CI1SE No. 05-15-00bbS-Cif.
IN THE COURT OF APPEALS
FIFTH DISTRICT OF TE.XAS AT OALLI\S
RECEIVED
Court of Appeals
t=>AR'I EU(g~N£. !5I.m~ APPe/IC111f JUN 2 2 2015
v. Lisa Matz
C erk, 5th District
. TilE ST~TE OF TEXA.S ,flfPeJJee.
ON Af'PEAL ~ADJYl TH£ dBd. nd r:JUDICLAL
O.ISTRICT COURT,OALLAS COLJNTY,TEXAS
TRIAL CDUY TJ-JJ4T THIS LllNbU}'}~E
/::>E. 9FF OF tnY DOCUmENTS FROm Tf/Zs
cou~-r'\ANt:J ou-r oF m£
COntPLJTE..R, J4JV!J
L ffm HESUE.ST VER .I J=ICATIONTH14 r
71-IIS IS OFF OF mY [JtJC,U111ENT:S ~
Thrank Vou ";Ju:s-h"e:e. EVan -.s,
1-of-~
CERTIF..ICATP OP ..SE.r?VX~£
1.. k-er-~ lov cerh'f ·Hrot-1 -a true a~ ce;mp)9~
COPY oP t-he fore B0/h9 n1bf-lon flo/
A#idavff- was V i-CJ re~ulrC¥r /Y/CI/1 served
uPot1 the O(str,fc,-f cre,;rk of' The P/P.fh £;(0~1-
o/ 14 PPec:J I s a f 60b'. co;n/11e,;rue >-h ,OoJ/Q...>
~ '- 7520~-
r3 Y ~J41RY EUBEA/E 5;J:J11.!!5) IIPPe//G'I ?f ;/7
fh f5 c;as,e_. • ~ }O'JC196t3,h.-LS-C}.tJLS
UNSWORN 0E.CLARJ:1TI.ON
I uVle'Jen +he P6Y1e::1/t-Y oP Perjury DeC/Cire:s
-I+Yct-t- all F='a"'C-f-5 PreSenf-ed ln OOCLIIY!~
ore frue a~ c.orr'€/CI- ~
S/9J1~ fh /5 dotv by tDt-rliV 5U~ENF-3Ihf_!S
0 Yl +hi~ +he .' /5 ,day of g'uMe a.o 15 ..
~
<:2ftR't EU&E.IVE .§J7YJ~
I.,o~ t:J.,JDd. '!f'9i8
Ct::Jnna//y vnil
J.<.~i1eciY ~ 78//~
Exhtbi+ of case His-tor'/
WRIT NO. W00-45450-S(A)
EX PARTE § IN THE 282nd illDICIAL
§ . DISTRICT COURT
GARY EUGENE SIMS § DALLASCOUNTY,TEXAS
STATE'S RESPONSE TO APPLICATION
FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS
The State, having considered the allegations contained in Applicant's Application for
Writ of Habeas Corpus in the above numbered and entitl~d cause, makes the following
response:
I.
HISTORY OF THE CASE
A jury convicted Applicant of the offense of aggravated sexual assault and assessed
punishment at confmement for life in the Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Institutional
Division. The Court of Appeals affirmed his conviction in an unpublished opinion. (See
Sims v. State, Nos. 08-01-00121-CR, attached hereto and incorporated herein as Exhibit 1).
This is his first Application for Writ of Habeas Corpus.
To · fYJ~ <9YJ Y-Z-03
1
.- "" .... .
• 't~
CASE NO, 05-15-DObb5-CR
IN TI-lE COURT OF APPEALS
FIFTH OISTAICT OF ICXAS AT tJIILLAS
(;,ARY EUISENE SI!YJS, AJOPe/Jan-r
v.
'THE STATE OF TEXAS, APPellee
CJJJ APPEAL FRom TfJE ;l~~nd 7f"UDICIAL DISTRICT
GALLAS COUNT'/) leXAS\TfiiJ4L COURT NO.FD0-45'iSD-.S
PURSUANT TO TC:Xf\.5 RULE OF APPELLATE PROCEDURE
RULE, 6'7, moTION FO~ REHEf41UNt3 E./'1 P:ANC ·
APPELLANT REGUE ST AN EN J3ANC 'REI-IEARINB
EXHIBIT ATTACH
fi).CoPY at- orderitla+ the cour+ dtdnot-en+ered.
(;;n. Re tOue-s·t- .Por se·+·h n'9,
0
{3.), ObJec.+loY11 Ur1der TeJvo-s f?uJe. of lf.pp, Proc., LJI.{.'-l~
('-4 1.. coPY of motion Por EvTden Harv fle<::J tin~
aYLCJ orscover't ~
{S) . Tl1i:s couri-Jrave. n1Y Case /1/.s;fory Wron 9
Se.-e E~J1ibi+ of c.ase J-1/:sforv.
(b).__ Afftdovit conrwer-n(n9 cose-IIJ'.sft:X't ~
·"'
-.:e.:.
TD THE 'HoNORABLE 'Jl.JObE OF SAID CIJUI\T:
Now comes EXPARTE . . ~ARY E.Ut5ENE~Im~,
APPellcrVJt ·IYJ me
above stYled and numberecl
case.. makefn'9 +his said mo-hD~n flo·r £n 13anc
Re.ClJYlSfdera+fon o-PRi~hs ·to J4PPeol saidorcler.
Thts Hon&J(IabJe. court, Sbie}s we.. .f'trs+ nlJ-Ie- -fhar
.o l-1-hou9l1 oPPe.JioY1+- s.J-ot-e.s the 1ric;,/ courf- dented
~is mofton on J4Prt/, ahaD/Sl We have no rec..ard
oP a wrtff-en ord-er hovfng Joee.n en-tered.
$ee.
EXHIBIT OF OROER flTTACH To 111EJTrO;Vn
Cllbe.. Trl'ol courl- ts Plavtn~ DirtY fbet\ Th~f- /s
se ~rre3udl'ce_ the subs+anfit:AI !fJ9ht-_ tof +he
APPellant loY "V lolafed o clufy I.n1Pe:sed b'Y law
I
/ BY no+
• .' \
i;,-V ·.rY·
so
En+ertn-<.:J 1i1e DRTJER on Record •
1
~. -: .~~\-/;:
'.,:'' ;:TURISDI.C.IDN OVER PBST-CDNVICT." LDN
WRITS OF HABEAS eDRPUS
~e.
.. e.., Ex Parte, Viii anueva, a.5a, sw..3d"3GJtux,cr/tY1.AfPJooB)
Bock.9rovncl: APPI icont soush+- wrlt- oP hohea..s
,,~or Pus .. The "' 398--H-1 ors+rtc+ ceurf,H/da/Af!lo counfY~"
Aido soJlflas Flores ,~tJ summ/f:lrtlv denied !fie s~ld
CIPPircoHoY1 -, as Joelrr9 Prfvolou.s, APPitcan-tDPPealed~
-me-co~PU:S chrts+l'-Edimburg courf oP J4pp-eo/:s,o,{)ob
wL a3'2a 'tb 1 -\ dlsmlssed the OPP-ea/,based on
lack o-P Suri.sdl'ct-ion ~ Dfscretiol1arY revte w was
G f'.oYJ+ed •
Hotdnll5~ The cour-t-lJ.P crtmtMai!JPPea/s,/'(eosler"
~ Yield tha-t- an order of a d/.st-rlc.f cour-1-
summari/Y denvlnd) as ft-tvolou.s, an aPPilocriTon
-Por wrlt oP Habeas carPus seeKtn<:t relt~.P
..Prom an .
set:tforhB, t-o the- Te.xta5 cor1sffturiDYI conler.s
dfstrict cour-f..s wlrh(( e.x~lustve., aPPel/ale
ai1d ortstrt~ L Jurisdic-Jfon oP all ac-t-lons,
Prot:- e.,ecl i'n tr?.J s , an.rd t-erYJ.ecl/fJ./5 • AI so s. e e
EX Parte Hor~e++ el'9, swad 0bb (T-+ZX~Crfm,14PP~I<=t91)
APPeal cOH he had -Prom dtst-rlc+ courf order
d-envtn9 aPPitCaHt- -Por Ha/Jea:s corPus re/le..P
or1 merits oP J.-.ts cla/m, V-ernon's 14nrk 7it>urfof' IIP~/.s
at- boo . . commerce. s+-, OC/Jias -r-exos,75;J,OJ..
B'J ~1'1KY EUfbENE 3I/11~, APPe/Jan-J- /n th/:S
tC "GG s -e . 01?~ 1=1
·~ · ~6S) "iiune-1 15iJ.00'-5
UNSWORN OE.CLAR,A TIO./V f'LI~Sil14NT
TO u, s i -c, 17'i ~:::,
APPelletn-1- und&r fhe {?e,J1CJitY oP PerjurY
oe.c/Cir-e..-s +-hctt- otl Facf.s Fr-es-enl-ed 1n
ooc.ume-nf are -/rue orJe:l correct- •
.Si~ned fhf's day by ~J4RY Eli~£11/ESI/11~
bn fh,:s fhe 15 d'CAY of! "Zfune ~o 15 ..
~~"i ELl ft>EN E ·~J..n1 ~
-ro.~~ :r~n}4JIJ~t:fq6!iJ
Conn ·e ;IIY LIJ11-r
KeY\ eel'! TeX. 7~1 I 9
Cause Number: W00-45450-S(D)
EX PARTE § IN THE 282ND JUDICIAL
GARY EUGENE SIMS, § DISTRICT COURT
Applicant
§ DALLAS COUNTY, TEXAS
ORDER
Applicant, Gary Eugene Sims, has filed a prose objection to the trial court's
ruling recommending denial of Applicant's application for writ of habeas corpus
without holding an evidentiary hearing. Applicant contends he is entitled to an
evidentiary hea-ing and discovery.
The Court finds that Applicant's writ application was dismissed by the Court of
Criminal Appeals January 18, 2014 and is no longer pending
IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that Applicant'srequest for an evidentiary
hearing and discovery is DENIED.
The Clerk of this Court is directed to forward a copy of this order to the
Applicant, Gary Eugene Sims, TDCJ # 1029968, Connally Unit, 899 FM 632, Kenedy,
TX 78119.
SIGNED this ~ ( day ofApril, 2015.
F-eJ 0 '-1 5 t..J 5o - P_s .
To ·~ Etd a OJ iva s , a.s ;;J ncl., o,:s J-ri c +- cour-+ c oorf1J:b.Sar
RE: Caus No F-oo 1...15'-JSD-PS: moTI.DN Fa81flfRJ:tl£-N'VIJW?Y
• r-1 [ 11 RINL3' OI s CML~I~P'WRt
(l;ARvf.UbENE ~Im!3 vs. -n-JE sri4T£ oF .;-r. 4...--.- -
.
R
· ...- ·-
rc~i\ls.
PUTV
.
REQUEST FOHSETTINLO .
Oe-or tt:ou r+ COOY'dtV1a10r'"'
-:I Ve flrle.d Cl mOh 0Y1 fDf' CH1 EY/denharV
0
1-/ear(Y'J:J /n
COLJ"Se. -t:1-- F-OO'i5"151!J·,. F.S •
Pl -e os·e. rc·on+-oc-t 'JLJde "J4r(dv cha+hmVVJ rCtnd -so
scV\e..duJe 1-hts mo+lon tot 1-/e.or/ns as SO(!JJ-1 as
Possth/e, I h1 froce ·e .cl/t1+ b-e.t;re. rh .~ c.~ u Yt- .co _J; ct::An have
rVI -e... oppor+-u Vlir'l ·f-c• .PuiiY d-eveloPe. onrd r.Bsolve
i-\-1 e.. mo -1-1- e r_, r-c{·/'.s, ·ed hy fh1s !'no-han ...
PJ€-a s~e .con11er wt+h · 0""udBe \ ChorOO}/V/, A Vz.cly ond
m~~-e.. the. ne-ce..s:scrrY orranEtel11ent-s •
Thrttnl-<. YfOU Por Your a++tonh·on to 1-l1is Mot-ter~
w i't-h t-¥te Ur-mo st Res pee,+.
e,f-l.RY £UC5ENESLm.S #IOJQ:J.~9'6B
ZJ.. r3.. COVH10 /IV 1./n/t) 8 '1Cf 1 F._ f11,
b 3d. , K e n €/Cl 'I "72x, 7 8// 9
;ilo .. P--·00 "15 45 0 -P.S
. {
, dARY EU~ENE SI m 5 ··IN THli dB~~d~lTUOICih.f;'lPLT;£TJUC1 .
•
v s, 2015APR~ , .. :' PH ..,;03 II
TI~E STAlE DF TEXA.$ • COURT OF D'ALLAS..CtJUNifl.(c 1 -lfrr~
DIST~ClERK . ·
. " 0EP£NDANT>.5 OBV'E:CT.I.V# UNOE.R DALL . o. EXAS .
· · . - - DEPUTY
TEXAS RULE OF APPELLATE PROCEOURE\'+'h'1 .
OF TRIAL COUR~ DE.I'IY-TJY~ APPJ.J..CAT:LON.S FOR
WIUT.S OF HAB.EitS CDRPU.S WLI'J-IDL.IT HOL-DIN~
EVI.DF/\II.I. ,t:1 R-Y H EI4~I.Nr1> ON CDN/.fENE. .SI!n..S • I.N 1HE~e;A~1d.- J'uD:I.CIALD.I.STR.ICT
•
v .9. •
•
THE STATE OF TEXAS •
•
COURT OFtiALLAS"COUJJTY, TE.XIrS
OB~ECTI.ON TO ADVERSE. ~ULDI~ UIJDER TEX.R.APP. P.
L.f "', Lf, OF -~ TflTI4L COUI{ T:S DE~ YI.IV~ WR Z T CJF HI413EA S
CORPUS WITHOUT HOLDING EVI.OENTI.ARY HEARIN~
To The. HONORABrLE. ':JliDtlE- OF SAID CDURT; ~.
t:.o~e.s 110w EX Porte. l3ARY E.UGE.NE .S~m.S\ dePendonr in
the above stYled and numbered cou.se. make.iY19 #1/.s
Sei,.d OhJe.chon,see..Ki'n9 E.vtaen+lorY Hearln!!l, W!~I.ShOUJ
unto the court' fhe- FollotP/n 9:
"On sePiembef',~ a·e uiilh I.n ihe... Hohe.,~:s ac:.t(oJI'I, The fr"la I
c.ourt so OROEJ~ D·ES~~NATINf!:, I.SSUES'' oP- AP.PlrmCit/Ve
Evtde..nc.e oF oe..ICYJd~nf· asser+ed a clc11m ~ he.. /.s
Ac+uall'l inVJOUY1t,Uncle.r SchluP, II s,.s.ct SSI \ CICf< .. , Of~c.ve rv oP E.rcul P~-tor-Y Pic+ure •
;:;.- o.fl- 8
H·1 t:.. trial courJ- "(/01. Cf.tf~~~)..)jr t' •. Jt~Q1~tLL'=.L~~k~5·)
l::....r~e.) D PPoi'n -r~~ AP.c{l F.?,r,»wrm ·J-o re so 1ve.. P·c.rc.t:..s. i..ssu e.s.
c. o urt
f"h e.. (c.tcf"Prndtn -: ; Proceclure. ~~r1PIOY-e.d J~v the. .Stclh::.. COI..Jr f' wa;s.
not· Ode 'CJUOf"e.. to ~.AI'Po I'd "Ci P.uJI c.n-t;J fcn ·r 11·e ur/rt·tJJ. f.frvcl ~Is .o
in de.Prl'v-r::.1tlon of de..·tt:.VJdetnt cort:s·h ·h..-4 Honed fll'!ifht flailed t-o
c.. PF"ofn ·,.. c..oan~el to rePr-e .se.nf JT/n1 ln ·f he. courr smre.
Fro c: e. e din ~ • ~~b.d.s::.fCe.s; e J~.S .r,\~-~Y.i C!rS _..,.(.:4 ...h~;Q.C.Ltl~ . n-1 ~ d en 10 1
oP o Pull ovwd lo.l'l' he. ·e trlnf:> den/eo cJePe.r1cle~r1t- () ·P hls._J)y_~
..er.r:~ C!fl: -~-:? ..Bt:tk! t ~ . lJI(Ikifj;C ..ti:J:fk:....Ett.~~o~~
. ,......._. ,.._ .
...Arnertdme.l1t..S ..· .. 10 o Puu oncJ f',tU/r he.crrir1S ln Ct c.ottrf oll~u/
. .
o Y} H.,.~ ; s.s (.,/e. ()f.. oc hi"'' 11 Y 1J1 111 o c. e 11 r U:.J.J.C ;z IJ a n t tQ . T:fi!Zi ~
.C:.Q.s;ir;., c...r.Lm·.Pror;, Ant' !.{;ll.~lL.' c..Dnre..m PJ-~1+-e.. .s cu1 e.vldtJ:nn·1"A r- v
he. CJ rt'n x, wi·H1 Uv e,. t-e.s.liYI1 on Y ·H1a 1- i..s mo :s .f rd< e I'"' ..suh ~1e t: t to
·li"lf. tu tfi:..s o~ re.vlclence.l~T:IJ$., .CQd~ 'efta t f'cta" · 1!1tV1Lttr·a It, 'tB
_{&.o_o.J,), .st-et te.s '111-o t ProoP. Sholl be. heord tlACC Or·c:l/n .5!11 Y \ boN1
Por and t:.JSOfo~01'1S+ the.. c.JPPllcon..r for l'e.Jle.f, Te:x. code... CnirL
Pr·o-c.• #nYJ, t-7rfr. JJ,44 .. td/r"'eA:...f's o. courl- k? Prcce. e..cl occ.ordln!'J
L "" i/1 •• I
rO '1-J.-1e. rCt·C f..S CiYicJ Cti"CU1?'1.Sfr...--::.tt1C.<:!.S Or!.fe.r' tt"crs ne.·o r
'·' L ,, d
·n ·1t;;;.. ta..s t-i rYH!J n Y Of·Pe,..te.cJ On b 0 f-'1'1 S lei e..$ ..,..t;.Jt;i rL':l t;$: eQC.t.s_
f=fCM1Kiin \6 ~:lfffi=) ,T-&.1: {j.PI,!~-~+t:J. , , Oi~t. . {~€1if,(d01,(Jt1/"'}}Q. ~.~.G 9l,$ >
.L..~J..aS.,.l33 ~'2.2. ~Q.fp ., St>... e.., J:(qti,Vr. e~cul)·f"!!;r!ZJ.CIJ1 ~ S . ~ If) ,}d Je,S .
l5:B:l C{Y! #.QQE.)~ The. .SuPre..J"YY"'f..... cour"·f· held fh,c.tr fhe. £.tOur!- J?1t.fSf- ctLs~
ltcons/d<-::..r wn ·e:t-htt.r ..such o h-lfArll-1 s tC..OL-1/(!"J enc,Jol~ ar1 af'PJ/canr
ro r-'rove. H1c;.. P.ertHon5 Pc~ctu Jit.d c;AUe.s.cdioYJ:s, wt-dch) if :lr"t.U:. *
L.uot.d ·d enfr0 t/e H1e. oPPJicc,nr to l'e lte.P.. (he c,f1Pitc.ont eJ1h'He.d ts
-t-o Od'l evid-e..nnCArY I1~Y'fnS on H1~ fssue .. ~:i!m {rdlGti"~f3.~~~~;a .. cr~
r,ah) ~ -L;t ~.L?I,C:t::c:.~a:.x:Qu \l.i ~-."-~.t(~~a i r~s¥r:/.. -!ilih~t27 ~ n,
.:a~ ,.:r~h cir.lJ '~)_
CC..oYt<:..ludin !t -11-,.-c,+ an evtde.n14arv hearfr)C:J on h;c.tuol fs.sues
Urk:lt:.(IYfn.£1 a ha.be.<:Ts ,cJalm.:s w-os re. t.)ulre.d b·e.c:ouse lh.e
-~.~ t .-/..
~o.-§c. <.,-.Q~YJ.t_ ll:f"P~. ,(1(1. . r~~ -
• L - t 7:r('r nqH1_~.?
(t " . -IJ.· ~
Q(1, !.l-1{#: J>S.~-5:.~-' see..
·,; .
1'?..~.~ :S.!?£1# \1__ ,2 ~ "': t "i 1 tt""~I!II(L.':.!;J-.4..-~~~~ Zl..-L ...w.r.:l:'-c..a~~--..i.....!~-- 1--0f?.~---·' .J-.C'!!....c.t :.L~..{ ...
(11 'Tht.~t +--he o-f' H1e.. f},~c.f'Lict/ cl/s.fute. w(:!.re Not l'e.s.olvecl
m·t:...Y"'/t..s
in ttl e.. s t·e=.t·ft.. c.(i'_.,u"" t h c:.?/tA V" In -i/,[J!J.,'!;J).,J:aui:.i::¥iJll.c.tt.~.;d)(d..) ;· 7i~e~ r
·-1-1-1 e. t~c1c tfiv.1 d i'rYt:J Pro ce ct ure. em PID Yed h y #re. st-<·J.fl e. Cl.ourf.
vvcl.s no;- C1~Jt-. ·fJUc.,+e It;; o.t~ ord c1 Pull c, nt:1 .Pa/Y' he.orlr1·9 .
(S ), Th·o.+ Fhe cJPPl ict:~nl. w e=!s C!n f.VTcJI~e.Y1r aY'Yd the.5~a ·H:,.
Lt-"L-1 rf- '· ~Yl._4!.,::..f.QVCI tioFi ~2{_bi4L CDfL~if f"_~fJ1(J.YJ.f.!L .. .Ci.9~_t.5 _fr_aii.~t~i
.> . c:A r"'r·__:_..
t··) ~o- ,i,n4-,.. ,. . ~unc:.t>.
;. ~,,, ·~ ./ .t.r..
~~~.._,;:.c;:___..li--~- ,.,. '"'A,....,. . J.t . . -..-J""""J r~~~-~~-""-·~·L.
11 ""-Pfl.t- ~.r..l n t I'J1-t-~..J......C~;.J...1.~--':.W.~. /~ ,v.Jv-j..ct .
Pr"oc eedin9. (7), ·r~t- +he aPPI /-r.::ant· wa.$ o·t h¢..rw/se
t.".\e.V1 ied clue f3tvce..s.s oP laLA.J l'~t1 fi/Je.. sf~-,te eourtProce.edi-
fr·~;, .nJ:n F·E...d-e....rCA I c. t!>U y•-j-' w h -e,..V} -cJU'f;, Proof. c:f· SU1Zh faC·h.l-c~ I
dt:..t-c.r;')1/r1a i..iDVJ t-Jtt:~s bj::..en ma-de.. unless. fhe sa;C/ 1
exrstt..VJCt:. ot one or n1on;. ot ;-he,. ~:,.lr•curY.1SI""C!f1cc...>.
t"'i:!.S P·ec...Hve\v se-t- f<;;r#·l t· ~1 f1a ·ra 9 rat;>h s (J) 7o(7}, or
I(tC.lusfve. Is sr-towvt bY tt1e.. of'PJrc.uJ1f, UJ-1 r:leY''
-ro~~!.tl~~I:J~~'-?..i~_id,:.~-~...a ,~ ) a~, :?c~tr . 7 "/.2 't -:z.ta l 'l
Th c. PuVt dome..r1 ra 1 ri:.. 'DLI i'tt;_rYI~n r cfl Due. Proc..e.ss t.s th<:. oPPort-
un tt-v m b(::.. h~.czr·d o .~ ~:;, n·1e.cn tn gfuJ tiff1 e~ D;~:J /VJ e-1 n1c: t~ltlln9Pt.JI
rYlCH1l1er"'. 111e Sto-le courf de.cfslon De..n'J.fn~ de.Penci-tAnt- on
f:.s sue.. t1t h~~.fn ret CtCttJC.IIIY i1.-'U ·10Cen r
E\1 !dw ti orv H:t:ot·rvt ~3 OY1 Pat:~t-
wo s c..on+rary to C.. Ie. '!Ar/v- e.sroblished lcu.u,.Pedere~/ h:::,"" ~
TI4e SJo'/e.. ~urt- .£ decJ.sian ro denY rJe/.eYk'::l~nt- -H1e f'/~ht to
C () 11 fr CJYI teA liD ~'J t.:A ;'Vt) c.r• O..SJ.i -e.;.'(t:Ji'Vd1'1 CA h'O 1'1 ;';1 .c.J t!.. tt.tr1lY1 fVI ~
whe+-nev·· h~ wt.-:-t..s. J.).c.n.JctiH1 :!.nnDce :Y ir un-cle!" SchluP_,// 5. s. .-c.l-.
231, (tQ Cf 5) ,C'fHVIri!
..
KUJ11WJCIJ7YI
. -~....
V.. wi /'S0/1, 4771 U, s,43b ,JOb S,C:h ~hli:>
__,___, __,......,.,t....,......,....-"' _.... ........_*i);o,...
.---.. ................." ...... - . 1 \'IIi ~,-.. .. --~ ...... ..,..... - - • •
Bb), VVQs.
t(J !Sf c.ont-rarv tv cl-e.c.~rJv ... e.stolhJlshe.cllecl~rCIJ l)
1C4N't~nei looKi:n St to fle.cJe.,roJ /a~.~V t>fl . clt.le Pr/.J c e .s.s; cJncll'ht:!
Ri'sl-1t- oP. c..ro.s.s ·e .xcJmii1orlon orJd coJ'7.Prt:'~l7 ·f1:-:,:tr"oJFJ CIS
cr.vit10u nc.,e.~r:J h'l· tl1 ~'i- s~JPrt.rv;e.. co:.JJ"J-., I. ~;n1 Pert..r~r~di::,ttJ fh,Jt
ti 1H!.. ('fS.JC:.~V.~fn f /1~/.LI /.:;, c! ~";(!''\ ·C)JVI!td r::J/c.f"t:::fe -:£~ fir?€. ·C. 01/fc./U ~[Of1
I-t--~·'!';: I- H"1 e:.. 5 ft':fll·te. -:.::;.r;1u ? '1/.J ;-; cl ~::.J s l'o Jf1'CJ I Pro c.. £.lb. \41"~..$ s ¢>.)
1
e.
ro t-h t's. Cle.r.:;'r·iY-(i:.~-J·ctl~?fsi'l etd Jct!A/, ·r;,.,e li'le..sen·:-e.YJc.e.. " .! -r:t
dei -t- '·11-::J.c,..-1 h df;.r~.111/rH:..cJ vvljJ.hclJt· e.vfc':i~:ntf<:.lf"/ h~~<.";tf"Ji4 '!1
1
cross
C-luY't- inl.s (;o.l"l.s,:~re. nfiY he ltd ~~+-ev/-elenJtclirY
heo~,f!J . e; are. e..ssen t fa .~
. I T£>1' d .e rermJnan011s
" " - .-1 "'- "1'
"'f c..r'fU:;I/uJtlt y'',see
_R f c!1 .:' ~ !!~e-~~tt~~Jt~(~161:~~~-~~~~.i9.. .'i'-.~ I ~~L1J, 1~CZ,_1_~.~->...~.b.k!§.~.J:.;
r, Unre.5DIVed Fb.c~ of I.nnecencf.':Affe.cJiY1!3 Wttne.S.S'S CreJ:Jl'bl'lltY)->
Oe.~ende-~nt· or<.:Jue.s m:At Cln £Vlde.rt ·H or'/ Hearln9 CAS 0
S i xt-h Amel1-dmt:.nt f\6"'5h-t- to ttH~.. 1J11/-rec.l Sl-clfe..s. Coi1Sii'ltltl'on
Gu-tH..oM re.e..s the rlSthr o~' an o-c.e:....u:s eel fn o crrm/YJetl
Prose.c.uHon to c.onf.rorlf' the wlrnesse.s agcnnst h!m,
u. ~· ,C.Ot::{J?J.• cun,e.nGJ.•.~,n Q~vf'~ . \(;i1l9~6 ,c;J ,f:i/i £./.. $.~0 8 .1 ·~~~-'
't·
9 L.J > ~,. HQ.'} >UlO >~ :t , t. ·ti.~ ~, ;;:, 'fZ-' l't.'f,"~ 'i l) .~ ere. CJ I so 8CilJ.H/n v:
,!,·~~~.'iLJ.k'!~~-~:l~~~'Lf..T;;&_.1eJ'.::.f.PJ:.t....VLQC/:b...J-~.!lt.f.~e;,:.f..J..;§t the PrlnclPC!J
me.aYl.s bY wht-c.~ th~ be.IJwe..vaJ.:JtlttY o.P a GA.Jttne:ss aJ1d f'he
truth oP h-e r resti'f1110I1.Y ore. te..Sfed:t..LI;I~<::t..t.31b~.9.4f. s.-.".tf!..IJIJJ:?.
Int.. cr"' s..s- exorv~rner not- tOniY ,:s Permlffed fr:> delve. /111-o
+V\t;. wtMe.ss's. S'/OrY to t-est- the. wiln·e .$$S P-e.rcePli'({)n.5
aVld memorv, iou 1- aJ:so t.t; tracllhon'CIIIv o/iotPed It> trr1Pe.ac..h ~
(:..~.:. di.s<:redtr 1+1-e. 4.Uftness, ld, H£nc.e... f-J-1e. n~ ;:;hr to cra.ss.-
€-X·C tmine o tr:..s Hf.Yln.!fl s;fr:;tte... wi t-11e s...s· €.X i-e.nd..s lo C/11 'I
mc.t+te..r +heft- C,4;uld re..P.Iec+ on rne.. vv1rV1-e..ss·)s cre.dfk:n'iltY,
'til.~t-:;_v:,. St'CJ..V. :..:Z.~ ::t. s w -a~g 2, s# ~ft~ C"f-eJ(,<:.•.t"/V'l-1,..,J4PP. fer 8 7 ),I'Thi.s
fn ,c lu d e.s~ lt"'1 fJ.e,o .c; h tYJ;:, ·J-J1e ,;,...t,.i/t·n f!. .s s w/ri"t ·reJe.v'c;ftl' e.,V/de.nc.e..
#vr.A.J.· n"1l~~J.1t· (<-- ?l-~2.-Ct- bf;Q..S ,fr ·l ter6 51··, Pr eJucJ{c.,c;; d)1C.Or?Sfs+e.tf1t
..st~1temer1t..s, 1raf·J-.s ot:. c.h c:trc"'4-c ·t-e.r of:.P'2£t1" ~·'1!.:J cr,~>.-dt'h:J"t'r'IJ
0 r e.. v l'de VI 1:. e. t·h~t1" 1111'3 j, t' ~a to CII'J"Y IJ11 Pet- rr .YVJ ,£ 1/i t ([) (' ')l
~r:so~fl lt'J af.P.e<:.Hn~ "fht~ w/t·f'l e. s s '$ c.r·e .dlhtJ(r'l.) 1a -&trAtJ::.ll4.'i ·~w?:s{rlft,
-
. ::z zfl-U
()
'I-w,aee,
• ,-t_
, -
QGI/IQ ·S» ll c:,9-, ,pe ·r-, r-e.P'd • rhe. trY~J
I - . tJ ( . . ;. 1 , -4. P , >.. -. 1 ;; , ·1
I ') ' } ( ( / .
J u d 'i1 t.. :sv. c u 1 d oJJ tf)t;J 1+1-e.. oc:::.. c;.u :sed 9Jfle...o+-· lo rl rude ro
Shou) any l'e.Je...van-r Pc=tc-t· rh-at mfs h r f~teJ1d to c2l¥e~ct ~-1 '1£.
""' h'l~~ s 'S c
r~.. d;,f,flft:/;.J~lJ:i:?.l1 ~.,,,. s_ vv,J?rd.-q,.t ~<:i ·~ ~o-Qd e. r v~ sto~~
62 ~. s \4t«&J ~l -9 c.rt~~ ,.rii11f IJett .L:l.~ ~ >.
Se.e... -rhoYtJ Ci 3 v. 5·ro rc!.. ~~5, s ·yJ.$Jd
~ ,(td£.. C.r't~Yl· I~ PI'. d,oo ·1)) SJ
unde.r 'T«~.B..( nee
e tj~~(l)__} 1'5"/ CDr71ra si· ts d-e...SI'!J)7ed
ro e.f ~6-C.r 1t1e.. Ct·ea#'or1 oP a ne/A/ record· ~ when a J-ri'CJJ
1
c: our-t~ has ... e..rr'cr7e ouslv \1/t}-hheld fl1fo.t~':H -crt/ot4llet:essary
to evaluate a de.Revlclants c.la1m on a~eal Ce.e.
Pc.ilure -te fi Ie.. reutrecl ·firl~h~19 .s of k.ic·t ) of' has
Pr"·e..ve.r1+ed tht:.. de.feridan-f fro~1 suhn'l/rt/YJ~9
t'rtffir\~rla ·tfotl J1C:.GC:..S :SorY to CVcdUC!iY:l.. )i/5 C.)aj)n
te.. 3·. rePtJ.Si'Y1 . .9J to Pt?t"m/1- C./!11 off-er of ProofJ of
001 tn s- Ac. ~t-tAct/1 Y _!/1J10c.:el1t,
TI .·-J!!f;.....l-Cj'Yi /CN ..,.... n..1 ,..,-. D -r.s··\...-V
,...\ 't=1- j "\') \'/'
-
r- fll
t:/V
.- . .
I 11.:..
. '
I
.
·-r;h
,._ ( .
· _.J.. . -· . ·-
See.._~ cx;tw.(~ ..~~b,Yl ~ rJ.l:LJ.J~ FJS. jp.~ ( .Sth C:,ir, I L., BJ}l. 4·17 8! #
whe.YJ there... r5 c. fuc.. ru Ct I Di'S p/./te..[Jj.,a£1 i'f resolved ,y, fhe.. de.Penda.n ts
11
·f -avor ,would ent-HI ·e.f.hirnJ ft;) Retie.P \He Ls enrltiecl fo fJlscoverY al4d
£vr'd·e n Hat' Y Jleari'YJ::J, se~~!J:tLIJ....¥..J!Pt!.t::l~'lPL!..J..llE.JJ:rl:L,'iJ..J LJ ~) .. . .. . '
-i±n..O:G..L%:/;t.)/~G$1d£tit?3.J.Jt!Slt:r;l.~~!Jitl!t.~L~k!J.J..!e.?i..kl~
w-J~-~..r.t.~...J.•'i.~L!:O{<:,) tr:. rc1l-lon s !'t1 or/ s ii-1a/) ..
5t~e.K tvJ ·'!.! Ito 0/se::.J/·e..r ExcLJif'atorv e..v/cle..YJC. e Phoro9rof.h
oP .14mc41rk:-Jct .;n/fc.heiJ T!f'Je.. /4/le~ Vtc.-h~m . . Or/nJia/n9'·
cl1ctmPtJ ::tne. OtAI- ofl #It~. Bortle iYJ ''vhr+e L.fn 9erl'e 11-t #1e
O-e.P-t.l/YelrAr11- 1-loM~e. .• E.vt.?Je..Jt1<-e of! 1*/e.. /al
ffi~i'r1"S Photo of YOt-i v.J/t/.1 a come.ra l ve.s·. see RJtf-a-~5
r, ~I- 1v rvl E'...Cl -the. ·13a rt-1 e. ,.,~,o, Th·e. . re vva5 o Ft f"_.r5/1 \ e. ;A/CIS rl
tokt'v7 ~ Ci Ptch~Jre o.P ~1e.. .'' ~tcfUre. Shot..U(vr:=t NO PhYstccd-
\lfoleYiCe.. 1 I.rr1Pectl'(..h{n ,~ fh~. J4JI.e.--:y~d Vic.hm Ti!.Stilli'IOI?Y lt-o111
p, R.-5-·J.~:;~.~.~ To t3'" n~Jse. 71e.,s+itJ1,0YIY fhat w/11 s:l"~