0752-13-1924-I-1 Ricardo M. Gonzalez DA-0752-13-3606-I-1 Richard A. Gabehart DA-0752-13-4043-I-1 Richard A. Gale DA-0752-13-2867-I-1 Richard L. Guenter DA-0752-13-2652-I-1 Richard M. Garcia DA-0752-13-1854-I-1 Richard P. Gonzalez DA-0752-13-3920-I-1 Robert A. Gonzalez DA-0752-13-3658-I-1 Robert Garcia DA-0752-13-3558-I-1 Robert Gomez DA-0752-13-3834-I-1 Roberto Flores DA-0752-13-2459-I-1 Roderick T. Dunham DA-0752-13-2657-I-1 Roel M. Escobar DA-0752-13-2589-I-1 Rogelio Gallegos DA-0752-13-3666-I-1 Roger B. Duenes DA-0752-13-2277-I-1 Roger Gallegos DA-0752-13-3986-I-1 Rojelio R. Garcia DA-0752-13-3627-I-1 Rolland L. Forward DA-0752-13-2426-I-1 Rosendo C. Gonzales DA-0752-13-2679-I-1 Ruben D. Gonzalez DA-0752-13-3687-I-1 Ruben Garcia DA-0752-13-2301-I-1 Rudy Garcia DA-0752-13-2835-I-1 Rudy Garza DA-0752-13-2677-I-1 Samuel Escareno DA-0752-13-3566-I-1 Samuel Garrett DA-0752-13-2837-I-1 Sandra T. Garza DA-0752-13-2938-I-1 Santiago Gonzales DA-0752-13-3126-I-1 Sergio Franco DA-0752-13-2735-I-1 21 Simon Guerrero DA-0752-13-2275-I-1 Sonia M. Esqueda DA-0752-13-2576-I-1 Stephanie A. Funk DA-0752-13-2905-I-1 Stephen R. Duncan DA-0752-13-2575-I-1 Steven Garcia DA-0752-13-3250-I-1 Steven S. Garcia DA-0752-13-2869-I-1 Susan E. Faught DA-0752-13-2703-I-1 Thomas Franco DA-0752-13-3847-I-1 Tina A. Gonzalez DA-0752-13-2886-I-1 Tomas Gonzalez DA-0752-13-3430-I-1 Veronica Gonzalez DA-0752-13-3869-I-1 Victor Garcia DA-0752-13-3812-I-1 Victor O. Garcia DA-0752-13-2850-I-1 Wilfrido Galvan DA-0752-13-1996-I-1 William H. Guinn DA-0752-13-2494-I-1 22 APPENDIX C CCAD ARX6-3 DA-0752-14-0379-I-1 Aaron Hoss DA-0752-13-3478-I-1 Abram Lopez DA-0752-13-3655-I-1 Adrian J. Martinez DA-0752-13-1078-I-1 Alejandro Lopez DA-0752-13-3143-I-1 Allen Heider DA-0752-13-2840-I-1 Ann G. Harris DA-0752-13-3466-I-1 Antonio G. Lopez DA-0752-13-2276-I-1 Armando E. Lopez DA-0752-13-2681-I-1 Armando Leal DA-0752-13-1484-I-1 Astrid S. Hopkins DA-0752-13-3940-I-1 Barbara Luna DA-0752-13-2471-I-1 Bruce D. Hardy DA-0752-13-2958-I-1 Bryan A. Martinez DA-0752-13-2666-I-1 Bryan J. Hedrick DA-0752-13-2722-I-1 Cameron M. McKenzie DA-0752-13-4052-I-1 Carlos Hernandez DA-0752-13-3445-I-1 Carlos Lopez DA-0752-13-3948-I-1 Carlos P. Luna DA-0752-13-2591-I-1 Carmen M. Loving DA-0752-13-4029-I-1 Charles S. Hoke DA-0752-13-3582-I-1 Christina G. Lara DA-0752-13-2871-I-1 Christopher R. Martinez DA-0752-13-3129-I-1 Clifford D. Hostutler DA-0752-13-2912-I-1 Clifton W. James DA-0752-13-3885-I-1 Curtis L. Langridge DA-0752-13-3992-I-1 23 Cynthia G. Lewis DA-0752-13-3683-I-1 Cynthia K. Holmes DA-0752-13-3814-I-1 Daniel P. Martinez DA-0752-13-3997-I-1 Daniel T. Jimenez DA-0752-13-2440-I-1 Daniel V. Hernandez DA-0752-13-2444-I-1 Danny J. Hughes DA-0752-13-2550-I-1 Darren V. Lister DA-0752-13-3861-I-1 David E. Lechner DA-0752-13-2319-I-1 David J. Landa DA-0752-13-3576-I-1 David M. Hurley DA-0752-13-1428-I-1 David V. Hernandez DA-0752-13-3565-I-1 Delma R. Lopez DA-0752-13-3875-I-1 Diana C. Maldonado DA-0752-13-3990-I-1 Edward Herrera DA-0752-13-3995-I-1 Eliseo G. Martinez DA-0752-13-2433-I-1 Emilio F. Jimenez DA-0752-13-2414-I-1 Eric F. Hill DA-0752-13-3443-I-1 Eric M. Jolly DA-0752-13-3934-I-1 Eric M. Killian DA-0752-13-2316-I-1 Eric V. Martinez DA-0752-13-3786-I-1 Ervey J. Martinez DA-0752-13-2412-I-1 Evan A. Huck DA-0752-13-3568-I-1 Ezekiel L. Lara DA-0752-13-3962-I-1 Francisco Herrera DA-0752-13-3542-I-1 Francisco J. Hinojosa DA-0752-13-2918-I-1 Frank L. Horton DA-0752-13-4044-I-1 Frank L. Johnson DA-0752-13-3866-I-1 Gabriel J. Luna DA-0752-13-2671-I-1 Genaro Lopez DA-0752-13-2861-I-1 24 George Leal DA-0752-13-3693-I-1 Gerald W. Hance DA-0752-13-2648-I-1 Geronimo Martinez DA-0752-13-2647-I-1 Gilberto Hinojosa DA-0752-13-3522-I-1 Guadalupe Leal DA-0752-13-3959-I-1 Hector E. Herrera DA-0752-13-3664-I-1 Hector Hernandez DA-0752-13-2607-I-1 Herman D. Harvey DA-0752-13-3559-I-1 Hilario Lugo DA-0752-13-3839-I-1 Hilario Martinez DA-0752-13-1705-I-1 Ismael Martinez DA-0752-13-3142-I-1 Jacob A. Leos DA-0752-13-3892-I-1 Jacob O. Hart DA-0752-13-4294-I-1 Jaime Jimenez DA-0752-13-3226-I-1 James A. Lott DA-0752-13-3895-I-1 James E. Hesskew DA-0752-13-2818-I-1 James J. Kinney DA-0752-13-1077-I-1 Javier N. Huerta DA-0752-13-2661-I-1 Jeremiah A. Johnson DA-0752-14-0195-I-1 Jim J. Hinkey DA-0752-13-3587-I-1 Joe F. Lopez DA-0752-13-3956-I-1 Joe G. Martinez DA-0752-13-2490-I-1 Joe L. Lopez DA-0752-13-2423-I-1 John A. Lewis DA-0752-13-3856-I-1 John P. Karg DA-0752-13-3592-I-1 John P. Luke DA-0752-13-2484-I-1 John T. Lopez DA-0752-13-3671-I-1 Johnny Martinez DA-0752-13-2790-I-1 Jose A. Hawkins DA-0752-13-4022-I-1 25 Jose A. Jimenez DA-0752-13-1797-I-1 Jose A. Martinez DA-0752-13-3653-I-1 Jose F. Jimenez DA-0752-13-2563-I-1 Josefina Huape DA-0752-13-2910-I-1 Joseph L. Herrera DA-0752-13-2675-I-1 Joseph R. Kaper DA-0752-13-3864-I-1 Joshua A. Leos DA-0752-13-3639-I-1 Joshua C. Lopez DA-0752-13-2830-I-1 Juan A. Martinez DA-0752-13-3816-I-1 Juan J. Martinez DA-0752-13-2692-I-1 Juan R. Lara DA-0752-13-3548-I-1 Juanita C. Martinez DA-0752-13-3116-I-1 Julian Lopez DA-0752-13-1756-I-1 Julio M. Lopez DA-0752-13-3942-I-1 Justin H. Hanson DA-0752-13-1492-I-1 Kara L. Howell DA-0752-13-2501-I-1 Karl W. Littlejohn DA-0752-13-4003-I-1 Kevin E. Kell DA-0752-13-4041-I-1 Kevin J. Lacour DA-0752-13-4008-I-1 Lemar S. Martin DA-0752-13-3903-I-1 Leonard Lopez DA-0752-13-2940-I-1 Linda F. Jackson DA-0752-13-4049-I-1 Lionel Hernandez DA-0752-13-1073-I-1 Lisa A. Matthews DA-0752-13-3135-I-1 Lloyd C. Loree DA-0752-13-2933-I-1 Lloyd M. Holloway DA-0752-13-3453-I-1 Manuel D. Johnson DA-0752-13-2506-I-1 Marcus W. Johnson DA-0752-13-3450-I-1 Maria G. Leal DA-0752-13-3622-I-1 26 Mark A. Heyder DA-0752-13-1074-I-1 Martin G. Luis DA-0752-13-3652-I-1 Martin Martinez DA-0752-13-3979-I-1 Merced Lopez DA-0752-13-3843-I-1 Michael A. Hernandez DA-0752-13-2680-I-1 Michael Kaufman DA-0752-13-2779-I-1 Michael L. Johnson DA-0752-13-4292-I-1 Michael W. Jewell DA-0752-13-1076-I-1 Michael W. Kyle DA-0752-13-3804-I-1 Milton C. Ivy DA-0752-13-2442-I-1 Nicolas Martinez DA-0752-13-3692-I-1 Noe H. Lozano DA-0752-13-2320-I-1 Noe Jimenez DA-0752-13-3907-I-1 Noelia P. LeLaurin DA-0752-13-2882-I-1 Norma L. Martinez DA-0752-13-3221-I-1 Nykkolette A. Hornsby DA-0752-13-3794-I-1 Ovidio V. Martinez DA-0752-13-2663-I-1 Pablo Lazo DA-0752-13-2959-I-1 Patricia A. Martinez DA-0752-13-3133-I-1 Patrick K. Lacy DA-0752-13-2464-I-1 Patrick Lewis DA-0752-13-1961-I-1 Patrick S. Hattersley DA-0752-13-2929-I-1 Paulino Landa DA-0752-13-2478-I-1 Pedro Infante DA-0752-13-2730-I-1 Pedro Lopez DA-0752-13-3785-I-1 Peli Leulu DA-0752-13-2804-I-1 Peter Hernandez DA-0752-13-4006-I-1 Phillip M. Letts DA-0752-13-2614-I-1 Phillip Martin DA-0752-13-1607-I-1 27 Piranski Joseph DA-0752-13-3921-I-1 Rafael Lopez DA-0752-13-2878-I-1 Raoul A. Lerma DA-0752-13-4034-I-1 Raul P. Lozano DA-0752-13-2955-I-1 Ray A. Madrigal DA-0752-13-3654-I-1 Ray Mares DA-0752-13-1228-I-1 Rene J. Hernandez DA-0752-13-2451-I-1 Reyes H. Martinez DA-0752-13-2963-I-1 Reynold A. John DA-0752-13-3857-I-1 Ricardo Lopez DA-0752-13-3969-I-1 Richard Loya DA-0752-13-1467-I-1 Richard A. Martinez DA-0752-13-3789-I-1 Robert Lucio DA-0752-13-1465-I-1 Robert E. Hopkins DA-0752-13-2721-I-1 Robert G. Hannabass DA-0752-13-3929-I-1 Robert G. Janosek DA-0752-13-4021-I-1 Robert G. Lemos DA-0752-13-2549-I-1 Robert Lazo DA-0752-13-3240-I-1 Roel F. Luna DA-0752-13-3838-I-1 Rogelio Lopez DA-0752-13-4002-I-1 Roger H. Krayse DA-0752-13-2507-I-1 Roger J. Huron DA-0752-13-3912-I-1 Roland D. Marquez DA-0752-13-2299-I-1 Ron G. Jaime DA-0752-13-2416-I-1 Ronald A. Kenyon DA-0752-13-2497-I-1 Sandra L. Jackson DA-0752-13-4024-I-1 Santos F. Martinez DA-0752-13-3691-I-1 Sergio J. Magana DA-0752-13-2514-I-1 Steve Mason DA-0752-13-4055-I-1 28 Sylvia M. Leal DA-0752-13-3937-I-1 Tammy G. Hilliard DA-0752-13-2731-I-1 Thomas Jaimes DA-0752-13-2654-I-1 Tomas Lozano DA-0752-13-3130-I-1 Tommy L. Herrera DA-0752-13-3549-I-1 Tracy A. Hughes DA-0752-13-3842-I-1 Valentin Lopez DA-0752-13-3610-I-1 Veronica Martinez DA-0752-13-2697-I-1 Wallace G. Ham DA-0752-13-3811-I-1 Walter L. Kroft DA-0752-13-2764-I-1 Willie L. Hill DA-0752-13-2673-I-1 29 APPENDIX D CCAD ARX6-4 DA-0752-14-0390-I-1 Alvin J. Mikus DA-0752-13-2925-I-1 Amanda Peralez DA-0752-13-1604-I-1 Arnaldo Pabon DA-0752-13-1080-I-1 Benjamin D. Miller DA-0752-13-2650-I-1 Brian Robbins DA-0752-13-1227-I-1 Caldean L. Pitcher DA-0752-13-3859-I-1 Carlos G. Pena DA-0752-13-3821-I-1 Carlos Montez DA-0752-13-3553-I-1 Carlos R. Medina DA-0752-13-2559-I-1 Carlos Rossel DA-0752-13-3431-I-1 Carrie P. Riley DA-0752-13-2868-I-1 Catherine M. Moulzolf DA-0752-13-2816-I-1 Cesar Munoz DA-0752-13-1220-I-1 Charles E. Robinson DA-0752-13-2651-I-1 Che A. Presas DA-0752-13-2482-I-1 Christobal S. Rodriguez DA-0752-13-2308-I-1 Christopher L. Rittgers DA-0752-13-3641-I-1 Crystal A. Rosales DA-0752-13-3125-I-1 Damasio Perez DA-0752-13-3518-I-1 Daniel A. Pompa DA-0752-13-2540-I-1 Daniel Rodriguez DA-0752-13-2743-I-1 Dara Rosenzweig DA-0752-13-3118-I-1 Dario J. Reyes DA-0752-13-2931-I-1 Darren R. Rew DA-0752-13-2415-I-1 David Pena DA-0752-13-2029-I-1 30 David K. Pletcher DA-0752-13-3879-I-1 David O. Rodriguez DA-0752-13-4045-I-1 David Ruiz DA-0752-13-3675-I-1 Denise Mechell DA-0752-13-3574-I-1 Dennis K. Norcross DA-0752-13-2806-I-1 Dina Reyna DA-0752-13-2585-I-1 Domingo Mendoza DA-0752-13-4005-I-1 Domingo Naranjo DA-0752-13-3436-I-1 Edward M. Morales DA-0752-13-3988-I-1 Edward M. Powell DA-0752-13-3898-I-1 Edward M. Rokusek DA-0752-13-3924-I-1 Edward R. Morgan DA-0752-13-4023-I-1 Edward Recio DA-0752-13-3965-I-1 Efrain Ozuna DA-0752-13-2950-I-1 Elva I. Rodriguez DA-0752-13-2736-I-1 Emilio Reyes DA-0752-13-3596-I-1 Eric J. Rodriguez DA-0752-13-2770-I-1 Eric Murphy DA-0752-13-1213-I-1 Erma L. Nelson DA-0752-13-2634-I-1 Ernest C. Ramos DA-0752-13-3247-I-1 Ernest J. Reyes DA-0752-13-3896-I-1 Eugenio Reyna DA-0752-13-2546-I-1 Evangelina Prado DA-0752-13-2473-I-1 Flenoy R. Phillips DA-0752-13-2660-I-1 Fred E. Paul DA-0752-13-2428-I-1 Gabriel Ramirez DA-0752-13-2914-I-1 Gary W. Musgrove DA-0752-13-3983-I-1 Gene P. Ng DA-0752-13-3825-I-1 George Robles DA-0752-13-2435-I-1 31 Gerald D. Reyes DA-0752-13-3871-I-1 Gilbert Reyna DA-0752-13-3941-I-1 Gilberto R. Rosalez DA-0752-13-4026-I-1 Gloria M. Olivarez DA-0752-13-2815-I-1 Gregory G. Overton DA-0752-13-2670-I-1 Guadalupe Quintanilla DA-0752-13-2686-I-1 Hadrian D. Morales DA-0752-13-3854-I-1 Helio Perez DA-0752-13-2810-I-1 Hermenegildo Perez DA-0752-13-1609-I-1 Horace S. Montgomery DA-0752-13-3777-I-1 Humberto J. Ortiz DA-0752-13-3419-I-1 Humberto Miranda DA-0752-13-4020-I-1 James A. Ortega DA-0752-13-2297-I-1 James E. Payno DA-0752-13-3546-I-1 James R. Middour DA-0752-13-3605-I-1 James R. Patterson DA-0752-13-3613-I-1 Jason A. Rodriguez DA-0752-13-3251-I-1 Javier A. Rosario DA-0752-13-2479-I-1 Jeffrey K. Reid DA-0752-13-2863-I-1 Jeffrey L. Nelson DA-0752-13-2817-I-1 Jeffrey L. Roten DA-0752-13-3853-I-1 Jeffrey S. Plake DA-0752-13-3241-I-1 Jesus Rodriguez DA-0752-13-3621-I-1 Joe E. Nesmith DA-0752-13-2443-I-1 Joe J. Montoya DA-0752-13-2774-I-1 John M. Rojas DA-0752-13-2688-I-1 Jonathan T. Rogers DA-0752-13-3224-I-1 Jose A. Moreno DA-0752-13-3600-I-1 Jose A. Ramon DA-0752-13-4600-I-1 32 Jose L. Puente DA-0752-13-3218-I-1 Jose L. Rivers DA-0752-13-3928-I-1 Jose M. Ortega DA-0752-13-3623-I-1 Jose Pardo DA-0752-13-2784-I-1 Jose Rodriguez DA-0752-13-2406-I-1 Joseph A. Ramos DA-0752-13-2510-I-1 Juan C. Orozco DA-0752-13-1915-I-1 Julian Palos DA-0752-13-3831-I-1 Kay L. Rittgers DA-0752-13-2420-I-1 Kimberly Quiroga DA-0752-13-3850-I-1 Larry K. Mitchell DA-0752-13-4011-I-1 Larry Ochoa DA-0752-13-3560-I-1 Lawrence M. Norotsky DA-0752-13-1437-I-1 Lee A. Ramon DA-0752-13-4013-I-1 Leroy E. Oelrich DA-0752-13-3670-I-1 Liza M. Reid DA-0752-13-3867-I-1 Mandy Muniz DA-0752-13-2800-I-1 Manuel M. Rodriguez DA-0752-13-2741-I-1 Manuel Perez DA-0752-13-2466-I-1 Manuel Perez DA-0752-13-2655-I-1 Manuel Rincones DA-0752-13-2953-I-1 Marcus W. Muniz DA-0752-13-3585-I-1 Mario Moreno DA-0752-13-2946-I-1 Marisela Moya DA-0752-13-4290-I-1 Matthew L. O'Donnell DA-0752-13-3827-I-1 Melquiades Miranda DA-0752-13-2542-I-1 Michael A. Ramirez DA-0752-13-3583-I-1 Michael H. Richardson DA-0752-13-3591-I-1 Michael L. Rust DA-0752-13-2495-I-1 33 Michael Q. Mueller DA-0752-13-3846-I-1 Michael W. Nsoh DA-0752-13-3578-I-1 Michael W. Orrick DA-0752-13-2825-I-1 Miguel Mendoza DA-0752-13-2842-I-1 Mitchum Nagir DA-0752-13-1233-I-1 Monica M. Medina-Garza DA-0752-13-3952-I-1 Monica Mondragon DA-0752-13-3899-I-1 Morris T. Mister DA-0752-13-2705-I-1 Nari A. Muhammad DA-0752-13-2880-I-1 Noe I. Ramos DA-0752-13-3876-I-1 Nora S. Najera DA-0752-13-3123-I-1 Oscar Rodriguez DA-0752-13-3636-I-1 Pamela A. Robinson DA-0752-13-2759-I-1 Paul M. Ramon DA-0752-13-3569-I-1 Paul Rowland DA-0752-13-3638-I-1 Peter L. Peralez DA-0752-13-1603-I-1 Ralph Perez DA-0752-13-2875-I-1 Ramiro Meave DA-0752-13-2289-I-1 Ramon L. Rodriguez DA-0752-13-3132-I-1 Raul A. Ramirez DA-0752-13-2951-I-1 Ray J. Rivera DA-0752-13-3878-I-1 Reymundo J. Ornelaz DA-0752-13-2775-I-1 Reynaldo Ortiz DA-0752-13-3981-I-1 Reynaldo Rodriguez DA-0752-13-2771-I-1 Ricardo A. Perez DA-0752-13-4307-I-1 Ricardo Renteria DA-0752-13-1916-I-1 Ricardo Rocha DA-0752-13-4030-I-1 Ricardo Rossel DA-0752-13-2960-I-1 Richard D. Ochoa DA-0752-13-3960-I-1 34 Richard Ruiz DA-0752-13-2920-I-1 Robert A. Orta DA-0752-13-3663-I-1 Robert D. Ramirez DA-0752-13-3906-I-1 Robert D. Rivera DA-0752-13-3677-I-1 Robert E. Moore DA-0752-13-4001-I-1 Robert M. Pena DA-0752-13-3833-I-1 Robert N. Mendoza DA-0752-13-2419-I-1 Robert N. Perusquia DA-0752-13-2583-I-1 Robert Olivarez DA-0752-13-3973-I-1 Robert R. Rodriguez DA-0752-13-3665-I-1 Roberto R. Pierce DA-0752-13-3237-I-1 Rodolfo Ramirez DA-0752-13-2823-I-1 Roel Ruiz DA-0752-13-3414-I-1 Roger L. Mora DA-0752-13-3584-I-1 Romaldo S. Rodriguez DA-0752-13-2767-I-1 Roman Pereida DA-0752-13-3122-I-1 Rosario L. Rodriguez DA-0752-13-1221-I-1 Rose Marie V. Rust DA-0752-13-3612-I-1 Ruben A. Rivera DA-0752-13-3144-I-1 Ruben Molina DA-0752-13-1611-I-1 Ruben Olmeda DA-0752-13-2593-I-1 Rudy Ramirez DA-0752-13-3136-I-1 Rudy Riojas DA-0752-13-2408-I-1 Russell X. Rosales DA-0752-13-3832-I-1 Santiago A. Ramos DA-0752-13-2948-I-1 Sarah A. Robertson DA-0752-13-3672-I-1 Sarah L. Ortega DA-0752-13-3476-I-1 Sean A. Ritchie DA-0752-13-2618-I-1 Sergio G. Perales DA-0752-13-3889-I-1 35 Shane A. Moore DA-0752-13-2632-I-1 Shane D. Montgomery DA-0752-13-3795-I-1 Shaun E. Mehegan DA-0752-13-3412-I-1 Stephen L. Perez DA-0752-13-3975-I-1 Sylvestre B. Reyes DA-0752-13-2417-I-1 Teesha M. Reynolds DA-0752-13-3238-I-1 Terence P. Odeay DA-0752-13-3801-I-1 Theresa M. Perez DA-0752-13-3127-I-1 Vance L. Rousseau DA-0752-13-3657-I-1 Victor M. Moreno DA-0752-13-3467-I-1 Victor Olvera DA-0752-13-4007-I-1 Waylan F. Miller DA-0752-13-3775-I-1 William J. Pipkins DA-0752-13-3451-I-1 William L. Rodriguez DA-0752-13-1224-I-1 William P. Murray DA-0752-13-2587-I-1 Xavier Rivera DA-0752-13-2287-I-1 36 APPENDIX E CCAD ARX6-5 DA-0752-14-0391-I-1 Aaron D. Tibbets DA-0752-13-3222-I-1 Abel Valdez DA-0752-13-3632-I-1 Abelardo O. Salinas DA-0752-13-3963-I-1 Ademar J. Silguero DA-0752-13-2595-I-1 Adolph Joseph Skrobarczyk DA-0752-13-4598-I-1 Alfonso E. Santos DA-0752-13-2684-I-1 Alfred E. Williams DA-0752-13-3782-I-1 Alonzo M. Valdez DA-0752-13-3254-I-1 Antonio Valadez DA-0752-13-2896-I-1 Arnold Zapata DA-0752-13-1086-I-1 Baldemar T. Munguia DA-0752-13-3667-I-1 Benito Salinas DA-0752-13-4000-I-1 Betty M. Vaden DA-0752-13-2916-I-1 Betty T. Sumera DA-0752-13-3432-I-1 Bradley D. Spaans DA-0752-13-3989-I-1 Brent W. Newton DA-0752-13-3608-I-1 Brian K. Sharp DA-0752-13-3128-I-1 Brian R. Trube DA-0752-13-3633-I-1 Bryan M. Smith DA-0752-13-2855-I-1 Carlos B. Benavides DA-0752-13-2762-I-1 Carlos G. Tey DA-0752-13-3830-I-1 Caroll R. Wallace DA-0752-13-3603-I-1 Charles R. Ward DA-0752-13-2645-I-1 Chasity L. Smith DA-0752-13-3836-I-1 Christopher J. Soto DA-0752-13-2678-I-1 37 Christopher P. Zuyus DA-0752-13-3902-I-1 Christopher T. Salters DA-0752-13-2481-I-1 Christopher Yanez DA-0752-13-3255-I-1 Clinton T. Werner DA-0752-13-2772-I-1 Cruz A. Zamudio DA-0752-13-2588-I-1 Daniel F. Tamez DA-0752-13-2581-I-1 Daniel M. Washa DA-0752-13-4293-I-1 Daniel O. Zona DA-0752-13-2313-I-1 Daniel Seanez DA-0752-13-2956-I-1 Daniel Wilburn DA-0752-13-3248-I-1 David M. Stephenson DA-0752-13-2832-I-1 David R. Stewart DA-0752-13-4025-I-1 Derrick D. Sullivan DA-0752-13-2626-I-1 Domingo Valdez DA-0752-13-4042-I-1 Donivan F. Babcock DA-0752-13-4668-I-1 Donney D. Zumwalt DA-0752-13-2556-I-1 Edmundo Valdez DA-0752-13-2733-I-1 Edward Salomon DA-0752-13-3817-I-1 Elizabeth S. Weeks DA-0752-13-3874-I-1 Elizabeth Sanchez DA-0752-13-2539-I-1 Felecia L. Taylor DA-0752-13-3580-I-1 Fidel Vela DA-0752-13-4016-I-1 Francisco Saldivar DA-0752-13-3980-I-1 Francisco Sanchez DA-0752-13-2623-I-1 Franklin Smith DA-0752-13-1613-I-1 Fred D. Warren DA-0752-13-2305-I-1 Gabriel P. Valverde DA-0752-13-3659-I-1 Gilbert A. Suarez DA-0752-13-3901-I-1 Gilbert I. Salinas DA-0752-13-3808-I-1 38 Gilbert S. Torres DA-0752-13-2504-I-1 Gregory Tharas DA-0752-13-1717-I-1 Guadalupe G. Silguero DA-0752-13-2917-I-1 Herbert R. Saenz DA-0752-13-3897-I-1 Hilda L. Santos DA-0752-13-2462-I-1 Ismael Vera DA-0752-13-2544-I-1 Israel R. Salazar DA-0752-13-3421-I-1 Jack E. Scott DA-0752-13-3778-I-1 Jacob Solis DA-0752-13-3985-I-1 Jacob Torres DA-0752-13-3590-I-1 Jacobbryan Z. Sauceda DA-0752-13-4015-I-1 James C. Stillwell DA-0752-13-2838-I-1 James L. Vaughn DA-0752-13-4010-I-1 James R. Trevino DA-0752-13-2580-I-1 Jamie Villanueva DA-0752-13-4047-I-1 Jason A. Webb DA-0752-13-2724-I-1 Jason B. Sullivan DA-0752-13-2752-I-1 Jay-Roland M. Yanez DA-0752-13-3416-I-1 Jesus A. Salazar DA-0752-13-3852-I-1 Jesus M. Torres Concepion DA-0752-13-3805-I-1 Jesus R. Sanchez DA-0752-13-3137-I-1 Joel H. Torres DA-0752-13-3434-I-1 Joel Tienda DA-0752-13-3776-I-1 John A. Veloz DA-0752-13-2422-I-1 John H. Tullos DA-0752-13-2413-I-1 John J. Vasquez DA-0752-13-3477-I-1 John M. Sondrol DA-0752-13-3599-I-1 John M. Valderas DA-0752-13-3862-I-1 John R. Scherer DA-0752-13-3556-I-1 39 John R. Trevino DA-0752-13-2280-I-1 John S. Shutts DA-0752-13-3679-I-1 Jose A. Uballe DA-0752-13-3844-I-1 Jose L. Untalan DA-0752-13-3913-I-1 Jose T. Salas DA-0752-13-3800-I-1 Jose Yzaguirre DA-0752-13-2750-I-1 Joshua K. Smith DA-0752-13-3246-I-1 Juan A. Sanchez DA-0752-13-3791-I-1 Juan R. Vega DA-0752-13-3617-I-1 Juanita E. Villarreal DA-0752-13-2418-I-1 Karl E. Trybe DA-0752-13-3674-I-1 Katrina Tomao DA-0752-13-3686-I-1 Kendrick J. West DA-0752-13-2954-I-1 Kenneth A. Weeks DA-0752-13-2639-I-1 Kennith L. Starkey DA-0752-13-2656-I-1 Lazoro P. Zaragoza DA-0752-13-2841-I-1 Leith M. Weeden DA-0752-13-3799-I-1 Leslie O. Witherspoon DA-0752-13-3588-I-1 Lucio A. Valdez DA-0752-13-3849-I-1 Luis A. Santos DA-0752-13-3923-I-1 Luis L. Zarate DA-0752-13-3244-I-1 Lynda L. Sanchez DA-0752-13-3690-I-1 Marcos G. Sanchez DA-0752-13-3848-I-1 Maria M. Zamora DA-0752-13-3977-I-1 Melissa A. Sanchez DA-0752-13-3999-I-1 Michael A. Trautman DA-0752-13-4014-I-1 Michael J. Wagoner DA-0752-13-3984-I-1 Michael L. Weikman DA-0752-13-3911-I-1 Michael R Vasquez DA-0752-13-3781-I-1 40 Michael R. Suarez DA-0752-13-3243-I-1 Miguel A. Santiago-Carrillo DA-0752-13-2421-I-1 Mike Sturgeon DA-0752-13-2942-I-1 Milton A. West DA-0752-13-2541-I-1 Natalie M. Salinas DA-0752-13-2812-I-1 Nathan J. Wright DA-0752-13-4050-I-1 Ned E. Smith DA-0752-13-3678-I-1 Nestor A. Villarreal DA-0752-13-2903-I-1 Noemi Vargas DA-0752-13-2407-I-1 Omarr D. Walker DA-0752-13-3909-I-1 Oscar I. Vera DA-0752-13-3408-I-1 Oscar Sanchez DA-0752-13-1919-I-1 Pablo Villafranco DA-0752-13-3860-I-1 Pedro Trevino DA-0752-13-2972-I-1 Pete Saldivar DA-0752-13-4599-I-1 Philip Salazar DA-0752-13-2658-I-1 Phyllis I. Summerfield DA-0752-13-2941-I-1 Randolph Wilson DA-0752-13-3223-I-1 Raul Toledo DA-0752-13-2957-I-1 Raul Vera DA-0752-13-1214-I-1 Raymond R. Tovar DA-0752-13-2728-I-1 Rebecca L. Simnacher DA-0752-13-3829-I-1 Rene Verastiqui DA-0752-13-3607-I-1 Reuben R. Trevino DA-0752-13-3545-I-1 Reymundo Vela DA-0752-13-1501-I-1 Ricardo M. Verastiqui DA-0752-13-3915-I-1 Richard A. Taylor DA-0752-13-2605-I-1 Richard G. Salcido DA-0752-13-3236-I-1 Richard H. Smith DA-0752-13-1082-I-1 41 Richard M. Sandoval DA-0752-13-2744-I-1 Richard Sanchez DA-0752-13-4037-I-1 Ricky Sanders DA-0752-13-2836-I-1 Robert J. Taylor DA-0752-13-3645-I-1 Robert R. Salinas DA-0752-13-2737-I-1 Roberto L. Tamez DA-0752-13-3976-I-1 Rodolfo Solis DA-0752-13-3140-I-1 Rodolfo Valdez DA-0752-13-3647-I-1 Roland A. Vera DA-0752-13-2516-I-1 Rolando Viera DA-0752-13-3797-I-1 Rory B. Thomas DA-0752-13-2492-I-1 Roxanne J. Vela DA-0752-13-2808-I-1 Ruben A. Vegacosme DA-0752-13-3423-I-1 Ruben S. Yanez DA-0752-13-2590-I-1 Ruperto Trevino DA-0752-13-1215-I-1 Samantha J. Ximenez DA-0752-13-3967-I-1 Scott A. Sanford DA-0752-13-3828-I-1 Scott F. Simmitt DA-0752-13-1429-I-1 Sean A. Weeks DA-0752-13-3475-I-1 Sharon F. Zambrano DA-0752-13-3220-I-1 Susan G. Middour DA-0752-13-2809-I-1 Teresa A. Vann DA-0752-13-3660-I-1 Timothy C. Teel DA-0752-13-1234-I-1 Tracy M. Vann DA-0752-13-2603-I-1 Troy Saucedo DA-0752-13-2641-I-1 Vicente Villarreal DA-0752-13-1728-I-1 Victor M. Zamora DA-0752-13-2662-I-1 Walter C. Williams DA-0752-13-2966-I-1