Moore, Michael Vincent

CAust No.CBj3r_Oo337 IRI.GINAL In TBe Co^roP cawiMl 'APteAle oFTSxks AuS7lHj'72XAS MicHAEl ViM^TMooRE/ COURT««lappeals APP&iVaNT, may 20 2016 Abel Acosta, Clerk vs, FILED IN ^ _ _ COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS THE STATE. oP TEXAS APPEl\e,fe f*Y202u'° Abel Acosta, Clerk AfPaUA^7% PzVTiotJ Foil D/scRETleWARy Review/ TbTHrE 'kfc*/oAA8lE C©c*cr©;c Cjumia/w/ 'AWteAls; VzhTloris TJfe CouaF To Review 7t-rkTidW oFrm^CpufCT •(DEFEtfDfW Pf\c-S£ / AfP^U^T BRIEF) table of coNTe/m Cov&A ?k>b v- - - - --•----_- _____ _. _ _. __ _j 7&81E oF^TfeNB--- -- - --'- -'- _•_.-•_•_':.•_ --r-if.' IPemTvFicaTM. oFAvrTJes -_-__.-_.- - - - --)ij TWPtX of' AoTWoRHiee-- ----.-->------ -.-jy STfATE.A\Ehfr Regarding* oral argument- ---V "37ATa^EhroF-7B£.'CAS6.-- - - — - - - -"- - - v ISSUES PKe9EA/TeP- - - - - - -•• ---v SlKfttmlToP pRocBDumL HiSloR/- - - - -• - -'-•- - - - -./ STATEMENT of FAcB- - - - - - - -- - - — * " "" ~^3 SUKMNR/ of ARGUHENT .ISSUE. NUMBER '•'/- ~ " ~ ~ ~ " ~ ^ SuMMwy dF Aft^Me^T Xsguj^ number X-— - - - - - 5 SuMMAft/ OF ARGUMENT -XSSUE WuhBER 3 k CoutCToF.APPEALS ^OPiMof/' .(^TWcHED) CowclosicW Amp PRA/ER For &I.&F - - - - - - - - -.-7 "CEKJiFic/ffi: OF MoTfcE /-_>ERWc_L- ,._--- - 7 iMMftE .-.pEClAflATloh/ " •* - *- .--•- - .-. - - - -7 APPeIIamT I^mce 75 Co^ToFAPftAte Cf;^ ^TTActePTo OfW»o$ MoTTo/g To Sv$pzND ^3(t)TR,A,fi (Attached) n; /hppeismT fii) Cause Ho^m-00337fmth\ a/q,/*#-oo&7~cr Sec Tot THE ttorioKftBlE,3ijD&E($)DF CovaToF CfcMirift) hpfttisl Cj&vpT oF ftppzAls lw£.ffl D)£faicTof 7kx/fc ffFTy\&& OH Af^lAl-,tot /fosjj$su£i> AFf/AM*7«/£ /7a//>/a/& /a/ BAP* Tc? ftpfpjlmjfe Bto& mjo -rftitf: fw&l^ files IfflxJy'* • *ft-TTTiW FeR bi&JNfl/ertftfy feMW* v/,ph flit Tim C&lj/X#F T,P»£ kui& ick /sJ&rfe&D ami> ilMTXRmk^T BwedcS /s rtDMi<>$/\$[& „ folt>-1fM>g*M Apply* 7? Ife hit ioi Co/ace^MS /^^IDEM GoNWS 'bocmiMB. of A'FaIaI ]MMMc£?' f& htpttffoir tft&'g&ul AccuszD yXNDioeDfamuED Mb S&JfBAkJLD To UfE WiTtfvuTffrRoJE F&k THE WvPtiEfl cF%ia/K MeoML* ~1fc PzMoAj/BoDy fount b£AD J6 ftf/fTo? Biff* C&tf\Fictf£. A/#ME 15 vAkaA CHASTE PeRKiaj^ lUe& vfas/\s t4o &vioe*iaL mWSu ev&& /\fp^/^Tf^Mmrm> Murder_ Ttkiffc ye» Fo& Coa/6wtntfwAt ^ MyCfiost/ IDENrrFtcATioAi of TWE PaRTi_.E> ——_———___—_————_________•_•__————_————____—_____>_______——___________—__——_—__________________________ icBAE-l V^C&mT A1oc^E) <27 CoVER y s^2, 7/3-W, Ad bll) Cms) '$L> DEMBy y, srATev (*5^ $-wV ^^ ^^ (nes) 47^8 FIdhes MSWfej *5ls.w Vg Garcia u sots > V^ s,v/ad 3ls 7} 0^3) H7 3acv:soa/ y V^gjmiA? ^ qs, 3o7, &i j., eo/aj ^a, Vis.cxmi(}*n$ -To^aj' yswg^ U7 5..w, ad ¥M fwe)- £7 /Jamas V, SUTL; /S 5,£,.3J 7£% &aoo) '•53 LocKtMT y, A!-LS0a/} V#£ :U£,33}H>U,ED,3ldZty/OIS'LVA&S- #Ws) £7 MohiTGoME^y V. STATE, 83o S,u>Ud -?7<3 >37tf-7? #?fr) 5a MoTT/K y,5^7£; 78 SM3J 353,335; &*&) 53 MiW/z. Vi 5^,85/ S,W.;td 338, (mi*) 57 stahl y..smtL^iHi s.y/,3J 8M?7 Lm&) $ojE>¥ WiliiAMs v,s«!E)8v^5.vaad ^ &w) 53 Rules; 7£x, ftM^CoDfci n,o3 -^e TEX. ft*/. CoD£.i5«'Dl' W Ttt, Phi, Code! ^,oa! VV T£X< Rules. Evri>. H&V Si Tex^ulE^EyiD^o/ 53 TEXVR^Pft RufeBi 5 T^Cft.APft 658.3,^) 5 UP (iv) STATSMea/T Regarding op*I- AR6uimea/1 APPeIIa^Asse/Os PuAsaAA/TT^^^ CiTfe-^ To- WAIVE OAAL ARGumeai1 /a* -7H 15 > ^PzTftioij FoR DiscAETcWMy Ri_yiEW\ Frdm Tw^/F:m DisT^icT C^urToF A/^M/5 CAUSE No>/^iS-oal37-CR AS TS/Al Col/kTMO.CR13-00337 FRdm^"W^JuDictAi DisTricT Cd^i^TexAS, STaTemeisTT oF TBe £ase_ Otg.ql)ly 35^013 |M CAU5E ^CRi3-^337j MicHAEL UAlCEA/rMo_^ETHe AePEliAMTvv/ASXMDidE.D FoRTl-fe oFFeaice oF UpUX MuRDER^%e&D To Have OocuRED °^oR ABotJT MCM&&Z* 6>2olA, (JM^) ^ THE. Case wasted BeBre. A^oRy Am AfltellAMT PfaxfuorGuATy* 737#£- OFFZAJSB, ON TUB. CduRT5 QMbRGB. To X/^T&E ToRy ReTufW-.D A GuilTy VBM)\CTof Ufa SmleNca. To CAptf&l MuRfcE-R i^77VooTftRd£. feR^^or3aicl)APP£//ANT Fd_D AMtfTTcW FeR A/EWTRiAl AMD MoTokJ )N AR^e£I dF JuDGEMEMTT^R.ABO^ApPEil^T^ M^oa/5 WERE DEAMED PuRSUMI \0 TTRAP4I3 W/toi; TftE C^at did rioT-rme-ly AuiE- oaJ7?/e MdTWs WiTHjaA 7SD^yS:.\M:&AR. y ISSUES PRESENTED LXwsuFf-.c^EA/T EViDEA/cE, 7S SvppofiTSfito CzMiChoN fog Q\fifh\ MuROER . A.CAfiiaVborder CoiJvtajcA/was ^^> c^DrcumsW^/. eyiD&A/ca W/7*/\/o K6T?VE To MuRDER "AllctA MooRE. A5 EVMHcJL fteSBH&b Supports AN TNfeGJbtUL oTrt&K TMAM'7I4E GuiiT #F APPeHAa/FAS J^yi F^dia^ "fo A GuilTy VERDICT WAS Is/dTA PstiUOAlAJ FiNDiAi&S- 2>Ttit AbGfiEGATi.D EFFECT oF-ERftod£GU_- Ruli*JG5 ByTftE TRIAI CovATlN MWvM&lftE ToRyTo-ReAR OBI^WaB/e. AMD I^ADMi^iB)e Ev»D£A)d iRREpARABly Warmed AfiPellfrA/T Aa/d AfftelifodT SfteufD //Ai/£, '&£*/ order, Ute &Ran1ed MewTria) ByTR/a) CouaTAa/VoR G>ukT_>^ /4PPEAU. (y) QCE D\j RAL HisTofKy OMXuV 30^0(3 i*/ Gau5£- a/o/CR13^od337 MicMaiO. \JwulajT Al#oR&-> WejUhT was rMDiO^D For Cfipiiht Murder dF A/.iu*-'Ateete. A//-D&&D "^ /fth/E ttfiPP&JBD Oa/ OR /}JBouT..A/*vftMB'CR £y,*0|a,- OM MfiyfyZolS\ JTuD6£tA£HT W*& &N7&&£D fe APPBIIanT UJA5 FoiWD Guirpy oF CApriAL HurdeR Aa/z) SbmTzaJcbD 7Z L&£- u/t^odT PaRoIe jaJ 7i>A5 Osp^RiM^aT^^ CAmiNfr] TusKcE- ft/sW Dh/isioaI. Ohl S^pT-MBEA 305^01^ AFPeIImT's BfKihFTo CoupTof AFFBALS Was Presented fly .-App£tl#J£ (Loumseu TZm A^cdJT AaJP Also A IftuE G^RREeT Copy WAS EMAil ~7£ APPB,/I^5 /fTftRNzy oF RBO>^ AT fcw -^dfe 7M _t*s-»&D AfrkfiMffiwe. Fimdims iaJ £*R r^ APPE.il/wT5 &Ri£F A*/_> aW APP&JImT frks Tun^y *penfioJ Fo« Di5cRETXeWiWy fUviEV* WiW ^ ^5 CaofiTcF CAmiNM fiPPebls (!) ^f^T^i^iW^r' of FpicTs TtAb\zJ\ $ytf>Jk$uFi£.D To 8e./fjG-me. /KuxTfoFTliB V;cX/m A\\l\A Moofte im 7/hs CAS& eyft»r(l^.te 3o),iA/o>J |\loV,aoa ^5i£A^ k-Aiw-OTjAR^ 6R£AT A^£li^TiS fejc^S u«ci6.(/^^R^)' A''ti'A: WrtS It ATTUlsTm {MPy3B). JzssittK UsT MwihiL iwib a weW Hc;ke 4a/Gf^A/yiile ^ wfacHTft£ySe€^'WffrA//6Mfc(&M3y% GjJ fJovSl^oia HessifA ./KflW£0 -M>M£ From h/cRK at Ztofrl AMD'AliUA W/A5 a/oT//0m A^d d,^>^f^^ &oi46T/MvzAW\ fttea/fi -BoT PiD HA^£;^lJPApV»7V #*R/(kRftyy), D&*5RA AMD ARE^A w*^ GRfi-AMjfe &lic DspT, Tbftlfc A.Kiss/rffc .feftWi* ftfepoJ0r^R«5b). As.ohl. Wotfi^oia F*M*y M*M* £)va/£«£ aTT^- fto*\e BAVute PRAy&R dRc\t.OA/77f£. PoRctt,(il*fUK6f), AppB\\tmr7e.%F 6AyiKifc ite vJ&soNlte WAy Af//tooAt\^RR ^). Ok) W£E>MeSD*y H0RWIM6, Nc\jt(e.p\& "^E ^j/y llAftig) Aht-iAi 0oD/ Hw 8&M .FoOMD,;(ibRRVD^jTiS AKwou/M fAcT'Ttt/frFovKf^a^^ EAAIi&R; Ah-*A\ WAS Having 5ex W/7% A50/ear o\d manJ NmjLTts&y .RahsHire./^^^'^ ^^ LttAR6£p: A^D LoMicfBt) of3~CouMi$ of SeXOpX ASSAuToF /Wo/} i&£M/& /96E /&• (WRR#a-83), .pjay.Mite WoFfaoWASlk^MDfy tl^PA87-88),\Vof3=oftD.>5 /W ftkoiloiic. Wifo mm5 A/'#Ay AM) Do^ /i^TV^k: ##//; 3t6$m Um WfFcHED AViMQ oP /4k/A fo777V6 oF* 7#£ _te /fF33dfiA THATDay of im DisAppi^^HCE^MB^.^ssiiA HmToiPPvha. %Xjz#/\&*S TSBjas Wfi&SJcfJe. AS ASuzpEcT/lhit) tfeR &yfR\tW,(foWi-w)> APP^H^1 14AD IwED IN (MiFoMiA BvT MoVEd To Gf^^D fk/Kifiu!-}lhv& ToTaKsL CARE of H15 s Father ?^\ MdoRE^RR ^k), APfelltoiFis Gfy as Fmily Xte^***1* •.3e5Sioq A/ev£R S^y ANyWN& vuvsufi1-8e7v^/ AFp&llA^r A*M) A/iaA- JCRkV), DM RECAil Ey7te STA^Stfa-S &Y*i&>rtJoJZ WMXmc®uc£J) Tfi&oV&H T^SSiCfi - /£ A LETTtR' 8/ ftPPEi//^T"il4fir He S/md TftE DMA EVtD&AiC-: cf thb\ ToAUupi- w/b plfr/jfeDtfotM^)- (Qs ComTniuat^oa/; STa\b.mea/TaF FAcTs TBE K^E FmJy Oio A/STRf\vE. R£Ip07v£s ja/ U/iHs fouST AREA WHbREA/iciA' BoDy jA/A5ipRAG_.7RUMK WAS PjftOLD 8eSiOE.'T^ RefrD AND FoOND- 0'8RR-Ac?-3tvXiA/.H-»cv|._^_^5tcA /^?z> AfZveK S££*f 3nFo&& - ARETi4^ MooRE^ AIi.ci/6, A*oW* lB67T^iDE OAjS^liMAoF 7/^STm^ (/£** #5)-- ARETHA* K/V/W5 AliciA GoTofPThz. Bu5 AT330M JttfrTDfry f\$£tadoaJGcWotA %vs Recorded ViD&o,([kRR /ts"), AretHa TEsTTF^d 1%/TAfPBiIfrjr^A 6**?° ReIaT/o/^-5//^ IA//77/ A/foA 4^WWl)' ON f\lo\7Ay1olX 77iE AJifzifT Ahafit D;sAfip£AAED •> MVKE WoFfoAp W^S /^^~ ffeKSoA/ Arue^e "^5£E Al^iA A/^^^^^^^/^^^^kaj^/-/^ TTi3 AUi^EO 0y SmTe^ P^o5ECvBR) APPdiAKirr^oERED AhaA oNAlo\j>b^o& BuTAS BNipm^t SlfoWsJtitoiJS&TEAT^^ -oF'AlwA- v^as ;w .RrsTSTa^E oF-CoM^fiouToF R>6oR M^lfe' ^^ (l7RR 3^3v)/ Sw/iFS LA8 i/M DaIIks^rR v^V^)As Ranger ApcocK oBb&M&d Trauma % fiTH AMU6 ANDJM V/3G/A/A oFAtoA,(!7XM3),TH£ MEO\cAl FXAM|/vi£^ ADV/5E0 Dea7 WA$,Rufe^ Two aa/3 AMF MonTUs LaT^R DP3 U6• M/fl£tt DMA-7oAppE//AA/TA5 QuesTTb/yi ISSUt.,(nfKfZ SieSfyTb DRiVE. To bREEAMH-- FAoH &KAND P«AiKl-_ TaKeB APARoX- \nbf£\y Art \fav(\AMD FiFTefM .MiMuT£s,.0"7ft8'3O' NodtftfA Ci'feD EViDfirtci DF 1+oME oR VEWicle. of APpE-WFtHT LiMKEP WiM7^.AklA'/^7^H1-^j). APDi1IbA/A/,-SuspE6is W£*£ AHe-Ge]) To-(«7RRi(^3)TT^y W&RE LiNk^DTo A WH»7e LiMcoW CQtiTeJJ&jfaL WHERE JiMKjld V&Hiclfi. WftS $£J~hJ artltt& DAy 7BE TRi/rtk Ulft5 Foua/D- D8£t/ZV£l[), (n^-lLS'/UX- ASecond 5pB.c\fAEKJ T-^TiKik oF DNA oNAlfppie.s And Aa/aI oF AlsciA SHowed ASecoa/D SuspficTJ CooID DoAA/y Co/MpAR/5/7y6?(/BRiH°l), STEf^EMSDAi 5EEA/ AlicA EX»T'ScHool BuS-, &&Tmlb Hl^PAMiC PfcRSoMs ,V/EHic[E?.(f8RR \^-\2>io)f (3 ISSUE Mo^BeR /: AS EV\0£a/cE Wfi5 TNSoFFiLiB.AlT To ^uppot Sfi\o AMIamB C^MVicTT^/v/y /4'iSs£ Pa^^7oF (iuATaFApP^/5 Appb/IanT BRxeF SXph^ATToM oFAa/£> IeGA/' ^FFiuBA/oy fab£-X7 CTimG 'lb 9V3 U,5307^1%-ftOvfa IockNarT v, neLsoM V^B us,33,HH^lc&L.EJM 3fcfiT, k* S>CT^B5"f/^g) And MuMiz. vSSJaiE, g5/SM aJj33^Ur^MKAFf IHHS) Ch_:S A$7c? ERR g^Tfe &t;RToFAPPMis ft&asioN XNCotiSi$TmTT\\/tf' ^w) . AR&uMeaFT ^M REQoip.&D ftl6V_V ORDER TftESfATE NZ£D£J> To P&eVZ Bn.yo/S/9 A Q&A5oNikB\^ ^oo^rTiW'ArpEi\h^XNT£AlVorMJy Ai4t> KWo\A/tMQ>ly Cavs£d7U& DzATti of AUaA Hoom By£Tf^}iG'olf^oN w%i£ JAi ATV-wpTTo AGGRAVATED S^XuM ASSKuiTfe AGA/-HakKc.R,1)5^e7^x. P-aW&>d£I 1^,03. T4E lACKoFfi\/tD£AjG£ 7S SuppoZX^oRy*!,VERbiCTAm MoTbtJZ S'wSJE PtfoWE CM CWS£ WAil&biHG APPEliAATT yAs SuspEcTT (rr//»tfi), TtfE SiftT-^ MkGATa/ AFPe]l^T^PicKED up AhctA V/ii£N5H&&o7cFf-fe& Zcticcl Bus oM A/oV,a>^oi3vfR_.iD W€R MCjusToOy TU&N RaPed/muap&red i-^A oN/\/oi/^y2o\X Ftt&l VdrftoiXA VfeHtdE ov^JooMiizS AWAy^Durtp HER #o£y BesidE-T&E fW> VU Wills fei*fi"*AS A/o PMt>A/E R&C_?R£)5 K/£R£ F^OAiD AMO lAJCON/SiSTeAlT 7f> $M=a/a£ £?&pmN6ob)5 \\JitN£S5 SThtiD TBSU/yjoNy of Fossil M/spAMiC M/.A ^Doof^ffl^ BRiEF 7£ ^iMT oF APP&A/s, Se£ /8A1EF5- Pages 16-V_> heTAthNc* xssub.s Dp fj0 BvroB^ca, fJoR §tioui'p lie llAi/B. B&&AJC'iTlD AS SuspBjTpJoR CoNi/iokO of AfuRPER 96 life 7A\a\ 3bfly AhlD CouftToF APP&Afe FRRED M 7/teR F^mA/GS, (H) •..A-RGUMeaTT SuMMAR/ 15SWE- WuihBERA' APP&(MTttSDND.h6ffv£jhloE HAy£ As See Afee-V7 ^F Cx>v$rofAPPeaIs APP^J/m/T8pjEP ExpMmjX/W oF /MD Argum-uvTTamd MfSis c$i*i£ GmaAyf^i^^^^u^7(^xmA,m\<)r PPcVBl JteycMD Aft_A5o/i/^_?/e dovBTMARMc^iAlF^^iNe^ pB/jBy V*SfffiE*&gys. UHS7)M(px-(*M£Ll7m'£(/JPm UfieMiy FsFf^\\s\kes TUE Accused's QuitT$EymJ>A RiASaNM/B jDcuBT. WjPHilLipsy CS5 Rftmo R£p0/^XAimRv/_wED AppeV^iN^i\rXrt*JHvM-'Ae> D^ck)S_D A^ooRE/qp^ilMiT. A/_*£R \bFT the ftoMB- oN/\loV^,^oi^ %bjCAU5^ IAs TAvok ifob 8Ro&£ Powd rffaTFmwy* ($>&,Uoj£) Pme -33 of BR\&Tr Aw6#fc> Mo$$7U?}fj6£> lb A//ppM mAANfii$WfiB5 wm^i CoHlfuMb> fyfiJfAi .Dili P$oFil&s F86K78& S&pa$bb wj&&A&£fe^^WVicj7Art/h/0A S0£orto CtfAirRiBu76RrcH^ so-m^o* A^rABi^ihDo &nPAMSOh/S.&BKRy/o/y.C>T&D dm P*6E,s &jMoFBr\& IZAViNG Suzpiaot Of 5ome. OTHetk Susfe-CrAMO UoT APP-Uaa/T ModRE, AsTM. M^^ERER BzyoHb ReASoAMHJE. DouSH TaI jtfcTJ "72/E C^uRTGVER DBj&cToa/S By D£F£rtMNTA/hi*S£D6'7l TNAcfiviTy of mi pfoME. Pfcfooas? (/7RR83), (5) gumenT SUMMARy JSSUE ttmSm 3: &IRomEoO$ RuI?/s)6S By T^B Jk\A\ GjutiTirJ Allows Tl^^^Tb^EA^omEXumiiL AMD JNAOMiSSAm F^D£N££ J£R£pARA$i j-^R/n^J) AppEtiAAiTAMD HE BlJaulD Be Gr^Md AVewIRjA/ As TOE CwtfT Of APP^AlS ERRED im *TJ ftuhalG AMD OptNioh)fSeE P^B-5o}of BRiIF To CbvfT cf AppEA/5 AS CMd/cj77a/& A^F\tuT AND Aa/^s . AT pAfi^ARGUMEA/rAMP AAiAiysvs CiTlAjG7?/£ uNQuesToN^B, AFFB-cToF feRRoR 7b ApPEiiA^O SuBST^aJTIaI Ri&/^G^iv/G 7c STftrtL V, SflTfe>7^.s>u/ a4-83fe(liBf)AMD To OBjEcVojJ ToSPRii EXHtB.iT hlo&T{!8Mt&~W Cotrfuoe. ..ftet-5-l AS IA/ ERR llBARSAy ZA/ADMttS't8/fL TtSnMoNy iNTfre. OocuH^jT over oBJEtToN Ahio M\mm 7te Raa/geR TolesTify To7T-/E-Records/ Q*to,878g).fc/^^ . tomiNaBoM fte£~5&\ MoMTfeoMERy V* Sftlfc) &*D3,vt3d 379,376-71(m A^DT^S Auk WhsXfrco^ MoTTl/ft y^TATe^BS,u/3d 35^,355-^^^TR.E^oj^ HR/E^Q3 CcwTa/uE f/teESV ASTtte&W of A'ppe llAiiT Brief T? ti+e C^l/at #F AppeaIs As at£/7*r7TOE M?RD5 vA/»66E/R WH6RE* Wft5 SpM/- pA^Tfe-iMSine toe wicker Tftu^WHwniE v*cw w»s Fbcwa Also Moie.: upohi .REC£lWh/G. MyCofy oFTitE CWr T&WScRifTs oF MyTa/ftj 7RAT Wa5 S-»8k\iTT£d"TS7^£ Gou^oF AFPEAls A/ tylE-Rjl^XAS^X HAVE Dte_£>v_4£D-flfc. >VioR DioR* /5 yo7^_TA/_/6P_.p/ENcic6E0 AA*D )£ hcfuaiiy Missis FAcM EisfftRE IftAA/Sc&fpT^v/^EFoRE 7B& T^AA/SC&pB yx/eAz/AfrE ThlCoHplBj^, (.(*)