Inasmuch as I made the decision at Special Term in Green v. Green (7 Hun, 492; S. C. affd., 69 N. Y. 553), and concurred in. the opinion in Petrie v. Wiliam's (68 Hun, 589), and prepared the opinion in Kane v. Kane (13 App. Div. 544), and am satisfied with the logic found in the opinion of Follett, J., and respect the authorities cited by him in that opinion, I fully concur in his opinion and vote to reverse the judgments below. . ■ '