Francisco v. Troy & L. Railroad

MAYHAM, P. J. (dissenting).

On the former appeal we held that there was not sufficient evidence of the defendant’s negligence to authorize the submission of the "case to the jury. I do not see that the evidence on that branch of the case has been changed on this trial, and cannot therefore concur in ordering a new trial. Proof of defendant’s negligence in this class of cases is always a necessary prerequisite to a recovery.