~CliO£. d. rJi; dJ)!$'
. 'Kf-~ ·v~tutU 4.Url.~-f~C&&b~o"
-t:1f..<- \-boo flP> .tfq, .tfCO -6-=J--
bl& c.[ f.R-l:
~ ~~:~tA\l d~ru&f~-k.-.LJU~\\~~ ~la\d't P?lE.,
~\LOCI:&~ • !\....x-1 u If\ -k E.-t-1•.1:>. I l -1-t:, PI I~ ~ AJf
AtVd bAd f~ dut:-£ ME A.JOi f..p,d(r-.X:f\AccekS' ~A~
Adm...~.PA~L Cc~~Ach?JJs;w~, ~1\\ol:a~
A'?,~?A=kJ .I\~ AW\Cm~';'J_c_ .fo 9,~~-lo /Lc..- _•
/Jooort.tJbft.. 'CJ~ o.f lt..c CcJufZ-1 ;rr Ce~ rAJA! ~f.f!
0Z~cc-f-fu I\~
~~
RECElVEDIN
C()lM\T OF CRIMINAl APPEALS
JUL 0120'5
Abel Acosta, Clerk
'' 1 /1_ . .b n
CtYl-VS. CouBZ AJ:JIIL£
:::(:0-ih.£ [.a)~Q\l L;R~N\~UI\1 ~f?EAig
, ~U&-\-~ ~ ~ -1aM
~\ k.b~·-- - - - - -
,il), '**~*'******'**'*'***1*1?2~~1~~.;.1 .......~~~~1-:A:..
04/..l0/12 1007 D1~LL.A:::J·PClLICf~ Dr..".PI'\r~H'lENl PAGE (11
H (I
• * ***.+Jt- ****** *"***;(·' ·11-******·ll- ***·!H+* li-,A *:""***·lf* -11-·lf- **lH+·W. JF...: THAT ON OR ABOUT !)7 APRIL 2012 ONE
•
CRAIN.RUGIN.IV, DTD THEN AND THERE lN THE CITY OF DALLAS,
DALLAS COUNTY. TEXAS COMMIT THE OFFENSECSJ OF:
•
BURG/Bl.DG
•
SJ ]0.02
Af:F I ANT'S BELIEF IS BASED UPON THE ffJLUJWI·t~G FACTB 1\t-!D I NF-01\MAT Hli'l:
• MCMILLIN • ROBERT KENN 7246 , A FELLOW PEACE OFFICER m- THF.: CITY OF
DALLAS, DALLAS COUNTY, TEXAS, WHO PERSONALLY PARTICIPATED IN THE •
•
INVESTIGATION OF THESE ALt_EGED OFFENSE, PROVIDING THIS INFORMATlON TO
AFFIANT. AND WHOSE INFORMATION AFFIANT GELIEVE5 TO BE CREDIBLE.
•
•
ON APRIL 07, 2012 AT ABOUT 1115 A.M. OFFICERISJ MCMILL.IN,ROBERT KENN # 7246
AND DE LA CRUZ, .JOSE n B862 f~ESPONDED TO A Ci\LL F'ROM THE f'OL tCE DISPATCHER •
REGARDING THE BURGLARYTO COMMIT THEFT OF COPPER AT 919 MORRELL AVE DALLAS,
•
DAI_LAS COUNTY, TD(AS •
I31JRC/BLDG
•
• CHARGE DESCRIPTION:
ON 4/07/12 AT AROUT 10~]0 Ai-1. THE RP, WHO IS A D[ACDN F'On THE CHUnCH, •
• CAME BY TO DO SOME WORK. THE RP SAW A BUCKET LYING IN THE ALLEY
BEHIND THE CHURCH. THE RP FURTHER ODSER\JE.:D vJATCR COMING F'RDf'l A CLOSED
DOOR. THE RP CALLED FOR POLICE.OFFICERS ARRIVED AND BECAN A SEARCH OF •
•
THE !3U I LD I NG. OFFICERS OBSERVED THE t1A X NTE:NE:NCE DOOR OPEN f\ND FUFHHER
OBSERVED THE AP' S FEET STICKING OUT FRrJM UNDER TH[ ODOR. THE f'P THEN
RAN BACK FURTHER INTO THE MAINTENAf•lCE: ROOt·1 fiND iHTEMPTED ·ro HIDI:::"Tl-lE
OFFICERS ORDERED THE SUSPECT DUT AT (~UNPOJNT AND f'l..1~CED HIM Ii'HO CUSTODY
•
• THE SUSPECT MADE THE RES GESTATE STATEMENT ur DIDNT BREAK IN 1 FOUND
IT OPEN. HE ALSO MADE THE STATEMENT" I WAS JUST GDJ.NG TO CO IN AND SEE •
• •
IF I COULD FIND SOMETHING LITTLE TO HECYCLE." THE OFFTCEF'{f:; OfiSERI/ED
SEVERAL CUT RECENTLY CUT GAS AND WATER COPPER PIPES INSIDE THE ROOM.
THE SUSPECT WAS PLACED IN LEW STERRET _}/\I l.. ADD CHAHGE BURGLARY or- A
•
BUILDING, STATE jAIL FELONY, C.JISS #~2990001 •
•
•
•
11111
lJfm ~''n llijii H/II/'IIl
~
m1r; 1111111 : 11
1
, .. " 1 I
) F-1254318
c.e,~
~
.,c~~
***~********************************************************************
•
04/10/12 1007 DAU~AS POl_ I Cf-: DE:.:PARTI1DlT
** * ** ** ·•** **** ** ·Jt- **** * * *********-'HHt1HHI•************* **·II-* II-*** -M· ·II-*** II-*·******
' \I '
008J297Z ARRESTi: 12-017426 ** **
• •
SERVICE#: ADD CHARGE
AFF1DA1V
0
Cl
::!:
rr~
.,,
, ..l
r:-?
r-·~
·~·0'
c:
--< C>
-<
against the peace and dignity of the State.
CRAIG WATKINS
Criminal District Anorncy of Dallas Counry, Tcxa..•\ Foreman of the Grand Jury.
COURT :_ /
Order entered January 7, 2014
In The
Ql:ourt of ~peals
.1'iftb mistrid of 1!ttxas at mauas
No. 05-14-01623-CV
IN RE RUBIN CRAIN IV, Relator
Original Proceeding from the Criminal District Court No. 7
Dallas County, Texas
Trial Court Cause No. Fl2-54318-Y
ORDER
Based on the Court's opinion of this date, we DISMISS the petition for writ of
mandamus. We ORDER relator to bear the costs of this original proceeding.
Is/ LANA MYERS
JUSTICE
c.c.12cnz:-
~~\o~+ ~:ti~~
.--
~
.JUDGMENT
CERTIFICATE OF THUMBPRINT
.
.r
=~. -~ --~
l~,;i
THE STATE OF TEXAS CAUSE NO. F \ J.Slf3 \e .y
VS. CRIMINAL DISTRICT COURT #7
(! r-t:t,·l"l '2. ,· 'R.o b ,~ ,._)
>
DALLAS COUNTY, TEXAS
~--
...: .-.-,--
0 >I
·-:····
RIGHT THUMB DEFENDANT'S ,fl- HAND
THIS IS TO CERTIFY THAT THE FINGERPRINTS ABOVE ARE THE ABOVE-
NAMED DEFENDANT'S FINGERPRINTS TAKEN AT THE TIME OF DISPOSITION
OF THE ABOVE STYLED AND NUMBERED CAUSE.
DONE IN couRT THis I ALLAS COUNTY, TEXAS
STIPULATION OF EVJDI<:NCE t" •••
TO THE HONORABLE JUDGE OF SAID COURT:
Now comes RUBIN CRAIN, Dcicndant in the above-entitled and numbered cause, in open Court, and
with the consent and advice of David Wright, the Defendant's attomey of record, enters in1o this
Stipulation of Evidem:e with the State of Texas as represented by her District Attomey Craig Watkins
through Assistant Criminal Dist1ict Attomey Angel Mata.
I.
It is hereby agrecd·and stipulated by all parties that if Deputy Washington were called as a
witness for the State, she would testify as follows:
That she is employed by the Dallas Sheriffs Department. She has completed the necessary
training and education and has experience in the field of latent fingerprints. Deputy Washington would
have compared prints litlcd !rom Defendant with lingcrjJrints attached to prior certified conviction
with Rubin Crain as the Defendant.
That the comparison techniques utilized regarding latent and rolled fingerprints arc readily
accepted and commonly practiced in the law enforcement community.
II.
It is hereby agreed and stipulated by all parties that ii"Dcputy Washington were ciillcJ as a
\
witness tor the State, she would testify:
The above named Dekndant, Rubin Crain, is one and the same individual who was charged
with. adjudicated and convicted of the tollowing ofti!nses:
{:It-)
In Tarrant County, Texas on or about January 28, 1998, the Defendant was convicted of'lbeft, Cause
No. 0662025. styled State of Texas v. Rubin IV Crain.
. If-
'-", l440:'1
In Tarrant County, Texas on or about January !D. tlii!S. the Dc1cndunt was convicted of Forgery by
Possession, Cause No. 06581130, styled State of Texas v. Rubin IV Crain. 0 yfl.
oOJ.fo.,t:::C
In Tarrant County. Texas on or about November I X. 2004. the Defendant was wnvictcd Theil, Cause
No. 00955811. styled State ofTcxas v. Rubin IV Crain.
In Tarrant County, Texas on or about October 14, 2005. the Dctcndant was convicted ofThclt, Caw;c
No. 0994038W, styk-d State ofTexas v. Rubin IV Crain.
ln Tarrant County, Texas on or about May 12.:2006, the Defendant was convictl--d .6 1-iARR Y T. LEMMON
LE'AH T. Tl-iERIO FACSIMILE: (504) 527-0801
tcowan@cvwanlemmon.com
Diret:t Dial: 504-593-4407
April 2, 2014
Rubin Crain, IV
#12023660
Dallas County Jail - 2
PO Box 660334
Dallas, TX 75266-0334
Re: Cause No. 3: 12-cv-04063-L-BF;'U.S. District Court for the
I ' • .
Nory:hern District.ofTexas,'Dallas I)ivision : .::: ·
R~bin Cr~in, IV v. Cesar A~gusto Men~hac.a; e:i% 1 · '•'
r•
1 . '• '~I • I> •
· ·
Dear Mr. Crain:
On March 24, 2014 we sent you a new medical authorization requested by Dallas County
HospitaL .District: d/b/a Parkland Health & Hospital System allowing us to speak to your
healthcan~ providers to obtain affidavits or depositions in order to proceed in this matter. To date
we have not received the executed authorization fr(>m you. It is imperative that we obtain this
authorization in order to move this matter forward.
.. .. '. ~- ' . ( .
For your convenience I am resending the authorization. Pl~~se sign where indicated and
place the original in the enclosed self-addressee( stamped enve.:ope to me as soon as possible.
Your cooperation will hasten bringing this matter to a conclusion, :•:
Very truly y;)iJ.fS,
-.~··:_ (!~.-
Thomas C. Cowan
TCC/maw: ~ :-. ._ ..
Enclosure
cc: ··'Winston Borum Esq:(via email).' · . ~ ~ '· .
·..:. . .· ,•
: :.: ~ \ .. ... ·.
.. ,··:.::.
\
'--'·
RivER PARISHEs OFFICE·: 150GR RIVER -Ro.',P.O. Box o3·o, Ht~i tNVILu::, Lot :i:iL\c.JA
1 700)7 ±UcENsrD IN I.o< ~~~'"N.\ A,,l) Tcx,,s
TEI~EPHONE: (985) 783.-9849 ._,FACSitviiLE: (935) :'X3-YS64
HOUSTON 0Fr:ICE: . 130 I MCKINNEY STREET, SUITE 2700, HOUSTON, 770 l 0 n::-:,,s
TELEPHONE: (713) 961-1222 FACSIMILE: (713) 91; 1-! 234
lf&i.o~t: v< ~CJ.) c_.c...'«ed
Borum & Hancock, L.L.P.
ATTORNEYS ~ND COUNSELORS AT LAW
2485 BURNETT PLAZA
801 CHERRY ST., UNIT# 14
FORT WORTH, TX 76102
PHONE 817.336.4100
METRO 972.263.7575
FAX 817.336.4141
Winston L. Borum
borum@borumhancock.com
August 23, 2013
U.S. Magistrate Judge Paul D. Stickney
Northern District of Texas
Dallas Division
1100 Commerce Street, Room 1611
Dallas, Texas 75242-1003
Re: Cause No.3: 12-cv-04063-L-BF, United States District Court for the Northern
District of Texas, Dallas Division
Rubin Crain, IV v. Cesar Augusto Menchaca, et al
Dear Judge Stickney:
In accordance with the Judges' Copy Requirements for Electronic Filing which states that
....,...../'---" - you are to receive paper copies of all filings, enclosed please find a copy of DEFENDANT
PARKLAND HOSPITAL'S RESPONSE IN OBJECTION TO PLAINTIFF'S THIRD MOTION
FOR DISCOVERY which was e-filed today.
With best regards, I am,
Yours very truly,
VJ~tSOl(MrL
6~ ·ms ·
Winston L. Borum
Enclosure
cc: Rubin Crain, IV (w/encl) via CM, RRR 70103090000338154475
Thomas Clifton Cowan (w/o encl.) via email
'"''' ,,;,"""31215-3096 *So\o ~~ ¥<
·-1f..z.. (pfl Ad tt.f.J../J~fr(W~
"iNet Brow.e< 4.5.10- R""'"'- looideot R'P"rt p;
,#/)c#fb?~),cident Detail Report ('!5,) u?.afp.-{,"cJrJ ~./ot\J& ... o"
.. Y- /1.
.~/jAJ
a,
·(jf G6 tf~ r
Data Source: Data Warehouse
Incident Status: Closed
Incident number: 2012064473
Incident Date: 4nt2012 11:36:14
· '7J ( 7
t)1:1
Last Updated: 4/2/2015 10:27:56
Incident Type: 1EN Alarm Level:
Priority: Emergency Problem: 12 - Natural Gas Leak
Determinant: Agency: Fire
Base Response#: 04072012-0089852 Jurisdiction: Dallas Fire
Confirmation#: Division: Dallas Fire
Taken By: FLIPPIN, WALTER M Battalion: Dallas Fire
Response Area: DAL Response Plan: *DFR-1EN
Disposition: Command Ch:
Cancel Reason: Primary TAC:
Incident Status: Closed Secondary TAC:
Certification: Delay Reason (if any):
Longitude: 96809771 Latitude: 32739140
Location Name: County: OALL.AS
Address: 919 Morrell Ave Location Type:
Apartment: Cross Street: HARL.ANOALE AVE/FERNWOOD AVE
Building: Map Reference: 55-E
City, State, Zip: Dallas TX 75203
Caller Name:
Method Received: Telephone Call Back Phone: 9
Caller Type: Caller Location:
Time Stamps Elapsed Times · · \ "
Description Date Time User Description Time
Phone Pickup 4/7/2012 11:36:12
1st Key Stroke 4/7/2012 11:36:14 Received to In Queue 00:00:28
In Waiting Queue 4/7/2012 11:36:42 Call Taking 00:00:42
Call Taking Complete 4/7/2012 11:36:56 FLIPPIN, WALTER M In Queue to 1st Assign 00:00:02
1st Unit Assigned 4/7/2012 11:36:44 Call Received to 1st Assign 00:00:32
1st Unit Enroute 4/7/2012 11:37:36 Assigned to 1st Enroute 00:00:52
1st Unit Arrived 4/7/2012 11:40:19 Enroute to 1st Arrived 00:02:43
Closed 4/7/2012 11:50:24 VisiNetMobilelnterface Incident Duration 00:14:12
Delay Odm. Odm.
Unit Assigned Disposition Enroute Staged Arrived At Patient Avail Complete Enroute Arrived Cancel Reason
E:N23 11 :36:44 11 :37:36 11 :40:19 11:50:24
No Personnel Assigned
No Pre-Scheduled Information
No Transports Information
No Transports Information
Date
4/7/2012
Time
11:36:42
No Address Changes
-
User
http://apcad 107 NisiN etBrowser/SearchllncidentReport.aspx?id= 12834208&ds=a[4/2/2015 10:28:44 AM]
~ 4.5.1 0- Reports- Incident Report
No Priority Changes
Date Time User Change to Alarm
4/7/2012 11:36:44 1
No Call Activity
Date Time Field Changed From Changed To Reason Table Workstation
4/7/2012 11:36:20 Address (Blank) 919 MORRELL New Entry Response_Master_lncident CADDFRF289
4/7/2012 11:36:21 Longitude 0 96809771 Entry Verified Response_Master_lncident CADDFRF289
4/7/2012 11:36:21 Latitude 0 32739140 Entry Verified Response_Master_lncident CADDFRF289
4/7/2012 11:36:21 Address 919 MORRELL 919 MORRELL AVE Entry Verified Response_Master_lncldent CADDFRF289
4/7/2012 11:36:28 MethodOfCa Telephone (Response VleweResponse_Master_lncident CADDFRF289
4/7/2012 11:36:42 Caller_Bul 152509 Polygon Lookup Response_Master_lncldent CADDFRF289
4/7/2012 11:36:42 Map_lnfo 55-E Response_Master_lncident CADDFRF289
4/7/2012 11:36:42 Pickup_Map 55·E Response_Transports CADDFRF289
No Custom Time Stamps
No Custom Data Fields
No Attachment
http://apcad 107NisiNetBrowser/Search/IncidentReport.aspx?id= 12834208&ds=a[4/2/2015 10:28:44 AM]
FELICIA PITRE
DALLAS COUNTY DISTRICT CLERK
Date: June 17, 2015
!1P: '\V-1254318 Y(C)
Ex Parte: RUBIN CRAIN
Dear Mr./MS CRAIN
The application for Writ in the above styled cause has been referred to the CRIMINAL
District Court No.7, Dallas County, Texas for processing. Please be advised that all future
Correspondence should indicate the above listed cause number.
,,,,,1111111/1/ifJt.•
Sincerely ~,,... lltt.
~ c,\ COULl "~
~ ~~ .......... :r'l ~
FELICIA PITRE ~ -5:2
::::: r-..
.::::-
:::
= .
•
~.. . · · 1
:·
\ kf.~·
<~
"(
··
·...
·
•
~
·.4.. _.....-::::.
. .....
~::::.
District Clerk = *:\ (/1 .
·~==
=r-=
Dallas County, Texas ;: -\- i~§
%1 ··.. V' .... c., §
~ <1'~··.. /r... ~
~ -_,;'1···········(\~.J~
L2
By.~·
.""'""""m"'"'
~ ""i 'Al~'\,,~
Deputy/COLEMAN
133 North Riverfront Blvd. LB 12- Dallas, Texas 75207- (214) 653-5973
FAX (214) 653-5986- e-mail: Sylvia.Medrano@DallasCounty.org
Web Site: www.dallascounty.org/department/districtclerk/districtclerk_index. html